Pakistan's Establishment and Politics ft. Syed Muzammil Shah | Cross Examination | Part 1
Pakistan's Establishment and Politics ft. Syed Muzammil Shah | Cross Examination | Part 1 | Podcast # 25 | Barrister Mian Ali Ashfaq
Syed Muzammil Shah (Journalist, News Analyst, Anchor, Political Scientist).
Syed Muzammil is a Political Scientist and a Prime Time talk show host of his own show named “Statecraft” at the Express News, one of the top 3 channels of Pakistan. He has worked previously in many leading media channels like Bol, GNN, Neo TV, Capital TV etc. Muzammil is a Philosophy enthusiast and he is also a Vlogger, a writer and a social critic.
#SyedMuzammilShah #crossexaminationwithali #mianaliashfaq #Podcast #CrossExamination #BarristerMianAliAshfaq #Pakistan #Politics #Establishment #PakistanEstablishment #SyedMuzammilShahLatest #SyedMuzammilShahPodcast
Topics:
00:00 Highlights
01:55 Intro - Syed Muzammil Shah
02:30 - Education - Professional Background
05:08 Independency of Electronic and Print Media
08:50 Black Money in Media - Business Media - Dark side of Journalism
12:59 Favorite Journalists
16:03 Digital Revaluation in Pakistan - Digital Journalism
27:58 Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah - Partition
33:56 General Ayub - Father of the Nation
34:46 Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Kidnapped an Army Chief - Power of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto
40:02 General Zia ul Haq Era - Zia Zinda Hai
43:25 Importance of Education in Politics
47:10 Zia Era to Democracy in Pakistan
53:25 Saif ur Rehman - Corruption Culture in Pakistan - Pmln, PPP Mr. 10%
56:34 Steel Mill Destruction - Political Victimization
01:02:40 Gymkhana Club Tax is 5 Thousand Rupees - Elite Captured in Pakistan
01:03:07 The Time of General Pervez Musharraf
01:07:51 2008 to 2018 - Democratic Era
To Be Continued.....
Syed Muzammil Shah Podcast Mian Ali Ashfaq
Syed Muzammil Shah
Syed Muzammil Shah Latest
Syed Muzammil Shah Cross Examination with Ali
Mian Ali Ashfaq
Barrister Mian Ali Ashfaq Podcast ft. Syed Muzammil Shah
Syed Muzammil Shah Balochistan
Syed Muzammil Shah Pakistan Army
Syed Muzammil Shah Philosophy
Syed Muzammil Shah Zia Ul Haq
Syed Muzammil Shah Latest
Syed Muzammil Shah Exclusive Podcast Mian Ali Ashfaq
Syed Muzammil Shah Cross Examination
Syed Muzammil Shah Imran Khan
Syed Muzammil Shah Interview
Mian Ali Ashfaq Barrister at Law, Master of Law, Master in Journalism, Senior Partner at S.M Masud & Associate, Proud Pakistani National, A Human rights Activist 🇵🇰
Follow These Links to Stay Connecting With Us:
KZread: / @crossexaminationwithali
Facebook: www.facebook.c... / cross_exwithali
Tiktok: / crossexaminationwithali
Instagram: www.instagram....
Пікірлер: 138
I regularly watch and listen to Syed Muzzamil Shah from Nepal. I wonder, in a highly radicalized and Mullah dominated Pakistan, How can Pakistan have a genius like HIM.
@syedfasih74
Ай бұрын
That's the beauty of reading books 😍
@syedfasih74
Ай бұрын
He has liberated himself from the system
@inamdurrani9259
Ай бұрын
If we are so radical why the hell we never elected mullahs as our PM's.. this tells alot about your level of brainwashing..mullahs have constituencies in certain bits and parts not the entire Pakistan..we always have elected secular parties certainly not radicals
@maheshlalwani6905
Ай бұрын
Very knowledgeable person
@Cine95
28 күн бұрын
kiddo he is not liberated but an army tout 😂
It was highly enlightening interview! Syed Muzamil is treat to hear.Keep it up, Pakistan is on the way to recovery with the people like you.
