Putin just changed EVERYTHING and Shoigu is Out ft. Scott Ritter
Ойын-сауық
Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu has been removed from his post as Putin undertakes massive reshuffling of his cabinet. The Western media is celebrating the change as a sign of crisis in Russia. Is it? This video breaks it down.
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL ON PATREON:
/ dannyhaiphong
Support the channel in other ways:
www.buymeacoffee.com/dannyhai...
Substack: chroniclesofhaiphong.substack.com
Cashapp: $Dhaiphong
Venmo: @dannyH2020
Paypal: paypal.me/spiritofho
Follow me on Telegram: t.me/dannyhaiphong
Putin just changed EVERYTHING and Shoigu is Out ft. Scott Ritter
#Shoigu #Putin #russia
Пікірлер: 448
Independent media is under attack! Please support this show on Patreon at Patreon.com/dannyhaiphong to ensure this channel remains sustainable. Other options for support including substack and Buy me a coffee are in the video description!
@pingpong7810
17 күн бұрын
Hongkong freedom 🌎🫡😮
@uncle_Samssubjects
17 күн бұрын
Be smart eat 100 year old Goldenberg ration bars. Hungry? Eat what the real men ate, eat Peanut chews and stop suffering from Low T.
@niket527
17 күн бұрын
Bro the vid says "featuring Scott Ritter" but you don't interview him. Rather you play a clip from someone else interviewing him. Honestly your video should be reported for click bait
@bassmit2304
17 күн бұрын
please stop with the clickbait videos, saying so and so changed EVERYTHING, and saying ft. so and so and then not having them on your show but just playing a clip, really lame stuff. Also Shoigu is not Out ffs, he got promoted djeez
@petersmeets7626
16 күн бұрын
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
According to Chinese media, Shoigu got promoted
@myview1875
17 күн бұрын
He has and his new job is higher than his old job. 🙂.
@pet0lm488
17 күн бұрын
He was assign to Security Council + as director for whole RU Military Industrial Complex... so yes, he was promoted
@lexburen5932
17 күн бұрын
yes he got promotoed as head for the russian security council, wich is a higher position then his " old " job.
@lilacer6841
17 күн бұрын
@@holdinmuhl4959he was promoted. He is best friend if Putin he wanted to retire but Putin wants him to head the security council. He replaces Patrushev who is a hard liner and wants total war.
@milanmarinkovic3016
17 күн бұрын
@@holdinmuhl4959 Totally wrong. Just look at what Secretary of Security Council does. He is replacing Nikolai Patrushev........
Shoigu is now in charge of the entire Russian military industrial complex. You could not appoint him to a better position.
@pvajit1109
17 күн бұрын
Shoigu is expert in this field.
@thewedge8823
17 күн бұрын
Then what is Belousov gonna do then?
@jacquescousteau217
17 күн бұрын
Congratulations to President Vladimir Putin on his re-election. I’m an American ,and I follow politics as best I can on a global scale. Zellenskyy like Biden are both criminals that have no interest in what is best for the American people. Our news media is all propaganda. We were even told if Tucker Carlson ever went to Russia to interview President Putin that he would never come back to the USA alive. That’s the type of warmongering we have in the USA . I admire President Putins intelligence, and his ideology that is aligned with diplomacy, not warmongering rhetoric we hear in the West. NATO should be abolished ! One must remember, a majority of Americans are not educated . People over fifty or possibly sixty years old get their geopolitical news from pundits that know nothing. We have a program called the VIEW. This show is anathema to any intelligent person, yet its viewers are mostly middle to late stage of life females that believe what these ignorant grifters spew . I live in San Francisco, and spent my formative years in Palo Alto aka Silicon Valley. It was a different world than it once was, technology has been the bane of mankind in the west . Free speech is one thing, free clothes,money,cars,and food is another thing, we have no laws for these criminals that have destroyed our major cities under this progressive umbrella of hypocrites that have made the victims in this country the criminals, and the criminals the victims. I’m an old man now;however, if I was younger in this period of time, I would be looking into moving to Russia, albeit I don’t speak a word of the language . With that said. Everything I’ve seen on social media sans politics shows Russia appearing more like the USA I grew up in. Your wealth distribution,infrastructure,architecture,history, and from what I’ve gleaned hearing President Putin speak about aligns with my ideology. I apology for every thinking American for what we have facilitated in favour of the Ukrainians corrupt government that our political leaders have embraced . Biden, and Trump are in reality the same . We have a Uniparty, we don’t have fair or balanced elections. Everything in our political sphere is preordained by capitalists . The man or woman with the most lucre wins . That’s not Democracy ! Now do I press send, and expect a visit from someone tomorrow or am I a man that from what I believe is right press send ?
