In my senior year of high school (2016) we were made to read Freire alongside Foucault in our “advanced English” course and it still blows my mind

@dwwolf4636

Ай бұрын

In what way?

@nobuneko2005

27 күн бұрын

@@dwwolf4636 That as minors in a public high school we were given reading material by someone who openly advocated for the legalization of CSA

Feire's Pedagogy of the Oppressed has had a huge impact in education/pedagogy worldwide and has achieved near-iconic status in US teacher-training programs.

I quit teaching in 2018 I remember being exposed to culturally relevant teaching. I taught in a mostly conservative area w/ a high Hispanic & low income demographic. I think a lot of people didn’t know it had Marxist roots.

@Ridingrules10000

2 жыл бұрын

What boggles my mind is how so many otherwise reasonable people fail to see the intentional racism and segregation that results from this philosophy.

@jeffyboyreloaded

2 жыл бұрын

Reading your comment, was the school district leadership entirely unrepresentative of the population they were elected to represent? Culturally speaking (conservative+objective vs progressive+subjective)?

@nparksntx

2 жыл бұрын

@@Ridingrules10000 I don’t think what little I was exposed to lead to racism

@nparksntx

2 жыл бұрын

@@jeffyboyreloaded the school board? I’d say it was fairly representative of the area. It wasn’t very political at the time. I knew 1 board member a bit outside the school & she’s moderately conservative.

@nparksntx

2 жыл бұрын

@@jeffyboyreloadedmost of the administrators that oversaw trainings were hired positions not elective. I do believe the superintendent was more on the left based on the fact he tried to removed the mascot (Indian brave) & the community put their foot down. They did change his costume a bit but no big deal. The super was a black guy. I know he was a Christian & the previous super (white guy having an affair with a teacher) would saw a prayer before district wide staff days & the new super didn’t.

I would be very interested in hearing your thoughts on Olavo de Carvalho's work. He's a Brazilian philosopher, a conservative and very much opposed to Freire's work, and he was instrumental to the revival of the mainstream conservatist movement in Brazil. He passed away very recently, but his legacy remains.

This episode of the New Discourses Podcast is available early for members. It will premiere publicly at 2pm EDT on Monday, April 18, 2022.

@robertlawrence2278

2 жыл бұрын

Oooo

@zo1dberg

2 жыл бұрын

@@robertlawrence2278 Aaaa

@jasontito7644

2 жыл бұрын

@@zo1dberg eeee

@zo1dberg

2 жыл бұрын

@@jasontito7644 Uuuu

Marxism as an inversion of biblical theology is one of the most mind bending things I've ever learned, so many implications

Working my way through Issac Gottesman's book, so much of this underpins the entire future of critical pedagogy. This summary is great so I can focus on a different angle.

@BlessedFigTree

2 жыл бұрын

I am surprised how the combination of Critical conscious word to meaning and how religious this is when compared to the Augustine tradition. That being, without focus on grammar, rhetoric, logic and natural philosphy without love and fear of the divine logos is flawed toward ignorance and concupiscence tainting all subject matter.

@BlessedFigTree

2 жыл бұрын

I need to understand the development of liberation theology because Paulo sounds so much like the early church fathers and monastic orders with a marxist twist.

@__loafy__

2 жыл бұрын

60 bucks is absurd though

@konberner170

2 жыл бұрын

@@BlessedFigTree Might want to look into the "Social Gospel" if you haven't already. Was a real eye-opener for me, and also speaks to what Progressivism may really be about.

@pesquer2211

2 жыл бұрын

What do you mean the future of critical pedagogy? Wouldn’t it be the past?

Thank You, Professor Lindsay!

New drop from James? Time for me to drop everything on my end, and listen in.

Bless you man! Sifting through piles of this crazy word programing and breaking it down like that!

That dude is cray cray. Look how far behind Brazil is when it comes to education.

The idea that he brought about a “true”dialectic by adding the positive to counteract the negative is mind blowing. Messianic hope is easier to swallow than mere negation, criticism and destruction, or at least justifies it as a means to an end: Utopia.

