Trevor Strnad will be forever missed. He was such a humble frontman, not to mention a very talented vocalist. Here would be my rating of each Black Dahlia Murder album. Unhallowed: 3.5/5 Miasma: 4.5/5 Nocturnal: 5/5 Deflorate: 4/5 Ritual: 5/5 Everblack: 4/5 Abysmal: 4/5 Nightbringers: 4.5/5 Verminous: 4.5/5

Trevor’s death hit me in a way I hadn’t felt for a very long time. It tool me three full days to realize I was in fact having a minor breakdown because of it. Ritual was my introduction to death metal, and it’ll forever be one of my personal favorite albums. I hope Trevor is at peace now.

Trevor's death hit home really hard. I've only been in that mental state like twice in my life but once is all you need to understand what those people are feeling. He seemed like such a cool and happy individual. RIP Trevor

I'm glad to see someone give Abysmal the respect it deserves, I love that album.

Rip Trevor

A shrine to madness is the best Halloween song ever……. Nothing even comes close.

Deflorate is top tier for me. I think it must be Trevor's lyrics. That which erodes the most tender of things is haunting. There are others but it's right there under ritual for me. You're one of the only metal youtubers who's actually enthusiastic about it. Nice.

RITUAL GANG

It's important to know especially from an evolutionary stand point, they started as a metalcore band. Yes, Trevor did have some cleans in his arsenal.

23:13 the leather's butcher apron🤣🤣 verminous is my fav black dahlia album! Perfect review man keep it up

Anyone else having trouble listening to Black Dahlia Murder after Trevor's passing? The days that followed his passing i listend to non stop. But now i can barely listen to a song without getting supper bummed and turning it off. I’m hoping i snap out of it and can enjoy the music again.

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

It felt weird for me at first, but not so much now. If anything, I crank it up extra loud for Trevor. But I know a lot of people who feel differently, and will for a while.

@spencer4359

2 жыл бұрын

Yea man. Im hoping i can rock out with it again. Im just so bummed. BDM is properly my fav metal band and certainly the most nostalgic. Unhallowed got me into extreme metal 20 years ago and i never looked back. That and the fact that he felt so down he took his own life just makes it all harder to listen to for me.

@artvandalay7632

2 жыл бұрын

Blood in the ink outro is very eerie now.

The only thing more shocking than his sudden death is that he chose to go by his own decision, that's the most eerie thing about it. A man that by all accounts was a happy, wholesome go-to guy gone in such a tragic, undeserving way. One can only wonder what type of issues he was struggling indoors. Mr. Strnad, although we never held any type of conversation (something that i deeply regret reading all of your comments), i will forever thank you for your music and all the memories that it carried. Whenever you are, i hope you rest easy and found inner peace. Anyways, my ranking: 9) Miasma 8) Abyss 7) Deflorate 6) Unhallowed 5) Verminous 4) Everblack 3) Nightbringers 2) Nocturnal 1) Ritual Wishing the best to Rob and the rest of you.

Everyone I knew RAVED about Nightbringers. I don’t know anyone who doesn’t love it tbh. Also Unhallowed slaps and it’s still Trevor’s fav 🤘🏻

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

Huh, maybe it was just the people around me at the time not digging it. Ah well.

@thelastdaybreathinginetern1385

2 жыл бұрын

Nightbringers and Ritual are their best imo!

@joshjohnson1699

4 ай бұрын

The badass galloping riff and drumming of Elder Misanthropy on Unhallowed instantly hooked me on TBDM. Such a great band still. Long live The Black Dahlia Murder, RIP Trevor.

@cringle7413

Ай бұрын

Closed Casket Requiem is also a banger

Carbonized in Cruciform is the most evil sounding track I’ve heard from them. Like, it’s the auditory manifestation of someone running from a serial killer. God damn, that riff…

@dcfromthev

2 жыл бұрын

Hell yes, underrated song!

@keithmjali761

Жыл бұрын

Yeah it is the most Evil song, they're legit sacrificing three priests to summon Satan and it sure feels like it too, every step of it. \m/

@keithmjali761

Жыл бұрын

Yeah it is the most Evil song, they're legit sacrificing three priests to summon Satan and it sure feels like it too, every step of it. \m/ Generally Ritual is a glorious fucking album. \m/

My band Darker By Design wouldn't exist had it not been for TBDM. We even did a studio cover of Deathmask Divine a few years back. It's on YT if you're interested. We may or may not be working on a tribute for Trevor right now... Unhallowed: 3.5/5 Miasma: 3.5/5 Nocturnal: 6/5 Deflorate: 4/5 Ritual: 6/5 Everblack: 3.5/5 Abysmal: 5/5 Nightbringers: 4/5 Verminous: 4/5

I didn’t really listen to TBDM until quarantine ,specifically nocturnal helped a lot dealing with the crazy times of early Covid lockdowns played it so much, TBDM was also the first concert I went to since Covid and the first metal show I took my little brother to. Still unreal he’s gone

