I stumbled upon this and whoa...this was unexpected...parallel worlds indeed! The story of the soldier setting up rehabilitation efforts is particularly moving...

@aloha5527

6 ай бұрын

parralel world is tag at zionist rule my country.

@cipdamboianu5139

6 ай бұрын

See many corners of US cities unfortunately, where veterans hide their traumas and despair in drugs or have lost their minds….I don’t have much hope for humanity!

This indeed is an amazing documentary. That Solider\Healer's insight into human psyche and accepting everyone's way of life is truly touching. Keep more of this coming.

Same in Ukraine. I see a lot of reach Ukrainians in Germany. Why does man don't go to war?

@DerDudelino

6 ай бұрын

*To waste their life? There is nothing to win in war, it's only suffering and it's going to destroy your life. All of those young men will come home with serious injuries or PTSD traumas. Very few men are actually able to leave the war behind - most of them are haunted by it for the rest of their life.

Can you speak about Ukrainian elite who have been in rich cities, like Courchevel , Nice...

@jkrock6635

5 ай бұрын

looooool

@markrathmell9993

5 ай бұрын

Yeh but what about what about what about what about... ad nauseam.

Responability for a majority of russians never existed and still don't exist. Bozunova is a rare exeption. Thank you to Arte/TracksEast and Bozunova for this content.

@junglesuperstar9270

6 ай бұрын

Reaaaaaaalllllyyyyyyy. Are my cards working abroad ? Can I buy medicines ???? Oh, shooooot. Medicines are not imported into Russia . LOVELY

@wernertognetti5956

6 ай бұрын

@@junglesuperstar9270 Responability means to take care for a civilized country and to build up a civiliced environment. The culture of most muscovits is to destroy everything, not to build up.

@martinmart481

5 ай бұрын

Responsibility of majority of Americans never existed and still don't exist too. Look at Hunter Biden. Right?!

@DChungking

5 ай бұрын

What means ‘responsibility’ in this case?

how about ukrainian elites (buying all these yachts in europe) and the war in ukraine?

@alic5812

5 ай бұрын

Tell us! You seem to know more about it!

What happened to all people speaking against war in Vietnam? Is there any actor or artist who could openly say anything against that war, without being stigmatized?

@desputnikcommander

6 ай бұрын

wrong video

Дуже цікава документалка. Дякую!

too funny, that timberlake second

Shoighus son busy singing in English as his dad makes war on the west.

Beyond description. Most moving and so timely.❤😮

Kiselev is contributing to the Russian culture by singing ... American songs in English ??

Hopefully our youth will do better than we did in the world.

I’d forgotten about PC Format, thank you so much for putting this together. I was an avid ACE subscriber, but PC Format was a regular shelf pick. Subscribed and Liked!🎉

There's no point in commenting if selective comments are either removed or hidden. Free Speech!

@artetvdocumentary

6 ай бұрын

Thank you for your comment. There can be two reasons why comments are deleted: On the one hand, KZread already deletes comments that violate KZread's community guidelines. We never see these comments ourselves. On the other hand, we also delete inappropriate messages that violate our Netiquette, as we want to enable a constructive and, above all, polite and respectful exchange on the topic with the comment function. Inappropriate messages, advertising and messages that violate our netiquette (www.youtube.com/@artede/about) will therefore be deleted.

As Ukrainian. I can tell the same about our corruption and oligarchs, celebrity's etc.

@Cocoisagordonsetter

6 ай бұрын

Yeah. Those people don't get a pass. It's the poor irrelevant people who always pay the price. Ukraine is CORRUPT.

@aloha5527

6 ай бұрын

In Ucrania same

@angeurbain6129

6 ай бұрын

Ukrainian border guard make money out of ukrainian mens going away of their country to flee conscription.

@valdemariv394

6 ай бұрын

It doesn't relieve you from your duty to protect your country though. Because it's regular folk who suffer from russian artillery and rockets, not oligarhs.

@0d1n61

6 ай бұрын

@@valdemariv394 you mean since 2014 and both ways flying rockets in Dobass? I'm not the one who was killing people in Odessa in 2014 that started all. So no thanks.

Need commentary and translations please

Russian losses, according to the Ukrainian ministry of defence: 07.01.2024 Tanks - 6022 (+4) Armored fighting vehicle - 11180 (+22) Artillery systems - 8653 (+36) MLRS - 951 (+1) Anti-aircraft warfare - 637 (+4) Planes - 329 Helicopters - 324 UAV - 6811 (+24) Cruise missiles - 1786 Ships (boats) - 23 Submarines - 1 Cars and cisterns - 11523 (+45) Special equipment - 1327 (+10) Military personnel - aprx. 364730 people (+860)

The same thing also happening in Ukraine. You should make a documentary about it too.