Brazilian educatiom is paying a high price for adopting Paulo Freire's pedagogy.

@stephanyrebelato1808

2 жыл бұрын

Ahahahah meu deus cara, você não sabe o que fala. Onde foi introduzido a educação do Freire aqui????

@stephanyrebelato1808

2 жыл бұрын

E você realmente leu os livros? Se leu certo, sabe muito bem que a pedagogia dele é crítica e conservadora neh? KKKKKKKKKKK

@subtitleslegendas1147

2 жыл бұрын

You sound more like an activist than an educator. Sorry, I don't do those...

@Mateo-et3wl

Жыл бұрын

i have no idea what brazilian education is based on but i regularly hear from brazilians (and other sources) that they receive one of the worst educations in latin america, which is saying quite a lot. i've never met a brazilian (and i've met lots) who had anything positive to say about education in their country. very sad

@subtitleslegendas1147

Жыл бұрын

@@Mateo-et3wl Lately I can't name a place with a "real" quality education system. Homeschooling for me is the way to go.

Eye opening as always Mr. Lindsay

The sad leftist agitators in chat were amusing today. Your over the target 🎯 James. Keep it up 👍

@PerfectTangent

2 жыл бұрын

If you look back through, the antifa lad deleted all his posts

Thank you

Wow. Christianity sees God as Logos; Marxism sees God as Pathos. This is brilliant. This explains, for me, why I feel so often when I listen to these podcasts that many of the explanations Marxism provides for how the world works are not entirely wrong, and are in fact congruent with a Judeo-Christian belief system. For example, the idea that humans beings speak and create existence through their vision, is not wrong at all, and in fact aligns with exactly how I understand Jordan Petersons religion based analysis. God spoke the world into existence in the beginning and created mankind in his image. Humans beings are in fact responsible for creating the world. The difference is nested in this Logos vs Pathos argument.

@jeffyboyreloaded

2 жыл бұрын

Really important distinction here is that inescapable original sin doesn't exist in Marxism. In Christianity, man's creations are only good if they align with God, because we are inherently flawed so we have to follow his lead because he is by definition all that is good. This means the map for "utopia" requires everyone to emulate Christ. Marx thinks the flaw in humans is inflicted upon us by other humans, humans who specifically lack awakened consciousness. This is also to say that Marx doesn't believe the slave or the prole is inherently flawed, and if they were to take control and act as they wished they could usher in utopia. In the Christian telling, flaws (sin) are inherent (due to our own actions in the garden) and only Christ can help us overcome them - in the Marxist telling flaws are inflicted upon us by the oppressor class and only the oppressed can overcome them. The only thing Marx did correctly was notice that there's a lot of not nice stuff in the world but he completely inverted the attribution and is as wrong as possible

@BarryWillBuck

6 ай бұрын

​@@jeffyboyreloaded👍 Hence why George Floyd was made like a Christ to them.

@BarryWillBuck

6 ай бұрын

I always recall what Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn wrote, "the dividing line between good and evil runs through the heart of every man."

The major reason Freire was such an effective reformer of Marxism was that he developed an explanation for Marxism's failings around the world that on its surface seems plausible as well as a supposed solution to it. This was his project.

@PenTheMighty

2 жыл бұрын

So he was an apologist for Marxism by adding the philosophical equivalent of "prosperity gospel".

@jeremyponcy7311

2 жыл бұрын

@@PenTheMighty I don't understand the "prosperity gospel" reference in this context. I think nondenominational church would be a better analogy within a religious context but this still isn't a great analogy.

@PenTheMighty

2 жыл бұрын

@@jeremyponcy7311 Prosperity gospel is a religious belief among some Protestant Christians that financial blessing and physical well-being are always the will of God for them, and that faith, positive speech, and donations to religious causes will increase one's material wealth. It's basically "The Secret" but for Christians and was seen by some newer preachers as a way to reach new audiences. At this point, some 17% of US Christians buy into it.

