Prepping for Winter: The Asha Fragment
Ойын-сауық
The line-by-line analysis of the Winds of Winters sample chapters. Here we look at the Asha fragment, a bit of the Winds of Winter found on Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
Patreon: / prestonjacobs
The line-by-line analysis of the Winds of Winters sample chapters. Here we look at the Asha fragment, a bit of the Winds of Winter found on Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
Patreon: / prestonjacobs
Пікірлер: 340
"Because we are psychotic, someone took a screenshot"... Well said...
@Blaklyon0
2 жыл бұрын
I would say, Dedicated... But, psychotic works, too.
@chronikhiles
Жыл бұрын
Psychotic would mean the experience of delusions or hallucinations. I don't believe that GRRM is psychotic, but I do believe that people use big words to sound smarter.
Don't forget the fakeout with Davos' head
RIP Mors Umber
I found Big Walder leading the Freys in the Asha fragment really interesting. A Frey host led by Hosteen is unlikely to switch allegiance to Stannis (especially if Stannis has the Manderlys) You point out in "A Frey in the Snow" Big Walder is likely clever and wants to be lord of the twins. Couldn't Big Walder possibly win the lord of the crossing if he aligned with Stannis (maybe after many of his men fall into the ice) and helping Arthur Karstark sneak Stannis men into Winterfell? Then Walder could hope to eventually usurp the Twins with Stannis support
@coopermaxwell5286
5 жыл бұрын
add this with the frey civil war...
@gabehcuod3200
5 жыл бұрын
also it makes the 1 eyed head on a weirwood spear to blood raven connection considering big walder is part frey part blackwood
@evilsimeon
9 ай бұрын
I’d rather see the freys extinguished.
Anyone else suspicious that George purposefully had this screen up because he likes messing with the fans?
@Jennifer-dv5ok
7 жыл бұрын
Jooooger that's exactly what I was wondering! George knows how crazy his fans are
@MissyAmy88
7 жыл бұрын
No, because then he would have to write that fake story. Him being a perfectionist, he would work to make it perfect, and him hating all kinds of stress it would be too big of a bother I think.
@logansmith2703
6 жыл бұрын
Jooooger at the very least there is the distinct possibility Crowfood is totally fine.
@TraciPeteyforlife
2 жыл бұрын
I'm pretty sure that is something George would do that. I'm also fairly sure he should hire Preston to do organization an help with things.
Low energy Freys should know better than to go after Crowfood, a great respected man, very great friend of mine. Sad!
@Kevin-fi4uo
7 жыл бұрын
President Donald J Trump Your syntax is so similar to his, wow.
@terranman4702
7 жыл бұрын
Stannis will win and people will give you a lot of credit for it.
@burtan2000
7 жыл бұрын
I know, it's scary. I've long thought that anyone with half a brain and great tolerance for stupidity could be a pop music lyricist or at least a country music lyricist. Now I know that anyone with absolutely no morals, a quarter-brain, and immense tolerance for immense stupidity, could speak only in empty promises, wild, groundless boasts, present themselves like spoiled 12 y.o. rich white virgin boys who have delusions of grandeur so extreme, mental conditions will be named after them and apparently make it the highest office in our once-great nation.
@heckyeah4314
7 жыл бұрын
You may not like me, that's okay buddy. I'm a big guy y'know, I'm a big guy I can take it. At least when I take office I won't be ordering our military to shoot down any Russians in Syria, like crooked Hillary wanted to! Putin's not a good guy, he's not a good guy okay. He's not a good guy, I get it. I get it! But I just wanna have a good thing with the Russians okay. It'd be good if we got along with them. Would that be so bad, eh? I was alive, for so long. Believe me. For so long in the twentieth century. I lived through so much of it, believe me. Okay. I lived through so much of it, I saw our beautiful country almost go to war with the Russians, that was a disaster for our country, the Cold War. A disaster. You want to go through all that again tough guy? You're a tough guy okay I see it, but let's not do all that again.
