Robert Cabral. By Definition - He Is Punishing The Dog And Rewarding Punishment. Why Doesn't It Work

Ask - don't tell. This is the Achilles heel of dog training. They expect the dog - they don't respect the dog. This dog has zero choices - and she's making choices for the food. Get rid of the treat bag, and show us the dog coming to you.

Пікірлер: 156

  • @roberthynesdogtraining
    @roberthynesdogtraining8 ай бұрын

    For trainers and dog owners that believe I'm blowing smoke up your arse? Join my little facebook group - and feel free to read the postings from dog owners that helped their dog overcome aggression and reactivity - ON THEIR OWN. No "dog trainer" required. They stepped out of the cash cow called dog training - stepped out of all the noise. How do they accomplish it so quickly? They now understand the very "object of the science of behaviour" - that trainers have thrown in the garbage. I dare you to open your mind to something old. Open your mind to the reality of what "dog training" is doing to you. facebook.com/groups/540079038188077

  • @alexandradittmann8588

    @alexandradittmann8588

    7 ай бұрын

    join request sent - new sub here, I'm intrigued by your angle, your perspective. It's refreshing, different from the mainstream "camps", and it reminds me of my time volunteering in shelters back in Germany in my younger years. Before any internet, let alone a R+ vs balanced controversy, so what I used to do with fearful or reactive dogs was merely, take my time, and sit with them. Just me and the dog, until eventually, trust was built, and we could move toward finding that dog a good home. I suspect plenty of behavioral problems could be resolved if people went back to the old days when you just invested TIME and patience in a dog...

  • @hdottraining
    @hdottraining8 ай бұрын

    I have to say, Robert, you have shifted my perspective on a couple of things - most specifically, the use of treats. I've used them intermittently, but now I'm not using them at all. What you've said about the dog coming in for the food in this video made the light bulb in my brain come on; I've always said I want a dog to follow me because they respect and trust me, not because they fear me. Well, that also applies to the use of food, too. Follow me because you trust and respect me, not because I have food. I really appreciate this so much.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Thank you.

  • @Sharetheroad3333
    @Sharetheroad33338 ай бұрын

    Here’s the other thing I think what people need from you Robert. Break down these videos, and THEN, give a brief narrative of what you would do if you walked into this same scenario.

  • @belgian_groenendael

    @belgian_groenendael

    8 ай бұрын

    I was thinking the same. To be a critic is fine, but not much value to be critical without offering any type of solution.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Critique is great, makes me want to do better. I'll be sure to add in alternatives.

  • @learnfacts101

    @learnfacts101

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@@roberthynesdogtrainingCabral is a great trainer.

  • @kpvvue7409
    @kpvvue74098 ай бұрын

    At this point your just trying to get some attention. You finding every little thing to say it is punishment or the dog is not willing to so its bad training. Anyone who sees this comment go watch this channels past videos with a dog and you guys can literally call him out on the same thing he call other trainers out on. Theres a video where he drag a dog on to the treadmill and another where he approaches the gate and continue to even though the dog wasn’t willingly letting him and barking. Also there was one where he went into a yard and a german shepard was barking at him and stayed away for 20-30 minute and he cut the video to the dog suddenly have a leash on and boxed in at the deck.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Read Skinner - you'll get it. I don't say anything without being able to back it up.

  • @RobertCabralDogs

    @RobertCabralDogs

    8 ай бұрын

    You’re 💯 right

  • @kpvvue7409

    @kpvvue7409

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining i watch all your videos with dogs. Lol and if u think robert, dogdaddy, and them other trainers fail. You also fail.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    How am I failing? Dogs running around a dog park just being a dog with no issues? You call that a fail? Dogs ending up in control and management with an e-collar and a prong is a fail. They turned the dog into a liability - I want the dog to be an asset.

  • @kpvvue7409

    @kpvvue7409

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining you failed. You drag a dog onto the treadmill and that dog was terrified. You cut the video where a german shepard was barking and staying the distance from u and she suddenly have a leash on and boxed in on a deck. You approached a yard that the dog was unwillingly letting u to approach and u did anyways. So you cut out the part where u punished her to put a leash on.

