Proton X50 vs Honda HRV: SUV Rivals Find Out Who's Boss (& Fastest!)
Автокөліктер мен көлік құралдары
The old HR-V was thrashed in a drag race at the X50's launch but this new 3rd-gen model also has a 1.5-litre turbocharged engine. On paper they're now very closely matched. With its wounds nursed and in stronger form than ever, the Honda is here to reclaim its past glory. Let's fight!
Motor Madness! Enjoy RM150 eWallet rewards with car insurance renewal by Tune Protect! Only till 30 April 2023. Find out more at bit.ly/tp-car-insurance
Website: www.carlist.my
Facebook: / carlist.my
Instagram: / carlistmy
Tiktok: / carlistmy
CarTell: / cartell
#protonx50 #hondahrv #carlist
Пікірлер: 225
I love watching things that i can't afford 😂😂😂
@carlist_my
Жыл бұрын
🙋
@cheekyboy21
Жыл бұрын
BMW xm is way too ugly.
@Seventy-SevenTimes
Жыл бұрын
hahaha same
@C3ByAx
Жыл бұрын
How's the A-pillar wind-noise in the X50 when going above 80km/h? The same problem China side also facing
@nicholasallan3755
10 ай бұрын
😂
pandangan saya bg pengguna kedua hrv dan x50. masa baru ambil hrv mmg rasa lagi padu. tapi selepas 2 bulan start suka drive balik x50 daily. ada kelebihan pada x50 yg saya tak dapat nak perincikan berbanding hrv.
The main complaint about X50 is the high fuel consumption (9.7 liter/100 km for town driving) but the saving of RM 20 k (difference in price) is equivalent to getting free petrol for 8 years.
@nexttothemoon1
Жыл бұрын
Exactly... the RM 21,500 price differential gets you ~10,000 liters of free petrol (at current prices). Also free sunroof & Auto Parking in the X50. Plus you can add in about RM 5000 total in additional insurance costs as well for the Honda over 10 years as well.
@jakirokiro5784
Жыл бұрын
Don't forget to calculate bank interest for RM 20K
@ranceng6560
Жыл бұрын
How's bout 2nd hand value?
@karinkatt7893
Жыл бұрын
@Rance Ng ....soo many poor people here.....buy car just to sell back later...no wonder too may 2nd hrv now for sale.....something wrong wit it tat people keep on selling it just after owning it for few years???
@C3ByAx
Жыл бұрын
How's the A-pillar wind-noise in the X50 when going above 80km/h? The same problem China side also facing
Drove the X50 flagship for a week. It is very impressive for a 1.5.
love my x50 so far been driven it for 6 month . fuel consumption not bad considering i did 150-160 on highway. 7.3 L/100km is not bad i would say
@jakirokiro5784
Жыл бұрын
7.7L/KM - 5.3L/KM = 2.4/KM = RM 4.92 , every month they diffrent RM100, 5 years only RM 6000. i bet X50 is the best for this
@akeshshi9137
Жыл бұрын
Now compare city driving difference.
@C3ByAx
Жыл бұрын
How's the A-pillar wind-noise in the X50 when going above 80km/h? The same problem China side also facing
@SollehuddinAziz
8 ай бұрын
Proton don't have efficient engine. Just admit.
@dhashrathwilliam9309
4 ай бұрын
Can I know what variant your X50 is ?
I hope u all can do the comparison between new mazda cx30 ckd with the corrolla cross gr sport. 🙏
In the Philippines, we have paddle shifters for the X50/Coolray, but we don't have rear airvents. and we don't have the whistling sound at high speeds.
@mabinyob7595
Жыл бұрын
What is the function of pedal shif because x50 has manual shifter on gear knop?
@kurtx8827
6 ай бұрын
The highest speed in the Philippines is 60km/h due to massive traffic. Lol
X50 came out a few years already before the current new hrv. Its like comparing iphone 14 pro max with like iphone 12 pro max. Regardless, x50 held out its own despite the 30k price difference.
