Response to 23 Questions - Part 21 - Interest / Usury (Sood) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi
Response to 23 Questions on Religious Opinion of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi
Part 21 - Interest / Usury (Sood)
Banking, Mortgage, Student Loan, National Savings, Bank Job, Prize bond
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: kzread.info?s...
▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.org/donate/
▶ CONNECT with us:
◼ WEBSITE: www.ghamidi.org
◼ FACEBOOK: / ghamidicil
◼ KZread: / ghamidicil
0:00 : پچھلی گفتگو کا خلاصہ
1:18 : سود لینے، دینے، لکھنے والی والے پر لعنت والی روایت پر گفتگو
21:00 : "موکل" کے مادے اور لفظ کے بارے میں بتائیے
31:19 : کوئی انفرادی طور پر کام کرنے والا ہے تب موکل کون ہوگا
34:14 : کسی شخص کو سود پر قرض ملتا ہے اور وہ کسی دوسرے کو اس بارے میں بتاتا ہے تو کیا اسے گاہک کا بینک میں لے جانا کہیں گے
#GCIL #JavedAhmedGhamidi #FromGhamidiDesk #AlMawrid
Пікірлер: 306
GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app
@karimdad3153
3 жыл бұрын
your are great sir
@mohdzaheerhaq2654
Жыл бұрын
You're good thinker and well wisher thanks
@muhammadyamin852
11 ай бұрын
@@karimdad315333:12 33:13
شُکر اُس رَب کا کہ جس نے مُجھ ناچیز کو استادِ محترم غامدی صاحب جیسی عظیم نعمت سے نوازا! 😍 💕
What a great scholar ....Allah bless him
ASSALAMUALAIKUM My Honorable USTAZ E MUHTARAM, May ALLAH KAREEM Shower His Countless Blessings on your kind self and your Respected Family (Aameen).
@abdullatifsatti3163
3 жыл бұрын
Proper word is “Ustad” not Ustaz. This is Urdu, our mother language, please correct it.
@sarangvision5533
3 жыл бұрын
@@abdullatifsatti3163 kia dunya me srf urdu ha, ?? Pushto b ha , ustaz in pushto. Agr tery satti ka tarjuma kee jayee tu esko pushto me( julsa howa cheez ) in hindi same meaning, julsaana , julasna etc , Ab bool mister, ???
@khalidh.shaikh9018
3 жыл бұрын
JAZAKALLAH KHAIR With due respect I always write the word, "USTAZ", which is always being used by Honorable USTAZ E MUHTARAM. This is Arabic word. Regards
@madeehasaeed786
Жыл бұрын
@@abdullatifsatti3163 It’s not the mother language or mother tongue of any of the native peoples of Pakistan, that is a fact, it is neither the mother tongue of any of the four provinces of Pakistan, not of Baluchistan, not of KPK+FATA, not of Punjab and not of Sindh, again a fact that cannot be denied, neither is it the mother tongue of the two allied territories of Pakistan as in Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan, again a fact, hence your claim of Urdu being your mother tongue may well be true but is nonetheless limited to you and may be a small subset of the population that in itself is not native to Pakistan but from outside Pakistan, but it is certainly not true for 90% of the population of Pakistan who have their very own languages connected to the very names of their lands and of the peoples that inhabit them. If Urdu is a mother tongue then it is the mother tongue of certain people in certain areas of India who happen to be Muslims whereas if they were not Muslims (Hindus etc) they would most likely be speaking Hindi and their mother tongue would be classed as Hindi too, hence it’s not even a mother tongue in those areas where it is most common or where it is supposed to originate from as the mother tongue there is Hindi or some variation like Bhojpuri etc. Neither is it true to imply as you did that Urdu is the mother tongue of Pakistan as a country, that is patently false and an attempt at cultural and linguistic imposition, if you were a truth speaking person you would have said if you couldn’t remain quite (after all what is it to you how somebody speaks a word especially when it is 100% a fact that every one of these words is either of Arabic or Persian origin and have no origin intrinsically in Urdu itself) that Urdu is Pakistan’s national language by fiat and government decree, it is not really a national language like English is for Australia and Japanese is for Japan and French is for France, therefore when it isn’t even really a national language (except by government enforcement or by law) then how on earth could it be a mother tongue of Pakistan, (which is what your statement implied), that would have been saying the truth. So have the courage to speak the truth and stop imposing yourself and your language on others and say it as it is that in reality Urdu is Pakistan’s official language at the federal level along with English by law, not naturally, not natively, not organically and not historically, it is not really a national language or tongue or “quomi zaban” at all and not the mother language or mother tongue of any of Pakistan’s native peoples nor of any province or territory and nor of Pakistan as a country, it is simply an official language, don’t force your language and hence attempt to show some sort of superiority otherwise English and French are far far far superior when it comes to being international languages and the lingua franca of the world. Pakistan Zindabaad
Assalamoalaikum Unbelievable. I cannot imagine a scolar like you end up doing this video. May Allah give us guidance.
