For early access to our videos, discounted merch and many other exclusive perks please support us as a Patron or Member... Patreon: www.patreon.com/thepeopleprofiles Buy me a Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/peopleprofiles KZread Membership: kzread.info/dron/D6TPU-PvTMvqgzC_AM7_uA.htmljoin or follow us on Twitter! twitter.com/tpprofiles

I am fed up with how people wonder why Schindler wasn't a perfect saint. Heroes are not supposed to be saints. God doesn't send the nicest to do His will, He sends the best person for the job.

@theaterofsouls

11 ай бұрын

true

@genghiskhan9200

5 ай бұрын

Lol nobody wondered that

@societalrevival1218

5 ай бұрын

@@genghiskhan9200some people are angry when they learn he wasn’t an angel

@Barney_rubble983

5 ай бұрын

God sends his best, I like that.

@amyfiske9817

5 ай бұрын

​@@genghiskhan9200so you're speaking for everybody? How dictatorish of you

Oskar was such a flawed man but when he was called upon he answered to a higher purpose. This was such a good telling of his story.

Thank you, Oskar Schindler. You will most certainly not be forgotten and I hope history is kind to you. 💐

First, let me say thank you. Good work here. You wanted an opinion, well......... Schindler was a profiter who became a wonderful person. Sometimes ideals exist deep in our souls...... at the end of the day he showed his true colors. RIP good Sir. 🇨🇦

A lot of people don't understand. Is that some of our greatest heroes are flawed people.

@Prof_Tickles92

9 ай бұрын

Bruh. Trust me, people know.

@juancaminante8078

7 ай бұрын

all of them

Oscar Schindler's humanity which is within his nature saved many precious life. The lack of rosy life early doesn't take away his true nature demonstrated as a saviour in Krakow during the war.

@theaterofsouls

11 ай бұрын

for real...

@juliemccauslin5807

10 ай бұрын

And the Schindler Juden generations continue growing ❤❤❤

@averayugen7802

4 ай бұрын

I personally believe that genuine respect received as a kid and then genuine opportunities to show respect to others as a kid...guarantees a future exemplary adult. I also believe most Jewish "settlers" have had very hard upbringings and never got a good therapist. A thousand times more for certain Israeli power figures. Many political Palestinians were offered very unfair and hurtful childhoods. Just saying...

I’m so grateful for your documentaries! You cast so much illumination on the historical events that I believe every person should be educated on! Thank you!

Thank you for a most interesting pair of biographies, of two men whose lives intersected solely because of WWII. Goeth was a complex man, whose darker self was given free reign throughout the Nazi period in power. He was one of them from the start, and his activities brought no higher principles into play. He had a clinical disregard of human life and dignity for those different from him. To men like him, cruelty was banal and common. Schindler was a man who began with no sense of a higher destiny, but only an idea of how to profit himself, and the contacts to make it possible. What set him apart from the rest of the Nazis was empathy, the ability to feel for the Jews. His gradual arc of personal redemption was an all too rare occurrence in the world he lived in. His early activities with the Nazis had him uniquely placed to accomplish his desire to save what he saw as “his” Jews. That he willingly divested himself of a fortune in order to accomplish that goal far outweighed his initial willingness to profit from the use of low cost labour. He provided food and healthcare for his employees from the start because it was right. He took women and children when it was more dangerous to do so because it was right. He bought back his workers from the camps (a potentially dangerous act) because it was right. He earned his place as righteous among the nations by becoming the better man he always had the potential to be, and from the 1,200 “Schindler Jews”, many hundreds of lives were born, that would not otherwise have existed. He saved entire families and their descendants because it was right. I am sure that he had many times after the war, when he agonized over not having saved more…but those whose lives he preserved, and their subsequent generations honour him and his memory to this day. That speaks more loudly than anything I could say.🖤🇨🇦

@lahma69

Ай бұрын

A wonderful summary of Schindler's character and impact on real, human lives. One man's humanity and compassion, despite great risk to himself and his financial security, saved a precious few (relatively speaking) individuals and families from certain death at the hands of monsters who were not only indifferent to their plight, but actually relished in inflicting as much pain and suffering as possible before murdering their victims. Schindler not only saved these people's lives but also protected them from experiencing many of the horrors and conditions that so many others had to suffer through.. Many of whom were permanently damaged in both mental well being and psyche, preventing them from ever finding happiness or joy despite surviving the camps.