  • @Sharetheroad3333
    @Sharetheroad33338 ай бұрын

    This is wonderful thanks! Do more reaction videos. This is so useful when you break it down like this.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    I think this is the way to go - show owners what they are watching.

  • @davidg1782
    @davidg17825 ай бұрын

    Has he ever witnessed dogs fighting? Going for the hind quarters is one of the tactics used. And he imitated it. The truth is, it takes time to build a relationship of respect and trust in a dog. I've been involved with probably 50 dogs in my life. 3 I owned, 5 others I might as well have. I have always built respect and trust.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    5 ай бұрын

    Same here. Relationship is everything, I've never had to train any dogs to be honest. All were off leash all the time, never had any concerns about them running away from me.

  • @RobiPerk0125
    @RobiPerk01258 ай бұрын

    according to you how is the correct way of approach a dog? u just criticized everyone that actually are helping dogs.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    You are on my youtube channel. Have a look. I don't say anything that I can't back up.

  • @RobiPerk0125

    @RobiPerk0125

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining yeah is nothing toback up cause u not showing nothing hahaha I don't see any step by step successful training methods on ur KZread channel Idont see nothing hahaha

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@RobiPerk0125 Look at Bear. great example. Not one trainer would meet her, all scared of the dogs. 4 hours, she was in a dog park - completely different dog. You're just here to blow smoke. I can't wait til your tools are banned - cause you won't have a choice but to seek out people like me.

  • @angelaw4063
    @angelaw406328 күн бұрын

    I get that you don't like his training method. It seems to be an ongoing thing with people taking issue with every training style these days. I have personally found with my two rescue dogs, it's not a one size fits all approach. Some times methods from a blend of Robert Cabral, Nate Schoemer, and Zak George work for my dogs. I personally am not sure you have proved what you think you have here and feel as though time is better spent showing alternative techniques to people on how to approach a situation rather than critiquing someone else's position if you are a professional. A few things I noticed from the video: He is clearly doing a video to assess this dog and her potential training needs, which means he has to get close to her to see how she is when handled. Hence, using food and leash to gain this. If adopted, she will likely have to be on leash at some point in her life, which she will need to get comfortable with quickly unless the person (s) who adopt her have a wide open secured place they can leave her while she gets used to them, which to people in the city is apparently abuse. He was holding the leash really tight at one point. I've watched a lot of his videos and he constantly tells handlers and owners not to do this. Even the most skilled people make mistakes, so he potentially made a mistake here. There were a couple of instances where he held the leash away from his body as the dog reacted "aggressively" to being handled. Robert's actions were to protect himself. Imagine if he had no idea what he was doing, he would have been bit. This literally has happened to people I know who adopted a dog and didn't know what to watch for, which is like 90% people adopting or purchasing a dog. He purposely touch her hindquarters to show her sensitivity and reaction, which he basically said in between your pauses. So..... And he is probably right that in her current state, she might not be the best fit for a family with kiddos. Kids can be rough when handling a dog. They have to be taught not to and that is generally better if the dog is not already uncomfortable with being around people or being handled. Can be worked through but definitely agree with him on this. When handling dogs in the real world you definitely want to try to provide a positive experience as much as possible but there are going to be times when things are uncomfortable for them as they learn what you want and you learn what they need. Asking a dog to do something when it doesn't understand what you want and expecting it to just do it doesn't make sense. One way or another (without actual abuse), you have to show them what you would like from them for them to offer it.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    28 күн бұрын

    Go watch my latest reaction to Cabral. You'll understand. In Cabrals own words - if you don't have the tools, then you can't train a dog. So take away his prongs and e-collars. He's useless. A fraud - and he's not the only one out there.