Ghamdi sahab is the best of this era, prayers for him. Thank you for educating us.
Itni saadgi se shayad hi koi apni baat rakhta hoga aaj kal😍 Allah slamat rakhe aapko.
ALLAH Ghamdi ko sehat dey ore omer mn barkat ataa karey, Aameen. He is true great Islamic scholar.
May Allah bless both Imam Amin Islahi RA and his true and Great student(GHAMIDHI SB..)
Assalam Elekum Ghamidi sir. Allah apko khush rakhay. Bht kuch seekha hai ap se. Barak Allah.
Messiah of the 21st Century. Ustaz Ghamidi RahimaUllah ❤️
حدیث کی تشریح سے معلومات میں اضافہ ہو ا۔ اللہ آپ کو لمبی عمر عطا فرمائے امین
Love you ghamidi sahab. Allah ap ko lambi umar dey ameen
Kamaal explanation. You are GREAT sir..!!
Mohtram tareen Scholar. Badnaseeb hai wo shakhs jo Deen ka fehm hasil karna chahey aur Janab Ghamdi Sahab ko na sunay. Iss daur main Aap jesay fehm ka maalik koi hai ? No No No. I salute you , Sir. ❤️❤️❤️
Well explained Jazak Allah khair
Imam of this era.... hats off to you Ghamidi Sahab..!!
JazakAllah o khairan ustade mohtaram.
Never seen a scholar with such clarity in thoughts 👍
Waaa Mashallah, Moulaan kyaa hi taareef karun uss khuda ki jo aapko iss zahanat se nawaaz.. waqe main Allah ki Rahemath bana ke bhejaa hin aapko iss dour ke liye.. jioo Moulana Jioo.. Allah aap jaise zaheen danishwar isss ummat ko mazeed den.. logo deen ki samjha ayese paida hoti.. jo sonch ne samjh ne kaa jazba rakhte hain.. na ke mahez jazbati Deen koo follow karten hain...SubhanAllah..
A great contemporary scholar.May the Almighty Allah bless him Long life and sound health.
@aslamjaved3360
2 жыл бұрын
Aameen Suma Aameen
@abuumair415
2 жыл бұрын
Abdullah (b. Mas'ud) (Allah be pleased with him) said that Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) cursed the one who accepted interest and the one who paid it I asked about the one who recorded it, and two witnesses to it. He (the narrator) said: We narrate what we have heard. Sahih Muslim: 4092 / INT:1597 Jabir said that Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) cursed the accepter of interest and its payer, and one who records it, and the two witnesses, and he said: They are all equal. Sahih Muslim: 4093/ INT:1598
@ScienceadobyDrEishal
Жыл бұрын
@@abuumair415 please hear this lecture again, this hadith has been explained in a lengthy detail
@goharrehman9023
Жыл бұрын
@@abuumair415 Please Ghamdi sahib Nation Al Saving Bank Me Amount per Interest ke bare Bryan Farmaye Thanks
Best scholar in the World ever.Awesome explain. 👍👍👍
jazakAllah Khair, Great scholar and inspiration for life. May Allah Bless you with good Health and Happiness. Ameen
@osamajaved9523
2 жыл бұрын
Jaza Ka Allah*
Well explained and correct interpretation of Hadith 👍
Mashallah very rationale interpretation of hadees. Thank you Ustade e mohtaram.
