The most ironic thing is that World Rugby actually use the Farrell tackle on Esterhuizen as a textbook example video of an illegal shoulder charge🤣

Proud to say I have been refereed twice by the linesman who absolutely botched the Tuilagi/Ashton situation.

And what about 2011 World Cup Final ? The whole match is controversial !

@Me-ex7qg

Жыл бұрын

French player should have been red carded for an eye gouge. So can't really complain about the end result

@jamespatagueule4599

Жыл бұрын

@@Me-ex7qg I bet you never seen the match

Can always count on a french ref to be a massive POES

@armellelalicorne8840

Жыл бұрын

Always count on a english ref to be a massive d***

@pnel7799

Жыл бұрын

@@armellelalicorne8840 Let's agree that most ref's (Not all) are dog water

@armellelalicorne8840

Жыл бұрын

@@pnel7799 yeah lets say that

Find it hilarious that there are still welsh fans trying to justify that first decision, despite the fact that the referee involved and the referees union all apologised and said he got it wrong. You would be fuming if that was given against you, not saying 'well they should have reacted faster'. I can look at that Farrell shoulder charge decision as an England fan and acknowledge we got away with one there, have some self respect and do the same.

decision against England the first one urgghhhh

@RugbyManual

3 жыл бұрын

I know!

@stevenmcalister826

3 жыл бұрын

@Luke Thomas No, because the referee decides to put time on without notifying England. Don’t know how they’re expected to know when time is put back on if they aren’t told.

@stevenmcalister826

3 жыл бұрын

@Luke Thomas It was such a good awareness that the referee admitted the decision was wrong. Who would’ve thought.

@stevenmcalister826

3 жыл бұрын

@Luke Thomas No they wouldn’t. Because that completely changes the game. You can’t guarantee they would’ve scored any points if those tries were disallowed.

"It's a high challenge by Tuilagi..." and that missed out the most important part: "... off the ball ... Ashton didn't have the ball!"

9:48 Cueto's foot was in-touch before he grounded the ball. End of.

EMG v SA in 2007 was clearly foot on the chalk before it rises up.

That ref who reffed that England wales game was the worst rugby ref I’ve ever seen. I was sure he was payed after that. He knew what he was doing

And no surprises Wayne Barnes features so often.

for the Italian win over Wales, the ref was talking to his bookie not the TMO for sure

@ 0.58 what was incorrect about the referee's ruling, couldn't work out what was wrong about it, thanks

The first try, Wales v England, should have seen sanctions for the ref. There was a clear advantage given by calling time on before England had got back into position.

Grate vid my guy

@rjws69

Жыл бұрын

🧀

What despicable things did the Welsh do to the ref from 7:03?

Ah yes. An excuse to add fuel to the fire in the war between Welsh and English supporters on social media🤣🤣

2007 World Cup Final there should be no controversy. Foot touches the line end of story.

@brentmeistergeneral6074

3 жыл бұрын

Left foot moves up just before the line is touched.

@christoffhavinga983

3 жыл бұрын

@@brentmeistergeneral6074 pause at 9.48

@brentmeistergeneral6074

3 жыл бұрын

@@christoffhavinga983 yes the foot moves across and literally pops up at the line, hence Stuart Barnes saying exactly that!

@christoffhavinga983

3 жыл бұрын

@@brentmeistergeneral6074 disagree. For me foot clearly scrapes the line.

@alex.1clark344

3 жыл бұрын

@@brentmeistergeneral6074 aggreed

As a french i agree france shouldn't win the 2007 world cup but we desserved to win the 2011 one. I think 2011 final is the worst refereed match of all time

As a Kiwi I felt sorry for England. Ref was completely against England clear as day. And the knock on from Wales in the same game was 100% crap call. He had no control of the ball dropping it forward regardless of it coming off his leg in any direction - he needed to have CONTROL of the ball. England hard done by. If Wales win the tournament it’ll be the most undeserved victory to date.

@lhommeheureux9699

3 жыл бұрын

lol you didn't see the game. Wales dominated almost the whole game. And, for the ref, he apologized. Tell me how many ref recognize his mistake ? As a frenchman, I don't remember any ref apologized after stealing us a game. And we got stolen a lot of times aha. The latest is the final of the autumn nations cup. Even the English newspaper told England got helped by the ref. And Andrew Brace will referee the next crunch. Try to find a justice in here. There is no. So stop complaining.