  • @angelaw4063

    @angelaw4063

    27 күн бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining Thanks for the offer but I will not be taking in anymore of your content. Based on what I've already viewed, this is clearly just an effort to drive your viewership up by using content from other people who have more viewers and subscribers. Click bait at its best. Great deflection though. The use of tools is a funny thing to argue because that literally includes collars, leashes, fences, spacial pressure, voice command, clickers, etc. All of which can be viewed negatively if not used properly (except maybe clickers). You might not like prongs or e-collars but you can't tell me that you don't use tools for training. It's literally evident in your own content. So to call someone a fraud for clearly owning that they use tools is ridiculous. I've seen him do training without e-collars and prongs but I guess you missed that content when you did your research. Bye now!

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    27 күн бұрын

    @@angelaw4063 Then feel free to move on. But keep an eye to my channel over the next few days. You're going to see alot more on Cabral that you never realized :)

  • @roberthynesdogtraining
    @roberthynesdogtraining8 ай бұрын

    I don't think people understand what I'm saying - maybe I should have made it clearer in the video. Dog trainers are causing this epidemic of dogs in shelters - it's dog training that's getting dogs killed. Now dog trainers want to invade shelters - they are going to fix all the shelter dogs with the same old garbage protocols, treats, tools, and quadrants. All I can do is shake my head. It's embarrassing to watch this.

  • @sannehansen4156

    @sannehansen4156

    8 ай бұрын

    Yes please to a video about. How it should be done, preferably with follow-up

  • @tlcdogtraining7552
    @tlcdogtraining75527 ай бұрын

    You keep saying she only comes for the food, ok so what would you do. You throw in lots of what not to do but don't give any explanation of what to do instead. You say be a positive reinforcement, how. Lots of words, not much explanation. If you have a shut down dog, who is clearly scared, why would she go near any human. She is a shelter dog who has limited time before being put down.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    7 ай бұрын

    I employ trust technique, it's about calm and quiet. When an animal finds peace in your presence, they will come to trust you. I would sit on the grass, shut my mouth and let her choose to come to me. Sometimes it takes a while. And I'm just observing the dogs behaviour in the meantime. If you were in a fear state, you wouldn't be thinking very well either. What would you be more attracted to? A calm presence or someone in an excited state?

  • @jerimiah_y
    @jerimiah_y8 ай бұрын

    The caption was foreshadowing. Not saying you’re wrong but how do you react before anything happens. Did you say owner? Shelter dog.

  • @gregcarrick4785
    @gregcarrick47855 ай бұрын

    I agree with you about treats, but everything else is bullshit

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    5 ай бұрын

    People aren't getting the joke. It's because of trainers like Robert that the shelters are full. Now here he is putting on a show in the shelter? 2 weeks? No results? What are you declaring BS?

  • @AustinLaramee777
    @AustinLaramee7778 ай бұрын

    Exactly! The food is making a positive connection to the trainer. You don’t know what you’re taking about. I want to see your ipo champion titles, and high akc obedience titles. Where’s your titles? You don’t do any championship competition

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    I want to see your dog running a dog park being a dog. I can show you my dog running a dog park. I can show you the most "aggressive" dogs running dog parks. I don't need food or tools - cause I understand the real science. I've read the books. Have you?

  • @RobertCabralDogs

    @RobertCabralDogs

    8 ай бұрын

    Running in the park. Wow. What an accomplishment. Go to a shelter and save a dog instead of stealing someone’s material and trying to poach likes and subscribers. You’re a pathetic person.

  • @jpaleblue

    @jpaleblue

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining Can you please direct me to the video of your aggressive dog in the dog park with other dogs? The only video I found you have a pug type mix and it’s the only dog in the park.

  • @seansvensson4400

    @seansvensson4400

    8 ай бұрын

    I started to watch you more and more, intresting to see your perspective. I don't want to train my dog with treats, i think it's The best way as you say to build a realationship without treats, sometimes maybe but not always.. I want my dog to Come to me becouse our realationship not for treats..

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@seansvensson4400 Then you have to ask, don't tell. Treats are a punishment just like e-collars and prongs. Think about treat training a child - that wouldn't end well right? So too for the dog.

