im a goan catholic. we are extremely devout catholics but equally patriotic Indians. Many of us hold high positions in the indian armed forces and many have laid down their lives for our motherland INDIA. Our Roman Catholicism doesn't make us any less Indian. To all the Portuguese and others feeling offended, I respect all of you. I don't know the situation in the 1950s but today Goans have moved on. We are Indian n proud. You had your glory days. now you too, kindly move on

@summersolstice4365

9 жыл бұрын

my ancestors may or may not have been converted during that period. whatever the case,my faith is the only thing that gives me 100% inner peace and satisfaction. also, what the Portuguese did was in complete contradiction with what my saviour jesus preached... to love your enemy, to pray for those that persecute you, forgiveness etc. most Christians in fact don't even have any regard for them as what many of them did went against everything that Christianity stands for. a blot on Christianity indeed. but most of us today have a very real and personal connection with jesus... n again, whatever the case, we are equally proud of our faith and our motherland... my being catholic in no way diminishes my indianness. it only strengthens it

@jess2897

9 жыл бұрын

summer solstice You don't get the point... your ancestors being converted or not is not the point here neither is you being a devout catholic. All I ask you to do is take a look at history and check the atrocities committed by the roman catholic church worldwide, and particularly in Goa which suffered the worst... check out the methods employed by the so called defenders of the faith... A person who refuses to see the truth is not worth my time... ... and all Christians are not Catholics, there are other denominations... just so you know...

@summersolstice4365

9 жыл бұрын

I think I have already made it very clear that we do know about the horrible stuffs committed by some loonies(sadly in the name of Catholicism) and that we look down on them. what do you expect me to do other than acknowledge these facts... I have never turned a blind eye and all your vehement assertions of me doing so make no sense. im sorry

@MegaBrijen

9 жыл бұрын

summer solstice That is all we want you to remain devoted to your faith,country and people.

@summersolstice4365

9 жыл бұрын

yes... I agree India is very very diverse... sometimes the extent of its diversity is beyond the grasp of even the normal indian person. India never ceases to amaze... fact is.. the word indian cannot be defined satisfactorily with respect to religion, race, language, dress, food etc... the easiest answer as someone rightly said is that anyone who calls himself/ herself an indian is an indian !

long live Goa, long live INDIA.

@invincible6411

4 жыл бұрын

long live my Goa...

@adriangaming4853

3 жыл бұрын

Long live India.

@walnut9472

3 жыл бұрын

@D KK Off your colonial hangover 😂😂😂

@LucasRodrigues-ef4un

3 жыл бұрын

Não

@apurvd6177

2 жыл бұрын

Long Live Our Goa, Long Live Mother India

I'm Goan/Indian and I have Goan blood, because My Parents are From Goa, But i'm Born and Raised in Mumbai, And Goa is a part of India, and Many people in Goa Know the Indian Language and Portuguese is less spoken, Konkani is the official language of Goa and has lots of Portuguese words and dialects in it, Right now (Agora mismo) I'm in Goa and the people are Good, we are also Good with ghanti's etc. Viva Goa!!!!!!!

@theartsyfartsyhookworm2210

8 жыл бұрын

+James Bhattoe hello my goan brother/sister .I have a question can you answer it please ?.The question is that do you look like india ?

@theartsyfartsyhookworm2210

8 жыл бұрын

+James Bhattoe by the way I'm a goan don't mistaken my for an indian ok!?!?!?

@metalmachine974

8 жыл бұрын

valleni The nightcore maker Your question was if I look like India, I didn't understand your question quite well

@theartsyfartsyhookworm2210

8 жыл бұрын

+James Bhattoe I mean do you like india ???

@metalmachine974

8 жыл бұрын

valleni The nightcore maker I think I understood your Question, If i'm looking like an Indian, Well, the first thing I can tell you is that i'm not Racist, and my Mom is from Portuguese Ancestry. So I have both Portuguese and Indian (Goan) Blood. But people say that I look like Greek

I'm from Goa. Long live my India

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

you´re from Goa invaded and occupied....for sure

@Alfablue227

4 жыл бұрын

What India??

@Panjim

4 жыл бұрын

@@Alfablue227 Democratic Republic of India.

@walkingswissknife264

4 жыл бұрын

@BVZ Leave the man in peace, you sh!thead. Unlike you, that gentleman doesn't suffer from a terrible case of identity crisis and inferiority complex.

@SK-fe2nd

4 жыл бұрын

@BVZ why don't you just shut up.... can't you look at yourself and see you are the same as people from the rest of the country....you can be dissatisfied with the current government but you sure as hell can't deny ancestory.....the original settlers of gia were the gowdas who were the same as tribals from anywhere else in India.....we look like people from the rest of the country....our language Konkani is spoken in Karnataka and many parts of Maharashtra has similar language.....our position right now is what it is because we are incompatible...... don't you feel tad bit ashamed of glorifying European colonialists who ruled for 400 years over your recorded history of 5000 years?And please speak for yourself.....and before you call me ghanti let me tell you I am goan by blood and birth my great-grandfather worked in the Portuguese railways and a true ponjekar......

if Portuguese want to express their sadness over goa... express it in konkani ...

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

You´re wrong...its the goans who want to express their sadness over Goa

@sunnyiet2011

5 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT then stop batting for the Portuguese. Stop being nostalgic about the colonial past of Portuguese. Stop hating people of color or people who resemble you. Stop being ashamed of your own color by glorifying the Europeans. Tell your supporters to not call India as a country of unjust people. India did not kill people for pleasure. India never colonised other countries and tortured their people. India did not invade a country and did anything in comparison to jalliawala bagh tragedy.

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@@sunnyiet2011 Goa was not a colony....India was not a country in 1498.... stop with your fake propaganda.... did you asked Goans what they wanted??...

@sunnyiet2011

5 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT you believe in whatever you please, sir, if it gives you joy.

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@@sunnyiet2011 International Court of Hage concluded in 1954: Goa was not a colony... The majority of goans never wanted to be part of Indian Union...thats the reality..deal with that!

Thank you for posting this film clip. It brought back very pleasant and nostalgic memories as I was in Goa during the exposition. Very proud to be a Goan.

That is a long time for Portugal not to have any influence in Goa. Portuguese rule in Goa endured for four and a half centuries. Goa was eventually granted the same civic privileges as Lisbon. Its senate or municipal chamber maintained direct communications with the King and paid a special representative to attend to its interests at court. In 1563 the governor proposed to make Goa the seat of a parliament representing all parts of the Portuguese east, but this was rejected by the King. The Portuguese rulers in Goa were either Viceroys or Govenors. Their original jurisdiction included the possessions of the Portuguese from Africa to Southeast Asia. The first viceroy to serve located himself in Kochi to the south on the Malabar coast; in 1510 this Portuguese seat of government was then established at Velha Goa. The Portuguese base at Goa worked to consolidate their control of the lucrative spice trade. Goods from all parts of the East were displayed in its bazaar, and separate streets were designated for the sale of different classes of goods: Bahrain pearls and coral, Chinese porcelain and silk, Portuguese velvet and piece-goods, and drugs and spices from the Malay Archipelago. In the 16th century Portuguese control of the waters off South Asia enabled them to tax the cargoes of its sea trade.

@nightrider12soul

Жыл бұрын

They have big trade with Macao.

@vishalsharma-je7re

7 ай бұрын

and killed thousands of people , destroyed 700+ temples of hindus and jews

I am from GOA...... LOVE GOA,, LONG LIVE INDIA ...........