@Peaceiseverything541
17 күн бұрын
@@thewedge8823 kzread.info/dash/bejne/dHp-pteKgrGqgpc.html
@nvs2815
17 күн бұрын
*But JOKER PUTIN THREATENS NUCLEAR ATTACK DAILY 808 DAYS. DON'T take PUTLER SERIOUSLY* 👿👿👿
So happy Lavrov is staying! He is the Master.
@jamesevans3492
17 күн бұрын
Yes, He's A Master Of Good In The Force . . . :-)
@user-ju3xv1xx5z
17 күн бұрын
Yes, class diplomat. Very Intelligent, elegant humour. Charming. Worried he’d finally retire.
@Meld61
17 күн бұрын
👍
@fuckthat132
16 күн бұрын
Joda
@lelanalela7932
12 күн бұрын
Legendary diplomat , Mr Sergei Lavrov . Highly intelligent , superbly educated ,gentleman head to toe . Hopefully he has someone in training to continue when he retires .
Shoigu is now more or less the Defence Ministers' boss.
@mikecimerian6913
17 күн бұрын
He holds a PhD in economics of industrial production. This job is closer to his number one skillset.
@JimCOsd55
16 күн бұрын
Really … did you know or have you even heard Belousov’s name mentioned before this? Did you ever see him in a meeting with Putin and Shoighu? Nope, so I’m guessing unlike Shoighu’s deputy who was arrested for corruption, Putin decided to only push him out of the way???
@AlexSpb871
16 күн бұрын
No he is not. It is wrong information about Russian government structure.
@tomaskinoshta7589
16 күн бұрын
correct
1 country Russia - making the collective west tremble. 😂🤣
@Lucia-sy7le
17 күн бұрын
They are a very good example of how to govern under duress.
@RoCK3rAD
17 күн бұрын
Russia shows us they’re not afraid of war except with any NATO state
@denizkizilates3063
16 күн бұрын
I wouldn't go that far. Russia is just fighting against an army which has been armed with disposable NATO weapons and intelligence. Russia would crumble within a month against the full might of NATO capabililities. The west might be afraid to shift their way of life for the sake of Ukraine but if the shit comes to show they surely will
@lelanalela7932
12 күн бұрын
NATO states shouldn't worry about Russia. They better worry about illegals who invaded their countries without a drop of blood and driving them in to misery .
@lelanalela7932
12 күн бұрын
NATO states shouldn't worry about Russia. They better worry about illegal invaders.
Shoigu is in better, important and sensitive position. Westerners leaders don’t have any things else to do.🦅💪🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺👍🦅
@oliveeisner8964
17 күн бұрын
They're playing their parts perfectly. What do you mean? They couldn't have picked better "losers."
@Sammyli99
17 күн бұрын
soon, retired. All of the West in an OAP Home.
Our media must look like clowns to Russia when they spin a promotion as a sacking. Unbelievable.
Shoigu is promoted guys ! After 12 years as MOD now is much higher and closer to The President !
@mikecimerian6913
17 күн бұрын
The last few years were very demanding in terms of continuity. As for president, nah not really. He is a stern and demanding fellow and he can be too abrasive to use baby gloves when circumstances require it.
@ryanwalters6184
17 күн бұрын
Hopefully not too high and not near a window.
@eliasphiniotis
17 күн бұрын
@@mikecimerian6913 Ideal friend and soldier
@eliasphiniotis
17 күн бұрын
@@ryanwalters6184 Those days are over !
@JimCOsd55
16 күн бұрын
@@eliasphiniotisI’m guessing that Shoighu is happy that he’s only being promoted rather than being arrested like his deputy Ivanov was last month … it was only a matter of time for his dismissal!??
Russia is the catalyst for real democracy in a world where the US has dominated the political affairs of numerous countries.
