Why do so many people insist on saying "The proof is in the pudding" - it makes no sense & it isn't even a real phrase. The correct phrase is "the proof of the pudding is in the eating" which does actually make sense, though people are either too ignorant or too bloody lazy to use it.

Thanks for uploading, @Political TV.

The only reason I didn't skip past this program was because of Andrew Marr 🙌

New changes, let us get rid of Fiona, who is dreadful.

@trevordaviesable

14 күн бұрын

Fiona is great, she manages the protagonists with intelligence.

@britsfirstfitness5026

12 күн бұрын

She is joke 😂

@encouragesolutions2595

11 күн бұрын

@@britsfirstfitness5026 She is typical of BBC; biased, rude and not worth the money. I rarely watch the full programme as she annoys me so intensely by shutting down the parties she doesn't like. Sack her ! BBCQT used to be very watchable under Dimbleby.

@jane7953

10 күн бұрын

Nah Fiona is a legend

@britsfirstfitness5026

10 күн бұрын

@@jane7953 joke

Thanks @Political TV. I'm not a reform voter and never will be, but the back and forth between reform and labour on the question of 'Who is suitable to lead the Conservative party?' really troubled me and underscored that, at least for the moment Labour are underestimating the potential pull of the Reform party. The whole interaction really just showed they don't understand the root cause of Reform's appeal.

@chbuki

16 күн бұрын

I found the whole brushing away of Reform’s electoral prospects by the Tory peer completely ridiculous. Look at how many seats up and down the country had Reform in 2nd with the combined Tory-Reform vote clearly higher than the Labour vote. I get that it’s too simple to just say all Tory voters would turn around and vote Reform, but I 100% think it should be clear to Labour that their popular support is a much less solid than they are trying to portray to the public. I hope they can find it in themselves to be more radical in action. I don’t want to know how things will turn out if the Labour government fails and the pendulum swings even harder back to “the right”, or “Right/Nationalists” however they’d like to call themselves.

@matthewv4170

15 күн бұрын

​@@chbukiif they start talking about nationalisation of public services I think they will win 2029. If they stick to this right wing stuff it's doomed to fail

@nojhead

15 күн бұрын

This plan the mainstream party’s have of calling anyone anti mass immigration racist is exactly what will make reform win the next election.

@user-gd1yg6le1h

14 күн бұрын

Deformed is bad Tory’s, true corruption

@britsfirstfitness5026

12 күн бұрын

Reform all the way they are the only ones that have this country interest. Look after your own 1st and foremost.

Go Ben, he needs to get a seat next time

@md8955

15 күн бұрын

He's a useful idiot

Ben told you what the USA were doing in the first 20 mins to stimulate growth through self sufficient fuels, which will put over 376 billion into renewables.

@johnmorris2414

16 күн бұрын

Ben should shut up and listen ...some chance .

@user-ob4wo9po2y

15 күн бұрын

Ben is on a different planet - why give him airtime. He’s a fossil fuel

@Dimera09

14 күн бұрын

​@@johnmorris2414 such wonderful insight....

Good old bbc..

@binagarten4667

16 күн бұрын

Black Brocasting Corp! Everyshow they have The great British Menu, British Sewing Bee, Repair Shop, Antiques Roadshow, has to have the token black person. It is amazing when they have cookery or a Medical programme they will only have Indian women. If you are a Hindu or Male the BBC and media in general do not want to know you. They even got rid of Hardeep Singh Kolhi on superious allegations, but tried to cover up grooming gang scandales because a certain minority would be exposed. They will happily beat up on Indians Punjabi, Sikh, Hindu males but will not on others. I think you will know who the ones who made Salmaan Rushdies life and eventually cost him his eye and nearly his life!

Thanks for uploading

And thanks @politicaltv for the upload :)

Why can't I find a woman like Fiona Bruce?

@marksc111

18 күн бұрын

To talk over you constantly?

