Remanding A Person To Police Custody On Mere Suspicion Is Incompatible With Constitutional Principle

#livelaw #supremecourtjudges #law #legal #lawstudents #lawyers #kapilsibal
LiveLaw brings you the latest legal news and updates from India and beyond.
We are into fact based legal journalism.
Endeavour of LiveLaw is to play an active role for a transparent and democratic legal ecosystem, in the larger public interest.
This video is an intellectual property belonging to LiveLaw Media Pvt Ltd. Any unauthorised usage of this video/script in any format is prohibited and will be subject to prosecution.
Stay updated. Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2pskgB3
Support Us: bit.ly/35qFj6A
Visit Our Website: www.livelaw.in/
hindi.livelaw.in
Facebook: / livelawindia
/ livelawhindi
Twitter: / livelawindia
/ livelawh
Instagram: / livelaw.in
/ livelawhindi
Linkedin: / livelaw
/ livelaw-hindi
Live Law app is India's fastest legal news app that will keep you updated on the latest law/legal news from India and across the world. Download now.
Android: bit.ly/2toaimp
iOS: apple.co/39dQ0vh

Пікірлер: 117

  • @mariafernandes6486
    @mariafernandes64864 ай бұрын

    Thank you Kapil Sibalji for being a beacon in the darkness. Generations will remember you in ages to come.

  • @kmochhary6160
    @kmochhary61604 ай бұрын

    Sr.Supreme Court s Adv.Kapil Sibal is making an excellent.analysis of some relevant legal provisions which directly affect the common people.

  • @tanapuia5144
    @tanapuia51444 ай бұрын

    Kapil Sibal is a great man. Long live Kapil Sibal so that you can serve the people of India in need of help in the court.

  • @legalknowledge1922
    @legalknowledge19224 ай бұрын

    Thank you so must sir for Opening eyes of youth lawyers and the citizens of India.🙏

  • @shoebansari2002
    @shoebansari20024 ай бұрын

    What an excellent speech sir ji

  • @fizani.husain.advocate5623
    @fizani.husain.advocate56234 ай бұрын

    Remarkable Sibal sir...u nail it well...thr shud be different laws to arrest for economic n petty offences...and Death n grievous offences...its time to bring a drastic change # Ld CJI...our country is going thru a very pathetic phase😢😢

  • @indratantiatantia-wp5ql
    @indratantiatantia-wp5ql4 ай бұрын

    I fully agree and appreciate your struggle .you're a legend undoubtedly in your professional field .your service to the nation is remarkable .satyamev jayate .jai hind .Vande mataram .

  • @avgopalan2761
    @avgopalan27614 ай бұрын

    Absolutely, I like your statement that, lawyers who ever you are, you should speak law…you should interpret law in such clarity that, no public can point out you, that you are an Opposition Lawyer…or you are a Ruling party lawyer.!! Unfortunately in our today’s India, what is our Solicitor General talking..??? Is he not a public servant, paid by tax payers money,???

  • @AnandKumar-ct1vk
    @AnandKumar-ct1vk4 ай бұрын

    Thank you Mr. Prant Bhushan and Kapil Sibal ji for ur efforts in protecting the "Democracy" of this nation,

  • @prasadmulupuri8714
    @prasadmulupuri87143 күн бұрын

    Kapilji has raised a wonderful point. How can you arrest somebody only on suspicion without any evidence and call the act constitutional? Such law which sanctions such an act has to be scrapped.

  • @BUY_YT_Views_858
    @BUY_YT_Views_8584 ай бұрын

    I can't resist sharing this with my friends. They'll love it!

  • @sankarbasu8524
    @sankarbasu85244 ай бұрын

    Thanks to Mr. KAPILji for rising to the occassion to save the country & its people,

  • @sachinwankhade5797
    @sachinwankhade57974 ай бұрын

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Superb Sir

  • @bijayanayak5992
    @bijayanayak59924 ай бұрын

    Well done Sibal ji for enlightening the citizens!

  • @lourencogoncalves5726
    @lourencogoncalves57264 ай бұрын

    I Salute You Kapil Sibal SIr ji

  • @pinakichakraborty7596
    @pinakichakraborty75964 ай бұрын

    Honourable Kapil Sibbal Sir is making a revolutionary step-out against the unconstitutional, draconian and fundamental rights snatching law. We people of India will remember you as the saviour of human freedom from the clutches of a demon. But you should take it to the supreme court. But why supreme court is keeping silence in this case while supreme court is there to safeguard the constitution and fundamental rights of people.