@sanjaydash18

3 жыл бұрын

@D KK free Balochistan

@sanjaydash18

3 жыл бұрын

@D KK Free Balochistan

@fredericchopin4821

3 жыл бұрын

@D KK YES

@walnut9472

3 жыл бұрын

@@fredericchopin4821 ah butthurted 😂

@AuditoreDeFirenze

2 жыл бұрын

@@walnut9472 XD

Goa ke bhai, beheno ne bahut julum saha hai, us liye mai apni dill ki geherayise une salam karata hun, enqualab jindabad

@elbafurtado7422

3 жыл бұрын

Lol

@VaibhavMisale005

3 жыл бұрын

@@elbafurtado7422 Thanks Lol

@VaibhavMisale005

3 жыл бұрын

@@elbafurtado7422 tum Portugal ki aulad ho aisa majhe lagta hai

@NachiketBhat1818

2 жыл бұрын

@@elbafurtado7422 jab man kare, jab dil kare, portugal ke log wapis aana chaho, toh sena lekar aa jao, phir se laat maar ke khadede jaoge mast..😊

@spycowboi2190

2 жыл бұрын

Bro u r a shayar :)

Prof. Dr. Narana Coisoro. Politician, leader of a Portuguese main Political Party, Vice-President of the Portuguese National Assembly. A Goan Hindu and Still is proud of being Portuguese

@VedicRevival

7 ай бұрын

Lolz...UK is currently being headed by Rishi Sunak, an Indian. US has appointed Kamla Harris as a vice president and she is half Indian😂😂😂😂 exceptions are not count anywhere. Whar are you drunk on? Sacramental wine ? Oh I mean "blood of Jesus"? 😂😂😂😂😂

Goa was always prosperous in it's past history ! And we are proud of it ! It's only after it was liberated that it has become a mess as it is today ! This is clearly the inefficiency of the Indian government to preserve the identity of Goa ! By not giving it a special status since it was liberated much after the independence of the rest of India !

I am a proud local citizen of Daman and a proud indian too. My grandfather was a freedom fighter and a great local leader in 60's after liberation. The times have changed now. As we are trying to enhance the bilateral relationship with the U.K. then why can't India and Portugal not do the same? There are great differences in India related to the enforcement of the Common Civil Code, but in Daman this law is already in practise and people of all religions have excepted this law. - Rajanish Joshi

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

so you know very well...the large majority of people from Daman...never wanted to be part fo indian union

@avatarrlv7868

5 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT Fucktard, did you conduct some sort of referendum there ?

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@@avatarrlv7868 asshole...are you trying to compare 1560 with 1960??????? Indian Union said its a democracy and didnt asked what goans wanted?? You gotta be kidding...

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@match box Europe also has the same cultural identity and there are dozens of countries. India was a gepgraphical concept didnt had political unity. Indian Union is beamed by the british empire in India colapse and the hindu nationalism. You can repeat your indian fake propaganda for more 71 years..do not change the reality. I know very well what is your point of view the same point of view who annexed Sikkim..who tryed to annex Butan and even Sri Lanka....One day the fake nation( all the fake nations)will crush....just wait. Greetings

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@match box ermmmmm dude wake up. India was not a country!!!! political entity its not political unity!! Have you ever hear about european integration? i guess not..LOL its what we are doing here since the 60´s!!!!!!! Portugal is older than Spain we have a great relation with them now...so try again LOL you cannot nuke Portugal because you ´ll have all the west against you also OTAN and yoll be totaaly fucked up if you try it :) Of course you don+t know where Portugal is...i know you´re quite ignorant thats why you are here lying about India as a political unity :) fake nation will pay the right price....fake nations like spain (full of separatism and nationalism inside lol) Portugal since 1128

My granpa was 23 years old when this videos was shot .... probably still a student at that time at varca ...

I love goa. The quaint clean towns, the small chapels, the lively beaches and the mix of cultures

@joaodemenezes786

Жыл бұрын

The East Timorese felt differently with regard to Indonésia.

I would love to know my family history before the portuguese rule, all my grandparents were born in goa but all 4 of them left when quite young after they married to live in Africa, Kenya. From there a lot of my family members made passports to come to the Uk as Kenya was under british rule and others for portugal as we were goan. My grandparents didn't think it goa was a place to make any money and moved so they could follow work. Being a fishmonger was frowned upon but that seemed to be the only work available in goa..i wish I asked them more questions before they passed away. Our generation, we didn't marry goans, so my daughter is very mixed, she hasn't really grown up with the goan culture I did but she does know some konkani as I teach her. I do wonder what the goan culture is like in goa itself..a different world i guess. Is it easy to track your ancestor's and create a family tree there? That's something I would really like to do. Our family names are Fernandes, Rodrigues, Colaco, Braganza.

@skylight0656

2 жыл бұрын

Goa is Portuguese

@abhinavgokhale6917

2 жыл бұрын

@@skylight0656 it is indian

@fernandocastro2680

2 жыл бұрын

@@abhinavgokhale6917 Es de Portugal.

@abhinavgokhale6917

2 жыл бұрын

@@fernandocastro2680 Ur puny army consisting of coast guards got kicked out along with ur Padres who force converted people, take that shit and get out. Soon even the Christians who were forced will become Hindus again 🕉️🚩🚩🚩

@adeepmamlekar5225

Жыл бұрын

Im a Hindu goan and yes these lastnames still exist here in goa have you visited goa recently?

About 33% of East Timorese were killed during the Indonesian occupation.

@abbad707

4 жыл бұрын

oof

@abbad707

4 жыл бұрын

@@swarnadeepsen9123 sources?

@pritsingh9766

4 жыл бұрын

@@sabilly1471 this sen is a racebag convert. These Christians after converting don't even support their own country what can you expect?

@didd2810

3 жыл бұрын

@@pritsingh9766 stop!

@swarnadeepsen9123

3 жыл бұрын

@@pritsingh9766 we'll destroy your pagan Rama temple and the devilish JAMA mosque after securing power.

I am surprised the video did not claim that somehow Goa was part of Portugal landmass till it got separated by continental drift. :-)

@br3menPT

8 жыл бұрын

i understan you difficult to understand a pluri-continental and multiracial country like Portugal was in those times. Portugal was a country in Europe, Africa and Asia. Its different to invent a continental country in 1947....

@Leaf8823

5 жыл бұрын

br3menPT Portugal is in Europe u dumb fuck

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@@Leaf8823 hey asshole, Until 1975 Portugal was in Europe, Africa and Asia...

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@match box no...just a coupe d´etat and a communist revolution. They gave the independence of all portuguese oversea provinces to USSR movements ...now 50 years after they are in deep shit among the poorest countries in the world....pretty good wasn't it? lol

@anime-cu7sq

5 жыл бұрын

@match box portugal wasnt in ww2

Portuguese colonized parts of Sri Lanka too in 1505. They ruled Beaches of Sri lanka for more than 150 years so as a resut we too have people with surnames of Perera, Fernando, Rodrigo,De silva,De mel etc. But they are mostly Sinhalese Buddhist not Catholic except for a few of course.I must say Portuguese ruled/Treated us better than Dutch and English.We have a Race called Burger, they are the Descendant of Portuguese/Dutch/English Vs Sinhalese Marriages. But they are proud to be Sri lankans

@sanjayvaidya4925

3 жыл бұрын

Right. What about the xian LTTE?

@alangervasis

2 жыл бұрын

@@sanjayvaidya4925 No..LTTE are 100% Tamil Hindu militants.

O meu pai aparece antes d e chegar aos 3minutos e 59(?) e vê-se depois, durante quase 30 segundos (uniforme branco, a analisar um relogio...)...foi com prazer e sobretudo emoção que o vi, ainda antes de eu nascer!

@abhinaba__saha

Ай бұрын

omg, was he a Portuguese official posted in Goa??

When goa was a colony of the portugese I was there, at that time all the places were clean but now as goa is part of india all people from other states have come to goa and spoiled it . Shitting in public, peeing in public, opening unhygenic stores to eat food and lots of other things which have spoiled goa the portugese were peaceful unlike the British rule they built magnificent churches which are still standing up to this date portugese was widely spoken during the Portuguese time until now.... Goa is now spoiled ... I missed the old goa.. all the roads are spoiled nobody is bothered to fix them....

@ashutoshkumar1960

4 жыл бұрын

How about the people u killed in order to conquer it . Who will pay for that blood of 500 years?

@ashutoshkumar1960

4 жыл бұрын

Why didn't they make Temples? Most of the Goans r still Hindus.

@nawab-e-trivandrum5526

4 жыл бұрын

Bro...both british and Portuguese were better than India today....i wish British never left

@nawab-e-trivandrum5526

4 жыл бұрын

@BVZ Bengal famine was no man made...Amartya Sen said it was due to war time Inflation

@nawab-e-trivandrum5526

4 жыл бұрын

@BVZ they did try to stop it.....