جزاک الله خیرا۔ الله آپ کو لمبی اور صحت مند ذندگی عطا فرمائے ۔
I am so inspired by Ghamdi sahab's intellect. I was so in darkness about this matter for the most part of my life. I see things clear now.
Absolutely correct narrative. May be Jawed sahab don't know in Pakistan's Frontier province this mahajani system is very strong and popular among people
Excellent explanation. 1 sawal paida hua hai.lekin I'm sure next program main jawab mil jaye ga. Thank u so much ghamidi sahab and team.
Alhamdulillah Very Very clear Jazak ALLAH khairan
Zajakalla sahi say samjaya allah aap ko salamat rakhay
Jazaak Allah...
God bless you sir, meri aankhein khol gaye., Jazakallah khair.
Awesome awesome just awesome
Jazak'Allah-o-khair mohtaram ustaz Ghamdi sahib for such a detailed and simplified explanation. Hassan sahb, could you please also request ustaz to shed some light on how sahaba and early scholars understood this issue (in the light of this hadith) and why many Arab scholars even today believe that this hadith is also meant for those who borrow money on usury? And if the sahaba and early scholars didn't have opportunity to give their opinion, when or what would have caused this misunderstanding?
MashaAllah Everyone needs to relearn Islam from Javed Ahmed Ghamidi Big time messed up
Jazakallah, ap ko hamesha zaaalim k khilaf, mazloom k sath khara paya jo k deen ki Asal asaas hai ❤️
Ghamidi sir is a ocean of knowledge...a thought provoking conversation...nice sir
Jazzak Allah
Masha Allha. Bahoot tafseel se batya
Itna wazay kar kay samjhaya hai tajub hai ab bhi log ghamdi sahab par tanqeed karty hain aur kehtay hain kay jo humary badon nay samjha wohi sahee hai. Iss say andaza hota hai kay andhi taqleed nahe karni chahey jabkay Allah nay kaha hai kay agar bat wazay ho jay aur samhaj mai aajay tou ausay qabool kar lo. Thank you sir.
Awesome explaination
Just one small clarification; any other historical scholar having the same opinion and explanation of Hadith? Though I'm much satisfied with the explanation given by Ghamdi Sahib.
@sarangvision5533
3 жыл бұрын
All other are just reading the old books of BaBa, s.
@Hamzaisme2007
3 жыл бұрын
No one but it doesn't mean that all were have no brain. Why ghamdi sahab is giving this meaning and not even single has given this meaning Also if u r given soud then u r also helping them to promote their system. Isn't it? Every person has to spend according to his limits then no need to give soud also. So I am not agree with ghamdi sahab.
@GG-ft1bf
3 жыл бұрын
is baat mein bohat hikmat hai. Quran rehti dunya k liay hai. Qarz lene vala aam to per majbur hota hai aur hr banday ki majburi b mukhtalif hoti hai. Jesay majburi mein murdar b kha saktay hain. Isi trarah majbur admi qarz b le ga be-shak sood pr ho. Sood ko khatm kernay ka ikhtiyar usi k pas hota hai jo sood letay hein na k jo sood detay hein. Allah ne hamein ye paband nahi kiya k qon si majburi mein lein aur kon si majburi mein nahi. isi liay sirf sood ka mutalba kerne valoun ko zymedar thehraya. ye bohat bari hikmat hai agar ap khor karein to.
@nawazkalwar8018
Жыл бұрын
What if there is none; no precedent? And there is always a first time everything. May be Ghamidi is the first one to interpret this like this.
@muhammadmithallashari6375
Жыл бұрын
@@Hamzaisme2007 Mere bhai, mein majboor tang dast hoon, majboori me sood pe paisa leta hoon, to mein kahan se supporter ho gaya. Mujhe bina sood k koi paisa deta to mein usi se leta kyun sood pe paisa leta. Matlab agar Muslim countries bilkul gareeb ho gaye hain, bhuka mar raha hain to main hijrat kar ka non muslim country k secular system me rehta hoon to kya mein us system ka supporter hoon? Bhai nhi jata to bhuka marta to majboori mein gaya. Isi liya Quran me Allah ne bhi sood lena wala ko kuch bhi nhi kaha. Bhai, kindly phir se gaur karen, Allah hum sab ko hidayat de, Aameen!