Such a great Analyst and Intellectual person across the whole country..keep sharing this type of thoughts and ideas to the youth ..Love u Syed Muzzamil shah❤
Very good job Syed muzamil shah ... exposed establishment and politicians
Thank you for the great conversation.
Why do Pakistani media outlets have this obsession with bombastic background music, it totally ruins the interview, here the anchor and Syed are discussing deep intellectual things and the background sounds like a Bollywood action sequence.
@oxabyte6987
Ай бұрын
agreed with you
@shivangsingh5834
Ай бұрын
Yeah unnecessary
@AdnanNazirPK
Ай бұрын
Exactly!
@swatip000
16 күн бұрын
I was about to comment same...its so disturbing ..😣
It was a refreshing and informative podcast, and I enjoyed every minute of it... thanks
Thank you for this podcast 🌸❤
سید مزمل کو سننا اچھا لگتا ہیں۔ کراس ایگزامینشن میں اس انٹرویو کو پورہ دیکھو گا۔❤
watching only for Syed Muzammil Shah
Topics: 00:00 Highlights 01:55 Intro - Syed Muzammil Shah 02:30 - Education - Professional Background 05:08 Independency of Electronic and Print Media 08:50 Black Money in Media - Business Media - Dark side of Journalism 12:59 Favorite Journalists 16:03 Digital Revaluation in Pakistan - Digital Journalism 27:58 Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah - Partition 33:56 General Ayub - Father of the Nation 34:46 Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Kidnapped an Army Chief - Power of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto 40:02 General Zia ul Haq Era - Zia Zinda Hai 43:25 Importance of Education in Politics 47:10 Zia Era to Democracy in Pakistan 53:25 Saif ur Rehman - Corruption Culture in Pakistan - Pmln, PPP Mr. 10% 56:34 Steel Mill Destruction - Political Victimization 01:02:40 Gymkhana Club Tax is 5 Thousand Rupees - Elite Captured in Pakistan 01:03:07 The Time of General Pervez Musharraf 01:07:51 2008 to 2018 - Democratic Era
You are great lawyers
Excellent analysis by Muzammil-
Supper
It was well putt with clear thoughts and facts.
I really impressed your very good and very impressive debate you cover all topic and muzamal is very educated I wish all social media doing good but unfortunately people have no education they're give us wrong information just for money
He is very popular in India🇮🇳 Luv from India❤
Hii.. syed muzamil shah you are the druv rathee of failed nation pakistan.you aware your people good work sir keep going..❤❤❤respect 👍 sir
@akashkumarcivil-2665
Ай бұрын
❤
Muzammil,”when we will see the good time”.
علی بھائی آپ ایک سچے ہیرو ہو آپ کی مہربانی آپ عمران خان کے سارے کیس خود دیکھے ان کے اپنے وکیل کچھ نہیں کر رہے آپ سب لوگوں سے گزارش ہے کہ علی بھائی کو اس بات پر راضی کرے عمران خان کے سارے کیسوں کو خود لڑے
Valuable discussion 👍
Ture definition of diamond 💎💎💎
Sir kindly keep background music low ... It is irritating and distracting
why is there background music in serious conversation? whole podcast it is very difficult to focus on what they are talking. its very annoying and irritating.
Very informative
Very nice
Awais Iqbal and Syed mujjmil are gem of pakistan
@kishanchauhan678
Ай бұрын
Awaish Iqbal atheist hai Pakistan mai 96 percent muslim rahte hai to kaise gem hoga waise bhi non muslim pm cm president nahi ban sakta o to murtad hai or murtad ki saza mout hai
he is a gem❤
Bcz we listen in very peaceful environment
Without papa..beta can-'t survive..
here to watch Muzammil Shah but background sound is too disturbing. But yet eager to listen Muzammil
I love syed muzzamil...