Today thanks to people like the BJP CM it will be no less than the slums of Bombay thanks to the Shiva Sena

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

Just come to Mumbai and see how many Goans are here. I have never seen a mumbaikar aur Marathi person complain about it. Goans alway complain about immigration but given a chance, they would surrender their Indian password in a single breath. According to British estimate, there were 7.5 lakhs Goans in 1930s. 4 lakhs in Goa itself, 3 lakhs in British Indian cities like Mumbai Kolkata Chennai Karachi and Hyderabad..you see there were some 40-45% Goans in British India. I have never seen an Indian complaining about it...

@delvingeorge2807

2 ай бұрын

​@@VedicRevivalMaybe because you live in a Bubble?

@VedicRevival

2 ай бұрын

@@delvingeorge2807 or may be because you live among bigots?

Want to visit again soon :) Last time was in 2009 as a school trip. Enjoyed so much :)

Goa is different things to different people. Please respect each one's feelings. And each one's story.

“Never argue with a fool, onlookers may not be able to tell the difference.” ― Mark Twain

@DelhiMan-xb8nm

3 жыл бұрын

That is why India never argued with Portugal or vatican regarding Goa

@NachiketBhat1818

2 жыл бұрын

That's the reason india never argued again with portugal over goa claims, and marched it's army to goa to snatch goa from portugal and kick them out of our country.

@dylanfernandes1547

2 жыл бұрын

@@NachiketBhat1818 ghattya you'll hv no right to talk about goa ..u be in Karnataka

@NachiketBhat1818

2 жыл бұрын

@@dylanfernandes1547 ghattya hoga tera baap, and you be in portugal...

@Taqiyya-Slayer

2 жыл бұрын

Gao inquisition is well documented

"Rule of power" that what east has learnt from West...

@walnut9472

3 жыл бұрын

You're here too😂

@alangervasis

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah..Because the east never had that concept..Ignorance at it's peak.

i'm here just to pay my respect to goa as a unique nation with a proud and rich history, throughout centuries, some of them with portuguese influence which makes it even more special and noble. you goans are very welcome in cplp, the organization of all peoples of portuguese heritage. we in portugal gained also a lot of good things from our cultural conection with you. there is no more space for debating little things from our pasts that only serve to divide instead of bonding all of us... viva. saude! cumprimentos desde portugal.

@Rotebuehl1

9 жыл бұрын

***** Ridiculous nonsense! The Portuguese actualy created a dictionnary Konkani-Portuguese and vice-versa! And You should read all the reports written about Goa and it's inhabitants, reports who date back to the 16th century! Tomé Pires (ca. 1465 - ca. 1540) wrote the most marvellous descrptions about Goa and her people(s), only for starters! And after him so many others... The medical-surgical high school was created in 1842, a school who had equivalences to the best European and Eastern Universities! In 1900 a newspaper was founded, who was written in both Portuguese and Gujarati! You simply don't know what You are talking, i.e. writing about! Persecution of Indian Languages in Goa???? That's a BLUNT LIE, worthy of a disturbed mind like Your's seemingly is!

@sv8211

9 жыл бұрын

V4Goa How is portuguese different from Adil Shah? are they natives of Goa? lol.. u white sucker.. have some self respect

@goa4you25

9 жыл бұрын

***** Indians roasted alive millions of widows who were forced to jump on the funeral pyre of dead husbands. considering the mortality rate then , you can well imagine the extent of genocide of widows that continued for thousand years . it was Portuguese and later British who stopped this barbaric custom.

@Rotebuehl1

9 жыл бұрын

***** Of course You couldn't find "even a single trace of Portuguese influence on the Hindus and Muslims of the region" First, the smashing majority of all of them came to the territories AFTER the Indian Union's invasion! And before that, Hindus and Moslems locked, not to say, entrenched themselves! It's more than evident You're stubbornly insisting on what better suits Your preconceived opinion! Fair enough! Yet, had You kept Your eyes wide opened, You would at least have seen all the strong influence, starting with all those monuments left behind by the Portuguese! After the Indian Union's invasion the policy of New Delhi was to settle lots of Hindus in the territories! Nevertheless, the Portuguese didn't only "influence" Goa, Damão and Diu, they really made those places something totally new. And when some years ago the portuguese navy training ship "Sagres" passed Goa and the Indian Authorities denied the ship anchoring in the port of Goa (veeery strange, isn't it???), forcing the ship to stay in international waters, it were the Goans themselves, most of them of humble origin, who jumped into their boats and went to the "Sagres" training ship to greet the crew, with cheering, flowers, little presents, and banners with inscriptions like "this is Portuguese India", and "this is indian Portugal" and so on, and so forth! I understand You may either not know any of that, or dislike it. And if You do know all of that, but insist in denying, only because You don't want things to be like this or that, it doesn't mean that they don't exist! They are all true and REAL!

@Rotebuehl1

9 жыл бұрын

***** You are ridiculous! I'm not a Hindu Hater at all. But I do hate sophistry like the one You are using! It's more than obvious that You are trying to misuse history only to make ends meet within Your wacky brain! I didn't even lost time reading all Your verbiaged slipslop gibberish. Instead of spending time on KZread it would much more appropriated that You go find a doctor who may cure Your daft and goofy brain!

Goa came under the governance of the Delhi Sultanate. But, the kingdom's grip on the region was weak, and by 1370 they were forced to surrender it to Harihara I who held on to the territory until 1469, it was appropriated by thesultans of Gulbarga. Then the area fell to the hands of the Adil Shahis of Bijapur, who established as their auxiliary capital the city known under the Portuguese as Velha Goa.

@NaliniXS

Жыл бұрын

@Sohail khan Start learning English!

Goan were liitle wealty n was k during Portuguese but now after indian came n now in 2018 v goan r struggling coz of all outsider came in our goa

@ashutoshkumar1960

4 жыл бұрын

Why don't u get a DNA check.. I wanna know how much ur DNA is different than Maharastrian, Karnataka ppl..or Delhi ppl.. Also, Portuguese allowed Goans who wanted a part f Portugal to get back there..why u stayed..

@pritsingh9766

4 жыл бұрын

Yes very wealthy that they even decorated cows like in the video hahahahahaha how did you get very wealthy by selling your ammi to Portuguese or by taking ricebags?🤣🤣

@pritsingh9766

4 жыл бұрын

@BVZ Yeas Pakistani and Bangladeshis do have same DNA as our i accept it ,no north Indian or bangali ever deny that .Even sri lankans have same DNA as Tamils and other south Indians, who is denying?? Even many Pakistanis too accept this fact .Atleast they don't claim DNA with Portuguese who lived 7000 km away! 🤣

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

@@pritsingh9766 why Goa had better social-economic level than rest of indian subcontinent? lol

@Panjim

3 жыл бұрын

Shut up clown. I'm Goan. We are happy with Indians. We are Indians

Goa was the Capital of the STATE OF INDIA, a Portuguese State (with Viceroy and authonomy, formed by many cities and forts in all East Africa, Arabian Peninsula coasts, Persian Gulf, (Even one in the Iranian shores), Industan coasts, Half Sry-Lanka, Malacca and along the Indonesia, Timor, Mollucas, and the tradeposts permited and cedeed by China and Japan Emperors of Macau and Tanegashima. From the Cape Hope, Asia, to Oceania in early 16th century. One of the first of Tricontinental States.

@SanG-tc3gb

9 ай бұрын

Whole goa wasn't anytime under Portuguese. Only north goa ... and east part was under thr control.. they tried hard to establish over goa but failed every time.

INDIA Should have attached Goa in 1951 after three Years of Peaceful and Democratic Negotiations with Portugal for Unification of INDIA .

@br3menPT

2 жыл бұрын

No way..India should have wait until 1974...Now everybody know how fake was Neru pacifism lol

@br3menPT

2 жыл бұрын

@AP France is France Portugal is Portugal...By the way Goa was not a colony anymore long time ago....Thats the problem! India think everything is colonialism! India had no right on Goa! India only had rights on British India raj nothing more else! When India get int UN they accepted all the Portuguese territoires across the world. How can Portugal accept to give a part of his own territoire? Nonsense...