@jackjohnston9618
7 жыл бұрын
lmao this made me laugh nice comment
I cracked up at the "because we fans are psychotic" part. So true! We might have been well-balanced individuals once, but the wait for the Winds of Winter made us all ... shall we say, a bit ... on edge.
@Kriegerdammerung
4 жыл бұрын
I feel in my bones that TWOW will be here in less than three months; this comment was written on Saturday 31st August 2019.
@haumea22
4 жыл бұрын
@@Kriegerdammerung of course your wrong
@Kriegerdammerung
4 жыл бұрын
@@haumea22 Yes, but a paparazzi has seen Mr. Martin going to visit his editor
@legrandliseurtri7495
3 жыл бұрын
@@Kriegerdammerung Yikes.
@Kriegerdammerung
3 жыл бұрын
@@legrandliseurtri7495 I'm sad, mate )= how could I have been so wrong?
I think it's Big Walder rather than Hosteen Frey in the armour... it fits the descriptions of his armour.
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
7 жыл бұрын
I do think you're right, actually. This was recently brought to my attention. I think I'll mention it during the Forsaken.
@alecnava5465
7 жыл бұрын
A nine year old tho?
@Igor_054
2 жыл бұрын
@@alecnava5465 Yes. Family status means more than experience in the feudal logic of Westeros.
@absolutechad5428
Жыл бұрын
@@Igor_054 That is completely ridiculous and incorrect. In both real life and ASOIAF there has never been a case of a nine year old leading a force in war. Muh feudalism is not an excuse.
seriously.. we've pretty much seen the entire book on your channel, bro.. love it
I really hope Winds of Winter is around the corner.
@hinahinananoha7783
7 жыл бұрын
CyaLatte We all do, sir, we all do:)
@Macconator2010
7 жыл бұрын
Nadiya Nanoha I know, I'm just having one of those moments when you get extra anxious, ya feel me?
@hinahinananoha7783
7 жыл бұрын
CyaLatte Me do:))
@shortstuff780
7 жыл бұрын
CyaLatte a joke my friend and I had due to the deaths of so many great people in '16 we were like watch grrm come out Christmas day stating that the books finished and that he will be announcing a release date the new year's, but pass away doing new year... thank God that didn't happen, but that would have caused riots for sure. hoping winds comes out soon.. like asap
@HH-cm5rp
5 жыл бұрын
and look at us now ...
Asoiaf fans are like crackheads. I can't believe they got this fragment from a John Oliver skit lmao it's like another little hit to keep us going til' we can re-up with TWOW
@ilertargenthorne4639
3 жыл бұрын
Heh. To think people were this intense 4 years ago. We still are of course... But...
@DannyWonder
3 жыл бұрын
Hope is gone. Preston’s theories are the cannon now
Holy shit 'The Forsaken' next?! As Chad would say: ''ITS GONNA BE SOOO AWESOOOME!''
@ilertargenthorne4639
3 жыл бұрын
Yup. It's gonna be.
I'm so ready for you to talk the Winds of Winter when it comes out. Since it seems to be the first book released since you started the channel I'm wondering if you're gonna do a chapter by chapter analysis, or do an overall plot review of the books by pov? Curious to see how you incorporate new info into your theories too!!! No joke, if I was only allowed to watch one KZread channel, it would be this one. Happy New Year!
@ilertargenthorne4639
3 жыл бұрын
Happy New Year
so many characters faking their dead. I now had in my mind a comical image of someone walking over Ice batlfield yelling "is anybody hare really dead?" and all the corpses start lazili rasing with someone saying "I have a flash wound"
I need this videos, they are like a drug!
@snowballandpals
7 жыл бұрын
Vanessa Amesty how do you know what drugs are like?
@pupintheturdiii
7 жыл бұрын
Vanessa Amesty video* or these*
@alessio32000
7 жыл бұрын
they good, everyone knows that.
@vanessaamesty6739
7 жыл бұрын
I meant they are addictive.. ¬¬
@pupintheturdiii
7 жыл бұрын
Vanessa Amesty Like cookies because you're fat.
absolutely amazing the lengths ASOIAF fans will go to get a little taste of TWOW
Lol Preston why u making vids during vacation.