@garystevens4303

18 күн бұрын

Are you another one of those kidnap merchants? 😮

@damienadams2070

15 күн бұрын

No hes another jimmy saville wannabe 😂😂😂​@garystevens4303

Outside of the single market the UK's economy is toast. The first person brave enough to say that will get my respect. It's the elephant in the room that everyone's trying to avoid.

@shelleyscloud3651

17 күн бұрын

It’s only because of being outside the SM that Labour can go ahead with their national energy plans

@christopherblackburn6811

16 күн бұрын

@@shelleyscloud3651really which specific single market regulation prevents it? As most countries in the EU have public owned energy companies.

@shelleyscloud3651

16 күн бұрын

@@christopherblackburn6811 because they owned them prior, go to EUR-Lex & read up on state subsidies, competition law & procurement rules. Btw I voted remain & used to work for the EU so please don’t start with the usual remoaner schtick.

@christopherblackburn6811

16 күн бұрын

@@shelleyscloud3651 I respect your expertise in these matters and I did the searches you suggested (as well as some others) and found that yes we would have to abide by laws on state subsidies (which are allowed), competition laws and procurement laws none of that seems to prevent the creation of a new nationalised energy company it just means we wouldn’t be able to favour it above others in offering contracts. Which seems reasonable as if EDF can do it cheaper than BE then so long as it gets done the policy would have worked. I am also confused as in 2014 we renationalised Network Rail which surely would fall foul of any regulation that prevents new nationalised companies?

@user-ds8rj2vc4v

15 күн бұрын

Why? We have trade agreements with the EU to reduce tarrifs. The amount of trade lost from leaving the EU is minimal.

The Greens not mentioned in the intro

@howtoappearincompletely9739

19 күн бұрын

Not were Plaid Cymru. They both had good results, winning four seats each, but's those are only four seats each, unfortunately.

@mikeyacson9542

18 күн бұрын

@@jayr9952 The reason the greens are not mentioned, is because their unachievable and hypocritical policies, they would have us using horse and carts while they drive cars and fly abroad, like Caroline Lucas does, a do as I say, not do as I do sort of thing.

@msirma0077

15 күн бұрын

Who?

Good bloody luck, Steve Reed get him out

21:57 is that Katie Waissel?

Give people a chance to speak

The answer to one of the audience, is they will raise taxes. Firstly by keeping income and n.i thresholds frozen.

@tawektawek3838

15 күн бұрын

Those were already planned by the outgoing Tory government.

What I get from this...I really miss David Dimbleby.

Reform and the greens, for that matter, did very well considering how FPTP works.

Fiona is wonderful

@Ridersonthestorm8899

15 күн бұрын

Goddess

On Israel, Andrew was more honest and nuanced than expected. I would have liked more time in that part of the debate as not a lot of substance was really covered.

@user-ds8rj2vc4v

15 күн бұрын

Because it's not really of much substance of a topic. It's talking about a war in the Middle East that doesn't really have anything to do with British politics. It's only being brought up due to the large number of Islamic migrants in the past few decades.

Better should ÷ politics and some can be done outside without politics... you know...

BULLCRAP THE LOT OF IT.

Good words lads about migrant,it looks they get some kinda push about this thing...🤔...

21:55 did she think she was being clever? it was pretty f'ing obvious what was being implied with the reference to Putin

Thanks P tv

Not under is the thing but are leadership good enough...

Correct 💯... good man ...that new English ship...some edit, the words if not wrong... sabotage...

NHS better bulid new one... discard unwanted people...

...Be a man of honour... without lose country pride...

Fiona is something else.❤

@tuckedup

16 күн бұрын

yes, a posh accent pain in the arse

Correct about energy... hopefully can be well done...

can't help but like Daisy Cooper

Name calling serves no purpose other than expose the deficit of intellect.

I really feel like we're going to pay for these little laughs they got in on reform. Disregarding a party voted for by over 4 million people is beyond stupid. If labour doesn't seriously address inequality (and honestly I'm not particularly optimistic about it) reform will definitely get more seats in the next election.

