I agree, it felt like Julia had too much power. Like, y'all remember when no one took Heather seriously when she suggested that Gwen was trying to make them lose? She lost her power, while somehow Julia still holds it

@PinguTheSwiftie

6 ай бұрын

This is no hate, but wasn't it Courtney not Gwen ? :)

@ScottTD

6 ай бұрын

@@PinguTheSwiftiepretty sure their taking about In Action Episode 7: Justin blackmailed Gwen to throw the challenge to make up for Trent throwing ep4-ep5

@PinguTheSwiftie

6 ай бұрын

ohh mb@@ScottTD

@AutumnPlains

6 ай бұрын

Yeah Julia had way too much plot armor. It made it unenjoyable for me

@rickyronny4019

6 ай бұрын

I agree. And times she would have plot armor cuz she’d have these plans that come out of nowhere with zero foreshadowing 😂

I really like the fact that they made a season 2. In season 1, we have such limited character interactions and most of them felt stilted and limited. With other seasons, you can fuse different character dialogue together and create new scenarios. Characters like Julia and MK hated each other in season 1, but in season 2, they decide to form a friendship and alliance because they both respect each others techniques and mannerism and have you extremely similar personalities and behaviour looking at it closer. Caleb was the first boot in season 1 and Priya was the winner of that season. However, in season 2, Caleb does a Justin/Alejandro and uses his looks to type and eliminate decent threats early on. Eventually, Priya forms a closer relationship with Caleb and he does too, but a bit later, becoming the screen time couple of the season. I will admit, they seem to act like ‘The Daters/Haters’ and seem to love and hate each other more and more.

@threeguysandagirlinabeachhouse

6 ай бұрын

Remember we don't know if s3 is confirmed!

@EvTheFlickFan

6 ай бұрын

@@threeguysandagirlinabeachhousewait a minute…

@threeguysandagirlinabeachhouse

6 ай бұрын

@@EvTheFlickFan sees..

Personally I think Priya should have been a much earlier boot in the second season. Realistically her team would have turned on her quite quickly. It was her idea to have everyone listen to what Emma said no matter what in the trivia challenge, she didn't really perform that well premerge, she never listened to anyone else's ideas , she sided with Millie when Millie was clearly in the wrong, plus she was the winner of the last season. Anyone with a brain would have done everything in their power to get her off the show. I think Nichelle could have easily taken Priya's role later in the season. That way a new character would have had time for character development and wouldn't have completely derailed another

@SpookyMertilo

6 ай бұрын

Priya carried her team in all challenges, makes zero sense vote her

@SuperCellSprout

6 ай бұрын

she would be a massive threat in merge is a good reason to vote her@@SpookyMertilo

@SpookyMertilo

6 ай бұрын

@@SuperCellSprout everyone in the island likes Priya and find her cool so is hard to happen

@catsthatsmokemeth

6 ай бұрын

I hated Priya

@YesImAYoshiFan

6 ай бұрын

​@@SpookyMertilopriya carried? She was out second in episode 1, barely scored any points in ep 2, was just a dead weight for Caleb in ep. 3, told Emma to not trust her gut in an answer she knew in episode 4 and risked getting hitted by the cannon in episode 5. Yeah, Nichelle is the only one that got them close to winning every episode

I think Julia being the main villian for season 2 works since Technically she wasn’t in season 1(a common misconception). She was one of the main antagonists, but didn’t do too much villian strategy like the others do. Basically she was if Lightning was in an antagonist role for longer than a couple episodes. Bowie is consider the main villian since like he was more friendly towards others and actually formed genuine relationships, he still was the puppeteer in things like convincing the others to eliminate Caleb, being the first to find out Julia’s true colors(though not the one to put her. Just the one to make fun of her next episode for it and be slapped by a burrito), tricked Julia into trusting him to get her out, and of course the whole thing of taking Julia’s phone to get dirt and using Millie’s diary(along with ripping the last page out of it) to make Priya hate her. Unlike Julia and a lot of TD villians, he’s not evil but just really competitive which makes him an interesting antagonist. Though yeah, I can admit MK would’ve probably been the better antagonist for season 2 just because she was the one giving them the ability to cheat and Julia lasted a long time anyway. At least she lasted a good while