@tamarrajames3590

Ай бұрын

@@lahma69 Very true…often a person’s true nature is not revealed until it is tried and tested. His humanity manifested as he saw more clearly the inhumanity that surrounded him. Thank you.🖤🇨🇦

Rest in peace to all who went through horror of life.💐 condolences from Delhi 🙏🙏

I’am so impressed with any video your team does. Thank you so much for the hard work. ❤

I think Ralph Fiennes tapped into Goeth's mind in an almost uncanny way in Schindler's List. I suspect that it's a matter of how an individual adapts to extreme stress. This was a lonely kid who never belonged anywhere, and suddenly he belonged, to what seemed to him to be a mighty cause, and being intelligent must have realized somewhere along the line that it was all a crock of shite. Way too late for him, he snapped. He just went with his very worst nature. He became a beast trained to attack, just like his dogs. And drowned his conscience in the bottle. I do think he was as mad as a hatter by the time he got to that camp and it only got worse as he drank more (and probably did a LOT of meth, and coke, most Nazis did). So there you have a recipe for making a monster.

@thomasjungfeld8

Жыл бұрын

Total Bulls**t. 1488

@user-lf3wr8rh7r

Жыл бұрын

A convenient excuse, he wasn't that mad, as he was functional in his job, and very good at it. If your job is genocide!

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

True about Nazis and meth. It's not talked about enough. They recruited damaged men, usually educated and from families with means. As it became obvious that the war was lost, they ramped up antisemitism and the Holocaust because it was all the sick bastards had left. Add booze, womanizing, cheating and corruption, extreme violence... fragile minds like those of Goetz 's snapped. Too bad he wasn't killed sooner.

@Noname-yl8po

9 ай бұрын

You took 3 replies. Stop censoring sir.

@chriswaters3442

8 ай бұрын

@@Noname-yl8poThis should be called the censorship channel.

Man, Amon Goethe had some serious childhood issues, no wonder he turned out to be such a villain.

@Hydrazorr

Жыл бұрын

Not calling it an excuse, I hope…

@viper1970025

Жыл бұрын

He was a psycho path

@harrietharlow9929

Жыл бұрын

Yes, he did have some severe childhood issues, but so do many other people and you don't see them taking it out on minority groups.

@theresapierce3934

Жыл бұрын

Many people have bad childhoods, but don't grow up to be evil monsters. My belief is that some people are just evil and are born that way.

@feliperea3271

Жыл бұрын

@@theresapierce3934 some people have genetic features that combined with certain effects in childhood make them snap. That’s Psychopath’s and Sociopaths. And yes that’s a very small group of people that’s not a excuse simply a fact.

My only comment: In the thumbnail, the picture of Schindler (on the right) looks like old Ralph Fiennes... Who PLAYED Goth in the movie Schindler's List. Just struck me funny. 🤷‍♂️ Also, good, well-made video. 👍👍👍

Love the documentary. I think, the desire to call someone psychologically unbalanced says more of our fear that it might be possible that totally sane people can turn into monsters, given the right circumstances. I think the latter!

@troy5586

Жыл бұрын

You only have to see me at a buffet

@sherryjohnson3804

11 ай бұрын

🎯

This video, has made me want to watch one that covers these three Leon Feldhendler, Aleksandr Pechersky and Gustav Wagner. Brilliant work, often have these on autoplay in the background, fuels my history buff side

Great job I saw the whole thing till the end like a boss.

