You have name called him about 10times within the first 10min. Why would he entertain a debate with somoene of your level? This guy is beyond ur age and thinking. Keep crying allah through his prophet chose the commander of the faithful Ali and u guys have rejected this.

@warezahmadi

2 ай бұрын

George floyd fish fish cry cry

@sameerwasim4187

2 ай бұрын

As an ex shia I would like to tell you Yeah even though he chose ali as his leader but chose abu bakr to lead prayer he chose ali but ask abu bakr for camel to medina he chose ali but tell a woman to go to take your matter to abu bakr when I am dead seriously shia do something better in life rather than proving this false leadership which ali himself doesn't believe and be caliph 4 rightly guided caliph 😂😂😂

@masteronmace

2 ай бұрын

@@sameerwasim4187Rasulallah waited 15 days for Imam Ali to catch up bc Ali was in Mecca absolving Rasulallah’s debts and protecting him by acting as a decoy. Look it up

@HanaHana-ft9li

15 күн бұрын

@@sameerwasim4187funny thing how can anyone steal leadership is beyond me? Like even if abubaker claimed to be a leader why didn’t Ali also declare leadership that was there wound be no argument about it. During the prophets life many claimed to be prophets the prophet didn’t just sit and watch them misguide ppl he fought them and declared them liars! If Ali just did one thing to prove he isn’t a leader and others have lied we would t even have any argument. The problem is Ali did nothing. Sun is are right to think he was okay with them at the end and accepted their leadership shias say no he kept silent for the sake of Islam even tho Islam to them is Ali leadership so makes no sense.

Ahmad ibn Yunus narrated to us and said: Ibn abi Dhib narrated to us from Imam az Zuhri who said: "I did not see any people who resemble the Christians more than the Saba'iyyah" Ahmad ibn Yunus said: "They are the Rafidha"

@Omar_0987

3 ай бұрын

The Christians are people of the book. Also, your narrating random people.

@bayern1445

3 ай бұрын

@@Omar_0987 no im not, they are anything but random

@Omar_0987

3 ай бұрын

@@bayern1445 who is Ahmed yunus and imam zuhri. Someone who worked for Umayyads. Let’s not quote him. Find someone with better credibility.

@midzfarsulaiman3209

3 ай бұрын

Christians in our country Philippines, they love body tattoo...

This guy is not even qualified to do a response to Shiekh Ammar. All he does is express his opinions with no evidence or substance. We not a religion of opinions by uneducated people. As always lost and really need to go and study real Islam. Stop 🛑 misguiding people with this baseless response

@HanaHana-ft9li

Ай бұрын

If you think nakshawani is great may Allah have mercy on you.

@Omar_0987

Ай бұрын

@@HanaHana-ft9li absolutely great and amazing. Allah mercy has always been on me. Unlike lost people. What happened to the responses. Allllll quiet now. Maybe he is guided now. And his a shia

@saadsalman4518

16 күн бұрын

​@@Omar_0987haha, u thunk nikshwani makes sense lol

@Omar_0987

15 күн бұрын

@@saadsalman4518 absolutely 👍

@Omar_0987

8 күн бұрын

@@saadsalman4518 absolutely,

Brother, when I look at the content of your channel this is what I see : hatred. Hatred tied with ego. I didn't find it a genuine discourse of seeking the truth . But rather a hatred (with ego that tries to prove its superiority) dressed and covered by reasons . I don't believe that this is the sunnah of the prophet. یا ایهالذین امنو لا یسخر قوم من قوم عسی ان یکونو خیرا منهم ربنا اغفر لنا و لاخواننا الذین سبقو بالایمان و لا تجعل فی قلوبتا غلا للذین امنوI ربنا انک رئوف الرحیم

@mrwhipnz8319

3 ай бұрын

ur supposed to ridicule ahlul bidaah

@farshidevazabadian8950

3 ай бұрын

@@mrwhipnz8319 this as itself is a bidaa.

@abdiaden4080

3 ай бұрын

TRUE BROTHER THIS CHANNEL IS FULL OF HATRED

@mrwhipnz8319

3 ай бұрын

@@farshidevazabadian8950 no it’s not

@aaminissa5392

2 ай бұрын

@@abdiaden4080 refuting ahlul bidaa is now bidaa 😮

Thank you for promoting Ammar

@TheIntrepid-tz4zo

3 ай бұрын

i think it's the other way around, amar promoting sunnah discourse otherwise you would not have been here.

@LadooCrew

3 ай бұрын

Ammar belongs in a biker gang with his tattoos not a mimbar

Response not convincing

These have been answered from ages. They don't have anything new. It is the same tired doubts and weak points. You could write down the response and answer 97% of Shia allegations and doubts.