@uniqimagination

2 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT now Portuguese are weak

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

​@@br3menPTLolz....Goa will and Goa was always a part of India. What makes you think that a far away European country of no consequence has any authority on a territory that is on Indian subcontinent? Portugal wanted to establish Nato base there and hence nehru was forced to use armed forces. If it was illegal then why NATO never attacked India? Afterall, as per the rule, nato members are bound to retaliate if any of the NATO member is attacked. Portugal was and still is a NATO member. Us president kennedy had said "India did what any other country would have done"😂😂😂😂 rice bags are crying because their free rice supply has stopped 😂

@br3menPT

6 ай бұрын

Don´t lie...USA criticized and condemned the invasion of Goa.... 🤣 Portugal was a pluricontinental country......starting in 1128 in old Galecia and spread around the world...@@VedicRevival

Goa a very peaceful state and very simple people . The European Portuguese influence can still be felt in the state. The state was lucky to be in Portuguese hands than going to british like rest of india where poverty and famines were part of llife. Also they built first hospitals and all European systems.

@SanG-tc3gb

11 ай бұрын

Portuguese were more fanatic than British and ruthless too... they made so many atrocities on hindus ..

@amitdabas229

8 ай бұрын

Portugese stole orphan Hindu kids in Goa from their extended families to make them Christians, imagine stealing orphan kids.

@fernaodias2591

5 ай бұрын

​@@SanG-tc3gb...mentiroso

@fernaodias2591

5 ай бұрын

​@@amitdabas229..é muito feio mentir....

@titbits2304

3 ай бұрын

​@@fernaodias2591 Of course , converted people who worship their Portugese masters , don't like freedom . Still suffering from STOCKHOLM SYNDROME !

It's was a Colonialism and people of Goa were salve. Money and other stuff enjoyed by Portugals. Goa was a part of India since thousands of years. Occupied by Portugals 400-500 years ago.

@ryantheroman4331

7 жыл бұрын

Then again, the majority of Goans wanted to remain part of Portugal, especially compared to how poor the rest of India was, and is.

@anantzunjarrao5371

7 жыл бұрын

who say

@hpereira1089

7 жыл бұрын

Im Mangalorean and I say, FUCK THEM !! My descendants were Goan's because of the immigration towards Mangalore. TO HELL WITH THE PORTUGUESE !! You want it back so bad Portugal ? COME AND GET IT !! Proud Indian here !

@dansavage1217

7 жыл бұрын

Shailesh Janwani well said my brother thank you

@br3menPT

7 жыл бұрын

India exist as a country since 1947 LOL theres no India during the 450years of portuguese presence. Goa was not a colony even the INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY SAID THAT...why do you need to lie?!?!?!?

as a Portuguese, I still love Goa and it+s people, we were not the best or the worst of people and we lived there for hundreds of years, so do not attack so violently a part of your history, yours, not only mine. Peace

@ThunderIndian

8 жыл бұрын

+abel borja Hmmmm when we attacked Portugal we killed only some of yours 30 guards it was peaceful war...

@br3menPT

8 жыл бұрын

it was not a war..because Indian Union invaded without war declaration.

@br3menPT

8 жыл бұрын

Morroco is another 3rd world country like India...

@ThunderIndian

8 жыл бұрын

***** you ass is 3rd world

@br3menPT

8 жыл бұрын

Thunder Indian just like your brain :)

Oh Goa was such a prosperous place. Even the cow was dressed well.

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

@Johan Smid in Goa they were now holy for sure lol

@sayantanbasu06

4 жыл бұрын

Indeed.

@granny2677

4 жыл бұрын

@Johan Smid Just like how in Murcia dogs have better rights than women? Guess yeah.

@1313tennisman

4 жыл бұрын

@@granny2677 but in america youre not lynched if you kill a dog but cow mobs in india are a real ting

@samyak9592

4 жыл бұрын

@@1313tennisman In India students don't shoot up the schools when they are bullied by their peers or teachers.

Our ancestors moved from Goa when Portuguese arrived today I can only understand 10% of Goan Konkani due to Portuguese influence. ( And influence in our language too)

@porothashawarma2339

3 жыл бұрын

Are you from Karnataka ?

@Rohankumar_deoghar

3 жыл бұрын

Those days....no demonic polythene bags.People brought clothen or jute bags or simply wrapped the bought items n took to home.That's why so much cleanliness n no needless heaps of garbage.

@Turplemaple6318

6 ай бұрын

@@Sangita_hotty ok but no.

Спасиз за красивре видео про Гоа и за перевод на русский язык автору я казахстанка и очень люблю гоа ❤.мы туристы

Not only in GOA also in Mangalore, Bassein which is now Vasai (mumbai), Diu & Daman was invaded by the portuguese hence the names For Eg: fernandes, Pereira, D'souza, rodrigues etc etc to name a few which are portuguese names, Brazialian culture is very much similar to Goan culture except the fact that they speak portuguese & goans speak konkani..

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

indians asked portuguese help against the muslims....read some books

@leaveme3559

5 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT isn't exactly the reason why they invaded they wanted the land

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

@guruprasad YM no..hindus asked portuguese help...hindus were under muslim control..not the portuguese

@notcool2594

4 жыл бұрын

Vinayak Bhat Bassein isn’t Mumbai. It is Bom Bahia.

@pritsingh9766

4 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT Even Portugal and spain was under muslim turk control. LoL you don't know your own history hahaha

Sad to see so much hatred being expressed in the comments section.

@mr.profundis3804

4 жыл бұрын

Mostly made by neo colonialists of Portugal.

@alangervasis

3 жыл бұрын

@@mr.profundis3804 Wrong! Mostly made by far right hindutwa bigots.

@saieellokre1408

3 жыл бұрын

@@alangervasis 💩🇵🇹🖕

@alangervasis

3 жыл бұрын

@@saieellokre1408 ha ha must be shiva linga

@saieellokre1408

3 жыл бұрын

@@alangervasis hahaha Jesus is a dead body which u people worship

Viva as Goeses e Portuguese! We love the Portuguese and we love Goa. Doesn't matter what anyone thinks, my Lusophone irmaos - one day we will unite together again. We are one in blood and spirit! Uma grande abracao para um amigo Goes :)

@shttykr

3 жыл бұрын

lol..in ur dreams bitch !!

@apurvd6177

3 жыл бұрын

Speak Goan, I dare you😂😂

@kangaroo4847

3 жыл бұрын

LOL 😂 Portugal uniting with Goa hahaha India is stronger than little Portugal and it will be forever 😂

@kangaroo4847

3 жыл бұрын

@@legionario1989 I don’t speak Portuguese, but I assume you’re saying United in Curaçao?

@kangaroo4847

3 жыл бұрын

@@legionario1989 oh ok that makes sense

How long did Portuguese rule Goa? 450 years The Portuguese rule in Goa lasted for as long as 450 years. The history of the Portuguese in Goa was similar to the British in India. It is interesting to know that while the Portuguese ruled Goa, their country itself was ruled by Spain from the late 16th century for a period of 60 years.

@br3menPT

2 жыл бұрын

You´re wrong...Portugal was no ruled by Spain during Iberian union..thats why the spanish was not able to get in Goa during iberian union 1580-1640

The performing cow still made an appearance at raves in goa 20 years ago.

My opinion it was better Goa under Portguese . There would have more developments like in Europe.

@SanG-tc3gb

10 ай бұрын

Portuguese looted goa... converted original tribal hindu people by violence and destroyed goa culture . They were wild and rude...it is foolish to say they would have done developement.. they have come here to loot the resources..

I will look into it. I have some books to read and this topic is of some interest to me. Thanks.

Long live indian empire

@samir6102002

5 жыл бұрын

Not goan we r portugal

@mattroules6691

5 жыл бұрын

It's only india India empire yet to come

@mattroules6691

5 жыл бұрын

@@samir6102002 Go there

@pritsingh9766

4 жыл бұрын

@@samir6102002 You are a part of Indian empire now you ricebag convert .Ask your Portuguese baap to take it back if they can 🤣 or else keep crying in KZread here

@dorothybuggins5795

3 жыл бұрын

@@mattroules6691 Stop bickering! Goa was, is and always wil be the SOUl of a Goan!