بہت خوب.. ماشاء اللہ بارک اللہ
wallah ghamidi ustad is gem i hope after his hadith project(IA) the doubts of munkir e hadith will be cleared
کیا خوبصورت انتظام ہے خدا تعالیٰ کا کہ جس دین کو اس نے ابدی دین بنایا اس کی حفاظت کا اہتمام بھی خود فرماتا رہتا ہے۔ جب بھی بگاڑ پیدا ہونے لگتا ہے اور لوگ دانستہ یا نا دانستہ اپنی باتیں دین میں داخل کر دیتےہیں تو اللہ تعالیٰ کسی انسان کو یہ توفیق دے دیتا ہے کہ وہ بگاڑ کی نشاندہی کرے اوراصل چیز سامنے لے کر آئے۔ جن لوگوں کو غامدی صاحب کا وجود اور افکار گراں گزرتے ہیں انہیں خبر ہو کہ غامدی صاحب نہ ہوتے تو کوئی اور ہوتا۔ اللہ تعالیٰ نے یہ کام ہر دور میں کسی نہ کسی سے کرواتے رہنا ہے۔ وہ یہ شرف کس کو بخشتا ہے یہ اس کی مرضی ہے۔
Such a great teacher and scholar ❤️
Subhan Allah kiya khoobsorat explaination JazakAllah
God bless you and I hope your knowledge benefit many Muslim
Ghamdi Sahb is mujadid of this century. Alhumdulilah, so glad to be born in his era.
جزاک اللہ
I am shocked 😳 what a great mind he has ❤️
As salaam O Alaikum.......Bahot bahot ... shukrya ,, Jawed sahab..
ell explained! Example is like this: CHORI KERNAY WALA AUR CHORI KARANAY WALA DONO MUJRIM HAYN. TO Kia chori karanay wala wo hai jiss kay ghar chori hui hai?
Jazak ALLAH Ghamdi sb
JazakAllah kher Ghamidi Sb.
Salam Hasan Bhai thank you so much for these sessions and of course ustad javed ahmed ghamidi sahib. Hasan can you ask javed sahib his position with regards to the hadith which mentions bartering of 6 items is haram. Gold silver barley wheat dates and salt. Shukran
@imgguru1277
3 жыл бұрын
Why do you think barter of food would be haram...? Not that I think gold and silver are haram either but especially food why on earth God would make that haram?
@wearcheer7763
3 жыл бұрын
@@imgguru1277 ghamidi knows the art of making everything halal.. 😂😂
@umarp5325
3 жыл бұрын
I was referring to a specific hadith
@kubrab2617
3 жыл бұрын
@@wearcheer7763 and u people knows art of making everything haram..
Very nice.. Jazakallah..
Bohot shukrya Ghamidi sahib itni details mein explain karney ka, apki baat kisi majboor inssan ke liye qarz leney tak theek lagti hai, my question is.. kia jo log ayaashi ke liye sood letey hain, ya phir gambling ke liye sood letey hain, ya phir luxry car leney k liye sood letey hain kia un per bhi koi gunah ya burayi ka ilzaam nahi? This is really confusing me because now a days a lot of people just take loans with interest without even their need. Thank you
Ghamidi sab truly explained otherwise all govt employees salaried personal should involve in supporting sood business.
معلوماث می اضافع ہوا
Great explanation, nowadays call them Loan shark, in Malaysia, Singapore, and South East Asia.
Outstanding
Ghamidi sahib is a great man.Allah bless you.
