Excellent summary. I think the main problem with Roman history is this insistence on using the word FALL, implying a sudden collapse. Whereas the reality, as this evidence demonstrates, is that Rome DISINTEGRATED, in an almost slow reversal of the way it expanded.

@mattwatson6259

11 ай бұрын

Romans were pretty high

@emanym

11 ай бұрын

Truth 😊

@chrisdiaz9011

11 ай бұрын

Sounds semantical. It certainly fell, but definitely stumbled several times before doing so

@bozo5632

11 ай бұрын

Yeah but "disintegrated" implies a phaser did it.

@mortache

11 ай бұрын

​@@chrisdiaz9011a slow decay over many centuries is different from a FALL though

I was shocked some years ago to learn that Irish masons building the Rideau canal in Ottawa, one of the coldest capital cities on earth, were dying of malaria in the 19th century. I realized then that it isn't just a tropical disease.

@infinitejest441

10 ай бұрын

Perhaps they caught it elsewhere.

@tdpay9015

10 ай бұрын

@@infinitejest441 By the mid-1600s, both Plasmodium falciparum (P.falciparum) from Africa and Plasmodium vivax (P.vivax) from Europe were firmly established in North America. P.vivax could survive farther north, and was killing builders of the Rideau canal.

@jeannerogers7085

10 ай бұрын

Malaria was also a problem in the US around that time - Indiana was mentioned.

@Christian-gy6fk

10 ай бұрын

Alaskans often joke that their state bird is the mosquito. Because they’re so common in the state. So yeah, they can reproduce easily in colder climates.

@tdpay9015

10 ай бұрын

@@Christian-gy6fk You're right of course that mosquitos can live very far north. But it's a parasite that lives inside mosquitos and is passed to humans that causes malaria. Luckily those parasites cannot survive as far north as Alaska.

A new toldinstone video? Ok let me drive off the Autobahn and take a break to watch it - seriously I’m instantly hooked just by the fact that you uploaded another great video without annoying and unnecessary music, long intros or whatsoever, just historic facts, a calming voice and an interesting topic. Thank you for your work, best wishes from Germany (and oc I already bought your book) :)

@davidemelia6296

11 ай бұрын

Why are you looking at your phone on the autobahn! Pay attention to the road!!! 🤣

@SPQRcat

11 ай бұрын

Man just announced commiting a crime in KZread comments

Those few sentences of closing remarks are a beautiful description of the historian's craft. If only more people were honest enough to say that the answer to most historical questions (the interesting questions at least!) are _"possibly, to some extent"_

@kahlernygard809

11 ай бұрын

Kinda like me questioning whether the math is correct on age of earth. I wasn't claiming creationism 7 thousand year old earth but questioning whether we truly know radioactive particles decay at a stable rate over billions of years.

@QuantumHistorian

11 ай бұрын

​@@kahlernygard809 The age of the Earth lines up well with the age of the Sun (calculated through very different, non-radioactive, means), so there's no problem there. Unless you believe that there are no laws of physics at all, and everything in the universe is just a huge coincidence. Which is, naturally, impossible to disprove but also a pointless ontology to even discuss.

@kahlernygard809

11 ай бұрын

@QuantumHistorian well quantum physics does not correlate with thermodynamics and its in your name. I find it funny how much those who cling to science push back against questioning the evidence and theories

@QuantumHistorian

11 ай бұрын

@@kahlernygard809 lol, quantum physics and thermodynamics agree completely. I literally have peer reviewed papers on quantum thermodynamics. But you have to actually understand both fields to see that. While you're not even using the word correlates vaguely correctly. Funny how some confuse utter willful ignorance with superiority. Go learn something in depth before spouting your opinion as if it was worth something.

@kahlernygard809

11 ай бұрын

@QuantumHistorian lmao you are the one spouting doctrine as science and deny anyone who questions. And once again quantum physics and thermodynamics don't agree, lmao at some internet account claiming they have peer reviewed papers on the theory of everything. Where's your Nobel award dipshit ?

I am Italian and I was born in Rome. Near my house Marcus Aurelius wrote "Τὰ εἰς ἑαυτόν". I'm glad you Brits love my city's history so much and I'd like to talk to you but now I have to escape because my home is surrounded by rats and mosquitoes...😅😅😅

That ancient Roman cat mosaic was very cool. Too bad cats never became man’s best friend in Europe

@infinitejest441

10 ай бұрын

Man became their servant 😼

The timing on this video is perfect these mosquitos been wilding

@noahsnumismatics

11 ай бұрын

Was just thinking the same 😅

@huwhitecavebeast1972

11 ай бұрын

Yeah there are tons where I live, more than usual.