@jeremyponcy7311

2 жыл бұрын

@@PenTheMighty I would say that is a better analogy for the the Communist offshoots of the 60s and 70s such as Cultural Marxism, Critical Marxism, and Postmodernism. Freire revived the classical Marxist tradition that brought these all back together under a single banner.

Awesome, another episode. Guess it's time to be terrified again.

One day we need a conversation with e michael jones and James.

@grekerbeer948

2 жыл бұрын

E michael jones is a hero

@teddysaginaw9101

2 жыл бұрын

@@grekerbeer948 his research is incredible. I don't always agree with his solutions, I don't think catholicism is the answer and I say that as a catholic, but if you want a clear diagnosis of why we are where we are today then read jones. Particularly Libido Dominandi and Slaughter of Cities.

Only teachers possess the intelligence to take Paulo Freire seriously.

I finished your book.. Good book. Sooo glad I bought it. Among the others I got as well. I do believe that if any who wants to learn of this subject but dose nit want to watch Lindsay rather really long vids., get the book. That way u can read it at your leisure. I literally breezed through the it, with done one with a grade 8 education. No problem 4 me.. I actually had mire trouble reading the the law from bastiat book. Actually had to look up words witch is rather districting when a person is trying to learn a few things. Anyways. Real easy read IMO.. I do think the book Lindsay wrote shoukd have elaborated more on fascism and socialism. However that not the topic., nonetheless GOOD BOOK... IMO . Just wanted to come in here and say that. And I'll might watch this vid later on, but not right now.

@konberner170

2 жыл бұрын

Solid review! Thank you.

@kyleolin3566

2 жыл бұрын

Tik History on KZread does an awesome comparison and analysis of Capitalism and Socialism.

@kyleolin3566

2 жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/nad109RtnK-nj7w.html

Would be great to have an episode that specifically centers on the CRT/Critical Pedagogy matriculation into math. With specific type math problems, what school districts this has taken hold in, text books used etc. Would be a great weapon in pushing back to the gaslighting opposition to HB 1557 in Florida!

When I searched for Freire's book on Amazon your book came up right underneath it for the Recommended 🤣

Been busy.... I have some videos to catch up on on this channel. Cool, because I'm thirsty to for this content.

Homeschooling is the solution by now. Unfortunatelly, I see these ideas in my son's textbooks.

@Seliz463

Жыл бұрын

Try classical Christian textbook sources, memoria press and seton are very good. I have found zero Marxist ideas in any of their stuff

39:41.. I am dyslexic.. I do sound out words or try to sound them out in the book the law. Few words their I had ntrouble with, but yes I use recognition of words. If I can't sound them out or to lazy to look them up ither in a dictionary or now on the interwebs i just move on and eventually I'll get somewhat what they mean or figure it out on my own. No the less yes. It's recognition of words that's y I can read rather fast. Cause ppl generally use easy words when writing books. Good thing. Man that book the law. Old language with odd or unusually used words makes a bit of a challenge to read..

The alienation idea is reasonable... probably Marx's only reasonable idea. So if you find yourself following orders instead of creating, the key question is what to do about it. There are solid options like saving up to start a small enterprise (happens millions of times a day), finding work that is creative (it can happen in some organizations), etc.. Or, of course, you could also hate everything in society and especially your employer, want to destroy all of it and replace it with a forced system that after passing through authoritarian and centralized phases may eventually magically change into a kind of anarchism that is completely free and everyone is equal and has equal outcomes. Yeah, great plan. What could possibly go wrong? It just goes to show that it is very possible to diagnose a real problem and recommend a cure that is not only worse than the disease, it couldn't possibly be more worse.. I honestly don't see how it is different than recommending someone to cut their own head off to cure a headache.

@kyleolin3566

2 жыл бұрын

I like your analysis on alienation and your analogy on cutting off one’s head to cure a headache. I may have to use that one. Lol

@konberner170

2 жыл бұрын

@@kyleolin3566 Thank you!