@jawadasgharrizvi1050

3 ай бұрын

Highlight an argument that you have against the shia ..that hasn't already been answered rebutted and refuted?...what new do you have??...your comment works against your position as well😂....now read your comment again you will feel a bit off 🤣

@rcmysm9123

3 ай бұрын

The truth is never changing and your ridiculous incoherent responses just further condemn you.

@MightyG0RILLA

3 ай бұрын

@@jawadasgharrizvi1050 a very simple arguement, concept of Imamah is stupid, the imams are infalliable and also scared as hell.

@omer1340

3 ай бұрын

​@@MightyG0RILLAwhat? how is it stupid, how is having an infallible being on earth who protects Islam stupid?

@MightyG0RILLA

3 ай бұрын

@@omer1340 invincible and scared? All knowing but won't help even a fly? has all the power in the world but chooses to hide like a coward from the Abbassids? even after they all died?

This got me thinking. Is there a sahih hadith in Sunni teaching us step by step how to pray?

The real "Tahrif" is by you. When you try to make the ayah 5:55 look generalised to "those who believe" by comparing with previous ayah and subsequent ones in which "those who believe" is spoken about in general. The difference of 5:55 being that there is Specification mentioned for "those who believe" i.e (الذين) This Specification directs the meaning of "those who believe" to the one(s) who establishes prayer and pays charity while in ruku' (الذين يقيمون الصلواة ويوتون الزكواة و هم راكعون) Its a Clear difference. How more specific do you want the ayah to become. And your own tafasir books prove to you that the one mentioned in 5:55 is none other than Ali.

@HanaHana-ft9li

Ай бұрын

So your 12 imams are the “believers” in the Quran wow. Your immas have total knowledge how can they be called believers? Belief requires you to believe in someone you never seen. So the term believers don’t apply to your stupid aqeda. Your immas are rejectors of the Quran who made up beliefs and innovations like the mutazila

@saadsalman4518

16 күн бұрын

Really? Is even a response?

It seems like proving Imamah down the line is an exponential equation increasing with difficulty...

Hey umari prove ur umàri religion

Hi Sunnah Discourse Where is your rest of responses. Are you hiding away.

Well then tell me the 12 caliphs mentioned in the Sunni literature?

@iMan-610

3 ай бұрын

Sunni literature doesnt says 12 Caliphs are infallible or from Ahlulbayt only

@12345sincara

3 ай бұрын

Tell us your 12 caliphs yallah HAHAHA

What Ammar meant with Hadith Al Ghadir , is that the mawla in this context refers to Quran (33:6) : “ The prophet have more authority(awla) over the believers than themselves “ . This verse proves the authority of the prophet and the obligation of the obedience to the prophet as the tafaseer of the bakris say . So it’s clear that the word mawla is used in the meaning of awla as the prophets asked “don’t I have more authority over the believers “ ? What furthers reinforces this is the fact that the prophet used exact the same terminology in sahih Al bukhari 4781 -> 1.The prophet used the word awla for his authority 2. He used the word mawla because of this authority

@noface9375

3 ай бұрын

You know that similar words can have different meaning, on different occasions, depending on the context right? This is common knowledge, and it's known as a "homonym." So unfortunately 4 u & Nakhjawoni, that argument is not going to fly.

😂😂😂... Rafhidis always recycled their already rebutted arguments. It's like listening to a broken record now... 😃

@jawadasgharrizvi1050

3 ай бұрын

Same as the nawasib...I agree!! 🤣

@noface9375

3 ай бұрын

​@@jawadasgharrizvi1050Which is the Shia.

@jawadasgharrizvi1050

3 ай бұрын

@@noface9375 Indeed you a true it's the shia....of muawiya 🤣

@abumuhammad6978

3 ай бұрын

@@jawadasgharrizvi1050 Ghadeer is non-argument any longer. Keep repeating makes you look like a broken record. So, what's the same? 😃 What nawasib? We love Ali. Unlike you, OBSESSED... 😏

@noface9375

3 ай бұрын

​@@jawadasgharrizvi1050Shia of Abdullah ibn Saba.

Bro in the last part there is a chain of narrators up🤦‍♂️

3:28 "ibn kuthayr"

@TheFaro2011

3 ай бұрын

Lol his reading is unbelievable. The way he reads English and puts on stressors is so grating

@justanotherman1114

3 ай бұрын

That can be one reason why their hadiths are rejected.

alhumdulillah I was born as a Shia. man spoke for 35 mins and nothing was said. i can show ammar this but doesnt do it ill leave it for someone more knowledgeable. akhi u got shut down by abu mukhtar and now u wanna come here talking about this. u dont have the knowledge to be speaking like this. dont embarrass urself

@masteronmace

Ай бұрын

he debated abu mukhtar? where is the video? i wanna see abu mukhtar crush this umari

he killed me when he said ibn "kuthair"

This the guy that got cooked by Hassan Allahyari?😂😂

*Grade: Daif.* I like that shot.

