Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS/ANDROID/PC: clcr.me/R_KingsGenrls and get a special starter pack 💥 Available only for the next 30 days

@KingsandGenerals

2 жыл бұрын

@@mattluke5546 only if you can spare it. Thanks for considering!

@hybridarmyofthegdl2193

2 жыл бұрын

edit for you > Muscovy, which has had 0 connection to Kyiv Rus´. Muscovy is a mongol product , even the extreme left know it, read the Marx

@hybridarmyofthegdl2193

2 жыл бұрын

"Let us begin with this evident fact: Muscovy does not belong at all to Europe, but to Asia. It follows that judging Muscovy and the Muscovites by our European standards is a mistake to be avoided."-gonzague de reynold, 19501 In methodological terms, one should de-Europeanise any analysis of Muscovy policy.- thomas gomart, 20062 "

@hybridarmyofthegdl2193

2 жыл бұрын

@@michealkelly1414 ivan, K. Marx: Thus the "russia" of the Normans disappeared completely from the scene and those feeble vestiges which persisted were obliterated by the terrifying apparition of Genghis Khan. The origin of Moscovy lies in the bloody degradation of Mongolian slavery and not in the rude heroism of the Norman epoch. Modern "russia" is nothing but a transfigured Moscovy

@madalinsayan7815

2 жыл бұрын

Hello kings and generals, when are you going to make the whole 30 years war into a 2 hours documentary? It s one of the most interesting periods in history

Tsar Peter once supposedly said : "My brother Charles seeks to become Alexander, but in me he shall not find his Darius."

@walrus1074

Жыл бұрын

that's a badass quote from a badass emperor

@fenriswulfe6661

Жыл бұрын

@@walrus1074 Actually, I read somewhere that Peter had a talent for remembering sudden engagements elsewhere before battles broke out, if you catch my drift. Witness Narva.

@nomooon

Жыл бұрын

@@fenriswulfe6661 he has to go take a shit?

@slawekwojtowicz

Жыл бұрын

Evil barbarian.

@FlaviusBelisarius-ck6uv

Жыл бұрын

@@Cheka__ I believe Peter was trying to convey his opinion that Charles sought to become as great a conqueror as Alexander the Great. If you know anything about Alexander, you’ll know that one of his greatest achievements and probably the thing he’s remembered for most was the conquest of the Achaemenid Empire of Persia and the dethroning of it’s King; Darius III. With that context, it seems fair that Peter also spoke in warning; If Sweden dared enter conflict with Russia, Charles would not defeat Peter the way Alexander had defeated Darius. And he did not.

Charles is a total war player. He wins in battle, gets favourable treaties, decline so he can have the entire pie, waltz deep into enemy lands so he can take significant places only to lose supplies and get defeated and lose his entire army. Been there. If only he could exit and load.

@Justintime8838

Жыл бұрын

Lol That was me yesterday in Rome 2 though I technically won I was bankrupt and lost like 90% of my army.

@simpsonfan13

Жыл бұрын

The music even played during his battles apparently

@Big_Glizzy.

Жыл бұрын

What's the channel where this guy takes doomed campaigns from his viewers and turns into a successful campaign?

@fsblninjx3604

Жыл бұрын

@@Big_Glizzy. bruh it depends tho. many yotubers do it now but it depends on the type of game.

@SlashHarkenUltra

Жыл бұрын

Knowing when to quit would have helped him avoid a shameful display

This comment isn’t necessarily related to this video, but I was wondering if you could do a video about how armies in general (I am thinking specifically Roman legions since that is my favorite period) were levied, how they wintered, and how their supply lines/trains operated. These aspects of battle and campaigns are very often mentioned, almost in every single video, but, to my knowledge, and I may be wrong, I haven’t seen a video regarding them. There are similar ones like how the legions built their forts which is very interesting though. I have always been curious about how such large armies could be levied so quickly, sustained through their supply trains and throughout long stays in lands whose food stores weren’t expecting such a large shock in terms of population increase so quickly due to armies stationed there.

@adityajadhav6008

2 жыл бұрын

If you’re thoroughly interested in these overlooked parts of wars (and especially interested in the Roman war machine), then “The Logistics of the Roman Army at War” is a thorough, detailed, and reliable book. It dwelves into food, marching rates, supply train contents, non-combatants, foraging, depots, roads, winter bases, camping, etc.

@maddogbasil

2 жыл бұрын

that is actually a pretty good idea iv'e always wanted to know the different ways empires supplied their armies people like the ottomans mongls perisans romans arabs chinese

@LilShakkas

2 жыл бұрын

I know on offensive campaigns they brought basic provisions but expected to either forage, buy or raid supplies to further extend they're campaigns - makes sense why scorched earth was so effective against so many different armies

@yindoh

2 жыл бұрын

@@adityajadhav6008 that is awesome! Thank you! I was actually looking for a book like that the other day! Did not end up finding the one you mentioned. Will look again!