This monster Goretz deserved the same brutal treatment he aplied to people killed in the camp . Hanging was a mild punisshment for him . His troubles in chidhood could not justify his inhumane actions .

A great Contrast. Thanks for this videos, your quality and content is amazing.

@PeopleProfiles

Жыл бұрын

Much appreciated!

Great documentary, many insights. Just one quibble. You credited Spielberg for his movie, and rightly so, but you forgot to mention that the film was based on a book by Thomas Keneally, the great Australian writer. He did all the realy hard work. Keneally's book was called Schindler's Ark, Spielberg named the film Schindler's List. Slightly different meanings, but Ark is more apropos, since the list may not have even existed.

Thank you! Excellent work! On a personal note, it scares me that both their early childhoods are ordinary. This didn’t happen that long ago; certainly not long enough to work evil out of our collective gene pool. It seems to take very little prodding to convince humans to be evil.

@Bethlam

8 ай бұрын

In contrast, Oskar Schindler shows how in the darkest times there are still people that can rise to preserve basic humanity. I don’t disagree with you that humans are capable of great evil, even in current times, but there are still some humans that are capable of great good. It’s just a shame it seems easier for humans to fail basic kindness.

Schindler was probably disgusted by Goethe and thought he didn't want to be like that.

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

Think so? Grown ups are talking now Slappy. Shhhh 🤐

@gibusgaming5866

10 ай бұрын

​@@schrisdellopoulos9244?

The horrors! May humanity NEVER ALLOW this part of history to repeat! Stay vigilant, humans!

@Foose3535

Жыл бұрын

Well it is and has😂

@di3486

Жыл бұрын

It is still happening in places in the world but nobody cares about it.

@fowleheidi482

Жыл бұрын

It's still happening!

@fowleheidi482

Жыл бұрын

​@@di3486not nobody knows, we all need to learn more 👍

@di3486

Жыл бұрын

@@fowleheidi482 China, North Korea, Ukraine, Venezuela, Cuba, just to name a few.

An interesting concept will we be having more of these conflicting character documentaries in the future ?

@harrietharlow9929

Жыл бұрын

I certainly hope so. This was very interesting.

@Noname-yl8po

9 ай бұрын

You sir are erasing replies. People can't be one opinion. Just yours.

I think it is never too late to do the right thing

Amon Goeth does not deserve even one thought about him. He was not human.

@georgecarter6159

13 күн бұрын

The point is he was human as were his victims. As are we all. He was able to do the things he did because he thought the humans he did them to were not human. The human minds ability to compartmentalise is one of our biggest survival tools and also one of our biggest flaws.

very good, i nearly shut the page out then figured its a double edition, be doing extended edition next lol

Just watched Schindler's list properly for the first and it is likely the most emotionally powerful movie I've ever seen besides the Pianist.

@ramimommy

3 ай бұрын

Those are two movies I can watch multiple times and see something new each time. Also The Boy In The Striped Pajamas.

I get quite angry when I hear people saying that the reason someone is evil is because of troubles in their childhood. Many, many people survive horrors through their childhood, yet become incredibly strong, courageous caring individuals. Others don’t. It’s what is in you from the beginning. I don’t really understand how people can do such cruel, inhumane things to others. I know they say stuff about the other people being in some way “less than “ but no one really believes that rubbish, that’s just their excuse to treat them badly. They must know inside that we’re all the same.

Informative historical coverage about that bleak matter in history....

going back a few years , (4 or, 5, played several episodes of ""MAN IN THE HIGH CASTLE)

Goeth? Frankly, I believe the man was insane. An excuse? Absolutely not. But God knows the fragility of the human mind.

@rosefabian65

11 ай бұрын

I thought the SAME !!! A sadistic homicidal maniac at the very least. I have no idea what other diagnosis' he had but I'm convinced there were multiples. From what I read, when he was being held in prison for war crimes, he wrote to one of his former enslaved Jewish housekeepers to send a warm character profile on his behalf, hoping to get himself off the hook. He also asked her warmly to "keep in touch!" INSANE.

