•Updates - • Yunjin has Eb5/E5 in her higher register, Her supported range is A3~Bb4/B4~Eb5/E5 • Yujin (IVE) will be around Jennie and Chaeyoung, Minnie can be placed somewhere around them as an estimation too. • Nayeon has a Solid G#3 in her lower register, Her supported Range is G#3~A4/Bb4 • Miyeon has A4/Bb4 in her mix, Her supported range is G#3/A3~A4/Bb4 • Sullyoon is a Weak to Average Vocalist, her place in this list remains the same. • For any updates on the dance ranking, please refer to the below document. - Dance Document ~ docs.google.com/document/d/1oiIblgTcOX0dmO2edqZ_yk6epR_E4bAOgva2f7n9CwY/edit?usp=sharing

@davakdks

Жыл бұрын

There is no tier in dance, it's just made by someone

@guigzs

Жыл бұрын

​@@davakdks if it was made by someone, then it began to exist. Please stop trying to ignore the facts

@reinaldolemus169

Жыл бұрын

Jihyo > Yunjin, Jihyo has a better low register and her mix is much more solid compared to Yunjin, on her tour she has had quite a few solid B4s, Yunjin only beats Jihyo in HV

@Doli702

Жыл бұрын

@@davakdks isn't everything in this world made by humans ? ( except for natural components) Even the device you are holding rn is made by someone, that doesn't mean that it doesn't exist lmao

@Cryforme-

Жыл бұрын

Miyeon has A4/Bb4 ryt so why it's written as (Bb4)

no matter whats the updates about vocal category with the new groups, i knew that wendy will remains at number 1 tho, the finest vocalist in kpop today

@somebodygill8666

10 ай бұрын

Not in kpop... Ailee and a few other singers are better... But for Kpop group... Especially 3rd gen.. Wendy is the best.

@solinkdc2645

9 ай бұрын

​@@somebodygill8666that's why they said in kpop 💀💀

@somebodygill8666

9 ай бұрын

@@solinkdc2645 AILEE and the few other singers that I am taking about ARE IN KPOP.

@user-dy1cz4tf4f

7 ай бұрын

@@somebodygill8666 kpop.... today

@yanetquesada2165

7 ай бұрын

@@user-dy1cz4tf4fAilee still sings

no way chaeryeong is below sakura and shuhua in vocal

@zyozyo24

3 ай бұрын

​@@aidentai5867 sakura and shuhua are the worst vocalists in their respective groups. Chaeryoung is the temporary main vocalist of itzy. How can u say that😅

@elfy2006

3 ай бұрын

@@zyozyo24 temporary main vocalist ? Yes she is better than sakura and shuhua but she could never be in a vocal line

@zyozyo24

3 ай бұрын

@@elfy2006 chaeryoung is infact a temporary vocalist. I don't think you have heard itzy songs. Don't worry. You should see Mr vampire and untouchable. Chaeryoung will prove herself there :)

@elfy2006

3 ай бұрын

@@zyozyo24 don't worry. I stan them.

@K__._0._68

Ай бұрын

She cant improve herself with straining notes every stage. It'll make it worse ​@@zyozyo24

1st in vocals = Wendy (Red Velvet) 1st in (open) dance = Seulgi (Red Velvet)

@kpome

Жыл бұрын

Yes, red velvet literally have the best 3th gen dancer and the best 3th gen vocalist

@martacastillo6272

Жыл бұрын

Also😮 2nd in vocals = Lily (NMIXX) 2nd in open style dance = Jiwoo (NMIXX)

@darksparks.