@ABCshake

2 жыл бұрын

Invicta has a good video on Roman army supply system

The Great Northern War is such a huge topic and this video handled it with ease. Shows the amount of time put into these videos... and for free. Mind blowing.

@anderspalsson8547

2 жыл бұрын

And also with the connections backwards (the vikings and so on) and forwards to today whith companies and deep state, yes.

@williamyoung9401

Жыл бұрын

Very good video. Going over the battle where Peter I was almost captured would have been sweet, too.

Charles was like a XVIII century Napoleon, he could defeat all of his enemies at least once, but they kept coming at him

@carnifex2005

2 жыл бұрын

Imagine Charles with a country that had a large population.

@jonbaxter2254

2 жыл бұрын

And Charles was like a 18th century Adolphus...

@danisrusski6297

2 жыл бұрын

He was a great general and a terrible politician. Too obsessed with military glory to do what was the smart move and get a very, very favourable peace and time to recover.

@livy456

2 жыл бұрын

@@legendarylimits564 not to mention, it might have even impacted his thought process when it came to warfare. Carolean tactics are today viewed as being very much the same/similar natured as Napoleonic, in the sense that they were based around physically and psychologically overwhelming the enemy. This was done so as to avoid Casulties, as even a victory through conventional tactics would have costed them (the Swedish) too many men and resources. A higher population would have only made the resource issue worse, they would have been like the Russians

@janprostejovsky5050

2 жыл бұрын

@@Wustenfuchs109 real-life example is Hannibal (but lowkey it was not his fault, he actually made a good effort with local Italians to get those on his side, simply got minimal/no support from his empire due to politics, rivals of the Barcid family actually wanted him to fail to gain control over Spain which was like private estate of Barcid family)

This gives me flashbacks to going to student parties in Finland and inevitably being trapped in a long conversation with a drunk Finnish dude giving me the complete history of the Great Northern War. Happens almost every time.

@jonber9411

Жыл бұрын

Lol!

@lux2132

Жыл бұрын

Wait, is this true?

@charlesandrews2360

Жыл бұрын

I guess that's better than listening to some drunk college student telling you all about the stupid crap they did in high school. More interesting anyway. The comment reminds me of a drunken conversation I had as an American student visiting London in 1979 when I loudly proclaimed, "If it wasn't for America, you'd all be speaking German!" LOL! Back when I was a young dumbass Long before I became an old fool

@jonber9411

Жыл бұрын

@@lux2132 I dunno. I regonize it from sweden aswell. Thats why i loled- always some drunk dude that is specialist on ww2 or other war, and insist on talking with you. Sitting in the kitchen, 'trapped' at some party and listening to the dude going on and on. Meanwhile the most amazing bulbous asses and blond females come an pick something for thier beverage or whatever. The historian completely impervious to anything feminie or any sensous appeal. It's all about war and history.

@lux2132

Жыл бұрын

@@jonber9411 I think I feel the same since I am a military history aficionado, however, I do not see me talking about that kind of stuff while drunk, though I can see it possible from others lol and given the importance of Finland to Sweden and Russia, I can see it happening.

After seeing about 1.5 hours of this episode, I am struck at how much King Charles XII resembled Napoleon. Very haughty, extremely capable, preternaturally gifted at battlefield tactics, very good at picking excellent men to lead his smaller armies (akin to Napoleon's marshals), this man was a beast. Unfortunately, like Napoleon, King Charles XII had one massive weakness--the inability to identify when he was weak, to call it quits and retreat to let his men rest. Napoleon also had this inability to see the bigger picture and just fold for his sake and the sake of his men. Thus Peter the Great struck upon this Achilles' heel at 1:21:54--the scorched earth tactics that would starve Charles XII's troops into submission and defeat. It totally worked. I bet in 1812 Czar Alexander I had read about these battlefield tactics from Peter the Great's Northern War and realized that he could vanquish Napoleon and his giant Grand Armee in the same way. And it worked too. Precisely because Napoleon just didn't know when to call it quits and retreat with his great Russian invasion. Just like King Charles XII roughly 100 years earlier.

@Reuel-Jazwa

Жыл бұрын

Underrated comment. I agree with you entirely. As with Żółkiewicz, who did conquer Moscow in 1611, the strategy was different which allowed the polish cavalrymen to obtain supplies not only from nearbye but from the surrounding fortresses which have been taken prior. Smoleńsk will always be important in relation of Poland and Russia as those who control it, control the buffer lands of white ruthenia.

@coryfice1881

Жыл бұрын

The only difference is Napoleon's splitting headache wasn't as severe as Charles's.