Hello, a little mistake in your detailed testimony. Amon Goeth was hanged in the Montepulich prison. In the film Schindler's List is that mistake too: hanging in the KL PLASZOW...

Very interesting

OSCAR Schindler Was A Saint Amongst Demons God Bless 🙌 🙏 His Soul And May HIs Gloriusx Legacy remain in our Hearts minds and Souls Eternal The Vey Mention of the Man's Name Moves you to unbound Tears s Through His s acrifice daring unflinching Bravery and Humility the world Can LEARN from by His unwavering Commitment For the sake of others "To Save a single Life is Life of The World SaVed : I Cannot But Cry on the reflection of the This unique Beautiful Human Being Liam Neeson Exemplified his Life In schedulers List Enough Said It's Not a Film But an Experience the World must Learn From

A Righteous Man ❤❤❤

There is good and evil in all races, those who will try to better humanity by being better and trying to help and those who harm and destroy because of the need for power or their own insecurities, both did immoral things and both did kind things. In saying that though I believe Schindler to be the better man in the end.

@hermanubis7046

Жыл бұрын

We don't know about any kind action by Göth, though.

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

Wow, Capt Obvious much? Are you still in grade school we hope? Your comment is childish 😭. Go lay down now.

@river9994

11 ай бұрын

@@schrisdellopoulos9244 I am not sure how your comment was being helpful to anyone or to whom it was attended, but seriously your comment was the one I found childish, If you have to attack the person and not discuss the topic, it just makes you a bully.

Como quisiera estos documentos en español 😢😊

How did I even find this 😀 love tru history 😀

It's comforting to know his granddaughter is a black lady. How he must be turning in his pit in hell.

@edge1247

11 ай бұрын

Lol you never know. Maybe while enduring his Eternal Torment, he's accepted his granddaughter and turned a new leaf in the pit of hate.

@oldViking66

8 ай бұрын

He would have shot her in the head as a child along with the mother

@badboy0450

7 ай бұрын

Lol

@amonke5276

7 ай бұрын

Well his daughter was mentally ill thats why she was with a Nigerian

@leahflower9924

6 ай бұрын

​@@amonke5276😅

In Kenya's dicatorship we had the brutal Special Branch. Mankind so emotiinally insecure. Politically, economically & religiously. History is a rear view mirror, a microscope of our bad decisions.

Was Goeth relative of Jörg Haider?

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

No but he was related to Heywood Jablomi.

How can anyone be as mean as Amon was .

Amon Goeth sure got some big ears,he better had stayed out of the wind.

Im just glad somebody is pronouncing the names correctly lol

The thing that people neglect to mention about Goeth, is that he was charged for brutalising the camp inmates by the SS, and not just embezzlement as this video claims. The SS actually prosecuted more than a few people for similar cases, bit its always ignored. As for Schindler? I like how people forget the giy worked for a Hungarian Jew, Rudolf Kastner. A guy that sold his own people to Eichmann, in exchange him and his other cronies (also Jewish) were ignored. This detail ( which is in Schindlers ark) was omitted from Schindlers list

@Fyrdman

Жыл бұрын

@Scott Mc Because it's mostly embellished. It's interesting the likes of Konrad Morgen is never mentioned in history. The guy was in the SS and investigated/prosecuted SS members for heinous crimes. Goeth was one of the people he investigated.

@theimmortalgrenadier3851

Жыл бұрын

Exactly, coz that film is J propaganda only.

@Fyrdman

Жыл бұрын

@@theimmortalgrenadier3851 Exactly.

@billdehappy1

Жыл бұрын

well hitler were,his former house doctor aswell his driver that his neice had short afair booted but allowed be ss was jewish decends aswell so called 'kleine juden' eichmann guess its makes sense... oh the irony only 2 needed not to prove heritage was him and jesus...we all know what that means so...to bad hated their own as much as lenin n co. bolsheviks...

