This is so lovely. The beauty and pain attached to love...you have shown that so beautifully here. What a wonderful reminder to grab hold of the love we have in our lives. Perfect song choice and you edited to the lyric brilliantly.

I love it. I came for the song but stayed for the video.

Very beautiful! And I like the yellow at the end........ it seems to say that there's light and hope after all the trouble........ And it is MUCH better than you think, very emotional.....

I remember when we talked about you using this song instead of Ophelia I thought it was a good choice, I was wrong it was an excellent choice One thing I have always loved about your videos is how you match not just the lyrics but the emotions of the song so perfectly to the scenes how you take such a variety of different movies and different women and tie them together here you brought all these different characters together under one theme, despite the deep sorrows of life there is still joy

I think you've done a lovely job with the video, all the moods of the film clips match the moods of the particular moments of the song (at least they do in my head while I'm watching it!). It's good that you are so self critical of the video as it shows that you are putting a lot into it. I get the feeling that you would never actually be happy with it, no matter how good it was, which is so refreshing when you see the amount of terrible videos which have had no thought or effort put into them.

@Jurisrachel

5 жыл бұрын

Hear, hear!

Oh Sarah! Du hast mich wirklich zum Weinen gebracht! Was für ein wunderschönes Video! Ich liebe Natalie Merchant! Und die Szene wenn Cecilia und James McAvoy am Strand sind, was ja nur in der Phantasie passiert, in echt haben sie sich nie wieder gesehen! Und dieses wunderschöne Video hast Du Deiner Klavierlehrerin gewidmet! Herzzerreißend schön!!! Sie muss ein besonderer Mensch gewesen sein um von einem so besonderem Menschen wie Dir so geliebt zu werden !

Hello sweetheart. I read your description and let me first say: thanks for your honesty and thank you for sharing that quote at the start. I really like it, it is a very true and great quote. I actually really like this video because it touched me. I love how you've used so many father/mother clips (you always prove me wrong when I think that it would be difficult to find the right clips for the lyrics :p) and I like your clever use of "good moments".

This might not be "perfect" the way you wanted it to be, but the important thing is that you made it and posted it anyway. (It'd be a shame if it remained unused inside a computer) It is a wonderful video montage and it's great that it's here for people to watch. And the gesture remains strong, a sweet tribute to a loved one lost.

are you kidding me ? this video is really good i actually liked it a lot, the song fits the fandoms you used very well and i spotted French Kiss :) and i'm sorry about your music teacher.

Thank you very much. and yes, i believe only because of self criticism can we really improfe ...

I hope you don't mind me commenting 3 times, but I just have many thoughts about this video ;-). I also like the massive variety in films you used. Many different types of movies and many different scenes and you are still able to create a coherent video! I think that it is a very good video hun! But I think we may not be able to convince you, right? And I love the idea of some sort of tribute. You ought to be proud of yourself :). BIG hugs, and take care (btw, still faves for me ;-))

@ruba1029 haha, well, i had more french kiss scenes planned (great that you rememeber btw!!) but somehow they did not really fit... thank you for your kind words:)

I think this is a lovely, beautiful video, coupled with one of the most poignant songs I know. While this video may not meet your own internal standards, it's still quite good -- and it's helped other find this lush, wondrous song by Natalie Merchant, so that's something, as well. (Even though I'm a bit of a hypocrite for saying this, 'cause I've by no means mastered this, myself ...) try to be nicer to yourself. Try to be as kind to yourself as you would be to a friend -- or even a stranger. You do deserve that. We all do. So. Thanks for the bit of beauty, even if it's not as masterful as you envisioned it. :)

The running part was the highlight of the video for me, I thought it was beautiful and very well made! :) I tried to find something I wasn't so fond of, because you aren't satisfied with it.. THe only thing I am not a big fan off are the transitions (like for example at 3:00) but they are only about 5 times in the video and you still made them fit in a great way :p. And why don't you like the yellowness? Wasn't that her favourite color or is my mind just making that up? To me it works!

@Lotjeknorrepotje thank you my dear.

@sallyannerenee thank you. well, i think the yellow in the end is a bit too intensive. like, emma's face looks even a bit scary, doesn't it? :)

@majtris danke nathalie! danke! es hat mir so viel bedeutet, diesen wunderschönen kommentar von dir zu lesen. ich denke allerdings, dass du mit dem letzten satz etwas übertrieben hast :) danke. es freut mich, dass dir mein video gefällt!

@Edelwyn12 thank you!!!

@vampires18 thank you

@PinkTitanium I am sorry, I don't know. i downloaded the song from the internet.

live version

@beretta1342000 thanks

which album is this version from? it's not from Ophelia