  • @ckaggarwal3436
    @ckaggarwal34364 ай бұрын

    Respected Sh.Kapil Sibal ji, THE GENESIS OF LAW AS MADE BY YOUR GOODSELF IS REALLY EDUCATIVE FOR PEOPLE DOWN THE STAIRS. BUT IRONY BEING, AT THIS BELATED STAGE OF POST 75 YEARS OF INDEPENDENE, AS TO HOW , THE GOVERNMENTS IN POWER DURING THIS LONG JOURNEY FAILED TO AMEND THE LAW IN CAMPATGIBLE TO OUR CONSTITUTION , ALSO, AT PRESENT, WHETHER ANY FUTURE GOVT TO BE IN POWER THE POLITICAL PARTIES, EVER INCLUDE IN IT IN THEIR MANIFESTO !!!!

  • @rssiddharth3134
    @rssiddharth31344 ай бұрын

    Hope, learned friend Mr.Ravi Prasad is listening to this speech...

  • @kuchbhi_kidhrbhi
    @kuchbhi_kidhrbhi4 ай бұрын

    The greatest personality as a lawyer I know only is Kapil sibal

  • @mb-ct8zk

    @mb-ct8zk

    4 ай бұрын

    😢His lawyer for rioters people who do j!ad against hndus

  • @mindtrekkerr

    @mindtrekkerr

    4 ай бұрын

    Advocate of most corrupt politicians

  • @kuchbhi_kidhrbhi

    @kuchbhi_kidhrbhi

    4 ай бұрын

    @@mindtrekkerr advocate have only task to protect his client

  • @shivajiraut31
    @shivajiraut314 ай бұрын

    nice analysis bhartiy nyasahinta 3 comming laws we salute all indian to adv sibal sir

  • @OnkarSingh-lq8ck
    @OnkarSingh-lq8ck4 ай бұрын

    Posterity will remember you for this analysis as well as for the speech. University professors please take note of all the facts, and nuances Advocate Sibal is raising, you have a lot to learn. Trial judge, learn from this speech.

  • @rajendhrana5883
    @rajendhrana58834 ай бұрын

    Kapil ji living legend of law iam proud to be a lawyer to hear your scintillating speech

  • @mohabat786
    @mohabat7864 ай бұрын

    Excellent sir, clearly explained

  • @ashok0429
    @ashok04294 ай бұрын

    Kapil ji , You made a very important point , “ it is un constitutional “ And , it is wrecking havoc on our polity .. Then .. Why has no one has approached supreme courts to render it fractuous ? Why don’t you take it sir ! 5:34

  • @chetansamariya8482
    @chetansamariya84824 ай бұрын

    Love to listen ❤️💐 eminent lawyer sibbal sir

  • @rohitsrivastava3229
    @rohitsrivastava32294 ай бұрын

    Sir, you raised valid questions of law, which was always there when you was in power to correct. Atleast, now challange or adopt procedure to correct.

  • @lourencogoncalves5726
    @lourencogoncalves57264 ай бұрын

    U have Superb questions to ask The relevant today's govt

  • @rajeswarayanamadala4820
    @rajeswarayanamadala48204 ай бұрын

    A good exposer to the basics of law. rightly pointed out lawyers roll. Lawyers forget integrity for earning for survival and takes active part in filing false cases.Court also misled and tow the line of prosecution.This is to corrected. Million doller question? If false cases are filtered, there is no need of more courts as i feel.

  • @lourencogoncalves5726
    @lourencogoncalves57264 ай бұрын

    Yes Kapil Sir you are dokngba great service to the People of Today India Kudos to You Sir ji

  • @gopalhembrom8242
    @gopalhembrom82424 ай бұрын

    Outstanding speech by Shri Kapil Sibal sirm

  • @biswanathbhandari7028
    @biswanathbhandari70284 ай бұрын

    These laws autocratically pushed through the empty houses of parliament are surely darker than darkness. They raise a serious question whether a brute manority is a licence for the formulation of laws that are evidently and incongrously incompatible with the basic charater and framework of the constitution. The bills before introducing in the parliament ought to be clarified and consented by the apex court to avoid any confusion or controversy.

  • @technologyinculator5677

    @technologyinculator5677

    4 ай бұрын

    This can't de done as law making mandate is given to parliament and judiciary interpretation of law. There should be some mechanism in the parliament itself to check , it can be submitted to select committee.