@thottobot7444

3 жыл бұрын

It was deserved England where indisciplined and where dominated in the last 15 minutes

@casperselka671

Жыл бұрын

I agree I remember that match it was disgraceful reffing. It didn’t seem like a mistake like a lot of bad reffing decisions it genuinely felt intentional and especially when he didn’t give the knock on. Wales got lucky in pretty much every game from that tournament the worst six nations winners I can remember.

@Snotzalotz

7 ай бұрын

Ugh imagine feeling sorry for a bunch of arrogant pricks like the English?.

the welsh 16 didn't appear off-side at all, accidentally or not; look at the 22m line? ...

The penalty against dean Richards 1st test v new Zealand in 93 .Was absolutely appalling.

Wayne had a few very honourable mentions there. I’m sure his wife thought all of those decisions were correct. And told everyone not to be so mean to him 😂

The only good french ref is one reffing a different sport.

Two forward passes in the AB’s vs French in 2007 RWC

Amazing how many of these absolutely BS calls Wayne Barnes is involved in. He is supposed to be a top 3 referee

Not one mention of Bryce ‘I need a guide dog’ Lawrence complete incompetence in the 2011 World Cup match Boks vs Australia - for his services to the NZ All Blacks he was promoted to the NZ ref performance head job! Amazing! At least 14 bad decisions in one match and he got promoted! The Peter Principle indeed

@Me-ex7qg

Жыл бұрын

He was fine. A few 50/50 calls didn't go your way and you wet the bed.

@richardscanlan3167

Жыл бұрын

@@Me-ex7qg no.no.apparently it was all part of a kiwi conspiracy to deny SA the 2011 title!

@cornelcarelse7613

Жыл бұрын

Like Suzy 😂

@onelokie

7 ай бұрын

@@richardscanlan3167 In 2011 only one team could beat AB's, however bryce made sure they don't have to play Springboks. No conspiracy just a typical convict cheating.

@richardscanlan3419

7 ай бұрын

Yawn,just another saffer boer,or,more appropriately bore. Here's hoping the poms knock you out in the semis,anyone but this grub,cynical outfit called the boks winning the WC.Your mob are just plain bad news.@@onelokie

Great video but why the pointless music that makes it hard to hear the dialogue? They are a key part of controversial decisions!

Farrel is a dirty player.

@WillCamx

5 ай бұрын

Utter thug.

One of the first things you're taught in rugby is to never turn your back if the opposition have a penalty. If you look at the first incident from a different angle, you'll see that the opposite wing is set, while the forwards are stood in the middle actually staring at Biggar, hence why Gauzere called time on. Then when you take into account the reaction of the English defence to Kieran Hardy's try in the second-half, the English were clearly under the impression in both instances that Wales were going to kick for goal. You can blame the referee all you want, but with England's ill-discipline, the first try could have been avoided so easily.

@RugbyManual

3 жыл бұрын

I just think England were hard done by as the referee told Farrell to have a word with England and only told Biggar that time was back on rather than letting England know. That being said I completely agree that it could’ve been easily avoided, the penalty Farrell gave away that led to the try was poor and ultimately poor discipline lost England the match.

@RugbyManual

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks for your comment!

@AndrewDavidForde

3 жыл бұрын

@@RugbyManual He blew the whistle to indicate time was back on; I think Gauzere himself assumed that he was going for goal hence why he blew it so quickly.

@matthewjefferson4037

3 жыл бұрын

The referee admitted himself he got both decisions wrong. As a neutral England were shafted.

@AndrewDavidForde

3 жыл бұрын

@@matthewjefferson4037 Shafted? They got back to 24-24 and then conceded 16 points in the final quarter, none of which were due to poor refereeing decisions. Hardly shafted. And yes, while he admitted he got two decisions wrong, England aren't the first team and won't be the last to be the victim of 2 poor refereeing decisions.

The thing is the ball hits off LRZ leg and goes backwards then goes forwards from the hit off the leg so it shouldn't really be controversial.

@jamesxife123

3 жыл бұрын

The reason why it is controversial is because he knocks the ball forward on to his leg

@rohanvandenakker5411

3 жыл бұрын

Watch Whistle Watch with Nigel Owens on the World Rugby channel. He explains why it is definitely a knock on every time.

