Qazi Faez Isa Loses Majority As 8 Judges Decide Reserved Seats Case In PTI Favour, Shehbaz Out?
PTI has been given reserved seats in an 8-5 decision by the Supreme Court of Pakistan. Chief Justice Qazi Faez Isa was on the minority side in the judgement. The 'controversial' decision could have far reaching consequences for national politics as well.
We have senior lawyers Asad Jamal and Idrees Ashraf to discuss the legal points while senior journalist Aijaz Ahmed comments on the political repercussions of the judgement in today's episode of #KhabarSayAagay with Raza Rumi
#NayaDaur #khabarsayaagay #atharminallah #qazifaezisa #reservedseats #pti #politics #pakistan
Пікірлер: 129
رضا رومی صاحب کو مبارکباد کہ ان کا کلٹ جیت گیا۔ وہ پیپلز پارٹی کی حمایت کے لبادے میں نیازی کو سپورٹ کرتے ہیں۔
QFE -comes out standing tall -did not try to manipulate or bring in only like minded judges!
نظریہ ضرورت کے بعد پیش ہے نظریہ چاہت
جوڈیشل مارشل لا۔۔۔
پنامہ سے اقامہ نکلا تو سنی اتحاد کونسل کی پٹیشن سے پی ٹی آئ نکل آئ یہ تو پرانا معجزہ ہے ۔
وقت نے ثابت کیا کے جنرل عاصم منیر جنرل باجوا کی طرح نہیں ہیں اور چیف جسٹس قاضی فیض عیسیٰ جسٹس بُندیال کی طرح نہیں ہیں
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
kaise?
اعجاز صاحب کا سیاسی تجزیہ بہت حقیقت پر مبنی ہے۔
فوج ژندہ باد ۔۔۔ملک کی وحدت سر آنکھوں پر
Qazi fauj extention isa zindabad
This is a very good example of the result of indulging in Political Engineering. There was no need for all this confusion and nonsense if the Constitution and Rule of Law was followed by all Institutions.
Raza Rumi a stellar program. Shabaash!
کچھ نہیں ہو گا رضا پانی کبھی کا سر سے گزر چکا ہے ۔
اطہر من اللہُ جیت گئیے مگر آئین ہار گیا
یہ بلکل درست بات کررہےہیں
اسلام علیکم جناب یہ سب شہباز شریف کا کیا دھرا ہے بندیال کی فرمائش پہ جج دیئے
قاضی فائز عیسی نے اپنی ساکھ بجائی اور اظہر من اللہ نے پی ٹی آئی بجا ئی اس لیے دونوں ک فیصلوں میں زمین آسمان کا فرق ھے یہ اب آپ سوج لیں کہ اظہر من اللہ جیتے ہیں یا قاضی فائز عیسی۔۔۔
Nice discussion
PTI nay mulk aur awam ke barbadi k Siwa Kya keya hy
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
try pdm instead of pti,then you will be right😝
مخصوص نشستوں کے کیس کے فیصلے نے ثابت کر دیا کہ نواز لیگ میں بیٹھے وکٹ کے دونوں جانب کھیلنے والوں نے ہتھوڑا گروپ کیلئے جمہوریت کو نقصان پہنچانے کا موقع فراہم کر دیا ۔۔اسی لئے صدر آصف علی زرداری نے فیصلے سے ایک دن پہلے نون لیگ سے حکومت نہ چلنے کا بیان دیا ۔۔
What s benefits of high stock market for the poors.
What does that even mean. QFI. Loses majority. Why should there even be a grouping. What a stupid caption
@ikramulhaq7883
23 күн бұрын
💯
It is wrong to assume, without credible evidence, that partisan media in some way influenced the majority of the honourable judges. If anyone is to blame, these are the political parties who are unable to resolve issues among themselves and go running to courts like crybabies, forgetting they were elected to serve the people in the first place. At this rate, the country could end up like Punjab after Ranjit Singh's death with warring Sikh 'jathas', which made it easy for a foreign power to take over. The politicians were elected to run the country not for themselves but for the people. They need to grow up and act responsibly. The same applies to all of the other institutions of the state.
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
yes for the people,not to make illegal govt of form 47
نیا دور سے سوال ہے کہ کیا اس فیصلے کے بعد ہم یہ کہہ سکتے ہیں کہ its judicial jerrymandering!
Good analysis
Rumi is very happy 😂
if courts provide the same nature of justice in other cases because in all cases they provide relief according to prayers
Its REWRITING of Constitution,
sir najam sethi sub ko be online hu ap week main 1 dafa jasay phly ftiday ko wo atay thay najam sethi k baghair ap k prog bilkul ada ha sir
SUNNY ITHIAD NAI APPLICATION SUBMIT KI PTI NAI NAHI BUT CLEAN CHIT DAI DI PTI KOU 140 JUDICIARY
Only Supreem Court is incomplete pl say SC 138/140.Chamber is not for correction. is it political offices?
❤❤❤❤❤😊
قاضى اور مندو اپنا سر بچا رہہےالکشن قاميشن پرالظام ديں رہہے ہہے
justice dena court ka kaam nahin to kya establishment ka hai?ya political parties ka hai?