@ulrichhinteregger9540

6 ай бұрын

Dringend notwendig ein Bericht über diese Welt in der Ukraine! Was ist mit den Oligarchen in der Ukraine 🎉😢

@xjapan3

6 ай бұрын

​@@ulrichhinteregger9540That is a good question! Surely there is no corruption there. Ukrainians are the "good guys" who can do no wrong.

@HaleG9

6 ай бұрын

it is not, even if your Tucker Carlson's try to make you believe. Ukraine caes for her soldiers, RuZZia does not and never did. Fullstop.

@xjapan3

6 ай бұрын

@@HaleG9 This HAS to be a joke.

One question is why those singers sing in the enemy language and not in their own?

@junglesuperstar9270

6 ай бұрын

Mmmmm. Who are enemies ?

@nickplays2022

6 ай бұрын

@@junglesuperstar9270 of course, Anglo saxons, NATO!

@junglesuperstar9270

6 ай бұрын

@@nickplays2022 I did not know nato is the language

Max was here

They are born lucky

о Маша!

What about the Ukrainian elite? I know for a fact some spent their birthday in Mykonos this summer 2023 spending at least a lavish 250,000 euro, private flights not included, just to party. Why are they not at war?

Amazing Documentary!!

Umm honestly, isn't it the same with elites everywhere all around the world😂

great coverage i also fled my home country of usa for many reasons anyone in stockholm

This video does not make much sense, in all the countries of the world, the one who has money can do more things, make records, make movies, be a politician, etc. Likewise, the law is for everyone but not for everyone, all over the world.

It is the same or vers in Ukraina. And here in Norway I remenber when I was servibg 12 mnd in military the ricch folk got the nicest jobb, it is the same every plave.

100 years later, doesn’t remind anything?

God Bless them.

можно мьютить музыку этих существ?

I am curious about American Elite and the was in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Or how was the one in Vietnam!

Awesome content from my favorite "Fake News" (ex)anchor! Masha, if you have an opportunity, please work a little more on your delivery with a native or naturalized (10+ years) English speaker.

@ElenaKomleva

6 ай бұрын

Why don't they hire someone who actually speaks good English to work for Arte. Instead, they hire someone who doesn't know either German, or French, and who speaks poor English to work for the German-French company. Talk about the fact that connections and bribes make everything happen 😂 This time in Europe though 😂

@timboshanghai6785

6 ай бұрын

the delivery is more powerful and insightful if it comes from a russian, simple as that @@ElenaKomleva

armes Berlin...

Спасибо большое

The sort of "Non-Performing Capital" exists in many "Developing" economies. Cronies hoard capital access to themselves while investing little to nothing into the economy. Bottom up entrepreneurs' ideas, projects, dreams and tech advancements go unfunded. Many attribute such hoarding by the Cronies as "Capitalism." It is a fertile ground for those agitating for Socialism as a cure. With no real jobs being created neither by cronies nor socialists, millions become government dependent mouths to be fed.Poverty becomes ingrained. The "Elites" are abstracted away from the masses while enjoying the fruits of their "Capital" like this video and many others like it have shown.

I offer this journalist to tell where they get money from? state department of usa or usaid?

This is the first time watching your channel and I applaud your exposure to this nepotism, hypocrisy, and absolute garbage from Russia. As an American who splits time between the US and Europe, the irony is that nepotism and nepo babies run rampant in the US too. But this is a global problem. Watching Timbaland on stage with the faux Timberlake was a laugh out loud moment for me, but I also felt a sense of profound sadness for Russian civilians being exposed to this “act”. Nepo babies dodging service in times of war is a tale as old as time. And a prime American example is Donald Trump. I stand in solidarity with defenders of democracy and this channel for exposing those evading it.

@ethicalhacker2318

6 ай бұрын

So You are ok with Russia putting rocket shields in Mexico and Canada.

@prostayas

3 ай бұрын

Цинизм и двуличие США и Европы поражает своей беспринципностью и наглостью. Почему эти страны с такой ЖАДНОСТЬЮ принимают ВОРОВАННЫЕ деньги от ВОРОВ и их родственников, продавая им недвижимость, яхты, машины, ювелирку, клубы и прочее?!! Зачем вы их ЛЕЧИТЕ, если знаете, что они обокрали медицину в России? Зачем вы учите их детей, если знаете, что они обокрали и уничтожают образование в России? Зачем вы приняли на хранение в свои банки ВОРОВАННЫЕ ДЕНЬГИ и начисляете % ? Зачем ваши юристы и адвокаты ЗАЩИЩАЮТ ТАКИХ преступников? Россияне рады, что наша СВЯТАЯ РОССИЯ, пусть и таких образом, избавляется от человеческого мусора. Считайте, что россияне вам приплатили, чтобы эти преступники и их отродья плодились у вас, а не в России. Хотя, по сути, ИМЕННО ВЫ СОУЧАСТНИКИ ВОРОВСТВА, так вы не брезгуете ворованным у нашего народа, у нашей страны.

