There are more than 100 reasons.

@iMan-610

5 ай бұрын

Even much more

@king_sss_man

5 ай бұрын

Infinite reasons

@sasuke.7251

5 ай бұрын

100 reasons more to not convert to the ghulluw based version of shi'ism we have today I agree bro

@GDL88

5 ай бұрын

One reason to never join Sunnism! They believe the prophet married a 6 year old.

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

Give example of ghuluw? Didn’t Imam Hussain not even know that Muslim ibn Aqeel was killed. So how do you assume that shia think Imam Hussain is all controlling? All Shia see Imam Hussain as ordinary pious people appointed by Allah to guide us all. If you don’t want their guidance, go to helll. Go fare on your own. Let’s see how far you get. Inevitably you’ll be back because in the end you are absolutely nothing without the guidance of Ahlulbayt. Just look at the 11th Imam (Imam Hasan Askari) and his role of guiding Sunni scholars and the sunni caliphs. And you are so ungrateful to think the imams are discardable and are not nothing at all? And Ismali are not Muslim, let alone shia.

as someone who converted to islam from sikhism i can say for a fact shiism is very similar to sikhi the samw way the 10 gurus are viewed as godlike saint like figures to be worshipped the shias do the same with their 12 “imams” that arent anywhere in the quran let alone the hadith

@Easy_Now_Star

4 ай бұрын

Spot on bro!

@Last2LP

4 ай бұрын

Khadeer al Khum doesn’t exist ig

@user-ch6qr7sd6k

4 ай бұрын

@@Last2LP it most certainly exists but Heresy of grave worshipping and having saints like majority of the kuffar makes shiism a boring UNunique religion… what makes islam different from all the world religions is its very very strict monotheism and the zero association with partners to God the shia added 12 imams grave saints etc and made the religion boring hence why SO MANY IRANAIN ARE BECOMING KUFFAR

@user-ch6qr7sd6k

4 ай бұрын

@@Last2LP why do u shia try so hard to justify shirk? i never yell YA UMAR YA ABU BAKR or YA ALI even tho i love all three of them and habe the utermost respect

@Last2LP

4 ай бұрын

@@user-ch6qr7sd6k tawassul not shirk. We pray to the Kaaba but you don’t say that it’s shirk that we’re praying towards a cube. Stop virtue signaling

Love this channel. JazakAllah Khair for doing the works you brothers are doing. Hope you all keep up the work and post more often Bi - Idhnillah!

Love this channel

Thanks for clarifying more and more, Akhi.

Christians- Jesus is all knowing all powerful, therefore god. Shias - The imams(x 12)are all knowing all powerful, controllers of the universe therefore godlike.

@gems8167

5 ай бұрын

Yeah the imamite is similar to the papacy.

@sensei2935

5 ай бұрын

Audhubillah

@discoveringtruth594

5 ай бұрын

All knowing, all powerful but didn't know the hour and killed himself or was sacrificed by his father for his own creation because he made it that he would prefer that over forgiveness. I'm not talking about Greek mythology by the way, I was talking about Christianity, it's a different word.

@discoveringtruth594

5 ай бұрын

And then you have similar mythology existing in the shia heretical sect.

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

If this is the case then why didn’t Imam Hussain not even know Muslim Ibn Aqeel has been killed in Kufa? The imams are only guides. That is their role. Because you don’t accept them as guides you’re making up things about shia that they see Imams as god-like. Please fear the hellfire and stop my brother. Just stop. Allah’s accounting is real.

Ah brother Super Omar joined this channel nice.

Glad to see Super Omar here. 👍

Please more Super Omar videos

Happy to see Super Omar here❤

@muflihoon10

5 ай бұрын

Aint no way

@mirtalpur739

5 ай бұрын

@@muflihoon10?

Shiaism is less god centric and not focused on the prophet muhammad saw it is more focused on the imams. May Allah Swt guide them to the truth ameen.

@gr3en_jamfatima295

5 ай бұрын

Wdym? the Imams worshipped and were guided By Allah SWT and Muhammad SAW, their literally the progeny of Lady Fatimah.. They preached nothing, but Allah SWT as their knowledge came from Quran and Muhammad SAW

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

Shiism is more god centric than any other group of people on earth. Did Allah not guide us to send praises to the Ahlulbayt? Did Allah not tell us (via Prophet Mohammad pbuh) that we have to hold onto the Quran and Ahlulbayt (Hadith Thaqalyn - that all sunni scholars agree is sahih) and we hate to hold onto them tight if we don’t want to go astray?

