I love that even 300 years ago pointy stick is still advanced military weapons

Dude you are really really underwached and underaprecated. This is some really high quality stuff. There’s obviously tons of effort and love put into every video and you deserve better. Just keep making stuff we love the content and love you. Great job.

@sampletext9390

Жыл бұрын

This

Regarding the loop on the plaid… A friend of mine, Pàraig MacNeill, a Gaelic storyteller based in Dunblane, has been wearing 18th century Highland garb for over 35 years… he has a small leather loop stitched into the hem of his plaid and a button sewn onto the shoulder area of his jackets and waistcoats , so he can pull the excess plaid up over his shoulder, and attach it by fixing the loop over the button. No idea if this was something done in the 18thC, or if it’s just something of his own devising, but it certainly seems to work…. He also has a small jaw harp in his bonnet as opposed to a clan badge so he can accompany himself singing pùirt a bheul! 😁

Back in the beginning, years ago, you were so serious and now, you are just bubbling and funny. Honestly, I love you and love the effort you put into your work.

@cerberus6654

Жыл бұрын

@@francisjurksaitis He's unique. He reminds me of myself at that age I think.

@alfiewhippet.

Жыл бұрын

Yes. That's it completely. The vids are outstanding.

@Steve-ls3yy

5 ай бұрын

I too enjoyed the fun he brings to his vids. But have not seen that serious side you mention. I went back to his first videos and found he's always been a live wire.

Where you showed the plaid wrapped up like a sash it made me think of how some Prussian soldiers during the Napoleonic Wars would roll up their great coats and wear them in a very similar way in order to protect them from bladed attacks.

@flyboymike111357

Жыл бұрын

Ponchos and blankets were worn in a similar fashion by immigrant Sergeants during the Civil War and Indian Wars in the US.

@vorynrosethorn903

Жыл бұрын

The Russians were often dressed the same in WW1 and their are pictures of Edwardian British soldiers doing the same. I think is was a quite common way of carrying greatcoats in a military context.

@StuartAnderson-xl4bo

8 ай бұрын

Girding your loins

From what I have read, the fighting stance looks like one that fell out of fashion in much of Europe in the late 16th century, and the reason it fell out of fashion was that it was _really_ uncomfortable with the cut of the fashionable doublets (and specifically the armscyes) of the time. But 18th century clearly didn’t have any such issues with their armscyes, so they could raise their arms without any issues and would do so whenever it gave them an advantage in their fight.

You're the type of person I'm going to look for when I make a video game. So much useful information.

@juniper2346

Жыл бұрын

right?? I'm working on a graphic novel! :D

I live just down the road from Penicuik. That massive hill on the way in is a challenge to walk up! Gorgeous woodlands there though. You yelling "get away fi ma bit!" was hilarious. 😂

I've done some looking around and found Est.Titles to be a scam, based in Hong Kong, other's report that the trees they plant are Douglas fir not native to Scotland, essentially just monocrop Christmas tree farms Great video regardless of sponsorship, the Highlander doesn't look a day over 26😂

@rembrandtshadows

Жыл бұрын

good to know!

@adeptronic

Жыл бұрын

The whole established titles thing is cringe anyway. Buy a house, rent it out and then you are a landlord. Otherwise you are all hat and no cattle as the Texans say.

@rembrandtshadows

Жыл бұрын

@@adeptronic but that perfectly describes human fashion and social hierarchy since 7000 BC.

@adeptronic

Жыл бұрын

@@rembrandtshadows Probably why for most of humanities existence it was the parents job to choose your spouse.

Thanks, Tom: I always enjoy your reenactments, history lessons, and self-effacing humor. Good on ya.

Art is so interesting. I love when you can see definitive differences via art. Like the wealthy and the poor and how they differed. But also, all art is colored by the thought processes of the artist, and that lends it's own sense of interest. Maybe they assume everyone has x thing, because in their experience everyone does, but an artist who is not as well off, or comes from a different background might notice the differences, and incorporate them into their art. Thank you for pointing things out, and re-enacting them. Truly the kind of content I love.

Tom you are MY FAVEROUTE youtuber OF ALL TIME as a guy in australia with scottish ancesters i have become fascinated with scttish history and have loved watching youre videoes

Imagine walking through the forest and seeing a highlander with a gaint axe talking to a camera

Something I needed, I wished you could come to our Highland games coming in November 4th thru 6th this year this would be perfect, cheers! from Wm, Tucson, Arizona USA, may Scotland keep on shinning.