  • @biswanathbhandari7028

    @biswanathbhandari7028

    4 ай бұрын

    It is patently clear that the only motive behind these draconian laws leaving no space to personal freedom and right to an individual even no provision or privilege for bail is to convert the country into a police state. We see how the agencies are blatantly being used to demonise the voice of dissent and democracy. These laws passed without the least room for wider discussion or debates in the parliament or outside lack the required democratic decency and decorum.These are not improve.ents or refinements of colonial laws but more consolidation of thecolonial legacy of repression with more comprehensive provisions for coercions. These laws reflect the total absence of trust between the ruling regime and the common masses. The sovereignty and supremacy of the state must not be equated with the supremacy and sovereignty of the ruling regime representing only a part or segment or sect of the populace. Gandhi has warned us against this dangerous slide or trend long ago exercing his proverbial far sight and wisdom.

  • @arunfucqeer9154
    @arunfucqeer91544 ай бұрын

    CONGRATS!

  • @sushantkumar4255
    @sushantkumar42554 ай бұрын

    I support this initiative live law

  • @kirankarhadkar315
    @kirankarhadkar3154 ай бұрын

    Sir thanks for educating us on the constitutional rights in present scary situation

  • @AkhailAhmad
    @AkhailAhmad3 ай бұрын

    It's has been really powerful attention..very well versed, great

  • @vasolkar
    @vasolkar4 ай бұрын

    Excellent lecture on the New Law ... Thank you very much Mr Sibal for putting the light of wisdom on this important issue

  • @bhatmuneeb252
    @bhatmuneeb252Ай бұрын

    Stalwart of indian legal System ❤

  • @VijayKumar-bt4rq
    @VijayKumar-bt4rq4 ай бұрын

    “Protection Of Fundamental Rights” Contempt Or Misuse Of LAW Accountability Of Person, Agencies n Etc With Punishment In Same Capacity Of The Accused Faced, If Not Able To Prove.

  • @shyamnarayantiwari4336
    @shyamnarayantiwari43364 ай бұрын

    Excellent and eye opening

  • @rohanmishra4782
    @rohanmishra47824 ай бұрын

    Thank u Kapil Sibal Ji.

  • @betibachao-betipadhao3890
    @betibachao-betipadhao38904 ай бұрын

    Thank you so much sir. 🎉

  • @rajeswararaoganugula417
    @rajeswararaoganugula4174 ай бұрын

    A good attempt Layers throwing light on legal aspects, if police also tell about peoples' right it would be better.

  • @johnjoseph3622
    @johnjoseph36224 ай бұрын

    Please lawyers come out in large numbers.

  • @samikshatrivedi1866
    @samikshatrivedi18664 ай бұрын

    What is the solution?

  • @sureshkumartg
    @sureshkumartg4 ай бұрын

    Salute 🙏

  • @ruminderrandhawa8501
    @ruminderrandhawa85014 ай бұрын

    Lawers must play roll of nation building and updating people

  • @advocatesambhajipatildyspr6850
    @advocatesambhajipatildyspr68504 ай бұрын

    Respected sir has raised fundamental rights and basic flaws in new laws

  • @KhalidKhan-hu4qi
    @KhalidKhan-hu4qi4 ай бұрын

    Case of Aasif Sultan, a Kashmiri journalist Case of Sidheeq Kappan, Keralite Journalist Case of Dr. Kafeel Khan Case of Mufti Salman Azhari Case of Haldwani Violence, UttaraKhand

  • @ch.muhammadmaroofadvocateh5437
    @ch.muhammadmaroofadvocateh54374 ай бұрын

    ❤Very mice lecture Sir

  • @NAZIRAHMAD-ok9ot
    @NAZIRAHMAD-ok9ot4 ай бұрын

    Excellent thought.

  • @gangadhardas3573
    @gangadhardas35734 ай бұрын

    Excellent. But, Sir, I beg pardon if am found wrong, you were Hon'ble MInister of Law, Government of India and in the Parliament for years together, what steps you had taken to amend laws so perpetuated even after independence.