@theprotagonist8755

11 ай бұрын

They must be those USA created mosquitos from those Ukrainian biolabs that Russia uncovered. Russia always speaks truth. Haha russkie clowns 🤡

@holechek

11 ай бұрын

they always get in your car too bastards

@KingOfPlastics

11 ай бұрын

Floridian Identified

The Elden Ring reference made me laugh! Love your videos ;)

As for Rome itself, Justinians conquests destroyed a lot of Italy. Once the Germanic Kings were firm rulers, they wanted the country to prosper

@Chadius_Thundercock

11 ай бұрын

Justinians conquests over stretched the empire and cost more than it was worth

@allangibson8494

7 ай бұрын

The problem was the Germanic rulers didn’t understand the criticality of Roman infrastructure (like aqueducts) and this was compounded by the ill informed Northern European Christian clerics campaigning against bathing and bath houses.

@napoleonfeanor

7 ай бұрын

@@allangibson8494 that was later.

@allangibson8494

7 ай бұрын

@@napoleonfeanor Actually it was at exactly this time. The east west split in the Catholic Church occurred just before this.

When the Aztecs conquered the Valley of Mexico they started something that almost completely reduced the mosquito population that bred in the shallow and often stagnant lakes and lagoons. Using wide shallow baskets made of reeds, they scooped up the larvae, patted them into cakes and dried them into 'crackers'. The other tribes in the valley were disgusted by this treat, but wittingly or unwittingly, it allowed the Aztec population to grow and to expand in health.

@qus.9617

11 ай бұрын

Very interesting! Is there a source? I ask because sometimes such interesting facts have obscure sources that are hard to find.

@Devantejah

11 ай бұрын

@@qus.9617 It might be eggs rather than larvae, eaten in around that area to this day.

@ContactsNfilters

10 ай бұрын

​@@qus.9617I saw a recent video where they were supposedly catching mosquitos to cook with in Africa. They were definately catching some kind of flying insect, but I couldn't actually see if it was mosquitos, but if you search for "mosquito burgers in Africa" here on KZread it should come up.

@ContactsNfilters

10 ай бұрын

Not only the diseases and parasites that they transmit, but if enough fleas attack an animal it causes them to become anemic so I wouldn't be surprised if enough mosquitos would affect humans in the same way. Maybe eating the insects helps provide back some of the nutrients/iron lost. 😆 Probably not though.

@maggiemae7539

10 ай бұрын

Bull! The Aztecs ate human flesh! So they did not advance in health!

I'm really grateful there are ancient history channels like yours that show how simple narratives don't really explain things, and that there is a tremendous amount of nuance even on a topic people have been talking about for more than a millennium.

Your videos make me feel like I'm there with them even though I'm sat in my kitchen waiting for the chicken to be ready 😂

Your comment near the end about how Justinian's problems didn't stem from the plague, the problems were just made far harder to deal with due to it, reminded me of the idea of Normal Accidents, which really seems to apply to Rome quite well. The idea goes that, in a large and complex enough system, there will be so many unique moving parts that not only are accidents or disasters unpredictable, but they were also inevitable. Rome was SUCH a massive empire, with so much going on at every level from the highest political machinations to the smallest scale supply routes, that it's only natural it would eventually being to "fall". Of course, it didn't actually fall overnight, humans are shocking resilient creatures and we can adjust on the fly as issues pop up, but it's gradual decline and separation into the eastern/western empire was only natural. Trim off the fat, narrow down how much needs to be managed by a single ruler, and things will get somewhat "easier" to some degree. According to the Normal Accident theory a major disaster was already practically guaranteed for the Roman Empire, so add in Malaria and no wonder things got as bad as they did.

I read Hans Zinsser's marvelous book, Rats, Lice and History years a go. It’s a classic. Many thanks for this history of Rome's little vermin problem.❤

Everything about this video was fascinating. I'd never even thought before about mosquitos and rats migrating and not just always being everywhere

Thanks! ❤️ When you say things like "If we can believe our sources." Dislike when you say "unprecedented" , "with that being said." Or "Without further Ado."

As mosquito season is starting in my area, this is a timely release. Thank you for all your great content.

your channel is like a massage for my brain. your content and presentation are solid gold.

I really loved this video. Your closing remarks are important for bringing complexity to people's understanding of history.

I like your 3 descriptors like the titles of your books, and I love your channel

There was also the failure of the Roman sewer system and the resultant flooding of the forum with sewage. I'm surprised you didn't mention this. The problem with the plague, is that the fleas get sick, and their digestive tracts get blocked, though most rodents are immune. The fleas jump from host to host, starving to death, and infecting everyone.

the title changes are giving me whiplash

It's so awesome that you're promoting Planet Wild, they're truly doing some incredible projects out there. Thank you!