10 ай бұрын

Only one problem , *ROSÉ IS THE LEAD DANCER IN BLACKPINK WHILE JISOO & JENNIE ARE LAZY . FORGET ABOUT JISOO , SHE IS IN THE PERFECT POSITION , BUT JENNIE ??????!!!!!?!?!???!!!!! U COULD'VE GIVEN 51 TO JISOO , 50 TO JENNIE & 28 TO ROSÉ . THIS IS VERY UNFAIR TO ROSÉ*

@sasakaanime5

9 ай бұрын

@@darksparks.why do you comment here they talk about rvv😂

@harandas8126

8 ай бұрын

Blackpink and twice are far better than these groups

NMIXX is such an all rounder group. Haewon : 3rd (vocals) - 16th (dance) Jiwoo : 18th (vocals) - 2nd (dance) Kyujin : 14th (vocals) - 10th (dance) Lily : 2nd (vocals) - 26th (dance) Sullyoon : 9th (vocals) - 30th (dance) Bae : 30th (vocals) - 20th (dance) Out of 54 idols😮

@helloeveryone00

11 ай бұрын

bae is 20th in vocals, so nmixx is top 20 for vocals!!

@shaima55

7 ай бұрын

Yeah nmixx are and also they are rookie and are competing with really talented groups so iam proud of nmixx

@stafiannisa795

5 ай бұрын

Top tier group

@cutesweetdadi9495

5 ай бұрын

Aespa too like they are very talented too 1) Ningning 4th(vocals)-32th(dance) 2) Winter 6th(vocals)-27th(dance) 3) Giselle 12th(vocals)-39th(dance) 4) Karina 13th(vocals)-13th(dance) Edit:Out of 54 idols 😮

@jianacore

4 ай бұрын

@@cutesweetdadi9495this isn't about aespa..?

Jiwoo being at 18th in vocals and 2nd at dance Such an all rounder

@diamondentertainmentkpop5008

10 ай бұрын

this girl isn‘t an all-rounder. Y‘all need to stop calling everyone an all-rounder. That‘s kind of an exclusive title!

@nurtilekkylshabaev6247

10 ай бұрын

@@diamondentertainmentkpop5008SHE IS AN ALL-ROUNDER!!! Open your eyes,she outdo all your favs!!!

@ricocarpenter2189

10 ай бұрын

​@diamondentertainmentkpop5008 all arounder is thrown around too much but jiwoo is definitely an all rounder. Dance, Rap, Vocals, and stage presence are all there

@cadendough

8 ай бұрын

@@diamondentertainmentkpop5008 jiwoo, karina, and kyujin are definitely all-rounders.

@WAFFLE747

7 ай бұрын

Seulgi being 5th in vocals and 1st in dance 💀

The way all 4 members of aespa are in the top 13 of vocals is *INSANE* , their vocal capability is one of the best of this industry..

@Safwaan_Q

Жыл бұрын

Ikrrr

@jendeukie_manoban

10 ай бұрын

aespa slays

@chinaramirzayeva4836

7 ай бұрын

Not in the industry but yes they are very good

@liana-cd9so

7 ай бұрын

They're good, but the best of this industry, no

@nctthebest

Ай бұрын

​@liana-cd9so there's a difference between the best and one of the best😊

SEULGI NEVER LEAVING TOP 5 😭💃

Aint no way u said that jisoo is better at dancing than Rosè😅

@Faithismyname

5 ай бұрын

her opinion

@Miyeonvrland

5 ай бұрын

@@Faithismynameyeah but Jisoo is so stiff while dancing

@flxxwersxbesties

5 ай бұрын

ikr-

@staycool97

5 ай бұрын

@@Faithismyname no they ranked according to dance tiers which is (supposed to be) accurate

@vibestown-td

5 ай бұрын

​@@Miyeonvrland who told you so

This is the most funny ranking ever😂😂😂......

Lisa vocal is better than jisoo?😅

@AASTHAPATIL-gh5kn

7 ай бұрын

No bro.

@manupate7986

7 ай бұрын

Yea Lisa’s voice is way better your right

@sooya_dream

7 ай бұрын

No.

@-_jnn_-

7 ай бұрын

Never

@-_jnn_-

7 ай бұрын

@@manupate7986no, Jisoo is a powerfull vocalist with a range C+ (In CVT) she can support C5 and D5.

i can't wait for aespa comeback !

@redvelvet9503

Жыл бұрын

Same🎉

@atikavanesa2288

Жыл бұрын

aespa Will comeback on 8th may And aespa Will realease prelerease song tomorrow 2th may

@NingKook_

Жыл бұрын

@@atikavanesa2288 yes !