There’s rules for the people,and there’s rules for the rich. So sad.

Well that's russia - not really something to be proud of 😵‍💫

Still think this war isn't a sham?

Границ у капитала нет. Вот и все...

They all go Asia now

@alexrangel1123

6 ай бұрын

I always found ironic how these rich Russian will come to Florida

@elperro3056

6 ай бұрын

@@alexrangel1123 Thailand 🇻🇳 Bali and ph is Geting takeover from them hahaha why they don’t go Western Europe 😅

@alexrangel1123

6 ай бұрын

@@elperro3056 they we’re until western governments started taking away their yachts & money now they’ve scurried away lol

@timboshanghai6785

6 ай бұрын

thay cant, travel ban@@elperro3056

What about the french elite and war in Africa?

@adamjerzyrodewald5752

6 ай бұрын

What about ism

@aldorein_

6 ай бұрын

@@adamjerzyrodewald5752whataboutism helps you look in the mirror

Is it different in Western countries? In NATO's completely professionalized armies I have not seen sons of the most favored classes enlisting, only men from the lowest strata of society. To think that what the video shows only happens in Russia is absolutely naive.

@laaaliiiluuu

5 ай бұрын

But but but CNN said only Russia bad and America good 🤡

@peteratkinson1492

5 ай бұрын

No one wants their kids to die, but wanting other people’s kids to die and saying one thing and doing another is a cynical double standard. It happens on all societies but still stinks.

I like how they want us to believe they are doing journalism while the Russians are doing propaganda 😅

@awannagannaful

6 ай бұрын

Exactly, as if any Westerners or Ukrainians are any different. Pathetic really, esp when one looks at who actually pushed for this war on Russia: the entire West.

@habicht6

6 ай бұрын

you can make the difference... the rest of humanity is just stupid...

@ovincent35

6 ай бұрын

Most of the american population is just propagandized sheep's that believe everything msm n the america government propaganda says .🤣🤣🤣🤣

@habicht6

5 ай бұрын

oh my lord...... Putin-Troll

@awannagannaful

5 ай бұрын

@@habicht6that is what western trolls say when they have no arguments.

🥱🥱

NEKI RATUJU NEKI SE BOGATE

thats nice and all... but the target-audience won't get this to see

Lots of tge bots in the comments putting down Ukrainian. I guess Russian machine found this documentary

Well I left Russia in 1996. It has always been this way.

Is there no one proofreading English scripts at Arte? She is a great presenter, but I'm surprised by the amount of mistakes. I don't blame her as English is clearly not her dominant language, but someone should be rereading and correcting this stuff. Give someone a job! 😄

@ryanwbourquin

6 ай бұрын

Im english and she was fine..her message was clear and the editing was excellent.

Right. The injustice is unique only to Russia. Propaganda anyone?

Its russia!😆

The day arte starts to criticize Israel with the same attention to detail, is the day they can be taken seriously. Until then your criticism is not based on morals and ethics but ideology and opportunism

@everydaylife5641

5 ай бұрын

@@jamesmccaul2945 I do, but you know what I don’t do? Selectively critize when it suits me, and look the other way when I doesn’t suit me 🤡 Besides wtf does that have to with my point ?

@thornil2231

5 ай бұрын

The day ANY WESTERN MEDIA starts to criticize Israel with the same attention to detail, is the day they can be taken seriously.

💩

Stunning that your English is good, but at least show truth not fake facts. Sad

"Creative Class", just as self-centered and ridiculous than its western sister.

they send the sons of the poor to die in their useless wars, as they enjoy the best of the best. sad

Arte keep going with it's ''liberal'' views.

@electrosyzygy

6 ай бұрын

reality has a liberal bias

@angeurbain6129

6 ай бұрын

This liberal bias is naked in Ukraine@@electrosyzygy

Какой же кринж

These russians living in Tbilisi, said we moved to Georgia after the war started in 2022 due to the protest against russian policies, but the war started in 2014 . why are they moving to 2022 and not in 2014? it so hypocrites

the last person is such a hypocrite... she dresses as provocative as she can just to determine reactions in ppl and then she poses as a victim when ppl reveal their most basic instincts... the documentary is enough solid without that last example imo...

@Cocoisagordonsetter

6 ай бұрын

She grew up homely and is a making up for lost time. I don't think she is unlikable, but she's not going to find the fame she seeks so hopefully she can survive and thrive somehow.

@luisvasquez5015

6 ай бұрын

Are you not angry at the people behaving like animals?