@badrolhisham1582
Жыл бұрын
Totally agreed with you
@Laughingorcorp
Жыл бұрын
not a good argument point. anyway,. take it
@karinkatt7893
Жыл бұрын
@@Laughingorcorp ...its valid
@nattokami9598
Жыл бұрын
@@Laughingorcorp it literally is
@macateer896
Жыл бұрын
Well the lastime x50 was release people were comparing with the honda hrv which come out at 2015-2016?? U cant compare phone with cars new phone will come out newer model every year bt cars will take about few years before coming out with a newer version tho
The HRV V spec is almost the perfect compact crossover except for the lack of these 2 things - floating infotainment display similar to the Civic FE, and secondly the power boot from the HRV RS.
@DaddyTesla
Жыл бұрын
Not only that…no front sensor as well
@ginodavis
Жыл бұрын
@@DaddyTesla add 360 camera too
@Laughingorcorp
Жыл бұрын
these 2 stuffs easily after market , worry what. haha
for a daily use car, CVT is better than DCT of course
Just want to ask... What about the cabin noise... Which is more quiet? I heard complaint about Honda CR-V crappy compared with X70... How about the lower segment B?
@lokekaryew8408
Жыл бұрын
Yes. X70 cabin is more quiet than HRV.
Great video. How does the Subaru XV year 2022 compare? Appreciate your comments. Thanks.
will choose HRV in a blink.. seeing x50 on the road like seeing myvi on the road….it’s like every 1 minute akan nampak satu x50 lalu
@banktraders7639
Жыл бұрын
Xada lah.i pula nampak hrv byk dari x50 disini. Tu smua mentaliti ja.
@vertigo2930
11 ай бұрын
Jenis mentality nak acah2 rare la ek
@missnuetral9516
10 ай бұрын
Mentaliti pkai proton org miskin.. naik hrv nmpk acah berduit
@sabmolly
8 ай бұрын
i keje area mont kiara. guess what race byk kat sini ? yes.. cina. sini byk cina pilih utk pakai x50. surprisingly mat salleh pun byk pakai beb
@vertigo2930
8 ай бұрын
@@sabmolly sebab kalau banding X70, X50 save minyak
Long-term maintenance cost?
Nice vid. Sorry I dont know your name but the X50 guy you do look and sound like Brainy from Supergirl.
Fuel consumption on the X50 is definitely an issue. Coupled with the small tank, you'll need to refuel twice a week based on daily 60km commute
@100flite
7 ай бұрын
Yes one full tank cant even get you to Penang from Seremban. Had to refuel at Simpang Ampat. Bad fuel consumption 😢
@danishraisham1697
6 ай бұрын
@@100flite Simpang ampat? Pretty sure that's more southern than Seremban, assuming using PLUS highway
@user-zc2xz2vf9f
4 ай бұрын
Dude it's easy to put petrol everyday.
x50- performance, interior, more features. hrv- handling, exterior, fuel efficiency, after sales, branding. Overall Hrv still win for me.
@kurtx8827
6 ай бұрын
HRV - lower maintenance costs.
@menot4691
13 күн бұрын
Hrv - High resale value
I still say dct are the best for gearbox
14:22 beautiful roaring V12 in the background, it has to be the Aventador.
let say you saving rm 4800 every 100k km for less fuel consumption compare to x50, then you need drive for more than 500k km for compesate the extra amount of money when you buy honda crv that rm30k more than x50, which mean only after 15years you can say buying hrv value for money
@ginodavis
Жыл бұрын
Nobody knows if the fuel price remains the same after a year or so. Need to consider resale value too
@HambaAllah91_
Жыл бұрын
Second value dont forget
glad to see if can compare c segment sedan car
Bagi aku.gearbox DCT lebih power dari CVT. DCT lebih lasak dari CVT. Dari handling kedua² pakai torsion beam. Jadi kurang sikitlah. Jika pakai multi link lagi mantap. Dari value market memang honda menang. Dari kelajuan x50 menang. Keluasan honda menang. Dari function dlm x50 menang.
X50 need a new trim. The one in Malaysia is old, the 1st generation.
