It's okay, I didn't need my heart anyways.

@mantra4ia

8 жыл бұрын

+SunnyVids What you said precisely.

@briahenderson5805

8 жыл бұрын

+SunnyVids exactly, actually. I will forever ship Whouffaldi. 12 and Clara were so perfect and real and amzing together, and they brought out the best and worst in each other and I'm really really glad we all got to see their relationship grow and evolve over the seasons. I cannot image the snogbox with their dynamic and I'll miss Jenna on the show so much it hurts.

@jamma.77

8 жыл бұрын

+SunnyVids Only Time Lords would be safe watching this video. Even if two hearts aren't enough, they can always regenerate.

@cynthiajordan8751

7 жыл бұрын

SunnyVids Oh so true. I'm in tears now.

@sgearxextreme8

6 жыл бұрын

No, you need 2 hearts! *fake laugher that turns into sobbing*

If you listen closely enough, you can hear crying oh wait that's me

@helenenichtfischer6181

8 жыл бұрын

Anyway, cheers from Germany.

@ButiLao44

8 жыл бұрын

Wow, ein deutscher Whovian :D Sieht man nicht oft :)

@helenenichtfischer6181

8 жыл бұрын

Stimmt, leider ist der Doctor viel zu unbekannt hier. :D

@kokohekmatyar1770

7 жыл бұрын

Stell dir vor, wie es in der Schweiz ist. XD

@sunnyflower313

5 жыл бұрын

And me

From Souffle' Girl in the Dalek, to "it's smaller on the outside", to dealing with an 'older' Doctor right before her eyes, to a relationship that drives him mad with her loss, to abandon all he is and stands for to bring her back at the ends of time and of space. And she'll still be gone, but she will never leave, and forgetting is only temporary. And she's simply adorable. That's the Impossible Girl, and she is sorely missed.

"Trust me she doesn't leave." Did anyone else die at that part?

@JhadeSagrav

5 жыл бұрын

Yes. Death was imminent.

@chanceneck8072

Жыл бұрын

I let her inside my head. I can confirm, she doesn't leave. Clara is STILL my favorite companion.

Four years later and it’s still my favourite doctor who edit

A large number of people overly criticise Moffat as head writer, but what I find amazing about you KatrinDepp is you are one of the very few who actually understands his writing. You're one of the very few to recognise the amazing and beautiful parallels, foreshadowing, character development etc. that he creates throughout series. I praise you heavily for your videos.

@Donnegail

8 жыл бұрын

+Donald Tramp 2016 M Agree. Moffat is really a good showrunner and Katrin understand it very well

Thank you for using my song on this. Loved watching it. X

@KatrinDepp

Жыл бұрын

oh gosh! thank you! I'm in love with your music. what a day to get a comment from an incredible musician, wow

I didn't warm to Clara right away. In fact, I spent most of her first season barely tolerating her... and then she jumped into the Doctor's timestream, and their whole way of interacting with each other changed... and then Capaldi came along and their relationship shifted even further... and she grew and grew until she became almost as dynamic and mad and clever and caring as the doctor himself... and I'll be damned if she didn't worm her way into becoming one of my all-time favorite companions ever to grace the Tardis by the end. Never EVER thought I'd see the day, but I can hardly stand to see her go! What I love about this video in particular is that it really shows just how much Clara has embedded herself into almost every aspect of the doctor's psyche... to the point where I'm sure that even having lost the memory of her, she will always, always remain a part of him. This video is so perfect and haunting and beautiful, and shows the absolute depth of the doctor's love for the woman who has saved him from himself so many times. Thank you for this FANTASTIC tribute to the pair of them! I can't stop watching it!

@nicolesong6199

4 жыл бұрын

I like the "it really shows just how much Clara has embedded herself into almost every aspect of the doctor's psyche... to the point where I'm sure that even having lost the memory of her, she will always, always remain a part of him." part because ... I think I'd like to see Clara reflected in the Doctors again.

Watching your video made me realize how much I'll miss the Twelve-Clara dynamic. It was one of the most complex, passionate Doctor-companion relationships supported by the stellar performances of Peter Capaldi and Jenna Coleman. They made me feel the special bond their characters share through adventure, heartbreak, and fights with bad guys and each other. That bond is beautifully captured by your video.