What is the difference between Israel Zionists vs. Arab Sunni Zionist???

@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul

3 ай бұрын

There are 10x more supporter of Israel in Iran Watch the video of sunnah discourse "Iran stand with Israel"

@zayn6725

3 ай бұрын

What does that have to do with the veracity of Sunni Islam? Your committing a logical fallacy.

@Farhadmusic29

3 ай бұрын

@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul right now, most of the Sunni governments are supporting Israel...

@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul

3 ай бұрын

@@Farhadmusic29 none is supporting

@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul

3 ай бұрын

@@Farhadmusic29 the only thing is that they are not boycotting

Stop that nauseating giggle every 5mins brother. Just focus on your counter argument. Leave the silly and childish antics

Not the best i have to admit super omar 🤔 did pickysealion really get you with trying to find a virtue 😂

Salams, 1. According to the Qur'an, what's your definition of the word "Mawla"? Sayyed Ammar uses the Qur'an (5:55) (66:4) to define it in his argument that it is a guardian or an authority. Does the Quran ever define the word Mawla as "friend"? 2. I Agree with you on (5:55) that the word transfer is not there, but you're using that as a straw man argument to avoid the main crux of the ayah. Guardianship belongs to certain entities. You didn't explain the presence of the second ٱلَّذِينَ in وَرَسُولُهُۥ وَٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ ٱلَّذِينَ That is important because the Qur'an is talking about specific people that are of the believers. The important thing is that these specific people exist where their Mawla is placed with a weight in terms of God and His Messenger. 2. (66:8) فَإِنَّ ٱللَّهَ هُوَ مَوْلَىٰهُ وَجِبْرِيلُ وَصَـٰلِحُ ٱلْمُؤْمِنِينَ ۖ وَٱلْمَلَـٰٓئِكَةُ بَعْدَ ذَٰلِكَ ظَهِيرٌ... You forgot the words: بَعْدَ ذَٰلِكَ ظَهِيرٌ in your tafsir explanation That phrase is pretty important when describing Gabriel, the righteous believers, and angels as "his supporters". In arabic grammer, those entities belong to "his supporters", not to "Mawla". 3. Place the Sunni and Shia Tafsirs of (5:67). The Sunni Tafsir is never given in this video. The Shia tafsir makes more sense when you place both arguments side by side. 4. If the religion is perfect (5:3), then what is Ahlul-Sunnah's plan for the Prophet's Succession? Surely a perfect religion would have a plan after the Prophet (pbuh), correct?

@JN-eq3gl

3 ай бұрын

Sunni discourse is a source of misguidance. I don't know how they lie to themselves, I swear.

@IBRAHIMMURATOZBULUT-ce7cp

3 ай бұрын

About 4, they worship to feeling of “Islammess”, their name has been given to them by Muawiya (l.a). Most Sunnis simply don’t care about the actual concepts of religion, they distort the book of Allah to rule for Him at Earth, nothing more. What can you expect from this people. The guy is talking about “proving” İmamet as a literal math equation.

@iMan-610

3 ай бұрын

A perfected and completed religion doesnt need additional things after Quran and Sunnah of Prophet a.s..

@JN-eq3gl

3 ай бұрын

@@iMan-610 true. It also doesn't need the sunnah of the shaikhain.

@IBRAHIMMURATOZBULUT-ce7cp

3 ай бұрын

@@iMan-610 Is that so, is that is why 1000 Sunni schools exists. If you and you Salaf exactly know what Quran is, why do you have infighting. Why your Shayhayns and such had differing rules and differing ways of not only ruling, but being elected as well (i for my life cannot understand this election thing, if your Sahaba exactly knew what Quran wanted from them, why is there a need for election process anyway, I guess the Sunni God is thinking things through while the election is in process.) Why does Quran points towards the “Ahlul Zikr” if all Muslims know exactly what is what by “Quran and Sunnah of the Prophet”, why do you include in your rulings your injust Sahaba’s decisions. The truth is, you call what Quran wants an additional thing. The Quran calls for obedience towards the holy Prophet for example. By obeying “Quran and Sunnah”, you are obeying your understanding of what has been passed down to you, I will tell you why, because your Salaf and Sahaba distorted the Book of God with their interpretations. You yourself disregarded Book of God, you yourself disregarded Sunnah of the Prophet of God (s.a.a). I know the circles of Sunnis, they made Quran almost linguistical problem, even though God himself says that he does not lead injust to a good place, they are not concerned with making their studies as just as possible but learning Arabic and such. Unlike Sunnism perfected religion does not make people submit to killers and thiefs, but makes people submit to Prophet (s.a.a), perfected religion does not command one to disobey God and His Prophet in the name of “Islam”, unlike Sunnism and its khalifats, perfected religion is not democratic but comes from holy order of God, perfected religion calls towards the justice and superior ethics and not the “political good of Muslims”, since perfected religion is firstly associated with the relationship of man with his God, and not the earthly concerns. And the Love of Ahlulbayt is an additional thing for you and your religion of Muawiya (l.a), not for us, not for God’s Prophet.