  • @clarealiberti3448
    @clarealiberti34487 ай бұрын

    The Shepherd is distracted and doesn't know this human. The trainer is trying to make being near him a better place to be than focusing on everything else. The dog is off leash and the trainer is giving the dog the chance to choose. Treats have their purpose in training for conditioning. I'm not talking about excessive treat giving. The trainer isn't by any means punishing the dog. He's trying to get his attention. Dogs know the difference between a person angry and one that is not. I don't know why your tearing down this trainer who is trying to help this dog.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    7 ай бұрын

    People still aren't getting the joke. It's because of dog training - because of people like Cabral that shelters are full to the brim with dogs.

  • @judet3026
    @judet30268 ай бұрын

    Restraint is not 'punishment'. Anyone handling any dog has the right to restrain the animal from inflicting a bite. As for the rest imho you are sounding just like ZG who thinks no one else can do it like he does. Shelter dogs are on death row if they can't be assessed and handled. And here you are criticising someone for making an effort. These dogs don't get a chance to "build a relationship" as the only hope they have is if someone thinks they are cute.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    B.F Skinner. Have a read then come back and talk to me. Punishment is the removal of positive reinforcement. PR needs to be looked at through the dogs eyes - it's their desire that you're shutting down. PR is not a tool you apply, it's not something you use.

  • @RobertCabralDogs

    @RobertCabralDogs

    8 ай бұрын

    Your spot on. Another hack. Reads a book, creates a KZread channel, gets no followers, so he poaches other trainers and does a BS critique to get people to watch his crappy videos. Total hack.

  • @fredericlinden

    @fredericlinden

    8 ай бұрын

    I agree with you. After a minute of hearing the commentary on Cabral that sounded..., I stopped. I am familiar with the work of Cabral and he has done a lot, a lot, and successfully. That was however, I will admit, in my view, a weak way to get any engagement from the dog. However, the tone of voice and the attitude of the commentator made me stop watching after a minute and three seconds...

  • @nancyarmstrong781
    @nancyarmstrong7818 ай бұрын

    Thank you 😊 this is a fantastic video in what not to do. I now understand where you are coming from. Thank you again for opening my eyes .

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Thank you. That's my goal, to make owners understand that trainers have you working backward. When you are scared and desperate, all you're going to hear is "hire a trainer, cause you can't possibly do it on your own". Trainers want you scared and desperate.

  • @rascal9646
    @rascal96466 ай бұрын

    Do I use food with puppy doing basics?

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    6 ай бұрын

    Define basics? Basics for me are relationship, socialisation - and social skills. The answer is no. Take the time to get to know your pup, get them out into the world. The real science says that your dog isn't that different from your child - so raise them as such. And you'll never have issue. If you want issues, use treats and clickers, and all the tools.

  • @rascal9646

    @rascal9646

    6 ай бұрын

    @roberthynesdogtraining I'm not questioning you. I have questions, so forgive my wording. It's very rare i ever post on anything. I just wanted to know when teaching a puppy to sit, stay, and leave it, for example, do I use food - treats or is there another way.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    6 ай бұрын

    @@rascal9646 I never use food or tools. Once you achieve a solid relationship with your dog - you won't need to train anything. What breed of puppy? And what is it you're looking for? Do you want behaved or obedient - cause you can train one - but not the other.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    6 ай бұрын

    @@rascal9646 Are you on facebook by chance? If so, join my group, so much easier to talk there and you can post anonymously. Other members have had so much success, and I'm not the do all and end all. They always jump in for support. facebook.com/groups/540079038188077

  • @rascal9646

    @rascal9646

    6 ай бұрын

    @roberthynesdogtraining @roberthynesdogtraining She's a 4 month old Malamute. I haven't used any tools or treats. This is week 1 with a collar and 15m training lead. I want the same as she wants love and respect. But just like my children, she needs manners.

  • @dawidjlb2589
    @dawidjlb25898 ай бұрын

    You cannot reward a fear. The only way you can od it is to let a dog be in that state of mind, so when dogs runs aways from you because of fear and you let her do it it means that running away works and fear deepens. I really think that you are simply against any method.