مارشل لا ژندہ باد
Welcome Martial Law ! Welcome ! Totally agree with you about Martial law !!
@OliJones-zw8hb
23 күн бұрын
It aint gonna happen
Thank God they just stopped short of releasing Imran Khan from all cases. AISH KARO😂😂
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
Will thank Allah when imran khan is out
maine google kiya,aisa koi rule nahin mila ki symbol na ho to election nahin ladha ja sakta
*Be slow and patient as the four [4] SPLIT judgements- orders need to be read minutely and understood in-juxta-postion of each others as apparently in result thereof, some members may face QUITE SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES on account of their mistakes committed. * Further there seems a serious VIOLATION THE OF LAW OF NATURAL JUSTICE R/W ARTICLE 10- A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN in respect of the vested rights of the members on the reserved seats. * Nonetheless, let wait for the proper appreciation upon close reading of the detailed REASONS to be followed in support of the four [4] SPLIT orders- judgments. * In the meanwhile, enjoy the SHOCKS - AFTERSHOCKS of the prevailing THAGHOOTHI SYSTEM with wa, wa, wa and no, no, no.
Qazi Sahib ♥️
@OliJones-zw8hb
22 күн бұрын
Qazi fauj extention isa zindabad
رومی صاحب ،،،ان کاروباری سیاست دانوں ،،،اور چند اداروں ،،، مہنگائی، بجلی،، گیس،، ٹیکسوں ،، اور حکمرانوں کی عوام کے مسائل کے حل کرنے میں عدم دلچسپی نے قوم کو اعصابی مریض بنا دیا ،،،
@ikramulhaq7883
23 күн бұрын
💯
party pti hi thi,chahe sunni concil ke zariye ho pehle ya baad mein khud judhi ho,sunni council ka naam suna tha usse pehle jab ec ne pti members ko independent kiya?
koi bhi law constitution vki spirit ke kgilaaf nahin ho sakta,right to vote ke khilaaf hota agar dusri parties ko seaats mil jaati
کیا ۱۸۷ مین مکمل انصاف کے لیے، قانون کے الفاظ کی بجائے، صورتحال دیکھنے کی گنجائش ہے؟ کہ فیصلہ اس کے حق میں جائے، جس نے درخواست ہی نہیں دی۔
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
pti became part after qazi questioned pti is not part of case
ادریس صاحب آئین کے مطابق بات کر رہے ہیں جب کہ دوسرے صاحب نظریہ ضرورت کو سپورٹ کر رہے ہیں۔
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
achchha?kaise?aain kya hai?
اگر اس وقت حکومت نے عطا بندیال ، اعجاالاحسن اور منیب اختر کے خلاف 63A میں آئین کی تشریح کے نام پر آئینی ترمیم کرنے کے جرم میں ایکشن لیا ہوتا تو آج منصور شاہ اور اطہر من اللہ بھی یہ جرات نہ کرتے ۔
Shahbaz sharif ko chahy abhi Hakomat khtm kry inshallah petrol 400 Rupees litr sy up ho jay ga Roti 50 ke koi b Pakistan mein inwist nhi kry ga
@MS-dg9rq
23 күн бұрын
Well said
جو کچھ سیکیورٹی کی حد تک کے پی اور بلوچستان میں ہو رہا ہے اسے ان غیر یقینی سیاسی حالات میں کنٹرول کرنا انتہائی مشکل ہو گا لہذا جلد ہی چائینا پاکستان کو write off کر دے گا اور امریکہ ان حالات میں جوہری ہتھیاروں کو بین الاقوامی نگرانی میں دینے کی ڈیمانڈ کرے گا خاص طور پر اگر ٹرمپ امریکہ کا صدر بن جاتا ہے-
sc ke saare judges including qazi fae in kaha ki ec ne bat wale faisle ki galat interpretation ki,yeh wakeel sahab kya sc ke saare kya zyada kaabil hain?
فیصلہ میں خرابی نہیں آپ کے ذہن میں خرابی ھے
Ain re write huwa hy isy faisla nai keh sakty sir
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
kaise?
W S 🎉🎉🎉 After Bindal court today once again SC thrown the constitution in a dust bin which will create instability in the country. 😢😢
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
constitution kya kehta hai?
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
constitution tab toda gaya tha jab 90 din mein election nahin hue the,aur ek party ko election contest nahin karne diya gaya
ifris khud hi sc mein pmln ki taraf se case ladh lein,khud ko itna kaabil maante hain to
phir idris jhooth bola,kpk mein sabne pti se hi election ladhne ke form diye the, independent ec ne declare kiya jo galat tha
نیا دور ۔ پاکستان ہمیشہ ایسے فیصلوں کی وجہ سے ہی تمام دنیا سے کٹ کر تمام اقوام میں پیچھے رہ گیا ہے ۔ کیا بات ہے آٹھ ججوں کی عقل نظیر کو ۔
Nazrya zaroorst aj k fasle main kya hai .
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
justice
تاریخ اس فیصلے کو کبھی بھی عدالتی مثال کے طور پر نہیں لے گی اور آنے والی عدلیہ اسے بھی بھٹو پھانسی کیس کی طرح اور پانامہ کیس کی طرح یاد رکھے گی ۔۔۔۔۔
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
you know future?