@martinbisschoff988
17 күн бұрын
I will not even use the word 'democracy.' I will call it the catalyst for "sanity.' For the entire planet.
@chrismcmorrow9738
16 күн бұрын
The U.S. has become woke trash. Because of rampant Liberalism I.e., it’s departure from Calvinist Protestant Christianity), “America” has now become a shining city on a dung hill.
Shoigu will be leader of the entire Russian Military industrial complex.
@mikecimerian6913
17 күн бұрын
And two other duties to top it all. No rest for the braves.
Lavrov is the best diplomat ever as well as a true Russian Patriot. Russia is beyond extremely fortunate that he is willing to continue in his position. Similarly, General Gerasimov is a superbly competent military leader with an outstanding background for his position as Chief of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces. He has an extremely thorough and rigorous Russian military education in addition to his combat experience. As a child, after fourth grade Gerasimov's father sent his application for admission to the Kazan Suvorov Military School which Gerasimov entered as soon as he was able to. Four years later in 1971 he graduated from the Suvorov military school in 1973 with a gold medal and was then admitted to the four-year Kazan Higher Tank Command School for officers from which he graduated with honors in 1977. He then began his service in Poland where he rose to tank company commander and tank battalion chief of staff. In 1984 he was admitted to the Malinovsky Military Armored Forces Academy advanced officer training. Graduating with honors in 1987. Subsequently in 1995 he was selected to attend the Military Academy of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Russia, graduating with honors in 1997.
Shotgun got a promotion he is in charge of the military industrial complex.
@reload.8056
17 күн бұрын
Shotgun! Now that's a good one
@HiArashi13
17 күн бұрын
@@reload.8056 Shogun would be even closer to his previous post.
God Bless President Putin ! UUURRRAA 🇷🇺 🎖️ 🇷🇺 🙏💞
@petersmeets7626
17 күн бұрын
Hahahahahahahahahaha👎
@brigittehoffmann8965
15 күн бұрын
@@petersmeets7626 yeah, you are right: you ARE quite laughable. And your user name is beyond cringe.How's the view from your mama's basement?!?
Shoigu was promoted, not removed, to a more important position.
@mikecimerian6913
17 күн бұрын
Shoigu is promoted. He now wears three hats. His replacement is a formidable team player of an economist.
I am impressed by the flexibility and creativity of the Russian government.
@petersmeets7626
17 күн бұрын
Hahahahaha 😂
@cyclonejane
17 күн бұрын
Yes. And the brilliance of the Russian Federation’s President. It’s telling that Putin can arrange the personnel. In the US, that’s done for, not by, the figurehead living in the White House.
@daveyjuice7710
17 күн бұрын
Indeed a group of men experienced are becoming a group of men with wisdom. I've rarely seen this or read about this type of progress in society.
@ronnyhelsing7499
17 күн бұрын
They allways have high educated people employed.
@Rick-sr5oj
16 күн бұрын
As opposed to the idiots in the US government .... or Europe now .... yes Russia is quite impressive.
It is so strange to see in the Russophobic totalitarian West people who understand and support Russia. Thank you, спасибо
@corvusduluthV2
17 күн бұрын
Mnp 6paT.
@randyindvik1171
17 күн бұрын
I think there are people who choke on the lies fed to them in support of actions that are against their morals. Rather than solely supporting Russia, they support truth over narrative. Objectively, Russia is on the correct side of truth. Translation, "Just because they are 'Putin's Talking Points', it does not mean they are lies. Expanding the US strategic border (think US Monroe doctrine) to the Russian border made/makes no sense.
@RoCK3rAD
17 күн бұрын
The west is not Russiphobic hundreds of thousands of Russian people live here in America. The west also isn’t totalitarian I maybe disagree with my government but don’t lie
@user-dy7ze2ey8q
17 күн бұрын
There are a hundred million Americans who love, respect Russia! We pray for the Russian people everyday!❤
@user-ju3xv1xx5z
17 күн бұрын
Russia didn’t have to do much. Just consistently faithful to their ways, wisely not reacting to infantile tantrums, hysterics, delinquent school backyards bullying tactics of hegemons. Russia (and China and the rest of observing world) understands west particularly usa is having an impossibly hard time losing their grip. So their patience accentuates even more what are being exposed by the west themselves - thanks to the courageous, intelligent, principled west alternative media like this one for their authentic journalistic work.
