Owned manual cars for many years and no longer keen on driving them in traffic. On the open road they can be nice but in town they're a pain. In any case this car has a huge amount of torque low down the rev range so one can execute ferocious overtakes without even changing gears. I'd take the tiptronic without hesitation.

The tiptronic because the wife drives us home from the pub.

@jezhopo7221

4 жыл бұрын

I'll use that excuse but also because I prefer auto...

@kynzie14

3 жыл бұрын

Truer words have NEVER been spoken

@guillevizconde1489

2 жыл бұрын

Good man!

@SignalCorps1

4 ай бұрын

Nice, but the Trip S equipped 997s are still one hell of a great ride.

@VraelFreorhe

3 ай бұрын

Underrated comment

I sold 997 new at a dealer many years ago and HATED Tip gear boxes - except in the Turbo, that engines works really very well with that box. 👍

@inspir3d81

2 жыл бұрын

What’s wrong with the tiptronic on base 997?

@9jfd1

2 жыл бұрын

What's there to hate? I owned a 2011 panamera 4 for 3 years with first gen dual clutch pdk and now own an 03 996 tip cabrio now for 3 years aswell. As a matter of fact the time lag to change gears is the same, can't notice the difference. As a daily driver tip is great and bullet proof!

@JoJoJoker

7 ай бұрын

Apparently PDK without Sports Chrono is fairly similar to Tiptronic.

A very beautiful and capable car regardless of the gearbox.

Got the tiptronic in my one. Its faultless and a joy to use. Great video and you make some very accurate points about ownership. An honest video for anybody thinking about taking the leap.

The Tiptronic S is an upgrade to the original Tiptronic, with the ability to adapt to driver's behaviour, and also allows driver to change gears without entering manual mode. In manual mode, if there is no driver input for a period of eight seconds, the system reverts to automatic mode.

The best looking 911 turbo. Wheels are perfect 😍

@JelloTypeR

4 жыл бұрын

troy anguin 2nd favorite wheel design behind BMW 359 from the E36 CSL / E92 competition pack.

@razrramon2256

4 жыл бұрын

Used to love em but they’ve aged to my eyes if I ever I’d have bbs like on 997 gts models

The Porsche Tiptronic transmission is actually a Mercedes Benz 722.6 5 speed auto trans that was used a lot in their high HP high torque models like the E55 AMG and the McLaren SLR. This unit was known for being light weight and capable of handling 1000 HP/TQ. It was used in a lot of Chrysler products where it was known as the NAG1. When the Eurporean motor press was shocked that 997 Turbo was faster 0-100 kph with the Tiptronic than withe manual. That was something that wasn't much of surprise to us in America where drag racing is the most popular form of motorsports. An auto especially a well built one with a higher stall torque converter will always always beat a manual every time. This especially true for a turbocharged engine where there is never an interruption of boost or power during shifts as you would experience this with a manual trans no matter how fast or skilled the driver is.

I am lucky enough to own a 997 turbo tip and SLK 55 AMG both 06 reg and I think the same gearbox. Both are a joy to drive, and for once someone has stuck up for the gearbox. Well Done Jay for a great review, and congrats on reaching a 100k milestone.

I have an 08 Turbo with a Ruf turbo conversion and an EVO chip. For a daily driver I hate the on and off the clutch in traffic and appreciate the way the car shifts with the Tiptronic S. Drive it like a maniac or sit back, turn up the tunes and cruise. This car is wicked fast especially in Sport mode.

One thing that nobody talks about with the five speed tip Tronic is you don't have to worry about doing a clutch job that could cost you 6+ thousand dollars to do

@jimsteinway695

Жыл бұрын

Dude I don’t know where you get your car worked on but a manual 997 GT3 clutch is $3000.

@marksmejkal4267

10 ай бұрын

This is true until the torque converter packs up!

