Just gonna say, if you put the magic shell on first, then put the sammich in the freezer, it hardens up withing a minute, and the rest of the sammich would be fine. I do this when i use magic shell on ice cream. Hardens it faster

Magic shell could have gone so much worse I think this was close to best case.

I would have recommended putting the shell on, then just sticking the sandwich in the freezer for a minute

The Mcelroy’s brought me here and I’m loving it.

I think they wanted you to just put the magic shell on it, then refrigerate it for like a minute or two to harden the shell, not freeze the whole sandwich

@ivan4993

8 ай бұрын

But he always rolls that part last right? So I think this was unavoidable.

@McBehrer

7 ай бұрын

@@ivan4993 ... I don't think you understood my point

🛡️Wild magic spoiler shield🛡️

This is actually a really prefect Halloween sandwich. A little bit of a trick, a little bit of a treat and chocolate is somehow involved lol

Oh no you almost had a normal sandwich.

I probably would have put the magic shell on just after sandwich creation and then put that in the freezer for like three minutes. Would have solidified the shell without freezing the interior of the sandwich. Not really useful now because you'll probably never have to do this to a sandwich ever again...

When I heard chocolate sauce I was actually quite excited, I didn't consider the freezing tho. Also it looks like milk chocolate. I bet this sandwich with some dark chocolate would be fire.

This one should have had the jus and the one with the jus should have had this lol

@Jeevesie1988

8 ай бұрын

The McElroys have ruined my brain (again). I can now only read jus the way Griffin pronounced it. JUH.

Damn, the magic shell could've been awesome on something better fitting... Like, smth with strawberries/peanut butter/cream cheese... Well, at least there's inspiration for a sweet sandwich!

@Jeevesie1988

8 ай бұрын

Has there ever been a purely sweet sandwich on RfS? I don't recall one that didn't have at least one extremely savoury ingredient alongside the marshmallow fluff or jelly or whatever.

@adancein

8 ай бұрын

@@Jeevesie1988 Good question! I don't remember seeing one... But there might've been?

All the McElroy episodes have been like, take the most beautiful sandwich you've ever seen and put the worst twist on it immaginable.

*chanting* Toilet bag! Toilet bag!

Biting into a sandwich with a frozen tomato slice has my sensitive teeth hurting just thinking about it!

Sandwich but cold

Homie was stoked on that 20 after the magic shell roll hahaha

Only needed to make the top bagel slice cold for the magic shell to work. BBQ+chocolate= cheater's molé sauce

He's been killing it with the mcelroy references

great episode!

@adventuresinaardia

8 ай бұрын

Mr… Mr Jones?

😂😂❤❤

That actually looks so good

nothing bagel is either Gluten Free or The Void

Oh bro, I would have put it in the center

Kinda like a cold doughnut sandwich

Maybe it would have harmed the sandwich less if you made like a solid disc of Magic Shell in the freezer then put that on the sandwich. (Also less messy.)

@anidnmeno

8 ай бұрын

sais this above, damn i like the way you think

May be cheating but I would of just put the untouched side of the bagel in the freezer then chocolate on the inside

freeze the magic shell into a disc, then put it _in_ the sandwich?

Wait, what's going on here? Between this episode and the one immediately before it, the Jelly Bean entry has been crossed out. When did that result get rolled?

Should have magic shelled it first and then put it in the freezer.

What do you do with the other half of the sandwiches?

@elizabethsmith6408

8 ай бұрын

Or do you eat both and cutting it in half is just for cross-section?

@adventuresinaardia

8 ай бұрын

@@elizabethsmith6408I eat the whole sandwich

Next season you should get Brennan and the D20 crew to maoe your wild magic table.

The whole time the brothers were talking about Magic Shell I was picturing some sort of like, toastie-press that shaped the sandwich like a ridged scallop shell or something, and the whole "put it in the freezer" thing was to make it keep its shape. I was not picturing... that. O.o

wild magic needs more options that can actually work. magic shell would never be goon on any sandwich. idk idk

It sort of feels like the Wild Magic list this season is more and more a how to screw up this good sandwich. Like Wild Magic has some benefits along with the bad. This whole list just seems like bad looking at it.

@Quiltfish

8 ай бұрын

I don't know, 12-19 seem fine to me, 14 and 15 have already been shown to be good. Around 10 seems more annoying than sandwich-ruining and well, botches gonna botch.