That's a promotion, not a removal.
@mikecimerian6913
17 күн бұрын
A big one with three hats.
Russia shifts their generals around so they don't get stale or predictable. Military to Russia isn't a ladder to a cushy board ot political job. Military is for winning battles for the motherland
Great report dude. Very uplifting. But very sad for America my my country. Hopefully our people quit fighting each other for the global bankster corporations.
Shoigu promoted!
Shougu is out This is false Shougu was elevated to the most powerful post of Putin's advisory counsel Shougu now holds the 3 highest posts Scott Ritter is completely wrong on this one. The counsel is virtually unknown by the west. It is somewhat like the join chiefs of staff for the military, In Russia this counsel is in charge of the military, The military industrial complex, The economy, And other related things. This is the core group that runs everything in Russia and advises Putin. Shougu is now the top dog there. .
Putin has promoted his Minister of Defence, not sacked him
Shoigu has been promoted to what is the second most powerful position in Russian politics. His replacement is an economics master and you watch how the Russian MIC advances in new technologies at economic management.
@jetset8090
17 күн бұрын
Good Financial Management underpins the Russian Success story, IE Safari Has Just Blocked the Australian Debt Clock.
They seem to not understand that Shoigu was also a civilian. Are they fooled by the military uniform. That's a formality for the Minister.
Shoigu got promoted, running production of the military complex.
The mainstream media have always got it wrong...shoigu promoted in the Russian reshuffle...next guy probably more serious.
Shoigu was assign to Security Council, what in RU is one of top spots!! + he is gonna take Medved place, charge of whole RU Military Industrial Complex... so he was promoted!!
@AlexSpb871
16 күн бұрын
He is not taking any place. Medvedev stayed where he was -- Deputy Chairman of the Security Council of the Russian Federation. Shoigu -- secretary of the Security Council.
@pet0lm488
16 күн бұрын
@@AlexSpb871 Medved last apointment was charge of all MIC... what are you talking about?? so Shoigu gonna take his place in this case ;)... take more info
Shoigu is UP, he's definitely not out!
Like any successful business you make management changes when your business moves into another phase. 💯
One man's purge is another man's reshuffle. Shoigu got promoted.
Shoigu is the most trusted Putin's man. If he moved to somewhere, it doesn't mean things was going bad under Shoigu, it means things was going bad at position to where Shoigu was moved too. Just for context, Shoigu was a head of ministry of emergency situations on the 90s, the most turbulent times in Russia. And I believe it was the only functioning ministry at the time.
NIkolai Patrushev will retire soon he is nearly 73 year's old have been in powerful position since the time of USSR/1992/. Shoigu asked to retire back 2021 but Putin convince him to stay put .The allegations against his anchorage in ministry of defense changed Putin prospective and Belov was put there to clear house and make the ministry more officiant and clean from corruption.
Out 😂😂😂 he got the top job...
Biden could never walk like that 😂
western media be like : Ukraine remove Zaluzhny after failed summer counteroffensive 😪😪 Russia remove shoigu after taking adiivka 🧐🧐
@marcobsomer5574
17 күн бұрын
il n'est pas retiré, il est promu.
@lelanalela7932
12 күн бұрын
Grandma dreams what grandma likes !!😂
But no, these are not purges. Wait and you will understand!
The instant reaction from the koolaiders was that Russia must be getting desperate. 😅 Absolutely zero context. Once these people are proven wrong, they will simply jump on another bandwagon.
Purge? I think not. Just restructuring the Military to suit the different phases of the War.
I heard Shoigu was promoted....
This war is ridiculous. $500 Walmart drone destroys $200.000.000 tank. Can not they make nice chair on top of the tank, give guy a shut gun with bird loads?