Very interesting and as always very entertaining, TY Tom. 😄👍

That bit of ad about established titles is the best in youtube, and there's a big load of them.

Fantastic video. So cool seeing things that no one else in the "outdoorsy" world is doing! Such a unique take and I enjoy it tremendously. Thank you, Tom! Both of you :)

Thanks Tom, I enjoy wearing my plaids, so the various options that you present, in all of your vids, are very intriguing. 💥

A real and very creditable effort to interpret the drawings and a brilliant presents.

Always brings a smile to my face when I see a new video from Tom:) Thank you for another classic!

Great job bringing art to life. Thank you.

When I made my Targe. I put two lyers of Kevlar on before the leather top . Good hunting.

I'd guess those drawings are authentic. Artists, because of their nature, tend to have a light-hearted approach to things, and see the funny side; and the guy was probably young, which adds to the playfulness. And then you see how you yourself, when portraying these drawings also have a humorous and light-hearted approach to the kinds of people they represent. It's one of the gifts of being young, I think, that you see what older people take as serious as just so much opportunity for fun. Also, some of the quirky details, like the little thing at the back of the neck, wouldn't be included by someone who wasn't familiar with it as a something. If it was on one drawing, you could say it was an inadvertent slip of the pen, but on all of them? It's obviously something the artist saw all the time. It was rivetting, by the way. Your obvious love of these things was really absorbing. Awesome stuff!

Ive been watching your chanell for a while and just want to comment that is a really brilliant concept, i love how you blend the art with the history and your analysis and I love the reenactments alot too. big ups to you for being such a capable and informed host, i admire a person that can not only survive sufficiently in the wilderness but present period accurate historical reenactment. Bonnets off to you my good sir, you are truly making history come alive for us. Cheers

I used to live in Penicuik . Milton Bridge , Glencourse Barracks . Loved it living there .

Please notify Established Titles the ad was as entertaining as the video. Thank you.

What a Great Video!, I love historical art and this book is definitely something I look forward to owning myself, thank you for the video, this one was Particularly great for Art Reference! ❤

Now that's how a KZreadr makes a commercial. Well done

There is ONE sketch that has a dirk…the Highlander is in a bed pulling it out from under his pillow as he’s about to be attacked. Otherwise…fandabitastic video!

Another excellent video with a professional-level standard of presentation. I have been following the channel for several years in part because my ancestors came from the areas depicted. I live on the other side of the world and have never been to Scotland, but your work makes me think that I have. All the best for the future. I must be away now to buy my wee bit!

Love your stuff Tom! You inspired me to take on the responsibility of lordship :p

I absolutely love your dedication to the history of your craft. It's fascinating ! Thank you for taking us on your journey 👍🏻 I'm guessing the loop is a simple practical feature to prevent the great kilt from falling off the shoulder during battle. With the kilt bunched in a large mass, it would even provide some minor torso protection from slashing & stabbing attacks to the shoulder and stomach area.

Another point on the fighting stance with the targe and sword, having your back leg loaded like that allows one to dodge backwards without off balancing yourself and further loads for a counter attack. It's something I do in boxing quite a bit, I've never tried it with a blade but I'd reckon it works just as well if you've got the range right. I love what you're doing, keep it up.

@elizabethpate9486

Жыл бұрын

Actually it is even better with the weapon. The weight acts much like a Cheetah's tail, as it provides a counterbalance for the warrior to gain inertia and thusly, whichever direction the warrior chose to move in the movement would have been made with little to no effort (especially true for the seasoned soldier well experienced and highly skilled say, the soldier who's weapon was merely an extension of his own body)!

@ajherring92

Жыл бұрын

@@elizabethpate9486 Reading my comment again, I'm not sure if I described well what I mean. When I'm boxing I keep my back heel lifted as pictured, but if I need to dodge a punch or kick to the head I simply set my heel down and let my body fall slightly backwards while maintaining a balanced stance. What follows is a counter attack sprung off that back leg which was already loaded but is now further loaded. If that's what you mean then it's brilliant that it works the same, but I have also blown my distance on that move, which in my situation has less final consequences with a fist than it might with an axe swinging at your head.

Many thanks, amigo. This is top shelf stuff!

John MacLeans journal eh? Supposed that's one of my ancestors. He got a bad deal from what I remember. Thank you for sharing his work. We MacLeans were renowned swordsman for centuries until around John MacLeans fall if I remember right.