@user-pp3gt8ch1v

5 ай бұрын

Al-Kafi isnad: I forgor

@mohammadaminsumar582

5 ай бұрын

Brother, go read Dua Jawshan Kabeer, it's one of the duas we Shias recite in the month of Ramadhan, mainly on the night of Laylatul Qadr. This dua praises Allah (swt) and attributes each of his names. This will show you how God-Centric we are.

@TheFaro2011

5 ай бұрын

And ofc we revere ahlul-bait, they seem to think that they raise it higher by omitting sahabih, and they act like we don't acknowledge the ahulul bait or we don't do it enough! So emotional.

Two most important reasons 1) Believing in tahreef of Quran 2) Believing imams superior to prophets pbut

@ytshorty2315

5 ай бұрын

you need to get out in world if you think shias believes such things.

@afrabinte2458

5 ай бұрын

Not all shias. But these are in the authentic shia Hadith. Learn your own books before anything else. May Allah guide you ​@@ytshorty2315

@ismail4900

5 ай бұрын

@@ytshorty2315 you need to get out in world if you think only zaidis and jaffaris are shia

@uthman2281

5 ай бұрын

​@@ytshorty2315 Shia are liars

@chiefz1143

5 ай бұрын

@@ytshorty2315 you need to step out of your taqiyyah bubble..

Reason #1: shirk That's all you need

@mohammadaminsumar582

5 ай бұрын

Brother, can you be more specific. I feel that lots of misinformation and misunderstanding is there about us Shias.

@aladin23

5 ай бұрын

@@mohammadaminsumar582it’s the layman Shi’is misunderstanding and ignorance in reality. We want the best for you, to be saved and turn to Allah alone. Yet your ‘Ayatollahs’ will use any deceptive lie to keep you upon the Rafidhi, Ithna Ashariyyah cult. Follow this channel and Anti-Majos and insha’Allah it will become clear. May Allah guide you.

@rifaiyassine98

5 ай бұрын

​@@mohammadaminsumar582 Shias say that they ask the graves of the pious people as mediators and the reality is they ask the graves as partners besides Allah, for example (Ya Ali help me, Ya Fatima provide for me...) That's clear shirk. And there's no verse in the Holy Quran or the Sunnah of the prophet (peace be upon him) to support this claim

@Talibros

4 ай бұрын

@@rifaiyassine98Shia visit graves to pay their homage not worship them, and there is nothing wrong with asking help from Allah through the martyrs.

@ahmedharajli189

4 ай бұрын

You can’t make baseless accusations that don’t have proof grounded in it actually being try (for example you said shias worship graves of imams, which is false unless you can prove otherwise)

Didn’t the sixth Imam Jaffer Sadiq (who taught all four sunni imams hanafi shafi hanbali Maliki) said that the Ahlulbayt are only teachers and guides. So why are you falsely saying they are all controlling? When each of the Ahlulbayt said that only Allah controls everything never ever a human being Astagfirullah. And you said Sunnis don’t accept Prophet Mohammad pbuh’s announcement that Ali is first caliph at Ghadir Khum. Can I ask what audacity you have to reject prophet mohammad pbuh’s wishes?

@muniralam1501

5 ай бұрын

What is written in Usul Kafi in a tradition is as follows: I heard Abu Ja’far (as) saying: "No one (among ordinary people) claimed that he gathered the Qur’an completely as it was revealed except a liar; (since) no one has gathered it and memorized it completely as revealed by Allah, the Most High, except ‘Ali Ibn Abi Talib (as) and the Imams after him (as)". (Usul al-Kafi, v1, p228, Hadith #1).

@yawarabass3328

5 ай бұрын

1934 in Sunan Ibn Maajah

JazakAllah'u khairan brother

Welcome to the team brother! I look forward to more vidoes from you in the future.

From where can I get Ya nasl e majoos nasheed? Pls guide me. Or any other nasheed similar to that. Jazakallah Khair.

Super Omar 😌✌️

Very interesting propositions

There was an older video on this channel listing 10 reasons not to be shia (may be by Bu Noor). Was that deleted? It was a very good video

I'm so happy

Omar joined SD. What a machine.

Great elaboration, Well done👏🏻

بارك الله فيكم جميعا

JazakALLAHukhairan

This video is more valuable than gold SubhanAllah. Jazakallah khair

The prophet's family gives everything for islam and humanity.