@John_Doe657

Жыл бұрын

Yeah charles could probably have won or at least reach a benifitial peace treaty if he had been smarter with his resources. Still Charles didn’t have any allies wich would have given him better chances. Remember Sweden defeated russias allies denmark, Poland and Saxony with victory after victory on the battlefield while mostly outnumbered before they where ultimately defeated at Poltava. I think this is what tzar Peter ment with the reference to Alexander the great of Macedon.

@Demun1649

Жыл бұрын

Did your Charles XII reform the entire national legal system? Did he reform agriculture across the whole spectrum of farming? Did he establish pensions for his injured soldiers? Did he establish FREE nationwide schooling for ALL children from 6 to 11 years old? Did he establish FREE hospitals across the whole nation? Did he establish pensions for the whole country after it was noticed how grateful the soldiers were? Did he establish FREE Almhouses for people too old to work? Did he improve canals and rivers to make them navigable, and also provide clean water to cities? Did he build a semaphore system that reduced message times down from two weeks to three hours? NO THE RUS CZAR DID NOT. "Napoleon also had this inability to see the bigger picture and just fold for his sake and the sake of his men." Can you identify, for me, the incident you are referring to? I can then compare your note to the book, that is used at Saint Cyr and Sandhurst to teach future officers, and find out if you have been loose in your identification.

@coryfice1881

Жыл бұрын

@@Demun1649 Did he walk on water, make the blind see, and the lamp to walk?

*Beginning of the war:* 10:26 Landing at Humlebæk (1700) *Allied invasions of the Swedish Baltic Dominions [Estonia, Ingria, and Livonia]:* 14:50 Battle of Narva (1700) 25:15 Crossing of the Düna (1701) 42:53 Battle of Erastfer (1702) 46:36 Fall of Nöteborg (1702) 54:03 Fall of Narva (1704) *Swedish invasion of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth:* 33:40 Battle of Kliszów (1702) 1:02:16 Battle of Fraustadt (1706) 1:10:20 Battle of Kalisz (1706) *Charles XII's Russian campaign:* 1:18:31 Battle of Holowczyn (1708) 1:24:37 Battle of Lesnaya (1708) 1:31:40 Siege of Poltava (1709) 1:32:59 Battle of Poltava (1709) *Allied invasions of western Sweden, eastern Sweden [Finland], and Swedish Pomerania:* 1:45:45 Battle of Helsingborg (1710) 1:50:03 Fall of Viborg (1710) 1:57:34 Battle of Gadebusch (1712) 2:08:08 Battle of Pälkäne (1713) 2:14:37 Battle of Gangut (1714)

@KingsandGenerals

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much!

@theunspokenwarsoffiction2235

2 жыл бұрын

@@KingsandGenerals if you add 0:00 it will add chapters I think.

@theunspokenwarsoffiction2235

2 жыл бұрын

(in the description)

@KingsandGenerals

2 жыл бұрын

@@theunspokenwarsoffiction2235 Good point, thanks! I am a pro youtuber, btw. :-)

@Alex-bu4dp

2 жыл бұрын

I>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>ii>ioiiooiooiooooioooooooooooiooooiooioooooioooioooiooooioiioioooiooioooooooooiooioooiooioooooooooooioo:

As an American I've learned nothing of significance about European history in school, so videos like this are a big deal to me. I appreciate them and thank you. I don't know how much editing goes into a 2+hour video because I'm not a content provider, but I assume it's a lot!

@50shekels

Жыл бұрын

It's good that you take your education into your own hands. The only one who loses by expecting to be taught rather than actively educating oneself is ourselves

@stevendebettencourt7651

Жыл бұрын

In fairness, though, if you are an American who doesn’t have an intention of traveling to Europe, I can see why this would be skipped in your education, at least as a grade schooler. There’s just not a lot about this conflict that really explains much about American history or our culture. Obviously, if you go on to college and study more about European history or military history, this probably should come up, but at this point we’re talking about some pretty niche topics for Americans.

A 2 hour documentary on a subject that I know barely about? Well, sign me up! These are very well made, and I can't even think how much effort goes into these, so good job.

@iikkuowo6735

Жыл бұрын

i like your username

The production quality in these videos have never let me down, I can't wait to watch all of this... 2 hour video, you guys are amazing.

@abrahamherzl9904

2 жыл бұрын

Fr

@Treysorable

2 жыл бұрын

Never ever let's me down.

@qutuveo6332

2 жыл бұрын

Holy shit I had no idea this was 2 hours until I saw your comment, and I was already 25 mins in lol

I LOL'ed out loud during that scene of Peter giving the same sword that he had gifted Augustus before back to him! Such a burn!!! Peter was an absolute lad

Russia's rise to power came by a war against a formidable neighbour. I found that really interesting because it is very similar to the rise of the Tang dynasty in making China the most powerful empire in ancient time - and the war that set the rise of the Tang, was also against the formidable Goguryeo Kingdom. I love that chapter.