@galgalimeyes91
17 күн бұрын
Shhhhhhhh gin 😂
From X : Since not everyone understands what the Security Council is and what the appointment of Shoigu as its secretary means, a few words of clarification: ✔️ The Security Council is the most important body making strategic decisions on key issues in the life of the country. Some compare it with the boyar duma, which is similar in form, but not true in essence. ✔️ It is with the Security Council that Putin discusses strategic issues weekly - in 99 cases out of 100, behind closed doors, only the topic is known. For example, members of the Security Council in February 2022 publicly discussed the acceptance of appeals from the DPR and LPR. ✔️ Secretary of the Security Council is by no means an honorary pension, but an expansion of capabilities and functions after the Ministry of Defense. In fact, this is the entire power unit in one place, and not only that. ✔️ The Chairman of the Security Council of the Russian Federation ex officio is the President of the Russian Federation, that is, Putin personally. The Secretary directs the work of the Security Council itself. Deputy Chairman of the Security Council Dmitry Medvedev reports to Putin. ✔️ Those who have already announced Shoigu’s departure from politics have gotten very excited.
@fryavanbosh3563
16 күн бұрын
Dank voor deze belangrijke informatie ! Gr. Frya
Mais non, Poutine commemce un nouveau mandat de président et remanie son gouvernement C'este fonctionnent normal d'une démocratie..D'ailleurs Shoïgu est mis à un poste prestigieux Il faut arrêter de prendre Poutine pour Staline
No " Purge " at all….But optimizing armed forces of RF and bringing it on highest level ever…
Wasn't Shoigu due for retirement in 2022? Sounds like he was promoted.
My boy Lavrov still in office 🎉
@TruthSeeker1511
17 күн бұрын
😂💪🏻
THSTS BECAUSE THEY SRE IGNORANTS SHOIGU PAY ATTENTION WAS PROMOTED SHOIGU IS NOW ON THE SECURITY COUNCIL AND THATS THE BIGGEST ORGANISM
Always interesting views from your channel DH .
This is a ground pounder war.
The more I listen to Mr. Ritter the more I realised he have a big heart 💜
Putin moving Shoigu, is a promotion for Shoigu [DEFENSE SECURITY} and the start of reconstituting the Soviet Union..
NOTE, updated rosters. Team A: Biden, Blinken, Sullivan, Kirby, Burns, Austin, and Nuland Vs Team R: Putin, Medvedev, Lavrov, Shoigo, Garasamov, Belousav, and Zakharova Hmmmm, vote for which team is more competant Team A or Team R:
@Tamara-nn1wr
17 күн бұрын
You forgot Mr. S. Lavrov, he stays on with 20 years experience and speaks five languages.
@ZZ90755
17 күн бұрын
🤣my Dog voted R and Long Live Russia
@joni8090
17 күн бұрын
R - UUURRRAA 🇷🇺 🎖️ 🇷🇺
@tao4124
17 күн бұрын
Team A looks like the israeli government. 😂😂
@Lucia-sy7le
17 күн бұрын
😂🤣😂🤣😂🤍💙♥️
Putin is a strategist..
Soigu was an engineer by trade, not a military man.
Thank you for the update brother
Not out,just got a great Promotion!!!!!!
Thanks for the upload, always enjoy your videos
If a country is in war economy what a brilliant idea to appoint an economist as the ministry of defence!
Purge? Propaganda isn't it.
Shoigu built Russian Army might!
@marcobsomer5574
17 күн бұрын
et continuera à le faire.
Great segment Danny...
Good job, Danny
Shoigu sometime asked putin for retirement as hes a very good fisherman but he agreed to stay with a promotion until the SMO ended Lavrov also asked to be put to retirement again putin asked that he stay to the end of the SMO nobody was sacked?.
Danny 👍🎯💜 keep up your spirite💜 I love you brother
I certainly do not understand why Ukraine and NATO would be rejoicing on the change of Shoigu. If he was incompetent, they most likely now have a BETTER leader of the MOD. In any case, nothing will change the eventual outcome. The difference is only in terms of time to goal and the number of casualties and death on both sides.
Shoigu has been promoted and is now in charge of the entire Russian military industrial complex… JFYI
Most obvious reason for a change like that is that the Russian army had changed in a way that the defense minister does not really have much to do with any strategical or tactical stuff, but has more economical fights, while the advisors, generals and so on are the link to the army. In that case a military guy at the top is not only a waste but contra productive, since he will not only not be able to use his talent, but struggle with all the actual tasks at hand.
Putin said a lot in his speech, but all mainstream media took from that was the warning. Plus, he did a lot of walking that day and didn't trip once
@TruthSeeker1511
17 күн бұрын
Putin is a smart, unique human speciman with a wicked sense of humour. I admire him as President and as a man. How lucky is Russia!! 🇿🇦
Shoigu is now the General Secretary of the Russian Security Council - he has been PROMOTED. NATO will not like this.