I've watched this fanvid several times a day, every day for the past ten days or so (in other words, since I finished season 9 of Doctor Who as I binge the show for the first time), and I don't see this stopping anytime soon. Holy shit. It's a MASTERPIECE. The editing, in particular, deserves a special mention here, because it's among the best I've EVER seen (and trust me when I say that, over the years, I've probably watched literal THOUSANDS of fanvids at this point), and I'm absolutely OBSESSED with it. It's just. SO GOOD. 😱

"when do I NOT see you?" O bloody hell 😭😭😭

4 years old and I still haven't mourned 😢😢😭😭

I'm embarrassed by how many times a day I watch this video. But at the same time I'm not embarrassed at all! This is the best fan edit I've ever seen. I love how "I am afraid/Let me be brave", "A soldier so brave he doesn't need a gun" and "How many have you lost/How many Claras" keeps repeating in my mind. Thanks, +KatrinDepp That's a masterpiece!

@KatrinDepp

8 жыл бұрын

+Carol Vaz you are very kind! thanks a lot =)

as always, you are amazing !

I'm gonna be completely honest here; I've watched this video as soon as you posted it just over 5 years ago, and to this day it's still my favorite fanvideo I've ever watched, and I don't say that lightly. I've shown this to lots of my friends, and even ones who never watched Doctor Who really enjoyed the video. I've come back to it myself many times in the past, and it's definitely inspired a lot of my fanvideos, so thank you so much

This will always be my favorite doctor who video. Not only does it perfectly capture the relationship, beauty, chemistry, and toxicity of the Twelfth Doctor and Clara Oswald, but also always leaves you wanting more. It's both bittersweet and awe-inspiring, and I can never get enough of it. Truly a masterpiece and just really depicts the deep complexity of Whouffaldi in a way that makes it closer to the human heart.

Okay, after all those years... I watched it maybe a thousand times

i don't even watch this show and i'm blown away by your work here, like always, you're the best !!!

@KatrinDepp

8 жыл бұрын

+ncismelanie wow, thanks a lot, Mel! It means a lot as always

@lootthellama8988

5 жыл бұрын

If you don't watch it then start

This entire video is a piece of art. The sounds of static and cracking and breathing and screaming just represented the general tone of DW. The fear, rush, and general adventure of the show. It merged with the music beautifully and complimented the scene it was put with. Every parallel connection was matched in such a lovely way and the scenes cut perfectly to the beat of the song, which changed pace throughout the video. God, it just completely gave me chills and this is probably one of the best fanvids I have ever watched.

@helenenichtfischer6181

8 жыл бұрын

I agree so much

@laurenclark1904

7 жыл бұрын

I AGREE TOO

Not only is this the best Doctor Who video I've ever seen, this just might be the best edited fanvid I've ever had the pleasure of seeing.

“I let Clara Oswald get inside my head. Trust me, she doesn’t leave” over the clips of him watching her leave OUGH THAT GOT TO ME

I didn't expect to fall so in love with their dynamic, but damnit, this show got to me again. Lovely video.

sadness is happy for really deep people and that's what this video is for us doctor who fans it hurts us but we love it all the same ;)

@kayleyhodson7079

8 жыл бұрын

+rachael martin nice subtle little reference there :) And so true

@leximartin4105

8 жыл бұрын

Kayley Hodson im so glade someone got that :D

@leximartin4105

8 жыл бұрын

*****​ its a quote from doctor who the Weeping Angels episode

I don't even know what to say in front of this masterpiece

@MichaelM28

5 жыл бұрын

What masterpiece?

"You, you gonna be alone now, and you're gonna be sad, but listen to me: Don't let this change you, promise me... Be a doctor... My doctor !" So great !

I now have over eight hundred fan-made music videos, years have gone by since I first found this one, yet I still come back to it and have the breath knocked out of me each and every time. Well flippen done

this is the most lyrical editing i've ever seen in my life. it's poetic in a way that i've never seen before. woah.

This is honestly my favourite doctor who edit. I watch it several times a week

So this is going to be a long comment, and I apologize beforehand. First of all, this video was just absolutely amazing and so emotional. I love it how you showed both the good times and bad times of the two's traveling together, and I'm glad you mostly focused on 12 because even if I think Clara and 11 seemed cute together and could connect as more than friends, I feel like with 12 she had a much stronger connection truly as the Doctor and a companion. Together they made a good team and I'm really going to miss Clara/Jenna. This video showed everything about their friendship and I just loved it. (I have to admit, it also made me cry haha). The other thing I wanted to mention, I've been watching your videos for over a year now and I even sent one of your Doctor Who videos to my Media Art teacher (because she is also a fan) and she absolutely loved it! Every time I get an email notification about you uploading a new video, it makes me feel like it's Christmas and I click right on the video. I think you are fantastic at editing, at choosing the right songs, making us feel so much emotions, and I really love how you time your scenes to the music and all the background sounds. Your videos always inspire and motivate me to push myself and work on my videos even more (because I also make quite a lot of DW and other kinds of videos). I hope one day in the future you are going to use this skill/talent even further and important people will recognize this unique editing style you have. So yeah I just wanted to let you know that I really admire you. Can't wait for more videos from you! :)

@KatrinDepp

8 жыл бұрын

+ashtimi85 this is incredibly kind of you, thank you very much! i'm so touched you have no idea!

