Rethinking the mystery of gravity

What would you think if someone said gravity might not exist as a fundamental force? Prof. Janna Levin explored that mind-bending topic on a recent podcast and breaks down what that means to NBC's Gadi Schwartz.
» Subscribe to NBC News: / nbcnews
NBC News Digital is a collection of innovative and powerful news brands that deliver compelling, diverse and engaging news stories. NBC News Digital features NBCNews.com, MSNBC.com, TODAY.com, Nightly News, Meet the Press, Dateline, and the existing apps and digital extensions of these respective properties. We deliver the best in breaking news, live video coverage, original journalism and segments from your favorite NBC News Shows.
Connect with NBC News Online!
Breaking News Alerts: link.nbcnews.com/join/5cj/bre...
Visit NBCNews.Com: www.nbcnews.com/
Find NBC News on Facebook: / nbcnews
Follow NBC News on Twitter: / nbcnews
Get more of NBC News delivered to your inbox: nbcnews.com/newsletters
#Gravity #Science #Mystery

Пікірлер: 702

  • @td3521
    @td352120 күн бұрын

    Right after the Terrence Howard interview on JRE 😂😂😂😂

  • @TheWaveFactor

    @TheWaveFactor

    19 күн бұрын

    Exactly!

  • @DanLyndon

    @DanLyndon

    18 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard can't even use the word gravity in a sentence coherently. This is a different thing.

  • @LOAMMX

    @LOAMMX

    18 күн бұрын

    came here to say this same thing

  • @corysgood881

    @corysgood881

    18 күн бұрын

    @@DanLyndon Actually this is exactly what Terrence Howard said...

  • @HMNBLDGLABZ

    @HMNBLDGLABZ

    18 күн бұрын

    Bro that’s what I’m saying !!!

  • @HakunaMatata-os1og
    @HakunaMatata-os1og23 күн бұрын

    It makes perfect sense; just folks get confused on the meaning of "fundamental" within this context. "Not fundamental" doesn't mean "not real", it means "emergently real". In the same way as a bird isn't a flock of birds, and a cell isn't a human; but if you put enough of them together in the right way, you get this new thing which while not fundamental to its individual parts, is emergently real to its collective parts.

  • @robertdeland3390

    @robertdeland3390

    20 күн бұрын

    Perfect explanation.

  • @donaldcarpenter5328

    @donaldcarpenter5328

    20 күн бұрын

    She SAID gravity is NOT "REAL", quit LYING for her!

  • @donaldpump8882

    @donaldpump8882

    20 күн бұрын

    It is a Holistic Interpretation, meaning it isn't OBJECTIVELY REAL. like a human isn't objectively real, but rather a human is ab massive collection of electrons swirling around quarks, which are the objectively real particles

  • @mad-meh2719

    @mad-meh2719

    20 күн бұрын

    Yes but the concept of the flock is not real. It's an abstract idea to label and identify.

  • @wesley6442

    @wesley6442

    19 күн бұрын

    You're exactly right brother, you need a large mass to bend and warp the spacetime manifold to create this pit or well of attraction for objects to fall into, which is what we call gravity.. it is "emergent" as you say, without significant mass you don't have much gravitational force, it's so weak because it requires so much mass to really have any effect compared to the other forces.. it's kind of a pseudo force, just a result of the warping of spacetime

  • @FlatThumb
    @FlatThumb23 күн бұрын

    debating gravity always has its ups and downs

  • @livethemoment5148

    @livethemoment5148

    23 күн бұрын

    Are you saying its a very heavy topic with lots of gravitas?

  • @sergiodidthis

    @sergiodidthis

    22 күн бұрын

    I’m sorry. This falls short.

  • @JustinatorxX

    @JustinatorxX

    22 күн бұрын

    It definitely is a weighty topic that keeps pulling us back into the conversation

  • @iamhawkeye3162

    @iamhawkeye3162

    22 күн бұрын

    It’s kept me at rock bottom lately

  • @orlandoarellano7390

    @orlandoarellano7390

    21 күн бұрын

    Its a heavy topic innit ?

  • @Vv20vV
    @Vv20vV19 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard: “I’ve been trying to tell y’all mayne”!

  • @DanLyndon

    @DanLyndon

    18 күн бұрын

    No he hasn't. His ideas are completely unrelated to any actual science. This may sound vaguely similar to something he said, but it's not at all the same when it comes to the details. It also isn't a new idea, it's been a feature of different areas of theoretical physics for decades to consider gravity to be emergent. Terrence Howard, on the other hand, is part of the electric universe cult, which is just the most incoherently stupid bunch of nonsense ever.

  • @rashadd2615

    @rashadd2615

    18 күн бұрын

    It’s a reason they have actual scientist on the show and not Mr Howard

  • @lorenwest6305

    @lorenwest6305

    17 күн бұрын

    😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @Trailerwalker

    @Trailerwalker

    17 күн бұрын

    Gravity clearly exists. Go jump off a cliff and tell us what you feel

  • @Kinesiology411

    @Kinesiology411

    16 күн бұрын

    ​@@rashadd2615because you have to be white and have initials after your name to say the same thing and be respected for it? Is that the distinction here??

