I was waiting for this comparison video. Thanx! But i wud personally prefer KIGER.

Best channel for car information ...no extra bla bla...up to mark information delivered very peacefully

Greeat work V3cars.., Pls include Water wading capacity in Specs slide which will be very helpful to compare

what a comparo! keeep going, one of the best car channels out there.

I trust this channel so much that I directly go to verdict section.

@v3cars, can you pls upload comparision video on punch and altroz non turbo. Those share almost same specs in same price bracket. Especially punch creative vs altroz xz+.

Hi, 1st of all love your videos and details in it. Please compare 1.5 LTR engines of Hyundai Creta (SX variant) & MG Astor(SHARP variant)

Guys Todays days Engine and safety and mileage are most important point then other features ..go to TATA punch 👍

Please compare punch accomplished and renault rtx (o) 🙏🏻🙏🏻

Great Job by V3 teams. Would it be possible for you to add driving experience as a key point while comparing the cars. Number based comparision And Driving experience will make it very effective and will guide viewers much closer to decision making.

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

Go for Magnite u won't regret at all..

tata punch pure rhythm aur altroz xe rhythm me se kaunsa lu please suggest sir? Aur ek comparison video banao????

Safety and build quality i thumps up 👍👍👍 for Punch aur kyun na hum kre Deshi jugar jo hai 🤩

Booked punch adventure for safety, bigger service network, bigger engine. Felt it's vfm

Punch kaziranga adition is best or magnite xv premium is best all comparison

Sir tata punch amt advantures vs Renault kiger rxt amt me Kon si better hogi pls 🙏tell me🙏 sir Kon si buy karu

Please suggest punch accomplish amt or magnite cvt turbo is netter choice?

Please correct the verdict as between Nissan Magnite and Tata Punch. It's written as Kiger vs Magnite

I will buy tata punch. Beacuse It is a Indian company And i proud of India 🇮🇳

@V3Cars -Can you suggest me with TATA Tiago NRG vs TATA Punch Adventure Rhythm..

Just one concern.. how long will Nissan stick around in India is a question.. Nissan is actually just selling Magnite well right now .. and hence the risk remains asto when it will close down.. will have to wait and what next launch from Nissan is going to be .. if it's not a great product, Nissan would be soon planning an exit ..

Please compair with terbo charge engine

Please give us a comparison between the automatic versions

Hi Sir, please do a video on punch accomplished and venue s models

Can you please compare or suggest the better one between dzire and altroz xm+ diesel... Which vehicle among the two is better for commercial purposes..?

Sir aj kaun c car sahi rahegi. Punch accomplish or magnite xv. Please suggest

Hi V3cars, There is a typo error in the Chapter list. It is written kiger vs magnite in the last chapter head, rather than Punch, Thanks.

Hi, please make a comparison video of top recommend varient of kia sonet and nissan magnite

Test drove Punch few days back came back unimpressed , found magnite to be winner on all counts even the altroz is a better and more premium than punch.

Bhai i20 Megan ya punch Accomplished konse achi ha ?

Such a useful video... Thank you ✨

Please give your review between Tata Punch Accomplished vs Tata Altroz XT

Magnite has better safety than punch in the turbo variants as it has ESP TRaction control and hill hold on top of a good 4 star crash rating. Kindly note Gncap is inferior to asean ncap as Gncap does not include crash prevention tech as a parameter. In summary Magnite turbo is safer than punch

@pravinmurthy

2 жыл бұрын

Not true.. 5 stars in GNCAP is superior to ASEAN NCAP!..

@Godzilla-hh8ip

2 жыл бұрын

@@pravinmurthy sorry have you checked the websites ?

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

@@pravinmurthy ASEAN Ncap has more tough rules than GnNcap ..

@seven6094

2 жыл бұрын

Thk ha but service centre he available nahi ha Yarr

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

@YoMamaBeenFartin' before makin fool out of you go n check the official Twitter handle of Nissan India.. Secondly Nissan is sharing plant with Renault and there is not much they can do to make a seperate car for each region.. because they are struggling to manufacture even 4000 cars a month on the same assembly line Kiger n Triber are also made so there is not much time to create a seperate car for out of India .. Hav some research first n then make ur comments

Please punch aur kiger k amt varient ka detail video bhi karna

Can u do a comparison between the automatic model of both

Plz do similar analysis of Punch with Ignis. Thanks

How do you compare with Magnite, a car that's notorious at huge waiting periods? I've been waiting for 10 months at this point and per their tracking site, it'll be another 2 months to delivery. It's like comparison of a car and the idea of a car

Triber me Kiger wala turbo engine laga sakte h kya ?