@matthewjackson5128

3 жыл бұрын

He loses it forward, then it bounces off his leg so its a knock on

South Africa getting screwed over and over

a lot of poor English refs and a lot of English thuggery here

lol

Don't know why England fans are crying about the Welsh try. You can clearly see the French ref say time off to England while walking towards them 00:31 and than Dan Biggar kicks the ball at 00:48 that's 17 seconds to get ready. England should be blaming themselves for sleeping or expecting Dan Biggar to go for the 3 points that's why they were all huddled up.

@RugbyManual

3 жыл бұрын

I think it’s more that the ref says to Farrell to have a word with his team and that time is off, but doesn’t let England know time is back on

@jamesxife123

3 жыл бұрын

Because ref’s always ask the defending team if they are set.

@terrifying7847

3 жыл бұрын

@@jamesxife123 this ref didn't and did not see a clear knock on either for another Welsh try.Hes absolutely useless and should not be given another game during the six nations

@matthewjackson5128

3 жыл бұрын

@@RugbyManual He blew the whistle and motioned that time is on, is that not how he is supposed to let England know time is on?

@terrifying7847

3 жыл бұрын

@@matthewjackson5128 no he is also suppose to allow England to reset before restarting the game

5:15 that’s not controversial at all

@rohanvandenakker5411

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah it's just plain wrong

@James-hm3jk

3 жыл бұрын

@@rohanvandenakker5411 the card or what he did? That was clear head to head contact

@rohanvandenakker5411

3 жыл бұрын

@@James-hm3jk I really don't see a lot of head contact, but I can understand there is a conversation to be had there. However it definitely isn't high as the ref suggests, and ultimately cards him for.

@caylebmladenovic3348

Жыл бұрын

@@rohanvandenakker5411it was high and a shoulder charge should have been red

@baconcheeseburger4504

6 ай бұрын

@@rohanvandenakker5411 It really is high there is head to head contact and he makes no clear and deliberate effort to lower his height. Cynical fould play and deserved a red

Should be a non-French sport

@gabrielbones106

Жыл бұрын

Shut up football should be a non english sport

@illeatthat

Жыл бұрын

@gabrielbones106 both sports originated in England - so did cricket and tennis and badminton and squash

@gabrielbones106

Жыл бұрын

Yeah but WE destroyd you 53-10

@illeatthat

Жыл бұрын

@@gabrielbones106 😴😴😴 how many times

@gabrielbones106

Жыл бұрын

England suck at the moment in rugby

I dunno in watching this it looks like the ref told Farrell time was back on. I don't think he has to then wait for England to get set up before restarting the play. Thats England's problem. Judging by farrells attitude, I'm being prejudicial here, I think he was taking his time after he was told by the ref his time to talk was up. Farrell had better learn to establish a relationship with the ref rather than always back chatting as its not working

@RugbyManual

3 жыл бұрын

The referee said to Farrell to have a word with his team and that time was off and then when the ref went back to Dan Biggar he told Biggar that the time was on. So England were under the impression that time was off and they could have water and Farrell could talk to them, it was definitely very poor refereeing. I do agree that Farrell needs to work on how he speaks to referees if he wants to be a better captain and up to the standard of someone like Sam Warburton.

@canadiancontent352

3 жыл бұрын

@@RugbyManual i thought the same until your video which clearly shows the ref speaking to England before he blows time back on

@jamesxife123

3 жыл бұрын

@@canadiancontent352 that’s when he says time off

@johnpollock7952

Жыл бұрын

The ref same time was on to Farrell at the beginning. Told them both time was then off. Farrell was clearly trying to play games with the amount of time they took to talk (they had 20 secs). England didn't get back in position waiting for the ref to put time on. Wales were ready and acted quickly. Farrell's attitude cost the try.

the 3 worst referees for me by far are Joubert, Barnes and Bevan... All 3 are from UK

What about the decision that screwed Scotland out of the 2015 World Cup against Australia? Was one of the most heartbreaking decisions I’ve ever experienced in any sports, Scotland had a real chance at getting through the next round as we would’ve gotten Argentina

So chuffed that South Africa beat England with 1 point in the RWC. Karma