@cxli318

Жыл бұрын

Same ik they gonna slay

✨Dance✨ 9. Tzuyu - 49 ranked 8. Mina - 47 ranked 7. Chaeyoung - 45 ranked 6. Jeongyeon - 40 ranked 5. Dahyun - 35 ranked 4. Sana - 34 ranked 3. Nayeon - 29 ranked 2. Momo - 7 ranked 1. Jihyo - 3 ranked ✨𝘎𝘖𝘋 𝘑𝘐𝘏𝘠𝘖 𝘚𝘓𝘈𝘠𝘌𝘋𝘋𝘋 ✨❤️

@ANDODARREXJBSHS

9 ай бұрын

how is momo 7th?????

@aestheticgorlmatrial

9 ай бұрын

@@ANDODARREXJBSHS idk 🤷‍♀️

@Rkive_thv-cr7be

9 ай бұрын

@@aestheticgorlmatrial It is based on open style

@dahyuncrazyfan

2 ай бұрын

@@ANDODARREXJBSHSthis is based on open style, momo is the best in idol dance

OK but kyujin at 17 years being at fifteenth in vocals and 10th at dance

At last someone appreciate how great Seulgi is in dancing

@imyour_joy217

8 ай бұрын

A lot of people do though…

Seulgi ace 1st in dance and 5th in vocal 💛

@Iuslays

Ай бұрын

If she can rap, write, and compose then yeah she's an ace!

Nmixx being in top 20 for vocals and top 30 for dance Slayyyyyy

Seulgi is so talented❤️

Irene and rose is lead dencer, mina is main dancer 💀

@singingwhale977

7 ай бұрын

This is about freestyle dancing. And positions doesn't mean your better.

@yeontan12thv

6 ай бұрын

@@singingwhale977 Oh, Ok then

@getuliocesar6275

5 ай бұрын

​@@singingwhale977 dizer que Jisso dança mais que Rosé é até crime

@MIDZYwhoONCEfoundtheNSWER

2 ай бұрын

So? Idk about Irene but Rosé and Mina are very stiff(due to them being flexible, it’s also the case with Lia and Kazuha), they often mess up the footwork, have little control over their body power, Rosé also has problems controlling her arms and legs due to their length and more.

Even though yeri and Irene are ranked low in vocals (based off support), I think they still have such a great sense of musicality in terms of music key, harmonies, layers, stability, and lyricism (for yeri)

this is one of the craziest rankings ever LOL

@Rkive_thv-cr7be

9 ай бұрын

Let's see, according to you which is correct ranking?

Aespa ranking: 13. Karina 12. Giselle 6. Winter 4. Ningning Dance: 39. Giselle 32. Ningning 27. Winter 13. Karina

@kpopstan636

Жыл бұрын

Karina is the 3 best vocal in aespa

@beautiful4816

Жыл бұрын

@@kpopstan636 Giselle is stronger vocally than Karina. Her vocal range is wider.

@Minty_Sana

Жыл бұрын

@@beautiful4816 Karina’s range is wider, Giselle has less materials. Gis > Rina, because Giselle is better in the range of A4/Bb4

@kpopstan636

Жыл бұрын

​@@Minty_Sana oh ok bc people say that she better and I thought she was

@afeliz2642

11 ай бұрын

@@Minty_Sana giselle and karina are literally at the same level, giselle just being a little more consistently open in her mix, but karina having so many good moments as well, plus karina having better lows than giselle at G#3

No way you put Ros’e that low in dance

JIWOOO YASSSSS BABEEEE ! no 2 for dancing while still a young group ! nmixx justt slayy ! 2 & 3 - haely 2 - jiwoo

how can jisoo and chaeryong be the weakest vocals (in their groups) if they are the lead vocalists how can rosè be the weakest dance (in their groups) if she is the lead dancer

@CarameLiife

7 ай бұрын

Chaeryong is sub vocalist tho

@amanpreetbrar7836

6 ай бұрын

Bp is rap based group and jisoo has weakest vocals among them along with lisa bruhh