In comments section I'm shocked to see how fluent are Portuguese in English... daal me kuch kala hai?

GOA IS NOT INDIAN

@zoroastrianisticzoro297

7 жыл бұрын

INDIA has RUINED Goa, it was so beautiful and clean its like all the other disgusting cesspits now, Goa brings most of Indians tourism revenue, most Goans have left for Britain, Brazil etc. they wanted independence they didnt want to be indian and do not consider themselves Indian, and rightly so

@zoroastrianisticzoro297

7 жыл бұрын

"happy to be part of India" in that case you aint no Goan, probably some Mumbaiker trying to force Indian RSS text book philosophy onto Goa.

@br3menPT

5 жыл бұрын

those "goans" are immigrants from other parts of India...they arrived after the invasion in 1961

@saieellokre1408

3 жыл бұрын

@@zoroastrianisticzoro297 🇵🇹🖕💩🇵🇹

@171_indranildutta6

7 ай бұрын

Lol where is zororastrian in Iran goen under Islamic occupation perhaps if India wouldn't have existed zororastrians would have been non existent

Well said Mr Suryakant......

Looks like a nice propaganda video made by the Portuguese government in 1953.

@vijaygovind128

8 жыл бұрын

+ML8593wy well.. Good for you.. I am not going to waste my 20 minutes by watching this .. whoever made it.. It is clearly a propaganda video... Did you even know that Portugal (Salazar) was prepared to burn Goa to ashes before giving up..Only the sagacity of the Vasalo e Silva prevented that from happening. Silva was exiled for his defiance..

@vijaygovind128

8 жыл бұрын

Dude.. You can check those facts or believe whatever you choose to believe. In any case I am not very bothered about either Salazar or Silva.The fact is that Goa is an integral part of India. It has been so and it will be so forever. Peace out. :-)

@MARKCRASTO

8 жыл бұрын

As a goan...i can tell u that salazar DID order the destruction of all civil infrastucture wen defeat was imminent. But goas governor general refused to follow that order..he believed thatt the beauty of portugals 450yr prsence must not be destroyed . Had he followed Salazars order...goa would look very different today

@br3menPT

8 жыл бұрын

"It has been so and it will be so forever."? Forever' Goans don+t wanted to be part of Indian Union...and in the future they will be finally FREE

@ashutoshkumar1960

6 жыл бұрын

br3menPT how exactly...u will only whine....but hw will u make it...now its fully assimilated in india...whether u guys r minority.....its just a thought to feel good...haha

Looking at comments below it feels like the Goa is suffering from an identity crisis!

@pritsingh9766

4 жыл бұрын

Most of them are RBC Ricebag converts

@sudinshirodkar3991

4 жыл бұрын

@@pritsingh9766 correct

@Ida-xe8pg

4 жыл бұрын

Bruh ever heard of a place called "Kerala" it was kinda under portuguese occupation too (ok only Calicut, Cochin and Quilon but there was a significant presence of the Portuguese in Kerala they cheated on our king, WARS bla bla bla then the Dutch came... then the British... then Indians came... and well here we are)

@adriangaming4853

3 жыл бұрын

@BVZ Ah dude you bunch of new generation eurocentric Christians tend to portray yourselves as the representatives of Goans.

@someshdevkar5387

3 жыл бұрын

@CIA: Central Intelligence Agency there has never been a separatist movement in goa... get your facts right first

I hope they make a video on Portuguese inquisition in Goa. From what I have heard many Goans speak of it was a very ruthless oppression of indigenous goan people worst than the British Empire tainted with mass conversions and other attrocities.

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

Portugal had Inquisition too...Portuguese people suffered with that too....whats new?????

@godfather911mafia

4 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT the difference is that Hinduism still survived in Goa but the original Celtic Lusitanian religion went to extinction in Portugal.

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

@@godfather911mafia the territoire where is Portugal in nowadays already had several religions

@godfather911mafia

4 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT just because Portuguese people had to suffer an inquisition does not mean that the rest of the world has to suffer one. Your argument is completely illogical and Invalid

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

@@godfather911mafia Its not the rest of the world....it was only the Portuguese territoire.....cant you understand that??

President Kennedy told the Indian ambassador to the US, "You spend the last fifteen years preaching morality to us, and then you go ahead and act the way any normal country would behave… People are saying, the preacher has been caught coming out of the brothel."

@adriangaming4853

3 жыл бұрын

The same Kennedy helped India in 62 ignoring Portugal.

@alanalmeida7887

3 жыл бұрын

@@adriangaming4853 You know nothing, America voted in favour of Portugal whereas it was the Soviet Union that was in favour of India

@adriangaming4853

3 жыл бұрын

@@alanalmeida7887 When you're so much arrogant that you don't even care to read the comment properly. Kennedy for sure wasn't very happy with India and it was USSR who supported India. But in 1962, during the last days of the Sino Indian War, Kennedy was making plans to help India against China ignorant the rants of Portugal just 10 months ago.

@Grogueman

8 ай бұрын

You don't preach sermon to animals and expect them to understand it.

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

​@@alanalmeida7887yes... kennedy said India did what any other normal country would do ! This was normal...why would anyone tolerate foreign presence on their land? Slaves are never equals. Having Portuguese names and surnames won't make you an European. Stop making a fool out of yourself. I can't claim the part of glory of great english inventions by assuming the English name and converting to anglicanism...it's pure madness 😂😂

Viva as Goeses :) Eu sao Goes e eu sao orguilhos ! God bless Goa and Portugal.

@dorothybuggins5795

3 жыл бұрын

BE KIND MY FELLOW COUNTRYMAN - LET US SHARE OUR BLESSINGS WITH THE WORLD - GOD GAVE US GOA, THE BEST PART OF THIS EARTH

@rohanchodankar3742

2 жыл бұрын

Long Live Goa .... Death to Portugal

@AuditoreDeFirenze

2 жыл бұрын

peace homie

I remember so well the "human chain" of women carrying the ore from the mine face to load it on trucks to take to the barges. My father's mines in Bicholim were subsequently mechanised - much more humane? But it put those poor women out of earning the pittance they received. Whichever way you look at it, a no win sitution. One further point, why so much hate - for the Portuguese... for the Indians ... who can blame anyone for wanting to be the rulers of one of the most fabulous places on God's earth?? Suffice to say it BELONGS to us Goans!

@miguelpimentel5623

3 жыл бұрын

Goa sould be an independent state, Portugal would rather grant independence to Goa then to deliver it to the Indian Union, thats why peacefull negotiations were never made.

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

​@@miguelpimentel5623Lolz...😂😂😂 Portugal made Goa a province because they were fearing military action from India. NATO provide protection to provinces of member states and not to their colonies 😂😂😂 does it look like that Portugal had any intention to grant independent to Goa? Show me some data/evidence to support your claim. You are clearly having a gala time writing fantasies 😂😂

Finally, a true insight of Portuguese Goa that was not tainted with Nehru propaganda.

Alright - thanks for your comment. God Bless!

Goa is one of my favourite places.

Viva Goa e Portugal para sempre! Pre-61 Goa was the best.

@alanalmeida7887

3 жыл бұрын

Sim, meus avós dizem a mesma coisa.

@dorothybuggins5795

3 жыл бұрын

@@alanalmeida7887 Eu tambem! Viva nossa linda Goa!

@dorothybuggins5795

3 жыл бұрын

@UCJKeZHriGGcorMZ9FNtnCzw Yes, also in British India and England but Goa is now only a happy but never forgotten menory

@VedicRevival

7 ай бұрын

How many rice bags your family had received when converted?😂

@Teskooano

6 ай бұрын

@@VedicRevivalThis is an old comment of mine. Goa (India) and Portugal should work together for peaceful relations and love between our cultures and people. Many mistakes were made in the past, the future should be one of friendship and progress together ❤️

S.R. Seeley former Professor at the University of Cambridge. “ The name ‘INDIA‘ he says should not be classified with France or England which indicate nations but rather as the word Europe designating a group of nations which acquired by chance a common name for having been a common land physically separated from the rest of the continent.