❤one of the greatest mind of islam,
Thanks sir ghamidy
Mai ek chartered accountant hon. Mujhe ye batain jo tareef aap kr rhe hain us mai ye waze hai k sood ek person to person hua krta tha or zarurat k tehat hua krta tha .... Or quran aap k mutabiq is liye mamnoon qarar de rha hai kahan aap ek qarz k achay kaam mai aap burai ka izafa kr dain . Jab k ham agr business to business transaction dekhain to wo is wajha se nhi hotin k us company ko zarurat hai pr is wajha se hoti hain kyu k hamari currency jo ham use krte hain wo ek jali currency hai or is ki value har saal chura li jati hai chahay wo govt ki tarf se ho ya phir kisi or wajha se . To us value ko store krne k liye businesses apne paise banks mai ya mutual funds mai rkhte hain ya yehi kaam individual bhi krte hain .... Yahan ulama is cheez ko account for karne se qasir hain k agar ham us devaluation ko nhi rokainge to ek din jo paise rkhe hain us ki value kuch bhi na rahe gi.... Or jis sood ki aap baat kr rhe hain wo is banking nizam mai lia hi nhi jata ..... Kyu k ye banks kabhi bhi kisi zarurat mand ko paise nhi dete.... Balk un ko paise dety hain jin ko us paison ki zaurat nhi. Ye ek haqeeqat hai. Plz is pehlu pr zaroor roshni dalain
@GG-ft1bf
3 жыл бұрын
is baat mein bohat hikmat hai. Quran rehti dunya k liay hai. Qarz lene vala aam to per majbur hota hai aur hr banday ki majburi b mukhtalif hoti hai. Jesay majburi mein murdar b kha saktay hain. Isi trarah majbur admi qarz b le ga be-shak sood pr ho. Sood ko khatm kernay ka ikhtiyar usi k pas hota hai jo sood letay hein na k jo sood detay hein. Allah ne hamein ye paband nahi kiya k qon si majburi mein lein aur kon si majburi mein nahi. isi liay sirf sood ka mutalba kerne valoun ko zymedar thehraya. ye bohat bari hikmat hai agar ap khor karein to.
Simple and logically explained.
Gamdi sir is very talented person
Thanks
Great ghamidii shb.....
السلام و علیکم محترم، ریاست کے متعلق راہ نمائی کیجئے اس کے لیے کیا حکم اور حد ہو گی جو بینکنگ نظام کو صرف مظبوط ہی نہیں رکھتی بلکہ اس سودی نظام کی حفاظت بھی کرتی ہے؟
Borrowing money with understanding with all conditions before borrow are ligit and both are equally responsible . People those are working also abider and aider. Ghamidi sahab is giving wave out to only receiver and present receiver innocent ? Amazing
With all due respect, interest is time value of money. Money is not created or destroyed because it is symbolic. It is not a thing. It is a store of value,. Even for money with intrinsic value like silver or gold, the exchange value of money is always greater than intrinsic value otherwise it is hoarded (Graham's law).
Very good explanation and clarification. However, one question. Q. If there is no payer of interest then how one can charge interest? Secondly, now a days people wilfully go to banks to take loans.
@alipakistani6328
2 жыл бұрын
Does every one have enough for basic needs? People don’t even have enough to eat in many parts of the world. Loan is a necessity for many. Those who are willfully paying interest for things they don’t need is a different category. Hope that helps.
Jazakallah khair ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Five greatest Scholars of this Era Moulana Abu'ala Moudodi Javed ahmed Ghamidi Dr Zakir naik Moulana Amin Ahsan islahi sb Maulana Wahiduddin khan
Sahih Muslim Hadith # 3854 also talks about giver and taker of interest being equally guilty. Please refer to that too as it just talks about the giver before equating it to taker. Thanks
Exactly ' Exactly'Exactly Same thing happen in recovery company in modern day corporate world
JAZAKALLAH
This video should be in English subtitles it’s extremely important for the English speaking audiences. Pls!
@kubrab2617
3 жыл бұрын
Your wish is fulfilled.... Alhamdulillah😄
@GG-ft1bf
3 жыл бұрын
subtitles are available. You can access them by clicking on setting in the bottom right corner of video.