I've been listening to TBDM a lot since Trevor passed. It makes me sad seeing how often he referenced suicide, he was suffering. 😔

Honestly the first time I heard black dahlia before I really knew much about them, I kinda thought they had 2 vocalists, purely by how distinct both of his different vocal styles are from each other and how easily Trevor used to merge those vocal styles together, when I looked into it and saw it was just him I was so blown away by how talented a vocalist he is

Thank you so much for making this video, TBDM is my favorite melo death band and I think they're the most underrated band ever. Here are my top 5 tracks: 1. Dawn of Rats 2. Matriarch 3. How Very Dead 4. Moonlight Equilibrium 5. What a horrible night to have a curse

Rip Trevor, mental health and suicide is a serious thing. Trevor was such a genuine guy and he truly loved and breathed Metal. The amount of support and love he had for underground bands. It’s devastating for sure. PLEASE go get some help if you have some Suicidal/Harmful thoughts everyone. you can do it, I believe in you, I care about you and it can get better. Ok now so The Black Dahlia Murder: S: Deflorate, Nightbringers A: Nocturnal, Everblack B: Miasma, Abysmal C: Verminous, Ritual D: Unhallowed

R.I.P Trev, such a massive source of inspiration over the years and definitely set a new standard for what to expect from lyrics in extreme metal. Stoked to see Abysmal get some love! It tends to get written off a lot by TBDM fans, but honestly it's the one I replay the most and is only a notch below albums like Nocturnal and Ritual for me.

You know there a very good band because they get better with every Album. Good work guys.

I see I wasnt the only one who went through their whole catalogue after Trevor died

Nope, I work for a company that doesn't give us Memorial Day off.

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

boooooooooo... but I feel that. I rarely get Holidays off myself. Try and have yourself a good day regardless bud.

@noogie3784

2 жыл бұрын

@@themetalmeltdownofficial 🤘

I remember I was not really into them for a long time. I remember really enjoying Nocturnal and that was the main album that I listened to. I heard Miasma and Unhallowed back in the day but at the time it was not my thing. One day I wanted to listen to their discography and dug the everlasting shit out of it. I was like "why was I so critical about them?" then I remembered my taste in music is varied and makes no sense. He passed and I was like "holy crap that sucks and definitely lost an icon". Reading articles and videos about him definitely seems like he was the coolest guy to talk to. I felt like we could trade conversations over obscure metal bands for a long while. This band does not have a bad album which is rare for bands. I do wonder if they will continue with a new vocalist like Suicide Silence did or are they going to do a benefit like Suicide Silence after Mitch's death. My list (my opinion) Unhallowed: 3.5/5 - For being their first album and the prodution is weak, it still fucking slaps. Miasma: 3.5/5 - My issue is the production and material is weak compared to what we will eventually get. I know this is Trevor's least favorite album from their work. Pretty neat article on his album rankings of BDM. Nocturnal: 5/5 - Bar none their best album. Even when I was not big into them, I loved this one. Deflorate: 3.5/5 Ritual: 5/5 - To me, Nocturnal 2.0. It's tied with Nocturnal but I think Nocturnal hits better. Still it fucking slays. Everblack: 4/5 Abysmal: 4/5 Nightbringers: 4/5 Verminous: 3.75/5 - I felt like this album has alot of fat to be trimmed. Great album but they could have added more to beef it up. Awesome list! RIP Trevor.

For Unhallowed, you really had to be there when it came out. For many metalcore Drop C kids like myself, it got us into death metal. You could tell the band was unsure of its sound and it almost doesn’t fit with the rest of their discography.

@destroyerofsenses

2 жыл бұрын

Right there with you. Seen them on ozzfest 05 which was a metalcore mecca at the time. Found these and suffocation soon after

You and I have basically the same ranking of TBDM’s albums. Their later stuff is much much better than their old stuff

Thanx 4 honoring trevor by doing this rankin rip to a real mensch....and unhallowed,.. u might only be 2.5 out of 5 in rob's eyes...but you'll always be a 4 out of 5 too me 💘

Put this on my Watch Later list. Awesome that you are doing this, Robert! Trevor would be proud of ya'. I'd bet he's watching this from up above/Heaven/Valhalla, too... preferably with a beer at his side, smiling away. RIP, Papa Trev!

idk if its nostalgia glasses but I feel like Miasma is GOATed.... when that album came out we were fucking blown away.

It's still weird to think that Trevor is dead. I didnt really get into Dahlia until Nightbringers dropped (liked a couple songs, but never dove into a full album) and just with Widowmaker I got hooked. Always bouncing back and forth on what the better intro track is between Widowmaker and In Hell Is Where She Waits For Me. For me Everblack and Nightbringers are the records I gravitate to. I felt underwhelmed by Verminous, I felt like the singles had this feeling of tiredness or a lack of energy I had expected. But I should probably give it another listen. The one time I had a chance to see Dahlia i ended up leaving the show early because i wasnt feeling very well. Think it was the Miasma anniversary tour, they were playing with Disentomb.