is the second half w ur mahdi 😂😂😂

Bro is so dumb to not understand that the word "transfer" used by Ammar is to make the viewers understand that Guardianship (wilaya) is been mentioned in the Quran for Wilayah of Allah over the people AND that of Prophets wilaya over the Believers.

Since I left shiism, I’ve seen alot of people leaving this cult. It’s a great blessing, keep up with these videos.

@abumuhammad6978

3 ай бұрын

Alhamdulillah...

@nyeeunfa8487

3 ай бұрын

Allahumma Barik. Keep istiqomah brother. May Allah bless u ❤

@rcmysm9123

3 ай бұрын

You can lie to yourself and others but you can't lie to Allah swt.

@justanotherman1114

3 ай бұрын

Are you from subcontient or arab world? Can you tell us what was the thing that made you realize that shiism is false?

@rcmysm9123

3 ай бұрын

@@justanotherman1114 Shaitan

Why was ammer nakshawani add family when Allah is speaking to the prophet saw?

@imanz4718

3 ай бұрын

Respect is saying alayhi salaam, loving them, teaching our youth how they were among the best..this what Amman did is not respect, its manipulation and academic insincerity. Is it respectful to the ahlulbait to add extra words to the Quran (the most perfect of words, a direct revelation from out Lord)..and then change the entire meaning of the ayah, pushing a narrative which isn't even hinted ..?

did you ever heard of a term called mutawatir??? 😂 even if he chain is weak it is still authentic because of the coobrating evidences almost like 15 to 20 chains

Super umar 🐐🏔️💨

29:04 I can’t stop laughing 😭😭💀

Approach should be changed. Instead always sunnis answering their allegation now time to put them on the spot. Ask them about the mistakes of their imams as per their books. And debunk their infallibility. Tell the rafidis if infallible can these mistakes then our fallible imams are better at least they don't claim themselves to be infallible

@StoryBuffett

3 ай бұрын

Exactly, brother

@bashar4550

3 ай бұрын

They don't care about mistakes of imams or authenticity of their books even Quran as long as one say Yaaa Ali madad mola Ali madad you are good. Basically most of them are ignorant and they dont care. I am sure shia only listening to nakshwani to give him support they never understand the actual argumentation as they don't care.

@nyeeunfa8487

3 ай бұрын

Agree

Oh yeah the thirmidhi hadith about the awla may be weak, but lets not forget Musnad ahmed ibn hanbal hadith 18479: “الستم تعلمون أني أولى بجميع المؤمنين من أنفسهم؟ من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه. فقال عمر، هنياً يا ابن ابي طالب، اصبحت وامسيت مولاه كل مومنٍٍ و المومنة” “Do you not know that I have more right over all believers than they have over themselves? Whoever I am his master, then Ali is his master. Omar said: Congratulations, son of Abi Talib. You have become and are the masters of every believer, male and female, in the morning and evening” (2) (2) صحيح Sound Here Omar ibn al khattab congratulates Ali and in other words pledging allegiance and not only that in the books al ghazali page 483 there omar says بخ بخ which is a term for pledging allegiance. And there you have it and in history of the khalifahs the narration is up top.😊 ahmad narrated from abu tufail

جزاكم الله خيرا ❤

Given the choice to follow AhlulBait and Rasool Allah alahummasallealaa wa ahlehi, And non AhlulBait and others, I would blindly stand with my Muhammad salawaath and His Ahlulbait salawaath than even fathom to stand with the rest of the universe. That’s my Yaqeen of each moment of my very existence. Please, stop lying and being a miscreant amongst the people!

Assalamulaikum please please make a detailed video about the incident of Hafsa ra , Aisha ra and Maria ra.