  • @MGeezydaWarrior
    @MGeezydaWarrior24 күн бұрын

    Ever since Terrance Howard went on Joe Rogan

  • @sireel

    @sireel

    23 күн бұрын

    He was quoting Walter Russel a lot from Secret of Light, but some of what TH says is incorrect.

  • @MiguellolTV

    @MiguellolTV

    23 күн бұрын

    @@sireel i think time will tell. you cannot discredit his patent and use of his own discovery as a foundation for his works. he is actually one of the few in a while to actually apply what he is talking about to the real world, like tesla, davinci, and other science thinkers. while the rest of the science world people, just theorizes and is afraid to step away from the norm. i would say in a world where no one knew nothing and you had to choose between the sciences, terrences makes more sense, when applied to the natural world

  • @sireel

    @sireel

    23 күн бұрын

    @@MiguellolTV I agree with the Walter Russell stuff, Tesla thought he was right, too. By "kook" I meant all the restraining orders and claims of having degrees from schools TH didn't go to, etc., - On Wikipedia.

  • @juzoli

    @juzoli

    23 күн бұрын

    Being on Joe Rogan is an immediate red flag… Like Michio Kaku went there exactly when people really started to question if he speaks really science, or just BS clickbait to propagate his own fame.

  • @gargoyle2585

    @gargoyle2585

    23 күн бұрын

    @@MiguellolTV Time?? The time is up.... i guess it must just be new to you. kzread.info/dash/bejne/i5l1s9lyia2tpLA.htmlsi=-S67EnxoQ0rvdJ9x

  • @Hesthegreatest1
    @Hesthegreatest121 күн бұрын

    Ive learned the only thing Neil Degrass Tyson is an expert in is : interrupting people while they talk.

  • @joehiatt1992

    @joehiatt1992

    18 күн бұрын

    That guy just likes to hear himself talk

  • @michaelpoison6732

    @michaelpoison6732

    17 күн бұрын

    Yes

  • @lorenwest6305

    @lorenwest6305

    17 күн бұрын

    I been saying this for years😂

  • @sinnermeister

    @sinnermeister

    17 күн бұрын

    ADHD bruv

  • @mour1s91

    @mour1s91

    15 күн бұрын

    You just couldn’t find any other reason to hate on him huh😂

  • @nickc9070
    @nickc907023 күн бұрын

    Glad to see science being shared on MSNBC 👍

  • @richardleirer

    @richardleirer

    23 күн бұрын

    If only they would do the same with the clot shot.

  • @Am-ih5nf

    @Am-ih5nf

    22 күн бұрын

    Except they keep using the term “black hole” which is racist

  • @anthonygordon9483

    @anthonygordon9483

    22 күн бұрын

    That is just Neil Degrasse doing his magic. Neil is a star, now he is putting his fellow physicist in the light. We like Neil but we know if Neils mind is blown that means something. I watch star talk all the time, this interview was probably one of the first in a long time where Neil's mind was blown and couldnt even explain it.

  • @jnah8733

    @jnah8733

    20 күн бұрын

    That is because you will not catch my Dad watching JRE. But he will be on the news channel. What a shame!

  • @8ightfaces
    @8ightfaces20 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard got the masses talking.😂

  • @250hero

    @250hero

    18 күн бұрын

    This is different. It is that one particle or one molecule by itself is not recognizable as a lake or a ocean. But when you take vastly more molecules it is water. She is saying gravity works for macro but breaks down as we dont have a generally accepted idea for individual particles. Let alone sub atomic particles.

  • @250hero

    @250hero

    18 күн бұрын

    A general idea of quantum gravity.

  • @daverumpel

    @daverumpel

    18 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard is a delusional narcissist. He spews BS from head to toe

  • @rashadd2615

    @rashadd2615

    18 күн бұрын

    Startalk is a show that has been going on since 2015, these guys don’t care what Howard is thinking. Lol

  • @kotonizna

    @kotonizna

    17 күн бұрын

    oh please

  • @kevcurry
    @kevcurry22 күн бұрын

    sounds like Terrance Howard called it. Interesting timing of this interview

  • @joehiatt1992

    @joehiatt1992

    18 күн бұрын

    Billy Carson is another pioneer thatll hopefully rewrite current fake history & beliefs

  • @rashadd2615

    @rashadd2615

    18 күн бұрын

    Explain further how this idea connects with anything Howard said.

  • @greyfenix7123

    @greyfenix7123

    17 күн бұрын

    ​@@rashadd2615he tried to explain that gravity isn't a cause it's an effect. Much like they just explained here.