@theownerofthisaccount2521

6 ай бұрын

I do also feel Wayne and Raj do have enough differences that they don’t just feel like the same character. In season 1 an argument could be made they were, but i honestly think that was the point to show they were kinda dependent on each other. After all, apparently they’ve been friends all their lives and essentially do everything together. In season 2 though I do feel they started to gain their own traits to make them stand out. Raj started becoming more confident and willing to be more independent from Wayne(he chose Bowie over him in episode 6, eventually was willing to do the challenge without him in episode 8, and wasn’t upset by his elimination with instead comforting Wayne) who was the more attached one to him to the point of temporarily replacing him with a bucket. Raj had his mini arc with Bowie to show his moral stand, has moments of intelligence specifically socially, and has complexity in his emotions like being upset with Bowie about the cheating or not wanting to work with Julia in episode 7 until Wayne calmed him. Meanwhile Wayne is a luck magnet(so many times he did something that either saved himself or gave someone the win unintentionally) with zero braincells and probably is incapable of knowing what the word hate is(several times he didn’t know what was happening but got angry just for someone else’s l sake/to be included, struggled to know when someone was insulting him, never held hard feelings and even considered Julia a friend, and is the only contestant to actually care about and help an intern). There was even a mini arc of Wayne being to attached to Raj and needing to accept that there will be times they need to be separate in some way which while short and done in a more comedic way, was nice to see. Personally, I love Wayne more but I’m just glad to see how much love they and the whole cast get. This season certainly was worth it

@AutumnPlains

6 ай бұрын

Julia was 100% a main antagonist. There’s a reason Julia had to rely on immunity as she herself admitted she’d be out. She shared the villain umbrella with Bowie.

@theownerofthisaccount2521

6 ай бұрын

@@AutumnPlains I did say one of the main antagonists, just not really the main villian. There is a difference between antagonist and villian Now I’m season two, there’s no question if she was the main villian or not. May they be strategies or at times petty reasons that worked in her favor(like her getting Nichelle and Bowie out was mainly cause she didn’t like them but they were also two of the best players) she played the game and everyone like a fiddle

@AutumnPlains

6 ай бұрын

@@theownerofthisaccount2521 Yeah I gotcha. It’s an interesting study. I’ve seen people say Julia wasn’t a villain at all in S1. She’s probably similar to Jo where she’s the de-facto enemy whereas Lightning (Bowie) are just super competitive and get grouped in as being a villain.

@theownerofthisaccount2521

6 ай бұрын

@@AutumnPlains Bowie does enough where he has reason to be grouped in, which makes him one of the most unique villians they created. And while Bowie gets redeemed, Julia accepts her flaws and becomes the true villian Though I love Lightning to and at times wish he and Jo were the villian instead(I love Scott but he was a pretty dumb villian given his plan didn’t really make sense)

A problem I personally had with Julia is that a lot of the things she does, specifically causing eliminations, are off-screen. It makes them more shocking, sure, but you know, show don't tell and all that. I want to see at least some of this stuff, or parts of it, for example when MK's badmouthing her we could see Julia going to talk to someone but not seeing what's actually said. As for Millie... Honestly, there was a really easy fix, other than your idea of her pushing Damien down the 3 pointer and then going down the 1 pointer (which might make it harder to justify her elimination). Simply... Have it be an accident. Maybe she does go to push him down the 3 pointer, but she's so tired she trips and accidentally pushes Damien down the 4 pointer. This way her elimination would make more sense (as they might not believe it was an accident, or don't care) but Damien forgiving her makes more sense since it was an accident.