Dont insult Muzammil by calling him Dhruv Rathee. I am from India and know that Dhruv Rathee has an agenda and says things from money and Muzammil is among the few voices of reason in chaotic Pakistan. I pray from more power to him. He is more like Abhi and Niyu from India
Peeche background main beating bnd krdejyega next time, it ruins entire user listening experience
*Here are 22 influential and politically powerful families that have governed Pakistan since its creation & present condition of Pakistan since 1947:* 1. Bhutto family 2. Sharif family 3. Pir Pagaro family 4. Jatoi family 5. Kasuri family 6. Leghari family 7. Qureshi family 8. Tiwana family 9. Dasti family 10. Magsi family 11. Bugti family 12. Jamali family 13. Raisani family 14. Marri family 15. Mengal family 16. Gul family 17. Mashkel family 18. Jakhrani family 19. Dastagir family 20. Qambrani family 21. Magsi family 22. Lund family These powerful landowning and political dynasties have dominated Pakistan's politics and governance since independence. Many have served as governors, chief ministers, federal ministers, and in other high-level government positions over the decades. 🙏🇮🇳🙏
@Shadybillionaires
Ай бұрын
Lund family 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣.. Seriously ????
@sunala1265
Ай бұрын
@@Shadybillionaires Yes.. They (Lund/Lound) originally came from Balochistan and are now settled in Punjab, around Dera Ghazi Khan and Sindh.
Chowkidaar is the real ruler of the country since Independence !!!
Is ki waja Ye hy k hamary idary treat he is trha krty hy k Awam samjti hy k us k Sath ziadati ho rhi hy mery nazdeek is mai Awam ko ki Koi galti ni hy Wo har us person ko hero samjti hy jo presnor ho
❤
Bro who puts background music in podcasts!
Muzamil Shah is inspiration
Man ffs, it's a podcast, not a drama series. Stop background music. It's so annoying and unnecessary.
I can't take anyone seriously who greets with "slaan-laikum". (the host) But always enjoy listening to Mazammil. Man keep up the good work.
Mr. Ali Ashfaq, please stop using suspense audios in the background. It’s a thing of the past now and it used to belong to mainstream “electronic media” which you just talked about. It does nothing but disturb the listener. It has no place on KZread, more especially on a podcast.
سید مزمل شاہ صاحب ۔۔ کیا شریف فیملی سیاست میں آنے سے پہلے مالی اعتبار سے ایک نہایت مستحکم فیملی نہیں تھی ؟ اتفاق فونڈریز پاکستان میں ایک بڑا نام تھا۔۔ آپ کی ریسرچ کیا کہتی ہے۔۔ براہ کرم رپلائ ضرور کریں نوازش ہوگی۔۔
1:07 MAJ requested aid doesn't mean that the state is bankrupt, right? Usually newly formed states take loans with the intention to build it's infrastructure. Please explain on this.
No he did not pat IKE's cheek . IKE was his superior in WW II . He patted LBJ's cheek as he out ranked LBJ in WW II
Music in the background... Not only is it annoying it also Points to words this host being of a Mirasi family background. 😮
Mujamil jaisa koi nahi
1:09 Before 18th amendment and after the charter of democracy, NRO came in. It means immediately after agreeing the PPP betrayed PMLN and it is continued...
Imran Riaz favorite journalist for Syed Muzamil 😅😅
insha'Allah future president of Imran khan 💖
This guy is trying to get benifit from Muzammil's popularity and nothing more. He installed more than six ads in the video while asking mediocre and general open history questions. Either ask important direct questions or discuss complicated issues along with rebuttals and replies in search of of deeper answers/solutions. Otherwise, its not fun at least for me.
Mian Sb please try to do vlog in Urdu so that reach and understanding to the ordinary people ❤.