  • @rashadd2615

    @rashadd2615

    17 күн бұрын

    @@greyfenix7123 He made a similar claim but don’t think their 2 explanations were anywhere close to one another

  • @jamespatterson6972

    @jamespatterson6972

    15 күн бұрын

    _Howard is a plagiarist._ *He mimic's what he hears on the internet & tries to integrate it with his nonsensical false narrative.*

  • @guguineo
    @guguineo23 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard just said that. . .

  • @skippayless4357

    @skippayless4357

    21 күн бұрын

    Exactly, he said gravity isn’t a force or a cause, it’s an effect.. Now Neil degrasse and his colleagues immediately start saying “Oh by the way, gravity isn’t a force”

  • @DANGJOS

    @DANGJOS

    20 күн бұрын

    What do you mean now? Do you think they just thought of this recently?

  • @BenDover-vp9ik

    @BenDover-vp9ik

    19 күн бұрын

    they're about to admit the world is flat lol

  • @ronthorn3

    @ronthorn3

    18 күн бұрын

    Stop that dude is a hack.

  • @daverumpel

    @daverumpel

    18 күн бұрын

    Do you really think Terrence Howard originated this idea? Jeez

  • @OracleTreehouse
    @OracleTreehouse17 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard was speaking about this on Joe Rogan’s podcast. Terrence Howard said gravity is a byproduct. Yall should watch the podcast. For some again.

  • @WillisAmak

    @WillisAmak

    17 күн бұрын

    i had to get back to th periodic table to fully understand his take on some things and he is very intelligent

  • @1TakoyakiStore
    @1TakoyakiStore23 күн бұрын

    My favorite idea about gravity is that it's an effect of entropy. PBS Spacetime did a great video about it.

  • @360.Tapestry

    @360.Tapestry

    23 күн бұрын

    i still find that channel way too technical

  • @randyt700

    @randyt700

    20 күн бұрын

    You wouldn't happen to have a link to that video would you?

  • @1TakoyakiStore

    @1TakoyakiStore

    20 күн бұрын

    @@randyt700 kzread.info/dash/bejne/o42HraeblJybZrA.htmlsi=ciphU8guzXO33H6S

  • @ianlassitter2397
    @ianlassitter239719 күн бұрын

    Conversations about gravity always pull me in.

  • @moe47988

    @moe47988

    19 күн бұрын

    it’s a heavy topic

  • @theDarkMatterMyth

    @theDarkMatterMyth

    18 күн бұрын

    🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @billkeisling2907
    @billkeisling290724 күн бұрын

    There is, however, a Santa Claus.

  • @anemonaloco

    @anemonaloco

    23 күн бұрын

    nah, he quit due to the inflation and low home affordability.

  • @moonshoes11

    @moonshoes11

    23 күн бұрын

    Jesus Claus.

  • @StuckTrippin

    @StuckTrippin

    23 күн бұрын

    Elves were getting expensive, so he outsourced to little asian children.

  • @MagnumCarta

    @MagnumCarta

    23 күн бұрын

    @@moonshoes11 He enjoys children leaving out bread, fish, and a bottle of wine

  • @kyledodge5513
    @kyledodge551322 күн бұрын

    If you listen carefully, you can hear my head exploding

  • @hera7884
    @hera788424 күн бұрын

    The universe is so confusing

  • @nicholashylton6857

    @nicholashylton6857

    23 күн бұрын

    It keeps humans busy, to say the least.

  • @michaelk3550

    @michaelk3550

    20 күн бұрын

    I fully believe we are living in a black hole, and the Big Bang was the matter in another larger universe collapsing into our universe(black hole) where the laws of physics act differently. I also believe the same thing about the black holes in our universe contain universes of their own. Maybe matter in the bigger universe that created ours was different and protons were the size of suns.

  • @eyeofsaurona2345
    @eyeofsaurona234520 күн бұрын

    Terrance Howard - there is no such thing as gravity, its just electricity and magnetism. We literally are on an enormous magnet with a huge magnetic field

  • @DANGJOS

    @DANGJOS

    20 күн бұрын

    That is completely different from what she's saying. Magnetism doesn't explain gravity.

  • @ianlassitter2397

    @ianlassitter2397

    19 күн бұрын

    And T.H. Is utterly wrong but nice try trying to glue two totally different theories together and tie him to an actual scientist.

  • @iFREDDYx22

    @iFREDDYx22

    19 күн бұрын

    ⁠​⁠@@ianlassitter2397Your opinion on TH doesn’t matter since you have no credibility to gauge if he is right or wrong Ian.

  • @ChiquitaSpeaks

    @ChiquitaSpeaks

    18 күн бұрын

    @@DANGJOS yes I don’t remember everything exactly but it’s more so him talking about the phenomena similar to that of pressure conditions within a limited space with two forces fighting against each other (magnetism and electricity) making it act as gravity and the shapes within that struggle of the space are inherent to the structure of what has been referred to as the flower of life. That structure only exist when relating to certain levels of matter hence why a large earth generates more of it

  • @DANGJOS

    @DANGJOS

    18 күн бұрын

    @@ChiquitaSpeaks But that doesn't really make much sense. Electricity and magnetism don't really fight each other, and that explanation seems vague. Putting words together can sound cool, but where are his equations? Where is the logical flow that leads us to believe that what he's saying should even apply to gravity. It's nowhere near enough.