100K!! You did it! Huge Congratulations James! Looking forward to the content that'll take you past 200K!

just traded the 997 manual C4S for the 997 turbo with the tiptronic. Spent a good bit more for the peace of mind of the Mezger in the turbo. there is an extra 100 horsepower in this trade-up. So far, the extra horsepower is nice and the tiptronic does not bother me but there's no doubt that I'll miss the visceral driving experience of the manual on a windy mountain road. agree with this guys take

I had a 997.1 Turbo tiptronic, I thought it suited the car perfectly. The tip allows you to focus on driving instead of shifting, which is nice when you're going 100+ mph

Just spent THREE DAYS at one of the biggest Porsche rally's in the USA - 150+ Porsches. There was a HEAVILY modified 997.1 Turbo with Tip. That car kept up with 991 GT3 RS's - even in the corners. I'm not exaggerating. Completely changed my mind about the Tip. As for me personally, I followed a 997.1 Turbo Tip Cab through the mountains one day...for about an hour...that car was just as fast as me in the corners and MUCH faster on the straights. I will never talk down the Tip again. Is the PDK better? Sure. But the Tip is great in a Turbo

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

Thank you for the comment. It’s great to see actual experience rather than speculation reviews 👌🏻

@robertwalters3955

3 жыл бұрын

Same here, Not only that a few C2S tips are always at the front of that pack too.

@SignalCorps1

4 ай бұрын

Yea, I have to say the 997.1 Turbo Tip is still a hell of a car. The Tip goes better with the Turbo than non-Turbos because it permits the turbos to stay spun up compared to dropping off some with a 6MT

5-speed auto 'box and turbo torque. Imagine how much of an effortless cruiser a 997.1 Turbo can be.

The tip box is like anything in life when it's different, doesn't conform with convention , it meets opposition. The tip box is actually very good and matches the car perfectly. I daily drive my car and fits in with my lifestyle. I have changed my steering wheel, that's my only complaint about the tip, the button placement . Steering wheel upgrade , problem gone for me. On the track you can just leave it , it kicks down well if you punch the accelerator and let it shift up in auto . Long live the tip box

@paulomagalhaes9405

4 жыл бұрын

Stephen owen - Agree . Btw what kind of steering wheel you used to replace de original ?... Anything with shift paddles ?...

I have a 2008 997 911 turbo tiptronic. With my bolt on mods and tune I’m pushing a little over 520hp to the wheels. I can’t imagine trying to control all that power on a road car all while shifting with a clutch. I can just mash my gas pedal and in a blink of an eye I’m at 120 mph with my heart racing and a smile on my face. I’ll keep my tip tronic

@fdation

3 жыл бұрын

Does it have the shifters on the wheel?The only tip I've owned was an is300 and they were on the steering wheel which was nice.

@p____p4tel

9 ай бұрын

100% agree.

Full disclosure: James drive my 997 Turbo manual last year and it's the review that is on the channel. I've had a tiptronic Turbo and sold it because while it gave immense performance and was incredibly fast in all situations, it simply wasn't that enjoyable after having a 997.1 C2S. It lasted less than a year and I went and picked up the 997 Turbo manual which is much more involved as a driver's car. But the truth is that the Turbo is probably way too fast for UK roads and the C2S is possibly the pick of the 997s... As for people asking about reliability, the only issues I've had in 6 years have been with the AC condensers rotting out, and it's cost under £2,000 to maintain in that time.

@radeon08

2 жыл бұрын

Did you get a 997.2? or 997.1. I'm torn between at 997.1 (2007) or a 997.2. I love PDK but I so prefer the look of the .1 and sound. the .1 in question has had a full engine rebuild and it already has the stronger IMS. I haven't driven a manual in over 5 years so I'm worried about stalling and being an all round worse driver haha!