@essenceofsuchness

11 ай бұрын

I'm so glad Garrett has stopped promoting the art share investment company, which is basically a scam that profits off of the average person's lack of understanding of financial markets and finance concepts.

@matthewh4747

11 ай бұрын

​@@essenceofsuchnesscan you expand upon that further?

@essenceofsuchness

11 ай бұрын

@@matthewh4747 To repeat, not literally a scam but I feel it's basically a scam - in short: Dodgy sales tactics (such as a selective presentation of returns or the FOMO-inducing "wait list" - that you can skip!); fees that may sound reasonable but have a significant ongoing component that would be either much much smaller or not applicable on conventional investment alternatives; significant additional fees are that are not well disclosed (and hard to parse for the lay person); and, in my opinion, far far too little emphasis on the huge illiquidity risk inherent to the asset class - actually let's say too little emphasis on price risk as well. I think it's morally questionable for anyone to market super speculative assets to unsophisticated investors.

@shakewait7612

11 ай бұрын

@@essenceofsuchness "basically a scam" is correct except for the word choice 'basically' also "unsophisticated investors" aka anyone stupid enough to fall for the scam

@landoonline6393

11 ай бұрын

@@essenceofsuchness based comment

This is my favourite channel at the moment, I always watch you before bed. Interesting enough to keep me engaged while I watch and listen, but the kind of chill demeanor I can sleep to. Just wish you did longer videos! I do watch for the great info about Rome and Ancient societies in waking hours too to be clear haha

It's a keen observation to link silting to swamping to 'squitoes to sickness.

I witnessed all the transformations of this video, its titles, its thumbnails. A truly beautiful butterfly.

Wonderful video as always. Would you please consider doing a video on alcoholism in the ancient world? Did the concept exist?

Beautifully written. Thanks!

Great video as always! Looking forward for the new book :) One proposal: I would love to see a short list of sources/ literature recommendations in your description - to give a hint where to start if the interested viewer would like to keep reading on the topic. There is such a diversity of publications that I at least as a layman cant tell what is worth the read if I just search/browse for books on the topics you cover!

I wonder if they had a tick problem like we do here in Kentucky? I also wonder if they had to deal with spiderwebs over all their trails (if they had hiking trails).

@intractablemaskvpmGy

11 ай бұрын

I'll get webs in the face down the trail and all the way back up again on my quad. They rebuild them that fast

@allangibson8494

7 ай бұрын

Try lice and typhus…

7:55 *Lauging with a geekish, snorting laughter* about HeRATodus

Very well done. I continue to enjoy your quality work. ❤

Thank you for presenting Planet Wild! What a great concept! Instantly subscribed :)

Excellent video!

As a Floridian, I'm all too familiar with the scourge of the Mosquito. They're literal flying dirty needles. I'm fascinated at how long they were a problem and physicians didn't seem to connect the dots with Mosquitos and disease.

@tebelshaw9486

10 ай бұрын

IKR? I live in Suwannee Co. and am so covered with bites, I look like I have smallpox.

@ReapingTheHarvest

10 ай бұрын

And we have special Bill Gates gmo mosquitos in Florida.

Paul Cooper has a podcast and KZread channel called 'The Falls of Civilizations podcast'. I've listened to every episode. It never ceases to astonish, not only in his dedication to production, the amount of context and information but the sheer hopelessness that is chronicled in these stories. Carthage and so many others are covered and when you hear the horrors, the devastation, the death and carnage, the struggle desperation of the inhabitants of these places beset by invading armies etc, it just moves a person with compassion for what they all went through. Trying to imagine being born in a beautiful city to simple hard working parents, betrothed to an empire by your proxy and heritage and then being cast in such a circumstance, damned in either fighting off the invaders or just being around when they finally burst through the gates. Having to watch invaders rape your mother and sisters as they put you in chains or maim and mock you.

Those final thoughts were so expertly worded. This channel reminds me every day why I love history. ❤️

Just love this video. Very informative,

Send me your second book early PLEEEEEEEEASE MAAAAAAAAAAN.

Lead cups probably played a role too

I had the closed captions on and they all popped up right at the beginning and then there were none for the rest of the video.

@joejankoski8471

11 ай бұрын

It's happening on quite a few channels. May be a You tube issue.