Thank you for not forgetting us, Preston. Keep it up! :)
thank you for time while on vacation!!
@skippycoulter
7 жыл бұрын
I'm sure he is enjoying himself. The Sweetrobin does these vids because he enjoys them.
Huh... I wonder if Crowfood Umber was inspired by Xiahou Dun from Luo Guanzhong's historical novel, Romance of the Three Kingdoms. When shot in the eye with an arrow, he removed the arrow and ate his own eyeball.
@axelNodvon2047
2 жыл бұрын
He might, there was a Yi Ti emperor inspired by Lu Bu. So he is familiar at least with three kingdoms
@jasonakers6538
2 жыл бұрын
@@axelNodvon2047 Cool. Nice necropost, by the way. From thy necromancy, I am become Lich!
@axelNodvon2047
2 жыл бұрын
@@jasonakers6538 I'm a wight 🧟
Hey Preston do you think Barristan will be betrayed in the battle of fire. Will the gate be locked when Barristan and his knights attempt to return behind Mereens walls leading to them being slaughtered?
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
7 жыл бұрын
Yeah, I would say that's pretty darn likely.
@Thullin00
7 жыл бұрын
Preston Jacobs Come on man you cant let my dude Barristan die knock that attitude of!!
@PewPewPlasmagun
7 жыл бұрын
That would mean that they are losing the battle. But last chapter they were winning... ostensibly.
@gajsempronijegrah
7 жыл бұрын
Rob Stark was also winning... GRRM loves to bring down his characters immediately after their victories... alas :)
@PewPewPlasmagun
7 жыл бұрын
Robb Stark was not killed in a battle. And Selmy won all his battles too - on the battlefield I mean. I'm just saying, he has the Stormcrows and there are also the Unsullied elsewhere and the freedmen companies. I am not sure if they could save him but surely Skahaz could not keep them out with his Brazen Beasts? Especially if the Free Brothers are still holding the Northern Gate (I assume they don't really participate on the battlefield?).
Enjoy South Africa and stay safe. I'm sure you have a lot of viewers from South Africa, myself included.
@ClaireYunFarronXIII
6 жыл бұрын
Ceasius Me too
I enjoy all of your content Preston but the 'Prepping for Winter' videos are by far my favourite. Keep it up!
Damn, I was about to crazily searching for the Asha chapter before starting the video. I thought I missed it. Luckily, I was inspired enough play the video first. I saved myself from who knows how much time of searching.
Northern treachery 101: Fake your own death.
and we are back.
GRRM is capable of "planting" that excerpt there to mess with us 😂
@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin
7 жыл бұрын
Ha ha, well, that's a lot of effort on his part. It's too well written to be faked, IMO.
honestly Preston, I'm so excited when I see you have posted a new video. I have seen everything you put up on this channel and I am such a fan. thank you for all your time and effort, sincerely.
I'm in South Africa. come to my brothel.
@TheWoodstock2009
7 жыл бұрын
Damnit Alayaya
@georgejenkins5186
7 жыл бұрын
***** Stole my joke bro
You are too good to us, big man. Enjoy your holiday.
If the freyleader is big walder, as you said in the forsaken, Mors Umber did bite of the enemies head, hosteen frey was the leader/head of their army and he has likely fallen, when big walder commands them now.
stannis. Stannis! STANNIS! 🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥. 🍑
@axelNodvon2047
5 жыл бұрын
🦌🦌🦌🦌
I'm so glad you're going to tackle the Forsaken Chapter, that's perhaps my favourite of all the sample chapters from TWOW so far, can't wait for that video. This was great too, I wasn't even aware this info was out there.
Hope you have a nice holiday and thank you for still putting out videos!
Nice job 😊 I really appreciate the way you communicate. You are able to present a wide scope of information in a concise fashion without overusing technical language. The sound quality was quite good IMO so don't stress. I can't wait for your analysis of The Forsaken but ... PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do the Frey civil war next! This is something I'm very interested in as I've been trying to figure it out myself, to no avail so I'm really looking forward to what you have to say! Cheers Ps: thank you for taking time out of your holiday for us Preston!! 😊
happy new year. thanks for the vid
happy new year Preston! hopefully this is when winter finally arrives
Thank you for providing us with this video while you're on vacation.