@swayback7375

Жыл бұрын

It seems like a likely scenario depending on many factors. In a way it seems more likely than not unless a third party swoops in and levels both sides.

@michaspringphul

Жыл бұрын

or the rise of the US..it fought wars almost during his whole existance

@nomooon

Жыл бұрын

Goguryeo formidable? They can't even invade China... I thought you would be referring to the Turkics.

@ozymandiasking8406

Жыл бұрын

Argubly cobquer west turkic khaganate had bigger impact that ked to control of silk road

@joerogue231

Жыл бұрын

@@dynamitebsb4520 The Tang dynasty of China was the most powerful empire in history.

Hay I just watched this entire 2 hour video and honestly this was completely enthralling, excellent writing and commentary and the block blocked animations amusing, just thought I’d let whoever created this video know, you’re amazing, congratulations on such an amazing video, new patreon supporter incoming! 💖

@fernfreeman1729

Жыл бұрын

This is all very interesting and educational but what it doesn't stress enough is that most of it neglects to take into account that no NATO attacks on Russia is possible 😳 Russia would turn Finland and Sweden capitals into elephant dust in 5 minutes. Nuclear weapons will save us from WW3.

Charles had that real EU4 spirit: "I will not lose a single province, I will quit before I lose this war".

@PeIeus

Жыл бұрын

If it's going bad just burgher loans and two Merc stacks - SOLVED.

@trailmix2062

Жыл бұрын

“Full siege me down”

@Dennan

Жыл бұрын

well its not a mistake that eu4 is made by swedish devs :D we want to paint the whole map

@Pannkakaize

5 ай бұрын

Its funny how Sweden has no Morale in its national ideas in eu4 lol

@emiloprisa

3 ай бұрын

But they do have +20% infantry combat ability ​@@Pannkakaize

The history of the Swedish empire is basically a long grind of punching way above your weight. Amazing how much they could do with those terrible odds.

It’s incredible how many parallels in history we see in this conflict. There’s the obvious one of Charles foreshadowing the fates of Napoleon and Hitler (spectacular early victories that went to his head, followed by a disaster in the Russian winter). Also I’m amazed how much the final brave but hopeless Swedish charge at Poltava echoes what would happen a century and a half later on Cemetery Ridge. Not to mention the numerous times both before and after this war when an army with superior technology/tactics/generalship is defeated by an enemy who can simply afford to take heavy losses, then raise a new army and try again.

@alexanderbenkendorf688

2 жыл бұрын

Well, Russia is big, but they win not just because of that, but because of their own saying "we're getting f*cked, but we become stronger". So, getting stronger under pressure, eventually becoming stronger than the thing pushing them.

@thegaminganimationstudio7976

2 жыл бұрын

Lesson Learned Don't Invade Russia in the winter LOL.

@mikolajtrzeciecki1188

2 жыл бұрын

@@thegaminganimationstudio7976 Try teaching this to Subutai...

@thegaminganimationstudio7976

2 жыл бұрын

@@mikolajtrzeciecki1188 LOL or the Huns and Japanese who had success against Russia as well.

@nattygsbord

2 жыл бұрын

WW1 - big lose for Russia

Karl XII is probably one of the biggest real life examples of “pride comes before the fall,” in history. A brilliant tactical mind with the charisma and drive to back it up. Yet at every turn after his early successes and especially when things started to go bad, he screwed himself over due to his own stubbornness and pride. From refusing favorable peace deals, to refusing treatment for his foot wound, to refusing the INCREDIBLY fortuitous Ottoman offers to get him safe passage home, and then AGAIN refusing the much needed potential Prussian alliance because he didn’t want to give up one rinky dink fortress town that was already surrounded by Prussian territory anyway. He got more second chances than frankly a lot of other people, and he threw them ALL away, and ended up with nothing in the end.

@Sognafar

3 ай бұрын

He ended up going down as one of the greatest military comanders of all time. Thats pretty cool

@zero_wing_

13 күн бұрын

he ended with a big ol’ hole in the side of his big dumb head

As a Urkrainian I just knew that Karl the 12th made it somehow to Poltava to join with Mazepa, but I never knew what preceeded to it. Thanks for this great series !

@Zarastro54

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, when I learned that such a famous battle was that far into the middle of Ukraine, I thought, “how could a Swedish monarch end up all the way over here without actually conquering any of the territory in between?”

The fact that you can find content of such high quality for free made me smile. Thanks Kings and Generals !!!

I appreciate your work with the battling details, the strategic and tactical analysis of every battle and with these deep conjuncture of factors analysed regarding the Great Northern War and how Russia managed to gain their power as a Eastern and Nordic juggernaut. I would like also to add some of your thoughts regarding how it would have been better managed the entire operations and strategic improvement on each side as a conclusion. Keep up the good work!