There were English Jacobite's too. Enjoyed the video, great fun, cheers.

@richerdjones1988

Жыл бұрын

Just not enough

FB is back and this time it's "No More Mr. Nice Guy!"

I haven't even got through the land/title thing and I'm already loving this.

@loribenton5975

Жыл бұрын

Also, very soon you may address me as "My Lady." I'm writing a novel now that starts on the Isle of Skye (1734) and since I can't get there at present to do any onsite research (I'm in the States), at least in this small, fun way I can say I've a connection to Scotland. And by the way, you continue to be a great source of research for me when it comes to the little details of auld Scottish Highland life (I used bracken for a mattress in a scene thanks to your last video.), as well as just plain entertaining. I recognize all the work and dedication going into these videos (man, it shows) and hope you may continue for many years to come.

Another very enjoyable video Tom. Thanks a million

Very interesting, good historical information plus great fun. Good work, keep it up! 👍

This is great. Excellent work.

As always Tom...brilliant!

Tom has vanquished his ancient enemy, the orange pumpkin! Great video

Very informative, great video :) I have only a vague knowledge of Scottish history but now I'm super intrigued and wanna know more, also I loved those old illustrations they have a certain captivating charm to them

That was a really interesting reenactment, thanks for doing it.

My favorite video of your’s so far.

Mate you are very good. A natural born talent. A friend from Greece

so great! The production quality here! Love the jokes too :)

Great presentation. 😃

As someone that was born in Penicuik, I am so surprised I have only just heard of these drawings just now!

Absolutely love the video. Lot of great information.

Good work man, good work.

Saw this video - and subscribed at once! Great Video indeed, my Laird!

An impeccable video as always, Lord Tom of My Bit

Excellent work 💯👍

There are older illustrations of poor men carrying centuries old medieval swords and such as sidearms when going to market, like the illustration of the man with the scabbard their scabbards are falling to pieces with age, even while the sword itself is useable if rusty. It is likely that as such I think that the chap in the picture is carrying an antique sword, and possibly a very old one.

Great video and a great history lesson. Thanks!!!

Keep up the good work brother

Really interesting and cool,thanks for sharing.

Love your videos.

I love learning about coulter from my home thanks

Thank you

Tapadh leibh gu mòr Tom! Is e seo aon de na bhideothan as fheàrr agad. Many thanks Tom! This is one of your best videos. Keep up the great work.

THIS IS SO FRIGGIN' GREAT!!!!

Salute from a fellow Cateran in California!

Outstanding thank you, you have done a great job. From Mark Phillips, Pennsylvania, USA

Huge fan of all the videos. I really appreciate all the time and effort you put into them as well as the research for the historical aspects. I was wondering if you could share a link to where you got your great kilt?

Brilliant video

The story I heard on the basket sword was that after Harlow, two handed great swords were spread in every field in the Highlands due to the MacDonald retreat so everyone picked one up and turned it into basket sword. There is evidence of this as the Cleveland Museum of Art has a basket sword with a German blade.

Great exposition!

Incredible video

This is a great peek back into time! Even though I'm descended from lowlanders (Montgomery) I can't help but be jealous of the uniqueness of Highland culture.

Very interesting. thanks for sharing

Where you been man? Iam glad to see you again ,, here,, cheers mate

I love this video!

AMAZING!!!

Established Titles is such an appropriate sponsor haha!

I think the loop on the back is a modern day version of the drag handle on a combat vest.....lol. Just kidding. I have no clue. Loved the video like always. Wish you made more videos but I'm sure it's hard to create 1 let alone creating a bunch of videos. Love your work man. Keep up the great job and can't wait for the next video.

I am proud to say I own 1 foot of land in Scotland and I live in Missouri lol. my family bought it for me as a Christmas gift our family if from Scotland and Ireland.

Another great video, Tom! Regarding the shoulder 'loop': I'm wondering if it's possible that it may represent a trend of fastening one's dirk to the back shoulder of the baldric? If a sword broke on the battle field, you wouldn't want to drop your shield in order to grab the dirk from your belt- pulling it down from your shoulder might enable you to keep your eyes up and your shield close. I have no evidence for this other than the lack of dirks in the pictures, as you noted. Keep up the great content, and thanks for always going the extra mile! Tioraidh!

Good video, very interesting thanks.