Great show Danny!
To put it simply, he's now THE Boss of next Minister of Defense. But that's sacking for sure (c) CNN
Thanks!
Belousov could be as evective as Albert Speer.
We have been Russia-Phobes since the cold war.
Sum-Times PPL need a break after 2 years of hardcore strategizing and the pressures of war.....rotation is a good thing in wartime.....
Shoigu is also an economist. He has never been a soldier.
Wrong, Shogu is not out, he's been promoted....
What the do is once theres an election the entire govt changes which prevens what happens in the us. He moved shoigu to equal position. Russia seems to be the most effective actual Democracy 😂
Shoigu was a crisis times MoD minister, stern and demanding. I have never seen him smile. Now that procurement is in order is a perfect time for a cabinet shuffle. If you don't promote and shuffle potential doesn't come out. Andrei Belousov seems like a very nice man. Among his first priorities : soldier wages, better access to medical care, better support for families. He is a known technology innovator with a similar economics background as Shoigu.
No Purge promotion
Wary, not weary.
It's not a purge the shuffle is rather normal. It is the law to have the cabinet resign and then reappointed. Appointments must be approved by Duma aka Congress and Senate. Shoigu was promoted bcs security council is a more important position than ministry. Ministers in Russia were and aee ALL civilians including Shoigu. Shoigu had no military experience when appointed so nothing have changed for that matter. The actual generals are the command center not ministry. An economist in light of rapidly growing MIC is only logical. All of this is rather normal and logical not very big and not sacking and not purge like everyone wish to believe. US media is frankly pathetic
Albert Speer2 is now running the military weapons production
Putins inauguration comes in the first week of May, you say . Did you looked at the Calander for this ? May is already half way through . Shoigu get's promoted to the most inner circle arround Putin and he might end up Putins successor.
Great 😃 Great 😃 Great 😃 Video. Please keep it up.
Wary, not weary
Okay I finally get it now! I never realized it's got lived in Russia until just now but when I think back on the last two years of watching interviews with him and he surroundings always struck me as old fashioned and now I'm thinking Soviet style cramp department😂
What is is propaganda, shougu got promoted, they improved their positions. Shoigu now in charge of all military complex, read, think..
Danny, I must apologize on the topic from yesterday. I have peace and blessings for president of China He respected indigenous black Americans we love China creates everything and technology. We all must stick together.
Bravo, "Danny"! Evthng correct
Patrushev became Minister of Agriculture.
@minochenkovatn
17 күн бұрын
His son, he is also Patrushev
@holdinmuhl4959
16 күн бұрын
@@minochenkovatn , ok. Patrushev father has been announced assistant to the president now.
If you felt that your country might be going to war (with NATO or the US), the leadership would be stupid not to rotate their personnel into positions to give as many people as possible practical experience in solving military problems. Each of these Generals, officers and enlisted men may be involved in a military campaign comparable to the Ukraine war.
Change is Good. Marrying a Finince Expert to the military is Good. A Strategist to Lead the war effort is Better. Sound Long Term Economic warfare is better than capitalist warfare...
Lugubrious had heart attack in beginning of war. They kept him. Putin and him are very close friends
Sounds like Putin is doing 2 things: 1) replacing the head of defense with a bean counter because he doesn't think he is getting enough for him money for the war 2) Replacing a hardliner with somebody who is more friendly with Putin. Protecting his blindside while trying to improve his reputation due to a very costly war that isn't doing much.
America doesn't care.
KZread is fucking with my comments
@kevinford6420
17 күн бұрын
Mine too ! 🤬
@kevinford6420
17 күн бұрын
Mine too
@jacquescousteau217
17 күн бұрын
Same here. I just wrote something praising Vladimir Putin, and I’m not seeing it. Biden’s “ Democracy “
@feydrautha012
17 күн бұрын
KZread/google will delete comments celebrating the defeat of a certain mustachioed man from ~80 years ago (even in the most polite terms). They've got a plan to revise history, it seems.
Putin shuffling his staff. No big deal.
Create an independent russia with allies
Showgurl is now the defence guru and that is not offensive to most of the proletariat