Thank you kings and generals for adding more battles in this epesode!

@KingsandGenerals

2 жыл бұрын

8 or so new battles

@mdmiloy5897

2 жыл бұрын

@@KingsandGenerals Love this epesode and your imposeive work very much. Thank you!

@user-ff2nk1po8g

Ай бұрын

​@@KingsandGeneralslove your narrator btw , and obviously your content and army drawing and mapping

Absolutely amazing video yet again guys, you have a real talent in the art of presentation and I for one massively appreciate all the efforts that go into the making of these... The level of information and the way that it is displayed and described really sucks me in, before I know it, hours have past and I'm disappointed that it's ended.... Love the work and please never stop! Acey Lust

Brilliantly informative & entertaining video, as usual, thank you for the passionate & arduous efforts of all involved. Thank you.

Ahh nice to see the big compilation is out. Good work on yet another completed project K&G!

@napalmholocaust9093

2 жыл бұрын

You mean kgb.

Let's goooo!

@obaone

2 жыл бұрын

Lol self love is a beautiful thing

@theuniverse5173

2 жыл бұрын

Hi

What a great video. You guys really do put in the work to make a great history documentary, and you do it so consistently. You are fantastic.

Thank you for consistently providing amazing content! I'm so happy to watch this!

This was an interesting yet educational video. I did not know a lot of the information. Thank you for sharing it with us. Keep up the great work.👍🏻

Actually seeing how the units move in the fights makes this so much more enjoyable to watch. Seeing them crumble as they take damage actually helps give an idea of who is winning and where.

This was one of the most important wars in history. Great video Kings and Generals.

Excellent video guys. Great to see a video on the Great Northern War.

2 1/2 hours, amazing. Big love to the crew ♥️

I never knew the Swedes to be such a formidable military power, time and time again smashing theire enemies severly outnumbered. Seems beyond belief.

@carlkolthoff5402

Жыл бұрын

People tend to forget that about us, as we've had peace for the past 200 years. Before that, there were countless wars and conflicts for as long back as there are written records and Sweden was considered a united kingdom. The Great Northern War was neither first nor the last time we faught Denmark and Russia.

@shar3066

2 ай бұрын

We particulary held back Russia. You see what happens when nobody does the job and let them roam free. You should know this about Russia. Land expansion is in their DNa. It wont stop until someone stops them. To them it doesnt matter they already hold enermous areas of land. Their whole structure is based on land expansion.

@Rahmatow

2 ай бұрын

​@@shar3066tbh you sound like a racist

@PlumbuM871

Ай бұрын

@@shar3066 So far it turns out we stopped you, and the Poles, and the Turks. By the way, why did you invade Poland in the 17th century? 🤣

i always feel like this war isnt talked about enough it changed history so much

Sweden annexed Skåne(Scania) in 1658 after the treaty of Roskilde and not in 1679 as you said in the video. The Scanian war was launched by Denmark against Sweden to retake Scania and they succesfully did so until the Swedish army under the leadership of Carl XI crushed the Danish army in a row of battles but most notably the battle of Lund.

@charleynilsson5543

2 жыл бұрын

@@tundrasheep Yeah no I live in Skåne and that is not something I have ever heard someone say ever. Scanians have more of an independent identity that both differs from Denmark and Sweden.

@Nick_Goblin

Жыл бұрын

@@tundrasheep Lol that is not true at all. You will have a hard time finding a scanian who identifies as a dane.

@linus1398

Жыл бұрын

@@tundrasheep they have their own flag yellow and red. yellow cross from swedish flag and red from danish.

@linus1398

Жыл бұрын

@@transparentghost2817 to clarify the danes dont want Malmö ;p

@tntfreddan3138

Жыл бұрын

@@charleynilsson5543 There are Swedes... And then there are Skåningar

It's been 7 years since I started watching you, and it really isn't fair that throughout a near-decade, a pandemic, and so many experiences with things that have been genuinely amazing, things haven't changed a bit.

@KingsandGenerals

10 ай бұрын

We have a nice team and genuinely love our craft. Thanks for being with us for so long!

The Polish deluge definitely deserves its own hours-long video. Poland at one point was entirely occupied by foreign forces, and by the end of the conflict, was able to recover most of them. The deluge also marks the beginning of four ways battle over modern day Ukraine between Poland Russia Ottoman and Ukraine. Plus, Polish failed attempts to centralize its political system is very poignant.