Sir.. from safety perspective which one is better?

please make a comparison between punch accomplish vs magnite XV

Need Creative variant of Punch and XV premium comparison

Nissan magnite is clear winner but service network is low. Hope they work on it.

Kindly compare punch accomplished vs magnite xv

Plz make a detailed comparison between the top models

Sir can u please guide me that whether Magnite XL CVT is Better or Venue IMT or I20 IVT, Which one I should choose as I live in Ludhiana, Punjab

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

Anytime Magnite ❤️

Which crash test is better global or Asian?

Mileage about magnite xl non turbo and what about its re sale value

Now all questions cleared sir ..I am going to buy magnite XL white colour

@TOP10_COUNTDOWN

2 жыл бұрын

Same here buddy, but does xl comes in black color?

@sharathmsg4436

2 жыл бұрын

@@TOP10_COUNTDOWN no bro brown white silver colours available. But Just changed the my opinion after driving punch bro.. it's more composed ,cool driving ability car than magnite . Almost 3 medium size adult can sit in back seat in punch... I have booked punch pure with dual tone and in accesories mai touch screen and speakers,rear camera lagwa raha hu company se ( 30k extra mai ). Now no warranty issue... total I am getting my punch in 7 lkh with accessories in Karnataka...saftey also highly considered here...magnite is bit more zerky because of less power more gear shifting required it will not give u composed driving pleasure...

@sharathmsg4436

2 жыл бұрын

@@TOP10_COUNTDOWN still magnite is all alone upper hand in features and looks ...great machine ..

@TOP10_COUNTDOWN

2 жыл бұрын

@@sharathmsg4436 great choice You will never regret it 😇😇 even Tiago NRG is awesome

Megnite is the Better option

I like Nissan magnite xl non turbo

I want to by magnite but I heard Nissan is leaving India soon. Is it true?

Magnite is definitely a better package compared to Punch but apparently their service network is shit. There are a lot of videos on youtube and reviews about the issues being faced by customers within few days of getting the car plus the service centres and Nissan customer care giving them hell. Nissan just puts their hands up and leaves it all upto the dealers who then give you the runaround.

@seven6094

2 жыл бұрын

Mere city ma Nissan kha service centre dur dur thk available nahi ha

@deepakpillai6384

2 жыл бұрын

Not true. I am a Magnite owner & can say the Nissan has worked a lot to improve their service since the launch of Magnite. But yes service stations are very less.

Compare punch base vs kiger base model

V3 cars plz compare top models of both cars plz 🙏

TATA Punch Accomplished vs. Nissan EV, your views?

Anyone plz reply which one is sensible to buy between Kiger RXT and Punch Accomplished??

@sharathmsg4436

2 жыл бұрын

Bro take a test drive both . Renault ac is poor, engin also poor.. thoda space jyada milega ... I changed my decision after driving punch in city ..it's Hassel free in 3rd &2 gear .. but magnite and triber& kiger will give more zerk ,leg pain ,more attention driving headache ..so calmly I have booked punch ..punch base ...

Do you suggest Punch Creative AMT or Magnite CVT XL Premium

@chandrakantjaiswal7346

2 жыл бұрын

cvt

Magnite value for money tho ha but sub punch Laga keu ke showroom ya service centre he available nahi ha .. or Keya PTA eya ve ford ke saath byby na ker de...

Which editing software you use?

Brake ( safety )system is similar only with magnite XL turbo and punch , then Magnite becomes costlier.

If punch was not over priced, every one could have recommended desi cars 💪 But with that price , u can buy magnite 1 L engine or turbo with CVT . . No to over priced punch. Magnite is bigger than punch, good looking and more ground clearance

@ManikandanSurendranath

2 жыл бұрын

All because of prelaunch hype created in you tube

@STgauss3268

2 жыл бұрын

Good looking? Lol

@sidd1910

2 жыл бұрын

Magnite is definitely not good looking and for safety, we can trust Tata. Yes, it is little overpriced but I feel that is Ok for a perfect 5 star. Also, we are feeling price as higher because there was so much hype by the youtubers regarding price. If reality is not as good as expectations, people tends to feel like this.

@pallabchakrabortyoriginal

2 жыл бұрын

@@sidd1910 most wise explanation 👍

@skilz9525

2 жыл бұрын

@@sidd1910 absolutely ...at this price also I find 2 base variants of punch are best in segment

Thank you for information sir ji . My fav car Nissan magnetic XL Red colour model . Yes this November I'm booking &. Next Month yaneki December buy 20th to 28th December buy nissan magnetic XL Red colour model ... Sir ji my request pls I need nissan magnetic XL Red colour video bonabo okay... I'm watching form North East Meghalaya.....

magnite 1L.engine has to drag a huge body so engine noise , and performance will be impacted I guess.. I would arrange magnite 1.3L > punch > 1L magnite..