  • @dawidjlb2589

    @dawidjlb2589

    8 ай бұрын

    That dog is simply lonely, Robert means nothing to her because obviously they haven't establish any relationship. Dog isn't afraid of Robert at practically any moment of that video. It is lonely dog cruising around looking for safty place. If you shut your month and don;t put any pressure at all dog will simply decide to stay away, there has to be a reason to come closer.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    What you know as the "The Quadrants Of Dog Training" is nothing more than a fabrication - a lie that was created back in the 1980's. Yes, I am against any method that employs quadrants - positive reinforcement included. It's all "punishment" based. What's being sold as positive reinforcement training is the worst punishment there is - and it's hidden from view.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    And sorry, wasn't ignoring you. You posted this 4 days ago, and it just popped up in my comments.

  • @Psuedodyonisuis
    @Psuedodyonisuis8 ай бұрын

    Hey man cheers to you and your common sense breakdowns something almost otherwise completely absent A voice 1 in a million. People are completely unaware of the silent language , all of us in the natural world use. Cheers. You’re brave for speaking up in public, where people will exhibit ignorance, in the comments.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Thank you. It's heartbreaking to see what dog owners have normalize in dog training.

  • @RobiPerk0125
    @RobiPerk01258 ай бұрын

    how is Robert Cabral Punishing this dog How??????

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Hear me very clearly. Dog training IS Operant Conditioning which IS the quadrants of dog training. How do trainers define Operant Conditioning? A method of behavioural modification using REWARD AND PUNISHMENT. They blamed B.F Skinner for all this crap - the FATHER of operant conditioning. Skinner himself would tell trainers they are lying - they are full of shite. Skinner should be mandatory reading for dog trainers. But most have never heard of him - let alone read him.

  • @RobertCabralDogs

    @RobertCabralDogs

    8 ай бұрын

    It’s not. This douche bag criticizes but does nothing to help dogs. Trying to use my name to get followers. Totally pathetic. Then we scam to get popular.

  • @Sharetheroad3333

    @Sharetheroad3333

    8 ай бұрын

    What he’s suggesting is that Robert Cabral is punishing the dog by using force, giving treats to a dog that is clearly afraid, and generally pushing the issue with this dog who isn’t ready.

  • @williamhoward3537
    @williamhoward35377 ай бұрын

    I have yet to see a video where you are not talking to the dog. Mostly it is just sitting there saying that the dog is afraid. Do you have a video where you actually do something? Its easy to say other people dont do things correctly but at least ypu could show you doing something.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    7 ай бұрын

    It's a calm voice, a reassuring voice. Not an excited voice. Calm is king, dancing around a field like an idiot isn't helping anything. When an animal finds peace in your presence, they will come to trust you. Cabral isn't at peace - he's creating excitement and the dog doesn't want nothing to do with him.

  • @williamhoward3537

    @williamhoward3537

    7 ай бұрын

    It's debatable if your voice is calming for the dogs in your videos. In your videos the dogs don't want anything to do with you either. Hell in one of them you had to get a leash to do anything with the dog. You seem to say a lot but I don't see you do much but criticize others.@@roberthynesdogtraining

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    7 ай бұрын

    @@williamhoward3537 It always comes. Sometimes I bring Monty in, and he brings them to me. Other times, it's a Monty job, I sit back and watch. Gus and Latte - that was a Monty job and he knew it.

  • @MoneyStrategiesSOULutions

    @MoneyStrategiesSOULutions

    6 ай бұрын

    I think what he is saying is that he would like to see videos of the dogs eventually coming to you (not just seeing the clips you are sitting and waiting)@@roberthynesdogtraining

  • @williamhoward3537

    @williamhoward3537

    3 ай бұрын

    @@MoneyStrategiesSOULutions I'm not against sitting and waiting. Patience is the best tool. I have an issue with someone that talks this much about how everyone is doing it wrong and then when i watch a video of his he is doing the things that he is criticizing other trainers for. Like when i said something about how he talks constantly in his videos. He comes back and says the way he is doing it is different. These videos of him criticizing other trainers are no different than Zac George's videos doing the same.