  • @ChristopherGruber
    @ChristopherGruber23 күн бұрын

    Why do interviewers have to act like physics is beyond human comprehension and also ask meaningful follow up questions like "Is there experimental evidence yet to support your claim or when will there be?"

  • @michaeltrower741

    @michaeltrower741

    21 күн бұрын

    They're clueless, and it shows.

  • @donaldcarpenter5328

    @donaldcarpenter5328

    20 күн бұрын

    nope, it is all conjecture that gravity doesn't exist on a MICRO level.

  • @boobishop9739

    @boobishop9739

    20 күн бұрын

    Albert Einstein explained everything he said so a child could understand it. Now the scientific community talks down to average people.That's how they are able to keep their jobs

  • @NickRichards

    @NickRichards

    19 күн бұрын

    It is a way to teach. There are many ways, and this one involves implicit praise to the viewer, that they might learn something obtuse, which is not widely known.

  • @ChrisinOSMS
    @ChrisinOSMS23 күн бұрын

    This isn’t a new idea, I was taught that the laws of gravity break down at the quantum-level while taking physics in college back in the 90’s. This physicist just explains it in a slightly less broad of a term.

  • @ScentlessSun

    @ScentlessSun

    23 күн бұрын

    Saying the laws break down is the same thing as saying that the equations of General Relativity spit out zero as an answer, which is nonsense. She’s essentially saying the math was never intended to be taken so far in the first place. The problem is we still don’t have any mathematical insights into the inner-workings of a black hole without a theory of quantum gravity.

  • @cletusjones9411

    @cletusjones9411

    23 күн бұрын

    Yeah, I’m confused on why this is presented as some radical new idea.

  • @DagNeb_It

    @DagNeb_It

    23 күн бұрын

    I been making this argument for years! The validation that I might not be crazy.

  • @Unknowngfyjoh

    @Unknowngfyjoh

    23 күн бұрын

    Unless I missed something... did she ever attempt to explain how it grew from the collection of the small interactions?

  • @babybirdhome

    @babybirdhome

    22 күн бұрын

    ⁠@@UnknowngfyjohThey kind of did with the water analogy - a single atom of water doesn’t behave like “water” as we know it - as a fluid that flows or has surface tension, etc. Water molecules don’t become “water” until there’s lots of them together. Only then do they become what we know as water and start to behave as we know water to behave. Another way to think of it is something like cars are made out of metal, but metal isn’t a car. It’s not until you have the right amounts of the right kinds of metal (and plastic and rubber and glass etc.) put together in the right way that it becomes a car. Or if you’ve ever seen one of those videos of a murmuration of starlings - that doesn’t happen with one single starling. It only happens when you have lots of starlings flying together. Therefore, starling murmurations are not a “fundamental force” of starlings because on the smaller scale of one starling, they don’t exist and can’t exist.

  • @mogdor
    @mogdor20 күн бұрын

    "rethinking the mystery of gravity"... shows the same illustration everyone always uses when they explain gravity lol

  • @devildoll9929
    @devildoll992923 күн бұрын

    The only thing I know about gravity is that it's a real b*tch after you've had more than three margaritas.

  • @askani21

    @askani21

    23 күн бұрын

    Clearly alcohol is a gravitational amplifier. Lack of sleep too 😂

  • @LukeKazmierski
    @LukeKazmierski23 күн бұрын

    Can you remove an object from quantum entanglement and if so, what would happen to the object? How would it interact with everything else?

  • @starventure

    @starventure

    23 күн бұрын

    Are you driving towards gravity modification?

  • @michaeltrower741
    @michaeltrower74121 күн бұрын

    Janna Levin is awesome. So articulate.

  • @mixey01
    @mixey0112 күн бұрын

    She sounds like the kind of professor who might come up with a theory of everything. Merging quantum physics and classical physics together I'm starting to wonder of all laws of nature only exist on a macroscopic scale

  • @michaelccopelandsr7120
    @michaelccopelandsr712024 күн бұрын

    🎶"We've only just begun..."🎶

  • @lokipokey
    @lokipokey20 күн бұрын

    This is so beautifully and understandably explained in these two clips, although mostly by analogy. I would love to know more about what kind of experiments or observations are behind this hypothesis. How do they know or hypothesize this? But I probably wouldn't understand it anyway even if they told me 😅

  • @Xonatron
    @Xonatron23 күн бұрын

    The confusion to most is the idea of emergence in the first place. Most things we experience are manifestations of many, simple things happening. Also confusion to most is the idea of process itself - related - as we once believed life was a thing not a process.