#CrossExamination, You should focus on Sound, I have increased volume at my pc's peak but yet I found it at medium level
Muzammil the only intellectual that Pakistan can truly boast of.
@queenmystery6389
Ай бұрын
lol
Time is over for the pakistani now time decide for Pakistan nation❤❤❤❤❤
It'd be great if you remove the background music from podcast.
♥️♥️♥️
❤❤❤❤
muzamil did not mention shahzeb khanzada of geo news, who is the top of all he mentioned are average anchors.
How mustafa khar can drive ghulam hassan on motorway in 1972???
Ye background music kyon daala hai
Aap dono Bhai aik aik podcast Engr. Ali Mirza SE karein Kisi achai topic pe.
Too long intro timing please don't repeat henceforth
Hundred % Correct , Allah Pak Pakistan Our Pakistan ki Mazloom Awaam Par Reham Farmayen Watan Aziz ko Imandar Bahadir Our Muhib e Watan Qeyadit Atta karyen , (Ameen) Ya Hayyu Ya Qayyum Syed Muzammil Shah Zindabaad ,(Salute) Mian Ali Ashfaq Zindabaad , (Salute) Pakistan Paindabaad ,
Plz stop your background music 😢 Bcz we want to listen your voices not a music
Mian Sb you are doing a fine job 👍. Like Imran Riaz Khan spread the better way of thinking ❤.
mansoor ali ki tareef kar di . . . . ab to dekhna pare ga wo kiya cheez hai.
Podcast vale bhai background music nahi hota hai podcast me. Ye bohat hi unprofessional hai
background music is too distracting
Larkio ko harass karne ka nai kaha tha judge sahab ne one-wheeling ka kaha tha
Not Agreed with Muzamil on the Pakistani Journalist names, which he taken the name, all compromised somewhere even Muzamil aswell who running a TV Show.
یہ بغض عمران کا بندہ ہے اس نے کبھی یہ نہیں کہا کہ عمران خان نے یہ کام اچھا کیا
@harismansoor5733
Ай бұрын
Or tu bughz e nawaz ka hy
Please remove thw background music
Bhai ye music to band karo! Cant listen for 5 min
Please stop this music behind
Pakistan = sayed mazzamil India = nitish rajput
When the 2nd part arrives
"you know" is 30% of the podcast So irritating to listen to
پروگرام اردو میں کریں یا انگریزی میں
I came to listen to syed muzammil, but the host has too much opinion. May be do a solo cast if you have so much to say?
@inamdurrani9259
Ай бұрын
It is a podcast not an interview
Sir you are a wonderful lawyer and you can reach people who have role in these times, so you should choose better guests ❤.
Hazoor military elites police judiciary and civil bureaucracy ye sb east India company k settle peoples hain and unki ghulaami karna in ka FARZ e AWAL hy
میاں صاحب وہ وکیل ہیں جہ جھوٹوں کے پیغمبر کو ہر مقدمے میں اسکی نمائیندگی کرتے ہیں ۔
Host looks like bhide from TMKoc😅
Too much irritating your background music 😢
15:48 lol talking about Mansoor Ali Khan where he was seen taking orders from maryam asking him to cut this part when asked a tough question, on the other side he claims that I don’t take dictations. Plus, if you are talking about mainstream media being managed (Which is true) then what are you doing on express news ? Hypocrisy at its peak!
indian media ka to aap se bhi jada bura haal he. murakh se murakh bithe rakhe hein hamare media mein.