@emmanuelobandodiaz5860

6 ай бұрын

It was not an accident, Millie was lazy putting Damien in instead of herself going, she always takes up everyone else hard work as hers, look at s1 with Priya

@forrest6939

6 ай бұрын

they said what if not this is what happened they are giving what they think should have happened

@IWestrada

6 ай бұрын

They probably would've animated her doing it if they had screen time for it. They had to crunch a 26 episode show into 13

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

totally agree with the off screen eliminations that Julia caused ESPECIALLY stealing Damiens idol, since it was obvious when the idol was gone that Julia took it they really should've just showed how she did it instead of saving it for next episode because it already stupid obvious that she was the one who took it. like your idea for the Millie fix definitely is a good way to keep the drama, i just personally wasn't a fan of the tube anyways since it was unnecessarily brutal (a problem i've had with the new season) but speaking from realistic terms your solution probably makes the most sense (also could make her being sleep deprived more excusable for this happening if it was just a genuine mistake)

Agree 100% on Julia being a writing device in S2. It was too much

Priya is the second closest contestant to almost repeat right behind Owen who came in 1st in season 1 and 3rd in season 2.

@Simplywoodlandofficial

6 ай бұрын

Zoey got 3rd and 1st

@christakanst7014

6 ай бұрын

​@@Simplywoodlandofficial org commenter is talking about people getting far AFTER already winning a season , Zoey got 3rd in her debut season and won in All stars

@Simplywoodlandofficial

6 ай бұрын

@@christakanst7014 there isn’t a season called debut??

@isrequired

6 ай бұрын

⁠@@Simplywoodlandofficialdébut just means first

@Simplywoodlandofficial

6 ай бұрын

@@isrequired then why not just say first?

Caleb: D (S1), B (S2) Axel: D (S1), D (S2) Nichelle: D (S1), D (S2) Scary Girl: B (S1), B (S2) Damien: S (S1), S (S2) MK: B (S1), S (S2) Raj: A (S1), A (S2) Wayne: A (S1), A (S2) Ripper: F (S1), F (S2) Zee: S (S1), S (S2) Chase: F (S1), F (S2) Emma: F (S1), D (S2) Julia: A (S1), A (S2) Millie: B (S1), F (S2) Bowie: A (S1), A (S2) Priya: B (S1), C (S2)

THE GOAT IS FINALLY TALKING ABOUT THE REBOOT 🙏 I definitely agree with a lot of your points on how characters could have been written better, especially MK. (even if, as an Emma fan, it stung a bit to see you rightfully criticize her lmao) I’m also glad that you gave Millie a fair ranking, I feel like she was overhated (pre-s2 that is lol) Would honestly love to see you discuss the characters more and analyze them like you mentioned wanting to do in the Julia section. I also can’t wait until you start doing What Ifs for these seasons, especially s2, you were already cooking with your suggestions for the Damien plotline. This cast is def the strongest of the 13-ep seasons. praying S1 and S2 do well enough to warrant a 26-ep s3.

@sau7255

6 ай бұрын

Cool Jenny pfp

I think you should make a world tour version of the if Sierra and Alejandro were in island as Alejandros charm wouldn't work as much because of them knowing his tricks and Sierra isn't as obsessive over Cody too because after action she views him as only a friend. + we get to see other characters get pushes. Do it if you want to as it's your option!

@shadowbladesabre1945

6 ай бұрын

Didn't he get burnt out doing Action though? He should only do the World Tour version if he wants to, there's no point otherwise.

@sarahshahid6275

6 ай бұрын

Im gonna listen to his opinions as its his option but it would still be cool to see​@shadowbladesabre1945

Finally someone else who likes Zee. Hes so overhated. Yeah he doesn’t really have anything going on but thats the point. Hes used just the right amount both seasons.

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

people hate him? I haven't seen anything about that, I thought everyone loved our little stoner good boy

@havikrogers1801

5 ай бұрын

Are you sure you’re not talking about someone else, because I’m pretty sure everyone loves Zee.