@apurvd6177

2 жыл бұрын

What Bullshit are you talking about? The name India comes from Indus Valley civilization in the 3rd century AD when hoards traveling from central Asia referred to the people of the lands as Indus instead of Sindus (or Hindus by 9th century) The nation was united under Ashoka from ancient times till the 13th century and again united under Akbar, Marathas and the British.

@SlaveOfDevas

8 ай бұрын

​@@apurvd6177When you only learn fake nationalist stories

good & thoughtful video 😃

I love the voiceover :)

Why should we leave Goa , be It India or any other country we will always have a special bond with Portugal which is within us . And you think your so great try to match the cleanliness and law and order of Goa during Portuguese rule and now . We aren't proud of anything we just don't like uneducated people trying to teach us what to do. [And I don't need to prove my love for my (secular) country.]

@tirikamtel

5 жыл бұрын

@@missiongamer4494 Goan people help poor india by sending billion of crores to indian coffers.

@tirikamtel

5 жыл бұрын

@Does It Matter Beggars we send billions in remittances to India.

@BenjaminRosh

5 ай бұрын

​@@tirikamtelYou ain't sending portugese r*pe product

@BenjaminRosh

5 ай бұрын

What are you waffling mf? Goa is Indian land. Your little portugal can fck off

Goa was the most important city in India, this bothered the Indian government und Elite indian. It was all because of politics and money, not because of religion or goans. Today there are more deaths in Goa due to hunger and abandonment of the Indian government than in the past inquisition of the Portuguese.

@mattroules6691

5 жыл бұрын

You are an ignorant fool

@mr.profundis3804

4 жыл бұрын

Goa was a shithole. We made it beautiful.

@rajputchauhanwarrior2637

2 жыл бұрын

Goa was so poor when it was under Portuguese rule .now goa is one of the richest and beautiful state

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

Can you back up your claims with some data and provide me some links? In 1930, as estimated by British, there were around 7.5 lakhs Goans. 4 lakhs were in Goa, 3.5 lakhs in British Indian cities like Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai and karachi. Rest 50k were scattered all over the globe...no other community except Jews are this scattered for livelihood. The only difference is - Jews didn't have their homeland at that time unlike Goans! Why? Because there were no jobs in Goa. Portuguese had made on capital investment in Goa. There were few schools of primary education in Portuguese medium. Rest were mainly konkani language schools for secondary education started by Goan themselves. The Portuguese government never established any general degree college in Goa even after 450+ years of rule. There was one medical College and one priest training seminary (rachol). Why are you proud of being a slave? 😂😂😂 Interesting seriously. I have never seen this before. 14 colonies of USA were in British control and they still fought for their independence !! Most of them were British themselves. Australia and Canada are contemplating removing British monarchy as head of states. Despite the fact that those countries were majorly populated by Brits themselves...and here you are, an ethnic konkani person whose ancestors were forcefully converted at gunpoint, whining for the country which is so far away from, which is not part of your DNA, Which subjugated your people from centuries 😂😂😂😂 Viva Portugal 😂😂 Lolz

Indian army took Goa in two days -- so much for the "martial" race of Portuguese.

@synthtastic74

3 жыл бұрын

India was ruled by foreigners for 1000 years.

Long live Goa n Real Goans ,excluding migrant indians !

Nobody can deny that Goa is part of India but don't get me wrong, that doesn't mean we will let anyone from rest of India destroy our identity. Our state is small and should be for Goans ONLY. What Goa needs is a special status because of our past, a status which was promised to us but never given.

@nightrider12soul

Жыл бұрын

Sadly many Goans sold there houses to rich traders from Bombay,Delhi,Bengalore etc.They destroy lovely Portuguese haciendas to restore them in vulgar guest houses. I love those old haciendas with nice stairs that lead to the terase.The nicest houses I saw in Goa.

@ajakajak4423

Жыл бұрын

@@nightrider12soul p

@madhavagrawal756

9 ай бұрын

If you feel, your state should only be for Goans than the Goans too need to be stopped from going to different states

@nightrider12soul

8 ай бұрын

@@xyzrrana7851 I still Prefere a Goa and Macao.

@nightrider12soul

8 ай бұрын

@@madhavagrawal756 They all go to Bhandra Bombay mostly. Everything change,we change but I am fond of Goa when was pristine. But I understand that mass tourism bring some money to some area,and too some area only the big corporates Are winners,and in some not. In north in places like Anjuna the locals had it good with old style travellers as they rented local houses per year and the locals benefited.

Was Goa a land mass that got drifted away from Portugal during the turbulent Biblical times ? ? 5:55 11:55

@br3menPT

3 жыл бұрын

Portugal was the only pluricontinental country in this world...Read about it...

@mr.profundis3804

3 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT Nobody care about salazar's colonialist bullshit.

@brucewayne4128

3 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT Dude you're not even Goan. You're some portuguese incel. Stop talking about shit you have no idea about.

@br3menPT

3 жыл бұрын

@@mr.profundis3804 Wake up...Portugal already was a pluricontinental country centuries before Salazar born

@br3menPT

3 жыл бұрын

@@brucewayne4128 Learn how to deal with different point of view....

i agree with u totally

There are many things in the video narration that are BS when subject to scrutiny:1. The narrator claims that exporting Manganese ore is profitable. That is the stupidest thing to do and is the recipe to remain underdeveloped. At least they should have developed competency in refining pure Manganese or to Ferro-Manganese.2. . The narrator claims that importing without customs duty results in heavy volume of business which furnishes Goa with a comfortable revenue. (4:14). I don't see how spending money to buy foreign goods increases Goa's revenue unless they sell in black market (refered to as 'devious route' to India)3. The narrator pulled this from his netherlands: "Most Goan families are content to remain Portuguese citizens". He didn't cite any source. He followed this with a bunch of derisive remarks on India's poverty. 4. "Goa has strong religious ties to Portugal". I don't think even the converted Christians would claim to have 'strong' religious ties to Portugal. Religion is simply religion.5. The interviewer is already claiming that the feeling of colonialism is absent. What he means is that people weren't already violently revolting. Then the narrator explains that Portugal treats Goa like a province, its own unlike Britain which treated India like a leased property. Since the Portuguese are benevolent in promoting native Goans to high offices in their government in Goa, the locals should be grateful to them. The narrator sounds like an American presstitute who is rented for furthering Portuguese propaganda on Goa.

@arghakoley8560

3 жыл бұрын

This video is a full Portuguese propaganda. Dislike it

goa is a nice place and we love it, sea beach is aawwwesome

Foi com emoção que vi meu pai na inspecçao dos relogios! Aparece aos 3m.59 e vê-se durante quase 30 segundos (porto de Murmugão?) Foi antes antes de eu nascer!...

Thankyou mario..for such lovely upload..!!

Nice video. Should have put a couple of slides on Inquisition too.

@gaurvlogs9394

3 жыл бұрын

Specially "haat katro khaam"

@rishuyadav4410

3 жыл бұрын

Why would they? They are proud of that Shamefully.

@br3menPT

2 жыл бұрын

Whats the relation between Inquisition and 20th century? lol....

@monsterhunt8624

2 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT Christianity is the relation. Same rabid ideology of heathen hatred that led to Inquisition is still continuing unchanged, condemning rest of humanity to hell.

@br3menPT

2 жыл бұрын

@@monsterhunt8624 lol.....Nobody was punished by Inquisition in Goa since 1777....Portugal had Inquisition too...Inquisition was not created to punished people from Indian subcontinent under portuguese rule. Get your facts right

The comments of some Portuguese users here don't express the overall opinion on the colonial Portuguese rule. European imperialism and colonialism were both terrible, we are not proud of it. That doesn't mean we are not proud of the good things that were left behind, but colonialism was a virus and we are glad it changed. Long life to Goa and the Goan people. I hope I can visit Goa one day.