😂Must go Again to debate Hassan Allahyari only this man can help you under my think! The Tahrif Quran munazra Available on internet Hassan Allahyari

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Up😊

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Upppp

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Upppppp

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Uppppppppp🎉

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Pin 📌

yo self pro claimed person telling us whom to beleive......just go and get a degree to have some knowledge

What a conceited refutation. If Imam tattoe dropped the ball so did this guy

FROM SOMALIA🇸🇴🇸🇴THIS CHANNEL ONLY IS MAKING US TO BECOME SHIA BECAUSE WE ARE SEEing The Truth of shiism we didnt new ..Alhamdulillah i have to visit Ammar Nakshawani channel to know tje Real truth of the two sects❤

@notgotnameyet

2 ай бұрын

Liar. All Somalis knows shia is a shirk religion

Just a reminder: just because a hadith is «Da’if» doesnt mean its not true.

@TheIntrepid-tz4zo

3 ай бұрын

Yeah not surprised comimg from a shia, sure.

@TheIntrepid-tz4zo

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 not surprised about the fact that if i make up a hadith and put it in a book you guys will consider it true because you guys don't even care about the authenticity of the hadith. Anything that follows your narrative and made up fabrications = true and authentic. So that's an easy job for any layman to do.

@TheIntrepid-tz4zo

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 Oh sure a guy that comments on youtube is now telling me that my books need an evaluation yes mr. Muhadith as you say. Since you are a scholar your opinion is so valid. It is you who has spent years on these books. Ofc you are right. Buahahahahahahahahh so helpless !!!! So damn helpless!!! Also no they are not just "sahih" nothing is ever sahih or hasan or strong hadith until proven but again shi'tism doesn't have the concept of that.

@captainrtf

3 ай бұрын

@@TheIntrepid-tz4zoHe is only telling you to read and research your books. For God sake, you guys should learn, read your books and use the Goddamn brains Allah has given you. Period!

@TheIntrepid-tz4zo

3 ай бұрын

@@captainrtf i read my books Alhamdulilah. If there's someone who needs to use their brain it is you Rawafidh people. Wassalam.

According to super omar the prophet muhammad taught us how to do hot steamy stuff with our wives, he taught us how to eat, how to use our hands properly, what way we should pray namaz, how to take a shower, all of this yet he forgot to appoint a leader for Muslims to follow to not go astray

@omarismaeel7838

18 күн бұрын

He did. It was Abu bakr as he was the most superior of the sahaba.

@masteronmace

18 күн бұрын

@@omarismaeel7838 proof?

32:03 oh my god sooo embarrassingggg 💀💀💀💀

Nice try bro but just be quite and hold the L

23:42 - so hang on.. the dude who narrated it became Shia, and so it was retroactively considered weak? Hmmmmmmmm Not suspicious at all ☠️

@afrabinte2458

3 ай бұрын

Who became shia? What's the reference of your statement? Even if this is true then what's so suspicious about it? Don't you know that sunnis don't accept shia narrator and vice versa? Do shias accept sunni narrator and consider the Hadith authentic? You gone crazy 😧

@Eggwrath

3 ай бұрын

@@afrabinte2458 isn’t that what it said in arabic? “Tashaya3”? I guess my question is was it considered weak originally by the person who took the Hadith? Or was it only considered retroactively Because if it’s the second, then that’s a big problem. It just means that any sahih Hadith can be retrofitted and considered weak if it doesn’t align with someone’s interests

@afrabinte2458

3 ай бұрын

@@Eggwrath bro it’s not about the authenticity of the hadith only. Even if you consider these hadith as authentic then there’s no problem cause we Sunnis already believe in the content of these hadith. We just don’t believe that maula means divine authority here. The reasons are mentioned in another video in their playlist, you can check that out. Therefore it’s never a problem for us if we accept the hadith.

@Eggwrath

3 ай бұрын

@@afrabinte2458in the video he’s saying the argument is weak because the Hadith is weak… My question is about the logic behind calling the Hadith weak

@afrabinte2458

3 ай бұрын

@@Eggwrath he told why the Hadith is weak.

Abdullah ibn Saba (la) = the founder

From 7:07~ 7:36 We finally get to see what Shia think like... Ammar exposed their beliefs openly 🙄 Ammar interpreted the meaning as Ally, then added "Governance" & "PRIORITY" THEN made a great claim of *TRANSFER* 😨😨 Welaia does not "transfer" that is pure SHIRK 🤦🏻‍♂(meaning God no longer has it) because it was transferred to the prophet !!!!!!! The prophet was sent to give priority to Allah ALONE, a messenger does not speak of his own~ rather its commanding what Allah commands ALLYING ONES SELF ACCORDING TO WHAT ALLAH REVEALS Even the verse CONTEXT details some commandments! Praying & Zakat ! إِنَّمَا وَلِيُّكُمُ اللَّهُ وَرَسُولُهُ وَالَّذِينَ آمَنُوا الَّذِينَ يُقِيمُونَ الصَّلَاةَ وَيُؤْتُونَ الزَّكَاةَ وَهُمْ رَاكِعُونَ (55) Notice Different degrees of "Welaia" is appointed by God hence he stated God reveals command you need to ally yourself to (ان تنصروا الله ينصركم) WORK HIS COMMANDMENTS The messenger convey the command (lead by example) you have to adhere to The believers grab hold firmly to commands apply them as shown & advice one another based on it.. The prophet does NOT make commandments, nor the believers! what kind of religion is that?