@debeeriz

19 күн бұрын

depends on how well their mps perform. just like labour they are both under a lot of pressure if they want to win next time round, lets face it the tories lost this election, none of the others won it

@iainmclaughlan1557

11 күн бұрын

@@debeerizyou are right it does depend on how the MPs perform. I have joined Reform UK and applied to be a local candidate, parliamentary candidates are not open yet, but plan to apply for that.

Why does the Lib Dem woman have such massive teeth

Lib Dem total votes 3.4 million. 12% of the vote. 71 seats. Reform total votes 4 million. 14% of the vote. 4 seats. Lol

@Fab666.

12 күн бұрын

The uk isn’t a real democracy. Never has been. It hides behind fptp because it controls the narrative to allow 2 possible winners term after term

Ben Habib and Andrew Marr spoke the most sense

@marksc111

18 күн бұрын

Ben Habib spoke the most. There, fixed that for you.

@thepepper191

18 күн бұрын

You sir have brain worms. They literally said opposite things.

@Alan-vo4br

18 күн бұрын

​@@marksc111I agree he got most of the speaking time, not by much though... However I do genuinely believe they allowed it ASX because of the biased ASX audience last week for Nigel Farage, where it ASX took 6 questions to actually ask ASX about policy 😂 That audience last week was a ASX joke haha... But what is it you don't agree with ASX on what Ben Said and please ASX don't tell me he's a ASX racist 😂

Maybe they want counter balance back ...(Tax)

WHO ARE YOU!!! WHO YOU (migrant)

Not deliver,so have to give results.. yeah politics (public view) confidence....yes...so honour words(one of English value)

The Gaza Questioners.. You could tell that they were dying to shout “Free Palestine!”😂 You just know that they support Hamas, like most the supporters do.

Britain and US have stood by Israel’s position here in a way that we haven’t stood beside the dictatorships of China and Syria. Israel is being let off the hook because Britain considers Israel a key ally. In this current flower of tensions, the death toll is far more in Gaza, so it’s not an equal balance, is not equal grievance, it’s not even a war

@Fab666.

12 күн бұрын

Britain and the Us gave Israel the keys to the country along time ago, they are now in a position where they kind of need to back their horse to the end. A part of British history that gets washed over time and time again

Fiona being her usual impartial self...

It looks metal health is big thing in British.... society is sick...lose humanity...you know... have connections with human value...

Excellent. Red says, no the reds, after the the mess the blues did, are the best. Blue says, no, because of the reds, blue can do much better. Meanwhile everyone CONTINUES.

Danny Finkelstein came over well. He suggested the Conservative party do more listening and reflecting, and he demonstrated that during the programme. Unfortunately for the Tories, its leading members will pay no attention, and any good he may have done for his party has long since been undone.

Labour completely avoid hard questions 😂

“Reform got a lot of votes. What are you gong to do about that”. Nothing. They lost. Just like the Tories, Lib Dem’s and the rest. Labour have the majority so they just need to enact their policies.

4 million people, after six weeks of campaigning, more and more people will wake up to the other parties, and turn to reform, as they are still sick of the same ass.

I would rather have a proportionate representation and parties trying to work out compromises /allegiances than I would have people lying to become leaders, lying to become government, Not disclosing their true plans for tax and social care because I know it’s so hard to get that magic number and because it’s so hard to game the first past the post system.

Well done Ben....you stood up to some tough questions.

Red Andy hasn't changed since university 😆😆

Why was Habib on the panel?

@howtoappearincompletely9739

19 күн бұрын

Farage has been on dozens of times. Reform UK and its predecessor parties always get diproportionate air time.

@gratiaDei777

19 күн бұрын

Reform got 3rd most votes, more MPs than the Greens as well

@rodemadoli

16 күн бұрын

why not ??????? are the silent majority not allowed a voice ... people like you are the problem

@user-ds8rj2vc4v

15 күн бұрын

If Reform got 14% of the votes, that's 1/7th of the population. Makes sense to have them on the panel. Same reason Lib Dems who have fewer votes are also there.