@quicksilver0710

8 жыл бұрын

+ashtimi85 просто подпишусь тут под каждым словом. вот. все твои видео выворачивают что-то изнутри, такое глубокое и искреннее, о чем даже не подозревал прежде. меня всегда поражало, как тонко и точно ты чувствуешь доктора, и просто за то, что в мире есть такой человек, как ты, хочется петь мантры и возносить благодарности ноосфере! спасибо! СПАСИБО! ты своими работами поднимаешь со дна души очень много боли - для того, чтобы мы могли обратить эту боль в откровение, в радость!

i'm coming back to this at least once in a few months after five years, and it's still being the best dw edit i've ever seen.

I've seen every single episode of Doctor Who, classic and new, and Capaldi / 12 is my favorite doctor. His chemistry with Clara and how this video captures that, just ... wow!!

This is a freaking masterpiece! This video totally did Clara justice. Amazing work!

I still come back to this from time to time. My favorite Doctor Who edit. Thank you for making this, it's beautiful.

I loved Peter as The Doctor. Miss him so much :(

Oh god. It hurts so much. Just thinking about Heaven Sent and how he killed himself over and over and over, punching his way through a wall with his bare hands, for 4.5 billion years just to save her. And the times when he wanted to just give up and die but kept pushing on. This show has really gotten to me in the past, but this season it just straight up broke me.

What. The. Fuck. HOW DID I JUST FIND OUT ABOUT YOUR CHANNEL! This is the greatest portrayal of Clara Oswald I have ever seen! Whouffle!

Holy moley. I think my heart just broke all over again. I feel like I'm actually losing someone who was a big part in my life. Only in season 8 did I realise how much I completely loved Jenna and her portrayal of her character and I really don't want to say goodbye. I hope she crops up somewhere again but it'll probably once again break my heart when that episode ends. Amazing edit again 💕😚

Thank you for the emotional and memorable tribute to beloved Clara! I will miss her, she was just what the Doctor needed! You captured the defining moments and I applaud the beautiful presentation! The thought of no more Clara in the Tardis is painful, she became so integral to the Twelfth Doctor's story!

I am still sad to see Clara go in such a fashion. I am also sad we have to wait a year or more before the show returns. By the way, the best video for Clara I've seen yet. Thank you =D Right in the feels.

Legitimately one of the best Twelve/Clara videos I've ever watched

This remains my favourite edit of all time - me rewatching for the twentieth time

holy shit...I was not ready for that masterpiece also I loved the call back to one of your early videos of twelve using that song WELL DONE

it's almost 2am and I am here crying actual tears over this video, I seriously cannot breathe properly right now,I had forgotten how truly heartbreaking this whole season was

This is genuinely one of the best fanvideos that I have ever seen for any show, and I have watched a LOT. I'm blown away!!!

Wow. Just Wow. Your videos really catch and carry the reletionships and the emotions of the show so perfectly! And your choice of songs... Everytime I see a video of yours in my youtube feed, I smile. Please, don't stop. Thank you.

@sealedwithakiss5485

8 жыл бұрын

+franziska1007 Same, same. ^^

This is another perfect example of that type of art where you just sit still afterwards, with your mouth wide open for a few seconds!...

This is literally perfect. You manage not only to put the images together but the emotion - it comes out so clear with you! Last year you did a series of fanvids during season 8 and I was spoiled rotten with the insight you brought with your vids and it was a genuine addition to the show. I've selfishly missed your DW vids this year which I have no right to of course, and then you create something that is the 12/Clara vid. This is it. When people ask me about 12/Clara I will have to reference this vid. Cannot put into words - really, you have put a thesis on DW and their relationship into 4 mins of colour and movement and editing and I'm completely in awe. Completely blown away. Completely ENCHANTED!