@kiabb8851

17 күн бұрын

God how I wish people hated Zee, but no. On average hes one of the most liked characters from this cast

What if ideas for season 1 of the reboot: What if Bowie didn't cause Caleb to be eliminated episode 1? (Can be pretty easily justified by him thinking having someone as strong as Caleb on the team would lower their chance of losing challenges.) What if Damien had made it clear that he had changed his mind about not wanting to leave? (Self explanatory) What if MK hadn't seen Julia's outburst? (This both allows for Julia to keep her secret for longer, and MK not to be eliminated) What if the Hockey Bros hadn't fallen down the cliff? (At the very least ensures that one of them stays in the game) What if ideas for season 2 of the reboot: What if Priya didn't pick Emma 2nd for "alliance building reasons". (Since it's never explained what this actually means, it bothered me) What if Bowie didn't pick Julia 3rd. (He clearly could have gone either way on this one)

MK and Damien were excellent in their respective positions, they're my faves and if characters are going to return, i hope it's those two, because there's a LOT more that could be done with em, specially since their eliminations felt rushed all the way. As for Millie, well, i think it kinda solidifies her not being a good competitor and other people are carrying her, like why wouldn't you go in the 4-pointer instead of forcing Damien to do the hard work for you? I think she TOTALLY got carried by Priya in S1 and if Damien didn't stand up for himself she would have gone far again with that same excuse.

Love your vids! You should have move views also what if idea "What if courtny jumped in the jelly during phobia factor?"

I dont agree with the "cheering Bowie on" in season 1. I think he is very clever and skilled and engaging. But I think he was essentially a villainous rival to Julia. He was very manipulative and cutthroat and even though I agree with A+ ranking, he was a villain through and through. Season 2 he was trying to reconcile some of his villainous behaviors

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

i personally am not a fan of normalizing the line between strategic and villainous, in my opinion you can play the game well and not be labeled a villain. voting Caleb out isn't villainous, its part of the game and turning Priya and Millie on each other isn't villainous, since those were real things that Millie said about Priya. If he forged that work to frame Millie that would be villainous but revealing the truth isn't villainous to some degree it could be argued as heroic since Priya deserves to know what her "friend" was saying about her. This isn't to say he's obviously a good person to any degree he does have small villainous moments for sure like when it was revealed in the finale that he cut out the part of Millie's diary where she apologized to Priya, but having minor villainous moments doesn't make someone a villain especially when they are pit against the antagonist (Julia)

Any tdi season needs 26 episodes it helps flesh out the characters and storyline I wish they would go back that format

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

also a big problem with season 2 to me is that it has no gimmick, i'd rather have a good season with no gimmick than a forced bad one but the setting is exactly the same as season 1. I could probably show people 10 images with season 1 and 10 from season 2 and you couldn't even tell the difference, if they were going to have back to back seasons with the exact same season theme then they really should've just made it one 26 episode season

Video Idea: what if Sierra never blew up Chris's plane in World Tour?

@mikenoble4511

6 ай бұрын

That would be like 5 minutes 💀

you should do a what if for one of the reboot seasons, i have no ideas yet but that would be cool!

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

definitely plan to get around to one at some point! just want spread it out from normal what ifs as I know there are still people that havent seen the new seasons and I dont want to marginalize them from my content

For another What If, I think a simple one for all stars would be "What if Sam didn't get his blood sucked out in All Stars?" It sounds weird, but if Sam didn't lose most of his blood, he likely wouldn't've gone to Boney Island, and wouldn't've lost the pancake challenge.

Future Video Idea- What if the team that won that week’s episode loss? Example: The Killer Bass lost in episode 1 of season 1 so what would happen and who would be eliminated if they won and The Screaming Gophers had to vote someone off

@darkishere233

6 ай бұрын

That’s a pretty cool idea! I would love to see how things would play out!