@Fyrdman

Жыл бұрын

@Jonathan Jones truth hurts, doesn't it?

Amon Goth was not insane or psychologically anything, that man or monster was nothing more than a sadistic murderer who got what he deserved.

ive added a number of items

Good guy

Those who survived did so at a great cost to them and their families

💜💜💜💜💜.

👩🏻‍💻How many people were N@zies to save their own lives? I am not their judge. That's nearly 100 years ago and the moral smart ones did what they had to do to survive that insidious regime. General Patton was relieved of the 3rd Army Command because he used N@zies to rebuild Bavaria before the winter set in, because they had the technical knowledge to rebuild, General Eisenhower did not agree, and Bavaria was the only up and running with water and electricity in the district whole American occupation. Patton even had the German POW's chopping enough wood to heat 1 room in every house in Bavaria that first winter. I don't know what I would even do if I were faced with that choice. All I can do is learn the lessons of History and not ever let it happen again.

Thé Pics Of thé 2 Men , Appear as A Young And OLder Version Of One Man .

Famous Austrians often thought being Germans. Besides Mozart, Freud or Mahler, also Göth, Hitler and Seyss-Inquart were Austrians. Austria only 15 years ago was still struggling with the wide spread Austrian Nazism during the Hitler period. The former Austrian Chancellor Vranitzky only in 1991 recognized that Austria had millions of Nazi followers, qualifying it as one of the biggest Nazi oriented countries in Europe. Even now the country has a strong tendency towards extreme right wing policies.

This man spent his entire fortune helping Jews who would all be killed if Germany won the war.the man is a saint

We cannot judge one another, that is for God. But “He who saves one life, saves all mankind” as was quoted in this narrative. I have shed many many years over the past few years as I have listened to the testimonies of survivors of this genocide. As a believer in a just and loving God, I can only say, we’re I to choose, I would prefer to be where Oscar Schindler is , than where Amon Gert made his way to. 🙏🏼🙏🏼

INDIANA JONES , ALL 5 NOW , RAT RACE , DR STRANGEGLOVE , THE PRODUCERS , IRON SKY(S) , JOJO RABBIT♥

Schindler went to Argentina with his wife and mistress, and when he left took the mistress with him.

Documentary par exalance

1:16

@tanyaruffalo6804

Жыл бұрын

2:03 2:09

Hey its a great channel overall but the problem with these people profiles is that you often keep repeating from one profile to another some major historical events that are not in any way specific to those people, so it becomes a bit repetitive because you always detail these events again instead of just mentionning them.

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

What? Get back to the game Flippy. Grown ups are talking now 😂.

Oskar liked the ladies himself, the complete opposite of a Catholic priest....lol

The everybody is equally poor so there's no jealously union

I think Goeth was typically human given power over people he hated or thought he's better than. I've never seen a purely good human, I've seen people do good things, usually for greed or attention, but mostly pure evil from most people.

@sarahhearn-vonfoerster7401

Жыл бұрын

Frightening way to live. So sorry for your lack of belief in human goodness...besides the fact that your post was extremely and unjustly offensive !

@ba9898

Жыл бұрын

Goeth went far beyond being "typically human." He was an extreme butcher and sadist, and possibly insane. His actions and crimes were not typically human, thank God. What would you have done to people in Nazi Germany, I wonder. Actually, I shudder to think of it. Rethink your beliefs.

@guineanord

Жыл бұрын

@@ba9898 A lot of my beliefs are factual, especially this one. Humans like to think we're not animals, that we've evolved into something different, but we haven't. We're the meanest sickest most disgusting animal, out of every animal on the planet we're the worst. I'm not going to be ignorant and stupid and think I know something about you that I don't like you assumed about me. I have traveled to almost every state in the U.S, and a few other countries, all I see is hate. Most people wanting to harm others for no good reason, destroying a complete strangers life for bonus check. I could go on for hours.