11:53 As an artist myself, I don't think that is an attempt at hatching or rough sketching, as it appears nowhere else in the image but on the sword, the rest of the outlines on the figure are smooth and deliberate, also the dirk looks smooth by comparison. It probably is depicting a serrated sword, perhaps such a weapon would be a status symbol due to it's difficulty in manufacturing, as was sometimes the case with serrated zweihanders. Great video!

Good educational video Tom and I especially like the traditional phillips head screw holding the Loch Aaba axe head on. 👍🤣

Witness to Rebellion is a fantastic resource! Absolutely love your interpretation of these sketches! If your are ever in the Southeastern U.S. my Jacobite clan would love to meet up with you!

That has to be the best organic KZread add I have seen to date.

Smashing them pumpkins must have released some amount of dopamine 😆

I've always felt that these sketches are a touch caricatural

I bought the "we bit" for my girl she loved it

Thanks, Tom - very interesting, entertaining and informative! As others have said, I love your humor, occasionally self-deprecating, but always with a lighthearted air. I hated history all through my schooling and now, later in life, I regret my failure to pay attention. I'm in the USA, but have a strong connection to England and Scotland. (Ireland is definitely a favorite too!) THANK YOU! Btw: Interestingly, I delayed watching your video for a couple minutes because my random-play CD carousel began playing Scotland the Brave with bagpipes. Somehow, I want to stand up straight and tall when I hear that!

@GaiusCaligula234

Жыл бұрын

"strong connection" okay sure hahaha

@randy-9842

Жыл бұрын

@@GaiusCaligula234 Yes, indeed. Ancestral. Vacations. Similar aspirations in many things. --- WHY in the world would you arrogantly and disparagingly question that in someone you've never met?

@GaiusCaligula234

Жыл бұрын

@@randy-9842 I see a common trend in Americans, many of them have this thing about "connections". It's just funny for a person who is from the place to see someone just claim that they have a strong connection because they read a few articles and their great great great grandma was from there

@randy-9842

Жыл бұрын

@@GaiusCaligula234 perhaps I should have anticipated your less than polite comments simply from the "name" and avatar you've chosen. Wikipedia says: "... after this, the sources focus upon his cruelty, sadism, extravagance, and sexual perversion, presenting him as an insane tyrant." I respect Fandabi Dozi too much to respond any further. He deserves better than these divisive comments.

@GaiusCaligula234

Жыл бұрын

@@randy-9842 Read a line before, lad

Great video, thanks Lord LARPer

According to family lore, many swordsmen wrapped up their bodies and swords with sheepskins. The wool would waterproof them and keep them warm, and the lanolin oil would help keep the blade from rusting. Likely, the artist was depicting such a sight.

The manner Duncan McGregor is depicted wearing his plaid "slung" much like a bedroll, is described as being a way Highlanders in the American colonies enlisted in colonial ranger units wore their plaids to be used on the march beginning in the early 18th century. A dissertation by Robert K. Weber entitled "Plaids and Broadswords of the Altamaha," explores this as well as another title I've read on the history of rangers, the title escapes me. Bonnets were also worn, though often in earthen colors as opposed to Jacobite blue. The utility of tartan crossed the big pond in the form of Highland emigrant and soldier alike.

@FandabiDozi

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for the reference

I'm a skilled comic book penciler. I can tell you that one possibility for the faces being grotesque is that faces are quite challenging for many people to draw, as well as hands and feet. The artist may have simply lacked practice at drawing faces. Sometimes for an artist that's learning, they have to wrestle with certain body parts until they get that epiphany and it just clicks for them.

maybe the "loop" on the back isn't the plaid but is the dagger, I know they're worn on their belts or waist, but maybe they decided to have them on their back

Awesome demo, v effective use, might come in handy as WW3 breaks out

hello from poland, we remember Bonnie Prince Charlie ;)

Awesome work, my friend, happy that I was of some help. The intro plus commercial was one of the best bits in KZread history I have seen so far… wait…. Bit seen so far-? Your bit? Awwwwwww see where the pun is leading to? Get it? See what I did her? 😂😂😂

Nice one.

What a cool idea! I want to do this with the painting of the MacLachlan Clansman in RR McIan's book, but haven't found a good deerskin vest. I also Don't have access to lesser periwinkle flowers. And I have no use or space for a targe beyond recreating that photo.

I knew the ad was coming with the bit but laughed anyway.