The problem with two right wing parties arguing, is that the bird only flies around in circles and gets no where

Scandal not one can make that, that old story,not new government, something to do about,so call share of English people, just see them face to face as a man,let go or not,if not the trouble will continue,if they put on table so they want to be done with it....

The fact is that we need to use warming up at an alarming rate because of fossil fuels like oil causing more extreme weather

the coughing freaked me out

Immigration about to boom

@binagarten4667

16 күн бұрын

That ship has already arrived. I collected some Aussies and Kiwi relatives and they said where all the white people? I sadi they are at departure gate on a one way ticket to your countries! After arrival here they phoned up Quatas, and Air New Zealand and said we would like the first flight back to anywhere outside of England. They could not beleive the number of Mosques the lack of white people in major cities and everything being halal!

While Bruce is 'hosting' there is always an extra tory on the panel.

Same old fixed audience from the BBC shut it down

@lenabo9929

19 күн бұрын

What sort of audiance do you want?

@dragoaus

19 күн бұрын

@@lenabo9929 that actually represents electorate

@johncrawford8214

19 күн бұрын

@@lenabo9929 Not payed by BBC real people ever question time is the same time for BBC to go

@shyhistorian

19 күн бұрын

@@johncrawford8214 You know these are real people?

@Human-le9nt

19 күн бұрын

Well, on QT, very few questions get a reply.

We need tax to pay for for services otherwise you cannot have the services we take for granted

Get a five year old child to replace Fiona Bruce

They actually care it would seem and that makes a big difference because it seems like the Tories didn't. I'm glad they've been honest about the state of things it's important there's no point being stupidly optimistic you've got to be realistic with people and set their expectations realistically. We're in this situation because they were lied to and manipulated.

So Ben Habib Vs the establishment lefties!

@SteveLaw-UK

16 күн бұрын

"Establishment" is as meaningless as "woke" or "Brexit".

@AnnaP-uh3mc

16 күн бұрын

More like lying bigot carnival barker & Fiona VS sensible people with human decency.

@jamesbuesnel5054

16 күн бұрын

​@@SteveLaw-UKno it isn't

@md8955

15 күн бұрын

Ben Habib is a helmet

@fashphil

14 күн бұрын

bunch of old neoliberal crap

More negativity from the tory!

Well done Ben standing up to the lefty zealots

@paulwalker797

14 күн бұрын

Grow up. There is not a single lefty on that panel. How far right must you be to think the panel members are lefties?? As to Ben, left or right , the man is a moron.

It's good to see her constantly interrupting the Labour bloke yet lets the Reform national front bloke talk for ages. Nothing changes with this woman does it 🙄

@bensmith5231

16 күн бұрын

National Front Bloke ?? 😂 What shit you spouting?? 😂

@Pabloso213

15 күн бұрын

She derides reform as she did with the debates. Completely biased BBC. Labour only has a third of support FACT. They will do nothing and they can spin as much as they like. Britain will soon see. Until the country grows up about immigration it will only get worse.

@samusaron1

15 күн бұрын

Reform is not National Front get it right please.

@KevenHutchinson-gt1nn

15 күн бұрын

​@samusaron1 Very true, they are not called that now, they are now reform.

@user-qq5ib4js5h

15 күн бұрын

He's son of immagrant

Fiona biased as always

Politics is becoming a comedy and drama show 😂

Electoral system is something that happened to be set up hundreds of years ago , that clearly should be modified according to a changing circumstance and that is being kept in place primarily by the tories or labour refusing to discuss the reform of it because it suits them as it is . Whilst some people are against a more proportional form of representation on principle by and large it’s about serving self interest - it’s not about democracy, it’s not about what’s in the interest of the country, it literally is about what serves the interests of the main two parties

Daisy Cooper has no volume button,dreadful.

Already continue some time,wonder where army go,are they being block by politics of something happen.. borderlands or a country cannot be play is a country pride do not ever play with it , where is man of English already die..