China cars (I know it's Malaysian brand but it's basically Geely), are known for low fuel efficiency, so the fuel consumption result is not surprising.
X50 still the best. 20k different .. hello . Really want compare?
@akeshshi9137
Жыл бұрын
20,000 for a 9 year loan is a rm180 difference. Now do the maths for the fuel, maintenance and resale value savings.
@anas7412
Жыл бұрын
I think more than 20k difference.
@ALF444
Жыл бұрын
Government tax save ploton ass. Or else nobody buy ploton and perodua
@kurtx8827
6 ай бұрын
@@ALF444It won’t cross your mind if you understand economics and watch less car videos. Lol
How about the sound systems? Which one is better?
X50 owner .good vid
Can you guys do a comparison on omoda 5 and gs3 emzoom? 😁
Need to test drive a few SUVs.
Why macai ploton crying in the comments. 😭😭. They thought X50 is supercar and unbeatable 😭😭
HRV vs CX30 Ckd pleaseeee
Tested both cars and in terms of handling, smoothness and most importantly NVH level, the HRV wins hands down. If you have the budget, go for it!
@imanbus
11 ай бұрын
HRV interior is way too ugly bro, either X50 or switch toyota LOL
@100flite
11 ай бұрын
@@imanbus LMAO!! The main reason I ditched the Cross was because of the hopelessly awful interior 🤣🤣🤣
@imanbus
11 ай бұрын
@@100flite cross and x50 are way better than hrv la
@imanbus
11 ай бұрын
@@100flite plus Cross exterior also far superior than hrv
@100flite
11 ай бұрын
@@imanbus which part??? HRV is so much nicer looking. The Turbo engine is so much more powerful. HRV's interior doesn't make you feel like sitting inside a tanning chamber LMAO 🤣
Thats why honda is more expensive than x50. Its value are hidden. You cannot explain to someone who are judging a car by its accessories.
@lambogini7586
Жыл бұрын
The tax make Honda price higher .. not hidden value or quality
@truthurts704
Жыл бұрын
the x50 is much more better looking, especially on the inside
@keithchai8566
Жыл бұрын
@@lambogini7586 but the fuel hungry x50 make it more expensive to maintain over the time
@lambogini7586
Жыл бұрын
@@keithchai8566 you are right
@BILZA
Жыл бұрын
@@keithchai8566 i cant argue more. Own x50 and it's really consume a lot of gas
In terms of seating position and comfortable for long distance I preferred hrv. Tested both car.
Weird why they took steering shifter out. All Coolray models has it.
@nawfas_mg2019
Жыл бұрын
It's even weird to remove led indicator for gear knob
I almost thought twas a GCR. Nice X50.
@jonmanilenio
Жыл бұрын
it is a GCR. in Malaysia it's rebadged as the X50.
Dua2 suv favorite , tapi saya hanya mampu pakai saga je skrg 😆
@carlist_my
Жыл бұрын
min pakai saga juga bro 😅
Dah test 2 2...loan pn 2 2 lpas... Last skali ambik x50... 😉
@hekh3k
Жыл бұрын
Ok
@mrsomebody4957
Жыл бұрын
good choice
@fairdh85
Жыл бұрын
Kita sama
@firuzzie6277
4 сағат бұрын
Mana lagi terasa power nya antara dua ni
During the drag looks like you guys being too soft to it coz it looks slow. Didn't you floor to the max?
I like my car vm. very smooth to drive. im x50 owner 😊
Focus review kereta ❌ Focus english dia ✅
What colour for hrv in this vid?
@mohdismin8325
4 ай бұрын
Ruse black
Overtime and after the more frequent visits to the petrol stations, the X50 will be the more expensive car to live with in the real world. The new HRV is just a better overall package in terms of performance and practicality. 😊👌
@axepro3053
Жыл бұрын
Lol no 360 camera
@KaryaTermasyhur
Жыл бұрын
@@axepro3053noob parking
@100flite
4 ай бұрын
Yes you're right. Also nobody wants those crappy 3 cylinder engines anymore. Even Geely China started to ditch it. Rough, noisy and bad fuel consumption compared to 4 cylinder!