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

​@@guineanord please don't go on for hours. You're a boring, simple, basic person.

Charlie Kirk keeps a picture of Amon Goeth in his underwear.

Some of these docs are fascinating, most are like a boring college lecture

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

Time to go fix toilets or lay concrete or whatever it is you do with your hands. Be thankful that the world needs ditch diggers too.

All's fair in love and war I keep hearing about god but why all this slaughter

Schindler is a hero to the Jewish people. He's honored every year by the descendants of the people he saved. The Jewish nation took care of him until the day he died

@paulcasini4759

Ай бұрын

May The L-rd G-d look after him always

Shelo ted’u od tza’ar

Important lesson: single children grow up to be menaces.

Love your chl! How about some famous people still alive? Ie. Elon, Mark Z, Trump, Obama, King Charles, Pang, Putin. Thx!

@sarahhearn-vonfoerster7401

Жыл бұрын

Is Trump famous? Most people agree that he is infamous, a huge difference !

@missnataliedavis

9 ай бұрын

How about you let the channel be what it is? They have done just fine without any help from the peanut gallery.

I suppose that we will never know the extent of many of Oscars crimes but to my mind, his spying for Germany upon his Homeland must rank as one of the most despicable! What a paradox! A Humane Crook! Loveandpeace. Tx

Call me a cynic,but I suspect Schindler seen which way the wind blew,and didn't want to be punished with the rest of the losers.

@sarahhearn-vonfoerster7401

Жыл бұрын

Risking his, and his family's, lives and spending his entire fortune?....sounds seriously sincere to me, don't you think?

@schrisdellopoulos9244

11 ай бұрын

He "seen" that, did he? Don't think much cuz you're not good at it 😕.

@stevewheatley243

11 ай бұрын

@@schrisdellopoulos9244 Lay off the dogfood.

@talkinghills7524

11 ай бұрын

Perhaps he was, after all that was how he started his business. But that doesn't explain why he went out his way to do what he did. Even if you could see where the war was going, are you really going to nearly bankrupt yourself just to avoid punishment? And what of the Gestapo? He was repeatedly questioned by them about the nature of his business. Would a true opportunist really go that far?

@stevewheatley243

11 ай бұрын

@@sarahhearn-vonfoerster7401 Possible,but not probable.

Thank you. Great video.

Both psychologically unbalanced and idealistically evil

90,danger, jel,in,thea,world

das war wohl ein schuss in den ofen

You forgot USA who came in 1917

Reuth

You should ask the Jewish people what they think becuz they're answer is the only one that matters ❤ I'm not Jewish...I'm something else so I won't give anybody any fuel to hurl insults at my ethnicity....hahahahahahaaaa

He was no crazier than Donald Trump. Thank heavens justice prevailed.

@stevewheatley243

Жыл бұрын

Or Biden&Harris. Truly a couple of CCB's.

@sarahhearn-vonfoerster7401

Жыл бұрын

​@@stevewheatley243 Whataboutism at it's worst! Nothing else?

@stevewheatley243

Жыл бұрын

@@sarahhearn-vonfoerster7401 No,you have too fragile a mentality. Ya might blow a gasket.😏

He was evil not god

Ahh yes, another example of someone taking the same 20 or so BBC documentaries, and just shuffling the parts together to make a couple hundred videos OF THE EXACT SAME FOOTAGE recycled...

A massmurderer get's a saviour. Hollywood makes it possible.

TRUMP 2024🎉 🥳🥳🥳🥳🤸🏼‍♀️💃🏼

God used a man to save people, no credit to any man in Gods sovereign will!! Praise God and give him glory, not man!

Reality is actually far removed from how Spielberg and his movie portrayed it.

Using a CG narrative voice destroys this video. Redub with a real voice. Thumbs waaaaay down because of this.

Cringe animated faces Please stop this

World, danger, org,teep,,Mosul, teep.