@AznYunHou

6 ай бұрын

and then for merge, it's the loser getting immunity

Reboot S1 felt pretty complete as a whole. I feel like for the most part a lot of characters got a reasonable amount of screen time and I found it to be a really enjoyable, using your metric I probably would have ranked the characters as: (and in order) S: Bowie, Zee (easily the most enjoyable characters of the season for me, purely personal preference without much justification) A: Julia, Millie, Wayne & Raj (For the most part it's self-explanatory. I really appreciate the amount of depth they tried to give Millie and even though it started falling a little flat by F6? I found her selfishly enjoyable) B: Priya, Emma, Damien, MK, Scary Girl (Priya's nice as a whole, she's just not a very interesting or complex character really? She feels like a really boring straight woman to everyone else's wacky shenanigans and I feel like she failed to standout, especially for a winner. I personally enjoyed Emma, she's a very hit or miss character but I think her bubbly personality makes her endearing and I loved her relationship with Bowie. Damien, MK and Scary Girl are simply here as a byproduct of not getting super far) C: Chase (Honestly, if they had just ditched his storyline with Emma sooner and given him some douchier things to do, Chase could have easily been B tier for me despite being an awful person, but despite his long stay his connections are sorely lacking) D: Nichelle, Axel, Caleb (Self explanatory) F: Ripper (I blame him for the monstrosity that is episode 5, in that he actively made the season worse) Something I feel like Reboot S2 failed with is focusing on the right characters. I feel like we just focused on entirely the wrong characters at times and I do think the season was going on a decline for a very long while but didn't truly hit "bad" territory till episode 10 where it became abundantly clear it would be the Priya/Caleb/Julia show for the rest of the season. It's frustrating how much focus these three characters (Julia and Priya in particular) just ate up so much time at the expense of other characters. Anyways: S: MK (I truly believe MK is one of the only characters who was properly utilised this season while staying consistent, so I'm giving her the entirety of S tier) A: Julia, Damien, Bowie (These three for the most part were really enjoyable, but have a few minor complaints about all three. Julia being overpowered, Damien's hit or miss episodes and Bowie was pretty decent but it's a byproduct of his placement) B: Caleb, Wayne & Raj, Zee (I like these four, I just thought they were insanely mid characters and could have been a lot better than they were) C: Priya, Ripper, Axel, Scary Girl (No true opinion on these four. Scary Girl is eh. Ripper & Axel were decently funny, but not enough to be in the same tier as the four above them. And Priya I just have so many writing problems with. She's not a bad character exactly, but she just feels really misused despite being in 26/26 episodes) D: Emma, Millie, Nichelle, Chase (Fodder characters, Chase is borderline F but I decided to be nice) I thoroughly enjoyed your video! Good one!

What if idea: what if Julia never made the fake contract

36:30 on the bright side, this did make the most iconic millie line in the next episode "That crossed the line!" "Yeah, the finish line!"

Julia’s plot armor was ridiculous this season. Everyone knew she was bad news after the previous season plus she straight up admitted to tricking Nichelle into quitting in front of her teammates and yet they still trusted her during the merge.

@AutumnPlains

6 ай бұрын

Preach

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

%100 agreed plus the fact it worked on Priya, someone who made final 4 with her last season is insane (also her somehow getting Damien's idol really needed to be shown or explained, am I seriously supposed to believe she was handing notes to everyone saying she knew about their idol and NO ONE else talked about it?!? also how did the plan even work, was she just eyeing everyone every time they left to see if they were suspicious?)

@AutumnPlains

5 ай бұрын

@@TDWonderer it’d be awesome for you to do a discussion video on the failure of Julia as a villain. Would love to hear it!

Video idea:total drama world tour but your universe with all of the rivalaries and alliances from your what if sierra and Alejandro was in action and island

I have an what if idea! : what if Sam didn't cheat in episode 4 of AS?

“Raj and Wayne being happy dudes.” Should’ve said gay dudes, if I’m being honest.

@havikrogers1801

6 ай бұрын

@Cxsanitiz_34 You didn’t get the joke. Gay back in the day meant “carefree” or “joyful”.

Are you going to make a Hot-take video? It would be fun to hear your unique opinions on characters.

respectable tier list 👍

The Priya and Caleb storyline was got worse as the season went on, but it was almost entirely Priya’s fault in my opinion. I would say high A for Caleb

Could you make a tier list about every Gen?

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

ehh, there's just so many of those already I feel like everything that can be said has been said

Suggestions: What if Harold didn't rig the votes on Courtney?

MOM WAKE UP TD WONDERER JUST UPLOADED A NEW VIDEO

Interesting take on the whole thing.

Does this season confirm cannon winners 🤔. (Asking because of the owen cameo and the fact that priya was referred to as the previous winner)

Hey this may sound weird but have you heard about a KZreadr names Sheff Austin? You sound similar to him

The tier list is coloured correctly

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

THANK YOU, THIS IS THE BEST COMMENT

It must have hurt seeing your three favourite characters get eliminated consecutively in season 2. Anyway I think next what if will be for this season

Fun fact: I’m a human

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

this is unacceptable, this is a channel for dogs only

@havikrogers1801

5 ай бұрын

Crap, I’m a car.