@jimsteinway695

Жыл бұрын

I had a 997.2 PDK and tracked it. Before that a 997.1 GT3. I could easily outpace 997.1 GT3s at the track. The PDK is a game changer. I drove manuals all my life and I’ll be damned if I’m going to drive the slower (manual) car

@PNoblesGarage

Жыл бұрын

Most accurate comment by miles. Unless you’re a woman or just want to pose, it’s manual all the way, don’t be a gay

@aulzhoefer

9 ай бұрын

@@PNoblesGarageso clever

My 2009 Turbo is also a Tip with ceramics. My 2012 is a PDK with Center lock wheels but not ceramic brakes. I like the TIp and the Ceramics best. The Tip shifts like the older muscle cars I grew up with, and I love the ceramics mainly because the wheels stay clean. I also think that the weight saving and marginally better braking is detectable for me. I would have also loved a manual, but that just was not an option for me at the time. These cars are so fast, I think I prefer to have both hands on the wheel when I play hard.

@stevebennett282

3 жыл бұрын

Totally agree with you!👍

I'm going to go ahead and congratulate you on 100K subs...well deserved!!!

I own a 996tt with tip . I live in Vancouver . Honestly when driving my Ferrari ( gated manual ) I rarely ever get into third gear unless on a bridge . Same with my tt . Personally the 15% less I paid for the car seems great value since shifting is almost nonexistent for me unless from first to second. Too each their own but I don’t regret the tiptronic purchase at all and after two plus years , I’m loving it . Also the lack of shifting allows my right hand to do other things while driving women around ;)

Congrats on 100k man, love your vids.

didn't know you would be driving my dream car too soon . i would still go for a manual though but the auto isn't bad at all

The Turbo has Tiptronic S, it was the first Porsche with auto that was advertised as quicker than the manual to 60.

@tiamofj842

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah..IIRC..3.7secs Vs 3.9 in favour of the Tip.

@HarshaJayasekera

3 жыл бұрын

@@tiamofj842 Wrong. The official stats for the Tip was 3.4 secs to 60

@tiamofj842

3 жыл бұрын

@@HarshaJayasekera My bad. Thanks mate. Dang..it's even quicker then!

@tony_5156

3 жыл бұрын

The PDK is far superior

@8359s

3 жыл бұрын

@@tiamofj842 This 3.7 is probably to 100km/h, but I remember the values that you provided were on Porsche site in 2006!

I have 997,1 Turbo with tiptronic, I also have a manual 996 Turbo and a 355 F1. if I had to choose one it would still be the tiptronic! Lets face it, even if we all think that we are Michael Schumacher and Rossi 99% of us are not! 997 might be getting old but its still a very fast car and no way I am driving that without both hands on the wheel! Bet that 99% can't get the full performance out of a manual 997 turbo! The 355 I always use the paddles, never in full auto! Different cars fit different driving styles. And don't forget, when new the tiptronic is the more expensive and the Turbo is a sports/cruiser not a track car! If you want the manual so bad than you should also want rear wheel drive? That means a GT3! 997 Turbo is best with Metsger and Tiptronic! My opinion!

That car is stunning. No omne has ever let me drive their turbo but from talmking to lots of Turbo owners most of them with Tip boxes they all seem to think the gearbox suits the car really well.

The internet is never the correct place to find the reality about cars. RR are unreliable, Ferraris burn down and the tiptronic boxes are the worst thing in the world. I think it suits very good to the 996-997 Turbo engines, especially on the road. Most people who buy them use them as a daily driver anyway. With a relatively small amount of money you can also upgrade the software which makes the gearbox more responsive. I am wondering if the average driver-owner of one of these can shift faster than what the time the tip needs if you select it yourself through those buttons. All these cars are amazing and have their own character and soul. In my book a true petrolhead is someone who can appreciate what a machine like this can offer and not the one that just goes for the V10 noise/sound-powerrrr-manual trifecta and 'shames' everyone else's choices. I always frown when people bitch about the wooshing sound of the Turbo - Porsche is more about go than show and personally i think it sounds awesome! Thanks for the video

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

Thank you for your comment. It’s very well explained and obvious I’d agree 👍🏻

@paulomagalhaes9405

4 жыл бұрын

... I have a similar tiptronic S in my 996 C4s and I have to say that it in combination with the engine in a power to weight 5kg/hp ratio , makes an amazing overall package ... Plus , that ratio is considered within the limit of the " Big Supercars Champions League " .... Anyway more than enough for me !... 👌👍