@abuumair415
2 жыл бұрын
Abdullah (b. Mas'ud) (Allah be pleased with him) said that Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) cursed the one who accepted interest and the one who paid it I asked about the one who recorded it, and two witnesses to it. He (the narrator) said: We narrate what we have heard. Sahih Muslim: 4092 / INT:1597 Jabir said that Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) cursed the accepter of interest and its payer, and one who records it, and the two witnesses, and he said: They are all equal. Sahih Muslim: 4093/ INT:1598
It seems that he is not only a Mujaddid but Mujaddid-e-Azam of Islam. I will follow you to the end of this world. By God, time is near when people will understand you. Please don't give up on them. ہزاروں سال نرگس اپنی بے نوری پہ روتی ہے۔ بڑی مشکل سے ہوتا ہے چمن میں دیدہ ور پیدا۔
MA What a great explanation
Great Scholar
Behtareen
Looking at bigger picture, If customers or interest payers neither take loan nor pay the interest, then the entire system will not exist, because there are no customers. Can someone answer this if Gamidhi saab already said about it ? In any lectures Chori jis ghar pe Hui usko q gunehgar maane aapne kaha.. lekin koi khud se agar chor k pas jaaye aur chori karne kahe, to kya chor gunahgar hoga ?
@aakifriaz2388
Жыл бұрын
Only banks can pay huge amounts to the needy person. Do you happily pay interest to them or banks force you to pay? Don't we prefer to get loan from our friends (if they can afford) rather than banks? We borrow because we need to borrow, not because we want to pay back an extra amount.
@aneeq.q6614
Жыл бұрын
@@aakifriaz2388 looks like these people live in fairy land They wont even move a finger to establish shariah its easy to say everyone should stop so what can poor do ? Die ? Or stay in prison forever ? We all know our system and hiw corrupt it is someone earing 10-20k whatcan they do But blame poor always in end sitting in their lavish homes
Mai ye baat manne pr bilkul tayyar hon k agar metal currency ho or us pr izafi raqam ka dawa kia jay kisi majboor insan se to wo ek zeyaddti hogi .... Pr ye tasawwur karain k mai aaj kisi ko 1 lac deta hon or wo mujhe 10 saal baad lautane ka wada krta hai or wo mujhe 10 saal baad lauta bhi deta hai to kya wo raqam mery liye utni hi eham hogi jitni aaj thi .... Yehi chez agar maj gold ki soorat mai deta hon to bilkul utni hi eham hogi .... Is pr roshni dalain kyu k sood asal mai ab wo sood nhi rha is mai bohat complications aagai hain.
@GG-ft1bf
3 жыл бұрын
Qarz ap date hi sawab ki niyyat se hein. Farz karain aik admi dusray ko 10 lakh 3 saal k liay qarz deta hai. Ab sawal to yeh b peda hota hai k qarz denay vala vo pesay kisi karobar mein deta to 10 lakh ko 20 lakh b kr sakta tha. us ka to nuksan hua. Jis nuksan ki ap ne baat ki vo INFLATION ki vaja se hota hai. yeh nuksan pesay ki value waqt k sath km honay ki vaja se hota hai. Jb ap kisi ko qarz detay hein to yeh nuksan to uthatay hein aur bohat baray sawab ke mustahiq ban jatey hein. Aur agar ap apna ye nuksan bardasht nahi kr saktay to qarz b na dein. qarz dena farz nahi. bohat bari qurbani hai.
excellent
When we keep our money in bank due to inflation its value decrease after one year or more. Who will responsible for it?.while if we buy gold or house or land it will call business.
Assalam Alaikum To phir hum log bhi taavun kar rhe hain mhajan ya bank ka karo baar flourish karne main unke ghahak bankar. Ye aise hi hai jaise munim hisab likh kar madad kar rha hai hum ghahak bankar uski madad kar rhe hain ALLAH AUR USKE RASOOL KE KHILAF JUNG KARNE MAIN. Agar hum client nahi bane to hum is Azeem gunha main shareek hone se bach sakte hain. Hamain iski talqeen karni chahiye.