Finkle dinkle loves himself too much

I don't like Reform but the point their guy made about why is it that Israel gets so much heat when other countries don't is 100% right- I wish they had directly put this question to the audience member who asked the Gaza question, as I suspect his answer (or lack of) would have been very telling. What lessons should Labour learn from losing a handful of seats due to their stance on this issue? Again the questioner should maybe ask himself another question- how did they manage to get 410 other seats despite this stance? Maybe because they picked the right stance?

@billjohns9488

19 күн бұрын

Because Israel is protected and supported by the West with out that support Israel would not last as long as it has.

@tomcapping2136

19 күн бұрын

@@billjohns9488 Many other countires (including some that do much worse things) are also protected by the West, and don't get remotely near the same level of criticism

@rooks4ever

18 күн бұрын

Maybe because the gvernment will call out war criminals in every case except when it comes to the terrorist stae of Israel? No one would protest if the terrorist is called, eg Saudi for the Yemenis etc. But as they supplies arms to the terrorist state of Israel and refuse to call out the literal genocide (that the UN has already done) the folk who want justice will protest against the government.

As usual bbc trying to get at reform, but Ben hold he’s own. The other are just full of them self .

In every comments section of every video even non political videos i kept seeing ''Vote Reform'' even though i'm on the left it started to make me laugh, when they won a few seats i just burst out laughing they are too funny like claiming they are not right wing is just classic comedy 😆😅🤣😂

@marksc111

18 күн бұрын

And they give them so much undeserved air time on the BBC

@JG-fv9bv

18 күн бұрын

The real right wing/far right were at Jess Philips acceptance speech shouting her down and intimidating her staff out canvassing

@lenabo9929

18 күн бұрын

@@JG-fv9bv that was the far left. Pro gaza. Do you think thr far right give a shit about gaza?

@berserker6950

17 күн бұрын

It's hilarious you still think Labour and Conservative is a choice.😅😅😅😅😅

Like disengaged and like ya know like disenfranchised like ya know....if you were disenfranchised you wouldn't be in thr QT audience?

Love ❤️ you ❤️ Douglas Murray 💋💕🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🌎👌💯👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🧡💙💖❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹

😢😢😢😢😢 Please resign today

Loaded audience and questions ,

Totally arrogant Of lord Finkelstein to say we’ve got this electoral system the favours labour and tories and this establishment centreism and therefore we’re going to keep it the main message of this election was a Voter despondency & the split electorate and it is outrageous that the reform and the greens got 20% of the vote share but one %of the seats. it is outrageous that Labour got less numbers of outright than in 2019 and only marginally higher vote share and yet declares absolute command of this parliament after spending the past four years denouncing Jeremy Corbyn as a man who could not command popular support.

@charlesoba51

15 күн бұрын

Why didn't Reform make this argument before the elections? It's trying to change the rules of the game after the game. Pretty self-serving, don't you think? Before a game, you set rules, and then you play within those rules.

Slow process investment,not at all ,if that happens, looks back who holds (keys),plan is plan but depends on English people they want or not.... yeah that fuzzy English man ... just throw him out of new English ship...

Who gotta be other side leadership....how about Jerry Springer...you know...that one in America comedian... just opinion

Ben Habib is a dissembler and lies through his teeth

Of course they havent costed them, they are exactly the same as the tories!

@rebeccarudkin5606

16 күн бұрын

Of course they are! 🤦‍♀️

@themasteryourdaddy.6307

16 күн бұрын

Kier Stamer is Tony Blair 2.0, he's turned Labour into the tories. Him and his party are going to be crappie and the same.

@TrevorWilliams-fq8mg

16 күн бұрын

Fully coated, just like HS2 was fully costed.

Just get lost FB

British political debate is so childish. Everyone trying to talk over each other to make 'gotcha' points. It's pathetic. All I learned form this debate, like so many others, is that Britain is the wealthiest failed state on Earth

@portzi2

19 күн бұрын

When the left wingers started to mention dog whistle then they have no facts just slander😢

@LuzDoSol-yr5bv

19 күн бұрын

Have you not gotten a bit of an optimistic view for the future? It's all too soon, but at least we got a chance for some kind of change. No?