@MIDZYwhoONCEfoundtheNSWER

2 ай бұрын

Positions don’t mean shit. Jihyo is the best dancer in her group yet she doesn’t have a dance position, Yuqi is the 2nd best vocalist and she doesn’t even have lead vocal ect. Chaer is sub vocalist and Jisoo isn’t a good vocalist, she just has an attractive voice. Rosé is stiff, dances awkwardly(due to her long limbs), has problem controlling her body and her power, often messes up the footwork and more. Chaer is my itzy bias and Rosé is my bp bias so whatever you say idk

Wendy 1st on vocal no surprise there. I know her dance kept improving but 18th on dance. Demmm. The improvement is crazy. Ace sonseungwan 💙💙💙

Haewon being the all rounder 16th at dance and 3th in vocals

@ferj_bat.

9 ай бұрын

Everyone at NMIXX is an All Rounder!

@A_Comfy_Blanket

7 ай бұрын

Will never regret her being my bias 🤍🤍🤍

@MIDZYwhoONCEfoundtheNSWER

2 ай бұрын

She’s not that strong in rap

The dance ranking was crazy omg😂

@reycousticx

6 ай бұрын

Truth hurts btw 🎉

@riahlexington

6 ай бұрын

@@reycousticxI’ve seen other rankings that say much different. How can we know which one is “true”?

@reycousticx

5 ай бұрын

@@riahlexington there are few facts there, but others are wrong

@binhtt6109

4 ай бұрын

​@@riahlexingtoncác bảng xếp hạng theo abcde, không có dẫn chứng là sai sự thật. Bảng này có độ uy tín cao

Was waiting for rap rank :’) good video btw, it just show to some people how some idol are underrated or overrated in some categories

@binhtt6109

4 ай бұрын

Không có rap rank, chỉ có vocal, dance. Tất cả bảng xếp hạng rap đều là bịa đặt 🙁

OMG!! I DON'T BELIEVE THE VIDEO IS GOING TO COME OUT IN 3 HOURS!!! I CAN'T WAIT!!!

Already know seulgi will top vocal and dance 1st in dance 5th in vocal

I respect your work and omg im so surprised that Chaeryeong is so low in vocals and that Momo is below Jihyo 😨 I am sor proud of Jiwoo being second but I somehow always knew since O.O she was such a powerful dancer

@Rkive_thv-cr7be

9 ай бұрын

What surprises you? Did you expect Chaeryeong to have a higher place in vocal?

@solinkdc2645

9 ай бұрын

​@@Rkive_thv-cr7beyeah because I know nothing about vocals I just started learning recently, I wasn't expecting her on like the top 20 ofc but just not 50th

@Rkive_thv-cr7be

9 ай бұрын

@@solinkdc2645 I don't understand much vocal either, but there are videos explaining why Chaeryeong is in the top 50

Red velvet and Aespa slay

Jihyo being 8th in vocal and 3rd in dance. Our GODDD is INSANE 🤩

@kikygustami3359

10 ай бұрын

Especially in the fact that she's JYPs

The fact that it is both rv members at top 1 for both categories their talent doesnt get recognized becuase of those dozen members ( yeri improved a lot)

@ryanlee3514

7 ай бұрын

which dozen? There's a lot.. TWICE 3 or 4 LE SSERAFIM 2 ITZY 1 (she's the dozen's dozen cuz she's better than most of dozens in dancing) NMIXX 0 (I'd say none cuz all of them are good imo, even Bae) IVE 1 (Leeseo is Wonyoung younger version) RV 1 BP 1

SLAYYYY Minty!! omg I was missing the long videos so much

can you do part 2 including rap and sp??🙂

@P.a.l.e.s.t.i.n.e

Жыл бұрын

And visual

@annamathew7096

Жыл бұрын

@@P.a.l.e.s.t.i.n.e visual isn't a talent💀🤌🏻

@gwiwiin

Жыл бұрын

​@@annamathew7096 yes but what if we just want to know??