When we look at the words "Ill-ness and Dis-ease", we see what ails us. Just like the Monty Python sketch "What did the Romans ever do for us", there is social rigor and infrastructure that made the people live longer.

speaking of the black death, thehistorysquad did a video where he read some contemporary testimony which indicated that the virulence was transmitted by breath, not fleas, and some people even knew this at the time.

To see the jewel of the western world virtually empty, stripped of decor, crumbled from earthquakes and filled with silt, overgrown; it must have been a powerful sense of loss as a visitor. It could be viewed as a symbol of how far eastern Rome was willing to go to forget the gods of the past.

Love the MTG shout out @10:00. Especially like it since I'm running a Rat Tribal deck at the moment.

HeRATodus had me dying (of the plague) 😂

Beat elden ring? Rodent with a magic card...Love it XD

I absolutely love your channel❤ Please be as eternal as Rome!!

I will have my first visit of Rome in a few months, for 5 days. I hope is enough time for seeing the most relevant history delights. I'm a history fan, so I'm not going for the nightlife and stuff. I'm going for the sights and museums. If anyone is experienced, I would appreciate if you'd let me know if 5 days is enough. I would also appreciate any suggestions of places to visit:).

@Jacob-vk2xg

11 ай бұрын

5 days are not enough, but you will still have a great time. I recommend the Basiilica di San Clemente (and it’s excavations), the Crypt of the Capuchin Monks, the Pantheon, the Forum, the Palatine, and the Galleria Borghese. The Vatican and St. Peter's are incredible but will be the busiest and most inconvenient. Also, the Capitoline Museum is amazing! Have fun, let me know if you have any questions.

@franciscostalteri4849

11 ай бұрын

Honestly, just walk around as much as you can and go in all the alleyways. The centre of rome is a great maze you can explore and constantly find cool stuff. The gardens in the north centre of the city and the art gallery in it is also really cool, has some beautiful statues. If you can, find a way to get a tour of tivoli, it’s a town that has Hadrian’s villa, but also the d’este villa. Honestly I’ve never seen a sight more beautiful than when you are at the top of the villa. Anyway, tivoli is 30 km from rome so that’s the one thing, cheers!

@jeannerogers7085

10 ай бұрын

Whatever you see, you will never forget. The city will rattle around your memories forever, even after 5 days..

Thank you for using AD and BC.

Funny enough, I was pleasantly surprised by the lack of mosquitoes when I visited Rome in early June. I probably encounter more mosquitoes in New York.

@Idntgt

11 ай бұрын

they had a big effort of draining any swamps in Italy I think around WW2? Anyways they eradicated malaria and most insects as well

The stubborn refusal of Roman planners to build roads circumventing marshes is bizarre, though marshes weren't the only terrain features they seemed to have ignored in favour of directness. Possibly it was to demonstrate power in areas where rebels/outlaws might hide but the issues must have been enormous from the roads sinking into the soft substrate to seasonal flooding and travellers/soldiers picking up diseases.

@qus.9617

11 ай бұрын

Interesting. Where did you learn that if you don't mind me asking? This reminds me of China for some reason. Rebel/bandit/outlaw strongholds which ranged from major nuisances to dynasty toppling threat level made their strongholds in marshes and precipitous 'wild' mountains.

@thescarletpumpernel3305

11 ай бұрын

@@qus.9617 nowhere specific, but perhaps the most famous example is the Via Militaris through the modern day Balkans, which transects numerous low lying and boggy areas in favour of circumventing round higher ground. It later became famous for crusaders picking up and succumbing to malaria on the way to Constantinople. Other examples abound such as the Ermine Street which ran straight through low lying fenlands in eastern England.

Your last comment is spot on.

the ability of humanity to never blame their superiors is disappointing

@victorygarden556

10 ай бұрын

French Revolution, American revolution, etc There is a pattern when they do lol.

Constantius II . About 34 years ago, a friend had an ancient coin, just like this one at 0:12 time. ONLY it wasn't gold..... / . Very interesting, seeing some HISTORY of this guy on a video, many years later. ATTA BOY Mr. Mark Felton ! ( Darius Arya has a KZread channel ; another great on-site historian ! )

thank you for the video

He never got to Elden Ring...

How many times has this video been re-named and given a new thumbnail? I saved it to watch later a few days ago and it was completely different.

The aqueducts didn’t feed stagnant pools - the Roman’s didn’t use taps to turn water off in houses but rather there was a constant flow at a fixed rate that you paid for that overflowed to drains and sewers. Only with the breakdown of the aqueducts was water stored in any quantity. As has been repeatedly discovered, mosquitoes can be controlled by covering water storage’s with fine woven cloth.

I bought your book. You write like you talk . I liked your conclusion to this video. "Yes, but only kind of." It would have been easy to just say yes.