@realjprc

19 күн бұрын

As a Canadian I enjoy British political discourse it’s so much more interesting than Canadian politics

@insertnamehere7630

19 күн бұрын

Lol. You should have watched the US presidential debate

@regkray

18 күн бұрын

Name a country where political debate is less childish...

GAZA WHATS THAT GOT TO WITH US ?

Why is it not obvious that every single problem with NHS, sewerage, power etc have one massive thing in common and that's far too many people suddenly requiring each service! We can't keep letting more people in without infrastructure which takes huge amount of time. NHS wastes too much money but also had far too many people using the service, water and sewerage infrastructure is mostly ancient with very slow upgrades and now with huge amount of people it can't cope, power again more people with more electric devices to quickly and upgrades to slow to keep up. Every problem stems to same issue, population growth is far too large for infrastructure and needs to stop then be balanced with what we can cope with. Just trying to pump more money into every service isn't the answer at all, yes everything needs money to upgrade but a realistic time frame needs to be put in place as all of these services took absolutely years to sustain population growth at a similar level for decades then boom we open borders and then people wonder why all our services can't cope? Just makes me furious when MPs keep saying it's lack of money what's caused the problem when it's impossible to keep up. All these parties angry at water and sewerage issues(quite rightly) but they want to build thousands of new homes for thousands of new people even though our ancient services can't cope now. Definition of madness

@Fab666.

12 күн бұрын

The uk government and media is terrified of saying no to immigration in fear of being labelled racist.. it’s really that simple. Reason being they have a history of mass colonialism and every country with this kind of history seems to catapult in the opposite direction sooner or later. It’s madness but obvious when u examine it

Impressed with Ben Habib as he once again walks into the lions den with dignity despite the interruptions, smears, condescension and pile ons. The attempts to misrepresent him were very distasteful. Must be doing something right.

@GoTfan-eb8tk

17 күн бұрын

'Dereuglate the economy'-Truss tried that. The markets went into freefall. 'Align with the EU'-Well Brexit has been going so well half the country wants to rejoin the EU 'Driving to net zero is economic emasculation'-The rest of the world is shifting towards net zero; the Eu and other countries are toying with putting a tax on high carbon emitters.

Who runs the world?

laboue and lib dems called for proportional representation, l wonder if they feel the same way now

@garystevens4303

18 күн бұрын

It's a good point though. Reform get 14% and only 5 seats compared to lib dems 12% & 72..🤔🤔

@Blorp_

16 күн бұрын

Lib Dem’s yes, but I dont think the Labour Party have ever had PR in their manifesto

@person876

16 күн бұрын

Lib Dems likely still would as their vote share Vs seat share is almost the same

@beasmith1

16 күн бұрын

Hopefully not, I used to support it, but now I know how it works, it's best as it is, representing each constituency.

@johnmorris2414

16 күн бұрын

Maybe, but we had a referendum in 2010.

thought bbc was bias and reform were boycotting

Reform have no clue about politics

Worst chairperson Fiona Bruce

Notice how Fiona lets Ben Habib drone on about his anti EU nonsense for several minutes but barely lets the labour guy get a word in before interrupting? So maddening

@marksc111

18 күн бұрын

Ugh... Girl in audience asks the labour and lib dem panel guests a question, and Fiona lets Ben Habib answer it instead. Impartial my fat aarse

This programme has had its day just word salad & bickering takes sensible veiwers for fools . That's dumbing down folks

So still a Tory heavy panel

Fiona's live shows are spectacular.

@MalcolmMacKenzie-ou1mt

19 күн бұрын

@malcolmpalmer569 My fellow Malcolm, no they are not, they are contrived with a left wing audience and conservative guests are spoken over in typical BBC fashion.

@danielgiansante9987

18 күн бұрын

@@MalcolmMacKenzie-ou1mt How many total minutes did Habib speak, and how does that compare to the total speaking minutes of each other panel member?

@binagarten4667

16 күн бұрын

@@MalcolmMacKenzie-ou1mt Well said!