I need BSM and RTCA because of nowadays traffic condition, and not those useless landwatch
do it always..the cvt will berkecai bang
Quite shocked how fuel efficient the Honda is considering it’s an SUV
@dorairajmokhan4692
Жыл бұрын
Agreed brother, me previously using honda city and upgrading to hrv the fuel efficiency are almost same and driving feels comfortable
@nagamurthy3739
Жыл бұрын
Honda engines nowdays are really efficient fuel burner
@tooinchi
Жыл бұрын
fuel savinf only rm4800 per 100k km, still far more than extra money you spend for 134k vs 106k car
@hamsterboy6314
Жыл бұрын
@@tooinchi Haven’t take into account on proton’s infamous abysmal after sales service, loss of days usage if car is stranded in SC, time loss frequenting SC and spare part availability.
@karinkatt7893
Жыл бұрын
@Hamster Boy ..not to mentioned too many 2nd hrv nowdays...even tis new ones will make it into 2nd car lot in just 2 3 years.....
You guys forgetting that there is a 114k hrv as well , S spec.
@nexttothemoon1
Жыл бұрын
Then to be fairer you'd have to compare it to the Proton X50 Standard at RM 86K.
@anas7412
Жыл бұрын
Yeah, 1.5NA for that weight?
Don't waste time comparing when you have it in your mind. Comparing should start from all the build parts not just i think and think bla bla bla
DCT is much reliable n better performance gearbox compared with CVT
The long waiting period and also the growing numbers of complains on the X50 turned me towards the HRV. So far so good and thoroughly enjoying it.
@TheZaman_
Жыл бұрын
i got my x50 within a month though.
@ybyusri
Жыл бұрын
@@TheZaman_ the Q has improved apparently. You would get before raya if anyone orders now
@akeshshi9137
Жыл бұрын
There's no more waiting for the x50 as people realised the parts and quality issues and cancelled bookings.
@TheZaman_
Жыл бұрын
@@akeshshi9137 lol.. x50 sales still best in class. 😂
@karinkatt7893
Жыл бұрын
@TheZaman ...yeah then can see new hrv in used car dealer soo fast due to many owners too poor to maintained it....only buy just for feel2 then proud of resale value....
HRV for sure !
Honda much better but high price
By the way... go google "Honda Admits the Honda HR-V Rear Window Has a Self-Destruct Function"
Turbo memang untuk tingkat fuel efficiency pun.
I think the only downside for x50 is the 3 years warranty of DCT gearbox. Buat ak fikir 2 3 kali nk beli. Kereta baru dibeli utk peace of mind usually for 5 years la u get peace of mind. Tp gearbox 3 tahun je warranty.
@isaac4396
11 ай бұрын
Lagi2 kalau X50 ni rosak GB,hantar SC banyak yg complain SC lambat buat kerja.
@georgebutland7367
7 ай бұрын
This DCT is quite reliable. It's designed for reliability. Unlike VW, it's design for sporty.. Ive been driving x50 more than 3 years and no issue with the gearbox..
@hatsuharu6111
Күн бұрын
DCT is more reliable than CVT lol
Of course u cant compare to newer hrb technology.
Hrv more latest..cant beat its prestige..and theres x50 draining battery problem
@100flite
7 ай бұрын
Many X50 owners also complained about high fuel consumption and vibration from the 3 cylinder engine 😢
Hrv worl level famous and x50 nly in Malaysia famous so please dnt compare orginal and local 😂
hahah. this video is sponsored by honda. can see how he try to promote the honda, and its weird when they said hrv has less body roll, when most of the professional driver said x50 is more comfortable in taking the corner, n hrv is better in steering handling.
@azuwanahmad2638
Жыл бұрын
Definitely bias
@haniffkamalchannel7487
Жыл бұрын
Go Test Drive first and u will know...