@xdboterham

4 жыл бұрын

I appreciate your comment. Then again I would be that person to go for the v10 manual combo xD

@paddybeadle9090

4 жыл бұрын

For me the argument about being able to shift more quickly is not really the point. I know that I can't, without any question, but the 997.2 GT3 RS shifter in my 996 Carrera is so enjoyable to use and I think I'd miss that experience. I want to move to a Turbo next and a 997 is a realistic proposition. The ~£10k difference between manual and tip is incredibly tempting... would I regret it though? "Not terrible" is hardly a glowing endorsement from someone that will have driven many 911's in many flavours. 1st world problems eh! :)

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

Patrick Beadle is suggest you drive both tip and manual turbos. You can’t compare a tip from any other variant as the turbo works very differently with this box due to its ferocious speed and only really having to use 2nd and 3rd gear so unsure where the manual box would actually help or be any better? In a Carrera where you’re constantly going up and down it’s understandable. Happy to take you out 👍🏻

Jay, you're so close to 100k subs!! KEEP IT UP! I've been watching your channel when you got around 20k subs. Wish I'm at your position, mate.

Hi Jay, you made laugh out loud, as if i wrote your script. In 2008 i was at palmer sport and came away bitterly disapointed at the 996 tip, as soon as you mentioned Palmer i knew where you were going with those silver slow shifting 996's.... did not stop me getting a 991 manual though... keep up the great posts. Scott

I have a 986 Tiptronic and I love it!!!! I hate changing gears ⚙️

For higher hp-numbers (750+) the tiptronic is the better way to go, as it can handle much more power than the manual transmission.

@ruben9967

3 жыл бұрын

The other way arround, the manual is stronger

@mTwMarco

3 жыл бұрын

@@ruben9967 what do you mean? stronger?

@harryssecretpowder4330

3 жыл бұрын

@@ruben9967 manual becomes unsteady at that high point. Honestly tiptronic isn’t probably better performance wise at that hp but the manual I probably more fun

@ruben9967

3 жыл бұрын

@@mTwMarco yes

I haven't tuned in for a week now as I'm now fully back at work after this COVID thing. So please accept my belated congratulations for breaking 100K subs. Nice one and well deserved.

@JayEmmOnCars

4 жыл бұрын

Welcome back, and thankyou

The manual car does 75mph in 2nd and 110mph in 3rd so while you're driving it hard on the road the only gear changes you'll ever do are 2nd to 3rd (and strictly even that shouldn't be necessary, particular since it's got more than enough torque to stay in 3rd 99% of the time anyway!) and back to 2nd. Great, that's really exciting, maybe one gear change every now and then! It's really just not worth worrying about. I'm afraid it's all just willy waving.

@latuba2478

3 жыл бұрын

No, it’s about price this time. These mannies don’t come cheap

@sherparoyale

5 ай бұрын

True. Almost anything in the US runs between 2nd and 3rd gear (110mph) so my tip is sick. Tho a manual feels way more visceral… le sigh… I wanted to save $10k.

Also massive congrats on 100k look forward to seeing your play button 👍

Been watching 996 and 997 turbo's for sale over the last couple of years and the tiptronic accounts for at least 75% of the cars for sale, I believe it was a lot more popular than the manual. due to how well it works with the massive torque of the turbo.

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

Bang on. There’s a lot of people who comment without knowledge. The tip isn’t as great in base models but in the turbo in my eyes it’s a perfect inbetween from Manual and leg ache. It changes quicker than a manual and if you wish to gun it, sport mode + 2nd and 3rd gear is all you need. The fun doesn’t last long if your right foot it flat so I tend to 1/2 or 3/4 throttle it most of the time.

"General bimbling duties", love the description of average driving 😂

I have a first gen Cayman S tiptronic. It’s not bad at all. Shifts in manual mode are nice and fast. But now I kind of wish that I got the manual, just for more driving joy. Also cool to learn more about the background of this gearbox. I guess if Mercedes was using it in turbocharged V12s then it must be pretty solid.

Congrats on 100k Subs!!