Fantastic insights! More Prepping for Winter por favor! Sound quality is fine - less high end, but clean and undistorted.
enjoy your vacation preston :) quality stuff as always. i like to err on the side of the fake outs myself but in this case my head is ruling my heart. i feel this was his destiny in the story, this was crowfood's purpose - to make this strange, artistic point about whether or not bloodraven has led the frey's to their final demise.
Been waiting so long for this. Thank you, Preston.
Quality content man! Best on the web!
The mic is fine.
Making a new video while on vacation? Much appreciated!
2nd time listening . . . sound was just fine both times. . . Nice work on the Asha Fragment .
amazing parallels
I think the umbers have a hidden army somewhere in between the last hearth and winterfell i think they might have maybe 500 fighters in their prime
thank you Preston
Another fantastic upload!!
thanks for uploading this while on vacation :)
Welcome to South Africa! Enjoy your stay
Happy New Year Preston!
Happy New Year!!!:)
thank you for contributing to my unhealthy obession, even on vacation. ❤
@ilertargenthorne4639
3 жыл бұрын
How's it going?
wicked. hadn't heard of the asha bit. glad it is around. good work as usual. when do you figure you'll have time to tackle the forsaken?
Enjoy your vacation. Try to hit up Jacks in Capetown if you make it there. It's lovely.
Talking about parallels: in the Battle of Fire we have dragons on the loose, and they're obviously going to play some role. Do you think the Others are going to crash the Battle of Ice, or its immediate aftermath? It would figure.
This series shoud have been called Prepping with Greyjoys :-)
Happy new year Preston.
All these people saying you should not make video's in your vacation. I'm just happy i can watch this video in my vacation! xD
Thanks Preston!
Thank you for the excellent video:) Enjoy your vacation:) xoxo
U should describe every chapter this way it's amazing
Im sorry but Big Walder is small and only 9 or 10 there is no way anyone could confuse him up for a fully grown man/Knight regardless of he's armour!
Hey Preston for what it's worth you've really changed my life. I'm writing a series and I'd lost hope that anyone cared about the lore and histories I wrote and that I'd wasted years working on this....Ugh, I don't want to rant... Just thank you.
Hey Preston, First off great research. Ever since I heard your analysis about the resurrection of Catlyn Stark and the idea of her body being controlled by some other Telekinetic person and not her come back to life. I began to wonder if Crows Food was being controlled in a similar manner since the time he got his new name. My go to would be to guess Bloodraven controlling him being that there there they are both 1 eyed followers of the old gods, and it was a crow that ate his eye perhaps the 3 eyed raven. And Bloodraven might be more interested in having influence in the north. However his actions appear to be more in line with a Crow's Eye influence, his raunchy behavior, his alliance with Stanis, and his other actions that appear to weaken and jeopardize the future of the north overall such as risking the green boys. Anyway this is all out of left field and probably an over study but I would find it interesting if Crow's eye or Bloodraven Factions were working with placed undead agents to weaken their enemy's positions. Great quality videos keep them coming.
A head of bloodraven and of bittersteel is cool since the two were rivals
I think it's great that Theon mentioned his own head on a spear. If Theon isn't really beheaded by Stannis, maybe Umber wasn't really beheaded then either?
Another parallel between the battle of ice and fire: Both will sacrifice a prince/princess. Quentyn burns alive by dragon fire. Shireen is burnt alive by Melissandre.
@legrandliseurtri7495
3 жыл бұрын
She will likely not be burned.
and I NEED more prepping for winter chapter reviews...
Great video!
the sword hilts on the drawing of hosteen frey look like his tiny fists. now i cant see them as hilts again
Interesting analysis
cheers preston
If this fragment was written in 2014, surely the chance is very high that it's been amended and is no longer relevant? Damn, Preston, kick back and enjoy your vacation, man!