@johnnydavis5896

Жыл бұрын

The difference was in the Swedish Monarchs - if it had Been Gustav Adolphus with his religious tolerance - Sweden would have conquered Poland, but the attempt to force Lutheranism on the Polish people turned into a conflict against the Polish people and was the ultimate cause of its failure,

@dddevchonka

Жыл бұрын

@@johnnydavis5896 And the Poles made the same mistake back in 1609. They managed to install a Polish king in Russia but insisted he'd remain Catholic. It caused a popular uprising that finally expelled the Poles from Russia.

@johnnydavis5896

Жыл бұрын

@@dddevchonka We makes it a dumber mistake to have not learned from that.

@johnnydavis5896

Жыл бұрын

@@dddevchonka But in the end, the failure of the Swedish Empire really boils down to the problem that no monarch ever lived up to the principles of Gustav Adolphus.

@dwarow2508

Жыл бұрын

Thanks to Russia defeating said power, yes. The deluge was also rather the end than the beginning about the reclamation of Ukraine.

that was freaking great. thank you for making it ❤

So happy to have this pop up to start my day. Thanks for the time and effort

These videos are really awesome, I can just listen to them for hours at a time and they go by so fast

Great work guys. No doubt this represents a ton of work but the end results is simply awesome 👏 and impressive on every levels. Congratulations and thank for your efforts. You are real professionals and it shows in your work, in your art!

These videos are fantastic! I love being able to balance reading with the visual depiction of battles.

Fantastic work on this video. I salute the effort and the team

The skill and level of organization of the Swedish army was impressive. Again and again they were able to defeat numerically superior enemies. One of the best - if not the best - army in the world at the time.

@freddekl1102

11 ай бұрын

Best army is one thing, but fighting literally everyone around you instead of making some friends or even NAPs is a stupid move on a strategic scale. especially if you're the smallest player. You can't win everytime you're outnumbered, your strenghts will be inevitably blunted given enough opportunities.

@hb9145

11 ай бұрын

@@freddekl1102 I agree.

@toddharig8142

9 ай бұрын

​@@freddekl1102Sweden did have allies. They didnt work like they do in EU4, allies defend and attack with whatever resources they can spare as long as it gives some proportional value in return. English and dutch ships helped in securing a quick and decisive victory against the danes. Regional allies in different theatres helped bolster their numbers. The big problem for sweden was timing. Considering they were attacked by a coalition there was no way of organizing a meaningful defense from allied nations. Western maritime nations had no interest in helping sweden beyond securing peace with denmark meanwhile they had an interest in keeping the straits split between sweden and denmark seeing as a monopoly on it was detrimental for trade. The only meaningful and viable ally against russia was the ottoman empire and even there the timing was off seeing as the start of the war hinged on russia making peace with them. The best alt history route would probably have been for sweden to accept peace in exchange for letting russia have st Petersburg after defeating augustus and then consolidating alliances for a second round.

Ótima aula de história ! Parabéns ao King and Generals !!!

production quality has gotten so good. unbelievable work guys, amazing.

Love these videos in their Long Form; your just better at it KaG. Also it brings together what......2 or 3 years of work with individual battle videos? It speaks to your skill and good work :)

I hope it's not one of those "everything ever happened with X was bad, because X is bad now".

Excellent video. Might I suggest periodic reviews of each year/campaign to give a brief review of the map showing the major battles and territorial seizures. Such long involved conflicts are extremely complex and reviews would help the viewer to keep events in context. Kings and Generals has provided the finest quality and greatest depth of historical material for which you have my eternal gratitude. Living on disability sadly does not allow one to give financial support.

@KingsandGenerals

Жыл бұрын

Hey David, the comment in itself is all the support we need from you. Wish you the very best! Joey is correct. Doing that is technically possible, but wouldn't be enjoyable to watch.

Informative and easy to watch! Good job!

Thank you so much for this video. As always the quality is sublime.

Kings and Generals is the best out there. Many thanks for your hard work. Absolutely fantastic. Officially Devin is probably the best narrator ever. I am a native English speaker (American) but his pronunciation has helped with my pronunciation, especially with Finnish. {Winter War long version}. What about the Continuation War? Especially the 1944 Russian Offensive.

Thank you for bringing up the The Great Wrath that happened in Finland. For the population that barely numbered 500,000 at that time the Great Northern War had a devastating affect on Finland.

Great video, great KZread channel. Keep up the awesome work.

Yay! You said it was coming and it came! Thank you :)

Great! time to rewatch this masterpiece

Quite frankly I can't watch the whole thing but if your previous videos are anything to go by, I know it turned our great, and I'm glad this accessible, quality, and in-depth is made about a region only commonly remembered for a very short time span in its history, namely the Viking Age.

Been waiting for one on this..thanks

Thank you so much, i just love these long documentaries!

Great content as usual!

Tsar Peter the Great: Your ship of the line will make a fine addition to my collection.

hell yeah dudes love the channel. Been seeing you guys on Facebook too so i hope yall keep growing

Amazing work, one of the best history channels on youtube!