A reasonable verdict given in a wrong way. Court should allow all those elected as independent to use three days to join any party again. Election symbol verdict of election commission and Supreme court were right, but after contesting as independent, the winning independent candidates should be given right to join or become a parliamentary party, in this case PTI in the assemblies, here the matter of taking away election symbol finishes as there is no election symbol within assembly elections anymore. All those winning as independent have right to reformation of their like minded group as a political party. Then these independent candidates after becoming or aligning with a party be give ratio of special seats accordingly. In the existing verdict, many questions arise which are against the rules. How they determined 39 PTI candidates, when after filing their party affiliation contested as independent and later joining Sunni Ittehad, is one of the main question and the rest 40 were not, who rejoined PTI after winning elections. The decision is basically still an incomplete justice.
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
because they file to contest election as pti member,but election commission wrongly declared them independent
@labeeb241
22 күн бұрын
@@Aaa-mv6rd They filed, then why only 39 such identified? And if ECP told them they are independent, they said ok and contested as independent, they didn’t oppose or contested this decision. Then again they joined Sunni Ittehad, why that was needed? And then also tried to get their quota members as Sunni Ittehad candidates.
@Aaa-mv6rd
22 күн бұрын
@@labeeb241 maybe others didn't filed for pti when ro's told them it will not be admitted,not all are equally informed,salman akram raja is advocate so he did everything right to keep evidences,after ec told them they can only contest as independents they filed other as independents,in between they filed one with pti nazriyati but ec didn't accept those saying after admitted with one party(pti)they can't file with second party,after they won as independents they had to join a party,they were confused about status of pti because pti was refused to contest elections,they first chose a party something as majlis...,but decided to go to sunni later,you should understand they were fighting against ec which was ready to do anything to stop pti .
@Aaa-mv6rd
22 күн бұрын
@@labeeb241 they tried to get quota as sunni ittehaad ,yes what they could have done,status of pti was not clear,in this case qazi fae isa repeatedly refused to listen side of pti saying pti is not part of case,so pti decided to become part of case and applied for it,in this case status of pti was cleared that it is still a parliamentary party and ec wrongly stopped it from contesting elections,even qazi fae isa admitted it
@labeeb241
22 күн бұрын
@@Aaa-mv6rd So this is what I am saying, the issue arose with the confusion of candidates and then their joining Miili Ittehad on the same note. Neither SC nor ECP were wrong in their decisions. Remaining a PTI contestant for half and choosing the other path by half, if that was the situation, party can have a unified stance rather then leaving this to individuals.
نیا دور , جنرل ضیاء الحق اور جنرل مشرف کا نظریہء ضرورت اک دفعہ پھر جیت کر سیاسی موڑ میں پاکستان کو دلدل میں دھنسانے میں اک اور سنگ میل ثابت ہوا ہے
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
theory of necessity tab jeeti thi jab bat chheena tha aur uske nateeje mein pti ko election contest nahin karne diya gaya
@aamir.s500
21 күн бұрын
@@Aaa-mv6rd آپ بہت بڑی غلطی پر ہیں پی ٹی آٸ نے پارٹی الیکشن میں تاخیری حربے استعمال کرکے سزا کھاٸ اور پارٹی کے نشان سے ہاتھ دھویا ۔ اسی بنا پر پارٹی الیکشن میں بغیر نشان کے اور بغیر نوٹیفیکیشن کے امیدواروں کو پارٹی ٹکٹ نہ دے سکی اور دٸیۓ تو بعض میں اختلاف شدید ہوا اور اب پارٹی بہت بڑے عدالتی بحران کے نتیجے میں پریشانی کا منہ دیکھ رہی ہے اس تمام اثناء میں اب محض نظریہء ضرورت کے تحت تمام مسٸلوں کا شکار ہے ۔
Very bad guy for your show
totally agree with asad jamal baqi participants tu lagta hai noon league ke payroll pe hain
یوتھیے بہت آپشن ہیں فکر نہ کر
It’s mockery of justice. These eight people are really funny😂😂😂
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
u are funny,you think you are more eligible than all judges😝😝😝
Millions lanat on youthia judges...
@Aaa-mv6rd
23 күн бұрын
billions laanat on patwari like u
@OliJones-zw8hb
22 күн бұрын
Youthia is the future get over it
@Aaa-mv6rd
22 күн бұрын
@@OliJones-zw8hb right,these rotten eggs cai get over themselves,😝😝😝youth is the future of a nation and it will be of pakistan as well ,youth ko gaali dekar apni dimaagi haalat dikha rahe hain patwari
Nice discussion
اگر اس وقت حکومت نے عطا بندیال ، اعجاالاحسن اور منیب اختر کے خلاف 63A میں آئین کی تشریح کے نام پر آئینی ترمیم کرنے کے جرم میں ایکشن لیا ہوتا تو آج منصور شاہ اور اطہر من اللہ بھی یہ جرات نہ کرتے ۔
Nice discussion
Nice discussion
Nice discussion
Nice discussion