@rcmysm9123

3 ай бұрын

This is pathetic, try harder.

MashaAllah keep it up

We need to stop defending Sunni Islam from these lying Shia and start attacking their false beliefs. Ask these Shia why they have authentic hadiths from their own Imams claiming they don't know who the next Imam is. If they're all-knowing like they claim then why do we have multiple hadiths from Jafar As Sadiq saying he didn't know who the next Imam was going to be until late into his life.

@rcmysm9123

3 ай бұрын

All you do is attack, you can't actually respond because the evidence is irrefutable. Alhamdulillah!

@omer1340

3 ай бұрын

no Shia claims they are all knowing apart from ghulaat

@aslanali819

3 ай бұрын

​@@omer1340 But their most authentic book says they're all knowing. (It has been narrated) from Abu Abdullah (a.s.) having said: ‘The Imam, whenever he desires that he knows (something), knows (it). Al Kafi Vol 1 - The Book Of Divine Authority -- H 661 CH 46 H 1 (It has been narrated) from Musa (a.s.) who has said the following. "The totality of our knowledge is of three aspects. Knowledge of the past, future and that coming into being. Al Kafi Vol 1 - The Book Of Divine Authority -- H 681 CH 50 H 1 This is a part of a long narration found in al kafi, Ali (r.a) is saying this supposedly. "I have been given certain distinctions which, are given to no one before me. I was taught all about the deaths, the sufferings, the genealogy of people and clear speech. I have not missed any of the knowledge that have passed me by and nothing of the future is unseen or unknown to me" Al Kafi Vol 1 - The Book Of Divine Authority -- H 502 CH 14 H 2

@azimshah-gw4dv

3 ай бұрын

@@omer1340​​⁠the next imam knows that he is the chosen imam at the last minute of the life of the preceding imam. Then how come u were divided into ismaelis and zayyedies what was the big confusion about, why do u have different imams in different sects, what was so difficult for the next imams to realize that he was the actual imam and not cause divisions. If they were divinely guided and infallible he would know he is the imam to be chosen, but ur most authentic books like Al kafi shows that they didn’t even know they were the imams. Neither did they know who the next one is.

@masteronmace

2 ай бұрын

Because the Abbasids were literally persecuting the Shia lol, the Imams had to be careful with publicly revealing who would actually be the Imam. Actually study history you jahil

amazing bu noor!!! again i do not think shias even know what a sanad or isnad is. I don't think they have the concept of weak chain, strong chain. Shiism wouldn't exist if that would have been the case and yes you did your best to show how ammar is incapable of making valid arguements. 👏🏻👏🏻

Even if we try listening to their arguments about the proof of imamah, especially from the Qur'an, we still are not satisfied with their understanding.

Ammar can only attack the sahaba but he can’t prove 12 imams 🥱🤧🤭

I’m only 7 minutes in, what the hell is this guy talking about? The wilayat of Allah can be transferred? What blasphemy is this? Allah is ALWAYS our Guardian, His Guardianship is never transferred.

🤣Ahle sunat have bhukri book it is made after the death of prophet Muhammad s.a 200+ years ago 😂 Shia Have a book Called Sulaim ibn Qas hilali which is wriiten after the death of prophet instantly in the Time of Hazrat Ali r.a.z, Now hence proved Shia have more Authenticity then Ahlesunnat If you wanf hadees of pray of Prophet Muhammad why not 😂 you read Sulim book must do debate again to Hassan Allahyari they will gave you right Guidence, May Allah help you to choose the right path The road of Ahlebait-e-Rasool s.a peace ✌🏻

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Pinnmn📌

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Pinnnnnn📌

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Upup

@hi-mq3gb

3 ай бұрын

Upupup

"Game over" 😂

PhD in acting 😂😂😂

"peace be upon his family" Skipping him Peace be upon him. But hey, what can you expect from those satanic creatures who in many instances just replace Allah with Ali. Their words have no worth to me whatsoever.

@jawadasgharrizvi1050

3 ай бұрын

Do justice atleast in the month of ramadan...he must have slipped....he has about 20+ video check all the videos and how every time he takes the name Of RasoolAllah SAWW he says the full durood and there might some instances in which he may have forgotten...WHEREAS CHECK ONLY THE RESPONSE VIDEOS YOUR PEOPLE AND SEE HOW MANY TIME THEY INCLUDE THE PROGENY IN THE DUROOD.... DISCLAIMER...none of the time....this is the proof against nawasib... And how many times you your self say....sallallahu alyhi...Wa Aalihi wasallum??? According to you it is not important to include the progeny and sideline them!!!