  • @lindamcmanus5807
    @lindamcmanus58078 ай бұрын

    Gee you sound like Zak George.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Do I really? I made a couple of videos to Zak George. Don't think I'm reacting to balanced trainers because I'm positive reinforcement - cause I'm not.

  • @alisha_madariaga

    @alisha_madariaga

    6 ай бұрын

    Ummm no…… not even close

  • @kandelapilingani3520
    @kandelapilingani35208 ай бұрын

    Do you really know what you are talking about,this trainer knows what he's doing 💯,you have a problem,that dog needs trust and he's doing it bro,

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    Really? Get you missed the part where he fast forwarded 3 weeks - no difference in the dog. But he knows what he's doing right? This is what you're protecting?

  • @jpaleblue

    @jpaleblue

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining You do understand the dog is living 24/7 in a kennel in the West Los Angeles Animal Shelter right? Robert is not working with the dog daily or even weekly, he is showcasing the dog to get the dog adopted and out of the shelter. This video is not supposed to be a “before and after”. The idea is to show the dog as it is, in the hope that someone will adopt the dog, provide a loving forever home and hopefully train the fog. If you are a professional I’d assume you’d know that it takes more than one ten minute session with a dog to change its behavior 3 weeks later. That’s unreasonable and unrealistic. If you were experienced you’d know that.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@jpaleblue Why are you coming at me? Watch his video - 3 weeks later, no change in the dog. What's all the hubub about? Then he calls me a douche.

  • @jpaleblue

    @jpaleblue

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining I think it’s mean spirited and negative of you to criticize a man who is sincerely trying to help get an innocent dog adopted and out of the shelter. If you truly had empathy for living beings you’d understand and appreciate his mission even if you didn’t agree with his methods. At this point it’s obvious you are using his popularity to try to gain followers and interactions on your page. Just go train some dogs, volunteer and help others, and try to appreciate the sincere efforts of others. Good luck and have a nice day.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@jpaleblue I'm getting requests from dog owners to react to videos - this isn't the only one. I've done upstate, zak george and others. and trust me, there will be alot more. People are clamoring for it now. again, 3 weeks later, no change in the dog. Cabral calls me a douche in return. Nice fellow eh? And I'm not the only one.

  • @markdubose1986
    @markdubose19868 ай бұрын

    You really get a man thinking with what you are talking about. Everything being backwards and disrespecting dogs. We humans think we can do whatever we please to dogs but that’s not the way to get trust I see.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    If B.F Skinner were mandatory reading for dog owners? This bullshite would stop. If I get my way, there is going to be a war in dog training alright - its going to be owners versus trainers. They keep talking us versus them...

  • @roberthynesdogtraining
    @roberthynesdogtraining8 ай бұрын

    Make a reaction video to Robert Cabral and he calls me a douche and pathetic in return. Looks like I'll be doing more reactions to Robert, lets see what else he has to say :0) I love when trainers get nasty cause dog owners themselves get to bear witness to this shiteshow.

  • @Grand-paws
    @Grand-paws2 ай бұрын

    You're just a rude dude!! What is the benefit of this video? What have you taught me? Show me what you can do. Don't just beat on other peoples videos!!! Show me what you got !!!!

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    2 ай бұрын

    If people would take time to go through my channel, you would see how I work with dogs. Shelters are full because of dog trainers.

  • @robertkezer3665
    @robertkezer3665Ай бұрын

    If you read this, I am just giving my thoughts. I agree that this is a perfect example of poor handling. At no point, with this dog, should the dog be touched. Also, getting down to the dog's level can be a challenge for most dogs. I do agree that if a dog like this will take treats they are valuable. Why, because a dog that will not take treats may be stressed. Not always though. What I would have done with this dog, is take her on a walk. Let her smell, let her wander around. Keep taking the dog on walks until the dog gets comfortable. The reason this dog complied at all is because the dog was forced to submit. You know how complicated these behaviors are. There seems to be urgency in this work to make the dog comply. I understand that because the shelters kill easily. A tough video to watch.My thoughts.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    Ай бұрын

    I agree with you. The primary reason for shelters being full is dog training. But here they are in shelters now. Cabral responded to this video by the way - then deleted it. He wouldn't dare respond to my other reaction videos to him.