Ik u said ur gonna take a break with what if Alejandro and sierra play in Island can u do world tour like cast like the last episode of action

@TD_Heather4TW

6 ай бұрын

He needs to add new cast members if he did that.

@Trent.TD9

6 ай бұрын

@@TD_Heather4TW nah cuz who will he add

@TD_Heather4TW

6 ай бұрын

@@Trent.TD9 Just a stretch, but Jose and Jude?

@Trent.TD9

6 ай бұрын

@@TD_Heather4TW nah Jude wasn’t in the timeline and it’s a what if that’s y

@TD_Heather4TW

6 ай бұрын

@@Trent.TD9 Fair, but honestly, that's the only one I've thought about since yeah.

My Original List: 16: Caleb 15: Chase 14: Nichelle 13: Ripper 12: Millie 11: Emma 10: Axel 9: Damien 8: Raj 7: MK 6: Priya 5: Julia 4: Wayne 3: Scary Girl 2: Bowie 1: Zee My New List: 16: Chase (-1) 15: Millie (-3) 14: Emma (-3) 13: Ripper (+0) 12: Axel (-2) 11: Scary Girl (-8) 10: Priya (-4) 9: Nichelle (+5) 8: Damien (+1) 7: Raj (+1) 6: MK (+1) 5: Caleb (+11) 4: Bowie (-2) 3: Julia (+2) 2: Wayne (+2) 1: Zee (+0)

@scream-xj3uq

6 ай бұрын

Why'd scary girl to down so much is it because of her lack of screen time

@dsmall0903

6 ай бұрын

@@scream-xj3uq Yeah. Still love her though.

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

interesting list! i personally don't see how raj and wayne can be ranked so far from each other when they are so similar to me but glad that you could find differences in them to enjoy uniquely from each other!

Caleb is probably the most awful contestant to make finale besides All Stars finalists. Even Sky and Shawn were less frustrating to me. Despite loving Julia (due to how much focus she gets...) I totally agree with her NOT needing so much focus in season 2. MK should have idoled Julia out in the final 7/6/5 and taken control as the true villain.

@volksc4687

6 ай бұрын

Disagree mk villain arc should be saved for season 3

@cashmere8059

6 ай бұрын

@@volksc4687 as much as I'd rather have any new TD season than no season at all, I feel like this cast is pretty played out already. Season 2 didn't do a good job for any of these characters longevity. MK villain arc season 3 would just feel too little too late.

@volksc4687

6 ай бұрын

@@cashmere8059 disagree season 2 was great and if the og cast can have 3 season then no reason they can’t either

@maxchristopher4352

6 ай бұрын

​@@cashmere8059I agree MK should have been the main antagonist over Julia.

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

opinions on caleb are wildly leaning from what i see people either love him or hate him, i can totally see why people dont like caleb, he was kinda boring and sometimes annoying due to his constant indecision but I did enjoy his more grounded nature especially on a pretty crazy cast, it was mainly the plotline he was used that made him hard to root for and I think it could've been fixed if it was just ended sooner, having both Priya and Caleb make it to finale 4 with that plot still going is nuts

As much as i love priya shes my girl and would still be my prefered winner. Not having bowie as a winner is the rumb8st dicicion ever cuz he played an amazing game better than alejandro

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

im just surprised that they took the approach of finally having canon winners, i guess it makes sense since people always argue about canon winners of previous seasons but I personally always enjoyed alternate winners and would've been perfect for priya and bowie (also wayne and julie as alternate winners for season 2 could've been cool)

Pardon me for asking but have you ever heard of disventure camp?

some tdi reboot s2 what ifs: what if julia got off instead of mk what if julia never stole damiens statue what if julia and mk never cheated what if emma never played with chases head in ep2 what if bowie won in ep 6 (i think it is or the one in the canoes) what if nichelle never voted herself off what if millie never put damien down the 4 point slide

i might be the only completely unironic ripaxel shipper on earth i can’t get enough of them. genuinely the funniest shit the show has done in a long time. these two are the total drama couple parody sky and dave wish they could be. i hope they show up next season wearing matching alpha wolf t-shirts

Where did you watch season 2?