Are you not the propagandist??!!😢😢

And the Kiev mafia, how do they live?

Could you ask a bit more washed (clean) anti-war people?

Schlechter kann man Missstände kaum dokumentiere und wird damit zum eigentlichen Problem!

If it hadn't appeared on this channel, it would have received some credibility, but arte is the cheapest Franco-German propaganda channel 🤣

Talking About propoganda while literally spouting anti-Russian propaganda.

Decadents

Why don't they hire someone who actually speaks good English to work for Arte. Instead, they hire someone who doesn't know either German, or French, and who speaks poor English to work for the German-French company. Talk about the fact that connections and bribes make anything and everything happen 😂 This time in Europe though lol

@bungee7503

6 ай бұрын

I’m a native English speaker and average speaker of French. This presenter’s English skills are fine by me. I don’t expect everyone to know my language perfectly.

@dhoraray1310

6 ай бұрын

​@@bungee7503and what?!? What goes next?!? Greetngs from south-east Siberia.

@neilclark8087

6 ай бұрын

What's your point? you are talking rubbish!

@timboshanghai6785

6 ай бұрын

thank you for your inputs here propaganda bitch

Hypocrites

Marha Borzunova didn't make any discovery. Parallel worlds have always been and will always be in all warring states. There are no exceptions! Masha is a so called "foreign agent", so she tries her best to spit in the direction of Russia. The reportage is mediocre, not talkative.

hope those russians don't come here..find a better place..

Isn’t this also a propaganda against Russia?

@golden1983golden

6 ай бұрын

this based of facts not rubbish

@tyroneslothrop123

6 ай бұрын

@@golden1983golden every piece of well made propaganda is based on facts. it's the remaining 5-10% and a bit of framing / emotion which makes the difference ;)

@paulminh3525

6 ай бұрын

@@golden1983golden You know the best lie in this world have some truth in it, but applying emotional appeal and emotional manipulation to exaggerate it! Like in Ukraine and Israel, there are historical channel that highlight some Ukrainian collaboration with the Nazi in WW2 but exaggerated in enormous proportions to make people believe that all Ukrainian is a Nazi state, despite data don’t back it up! They use some truths, but exaggerated to make it more dramatic and serious! US and Russia use some truths, but exaggerated it in their propaganda techniques to make it other as an extremely evil yet both use the same propaganda techniques to boost their images! They simplify the current situations to make people believe that this information is absolute truths, but they are no absolute truths as both sides always justified of why they does what they does logically according to their own understanding! People lack common senses to understand that the truths is in the middle, not between the extremist sides!

These people are the hope for Russia

get rid of this weeds... same parents same kids

Stop EU sponsoring for ARTE. Another waste of money.

@neilclark8087

6 ай бұрын

who cares about u?

Imagine believing 1 word in this video. 🤣

RUSSIA IS BIG !!! ❤ Russia

First boy and first words "alleged illegitimate son'". Masha ,if you want to be a journalist but not BS girl, don't use anything "alleged". Otherwise your video is just a hipe . There are 250 new plants were built in Russia for past 1 year related to military production,hundreds thousands volontiers went to the front, but you have selected few boys and girls with alleged relationship and alleged stories to report. This ,my dear,is not report but hipe. But I guess you know this well and that is exactly what you are doing. Success and good thins about Russia are not interesting and will not bring attention and money.

Making a video in English is a good idea But…she needs to work on her ascent😅😅😅 so painful 😭 it was distracting me the entire time

Пьяные крики и запах сортира Внешние признаки "русского мира". Цепь золотая на шее банкира - Связь поколений "русского мира". Русский язык стал родным для башкира - Это политика "русского мира". У депутата седьмая квартира - Вот справедливость "русского мира". Крест золотой на груди рэкетира Это духовность "русского мира". Из негодяя сделать кумира - Идеология "русского мира". Ложь ежедневная телеэфира - Это правдивость "русского мира". Двадцать копеек пачка пломбира - Память фантомная "русского мира". В морду удар от отца-командира Вот "педагогика" "русского мира". Насмерть кувалдой забить дезертира Это гуманность "русского мира". Сытый смешок на устах конвоира - Это реальность "русского мира". Вор, матершинник, подлец и задира - Это сторонник "русского мира". Кнут, кандалы, яд, петля и секира Издревле скрепы "русского мира". Смерть вместо масла, война вместо мира - Это основа "русского мира". H

this is soo liberal leaning xD

your just envy 😂

Morons! They don't know that NATO is to blame for this mess.

@hhKJgf1M8a0rzt8hP

6 ай бұрын

If Russia is afraid of NATO why they are not protecting the borders with their NATO neighbours, hardly no troops and equipment there?🤔