@guigzs

Жыл бұрын

​@@gwiwiin then search how much % each idol fit on kbs, visual ranking is useless

@dahyuncrazyfan

2 ай бұрын

@@guigzsgoogle doesn’t give the answer right away, we have to look through stuff which is quite a waste of time if we don’t find it

What did u expect ? # 1 vocal : Wendy # 1 dance : Seulgi Best kpop duo

@guigzs

Жыл бұрын

Agreed! 🫶🫶

@queen_yulia

10 ай бұрын

YESS RED VELVET SLAYS

@AishaAisha-on7jd

7 күн бұрын

RED VELVET AMAZING

Red velvet on top ❤

Selugi deserves more 5th at vocal 1st in dance Our talented queen

Liz > rosé for me but it’s interchangeable

@Minty_Sana

Жыл бұрын

What the heck? I had a stroke

@pinkladyblogentertainment

8 ай бұрын

No you are just biased

rose #51 in DANCE??? u're probably joking right now because WHAT

@clefdesol13

9 ай бұрын

Based in open style dance but I think she should be 50th

@lyricsarmyup2979

7 ай бұрын

Rose is High Tier 7

@MIDZYwhoONCEfoundtheNSWER

2 ай бұрын

What’s the problem? Don’t tell me, “she’s lead dancer” because that doesn’t justify it.

the way yeri become the last at dance and seulgi become the first at dance

Can I ask, how do you know all this informations? I mean, I geniuely don't know where to find them (about vocals and rap)

ALL ROUNDER JIWOO APRECIATION 🔥

Vocal: 1)Liz 2)Yujin 3)Rei 4)Gaeul 5)Wonyoung 6)Leseo Rap: 1)Rei 2)Gaeul 3)Yujin 4)Leeseo 5)Wonyoung 6)Liz Dance: 1)Yujin 2)Gaeul 3)Leeseo 4)Liz 5)Wonyoung 6)Rei

@fluffythecat9915

9 ай бұрын

Yujin is not ready to leave top 3!

the new layout is so good!

Newjeans being a great dance group ofc nmixx and redvelvet being amazing Hanni 8th in dance is everything

all new jeans members came under 15 in dance it shows new jeans is the best dance group but many people will disagree this becuase their dance steps is not hard as itzy nmixx but their choreogrphy is based on open style thats why they are good at dancing

@kikygustami3359

10 ай бұрын

Actually NJ dance is the hardest, it's not fully coordinated dance but every member have different move when they keep in sincronisation

Rose is a lead dancer? Why is she so low

SO EXCITED❤

Jihyo being 8th in vocals and 3rd in dance

Minty slaying as usual. But i have some disagreements • I don't think you should use Underdeveloped to Weak, this isn’t a real Tier. • I don't think you should put Yujin/Rei/Minnie in a different tier as Mina/Chaeyoung (I didn't said Jennie, because she could be a really low w, but That's arguable), they are the same. • Liz doesn't have G#3/A3 - A4, her supported range is A3 - A4/Bb4, she has never supported a G#3. • Hyein is Weak tier and stronger than Haerin imo. • Chaewon has enough development for say she has A3/Bb3 on her supported range. • Yunjin has supported head voice up to G#5 (at best) (but I don't know how consistent her hv is.)

@katykim

Жыл бұрын

Mina jennie and chaeyoung all were weak at a time their just less consistent they have a support range arguably weak but lack engagement with their diaphragm, undeveloped are those who haven't supported but are relaxed its unfair to put people who's support is inconsistent there because they have actually supported, Liz has supported G#3 but since Debut its debatable, haerin is the second best Vocalist in New jeans ,yunjin head voice is extremely consistent but she supported Eb5/E5 in head voice no more no less.

@Lss125

Жыл бұрын

@@katykim not sure about Rei, but Yujin and Minnie have occiasional moments of support too, and are more than "just relaxed", and that is the reason why I said they should be on the same level as Jennie, Mina, Chaeyoung.

@reinaldolemus169

Жыл бұрын

@@katykim the weak tier already encompasses the differences between support, low weak is for those who have had occasional support or that is extremely inconsistent and shallow (Mina, Chaeyoung and jennie), mid weak is for those who have shown support more than low weak and is less inconsistent, but not enough to be high weak (Sinb, Yoon and Yeji), and the high weak show almost all the time shallow support but have some inconsistent moments (Chaewon, Joy and Lia), no need to invent another tier

@Oliver-uz1fs

Жыл бұрын

​@@reinaldolemus169 Sinb and the trio aren't weak tho

@reinaldolemus169

Жыл бұрын

@@Oliver-uz1fs They reanalyzed them and the three were left as Mid Weak (E), since they do not meet the standard of an E+

Omg i cannot with this storage i already used up im troubling 😭 very hard work you did you deserve all the views wait seulgi is mid tier 5 ?