I had a 996 turbo stick and now have a 997.1 turbo with Tiptronic and love it.

Having 5 long gears and turbo torque sounds fantastic

@danielsonscott3038

3 жыл бұрын

I installed a Tubi catback in my 997.1 Turbo and it did improve sound and hp, it's worth every penny

My SLK AMG was the same, big torque rich 5.4l engine and an ok gearbox. You could be arguing with it requiring a downshift. But because of the flexibility of the engine it meant you didn’t need to change as much and so masked the 70% performance of the gearbox

It’s becoming quite amusing how any time I have a question about a car, it’s already been answered by this channel

100k subscribers looking likely by the weekend. Congrats in advance 👍🏻

I've got a 986S with a tiptronic and I reckon it's great for an auto. I do a bit of city driving as well as open road and it is very easy to live with. It's good fun when you do the double tap on the gas pedal to tell it you want to play.

@dsrrecordsent

11 ай бұрын

986S 99” 2.5 love the vehicle it has enough torque down low and rev’s high with great shifting in auto or manual and also has enough power to weight with the perfect balance for phenomenal and handling! It’s a BLAST of a vehicle to drive in all conditions that’s also a fantastic convertible very diverse and best of ALL worlds! 🏁💨💨💨💨🥳👍

Great gearboxes and superbly reliable.

Ive the tiptronic 997.1 turbo i can say i like it even more than pdk :) that thing can hold huge amount of torque and power without any modifications into it

@HansBrodiAutomotive

4 жыл бұрын

I also like the tip for the smoothness around town and in traffic. PDK grind a bit at low speeds

@JoJoJoker

3 жыл бұрын

PDK has “character” - Tip is probably better objectively.

From a tuners perspective, its easier to upgrade with a tiptronic than manual... since the manual clutch must be replaced when upping the horsepower. Also, once upgraded.. the torque is incredibly strong and flat from 2000-6000rpm .. there is little to little gear shifting needed when doing spirited driving on the road or a typical 1-2 mile track. With the Tip, basically only uses 2nd and 3rd gear .. 4th and up are for saving gas.. and nobody knows why there is a 1st gear??

@cw4744

4 жыл бұрын

I've got a .1 tt manual and you've missed the mark considerably. It's fine if you need to justify the Tip but make no bones about it the manual is by far the better option. If one is doing substantial power upgrades as I've done, replacing the clutch with a more substantial single mass fly unit is really not a big deal and truly transforms the car. Driving twisty roads and short courses requires all manner of shifting prowess, heel toe and rowing of the gear box - remember the car is geared for 200mph but it's not by any means geared "tall" especially on 1-2-3 positions

@KrustyKlown

5 ай бұрын

@@cw4744 I'd rather have the manual .. but it is easier and cheaper to up the power with the Tiptronic, since for moderate HP increases (

Congrats on your 100K subscribers! 👍

Well done Jay. The sky’s the limit now!

Interesting, I've heard others say the Tiptronic actually suits the character of the Turbo a bit. Never driven one myself.

@midasman1768

3 жыл бұрын

Bought one today with the Tip, lets hope I like it.

@MartynStanleyAuthor

3 жыл бұрын

@@midasman1768 let us know how you get on!

@tomburns890

9 ай бұрын

@@midasman1768I had a 996 turbo with stick and now a 997.1 turbo with Tiptronic and love it!

The tip gearbox is great for the base Carrera as well. I don't get why people don't like it

I drove a 996 Tip at Bedford Autodrome - had a paddle sift conversion and simply refused to downshift It was the only car I spun on the day - and I drove there in my own Porsche!

@sutherlacd27

3 жыл бұрын

The 996 tiptronic wasn't as good as the 997

Been driving a manual for a while now, honestly would prefer a semi automatic for 'all out attack' seems like it's quicker shifting and can focus on steering better

@Lancelotxxx

Жыл бұрын

pdk is what you need need !