Rewatching this every few months, truly a condensed of why I love them so much This video is so so so good fr fr

Good job on making me cry like a baby....but seriously, thank you for this beautiful video, you have captured everything for 12 and Clara. I started watching the show just a couple of weeks ago and I fell in love with Peter and Jenna. I originally thought I was gonna be weird about 12 after loving 11 and Clara so much, but Peter's performance is just as epic as the others. Thank you again, and I hope we will see Jenna in the future too TAT

I literally cry so hard every time I see this video. It makes me think about 12 and Clara's relationship and it hurts so much... Their farewell is the saddest among lots of doctor-companion parting scene to me. Thank you for creating this such an amazing work.

I really like how you didn't add too much of the romance aspect. I'm not a whouffladi shipper at all but I appreciate their deep connection and almost familial love they have for each other and I really liked how you displayed it in this video. Well done!

I haven't watched this fanvid in over a year and it's still a masterpiece

fuuuuuuuuc this was incredible. the transitions were so sharp the colors were so amazing the clips and the way you told the story were great and thank you for using subtitles!!

For me, this perfect relationship was what was missing from series 10

@GotoMaki4Micah

5 жыл бұрын

yeah this relationship dynamic was too old hat im afraid, they had to give the doc an ensemble cast that he or she can be a side character of and not have a relationship be near this compelling with any of the companions. there wasn't an out right romance in moffats writing but it was in the subtext. there's a lot missing from series 10. shes so watered down and ''accessible to everyone''

This is the best fan video I've ever seen hands down and I've seen it like 20 times it never fails to make me cry 100/10 I love you

I came here years later to tell you that this vid still moves my heart, just as much as it did years ago.

This is... the greatest fandom video EVER... like, seriously, I am SOO familiar with this video I can't even count the amount of times I've watched it... I don't think this could be any more perfect. You did an INCREDIBLE job.

Well, this was just simply, absolutely, and heart-crushingly magnificent. You summed it up better than anyone. Thank you.

This was...so painful. But also unbelievably beautiful. You've captured the essence of their relationship so perfectly, and your cinematic work is breathtaking. Thank you so much for uploading.

Already two years... I still can watch this video again and again... It's incredible. The est of the best of all the fanmades I have seen so far. Incredible.

@Kant1_

3 жыл бұрын

I think this one is my favorite fanmade video. Six years after, I'm still there. Such beautiful vid. Thanks.

This is my favorite Series 8-9 tribute I've seen. The editing and parallels and emotions are just...wow. You have a real talent!

OH MY GALLIFREY! This is something. I can't even begin to describe how awesome this is. This gave me so much life. I will bookmark this and watch it until I get over them (which is never).

You are fantastic! Oh, I can't describe how beautiful this is. I couldn't take my eyes while this was playing. I was like intensely close to the screen, lol.

I can't quite believe how good this is, holy shit. Your use of sound is masterful - that section at 1:00 where 'you are dying' was timed perfectly to the three drum rolls I swear my goosebumps had goosebumps. I was hoping that you'd do a S9 video and this was more than I could ever have expected! Thank you so much

WOW - I forgot about this - Just watched it again. so powerful. You got some skillz GUURL.

This video means a lot to me. It is such a stunning capsule of the journey of 12 and Clara that is has made me cry. It makes me want to make better cinematic edits like this. I am going to keep going and keep trying to improve until I can make someone cry. Great work, it's going in my all time favorites.

когда первый раз смотрела face the raven, то, умываясь слезами, думала, как же мне жизненно необходимо будет видео от KatrinDepp по этому поводу. и поэтому Я ТАК ЖДАЛ, ТАК ЖДАЛ, 12 лет в Азкабане. и это настолько того стоило ролик восхитительнейший, я не перестаю восхищаться вашим талантом

I never saw a better twelve/clara video. I'm literally in tears rn.

I can't even begin to tell you how many times I've watched this over the past month. As usual, utter perfection. Dotan's Home has become my new favorite song, thank you for introducing me to it! This video captures the light and the dark moments of their relationship, and it is absolutely beautiful. I keep trying to make my own Twelve/Clara videos but I end up fizzling out on them, because this video has set the bar. It is the perfect video for them. I feel no reason to make another :) thank you so much for this

Your video is amazing, and I absolutely adore your music choices ! I really miss those two travelling together :(

Excellent work - this beats the crap of season 11 any day - when we had a real doctor and companion ;)

This is one of the best Whouffaldi videos I have ever seen. Beautiful work.

Oh my stars! You've gone and done it again! Raised the bar! I don't know what to even say, this is... this is... this is gorgeous beyond the capacity of human speech to express. Magnificent!

the more I watch this the more I realize how perfect it is

A fitting tribute to my favourite era of the show.

not gonna lie, since this vid came out i watched it at least twice a week!