@NaliniXS

3 жыл бұрын

I'm' not proud of either, of ANY form of imperialism, but now Goa is being DOMINATED, colonised and destroyed by the so-called "liberators". After my last visit, in 2015, I think I will ever return no Goa! ''The pollution in Goa’s air is almost visible to the naked eye, especially when driving over the Mandovi bridge into Panjim. It’s almost as though the state capital is covered in a faint haze. Only as one gets closer does he realize that it’s pollution and not mist Illegal mining in Goa is one of the biggest environmental disasters in Goa. Mining has caused irreversible damage to forests, agriculture, fisheries and water aquifers. An estimated 100,000 people living in the villages in four talukas in north and south Goa have lost their source of living with their farms destroyed by mining silt and water sources contaminate...'' The Destruction Of Our Environment - A Goan Perspective” - Christopher Pereira

@lucefece

3 жыл бұрын

@@NaliniXS Had no idea things were that bad... But the liberators might not be the same people that allowed this to happen, Nehru is dead for a long time...

@NaliniXS

3 жыл бұрын

@@lucefece TRUE. Now capitalism is running wild!

@alanalmeida7887

3 жыл бұрын

@@NaliniXS A guy once said "He who has seen Goa need not see Lisbon". Things have changed indeed.

@SlaveOfDevas

8 ай бұрын

​@@NaliniXSKeep your commie conspiracy theory to yourself. Every country while industrializing faced the same problems

People talking about all the horrors by Portuguese but they don’t see that even in USA there were such horrors but it got better over time whereas in India 73 years after independence we still have the caste system, reservations based on caste and law and order is at its worst. Development seems to never happen and ministers just keep looting the unsuspecting people

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

Do you even know how India used to be in 1947? We barely had money to survive for few weeks! We are the fifth largest economy right now and on our way to become third. India as a democracy is still in its childhood. USA is a 250+ year old democracy. Read the history of USA. They have seen horrible racism, civil war and riots before they became this "the great power USA - the envy of the world" the rome wasn't built in a day my friend. You are comparing orange or an apple

Yeap..!! Truth can be funny some times. Some times bitter. But I'm glad I made you laugh. Have a good day to you Sir..!!!

How many people were converted into Christianity by giving money they built all those cathedrals with Indian money What happened to the culture before Portuguese arrived

Goa was almost an unique-inedit autonomous State at the time (in world History) much more authonomous Super Tri-Continental State than in Portuguese 20th century times. Heritage-History, bad or good, is also important - is knowledge, memory and general culture. It was State of India, very autonomous within the Portuguese empire - in the 16th and 17th centurys included possessions in all the Asian Sub-continents, East Africa and the Pacific. It will be hard for Goa or for any state repeat something like that again.

Lot of "citizens" of Goa were roasted in bonfires during the Inquisition that lasted till 1850.

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

FALSE..Inquisition in Goa lasted until 1812, and nobody were roasted in bonfire since 1774

Thank you!

@ Gautam Have been told by my parents that even the poor would eat food in ceramic plates("Boshi" in konkani if your not a goan) and that they would never starve!.

@alanalmeida7887

3 жыл бұрын

exactly

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

Then why Goan colonies were everywhere in British India...from Mumbai to Karachi. From Hyderabad to Chennai and Kolkata... Lolz 😂😂😂 Portuguese never made capital investment in Goa. There were no jobs. There are so many Goan colonies here in Mumbai. From Santa Cruz to Bandra to Mahim! You guys are everywhere in Mumbai! This is British India I am taking about. Can you site one British Indian that was living in Goa to eat from that ceramic plate?😂

@dark.wanderer

6 ай бұрын

@@VedicRevival I know that people around India have been coming to Goa and stealing identities of people of Goa to get Portuguese passports.. Why talk about Portuguese or British times.. India is free and so is Goa, well.. after 14 years from Indian freedom though... People in India are migrating to other countries even after 75 years of Indian freedom... Wonder Why?.. No jobs? Or they don't have a plate to eat in India?.. 😂😂

Today unfortunately I see a lot of catholics in Goa saying that it was better off under the Portuguese.. these people were born in the 80s and 90s and never lived under the Portuguese rule and have been radicalized by the political priests in their sunday churches. They think "We are Catholic and so were the portuguese, so our loyalty should lie with them and not India". These are ignorant and misinformed people who are not aware that ethnic Goan christians also wanted the Portuguese to leave and wanted to join India. There were many Goan Catholic freedom fighters. Tristão de Bragança Cunha was one of them. Why were they against Portugal and for India in spite of being Catholics? The reason is, along with being religious bigots, the Portuguese were also racists. The Goan catholics were never treated as equals to the Europeans. They were denied high posts in the church because of their dark skinned. In fact the Pinto revolt of the 1700s happened because of this. Goan christian priests were denied the post of archbishop and it went to a European instead. Hence they revolted. If you were under the Portuguese regime, you would be treated as inferior because of your ethnicity.

@adriangaming4853

3 жыл бұрын

Absolutely right. Are you a Catholic or what ?

@aaronleperspicace1704

3 жыл бұрын

@@adriangaming4853 nope but I have lived in goa all my life and as such have a close contact with many goan catholics and know how they think. The fact that theyre fans of the portuguese is stupid. Even St xavier who is called the patron of goa and venerated by hindus and catholics doesnt deserve the worship because he is the one who ordered Goa Inquisition where many Goans were killed (this also included Goan catholics who were suspected of still practicing Hinduism). Indians always worship their oppressors for some reason. If it was America, his statue would have been pulled down the way christopher columbus's statue was destroyed.

@alanalmeida7887

3 жыл бұрын

What blasphemy! Read about St. Joseph Vaz. He was a Goan Catholic and his parents if I'm wrong were hindus, he was canonized as a saint a few years back.

@alanalmeida7887

3 жыл бұрын

@@aaronleperspicace1704 coming to the inquisition. You must look at history in the perspective of those time especially when religion was kept at the apex priority. Wars are a taboo now, but back then there were frequent wars between various dynasts be it the mughal or Vijaynagar empire.

@aaronleperspicace1704

3 жыл бұрын

@@alanalmeida7887 It's blasphemy to condemn the violent religious bigotry and persecution now? Unbelievable man. Anyway I have some respect for you because you did not abuse me and are trying to debate in a civil manner so i'll do the same. No doubt religion was important back then but this cannot justify what the European aggressors , particularly those from Spain and Portugal did and inflicted upon others in the name of religion. Try and understand, native people of North and south america and Africa and India were tortured for the sake of the church. The native people of the Caribbean islands almost went extinct because of it. This is unacceptable even for the era that they were in. This is why earlier in 2020 they attacked a Columbus statue.. what else will we justify?? African slave trade? Saying that it was an important part of their economy to sell slaves?? Funny part is if someone would behave the same way with the Spanish or the Portuguese now, these same countries would call them terrorists. Anyway it is the past now; most (not all) christians are peaceful and non controversial

"all races work together as a team" I couldn't have said it better myself!

That last one church where is from?

@rsharpforever9472

5 күн бұрын

The last one church shown is The Church Of Our Lady Of The Rosary in Old Goa commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:The_church_of_lady_of_Rosary_in_Old_Goa.jpg

Are you the same person who writes articles on Niz goenkar, Mr Franco?

Looks like there are lots of jealous trolls around here.........

To all so called portuguese goans, can u tell me the name of your great great grandfathers? I must be Kashinath, Vithoba or even Vinay, hahahahahahahaha. Christanity was introduced 300 yrs ago by portuguese plz note this down.

@boneysharaon

9 жыл бұрын

You are right brother. The ancestors of present Christians in Goa were Gaudos, Kunbis, Kamats, Dessais etc. No one denies it. If you go to Cuncolim(Kunkulli), you will find that the Christians still maintain their ancestor's Kshatriya traditions. The Sontreo or Umbrella festival is an example.

@maheshm5463

5 жыл бұрын

vinay gawade Goa was ruled by Kannada Hindu empires of Kadambas and Chalukyas and Rastrakootas and Vijayanagara Empire for a total period of more than 600 years

@TheJoseph0123456789

5 жыл бұрын

So what ? Do you know what religion your ancestors from 5000 years back followed. Why is it that what religion your ancestors followed from 500 years ago matter more than 5000 years ago.? How do you draw the line.? And FYI. Even Jesus was not born Christian. So there's nothing wrong with changing your faith. Ppl change. And let them.

@Casinodemedici

5 жыл бұрын

They forcefully change religion on There controlled land. So don't be proud of so called thing

@TheJoseph0123456789

5 жыл бұрын

@@Casinodemedici : Most if not all the conversions were people escaping the tyrannical caste oppression in the Hindu religion. You shouldn't be proud of that too. :)

Jayaprakash Narayan “ We were never a nation in the modern sense of the term till the experience of the British rule “.