I was looking for a manuel 997.1 turbo becouse the " internet" said it was better and i thought i would like it more than the tiptronic. I desided to testdrive the tiptronic too, just in case and i can tell you i prevered it over the manuel! Me personal, i think in this type of car with all its power the tiptronic is a better choise... For me it's nice to drive it relaxed in town in auto, instead of poking arround in the gears. But if you deside to race it put it in manuel and use the tiptronic to shift faster than manuel, its not a PDK but its not bad either... My advise to you if your interested in buying one, dont believe the hype and try them both!! Anyway you cant go wrong with both of them, its an absolute beast!! Its a very underestimated car with the last Mezger engine, prices will go up!

I've been seriously looking into one of these as a daily driver and you post this Jay... 😁

@davekennedy6315

4 жыл бұрын

DO IT! They're a lovely car, go like stink, sound incredible and handle great. The perfect package!

@whomstd

4 жыл бұрын

What’s the reliability/service costs like? Have been looking at these too recently

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

Ant D budget around £2,000 a year for general maintenance.

@HansBrodiAutomotive

4 жыл бұрын

@@whomstd two big ticket things: Spun cam shaft sleeve, water fittings problem. Other than that very solid and affordable car.

@trihardcx6743

4 жыл бұрын

@@davekennedy6315 Sound incredible? The 911 Turbo S does most things incredibly well, but they don't sound good stock.

Another great vid

I have a 2001 986 with tiptronic and sure it would be better with a manual. Reason being I'm old and used to manuals but in auto it doesn't let you choose that wonderful sound. I have a BMW 530i and that is suited to it and wouldn't change. I do use the manual side of the tiptronic a lot for said reason.

I’ve got a 2.7 987 tiptronic because I couldn’t afford a manual and you still get the handling if not the acceleration. I’ve had a manual 986 2.7 and a manual 987 3.2s in the past and I’d put the tiptronic in the middle of the three. Auto not because I can’t be bothered changing manually but because when you get stuck in traffic jams especially on motorways it’s just so much easier.

@stevebennett282

3 жыл бұрын

Wow.. matching my three Box experience as well.. and totally agree with your assessment!! I still have the both 986 2.7 Tip, and a 987 ‘06 S manual.. having a hard time letting go of the former.. they are a very different driving experience.. but both fun to drive! Tiptronic is a learned experience.. I did not understand how to drive it properly until I track trained in it.. huge difference now when I drive it.. I think most people don’t understand how to use them to their advantage.. and added enjoyment!👍😎👍

I owned 993 Tip S back in 1996 and yes it wasn’t ultra responsive but it was 90% perfect for every thing else. Also had 997.1 with Tip S in 2006 and that was much much better. Then bought the wife a Boxster in 2013with PDK and that was and still is stunning. Tip doesn’t work well on track but PDK is fantastic... also ignore everyone that says you have to have optional paddle shift as opposed to buttons on wheel... I had both and preferred the ability to use you thumb palm to flick gear on both side of steering wheel. Hardly ever used the stalk based flippers on my Cayenne.

@stevebennett282

3 жыл бұрын

Agree on the paddle shifts.. and have seen some horrible mods on adding longer paddles onto the front of the button shifters.. really bad idea.. and scary for track!😳👍

Most of the time, with sports cars or sporty cars, I’d prefer a manual for that extra element of connectedness to the vehicle and driving experience; however, I know what you mean and have felt the same way about other cars including the Audi B5 S4 and the Mk7 Golf R. The auto gearbox (whether true auto or DSG) can be the better way to go. For the B5 S4, with its softer suspension, the car would porpoise during gear changes while the tiptronic would not - the latter being more controlled and having a more seamless stream of power, too. Not to mention, the less than ideal shifter feel of that manual Audi gearbox. The same gearbox issue is present with the VWs, but I’d say even more so, the reason for choosing the DSG in the R, is the fact that the DSG seems to be a better pairing to the R’s motor characteristics - if that makes sense.