@Minty_Sana

Жыл бұрын

For now, yes

@thiyammanglemba3564

Жыл бұрын

@@Minty_Sana omg i already believe she is mid 5

@Minty_Sana

Жыл бұрын

The lowest Mid T5, for now

Ofc red velvet are the true queens

Finally, I've been wait for your long video ranked, love it💕

CHAERYOUNG IS BETTER VOCALIST THAN SAKURA(i think sakura must be the last,no hate I love her)

I feel like it’s very important to recognize the supported head, voice of vocalists like yunjin, Wendy and such, that’s still a very important part of the registers, and the fact that you were completely ignoring them even in the supported range is unfair

@dalsonyan

Жыл бұрын

Scratch that, you completely ignored Yunjins head voice and only hers A3-B4(C5)-G/G#5

@afeliz2642

11 ай бұрын

@@dalsonyan the G5 IS part of yunjin"s head voice😐 and yunjin mix is so inconsistent to be B4 and she doesnt support C5 IN MIX Neither, shes A3-Bb4/B4-Eb5

@dalsonyan

11 ай бұрын

@@afeliz2642 yes, they completely ignored the two notes even in the update, and, if you use proper notation, you can properly acknowledge her full range

@afeliz2642

11 ай бұрын

@@dalsonyan she just has an average head voice…it’s not like she’s going to downgrade the hardest for not putting head voice The most important registers for sopranos is the mix/belt so even if she has the greatest head voice if she doesn’t fix many aspects of her mid-belts she’s not going to be better vocalist

@dalsonyan

11 ай бұрын

@@afeliz2642 I’m not worried about the tiering, I’m worried about the notation

How did you make the video?

NMIXX is such an Insane Group In Vocals All 6 members in Top 20 3 members in top 10 Nd 2 members In Top 3!! In Dance All 6 members r minimum at level High Tier 7!! (Which is the level of best dancer in many groups) Haewon being Low Tier 6 Kyujin High 6 ranked in Top 10 Nd Jiwoo Taking 2nd Spot Overall with her level of Low Tier 5 making her One of the best dancers in 4th Gen!! Truly Amazing NMIXX is such an All Rounded Group Even in Rap though not as strong as their Dance nd Vocals , Still is quite good and all 6 members have shown the potential as rappers while Jiwoo Being Good at Rapping Kyujin Sullyoon Haewon Bae nd Lily have proved they can rap too in their Videos!! Nd Btw Not Newjeans being one of the best dance groups in 4th gen!!

the dance ranking💀

Lily deserve that, go girll! 😩

6:52 What song and where is the excerpt from?

I think she loves nmixx, which is why she puts them in the first ranks

the dance list is definitely a list

Wendy ace and all rounder, vocal queen 🔥🥰

hanni is truly one to look out for!! main vocal AND main dancer of her group???? truly the next it girl

Nmixx and red velvet best groups

nayeon is absolutely better than jennie in dance 😭😭😭

@marangelysgonzalez8203

Жыл бұрын

It's open style

@swiglies6418

Жыл бұрын

@@marangelysgonzalez8203 in open style nayeon better than hennie

@aliceyat2793

11 ай бұрын

@@swiglies6418 jennie is improve

@lluuiizzff

7 ай бұрын

when jennie wants she can EAT

You're so talented I can't imagine ranking so many Idols in so many categories You deserve sm more

I would rank 55 in both categories

Hello 👋 I'm a huge fan of MAMAMOO. Just curious how you think my girls would have done in this ranking 😁

wait how come yeri is low when she is confident in singing unlike others few spots mentioned after her