Nice epilogue

Jeez… how the heck do you even de-swamp a swamp? After the floods and the stagnant waters, how did they undo the waters and did those men die for the sake of everyone else?

@tebelshaw9486

10 ай бұрын

Washington D.C. was built over a swamp. That's one way. Oops, not a great example. 🙄

From the title for some reason I thought this was going to be about the Khazars

Excellent and enlightening video, as always

"possibly. To some degree". Well, it's settled then

@tebelshaw9486

10 ай бұрын

Maybe 🙄

"leaning further from each frost" . . . frightening. don't want MY apt walls doing that!! yeah, sis' was 'conservator' on that soren dig @ malaria-riddled villa n tiber. she mentioned that to me years ago they were finding some thing deccimated by malaria . . .

proud of myself for noticing those were video game assets and not real logs

8:05 The Rat, is staring down a spider that's out of focus... Or maybe the Rat doesn't care, and the spider is just hanging there, being creepy.

Have you done a video about coopers/barrels?

For mosquitoes, a used dryer sheet rubbed on exposed skin helps me. It also smells and feels better than bug spray.

Could you do a video on the relationship between Belisarius and Justinian?

Mosquitos Gates next trick?

Can you do a stand alone video on Emperor Constantius II?

"Beat Elden Ring" You and me both Justinian LOL

Does anyone know what the art style at 2:20 is called? I’ve seen many paintings similar in style and theme and always love them, but I don’t have any idea what category of art they are classified in!

I recently purchased a Tuserkan rug which seems to have mosquito-borne fever & hallucination as its theme. Most unusual.

The remarks about the procession in Rome just... broke me. I can´t fathom it. Were they curious walking down those empty streets?

Justinian couldn’t even get passed Godrick.

3 title changes in as many hours. Why?

Alright alright Todd I saw the name change 3 times and Im finally watching the video lol

How did Ravena survive malaria? Wasn't it literally a "swamp castle?"

Idk what class you took about user engagement but the fucking mtg card cracks me up great work Edit: Everything looks clear in hindsight if you can adjust to the twilight

That damn Elden Ring…always the bane of Roman emperors…

Say Blanche we've got rats in the cellar!!! - Whatever Happened to Baby Jane? Descendants of Roman rats invade Baby Jane's house! The rise and fall of Baby Jane Hudson!

WOO HOO! Fleas on rats! Fleas on rats!

I am so thankful we have no malaria mosquitos in Washington. It is bad enough I have to deal with mosquitoes in the back country. 😂🎉

I just realized… is the intro jingle… the lick???

I would imagine that the kingdoms of the Frank's, who just watched Italy and N Africa get conquered, were a little wary. Not able to be taken by surprise like the vandals and to a lesser extent the ostrogoths were.

I'm curious what you think of the Krakatoa volcanic winter of 535 theory - supposing that lower global temperatures in following years made perfect conditions for the spread of bubonic plague into Europe.

@toldinstone, I liked the title about "Rats and Mosquitoes" but I didn't have time to look until after you changed it to "Did Malaria . . ."

Sounds similar to 800-600 BCE, just before the Etruscans built the Cloaca maximus (draining the marsh in Rome)

One question for the future since I have a strong storm outside. WEATHER: What did Romans think about lightning storms, hail and extreme weather. Especially when someone was hit by a lightning?

Yet another fascinating discussion that we have not heard about previously. Most, if not all, of the information about the Roman empire has been focused on political intrigues of the early empire. Clearly, the problems with which we are dealing today, are no different than the issues of the Roman empire, namely infectious diseases and human caused environmental issues. NYC has a really bad rat problem today. I wonder what the future will bring to America's largest city and others struggling with the same.

The MTG card hahaha!

Actually it was a miracle that the ERE lasted as it did after the death of Justinian.

what become of the libraries and their scrolls?

Cats and Rats In about 1970 I walked by an overgrown depressed ruin in the middle of Rome. There must have been at least 100 cats in that ruin. Apparently the cats would go out at night and hunt rats, mice and bugs. I thought...what if all those 100+ cats decided to attack me in mass......I would be reduced to a pile of bones in ten minutes.

"History is something that never happened, told by someone who wasn't there."

Interesting title change. I think this one is better.

Read about this recently. Rural dovecotes in Britain were built at ground level in medieval times because there were no rural rats. The black rats stayed in towns and cities and didn't go into rural areas. It wasn't until brown rats came in that dovecotes were built higher to deter rats as brown rats spread into the countryside. So this questions the notion of rats spreading plague since plague spread through the countryside areas without there being any rats there.