This was great.. A request... The new Zealand land wars... theres like 6 of them im currently working on it myself but with school taking most my time u guys would be 200% faster then me as one man.... completing this would be a great boom for new Zealands history department and if u release it before next year it could be used in official schools.... (imagen the veiws.....) I pray to god u see this soon... Also if u did it iled have some nice competition to see who finishes first (im a bit behind hafe way done)

love the video ❤

Thank you for your time and energy it is very much appreciated

I love this channel a lot! Keep up with the good content ;)

I really love to study this part of history (Since I am a Swede myself), and this is really nice to have so you can more easily visualize what happened. Sure, there are some mistakes here and there, but none that are super important overall (for example, you seem to have called all infantry in the swedish army "Grenadiers" when they used a mix of musketeers, pikemen and a few grenadiers). Good job!

@Tawnyj

Жыл бұрын

@Ucantpvp During the Battle of Narva section he said that Swedens army was comprised of 5500 grenadiers. 1/3 of the infantry was pikemen and 2/3 was a mix of musketeers and grenadiers, where about 1/10 was a grenadier and 9/10 was a musketeer. So no, there wasn't 5500 grenadiers, there were about 370 grenadiers, 1830 pikemen and 3300 musketeers (If we go by the 5500 amount, some sources claim that the swedish infantry was comprised of up to around 5900 soldiers).

@tyskbulle

Жыл бұрын

@Ucantpvp There was already a mistake 5 minutes in, with Sweden defeating "Scania" But for 2 hours of content they did a good job with accuracy

Thanks, really interesting and a war I didn't know much about. Can't help thinking charles really should have taken the offer for peace in Poland and the Polish Army to have gone to Spain, he overstretched hugely. It also seems that Charles failled to appreciate how important strong Navy was to a country around the baltic. All in all great video! It's interesting to see a poor Russian army take extensive casualties, be considered effectively a useless army and then still eventually win.... you can't help wondering...

@therobro5089

Жыл бұрын

Polish army? U mean Saxon army the Polish army barley even participated in the actual war

you make awesome content! i love learning about these old wars.

Possibly the greatest Kings and Generals video to date, and that says a lot!

"Sir I watch Kings and Generals" - proud moment in my career

@geoms6263

2 жыл бұрын

Putin?

@giorgijioshvili9713

2 жыл бұрын

@@geoms6263 we don't like him, but we like history

I just started a campaign as Russia in empire tw, it started out quite similarly to this and now I'm learning about the real history behind it. Very cool

Thanks you, whoever you guys are, for existing and making this video.

Damn, I have waited many moons for a good documentary on this subject. You guys never disappoint!

Great video! You did good with the pronunciation of Swedish words, but just FYI: The letter Ö is pronounced like the E in "earn", Ä is pronounced like the E in "ferry", and Å is pronounced like the O in "bore". Still, fantastic video!

I usually haven't commented on these ever, but your voice can narrate everything, and I will probably listen to it.

Best channel on KZread, and cable lol thanks for the hard work on these

thank you . this is a priceless and highly informative details of events. thank you again.

This chanel really made me love history, thnx so much!!

Amazing job! This is an absolutely fascinating war that I didn't know anything about. I loved it and you have to wonder what if Charles had of made peace years earlier.

It took me 5 days but i always love to watch this documentaries, great job Kings and Generals!

Your videos are of legendary quality. Bravo!

The Greater Wrath might not seem that bad by just looking at the numbers, but taking into account Finland's population being around 400 000 at the time, it was devastating. Some areas of Finland, like Northern Ostrobothnia, lost 25% of it's population or around 6000 people. The estimates for how many of the population was taken back to Russia basically as slaves ranges from 10 000 upwards to 20 000 by modern estimates. Out of the people who were taken as slaves, only around 2000 returned and out of 2000 forcefully recruited into the Russian army, 500 made it back home. The Russian occupation of Finland during the Great Northern War coupled with a famine happening in 1695 to 1697, a period known as "the great years of death", Finland's population dropped from 500 000 to 391 000 between 1695 and 1721. There's a Finnish made document here on KZread with added English subtitles on the Greater Wrath labelled "Isoviha-dokumenttielokuva", so if one is interested, watch that.

@KateeAngel

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah here in Saint-Petersburg people worship Peter the great cause he made their city but that's so dumb. He did a lot of bad things too. And basically was a tyrant towards regular people, he only reinforced serfdom, making it more like slavery. But I originally come from Vyborg and they try to make Peter into some super figure as well because our government is all into propaganda and ideology, they try to emphasize only Russian parts of international history of our town. As an anarchist I see through all this, how history is taught almost everywhere, including in Russia. Trying to convince people that there is any "continuity" between current state and previous ones, and portraying states, identified as "predecessors" as all good, while others as "all bad". To be fair when Sweden got a lot of land during Russian times of trouble in 17th century, they were very oppressive towards Orthodox religion, and many Orthodox Karelians and Ingrians left, so that is how Tver Karelians came to be

@J.D-g8.1

2 жыл бұрын

@@KateeAngel Well said.