Lisa should be higher in the dance category

the fact that this was uploaded on my birthday-

Sullyoon on 9th at vocal and 30th at dance most talented visual from these groups No don't feel like I am just dragging other visual down no sullyoon just is so talented despite her knowing tabt she will get in without talent Bae dozen who cares to call her that 20th at dance and vocal both

@pinkystar6469

Жыл бұрын

bae & sully outdance & outsing their main & lead vocal & dancer

@afeliz2642

11 ай бұрын

1, this ranking cleary is not the best(is not that bad but has to change a lot of things), like chaer from itzy being last in her group when she has better placement and relax momets than yuna or ryunji with that said, sullyoon is not near to being the most talent visual when winter is here, winter has better vocals, dance and rap by far than her

@MIDZYwhoONCEfoundtheNSWER

7 ай бұрын

@@pinkystar6469Sullyoon definitely doesn’t outsing Lily

Wow. Nmixx over all rankings are really impressive.

Thank you for ur effort and hats off to u and ur phone to making it through the process. Now a criminal offensive side eye request can you do vocal tier for boy group.p

@meteor2.074

Жыл бұрын

Tnku 💞

the fact that 4/6 nmixx members are higher than the 1/x in other groups is insane! oh also aespa all being top 13 wow

I am surprised with the ranking but I am not professional so I can't argue. Still, I'm enjoying Blackpink (Itzy, Twice or Ive...), whatever average or bad dancers/singers they could be. It seems to me that success is not just linked to individual ranking. Synergy, cohesion and unity are important too. Maybe more.

Woah Jihyo beated Momo in Dancing 😱🤯

@littlered444

8 ай бұрын

this is not an accurate ranking

@Hrts.4.itzyyy

7 ай бұрын

Yes, unfortunately it is biased

@hqnaemu

7 ай бұрын

​@@littlered444It's accurate

@hqnaemu

7 ай бұрын

​@@Hrts.4.itzyyyNot biased, it's based on open style

@dahyuncrazyfan

2 ай бұрын

HOW MANY TIMES DO I HAVE TO REPLY TO COMMENTS AND SAY THIS IS BASED ON OPEN STYLE?

For me Twice and Ive are the vocal queens✨ And of course I don't know about dance queens but Momo and Jihyo are the Emperesses of Dancing 💖 🔴IT'S MY OPINION

que ranking de dança é esse?

Jennie must go all the way in the dance :33

Why is Shuhua so high

This list is seriously wrong.

Not sure regarding Minnie but Yujin is definitely better than Jennie/Chaeyoung

@Minty_Sana

Жыл бұрын

I guess Minnie had supported a few times? I saw it somewhere being mentioned I don’t quite remember

@Multistanofkpop888

Ай бұрын

@@Minty_Sanayour ranking is so stupid

13:16 song name please (

No rap category?

@Minty_Sana

Жыл бұрын

My phone’s storage was on the verge of crying

@NingKook_

Жыл бұрын

​@@Minty_Sana how about a part 2 including only rap ?

@genius_on_the_way8702

Жыл бұрын

not evrryone can rap

@CheShiny

Жыл бұрын

​@@NingKook_ Stage Presence too?

@CheShiny

Жыл бұрын

​@@Minty_Sana oh

Aight so average placement: Vocals: Aespa: 8,75 Nmixx: 11 Red Velvet: 22,6 NewJeans: 28 Twice: 31,33 (S)I-DLE: 31,4 Blackpink: 31,5 LE SSERAFIM: 32,2 Ive: 36,67 Itzy: 37 Dance: NewJeans: 11 (omg, I was not aware of that at all) Nmixx: 17,33 Itzy: 18,4 Aespa: 27,75 (S)I-DLE: 28,6 (huh, I expected them to be lower) LE SSERAFIM: 29 Twice: 32,11 Blackpink: 33,5 Red Velvet: 33,8 Ive: 40,5 (saved by Yujin💀) My fav: 1. Itzy 2. Blackpink 3. Nmixx 4. Aespa 5. (G)I-DLE with 6 members 6. LE SSERAFIM (surpassed TWICE with this comeback) 7. TWICE 8. Ive 9. Red Velvet 10. NewJeans 11. (S)I-DLE with 5 members

@onyourm_ark1711

11 ай бұрын

NMIXX ATEEEEE !