@respectthemanthatchangesfo760

3 ай бұрын

​​@@jawadasgharrizvi1050please spare me with the selectieve morality, I will not be guilt tripped on. Isn't this dude doing his attack series in Ramadan? I can point out what I noticed without being a cherry picker. One comment and you fill in the blanks to your heart's content.. Wow like you know me. Not

@jawadasgharrizvi1050

3 ай бұрын

@@respectthemanthatchangesfo760 so you conceded that generally the ahlus sunna...do no include the progeny in their durood and they just say "sallallahu alaihi wasallam" rather than "sallallahu alaihi wa'aalihi wasallam"....and what about you do you not say just "sallallahu alaihi wasallam"? Secondly, he is not attacking anybody...he is just providing evidence to the shia-sunni for the things we believe in from the books of our opponents....and we do not need explicit evidence from the books of our opponents just supporting evidence.... If you feel he's right then accept otherwise reject!! Nobody is forcing anyone shoving our stance down their throat!!! Also the best refutation would be to ask your people not to watch him! 😂 May Allah guide us all! Was-salamu Alykum

@respectthemanthatchangesfo760

3 ай бұрын

​@@jawadasgharrizvi1050What trickery is this? "So you conceded" No, I just ignored the rest of the noise. I will not let my time and energy be hijacked. I will just ignore you from now on

@jawadasgharrizvi1050

3 ай бұрын

@@respectthemanthatchangesfo760 Everyone know what this mean! 😂 Fi amaanillah!

The Infallible divinely appointed Imam couldnt overcome fallible men from snatching away his Viloyat/Imamat ??????

@soujurix7979

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 So the Messenger صلى الله عليه و سلم allowed his 'infallible' daughter to be physically opressed by Fallible Men???? Your cult has shaky foundations.......

@soujurix7979

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 Are you denying that according to your sect, The Prophet had knowledge of the future & unseen ????? Look whose stupid now

@soujurix7979

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 Yeah Mister, your're only good using the word 'STRAWMANNING'

@soujurix7979

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 Dude, dont you have better things to do instead of spamming other people's comments ?????

@soujurix7979

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 You want a response Ya Raafidi. Your matam-laden cult protrays the Prophet as only spending 23 years of his noble life to be with people who would oppose him and his family ! Did Allah order His Prophet to make such people as his companions ???? How is this patience ?????

Hammar not Ammar

@Historylover140

7 сағат бұрын

Thanks for making fun of Ammar the sahabi of rasul (ra)😂

Fail again

Ammar 1 : wahabis 0

Some of the problems I have with sunni theology, if someone can solve these for me I’d appreciate it, just for my own knowledge. -where are the Hadiths in sunni books from Jafar Al-Sadiq? -what is the justification for the hadiths in this video being weak? As a Shia, all that looks like to me is convenient whitewashing. -why do Sunnis pray like Sumerian idol worshippers (with hands folded- where did that come from?) -need explanation on why every Sahabi is considered good -need to know, in the first few hundred years after the prophet, where the affinity for Ahlulbayt was. No affinity in the ummah is highly highly suspicious to me, because that means corruption in Hadith books is imminent. This is not meant to be inflammatory, just genuinely haven’t seen these questions properly answered without historical whitewashing For me, the Islamic empire leaving Ahlulbayt for first few hundred years is HIGHLY problematic, especially when it’s that same ummah who formed the what we call Ahlul Sunnah today. The Ahlulbayt being neglected in the Hadith corpus despite all of the “imams” being recognized as the greatest scholars of their time is probably the most suspicious thing in Islamic history and I haven’t been able to resolve this problem.

@abumuhammad6978

3 ай бұрын

You've been brainwashed too hard. Pity. All your "imams" were recognized as greatest scholars? What have you been drinking. Some of them, yes. But all them?... hmmm

@Eggwrath

3 ай бұрын

@@abumuhammad6978 I didn’t throw a single insult and you’re already starting this. What’s the point of this channel? Just to talk in a sunni bubble? Or is it DISCOURSE? Which of the 12 imams do YOU recognize as having had immense knowledge?

@Spined1234

3 ай бұрын

Maybe you can answer me why there are multiple authentic hadiths from the Imams claiming they didn't know who the next Imam was going to be? We have multiple narrations from Jafar As Sadiq stating he didn't know who the next Imam was going to be until late into his life. Don't the Shia believe their Imams are all knowing?