Guys super Put punch creative vs magnite xv

Awesome comparison

Do share punch comparison with Kiger

What about kiger sir ??

Magnite XL is better for its more practical features.

@seven6094

2 жыл бұрын

What about service centre availablity

@sunandakumarsahoo6129

2 жыл бұрын

@@seven6094 Magnite or for that matter any car, people should buy car if the service center is available with in their reach.

Please compare magnite vs Tiago

Kiger vs punch accomplished please.

Magnite XV CVT purchased

All time magnite value for money

Kiger Non Turbo AMT ( RXT) or Tata Punch Adventure AMT+Rythem , which one i should buy? Price in Bangalore- Kiger -9.4L Punch - 9L

@phanindrak9880

2 жыл бұрын

Non turbo go for punch but if you want turbo then kiger without a doubt

Sir🙏🙏🙏.💐 VW taigun 1.5 or skoda kushaq 1.5 which on better car pls tell me sir... 💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐

@1091Matrix

2 жыл бұрын

Both problematic

@ravipongileti5346

2 жыл бұрын

Pls tell me sir which vehicle best.. in15laksh. Creta. Kia. Seltos or vw. Polo. Or Honda Amaze. Or vw ventoo whin one is good&better car...

@rohantolani4065

2 жыл бұрын

@@ravipongileti5346 Wait for Skoda Slavia if you can cross shop for a sedan. It is coming next month and it will be more fun to drive than Kushaq or Taigun.

Can you please compare between magnite xv and punch accomplish!! I had booked magnite xv but then cancelled it for punch !! Now I am confused if I have done right !!

@jamesbrook173

2 жыл бұрын

Same I did

@SuperPoo24

2 жыл бұрын

@@jamesbrook173 finally bought punch accomplished !! And no regrets !! Its worth every penny !!

@jamesbrook173

2 жыл бұрын

@@SuperPoo24 Thank you for providing me direction

Good review..My concern is with Magnite Engine power..I need to travel 1000kms once in a month, Which one is better?. My Maximum Budget is 8lakhs on Road.pl suggest

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

Magnite XL Turbo best option.. if 8L or if 6.5 - 7L then Magnite Non-Turbo does its job very well.. engine m koi issue nai hain..

Of course Magnite 👍👍👍

Tata punch vs renault kiger plzzz

Which scores higher GNCAP/ ASEAN NCAP?

@bhargobhipaul5559

2 жыл бұрын

Gncap

How u compare 1L and 1.2L engine .. tata stands out amongst this two

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

That 1L engine is more quicker than the Punch 1.2L .. Magnite 1L takes 16 sec for 0-100 while Punch takes 16.5 sec for 0-100.. Turbo ko toh chhod hi do bhai.. 😂😂

@deepakpillai6384

2 жыл бұрын

Specifications are not everything. One needs to drive the vehicle himself to get the accurate idea.

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

@@deepakpillai6384 after driving both Magnite engine is good, refinement is at par at ideal there is no sound inside being a 3 cylinder.. but TATA engine feels.like diesel

@siddh234

2 жыл бұрын

@@ankitgarhwal857 that I agree TATA still needs to improve a lot on its Engine noise.

magnite xl model how many colour variants are there?

@lohithmangalore8481

2 күн бұрын

3

Magnite is bigger then punch . Design : u can't even compare punch with Magnite . Safety : both r good . Price : same price and u'll get good safety , good beast looks 🔥 + value for money , evrythinng u need u will get in Magnite . Whereas Punch is overpriced micro SUV , so why to go for Punch ? If it's price was same as kuv 100 or ignis , it would be a best option , but it's very much overpriced

@seven6094

2 жыл бұрын

What about service centre??

@manojchandra1113

2 жыл бұрын

Bcoz punch is Indian car

Need Punch Vs Ignis...

Thank uh...🙂

Which is batter buy option punch creative. Amt or nexon xma pl suggest

@kunaldhanak6427

2 жыл бұрын

Creative is over-priced buy Nexon xma, a proper SUV experience you will get

@vinodr7975

2 жыл бұрын

No I think creative is better because it is rich in features cruise control is also offered in it but it is a bit overpriced In my opinion you should consider creative or Nexon xz both are of same price

@vinodr7975

2 жыл бұрын

Sorry u wanna purchase amt so u should consider xms (a) because amt in xz is not available

@vinodr7975

2 жыл бұрын

@Neeraj Krishnan Nexon or punch

@vinodr7975

2 жыл бұрын

@neeraj ya that is what I thought Btw I also have a Nexon xza+

Sorry TATA.. We have to go to Magnite even waiting period is high.. the looks😍 VFM Comfort and most affordable when you compare with other luxury SUV's.. Secured 85K + record booking for Magnite..!!😊

@ajandas3452

2 жыл бұрын

Wht if Rathanji told to India in covid days that "Sorry India we will donate 500 cr to Europe since num of cases are more then here"😂

@cancerrim2220

2 жыл бұрын

@@ajandas3452 Nikal chu

I will buy punch in these 2. Because it's small. It can fit into tight roads and lanes.