  • @pushlocal5040
    @pushlocal504018 күн бұрын

    Terrance Howard has started a tidal wave

  • @Djentc0re
    @Djentc0re22 күн бұрын

    I had this idea more than one time, but since I'm not a physicist it was just an idea. Am I the only one? It feels hard to believe to me that this is the first time anyone else had thought of gravity as an emerging force..

  • @ruxleec

    @ruxleec

    22 күн бұрын

    The overall goal is to be able to explain concretely, most likely with maths

  • @The_Quaalude

    @The_Quaalude

    22 күн бұрын

    No you're not the only one, just write a math proof and be famous

  • @napilopez

    @napilopez

    20 күн бұрын

    This is a decades old idea. It's nice more people are hearing about it, but there are a bunch of videos about emergent gravity on KZread alone

  • @boyzaya15

    @boyzaya15

    18 күн бұрын

    I swear physics really is so simple without mafmatics. It would be easier to figure out without the mafmatics in my opinion. Especially considering the math we use might be wrong

  • @eternalspacez
    @eternalspacez17 күн бұрын

    It’s crazy I was saying this a decade ago, thank you for greater minds trying to explain and rationalise for the masses.

  • @Slide61
    @Slide6122 күн бұрын

    Totally makes sense. Thank you.

  • @ValidatingUsername
    @ValidatingUsername23 күн бұрын

    Just a point of clarification for the record, the “planet” you see is reduced to a point like object in the math and the visualization only really allows for 2 dimensions of interpretation.

  • @JessyGreene
    @JessyGreene22 күн бұрын

    I love Janna Levin ✨

  • @stewartquark1661
    @stewartquark166123 күн бұрын

    I understand this, a basic approach to gravity, because just the other day 5 18 24 I refined my 'letter' concerning the origins of gravity

  • @alecbinaud2881
    @alecbinaud288110 күн бұрын

    If I look at my pillow at a quantum level there's also no pillow anymore

  • @jayrussell3796
    @jayrussell379624 күн бұрын

    Gravity worked pretty well on me a few times.

  • @DC-qn4wz

    @DC-qn4wz

    24 күн бұрын

    All the time!

  • @keysemerson3771

    @keysemerson3771

    23 күн бұрын

    She didn't say it doesn't exist. She said it is emergent as opposed to fundamental. It makes sense scientifically, in the mean time don't worry, you're not going to float away.

  • @wolf17238

    @wolf17238

    23 күн бұрын

    @jayrusell3796 Yeah, me too. Especially when I used to drink.

  • @DarkseedAlpha

    @DarkseedAlpha

    23 күн бұрын

    That’s because you are a macro-organism.

  • @RobertSaxy

    @RobertSaxy

    23 күн бұрын

    ⁠@@keysemerson3771I imagine that was a gravity joke not commentary on Janna’s points

  • @Jedindy
    @Jedindy23 күн бұрын

    The painting example is 💯

  • @lorenwest6305
    @lorenwest630517 күн бұрын

    So Terence Howard ISN’T crazy like people are trying to make him sound????

  • @nancychace8619
    @nancychace861923 күн бұрын

    Fascinating. Just learning about emergence theory. Is this an example of it? What about unification theory? How does that tie in, or does it? Interesting stuff 🙂 Thanks for sharing.

  • @solapowsj25
    @solapowsj2512 күн бұрын

    My friend once said,, "I've a gut feeling that image kinetics doesn't exist. "

  • @bugtusslealien3931
    @bugtusslealien393119 күн бұрын

    Georges Seurat would thank you for describing what gravity means using the collective of his "dots" which shows his painting as what it is. Very eloquent way of describing a theory of gravity. 🙂

  • @glennelliott708
    @glennelliott70823 күн бұрын

    There is definitely a gravitas to this argument

  • @innertubez
    @innertubez22 күн бұрын

    Pretty interesting analogy. Like saying one water molecule is not “wet.” I don’t know enough to say how accurate another physicist would say the analogy is, but I can wrap my head around it. But I suspect there are equations that can describe wetness in fluid dynamics or whatever the field is called. It’s just fascinating to speculate that what we call gravity has the same relationship between describing it in the aggregate versus describing it at the tiniest possible scales.

  • @bonefishboards
    @bonefishboards23 күн бұрын

    Time = Gravity = Time

  • @eyeofsaurona2345

    @eyeofsaurona2345

    20 күн бұрын

    Time doesn't exist - gravity = magnetism

  • @romeblue6198
    @romeblue619820 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard just said this…. 😑

  • @nestorpylos84

    @nestorpylos84

    17 күн бұрын

    Don’t let people gaslight you into saying he wasn’t saying this because I see some comments saying he’s still wrong

  • @Kinesiology411

    @Kinesiology411

    16 күн бұрын

    Seriously. Is it because he's not white or doesn't have the useless initials after his name that the same theories are treated with completely different reactions?

