Phantom Comparison - You Alone Can Make... It's Over Now... part 1
Музыка
Steve Barton
Ian Jon Bourg
Earl Carpenter
Michael Crawford
Anthony Crivello
John Cudia
Franc D'Ambrosio
Scott Davies
Ethan Freeman
Davis Gaines
Tim Martin Gleason
Peter Jöback
Ramin Karimloo
Peter Karrie
Jeff Keller
Пікірлер: 72
Michael Crawford cried every night. Somehow this man can tap into his emotion every single night. Genius.
@altf1279
5 жыл бұрын
Lila Angelique And the fact that he cried made it so much more real. Erik isn't just sad that Christine left him, he's devastated and heartbroken. He's not going to just sing the last line, he's most likely going to be sobbing because the one light left in his life left him and he know he's alone again.
It's Michael! His interpretation is mesmerizing....He is Erik!
micheal crawford was the best phantom hands down
No one can do this one like Michael. Some you could even say have stronger voices or a cleaner vibrato, but that emotion...listen to how he chokes up on the "can" part, iys utterly beautiful and devastating
Every Phantom in this video is amazing But...when I heard Michael Crawford's crying voice, I cried too
@angelcaldwell4190
6 жыл бұрын
Same...it's even sadder if you know that this particular audio was taken from his final performance.
The problem I'm noticing with a lot of phantoms these days is that they use way too much vibrato. To me, it drowns out the melody and the subtlety. It kills the tenderness.
@bawoman
4 жыл бұрын
Exactly, and MC is the exact opposite of this
@Pannkakaize
3 жыл бұрын
Indeed thats why i like phantoms like Peter joback
@mattg177
Жыл бұрын
Agreed 100% I can’t stand actors who make your ears bleed with too much Vibrato.
He's not my favorite, but I love the way Earl Carpenter's voice resonates holding that last note. It sounds so satisfying.
This song makes me want to cry 😢 I went to see this in London and I love it I hop it stays in her majsty therta
Gotta go with Michael, my fave. Oh, and I think that particular clip was from his final performance as the Phantom in the LA production, so the emotions were especially high there.
These were absolutely incredible! I am floored! Thank you so much for uploading!
Steve bartons was Awesome ............ Btw rest in peace Steve have a good time in heaven buddy
Steve Barton as the Phantom? He should've stuck with Raoul. Michael Crawford hands down for me.
Davis Gaines was heartbreaking. That wasn't expected at all. It was good. And I love John Cudia's like every time. Of course, Michael Crawford's hurts me too. An expected happy pain. But Ramin Karimloo, even with low sound, is just.... yes. The man can sing.
I saw Tim Martin Gleason live when I was 10!! :)
Michael Crawford... so much emotion. But I'm in love with Ramin's voice, beautiful.
Sorry but michael crawford
No contest...Michael Crawford!
jeff keller is my amazing vocal teacher !!
Hopefully part 2 will be released SOON! I saw a few Phantoms in here I had not ever heard of.
For me, my favorites are Anthony Crivello and Michael Crawford.
Peter Joback was my first and favorite Phantom, I LOVE his voice and seeing him live was incredible. He was the only member of the cast who really impressed me, my jaw literally dropped when he sang this...his whole performance blew me away
@Pannkakaize
3 жыл бұрын
I agree, he has that real Disney voice
Where is Anthony Warlow?
Where did you get the audio for Ian Jon Bourg?
Which show was the Franc d'Ambrosio clip from?
i saw scott davies as the phantom a weak ago, he was honeslty the best i have ever sean:):)
working on it :)
@youtubingjaguar5082
6 жыл бұрын
Could you put Butler's version in the part 2? ;)
i saw jhon cudia live myself!
I can hear his voice in there but that must have been an early clip or the person that filmed it had a bad camera. ;)
This part made me ball even harder after I read Leroux's book because (SPOILERS!!!!) he dies in the end. I know in this version he "mysteriously disappear" , but I always assumed he knew he wouldn't be able to take it anymore and that's why he said the music of the night was over. "I COMPOSE THE MUSIC OF THE NIGHT." someone hold me, I'm sad :'(
@muchomarco5
8 жыл бұрын
If he dies, then how did Love Never Dies happen?