Mashallah allah nay ap ko bat karnay ka sleeka diye ha wo kisi or pass mushkil ha Lakin ghamdi sahib 1 meharbani karay 1 fatwa chiye tha ap say jo ye student loan humay gov dey rhy ha jis me almost 8 percent sood hum nay gov ko deyna ha Kaya hum wo ley saktay ha Q kay iss case me gov hum say sood khai gi or hum sirf dey gay
Please also get Ghaamdi sahab's opinion on stock exchanges. Clearly these do not represent the economy and more or less working as sitta markets.
Book: Jam e Tirmazi Hadees no.1206. Yah hai jo har kisi ke liye mana kiya gaya hai RIBA Lene aur dene. Aap Ke jawab ka muntazar rahunga
@ZK-lb5rs
3 жыл бұрын
???
@adeptmaneuver
3 жыл бұрын
Isi hadees ko hi to byan kr rae hain ustad Ghamidi sahab. Is hadees ko arabic mei parhen to pata chalega k mukila ka tarjuma ghalat kia gaya hai.
@adeelahmed1749
2 жыл бұрын
Bhai pehle part or dosre part dono sune ghamdi sahab ki bato main shadid tazad ha.
With all due respect to Ghamidi Saheb, I would like to point out that why the one who is giving Riba also sinful. 1) The reason is that when this transaction is documented which is Usury (Riba) based, he (the one who went to get loan) agrees to this transaction. He is not forced to pay Riba, He actually went to get loan and agreed to pay additional (Riba) more than premium and sign the document to agree/approve this Riba based Transaction. That's why All mainstream scholars considers that person feeding Riba to the one who is taking Riba. This person is Mukil actually. Another example is that Bank's agents not coming Individual's home to force us to agree/sign any Riba based loan . This is the Individual (Mukil) who going there and agree/signing the document to participate in Riba based Transaction. 2) In Quran, the word has been used as " Qard-e-Hasana" means Goodly Loan which defines a type of transaction in which person takes a loan from other person without repaying him anything additional. In case if person can not return the premium amount on time because of some serious issue like medical or loosing job or whatever then the word "Hasana" has been used which means Goodly Loan. Goodly (Hasana) means if genuinely person (the one who taken loan, Qard-e-Hasana) could not return money on time then Giver (Person who given the loan) would either wait or forgive rest of it that's why it is called "Qard-eHasana". 3) Thirdly historically there is no transaction (approve) by our Prophet which indicate that he has ever approve any Riba based transaction. So all participants like Giver, Taker, the one who document this contract/transaction all are extremely sinful. This is the understand of majority of scholars . Also Please do not engage into a debate or disrespect anyone if we do not agree with other person. We can follow the teachings of Quran and Sunnah and righteous scholars. of our choice. Allah(swt) is the ultimate judge. May Allah(swt) give us toufeeq and ability to practice true teachings of Quran and Sunnah. Aameen.
@fahadriaz5628
Жыл бұрын
I agree with you and I want to add one more thing in it that the worker(agent) are also the employees, they do job their, they don't own this business, 90% they do job for their living, they are also needy ones. Just like if the giver is not including in it because giver have some need so beside worker has also his/her need. I was agreed with them in part 20 but in this 21 part I think I'm confused for one thing which is as they are saying that hadith inherits(relate) from QURAN so the thing he is saying "why about giver is not included in the QURAN by ALLAH". That's why I'm in a doubt. If anyone who can clear my doubt are warmly welcome. and maybe I can be wrong so please correct me if I'm. MAY ALLAH forgive me and us. Ameen
@cryptotradingwithayan
9 ай бұрын
Brother if the agent is needy one and doing it bcz of there family ao just find other halal job why doing this haram job like collecting sood and providing a customer..???
AOA, I have a question that is profit of National Saving Account / Certificates is halal or haram. In other words amont invested in National Saving is halal or not?
Make sense 👍🏻
Very nice
MarshaALLAH, Sood par raqam lety waqt kya wo bekhabar hai? Wo kaha khara hai?
In today's banking system, can we consider the depositors of a bank as the "mukali Riba" as it is their money which is further lended to the borrowers for excessive interest? Dr Abdul wasai... A student of Islamic banking
Plz. Btain k. Qomi. Bacht. Se. Jo. Profit. Milta. H wo. Kesa. H. Plz btain ??