  • @ScentlessSun
    @ScentlessSun23 күн бұрын

    Einstein’s equations of General Relativity spit out zero as an answer at point of a singularity inside a black hole, which is nonsense. She’s essentially saying the math was never intended to be taken so far in the first place. The problem is we still don’t have any mathematical insights into the inner-workings of a black hole without a theory of quantum gravity. I get the logic of what she is saying but we need be able to describe a singularity mathematically. The same problem exists on that end of the spectrum even if we let General Relativity off the hook.

  • @Spectre-wd9dl

    @Spectre-wd9dl

    20 күн бұрын

    That's because the entire basis of cosmology I'd off. Gravity is an effect of electricity and magnetism. No need for dark matter, energy, higgs bosons and all the other BS they come up with. There's a reason why they can't figure it out. They're wrong.

  • @Spectre-wd9dl

    @Spectre-wd9dl

    20 күн бұрын

    A singularity doesn't exist. Infinity doesn't exist. You can keep squeezing something to basically nothing. Think about it. You can only squeeze something until you have every proton and electron so close together they can't move. Then what.

  • @DanLyndon

    @DanLyndon

    18 күн бұрын

    Singularities just occur when you apply the wrong type to a problem. They are a signal from reality telling you that you can't use this equation to describe this situation. You can't use fluid dynamics to describe a problem involving relativist phenomenon, such as the motions of a liquid at ultra high speed. That's what it means to say that 'the math breaks down.' The assumptions that the equations have built in no longer apply. General relativity is a great mathematical framework for a certain domain of problems, but can't be applied indiscriminately. The existence of singularities means we need a more sophisticated notion of what is going on.

  • @mel-nm6oh
    @mel-nm6oh13 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard called it..😂 gravity might not exist as a fundamental force..😮🤯

  • @michaelgermanovsky1793
    @michaelgermanovsky179314 күн бұрын

    Now how do you influence a proton to collude with other protons to create temperature?

  • @user-xn9eg8pq6e
    @user-xn9eg8pq6e23 күн бұрын

    The macro to micro concept lens?

  • @grapeape780
    @grapeape78022 күн бұрын

    I like the description of "matter" being "frozen" light. Light being tied to Electromagnetism might be another explanation. Chilling!!!

  • @napilopez

    @napilopez

    20 күн бұрын

    Light literally is electromagnetism!

  • @geebashiri3315
    @geebashiri331517 күн бұрын

    Why did I know this a long long time ago. I can’t be the only one.

  • @OnlyAFlame
    @OnlyAFlame15 күн бұрын

    if quantum is behaving at that level, fractal reality or quarks , either or, then it would be apparent to me that the mystery still be unsolved. Rather more fundamentally I would say its not only a consequence, like water, rather a principle that gravity is still a possibility that energy can come together to create gravity as a structured energy or wave rather than gravity as a consequence of the whole of reality. Is it a source or a consequence? I couldnt imagine for example gravity being a particle or a wave like neutrons or quarks, however at that level I have to ask absolutely absurd questions that are which not so absurd. If I am to create certain rules. I have special interest in wondering if gravity is a thing, or a wave rather than a consequence.

  • @vluxmea
    @vluxmea21 күн бұрын

    Generally spealing, the 10th house follows the 9th, therefore without "structure" there will be no ways to organise materials to manifest weight.

  • @sireel
    @sireel23 күн бұрын

    It’s an emergent property created by the incommensurability of the atoms. A magnetic field emerges from commensurate atoms.

  • @marishkagrayson
    @marishkagrayson23 күн бұрын

    So the universe is post-impressionistic! 😊Very beautiful. ❤

  • @Xerion1
    @Xerion117 күн бұрын

    I'm a biochemist. Terrance Howard wasn't saying anything that made any sense but people that don't understand the most rudimentary concepts in science think they have the wherewithal to give their 2 cents about how "brilliant" his perspective was. I'm going to give the science laymen a very easy example. You know your job very well, right? You understand how it functions in your field pretty well, though you may not know everything about it. Imagine a person comes in and starts talking crazy about it in ways you know are incorrect, however, because the local population doesn't understand much of anything about your job, they think this person is incredible even though you know this person is wrong about the procedures, nomenclature, functionality and explanation of your job. Now you've got to convince people that know nothing about your job that this person saying these crazy things are incorrect... 🥴

  • @SJR_Media_Group

    @SJR_Media_Group

    17 күн бұрын

    Spot on and explains the sad reality... most Americans are math, physics, and science illiterate...

  • @moonshoes11
    @moonshoes1123 күн бұрын

    Startalk is a great podcast. Neil and Chuck are always entertaining, but their guest on this episode was amazing. ✌️

  • @Nuno_Alves
    @Nuno_Alves12 күн бұрын

    Gravity is described as an acceleration, not a force... So how it could be fundamental?