@Eggwrath

3 ай бұрын

@@Spined1234 I am fine answering questions but this isn’t really about me justifying my own beliefs I’m just expressing what turns me off from your sect. You’ll gladly do dawah to Christian’s and athiests and then be combative with someone who says the shahadatayn… If you had an ounce of intellectual honesty you wouldn’t attack someone who isn’t attacking you. I posed questions, as someone from the outside If you don’t want or don’t have enough knowledge to answer, then the post isn’t for you, please let someone else talk to me. I’m not going to debate in this thread, I just want to be preached at basically.

@afrabinte2458

3 ай бұрын

Listen brother, if you just want to debate then there's nothing to say except for may Allah guide you. And if you're really sincere to know the truth, then read the meaning of Quran without any tafsir, neither shia nor sunni. Just the meaning. And check out if you find the foundational beliefs of shiaism in Quran. Not just the word "imamah" or not the appointment of previous prophets. Find out any clear verse (not unclear text) about the divine appointment of the progeny of rasul sws, find out the infallibility of the family of rasul sws, find out what Allah said about the knowledge of unseen, about how to invoke Him, about the authority of world and hereafter, about the nature of the shirk of the arabs And then get back to shia and sunni Hadith then check out which side contradicts with the clear verses of Quran? Which side resembles the actions of mushriks stated in the Quran? Allah won't ask you about the fabrication of Hadith. Allah will ask you about quran, about the foundation of Deen. May Allah guide you

Nakhjavani the PHD holder got shot by the Word ضعبف

Shaykh Mufid in kitaab al irshad admits the reason for ghadir khum, namely the journey in Yemen and the discontent of the companions of Ali ra

Be quite he living in your head rent free

Allah revealed the Qur’an, thought us about everything, even the menstrual period of women, but NOTHING on IMAMAH, a core belief of the Shia?????

@masteronmace

Ай бұрын

Prophet told Sunnism how to do hot steamy romance, how to eat, sit down and pee, but he forgot to appoint a leader after him?

@hermanvanvliet1276

Ай бұрын

@@masteronmace So basically you can’t answer the question, instead you ask another question? Does that really sound convincing to you? There are plenty indication that the Prophet gave instructions on the leadership. Such as, the leadership should remain within Quraysh. Back to Shi’ism. Menstrual period is mentioned in the QURAN, but Imamah is absent?

@masteronmace

Ай бұрын

@@hermanvanvliet1276 No lol Imamate is in the Quran. God made Prophet Abraham an Imam after making him a Prophet. Look up Imamate in the Quran and try to actually learn the Shia perspective

@hermanvanvliet1276

Ай бұрын

@@masteronmace not true. That isn’t about Ny concept, simply stated that he was made a role model to be followed. Like we follow him today during animal sacrifice, Hajj etc. If you read the Qur’an, you will find more verses about people being named imams / a’immah, which again has nothing to do with the imaginary Shi’i concept. Take for example: Quran 32:24 We raised from among them leaders, guiding by Our command, when they patiently endured and firmly believed in Our signs. Or Quran 28:5 But it was Our Will to favour those who were oppressed in the land, making them models ˹of faith˺ as well as successors; Does that mean all children of Israel were made infallible imams? Of course not! Read the Qur’an with a rational understanding and you certainly will Know nothing, absolutely nothing is there to be found about these Shi’i concepts.

@masteronmace

Ай бұрын

@@hermanvanvliet1276 You’re reading the Ibn Kathir exegesis of the Quran. Sunni fiqh translates imamah as nothing more than a leader. Obviously if you rely on the Sunni madhhab that’s all you’re going to get. But let me ask you this, what’s a role model? It’s someone whose standard and character is the model of Islam right? Anyways, Ibn Kathir isn’t Ahlulbayt. He isn’t Rasulallah’s family. Ibn Kathir isn’t the teacher of the teachers of the Sunni madhhabs. He has zero right to provide his own interpretation of Allah’s book because he isn’t the appointed authority figure as Surah Nisa says. Right there in the Quran it clearly says Imamate many times. Not to mention, Prophet Ibrahim was already a Prophet at the time and place of this statement. You gotta think outside of your own madhhab and belief system and look at the bigger picture only then can we properly explain both our sides without going into baseless baby crying

As a Shia this is embarrassing to us that Sayed Ammar N has yet to accept any of the Sunnis challenge to debate. Great Video! May Ali reward you!!

@Numeral0

3 ай бұрын

but Ali is dead 🤔

@mhmd1854

3 ай бұрын

Sunni pretending to be shia spotted, no shia say Ali reward you, what al liar 🤣🤣🤣

@mhmd1854

3 ай бұрын

@@RUNESCAPER123 This bakri is plainly lying, he is is saying "may Ali reward you" no shia says so 🤣🤣🤣