@helenenichtfischer6181

8 жыл бұрын

Still true for me

@alicegurska

7 жыл бұрын

I do the same now

I'm kinda stuck between "NO," and "YES," and "YOU QUEEN."

I've watched a lot of Clara/Doctor videos after her departure, and this has got to be the best one. The parallels! Just amazing. Thank you for this

OMG-- this is an absolute masterpiece!!! O.O I am literally in awe right now. THANK YOU FOR THIS BEAUTIFUL VID!!

This is the best thing on KZread and I'm not even kidding

this made me want to watch doctor who again! this is so cool, i squeeled while watching lol, i'm glad i'm home alone!

The timing in that first part just took my breath away. Farewell.

This is everything I ever felt for twelve and clara. Love and friendship and fear and running uncontrollably--everything. Thank you for this.

This is such a good edit. Really love it!

Wow... this was some of the best editing I've ever seen. Really gorgeous work. Thank you for sharing. Twelve and Clara will always be my favourites

Ok that was quite something. Not sure why some of the images were flipped but I loved how you joined together the recurring motifs and shots. And the thing is you're not putting words into people's mouths or making suppositions from things that aren't there. I still am amazed that people continue to insist there was nothing between the Doctor and Clara and that they had no chemistry, etc. The episodes speak for themselves but this video is a good one to show naysayers, I think.

This has been my comfort edit for a few years now I come back every now and then cause it’s just immaculate

How did you even make this without dying from dehydration from the tears? So sad. But let me say. You have a wonderful talent. The best edits I have ever seen. This may have broken my heart into finer pieces than it already was but it was so beautifully made I couldn't help but love it. I always look forward to an edit from your ever amazing skills. Thank you. So much talent lies within you.

The best fan-video i've ever seen! Absolutely Excellent!

oh my god, i was waiting for you to make a s9 video, and now i'm just sitting alone in a room and sobbing. great work, what a talent! twelve/clara were wonderful together, imo their relationship was much stronger than ten/rose, and ended in even more devastating way. cheers (and tears) from poland!

This is probably my favourite doctor clara video ever

Oh my stars, this is one of the most amazing videos I've ever seen, kudos to you!!!!

omg your work....so amazing...watching such a beautiful video of them after the heartbreaking 9th season brought tears on my eyes.... Their relationship, my God, it hurts....I love the pre and after death of Clara division, it's so clever and right to the point of these two... Clara is clearly the strongest companion character mainly because of Twelve, coz he is so so dark but in a much deeper and different way from all the previous.. I believe the Doctor trusted her and saw a strength in her that would help him balance himself when the 12 or that dark personality came, which is the burst of his life,of the things and persons he lost, of everything that he lived so far and so many years..this personality would arrive eventually and he needed someone realy strong beside him, and that was Clara... It's OK though, I do not have a problem with that, and I'm telling this coz there are people who say that this is unfair for all the previous companions, while the truth is that every companion had exactly the same duty towards their old friend, to protect him from himself and giude him out of the darkness he often has fallen.. Also I would like to comment something that I am thinking right from the begging: the "duty of care" thing is more like a clever way of avoiding this " I love you" thing..He didn't say it, like he didn't say it to Rose...I am not OK with neither of the "I love you" that were never to be said, but that's his thing and I don't really want to hear it in the future, coz that's when the big betrayal starts...

Be still my beating heart! This is simply everything and I think it pays the best tribute to a Doctor and a companion relationship that one could wish for. Outstanding job! Thank you for the tears!

this video perfectly encapsulates season 9 and their relationship. Fun and free at first then hurts like hell. I'M NOT CRYING NOPE

Still brilliant

I have been waiting for this - when I saw your video in my subscriptions I was almost as excited as I am for the show itself!! And you did not disappoint. You really captured the intensity of near fanatical devotion these two had, and the arc of their story. Thank you for posting :)

That video is awesome! Wow! Just WOW! That is one of the best things I've ever seen. Thank you. I looked it over and over again and it gets only better and better. I love how you used the character developments and paralleles. How you bring out the depth in their relationship is perfection and the combination with the music and the scenes you chose is pure magic. You are incredibly talented and I hope someone important notices you. I really love your work. You not only give us such a wonderful work of art you also inspire people. And that is awesome.

This still gets me every time...

@helenenichtfischer6181

2 жыл бұрын

still true..

The interaction at 0:53 blew my mind The Doctor: I can save you! The writing on Clara's walls: "No! Dying. JUST _SAY_ IT" The writing on The Doctor's screen: "NIGHTMARE SCENARIO"