  • @robertkezer3665

    @robertkezer3665

    Ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining You hit the nail on the head. Too much ego from him. TY i learned a lot.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    Ай бұрын

    @@robertkezer3665 Thanks for taking the time to learn. Positive Reinforcement creates a need for balanced trainers. They are all part and parcel of the same system of lies. Dog training is nothing more than Schutzhund in disguise. Why else would a Schutzhund trainer like Cabral be doing this?

  • @tracyreifkind3810
    @tracyreifkind38108 ай бұрын

    How do you "ask" a dog? I'm surprised the dog is taking treats at all since she looks stressed out.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    When an animal finds peace in your presence, they will come to trust you. You are no different. You will be attracted to calm and confident people. Cabral isn't calm - he's excited. He is a negative reinforcement to her - but he's luring her with food instead of being calm and quiet and letting the dog decide how things go.

  • @tracyreifkind3810

    @tracyreifkind3810

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining Yeah, I can see how excited Robert is, typical strategy when training a dog with NO issues, but she is still taking treats, why do you think that is? Neither of my dogs will take a treat if they are stressed in any way. Another question is, considering this dog has been a the shelter for 9 months, how would you help her to get adopted? I also want to add that I'm pretty sure prong collars are not allowed to be used in shelters, at least in CA where this is. (since you were wondering in the beginning of the video)

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@tracyreifkind3810 I worked with a dog named Mini a couple of years ago. It was about building trust in the back yard - then out for a long long walk. Get her out of her comfort zone - and a shelter would be a negative comfort zone. I am always amazed at what can be walked out of a dog. It's the best way to build a relationship. Right from the get go, everything is the dogs choice. If a dog doesn't trust you, they have zero reason to follow. I've tried working for shelters- and if you're not treat based - they don't want your help.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@tracyreifkind3810 She's conditioned to take treats no matter what. Likely what the other owners were doing - or the shelter staff. They believe that reward fixes everything, in reality - treats fix nothing. They screw up the relationship.

  • @tracyreifkind3810

    @tracyreifkind3810

    8 ай бұрын

    @@roberthynesdogtraining Watching and commenting on your vid of Beckman....way worse than this one. I appreciate your videos :)

  • @samkhadre2959
    @samkhadre29598 ай бұрын

    You sounds like Jim Jordan, a lotsa of noise with no results, Robert Cabral might have said a couple of things in this video that doesn't make sense , but he gave some correct information, so my advice to you is show us how it's get done, otherwise stop wasting your time to get a few hundred views

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    You are on my youtube channel. Lots of videos.

  • @RobertCabralDogs

    @RobertCabralDogs

    8 ай бұрын

    He can’t.

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@RobertCabralDogs Are you saying that I can't back it up? Oh Robert, you have no idea who you're dealing with cause I can back up everything I say. Now, go make a video in response just like you did to Zak.

  • @HandraCorjnaLevstean

    @HandraCorjnaLevstean

    8 ай бұрын

    Can i see how would you do it? I want to see how would you fix this,

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    8 ай бұрын

    @@HandraCorjnaLevstean I'll go you one better. Here's a case study on Bear with full video. Bear was a PTSD case, not one trainer would dare meet her and I believe the owner called 7 balanced trainers? I can get the owner on here if you want proof. Lots of case studies on the site with video and explanation. roberthynesdogtraining.com/2022/07/22/little-bear-how-fast-can-a-dog-change/

  • @Dragon.gsd.kuwait
    @Dragon.gsd.kuwaitАй бұрын

    what about @hamiltondogtraining is he good

  • @roberthynesdogtraining

    @roberthynesdogtraining

    Ай бұрын

    That's a big no.