@haterhayder
7 жыл бұрын
Cardinal Doomsday probably not, grrm apparently over writes and uses what he doesn't add into the books as references to keep his canon right. So even if it's not added to the book it'll be referenced
@ilertargenthorne4639
3 жыл бұрын
I should hope not.
Saw a new PJ upload - ecstatic. Saw it wasn't 1,000 Worlds book club - come down
Another great video :)
We all know stannis will win. Show is fanfiction. ONE REALM, ONE GOD, ONE KING.
Holy shit that was a fucking quality video, Preston. Anyway have fun on vacation!
I am clucking so hard for your next video
Damn I clicked on this hard. Have a nice vacation.
Doesn't lapis lazuli feature in other sigils? The Florents and the brooches given to the Vale tourney in the Alayne sample chapter? Any significance in this material? Where it's from in the World?
I never knew the Freytowers are blue in the sigil. Does that colour have a special meaning? It seems rather unusual or are there some blue rocks, people built castles with?
oh thank you ❤️
Sounded fine to me. Lesotho? Interesting vacation choice.
Preston (and y'all) what do you figure will be the role of Greatjon Umbers other sons in all of this? I figure they're younger than Robb, but not of age with Brann - I fell that would've been mentioned. ? Unless theyll have no role at all ?
@FalloutBattles
7 жыл бұрын
It is interesting that only Smalljon has been mentioned. You would think they would be involved in some way...and if the Bolton's and CO. had a hold of them we would likely know. That would be a big piece to have against Stannis. Crowfood wouldn't have fought for Stannis if his relatives who would inherit were held. But where are they? It is weird that we have heard nothing. I mean their forces have been used up and even more were taken by the Greatjon's Uncles...so maybe they are not at Last Hearth.
Can't wait
lol, Mors Umber was one of Jon Olivers favourite characters it seems....Nice catch with the parallel imagery and Bloodraven/Bittersteel. One too many fakouts, but I reckon there is legitimacy to Hosteen getting Mors, as you say people think the Freys fools but Hosteen may not be. Enjoy Vacation
I'm sure GRRM knew for absolute certain that his computer screen was visible and people were going to figure it out, which leads me to believe he was either having a little fun with us and it's all bullshit or he's also having a little fun with us and throwing us a bone. I for one believe it's bullshit. Don't you think with as secretive as he usually is the chance of this being absolutely legit are quite low? He is definitely a little more low-key then not and we know this for a fact.
Nice little surprise upload c:
you sounded great.
Is there any hope of the book coming out this year?
I was a bit disappointed that this wasn't Euron, but I can forgive if your on vacation. I can wait, but not forever man; I need to know what you think about that suit of valyrian armor
Stennis is an ancient term that represents the transition from winter to summer, just saying
@shireenbaratheon6955
7 жыл бұрын
Zach Simon Wow, I hadn't heard of that before. Stannis fighting the Others confirmed!
@zachsimon5587
7 жыл бұрын
I was really high when I wrote that. Stennas/stennis (sp?) is not a person but an ancient Scottish megalithic/religious site where people would go for the reasons I stated above.
@allyriastark3508
6 жыл бұрын
explains his connection to Light Bringer and Azor Ahai - even AA didn't fight alone and Stannis is doing everything he can before real hero is here
This is what I was made for he thought. The dance, the sweet steel song... -Barristian The Bold
I need Alayne
@ferraghamo
7 жыл бұрын
ikr
@aviehmayer
7 жыл бұрын
Me too!
what if Big Balder takes the power in the Frey army and then join Stanis along with the Manderlyes. Then they spead false rumors about kiling Stanis and somehow atack Winterfell together , using the Suprise. Then Stanis gives him the Twins for the good service . Thats how Big Walder becomes owner of the Twins .
Hi Preston, Awesome, where in SA are you and the wife visiting, hope you guy's visit my home town "Cape Town". I wonder how many South Africans watches your show. Anyway enjoy the trip and keep up the awesome vids...
I find it hard to believe that Asha can mistake a nine year old child for a Warrior leading an attack, and he's small for his age and a seasoned fighter like Asha is would be able to tell the difference, so it must be Hosteen.
Did you visit Cape Town also?