  • @DurtyDiddy
    @DurtyDiddy19 күн бұрын

    Very small things act differently to much bigger things. Life just depends on your perspective

  • @istoa22
    @istoa2220 күн бұрын

    This is why there must be so much space in space, otherwise it would collapse

  • @JehovahsaysNetworth
    @JehovahsaysNetworth22 күн бұрын

    My answer is gravity is magnetic polarity

  • @percys9427
    @percys942723 күн бұрын

    Even my Dog understands Gravity ball goes up ball goes down

  • @keysemerson3771

    @keysemerson3771

    23 күн бұрын

    She didn't say it doesn't exist. She said it is emergent as opposed to fundamental. It makes sense scientifically, in the mean time don't worry, you're not going to float away.

  • @askani21

    @askani21

    23 күн бұрын

    Go ask your dog to calculate the inner curvature of a black hole if he understands gravity that well 😂

  • @MagnumCarta

    @MagnumCarta

    23 күн бұрын

    @@askani21 Dog say light is like tail and black hole is like mouth. No matter how much tail try to get away, it eventually gets eaten!

  • @Sakamoshi
    @Sakamoshi15 күн бұрын

    Thank you Terrence Howard

  • @thegreatmonster
    @thegreatmonster23 күн бұрын

    So, what, there's a force that is pushing or pulling on space itself, and that then causes some sort of pressure resulting in gravity?

  • @stewartquark1661
    @stewartquark166123 күн бұрын

    The 'mystery' of gravity is something most will find difficult to believe

  • @dushyantbhatt9345
    @dushyantbhatt934515 күн бұрын

    and what did Terence Howard trying to say us ,.... but they called him mad

  • @RobertSaxy
    @RobertSaxy23 күн бұрын

    Love seeing deep science and Jana Levin being showcased but at 3:43 why wouldn’t you show the dots

  • @josephbenham649
    @josephbenham64916 күн бұрын

    Lollll Terrance has clearly shaken up the scientific community

  • @therationalist234
    @therationalist23423 күн бұрын

    In short, the laws of physics change at the smallest scales. This isn't a revelation more of a potential framework for thinking

  • @Spectre-wd9dl

    @Spectre-wd9dl

    20 күн бұрын

    They don't when you understand that the universe is electric.

  • @thetacoguyy
    @thetacoguyy19 күн бұрын

    She's not saying gravity is not real. It's like saying nothing is cold, it's just the absence of warmth.

  • @eobias
    @eobias22 күн бұрын

    So all 4 fundamental forces are actually all emergent properties then?

  • @tamastarczy6262

    @tamastarczy6262

    19 күн бұрын

    Good point. Could very well be! I applaud to the idea!

  • @michaelpoison6732
    @michaelpoison673217 күн бұрын

    She said this a week before Terrance said what he said. Im not saying he saw her Interview but it is weird that he was speaking on no gravity as well.

  • @leonardomotta4613
    @leonardomotta461323 күн бұрын

    This a very old idea, set up by Ted Jacobson in 1995. His set up of gravity as emergent is a very well known research topic in physics.

  • @vibehighest
    @vibehighest19 күн бұрын

    yea Neil's underwear was spoiled after that comment from Janna

  • @JonathanGarcia-nr9yj
    @JonathanGarcia-nr9yj17 күн бұрын

    So if we can disrupt the field or process of it's interaction with itself then we can manipulate it at will and discover ftl travel

  • @georgespiese7388
    @georgespiese738823 күн бұрын

    There is some kind of network for communication going on that we can’t sense. Living cells do the same.

  • @The1JTA
    @The1JTA23 күн бұрын

    The 'rationalizations' make a lot of sense. Would this imply there is no photon "force carrier" for gravity? If so, why would gravity waves 'appear' to travel "at the speed of light"? Coincidence?

  • @matdrat
    @matdrat22 күн бұрын

    The leading edge idea that blows my mind is that quantum entanglements are the threads that make up the fabric of spacetime.

  • @jdotbeats3727
    @jdotbeats372714 күн бұрын

    Terrance Howard has said the same.

  • @craigmackay4909
    @craigmackay490914 күн бұрын

    “I killed gravity Mayne “

  • @dustinwarender8955
    @dustinwarender895517 күн бұрын

    I have literally always said that gravity isn't its own thing. It's a combination of gyroscopic procession and mass and the directions that we are spinning against the magnetic current, which is holding us down.

  • @dustinwarender8955

    @dustinwarender8955

    17 күн бұрын

    You have the magnetic current from the Sun holding us down on the Earth. You have the magnetic current from the Earth, holding us down in the Earth from the Solar System and from the Galaxy and so on. And this combination of electromagnetism and gyroscopic prosession, along with atmosphere, creates gravity. That's why when you go to venus it's not gravity that crushes you it's atmospheric pressure that crushes you

  • @Devon7839
    @Devon783923 күн бұрын

    Highly recommend anyone who's interested to go watch the quantum gravity episode and other quantum episodes from PBS Space Time

  • @denooo127
    @denooo12724 күн бұрын

    Terrence Howard really about to break the internet

  • @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot

    @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot

    23 күн бұрын

    No he not this is different from what he was saying.

  • @kitjones6896

    @kitjones6896

    23 күн бұрын

    1x1 is 1 x (one number of times). If mangos cost 1 dollar each and I buy 1 what is the total?