What if idea "What if: MK didn't say buttknuckle to Julia in "The Launchback of Notre Game"?"

Ranking each character based on how strategic they are, season 2. Then in a reply I'll compare my season 1 ranking. Lower means they did worse and higher means the did better. But for now, let's rank hiw strategic they were Not strategic : 16th: Lauren 15th: Chase 14th: Zee 13th: Millie 12th: Raj 11th: Wayne 10th: Nichelle 9th/8th: Ripper/Axel Semi strategic: 7th: Emma 6th: Bowie 5th: Damien Strategic: 4th: Priya 3rd: Caleb Very strategic: 2nd: MK 1st: Julia The last two were so hard. Also I agree, the only one who would push Damien down the 4 pointer was eliminated last episode.

I respect your opinion but I’ll have to disagree on two things. 1.Ripper is really enjoyable in both seasons(But I can understand why you don’t like the fart gimmick, I guess I’m just different because the fart thing never annoyed me even with Owen). 2.For me Millie was a terrible character as she was not enjoyable and she completely overstayed her welcome because a lot of people criticize how much I hate her but if she were to be eliminated where Ripper was in season one she would have been way more tolerable but she stayed every episode of the season and she took up screen time from characters who actually needed it or could use it. Anyway I really liked the video and I hope you know I’m not criticizing you or anything, I’m just expressing my opinion about the matter and I can’t wait for your next what if video!

@forrest6939

6 ай бұрын

i dont know what makes me not like ripper but ive heard people say ripper is like owen mixed with scott which i sort of agree with. Also he turned into geoff and brudget in s2

dang im pretty early ^-^

Chase underrated king

How is Emma so low???

I would have put Julia, Bowie, Wayne & Raj on S & Damien, MK & Zee on A and Scary Girl on D, but otherwise I agree with you

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

completely fair as I said at the beginning A and S are pretty interchangeable its just more when my personal preferences start to kick in and Scary Girl didn't do a whole lot, I just enjoyed her crazy moments for the short time she was there but I could definitely see why you'd rank her low

Damien in S for both seasons AND in 1st place for both seasons feels correct

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

so true

@AshleySassypants

5 ай бұрын

@TDWonderer he's an icon, he's a legend, and he is the moment, now come on now

“At least we avoided having a character that was centered around bodily functions” Merge Sugar: “Am I just a joke to you” (I know her WHOLE personality wasn’t centered around bodily functions but then again some people say she’s a female Owen so that says something..)

What if idea "What if Geoff and Bridgette nevet kiss 24/7 in Total Drama Action?"

Caleb doesn't get any higher than his appearance in Season 1. In season 1 he was such a non-character and him being voted out first was kind of funny, while with season 2 he felt very confused on if he was supposed to be a alright guy or a not-as-alright guy.

Did you change your profile pic

Yay

Damn, this might turn into a reboot what if. Thoughts on your ideas, anyone? Me: What if Nichelle wasn't unfairly booted off.

@RasmusVJS

6 ай бұрын

In which season was her boot unfair? In the first she revealed herself to be a liar and useless, and in the second she left without being voted off.

@TD_Heather4TW

6 ай бұрын

@@RasmusVJS Answer: 2nd season. Reason: Julia. She made a fake contract for Nichelle and since Nichelle thought it's real, she forfeited.

I respect your opinion but most of the rankings were just based on how likeable, relevant, and unique they were to the show. While that is a major factor on rankings, would have preferred if you also ranked them on how well they did in the game. In like competitive, strategic, and social skill terms on their performance throughout the games. While you did include that in, I felt that it was lacking that and was mostly only based on whether they were unique or you liked their character or not (which I know is a major factor in rankings since they are opinion based) Great video still,

@plebaidendapleb2180

6 ай бұрын

I mean, you gotta give them credits on their performances in the game rather than it just being based on the uniqueness, likeability, and relevancy of them in the show.