  • @architsinghal9006
    @architsinghal90064 ай бұрын

    It is completely unconstitutional we need to talk way more about it

  • @architsinghal9006
    @architsinghal90064 ай бұрын

    Also needs to be factored in - the shabby and below international standards investigation abilities of our agencies. All the more reason to have more than a shadow of doubt at the intension of the agencies to file under this law

  • @sandeepsinghsoni
    @sandeepsinghsoni4 ай бұрын

    Mr Sibbal was law minister and was in power for 10 years. He did not care to change it. Now he is feeling because he is not in POWER 😂😂😮😮

  • @akshayagrawal5114

    @akshayagrawal5114

    4 ай бұрын

    He is talking about the new law ,brought by bjp

  • @Joseph-pw1im
    @Joseph-pw1im3 ай бұрын

    Law stand for the betterment of people,every law created for that, but using it for opposite way

  • @lourencodafatimasouza1479
    @lourencodafatimasouza14794 ай бұрын

    Is there natural justice in the country?

  • @Mr551955
    @Mr5519554 ай бұрын

    👍👍🙏🙏❤️❤️

  • @parkarsingh9765
    @parkarsingh97654 ай бұрын

    सरकार पुलिस को शक्ति देने की बजाय दायित्वों का निर्वहन करने पर ध्यान दे ! तो मानव के सारे सवैधानिक अधिकार बचे रहेगे ।

  • @vijayanandtyagi5894
    @vijayanandtyagi58944 ай бұрын

    Sir crpc evidence act and IPC all sections distrub series off these acts by govt but no one has raised about this issue. While new sections can be insert and unwanted section can be deleted as in ordenery amendments made

  • @ashutoshtiwari3927
    @ashutoshtiwari3927Ай бұрын

    Has someone filed a PIL concerning the matter stated in the video? If not, then why hasn't Mr. Sibal filed one, given the knowledge he possess

  • @askr777
    @askr7774 ай бұрын

    Every law in this country is applicable and if necessary tweaked to the rich and the powerful to defend him to the fullest but nothing for the poor and the common men.

  • @chandankumarbanerjee7568
    @chandankumarbanerjee75684 ай бұрын

    IN THIS COUNTRY OF UNLIMITED CORRUPTION AND MISUSE OF OFFICIAL POSITION BY POLICE OFFICERS ALSO MANY INDUSTRY EXIST SUCH CALLED - LEGAL AATANKBAD U/S-498(A) OF IPC OF-₹35000/- CRORES INDUSTRY OF POLICE DEPARTMENT, JAIL DEPARTMENT, ADVOCATES AND COURT'S NEXSUS WITHOUT - INCOME TAX, GST, SURCHARGE, CELL ETC.

  • @lourencodafatimasouza1479
    @lourencodafatimasouza14794 ай бұрын

    Element of Common law of land is missing.

  • @cpssindia
    @cpssindia4 ай бұрын

    Who cares for constitution ? Who learns the lessons of the constitution? Who have faith in natural justice ?

  • @srinivasannarasimhan187
    @srinivasannarasimhan1874 ай бұрын

    Prolonging caaes with adjournment by learned council for want of money and asking for clemency.

  • @kuldipjain8268
    @kuldipjain82684 ай бұрын

    Spoken words are highly attractive and appreciable. But I am yet to find application of most proclaimed fundamental right of *Equality before Law*, as enshrined in our Constitution. An ordinary person with meagre finance can't dream of hiring services of a lawyer, as that of the stature of Speaker either in Supreme Court or any High Court. Invariably hefty fees are charged by renowned lawyers irrespective of the speech of Sh. Sibal Ji that legal profession is a service oriented and not money earning

  • @francisdias1991
    @francisdias19914 ай бұрын

    There is a rationale. In a Monarchy the ED does not require any reason to arrest you if ordered by the govt.

  • @yuvraaaaz
    @yuvraaaaz4 ай бұрын

    Mr Sibbal was law minister and was in power for 10 yrs. He did not care to change it ! Moreover he introduced draconian provision of IT Act . He is feeling the heat bcz he is no more in power . 🤣

  • @sandeepsinghsoni

    @sandeepsinghsoni

    4 ай бұрын

    💯 now he think about it😮😅

  • @sandeepsinghsoni

    @sandeepsinghsoni

    4 ай бұрын

    Mr Sibbal was law minister and was in power for 10 years. He did not care to change it. Now he is feeling because he is not in POWER 😂😂😮😮

  • @akshayagrawal5114

    @akshayagrawal5114

    4 ай бұрын

    ​@@sandeepsinghsoniCopy paste

  • @What-do-you-want824

    @What-do-you-want824

    4 ай бұрын

    He is talking about new law's .