  • @acekiller48

    @acekiller48

    23 күн бұрын

    ​@@kitjones6896 Gravity

  • @sireel

    @sireel

    23 күн бұрын

    Besides the Walter Russell stuff he's quoting from Secret of Light, he's a kook. Look up his Wikipedia.

  • @Spectre-wd9dl

    @Spectre-wd9dl

    20 күн бұрын

    ​@@sireel using Wikipedia is like using CNN. Good lucking finding anything other than what you're being told.

  • @motivationalpoet
    @motivationalpoet17 күн бұрын

    That's the same concept Terrence Howard was explaining, yet people in the science community called him crazy.

  • @stewartquark1661
    @stewartquark166123 күн бұрын

    The quantum interactions manifest in what we call gravity Gravity might not exist as a fundamental force

  • @starventure

    @starventure

    23 күн бұрын

    But are those interactions based on entanglement or wave? If it is entanglement, then what is the mechanism of interaction that causes attraction? If it is wave, what sort of wave functions are created by fundamental particle mass and how do they attract through interaction?

  • @user-xh4bw2zc4g
    @user-xh4bw2zc4g17 күн бұрын

    Always said this...its like a bowl of minestrome soup. What people think gravity is on earth is just weight against external atmosphere. In space more magnetism and energy/heat deflection.

  • @jamescole3524
    @jamescole352417 күн бұрын

    curved spacetime is due to vibrational shockwaves from star activity compressing around solid objects and pushes downward on atoms and by downward i mean pushing towards the middle of the solid object

  • @CHXFIT95
    @CHXFIT9517 күн бұрын

    I just wanna copy and paste this link to this video on everything Terrance Howard is on inside the KZread world lol

  • @shahbazfawbush
    @shahbazfawbush23 күн бұрын

    Gravity is love, and love is gravity....

  • @YawnGod
    @YawnGod22 күн бұрын

    If you want to think about it a certain way, gravity is a collective van der Waals force, as opposed to an individual van der Waals force. Quanta of van der Waals forces, if you will, although renaming "gravity" to "distributed van der Waals force" isn't as etymologically satisfying.

  • @jmtawney3530
    @jmtawney353020 күн бұрын

    Yay for having her on.

  • @imaniwillis18
    @imaniwillis1818 күн бұрын

    I hypothesized this after learning basic college chemistry. It's a wonder to me how this is even a debate anymore. You think someone would have proved it with mathematics. A vast accumulation of charged particles should then result in forces similar to gravity. Same way intermolecular forces work.

  • @jaycorrales5329
    @jaycorrales532920 күн бұрын

    Neil deGrasse Tyson and Chuck Nice on StarTalk doing so much for creativity, and opening up the dialog in fascinating ways, also mention having super guests!

  • @WiiSpords
    @WiiSpords20 күн бұрын

    Time is emergent. Gravity is emergent.

  • @kjlkathandjohn6061
    @kjlkathandjohn606120 күн бұрын

    The Higgs Field is the atmosphere of Space. Galaxies and their stellar bodies are turbulently swirling, moving through this atmosphere of space at several million miles per hour. There is turbulent disruption of the Higgs Field, with vast compression increasing around all massive bodies. This is the dynamic reality of the universe. "Curved Space" is a photographic snapshot of the compressing of Higgs Field, frozen in time, just as a photo of an ocean wave looks like a solid ramp. But no curvature. The Higgs Field is forced into each body, interacting (colliding) with the quantum fields of the stellar objects, pushing them toward the center of mass (but the mass of objects resist each other, giving the "gravity" appearance). Only light waves seem not to collide with the Higgs Field, but it does curve as it passes through the collapsing density of the Higgs Field around massive objects. No gravity. No curved space/time. All material motion is from collision, of matter, of fields, etc.

  • @JimmyTaylor108
    @JimmyTaylor10821 күн бұрын

    not sure why his mind is blown by this information. This makes a lot of sense, especially how Dr. Levin explains it, but it's something that has been talked about for a long time.

  • @freddygolzofficial4129
    @freddygolzofficial412922 күн бұрын

    This is actually going to be a prevailing paradigm for the explanation of reality. The analogy she gives of a pointillism painting is exactly how the hologram of our 3D reality works. At a micro level, nothing actually exists and there is no meaning. But at a macro level, it’s all there to make meaning from in our consciousness.

  • @danielmicalizzi8261
    @danielmicalizzi826121 күн бұрын

    Time also not fundamental, depends on scale and distance. Perhaps this is also a quantum additive emergent property.

  • @FugazStar
    @FugazStar23 күн бұрын

    Well, we knew this from a long time ago, didn't we? that the every-day laws of physics that we're all familiar with don't actually work the same way or at all at the quantum level. Though now that she has worded it this way, it does make a lot of sense.

  • @healthyconscious3883
    @healthyconscious388311 күн бұрын

    Right after the episode on jre is crazy to me lol.