@zahidanzullkefeli1758
Жыл бұрын
@@haniffkamalchannel7487 i booked hrv at first place and x50 second. :) both are tested
@haniffkamalchannel7487
Жыл бұрын
@@zahidanzullkefeli1758 then which model u pick?
@zahidanzullkefeli1758
Жыл бұрын
@@haniffkamalchannel7487 x50 of course
That's what Honda means the power of dream.....hehehe
Nasib baik dalam hujan lebat.. ada berani?
X50 FLAGSHIP Best siotttt..
Hrv looks boring and old fashion....X50's design interior/exterior looks young fresh and eye catching...
Finally…
X50 ❤
My old starlet rwd 62 hp car smoked the slow fwd x50 in pick up I done several times tell you rwd always have that explosive pick up more than fwd look atdrag racing videos Toyota start even when low powered like mine it's all in traction for that instantaneous burst shame on fwd
new x 50。。。。bingyue cool 。。。。will beat HRV
Spe kata handling proton bgos sgt haha
no apple car play and android auto on x50 is a big turn off seriously
@Joengos83
11 ай бұрын
U can solve it easily by using carlink kit...u will got wireless AAuto and Apple Carplay better than wired CRT TV inside HRV
Infotainment choosen by Geely..... No android auto and Apple car play is big stim cutting.
@Joengos83
11 ай бұрын
U can buy carlink kit and solve the problem. Plus u will get wireless android auto/carplay not like the one in HRV (old CRT TV)
@candid244
7 ай бұрын
U bring up another point. I don't like to modify anything. I like stock car only @@Joengos83
x50 less cylinder but makan minyak then hrv by alot..
@watb8689
Жыл бұрын
got change the rims and tyres and do a good remap. Then you will see the true potential of the car
@michael9413
Жыл бұрын
Haha... you see people complaint about proton FC... But I got a friend doing less than 9.0L/100km on X70 CBU... It really depends how good is your right leg...
@Joengos83
11 ай бұрын
@watb8689 can share what rim n tyre n what ecu used
@100flite
7 ай бұрын
Also vibration a lot... 😢
X50 Many Consumers Complaining Have Many Issue Too Many Electronic Parts..
@leezhenxiang4146
Жыл бұрын
Seems like u never used newer hondas before, the electronic parts.... Prices...
@100flite
7 ай бұрын
It's a Proton what.. sure problem 😅
x50 tech is from Volvo... Brand is from geely.. Volvo owns by geely.. 😊
Please kick out that guy..i dont like him..
X50💪🏼
Did Honda pay you guys?
@Joengos83
11 ай бұрын
I second u
Nonesense comparison latest compare for 3 years old car. Of course latest will have a recent technology. True like comparing ipone 14 with samsung S20 not even S21 or latest S22. Why dont compare it with volvo XC40 ?
@ALF444
Жыл бұрын
So you forgot the last time 2020 X50 compare to 2015 Hrv? And why would Hrv compare to XC40. XC40 is completely on different level that's why it cost 100k more.
@100flite
7 ай бұрын
@@ALF444correct...Proton supporters semua mangkuk 😅
Japan vs China
@khairulannuarabuzaki8150
3 ай бұрын
Made in melaka actually
X50 always taking care its owner safety. When driving X50 seems like your next passenger is your driving school teacher. Dont do this, do this and blaa..blaa. Nice
This guy just hating the x50
Bias
Kebanggaan China lol
What a biased review! It makes honda looks so desperate.
Bro don't t compare China car with Japanese car.. This China car engine for sure cannot lasting like Japanese car.. 😅
Gemuk cam try hard sangat laa..
@TheNazreensyah
Жыл бұрын
At least he got the job done. I bet you cant even record a proper vlog.
@mohdhanif1803
Жыл бұрын
@@TheNazreensyah yeah agree with ya..setakat toxic sampah...yg peliknya puak2 ni sentiasa wujud..
proton x50 suck
@jossy1981
Жыл бұрын
Can you explain
I would always prefer a Japanese car over a Chinese car
@Joengos83
5 ай бұрын
Dulu yes...now,no more