@Siioh

6 ай бұрын

What a thoroughly stupid comment.

@TDWonderer

5 ай бұрын

... i guess i could see that? but total drama is a written show, its not like anyone who played well actually did anything they were just written to succeed, in that sort vacuum no move is really a bad move if the writers just have it turn out well. we definitely did see strategy and I did mention it occasionally in my characters ranking (namely with Priya and Bowie) but I don't exactly give them props for it, I just give props when it was entertaining to watch them play well.

@Bentrap15

4 ай бұрын

​@@plebaidendapleb2180I have to disagree with that take. I feel like that ranking mindset is more suited for survivor. You gotta remember that total drama is not a very serious show so obviously strategy is not going to be the writers priority for writing a character. For example, zee us one of the best reboot characters IMO not because of the game he played but because of his comedy and how likeable and fun of a character he is. That just how I see things.

mine: ( worst to best ) 16: Chase: F (S1) F (S2) 15: Caleb: F (S1) F (S2) 14: Ripper: F (S1) D (S2) 13: Axel: C (S1 ) D (S2) 12: Nishelle: D (S1) C (S2) 11: Emma: C (S1) C (S2) 10: Millie: B (S1) D (S2) 9: Bowie: C (S1) B (S2) 8: Scary Girl: B (S1) B (S2) 7: Damien: C (S1) A (S2) 6: MK: B (S1) S+ (S2) 5: Zee: A+ (S1) A+ (S2) 4/3rd: Wayne & Raj: A+ (S1) S (S2) 2nd: Julia: S (S1) S+ (S2) 1st: Priya: S+ (S1) S+ (S2)

Total Drama revenge of the island being the OG cast as a what if would be cool!

Best character: Nichelle Worst Character: Julia

honestly julia did way too much i disliked her but i felt like i was the only one tbh

I honestly liked Nichelle in this season

O yes

Julia supremacy 🤌

Nichele and Axel being better than Emma, Chase and Ripper? I don't know man...

My rankings Love Julia Priya MK Raj Wayne Zee Bowie Millie Like Caleb Scary girl Damien Dont care fore Axel Ripper Nichelle Hate Emma Chase

I have to be really honest here, I don’t like Damien all that much, he was okay in season 1 part 1, but in season 1 part 2 I didn’t care for him all that much, his biggest personality trait is being afraid, but he doesn’t have anything else to balance that out like DJ does.

Season 1: 1. Julia 2. MK 3. Zee 4. Priya 5. Bowie 6. Damien 7. Millie 8. Wayne 9. Raj 10. Scary Girl 11. Axel 12. Emma 13. Nichelle 14. Caleb 15. Chase 16. Ripper Season 2: 1. MK 2. Julia 3. Zee 4. Damien 5. Bowie 6. Wayne 7. Raj 8. Caleb 9. Priya 10. Axel 11. Nichelle 12. Emma 13. Millie 14. Scary Girl 15. Ripper 16. Chase OVERALL RANKING (SEASON 1 & 2 COMBINED): 1. Julia 2. MK 3. Zee 4. Priya 5. Bowie 6. Damien 7. Millie 8. Wayne 9. Raj 10. Axel 11. Scary Girl 12. Caleb 13. Nichelle 14. Emma 15. Chase 16. Ripper

OMGA

Raj is a bit less stupd tham wayne and he focuses more While wayne is a complete wholsome idiot that gets hurt way more than raj, like in the pinball episode, raj was focused amd did well While wayne got lost the whole episode

Why does evryone still like Scary girl? She was really bad this season

Caleb sucks, very annoying bland character

My Rankings: 16. Zee 15. Ripper 14. Caleb 13. Axel 12. Raj 11. Chase 10. Damien 9. Emma 8. Julia 7. Priya 6. Millie 5. Scary Girl 4. MK 3. Wayne 2. Bowie 1. Nychelle

Zee is still the best character of the reboot in my opinion and priya was one of my least favorite after season 2 she was unbearable and her and Caleb were so annoying and then she was just a jerk in the finale and overall was just bad this season

caleb is the worst character of the cast, his plot with priya was painful to watch