What about rap and stage presence?

I really think that you should put Yeri lower in vocals, since she's more confident singing live than the others

I think kpop idols should be ranked as performers, not dancers. Dancing is part of performing and it's very important, but if someone dances well with stiff or bad facial expressions, even if their dancing is great, they're not good as a performer.

@riahlexington

6 ай бұрын

Exactly.

Wendy and Seulgi 🔥

@Anjan_-

Жыл бұрын

The main slayer

Gigi being main rapper but 13 in vocals

Increíble lo de Hanni de New jeans 😯

Seulgi number 1 in dance??? Bro Lisa and momo-

@WoNYOUngfallingoffaBigbIgStAGe

7 ай бұрын

They arent half as good lmao yes they are in top 10 but not number one 💀

@amelialalisa

7 ай бұрын

@@WoNYOUngfallingoffaBigbIgStAGe ur opinion babe 😘 I was stating a fact... Momo and Lisa r better luv 😔

@WoNYOUngfallingoffaBigbIgStAGe

7 ай бұрын

@@amelialalisa its not an opinion its a fact seulgi is better lol sad you cant handle the truth🫶😙

@amelialalisa

7 ай бұрын

@@WoNYOUngfallingoffaBigbIgStAGe sure... Go cry to ur Plastic wonyoung pick me 😂😂😂

@dahyuncrazyfan

2 ай бұрын

open style~ NOT IDOL DANCE OMH

Seulgi bear slays as always 🐻

This isn't about our beloved idols or the video, but I want to say this to you, Minty Sana: You've always been one of the most unbiased KZreadrs (in the k-pop community) and one of my favorites indeed. You know how to make a good ranking and list. You have some of the most agreeable rankings. I totally approve of Seulgi being moved to Mid Tier 5, she's super satisfying to watch. I agree with Ryujin being a Low Tier 5, I just love the way she dances. I agree with Chaeyoung being a Low Tier 7 instead of a Mid Tier 7, she's pretty stiff. But, back to you, your editing is super good and the format is great too. Super unbiased and great explanations and details. I feel like people value support too little. It's a big saving grace on a vocalist. Yoohyeon has support, and Siyeon doesn't. She may have it now, Dreamcatcher is a small group, so it's hard to find updated rankings on them, but I believe Yoohyeon has had it for a while. Support is what would put her above Siyeon. Also, if this isn't too much to ask, could you rank Dreamcatcher? I really need a good unbiased ranking for my ultimate group, and you happen to be very trustworthy with that question. Also, in your opinion, who is a better vocalist? Wendy or Taeyeon? I see it as a big debate everywhere, so I'd like an answer. In my opinion, I'd say Wendy, but she's my bias and I have no idea about vocal. I'm more knowledgeable on rap and dance. So, this is more me ranting about idols now, so I better finish it up before I go off about LE SSERAFIM's comeback lol. Anyways, hope you enjoyed my sweet message and love from karomi!

@Minty_Sana

Жыл бұрын

Taeyeon is quite better afaik

@Lss125

Жыл бұрын

Actually Siyeon has support, she was misuvaluated. Yoohyeon is low Average Siyeon mid Weak to Average SuA and JiU Low Weak to Average Handong has some grasp of support, but is inconsistent Gahyeon and Dami doesn't support

@KaiIsNotFine

Жыл бұрын

@@Lss125 My bad, shouldn’t have assumed. I saw videos from a while ago saying she didn’t have support, and some saying she does from just a little while ago, making me assume she does have it now, but didn’t back then. So, my bad, and thanks for the kind correction. I’ll make sure to remember who supports and who doesn’t for the future. God, I’m a bad Insomnia lol.

@KaiIsNotFine

Жыл бұрын

@@Minty_Sana Thank you! Maybe shouldn’t have been biased there. Thanks for the facts. :)

@SMGENTERTAINMENT3

11 ай бұрын

​@@KaiIsNotFineTaeyeon is really better. Tbh Wendy mix is like High AA level, She is Just in Low P due to her developed registers (Lower and upper)

rv first place for both categories 😩