This video brings some very good points. I own a 996.2 GT3 Clubsport in Tokyo - and have many Porsche mates. While I'm a manual person myself, I think the tiptronic is a very solid unit. Many of us here in the Japanese Porsche community do respect the 997.1 LHD Tip as the "best buy" - no PDK issues that could cost a fortune (starting with the 997.2), the last mezger, and vastly cheaper than a manual. And significantly more power than the 996. Of course one can argue that the 996 turbo tiptronic is the best buy - 15% less than the 997, and a significantly more edgier design. But if you don't like the design of the 996, or it's slightly blunter handling, and the HP deficit - the 997.1 Turbo is a tremendously appealing car, for those who want to really put on the miles, without the constant worries. It may be different in London - but here the 997.1 Turbo Tip, is the under-the-radar car that can be used for daily errands, can be driven by the wife, and can go for the 320kph blast down the Wangan, chasing the GTRs, and GT3s. All without any tuning, that could put significant stress on the bodyframe.

Yay Jay 100k!

Used the gearbox in the xkr till 2002. Good gearbox went in the slr McLaren because of the torque.

I had one a 2009 in black my only gripes were the seats felt too narrow and the button gearchange interface was annoying though a 997 paddle conversion would have been cool

I always find it strange that a " cheap 911" is often the convertible with the auto box. As a driver who isn't about to attack the ring or book a track day,yet am attracted by the pull of the Porsche badge,the spec above would actually attract me to it.

@johnz6877

Жыл бұрын

You find it strange that most people don't share your preferences?

@JoJoJoker

7 ай бұрын

Auto cabs cost more new so it’s objectively odd they’re considered cheap…

PDK/DCT! Dual-clutch > One-clutch > Torque Converter

Jay, I'm still feeling betrayed that your ultimate dream car is a Ferrari over a Porsche...but, great video and congrats on your subs!

@tiamofj842

4 жыл бұрын

Had a few Porsches. Then a Ferrari. Back to a Porsche and still dreaming of a Ferrari! Glutton for punishment my SWMBO says...!

My mate had a 991 Gen 2 turbo with a DMS tune and over 750bhp. It's silly quick but given the choice for a spirited drive I'd still take my R8.

“Give me the manual, or give me death.” Best line ever. Should put that on a t-shirt and sell it

@trackdays7625

4 жыл бұрын

It would definitely sell 👍

@johnnyboy1586

3 жыл бұрын

I was a manual man but after loosing my right leg above the knee I am afraid a auto with left foot excelerator adaption is the only option now 😥

Tip suits this car better. Not a high rev motor, and it’s quiet, so no need to wind it out. 1st and 2nd gear come and go way too soon in a manual turbo, and you really need both hands on the wheel if you modify one of these. That’s just my experience and opinion.

The Turbo isn't a driver's car anyway. For a very fast GT car, of that time, i think that gearbox makes perfect sense tbh. IF i were interested in a Turbo, and could save a shit ton of money by chosing a Tiptronic, i'd go for one with no hesitation.

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

Brilliant comment, thank you 👌🏻

Finally someone hasn't posted a negative video about the tiptronic box 👏 I honestly don't think 10k on top just for a manual box is worth that extra more. 10k is a hell of a lot of money for someone like myself who is actually considering the tiptronic over the manual. All the other videos people post, they think everyone is rolling in cash 🤦‍♂️ like everyone is a millionaire 😂 they need to come down from their pedestals...idiots

Guess how many times i have had that mental conversation. Still waiting for a manual

Same case as the hate the automatic mkiv supra gets from people. It’s not any less potent but it makes the milk runs/ school runs more bearable. Cog swapping is great and all but I have come to re-love autos/tiptronics

There’s a reason why Manual Porsches are rare beasts, when you’re really going at it changing gear can take away from the visceral experience at high speeds. I love the PDK in my panamera turbo but I’m looking for 997 gen1 turbo tip, for weekends and tuning and wouldn’t ever consider a manual.