Love from Kafir heart Jay Hind
السلام علیکم میاں علی اشفاق صاحب! دو مودبانہ گزارشات ہیں؛ اولاُ، یہ کہ پوڈکاسٹ کے شروع میں موسیقی سمجھ آتی ہے، اسکے دوران موسیقی، کانوں کو تکلیف دیتی ہے۔ ثانیاً، انگریزی زبان سے واقفیت میں کوئی مسئلہ نہیں مگر اپنی قومی زبان میں بات کرنے میں ایسا کیا عذر ہے جس کے باعث آپکو انگریزی کا بے جا استعمال کرنا پڑا؟ میری رائے میں شعوری ابتری / mental inferiority کی نشانی ہے کہ آپ کو ساختہ اور در سطح بالا / sophisticated نظر آنے کے لیے ایک غیر زبان کا سہارا لینا پڑے۔ اگر بات بری لگے، تو معذرت خواہ ہوں۔ کوشش کیجئیے کہ پروگرام اردو میں ہی رہے۔ اس امید کے ساتھ کہ "یہ آرزو اسی چوکھٹ پہ شب گزارتی ہے"۔ والسلام علیکم۔
Mai andho ke shaher me chasma bechta hu
5 wakt ki namaz ada kare or madarso me taleem hasil kare or hafiz Quran bane aameen
Muzammil is being over rated. By just reading few books of westren philosophy you cant be good analyst. No history based opinion. I haven't heard him ever telling causes of WW1&2, causes of 40 years afghan war, causes of present brutal israel hammas war etc. Ever mentioning Arnold toynbee books.
Muzzamil liying and being dishonest abt historical crimes of Jinnah. Wt a loss.
Koi aik language bolen Please
Aghr aap sirf urdu boltay tub bhi aap kay bhut views ajatay...😂
Muzammil is being over rated. By just reading few books of westren philosophy you cant be good analyst. No history based opinion. I haven't heard him ever telling causes of WW1&2, causes of 40 years afghan war, causes of present brutal israel hammas war etc. Not Ever mentioning Arnold toynbee books.
@hasnainhashmi7930
27 күн бұрын
He has actually already talked about the whole above you mentioned, you just need to watch his rest of videos.
Little knowledge is always dangerous for Muzmmil
Tikka Khan was wrongly called the butcher of East Pakistan, perhaps as part of the nationalist movement of Bangladesh where even Pathans like Yahya Khan and Ayub Khan were portrayed as Punjabis and the entire West Pakistan was referred to as Punjab. According to Hamoodur Rehman Commission Report. it was AAK Niazi who was the actual Butcher of Dhaka after he famously barked "I will change the bloodline of this bast*rd nation" and unleashed Pathan soldiers on Bengali women (according to published interviews).
Ya Muzamil khud ko Dhurvv Rathe smjhta ha. Ukat ess ki rakhi sawanat wali ha😂😂😂😂
@AJ-po4sr
Ай бұрын
App muzammil kai sub se barai fan hain. Congratulations 🎉
@Wajahat-vu4fx
Ай бұрын
کیوں کے یہ عمران نیازی کی بھی نوکری نہیں کرتا،اور نہ کسی اور کی، اور اس کی باتیں بھی حقیقت پے مبنی ہیں ،اس لیے آپ کو پسند نہیں ہو گا۔
@hamzakamyana8587
Ай бұрын
@@Wajahat-vu4fx Konsi haqeeqat election kon jeeta ha? Gov kis ki ha? Kon kabiz ha Pakistan pa kabi ess na sach bola
@Wajahat-vu4fx
Ай бұрын
@@hamzakamyana8587 بھائی آپ کا اختلاف رائے ہو سکتا ہے اس سے،مگر پاکستان میں اختلاف رائے کا مطلب گالی دینا ہے،اور رہی بات الیکشن کی تو وہ سب جانتے کیا ہوا ہے،اور سب نے بات کی ہے اس پے ،سوائے چند لوگوں کے۔
@Wajahat-vu4fx
Ай бұрын
@@hamzakamyana8587 آپ کبھی اُس کے یوٹیوب چینل پے جانا اور دیکھنا اُس نے بتایا ہے کون کیسے اقتدار میں آتا رہا ،اور کون قابض ہے۔