  • @gaurishankarprasadgupta457
    @gaurishankarprasadgupta4574 ай бұрын

    देश में ही नहीं पूरे पृथ्वी पर एक मात्र संविधान के ज्ञाता बचे हैं जो जज को भी ज्ञान देते हैं

  • @Adv.Rahul_Chauhan
    @Adv.Rahul_Chauhan4 ай бұрын

    😳😳😳

  • @chandankumarbanerjee7568
    @chandankumarbanerjee75684 ай бұрын

    FOR ILLEGAL NOT FOLLOWING PROCEDURES OF LAW, RULES OF ARRESTING COMMON POOR MANS NO FINANCIAL COMPENSATION PROVIDED BY STATE GOVT. AND LEGAL ACTIONS AGAINST POLICE DEPARTMENT.

  • @Rahulyadav-lz8sx
    @Rahulyadav-lz8sx4 ай бұрын

    Cute sar

  • @MIDRaju
    @MIDRaju4 ай бұрын

    There can be no law that is incompatible with constituional principles. Then under which law such arrests are being made? That too on mere suspicion. And now who should prevents it?

  • @chandankumarbanerjee7568
    @chandankumarbanerjee75684 ай бұрын

    NOW THIS IS HIGH TIME TO BRING A COMPREHENSIVE DRAKUNIAL LAW CALLED- POLICE ADDROCITIES AND TORCHERS ACT IN THIS COUNTRY WHERE POLICE DEPARTMENT AND JAIL DEPARTMENT IS GREATER LAW VIOLATER IN THIS COUNTRY.

  • @drgayasmakhdumi7067
    @drgayasmakhdumi70674 ай бұрын

    Can it go to the common man in Hindi. Any possibility?

  • @abdulahadashraf4376
    @abdulahadashraf43764 ай бұрын

    Sir, I dont understand why you have not resolved these issues when you were in government.

  • @dreamias6846
    @dreamias68464 ай бұрын

    ita an an fact that maney laws in India is not accordance to the constitution

  • @gilbertdsouza7752
    @gilbertdsouza775224 күн бұрын

    Judges need basic education

  • @parameahwarbt4920
    @parameahwarbt49204 ай бұрын

    Sir, representing pak slogan raiser as a client is compatible with constitutional!?

  • @sadanandanpillai11
    @sadanandanpillai114 ай бұрын

    Where was Kapil Sibal when Ambedkar was preparing the Constitution of India. He thinks what ever he says, people must accept. Not only people even any court.

  • @mr.satishpdeshpande2702
    @mr.satishpdeshpande27024 ай бұрын

    We're the law and principles different while congi were in power?

  • @cpssindia
    @cpssindia4 ай бұрын

    Sibbal sir, as i remember while you were in power you always opposed the values of constitution and were always against people's liberty.. please remember and apologise for that first before showing your commitment for people's rights and liberty.

  • @What-do-you-want824

    @What-do-you-want824

    4 ай бұрын

    He is talking about New criminal law's.

  • @siddharthb2633
    @siddharthb26334 ай бұрын

    Chidambaram brought half of these draconian laws he is talking about.

  • @akshayagrawal5114

    @akshayagrawal5114

    4 ай бұрын

    But then why bjp brought the other half ?

  • @mb-ct8zk
    @mb-ct8zk4 ай бұрын

    Ant! hndu lawyer

  • @goat-jd2cr

    @goat-jd2cr

    4 ай бұрын

    😂😂😂

  • @akshayagrawal5114

    @akshayagrawal5114

    4 ай бұрын

    Define being a Hindu lawyer ?

  • @goat-jd2cr

    @goat-jd2cr

    4 ай бұрын

    @@akshayagrawal5114 what are u asking him , he has to beg for an internet recharge from his papa . 😅😅😅

  • @What-do-you-want824

    @What-do-you-want824

    4 ай бұрын

    😂😂

  • @karanswamygowda
    @karanswamygowda4 ай бұрын

    when he was law minister he did nothing ,now he is shouting from the roof tops

  • @akshayagrawal5114

    @akshayagrawal5114

    4 ай бұрын

    PMLA was amended and made draconian by bjp

  • @sanjayb4159
    @sanjayb41594 ай бұрын

    The India alliance.opposition should also bring this to the public The new laws which are an attack on article.19 and 21 -

  • @manavchoton
    @manavchoton4 ай бұрын

    Gujju bastards gi back

Келесі