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

U deserve Alto 😂

@shadow-qc1rf

2 жыл бұрын

@@ankitgarhwal857 Alto cannot do off-roading. Punch is a car that gives a solution for Indian roads. And trust me, u will see the results in the form of sales in few months.

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

@@shadow-qc1rf Magnite has much better ride quality with 16 inch tyres.. Magnite is better option.. its not that much big ..

@johnsondavid3867

2 жыл бұрын

If some one elooking for smaller car should go for different level hatchback.

I think Magnite XL is much loaded futures in its rivals and price range

@sadwik1208

2 жыл бұрын

Safety is the priority

@baibhavsamal2564

2 жыл бұрын

@@sadwik1208 ha toh magnite bhi 4/5 laya hai🤷🏻‍♂️

Ye video reupload kiya hai kya...? Have already seen this video before #dejavu

@tarunrawat5132

2 жыл бұрын

Same here. Or may be I am seeing more magnite videos these days coz of buying it soon.

@vipinbhat6395

2 жыл бұрын

In the Earlier video he compared base variants of both cars. And in this one 2nd base variants have been compared

finally the game begins

Power different is important

I will buy punch. Because I can add features to my car but can't change the engine. And for me first thing is engine.

@deepakpillai6384

2 жыл бұрын

Drive both & then decide, not just by seeing the numbers

I will definitely choose tata altroz xm pluse than any of these car. Because suv fever can not fulfill the day to day requirement.

@deepakpillai6384

2 жыл бұрын

Why?

I would prefer punch because punch is safe car and it is a top selling car also. In terms of engine and performance punch is better than magnite. And We being a INDIAN should support INDIAN car brands.

Will go for punch any day as safety is first priority for me Asian ncap will be 3 star in gncap plus service network and 25000 km means on an average people drive 10000 km in a year in tier 2 cities even in Bombay so if we calculate we are getting 3 years more warranty than magnite and what I know punch boot is of 366 ltr anyway Main reason is safety as in practical we have seen the magnite performance which is not up to the mark and it proves the Asian ncap rating

@sumeetkumarroy

2 жыл бұрын

HAHA fool do u even know that asean ncao is stricter than that of gncap. Lol. 🤭😆. Punch doesnt has 366 ltrs fool, its only 319. 🤭😆🤣. 366 litres is the bootspace after removing parcek tray, its a cheap tactis buddy. 🤭😆. Huh, who said and hiw many accidents of magnite have been shown. 😏😏. Only in one accident it had most danages becoz it hit the trailer from behind due to which its a pilalr collapsed which is geniune and would have happened to any cars. So dont speak shit man. 🤭😆🤣

I'll select punch adventure rather than magnite xl...bcoz 1)engine is more powerful. 2)punch is more safer car than magnite 3)most important thing is, I love Indian cars only (Tata n Mahindra)

@keepingitsimple8705

2 жыл бұрын

Ok

@cancerrim2220

2 жыл бұрын

3rd Reason is very Lame

@manojchandra1113

2 жыл бұрын

@@cancerrim2220 it's ur opinion brother... opinions may change time to time.

I have purchased magnite xl turbo, I loved its drive quality and it is a fully featured car.

@ankitgarhwal857

2 жыл бұрын

There is no car better than Magnite in the Range of 5-8L .. really VFM.. I m using the base variant the non turbo engine is really good ..

I will go for Made in India

Why did you not capture the monetary part from the last 3 points, having higher safety and longer km warranty also cost more. The comparison is good but not practical. A consumer should ideally never buy a vehicle based on this. Go take a test drive and choose!

@deepakpillai6384

2 жыл бұрын

It is just to help in better understand both vehicles. Of course one wouldn't buy a car without test driving it.

Most of my friends and relatives are buying Tata vehicles because of only reason SAFETY and build quality

@Godzilla-hh8ip

2 жыл бұрын

Magnite has better safety than punch in the turbo variants as it has ESP TRaction control and hill hold on top of a good 4 star crash rating. Kindly note Gncap is inferior to asean ncap as Gncap does not include crash prevention tech as a parameter. In summary Magnite turbo is safer than punch

Nice comparison but would like to know which one is the best in automatic version?

@keepingitsimple8705

2 жыл бұрын

Never ever go for Tata AMT