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

Nation state itself is a new phenomena. China of today was constituted only in 1949, India in 1947, turkey in 1919 and even Portugal in 1810 ! But they are ancient civilizations. The story of the nation state can be new but not the story of nationalism

Goa today is a disaster .. I wish Portuguese still ruled it ..

@br3menPT

3 жыл бұрын

@@ankykkr7904 Goa has amazing culture...how dare you to say they fucked all their culture???

Viva my goan brother, Viva Goa e Portugal para sempre!

@tubemaster2676

3 жыл бұрын

Goa was and is a part of India.

@dorothybuggins5795

3 жыл бұрын

HEY - SOME INDIANS ARE ALSO VERY OK, I FEEL SURE YOU AGREE

@tubemaster2676

3 жыл бұрын

@@dorothybuggins5795 , in what sense. All Indians are ok according to me.

@dorothybuggins5795

3 жыл бұрын

@@tubemaster2676 Good and bad everywhere. No disagreement.

@tubemaster2676

3 жыл бұрын

@@dorothybuggins5795 , portugues who ruled Goa , for rude and wild. The barbaric rule ended.

It is wrong to say that Nehru was in the know of Operation Vijay in Goa in December of 1961. Nehru had given a word to UN and Western Powers that no military force will be used in Goa to avoid avoid blood-shad as Portuguese Dictator Antonio Oliveira Salazar was ready to convert Goa to Stone-Age if India used Military Force. Salazar who was member of NATO tried to hand over the Portuguese overseas territory to hand over to US to have NATO bases in Goa, Daman & Diu. As India moved it's Militry in the Indian territory of Goa. Even the Tank Unit from Punjab was moved to Belgaum. To this Salazar requested NATO force to move its fleet to Goan waters. America moved it's 7th Fleet from Rock of Gibralter. USSR who were averse to NATO to be in Indian Ocean. The KGB who had infiltrated the Indian IB & MI alerted the Defence Minister Krishna Menon. Nehru who was against Military Action was not informed. On 17th December, 1961 Menon approached the Supreme Commandant of Defence forces, the President of India and placed all Intelligence Reports before him and asked to issue Orders to Defence Forces to move in. Air strikes began at 5.30 am when Powerful Radio Transmiter of Emisora de Goa was bombed and two bridges of Banastari and Ponda. Then by 12 noon War Ship Afonso de Albuquerque was bombed. At 8 am of 18th December, Nehru as usual was was hosting Morning Breakfast to Western Ambassadors at PM house Teen Murti. Krishna Menon who was staying just accross the street at 1-Kushak Road had walked in uninvited. The US Ambasador turned to Nehru and said," but Prime Minister you assured the UN and Security Council that you will never use force in Goa, and Nehru replied, no we will never use force. Ambasador said that your Forces have entered Goa". Nehru turned and looked at Menon in anger. Menon who was equally taller then Nehru told him the President who is the Supreme Commandant has issued the Orders last night and he was not disturbed as he was in sleep. Haa, Haa, Haa.

@prit0012

2 жыл бұрын

Well done Krishna Menon. The days of slavery nd white supremacy is gone. NATO is worthless as we can see in this current Russian Ukraine war lmao. NATO is a puppet of US UK nothing else. Nd poor countries lyk Portugal Turkey Poland r just vassal states of US ready to be sacrificed when need comes lol

I am from Assonora l used to work in srigoa mines for a few escodex

"Colonialism has been the cause of so much trouble in this part of the world" says a Brit.

goa would have been a developed place if the portuguese still had it now, and this is coming from a Hindu

@Alfablue227

4 жыл бұрын

Absolutely agree. A shame... Miss, Goa so much.

@ronpaulsonshow3389

4 жыл бұрын

Goa is the most developed part of India, a large part thanks to the Portuguese. This statement just doesn't hold any truth. Using economics to argue against imperialism is a slippery slope, and oftentimes can be used to justify imperialism just as much as it can be used to denounce it. Goa is a prime example of this. Goa is in fact one of the richest provinces in all of India, and that's mainly due to Portuguese presence in there. Another example: was colonialism justified in Algeria by the French? Economic investment was large-scale, and the economy in many ways advanced in a way it wouldn't if France was not present. Of course the answer is that it was not justified, but the reasons for which is that the French had bereaved the population of Algeria of self rule. The fact that neither the Portuguese nor the Indians wanted to grant Goa the question of self rule is the real crime.

@adriangaming4853

3 жыл бұрын

Search for Goa Inquisition. Portuguese colonialists were worse than the British. It was only in the very late years that they liberalized.

@alanalmeida7887

3 жыл бұрын

@@adriangaming4853 yes no one denies inquisition. But even portugal had an inquisition in the past. Talking about conversions, various practices were banned in goa like Sati in the 16th century by Afonso de Albuquerque. Even hindus mourned at his funeral. And you are wrong about the portuguese, portuguese never saw goa as a colony but as their own territory.

@tubemaster2676

3 жыл бұрын

Are you a fool ? Portugal just looted. Our land and ended our rich heritage. They made us slaves and beggers.

Thank you so much for this video. Hope this enlightens Goans all over the world and evokes the true Goan in them.

@apurvd6177

3 жыл бұрын

You mean the barberic inquisition that was shamelessly imposed on us? No thanks

@VedicRevival

7 ай бұрын

What do you mean by "true Goan"? 😂😂 there are suburbs in Mumbai like Bandra and Mahim where Goan Catholics outnumber Marathi/Gujarati/Any other Indian😂😂😂 no one has said anything about "uncontrollable migration"

Rabindranath Tagore - “India is constituted of various nations enclosed in a geographical receptacle”. Reference - Nationalism.

@adriangaming4853

3 жыл бұрын

India is ONE.

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

It can be said about USA too..and many other nations of South America. China is also not homogeneous. They are still proud nations. Nothing wrong in diversity.

Splendor of 400 years ago in ruins because people may not care and happy to see it go.

@br3menPT

4 жыл бұрын

World Heritage from UNESCO...

@VedicRevival

6 ай бұрын

Yes...imagine the spendor or thousands of years that was destroyed by the Portuguese! Basilica of bom Jesus and Se cathedral are still standing today but original temples of Mangeshi and Devi mahalsya were destroyed Enough said about the difference between Indian and Portuguese

@Funnyedits1312

6 ай бұрын

For some, the wonders of the past doesn’t matter only religion does

Portuguese shd have fought no!! They r always welcome ...but this time it will not be like last time...

@Trials_By_Errors

3 жыл бұрын

Don't Even had Chance and no Right.

8 years later, Portuguese were given royal kick out of Goa, India (after they were thrashed and surrendered)

@br3menPT

3 жыл бұрын

and now Goa looks like a shithole...

@DelhiMan-xb8nm

3 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT but Goa still looks better than portugal and vatican

@br3menPT

3 жыл бұрын

@@DelhiMan-xb8nm yeah sure....LOL.....

@mukundarora5138

2 жыл бұрын

@@br3menPT shithole bro have u even gone there do u have enough Portuguese money to make a flight to India let alone the beautiful exotic ,secure, and secluded places of the nation.

@br3menPT

2 жыл бұрын

@@mukundarora5138 Portugal high income economy India low income economy...do you have money enough to pay internet???? Im impressed!

Texas is now separating from the USA. GOA should follow suit. They have a Signature campaign. The USA has to give in to their just demand. Can we Goans do it ?

@rico6609

3 жыл бұрын

This comment didn’t age well😂😂

Thanks Nandan, That's the spirit. Indians fucking cannot divide us Hindus and Catholics in Goa. After all we catholics were once hindus and converted by force. We are one let not religion come in the way when it comes to Goans interest. Drive away the jharkadis biharis odisis, gujjus, malabari, marwaris, what have you. And if the people from nearby Maharashtra and karntaka konkanni speaking who were once Goans are welcome back

@sumukhshankarhegde2853

7 ай бұрын

Agreed firstly convert all churches to karnataka Konkani speaking temples once how it was and then we can speak