@febrian0079

2 жыл бұрын

@@KateeAngel be proud of your nation's ancestors is not dumb, it's great. Qin Shi Huang for example was a great tyrant and yet the Chinese people worship him (either figuratively or literally) since he united the previously fractured China into one state, a theme which continue until this day. The other example being Genghis Khan who despite his incredible brutality across Asia, he gave birth to the idea of a united Mongol nation. Peter the Great, while a "tyrant" as you put it, did so many great things to Russia, without him Russia's development as a civilization would be hampered and the Russians may never got Catherine the Great. National heroes is very effective at bringing people together and encourage people to defend their country. Of course since you're an anarchist you wouldn't understand

@tsud165

2 жыл бұрын

And then they cry about the siege of leningrad, they fucking deserved it.

@hehhuh3991

2 жыл бұрын

@@tsud165 bruh

Great video, thanks for producing it!

This is def one of my favourite channels!!

Charles XII was shot some 150 meters from the walls of Fredriksten. It was a perfect hit from a little more than 90 degree angle to the side of the head. The bullet went slightly upwards. It looks more consistent with one of his own blindsiding him and shooting him than with a lucky shot from the fortress.

@laststand6420

Жыл бұрын

Friendly fire isn't.

Thank you

The quality and thoroughness of your videos never cease to amaze. Thank you

Look forward to every video its crazy

I lost track of who was fighting whom when the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth started fighting itself and everyone else got pulled in. Once the Ottomans got involved, I was expecting to see some Portugese for good measure. While all that is happening, Prussia just ominously growing and changing its name every time it appears on screen @.@

Charles XII is one of my favorite generals of all times.

Excellent series, much appreciated!

Great coverage and content, Thanks!

Fantastic video, I’m so glad that you covered the great northern war. It’s sad that nowadays zero attention is being paid towards it and the outcome it had for Europe which solidified the downfall of Sweden and Poland Lithuania as well as establish Russia as a great power. One think I would just like to point out is that Rehnskiöld was the true genius. He didn’t just masterminded victory at Fraustadt but on every major battle up until the invasion of Russia. Charles had the overall command and would decide where they would campaign and when they would accept battle but it was always Rehnskiöld who would formulate the battle plans. That is not to disregard Charles. He was an extremely determined and brave leader, always at the front fighting and inspiring his troops but he was just 18 years old at the outbreak of the war with zero battle experience so he knew it was prudent to let his best general command. However Charles learnt while on campaign and in 1706 at Grondo he scored a brilliant victory over the Russians, losing just 100 men against their 17,000.

Hard to watch this, as a Swede. But a great episode as always from King and Generals, this is quality. Charles XII is my favorit king of Sweden, but he is actually not that popular here, being called the warrior king who was obsessed with war (which of course has a certain truth) But to be fair he never started an offensive war and i guess anyone would have had som kind of hubris after defeating one by one of that gigantic coalition - from a Swedish perspective. Fun fact, there is a statue of him standing in the kings garden in Stockholm. There he stands with the sword in one hand and the other pointing out over the battlefield, to the east (which of course is Russia)

@oksanamazur2123

Жыл бұрын

As a Ukrainian, I am really sorry that Charles lose that war, as that was one of those chances to extinguish russian imperialism

@amaestro1697

Жыл бұрын

@@oksanamazur2123 yes you are right, the power vacuum Sweden left behind when loosing the status of a regional power in the Baltic, Russia could establish as a major power

@amaestro1697

Жыл бұрын

@@oksanamazur2123 also all the best wishes to you and the people of Ukraine 🇺🇦 may you have peace soon

@oksanamazur2123

Жыл бұрын

@@amaestro1697 thanks for support!

@alexeyamosov664

Жыл бұрын

@@oksanamazur2123 there were many empires that would like to control fertile lands of Ukraine. If Poland and Russia are utterly defeated and shattered (the only outcome that might have been called Carolus’ victory) Ottomans or Habsburgs would’ve probably just took these lands with no effort. At the time, when there were neither Russian nor Ukrainian nations presented, Russia was a better alternative than any other, whether you like this or not (simply because of faith and culture stuff). But this doesn’t mean that nowadays whatever our corrupted militaristic regime is doing is justified, I am against Putin and this horrible war. Best wishes (even tho I won’t be mad at all if you don’t accept them).

Very insightful on the History of Europe continue with the great work

Going through a rough breakup and have been binge watching your videos like there's no tomorrow to distract myself, cheers for creating such fantastic content!