I'm working today so you got that wrong.. glad you uploaded this.. R.I.P. to Trevor Strnad.... He was fvcking awesome vocally. Ritual and Nightbringers are my favorite albums by TBDM. I've been listening to them since 2010. TBDM was one of the gateway bands for me to. Great video. I suffer from a lot of mental health situations, when Trevor Strnad passed I had a fever and a headache for 3 days afterwards.

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

Im sorry to hear that bud. Feeling any better lately?

@thelastdaybreathinginetern1385

2 жыл бұрын

@@themetalmeltdownofficial No, I have extreme depression and using metal music as my only outlet because people dislike me.. just being Honest, Thank you anyways..

I high fived the man when I saw him on the nocturnal tour doing his mic check. He will be missed. TBDM influenced my taste more than most other bands I’d say. Nocturnal, Nightbringer and Ritual are my favourites.

Glad you got to this, but I’m still waiting for every avenged seven fold album reviewed lol.

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

lmao maybe someday, it'd certainly be interesting

@derekbastien2181

2 жыл бұрын

@@themetalmeltdownofficial absolutely you should deffently do that

Idk man I think nocturnal is head and shoulder above everything they’ve done besides nightbringers. I agree that you could slap a 3.5 or 4/5 on pretty much anything else they've done.

Damn, what a downer. I listened to Nocturnal a few weeks ago and remembered laughing at an interview with Trevor where he reminisced about his first time seeing Cannibal Corpse album covers. He seemed like a genuinely cool guy. RIP

He had a great voice, and I've seen some of the you-tube vids he did just goofing around, seemed like a good guy. As we all know, good people in this world suffer and die while rich, vile, evil men live forever in luxury.

Everything is fair in the ratings on your video. Nocturnal would be 5/5 for me but that's the only one I would argue

Every album is great so it’s hard to judge.

I consider Abysmal and Deflorate to easily be their worst. I guess I like their earlier records much more than you do (Nocturnal #1, Debut in top 3) and their more MDM side.

Im gonna try to keep this as short as i can, because its a topic that im just not comfortable talking about. To be extremely serious for a moment, what happened to Trevor was truly tragic, Mental Health and Suicide isn't a joke for me, and its something that has deeply affected me throughout my life, especially because i had peoples close to me either trying or fully commiting to taking their life, and i did try to take my own life on more than one ocasion when i was a teenager too, and even as early as this year in January. But if there's one thing that always helped me, its music, because i had no one to count on, my only source of happiness for the longest time was music, be it any kind, Metal, Pop, Rap, Hip-Hop, Latin, Jazz, anything, and while i wasn't really familliar with The Black Dahlia Murder, Losing a person like Trevor to Suicide is just, sad, imagining the pain of what his bandmates, his family, friends, fans are going through now...there's simply no words to describe the pain and sadness they feel, and Robert, hearing you say its gonna get better and on your words "hang in there, you got this" is something everyone needs to hear every once in a while, even if its from a complete stranger on the internet, because at the end of the day, we as humans really should look out for each other. So thank you Robert, Thank you for your words. And for Trevor, Rest in Peace, hopefully you're much happier now, and rocking heaven's gate as we speak.

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

You're very welcome friend, cheers.

Is that a carcass shirt

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

correct o mundo good sir

Hello can you review every nine inch nails album? ty

It’s a little disingenuous to rate Unhallowed the way you did. I completely understand feeling that it’s not that great of an album compared to what the band would go on to do later. Maybe you’re too young but at the time unhallowed came out it was absolutely game changing. I’m not saying it was a perfect album, but you can’t really judge the album without taking in to consideration the relevance it had at the time.

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 ай бұрын

It isn't disingenuous because this is genuinely how I feel, and yes I absolutely can judge the album without taking into consideration whatever relevance it had because thats how an unbiased review works. Or at least, thats how its supposed to work.

Nightbringers is faaar better than Abysmal and Everblack, bud.

Unhallowed my favorite. unsubbed.

@themetalmeltdownofficial

2 жыл бұрын

Ok, bye then.

@MetalTrenches

2 жыл бұрын

I mean it's one of my favorites too, but if you are unsubbing because someone likes and album you do, but not AS MUCH as you do, I don't know how you navigate things that actually matter.

Dude....everblack over nocturnal. GTFO

@themetalmeltdownofficial

8 ай бұрын

Nahh

@WHOREHAMMER_OFFICIAL

Ай бұрын

​@@themetalmeltdownofficial phantom limb masturbation just goes to hard man lol. Too many awesome tracks. And the opening track and scream is iconic