@elliart7432
8 жыл бұрын
*shhhhhh*... it didn't...
@ReyntiensDanny
7 жыл бұрын
Les Walking Dr. Musical Lover muchomarco... sssshhhh it's ok , we don't speak about the phantom of Manhatten/love never dies
@LoveSnoopy1962
5 жыл бұрын
@@muchomarco5 no such think. another story, another time, nothing whats so ever to do with Phantom. Only Michael can do Phantom. He said once that each song is a play, He is an actor and he just goes into that song as a play. He is the finest singer I have ever listened to. I never saw him in Phantom except on YT. I saw him perform the MALW in Buffalo on his 50th birthday and in London in Wizard (three times in one weekend). He is a master.
@bawoman
4 жыл бұрын
I dont believe he died.Not because of LND but because why would he bother escaping if he did? I like to think he gets his shit together, somewhat anyway. At least he has now been shown some love and compassion. Maybe that helps hmi hold on
Dave Willetts. That is all. You're welcome.
Damnnn!! Steve Barton blew my mind!
@CanadianGuy2004
5 жыл бұрын
He sounds like he's stuck in some machine getting shook up
1. RAMIN KARIMLOO!!!!! I love how he sings. He brings his soul with him while singing. He put his self on the character 2.Michael Crawford 3. Peter Jöback
Yeah same here
Michael, Barton and Ramin are my favorites :)
Ramin Karimloo, John, Cudia, Earl Carpenter and Scott Davis are my faves!
For heart-wrenching, soul-touching, I have to stick with the master, Michael Crawford. For pure vocal ability, I liked John Cudia, Ethan Freeman and Davis Gaines. Cute as Ramin may be, I just don't find his voice as attractive as many of the others who have played Phantom through the years. That said, Peter Karrie was abominably bad, and Peter Joback is pretty awful too. How they were cast, one must certainly wonder.
@Pannkakaize
3 жыл бұрын
I dont agree, Peter Jöback was great, not the usual boring sound, he has a Wonderful emotion and a great actor, thank god you dont cast them, the Phantom would die out real fast if it all was the same
@PaulBadman981
3 жыл бұрын
I know this post is almost a decade old but Peter Karrie went an octave higher than the usual norm and made it apart of his act, I know his style is.....a bit out there but he plays it to perfection and I think you need to give him another chance. 🙏🏻
Scott Davies
Ramin Karimloo all the way!
Also, is it me or does Ramin not sound like Ramin in this clip...? Usually he sounds much better...
My favorites would have to be: 1. John Cudia (god that was the most heartbreakingly beautiful thing I have ever heard!) 2. Ramin Karimloo 3. Michael Crawford
The best phantoms are joj, ramin and gary mauer hands down
@orlaghswords4322
7 жыл бұрын
My thoughts exactly☺
My favorite and will always be my favorite is Ramin Karmiloo though!:)
ramin karimloo is the best!!!! He's PPUURRFFFEECCCTTTOOWWW!!!!
I wish that they had Gerard Butler's version
@goo83
9 жыл бұрын
WHY?!
@robertjames4528
9 жыл бұрын
You do know gerard butlers voice was dubbed for the film because he couldnt sing
@theartofbeingcompletelyran1788
9 жыл бұрын
Robert James He dubbed himself.
@robertjames4528
9 жыл бұрын
Odin Eidolon fair enough
@jackbiggs1
9 жыл бұрын
Scott Hamp So we can all laugh at him?
Ramin is the best
I can't get myself to like Michael Crawford's voice. It just makes me cringe. JOJ and Ramin are my favorite
@jack_mtg1248
7 жыл бұрын
Same!
@feabicyoplung
5 жыл бұрын
And to me Michael Crawford’s voice is the most beautiful. We all hear things in a different way. I am glad you have Phantoms that sing to you.