A manual 997 cab is such a dream car for me, I’d love a C2S as a semi sensible daily, but a turbo would definitely be fun to try out even if I am a RWD guy

@benjaminhodgson4155

4 жыл бұрын

They may be AWD but they drive in a very RWD manner

@marcwilliams4014

4 жыл бұрын

@Chritopher O'Grady shouldn't take long to save for one. Cabs go for about £9.99 because they're awful. And you would be lucky to get the top down 1 day a year in uk. Put it down go up the road pull over 5 mins later put it back up because its raining again. Lol

This 911 special series is super cool

I definitely prefer a manual but if it was a daily I'd consider the Tiptronic 👍

As someone who is extremely price conscious, I'd always feel cheated paying extra for a manual.

@stevefowler2112

4 жыл бұрын

Until you sell it then you get the backend of the tip discount, which is over $10K

@autobahnproven

4 жыл бұрын

@@stevefowler2112 Or you could put the £10k you saved into Bitcoin or another great crypto then sell it next year to pay off your house/buy a new 992.2.

@danielmarshall4587

4 жыл бұрын

I aways like a manual...... HOWEVER, the price difference will buy a whole lot of fuel.

@mattevans4377

4 жыл бұрын

@@danielmarshall4587 Or another car ;)

@stevefowler2112

4 жыл бұрын

@@autobahnproven Or you could walk away with enough to by a nice Schwinn bicycle, crypto stocks are known for their wild swings.

I believe that auto is faster than manual of the line. Had 996 turbo with manual, hills sucked- getting fast of the line sucked too! I'm really thinking about 997 turbo auto, it's cheaper and it can hold 800hp n/p.

100k - you could fill (the old) Wembley! Congratulations.

Not terrible.. that is high praise 👏

Awesome

Looking at purchasing a 997.1 tip s and will be modifying it... Gt2 hybrid turbos, proper suspension, intercooling, water/meth, etc. What is the tip s box capable of handling?

The only good thing about the tiptronic box is that it makes the first generation PDK feel space-age [tonque-in-cheek]

'generally' the ones that bag the Tip are the ones who have never driven one. The Tips are great and despite manual purists talking about the slower speed of shifting when compared with the PDK (which is true BTW), the Tip shifts faster than the manual (True) and you don't up banging your clutch knee on the dash, or get leg ache in traffic.

One thing to keep in mind is that with manual gearboxes you can mechanically overrev the engine. Too many people have gone into 3rd rather than 5th while accelerating hard and ended up damaging the engine. I believe on Porsche you can check how many times the engine has gone into mechanical overrev.

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

Yes you can indeed and this is another great reason to have a tip or PDK. Idiot proof.

There is a good reason why so many of these cars are available to purchase at what appears to be a favorable price...

@s20ttv

4 жыл бұрын

And what’s that reason?

What's maintenance one one of these is it a hassle? How much and what to look out for?

I had the 996 turbo and went from Switzerland to italy (Venise) to buy a 997 turbo tiptronic. I was so disappointed that I came back by train. Even if the stats are way better tant the 996, the feeling doesn t come close. I had the feeling I was riding a à hoover

do you think the mercedes benz 5 speed titronic transmission in the naturally aspirated engine porsche is also as durable as the one in the turbo 911 ?

Work colleague has one, reckons the manual eat's clutches .... reason enough to avoid.

There are different tiptronic boxes and ecu's for 996/997's. If you get the chrono sport plus package regardless of car you get different ecu settings and sport clutch packs etc. Why some are lazy and others are high performance.

I’ve heard the same thing. Although, I always thought people meant in 2010 and newer cars. The PDK came out in 2009, right?

If think if I ever could afford a Porsche i wouldn't really car what box I had in it as I'd be using it for grand touring and in that case the auto would be best

Soooooo close to 100k 👍🙂

Before I bought a Porsche I desperately wanted a manual but eventually ended up with a tiptronic. But, I absolutely love it and wouldn’t want to change. I always drive it on ‘manual’ and it’s just great fun. Always two hands available for the steering wheel, faster shifting and as a result great acceleration. Respect for the purists tho.

tiptronic is better in every way, it's faster it never misses a shift, and doesn't lose tenths of seconds every shift that you get with a manual.

@JayEmmOnCars

3 жыл бұрын

What you mean is, it's faster. It isn't "better in every way"