An old WW2 joke came to mind and it updated in my head into... "TICK... TICK... TICK..." says one The WOKE thug in a suit leans in and says "Vee haff vaaayz uff makinink you TOK." From Montreal with love 💪🏼🇨🇦👊🏽🚛📣 INFOWARS

Can anyone point to any content from the left (or anywhere) that refutes these readings and interpretatios from James? I feel like there aren't any. I'm right with James with what's going on, so I'd like some good faith argumentation that attempts a refutation.

(Wish you could boil it down to 20 minutes, but it hit the algorithim for a reason)

@jeremyponcy7311

2 жыл бұрын

1)Marxism fails around the world 2) Marxists become disillusioned and disoriented 3) Freire generates explanation as to the failures of Marxism 4) Marxism was reproducing systems of oppression through capitalistic forms of Education 5) These banking systems of Education socialize people into dominant structures 6) These dominant structures form classes such as teachers students/conscious unconscious/knowers unknowers/ dominant dominated 7) Freire provides solution to declass Education 8) Teachers must become students and students teachers, conscious must recognize their lack of full conscious and unconscious must become aware of their conscious contributions, knowers must recognize what they don't know and unknowers must recognize what they 9) Equalization in education to desocialize dominant dominated relationships in society will bring about true Equality in society and Communist utopia. 10) Communists are reoriented by these "discoveries" and disoriented factions are brought back together through intersectionality.

Skill based education is mentorship... am I correct in thinking that? From Montreal with love 💪🏼🇨🇦👊🏽

@saerain

2 жыл бұрын

Seems more like the lack of mentorship. Skill without understanding, habit without thought, following the Word.

Good vid.. C u next time

are you going to talk about the Unhinged Giroux?

Its not really a rejection of order, just like Machiavelli's princes it's to reject the current order in favor of a new natural order. Order out of chaos so to speak

Hay I like Star Wars..

Giving students the ability to find Marxism by reading between the lines, without giving them the ability to read the lines.

@Slimc74

2 жыл бұрын

Yes. Its called evil. Which the Marxist believe is a " concept ". Only they have the " devine spark of the inner self ", to be able to control. By hiding their motives. This is what destroye them

Hiya.

Dammit James it's Paulo "Frayre" not Fraieyre.

@SomboonCM

2 жыл бұрын

Go wash out your mouth with soap!

@kylewhite2985

2 жыл бұрын

@@SomboonCM I don't get it. I'm just trying to help his pronunciation.

I mean, I have a lot of sympathy for the arguments about the trap of "reproducing the existing society" and the useful idiots molded by "skills-based" education. As with Marx there's so much perfectly fine critique with prescriptions that are just differently terrible.

You should give a math or physics lecture on here sometime. Just to contrast fake scholarship with the real deal.

I’m hearing a hell of lot of romanticism in what you are saying.

Stop being a beta and debate Vaush already.

T R A S H

@JordanX767

2 жыл бұрын

I agree. Freire is trash 🗑.

Karl Marx: Brilliant man, and blamed for everything you're ignorant of, afraid of, or angry at on this channel on a daily basis. Guaranteed.

@cooke828

2 жыл бұрын

Karl Marx: Brilliant man, the cause of millions of deaths, the loss of reason & edgy teenagers. Guaranteed.

@Xirrious

2 жыл бұрын

Is someone upset light is being shone on their insane ideology?

@PerfectTangent

2 жыл бұрын

"Brilliant"

@andrewpotter4131

2 жыл бұрын

Bullshit

@clifford7594

2 жыл бұрын

@@cooke828 I think you're confusing him with Bill Clinton.

I adore you James and promote you on all my social media platforms. Please do something for me. Speaking of phonics PLEASE take this recommendation in the proper spirit of admiration. Please exercise “EX CETERA” out of your lexicon. ETCETERA. ET CETERA. ET CETERA. ET CETERA SOUND IT OUT. Keep repeating it over and over until you’ve expunged “EX CETERA” out of your speech. SOUND IT OUT ET CETERA. ET CETERA. ET CETERA. You are waaaaaaay too smart not to fix this little but glaring grammatical bad habit. With agape love.