@user-hi5xq7nx2y

5 ай бұрын

You cling to emotions and deny the truth

@TheFaro2011

5 ай бұрын

​@Peacegermany-Mapperthis doesn't actually prove your religion

@Nader_shah-r9y

5 ай бұрын

​@@TheFaro2011 Sunnis are the biggest coward throughout The history you sunnis fear the rafidah and to till this date also you fear us 😂

@Nader_shah-r9y

5 ай бұрын

​@@TheFaro2011 this does standing against oppression This is what Islam and Ahlebait teaches us not being cowards like you

You should have added some recommended reading in the description

They made their 12 Imams into Prophets without calling them Prophets. In addition from their own books these 12 Imams do not go in public and declare their divine appointment.

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

No brother fear Allah for lying so blatantly. Do you see lies as ordinary withiut accounting? All shia see prophet mohammad pbuh as the last and final prophet of Allah. The imams are only guides nothing more.

@amjadqureshi4622

5 ай бұрын

@@B11Zero before calling me a liar you should ask for daleel. Before I provide my proof, let me ask you, do you believe Imams can receive wahi which is sent for the Ummah's guidance?

@yourfriends

5 ай бұрын

@@B11Zeroread your books

@bilalbutt8574

5 ай бұрын

Into gods*. They worship them and ascribe attributes of Allah swt to them. Audhubillah

@nyeeunfa8487

5 ай бұрын

​@@B11Zerou can refute that but without u realize u do that. U overpraise to ur imams, u call ur imams oftenly than call prophet Muhammad SAW its self. U consider that all ur imams infallible can hear u when u calling them. Remember that only Allah who all-knowing n all-hearng. Even prophet Muhammad SAW himself can't hear u from akhirah

Please make a video regarding Imam baqir and jafar as Sadiq I'm very much confused about their positions as Sunni scholars have high regards for them and if I'm not wrong they also are twelvers.....

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

Now you are on the right track my brother. Keep researching about them, you’ll revolutionize your life. And sunni shia both love Ahlulbayt. This is what unites us. It doesn’t divide us. No. But way too many Sunnis don’t look into Ahlulbayt and what a great source of guidance they are.

@syedjaffer2125

5 ай бұрын

Don't listen to this Rafidhi above, Imam al-Baqir and al-Sadiq were great men and they were Sunni by definition, all Shia accounts relating them are fabricated, just read the horrible things they ascribe to these 2 men in al-Kafi, stick to the authentic narrations about them in the Sunnah.

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

@@syedjaffer2125 You can have them too. We can share them no? But they are the 5th and 6th imams yes. Imam Baqir is the son of the 4th Imam (Imam Sajjad Zainul Abideen). And Imam Sadiq is the son of Imam Baqir. Do you see a pattern? If you ask 10 sunni guys on the street about these two, will even one of them recognize thir name? And if you ask 10 shia guys, won't all 10 of them know these two in and out. But sure if you want to say they are sunni, that even makes me happy because the love for Ahlulbayt can be the bridge that unites sunni and shia.

@syedjaffer2125

5 ай бұрын

@@B11Zero don't really care about what Rafidis think of our Imams, you have hijacked them and corrupted their teachings. We do not worship them, like you, and the average Sunni might not even know about the companions, one thing he will know is Allah and his messenger, because our focus is God, yours is the 13 demi gods you've created, never seen a single Shia cry out to Allah in times of distress, they all say "Ya Ali madad", as if Ali is capable of helping anyone, I've seen Shia say "Ya Ali madad" while getting up, sitting down, climbing the stairs, etc. it's disgusting and clear shirk.

@TheFaro2011

5 ай бұрын

Generally in my research, good guy, but like that's it. They give too much status, goes back to square peg through a circle

Very cool

Nicely described, and very beneficial lecture. Thank you and keep the great work , Sunnah Discourse!

Excellent response, and I 100% agree. But like... did you have to make it THAT obvious that your script was written by ChatGPT?

BRAVO👍

Can we debate live ?

Sunnah discourse coming backkk

@redmidigit8995

5 ай бұрын

Its needed after the hypocrisy and being exposed in the current crisis. Every sunni nation has bowed down and appeased the US and Izrael. Its a tough pill to swallow. So you need to claw back some 'victories'

Where is hani? Is it true what i heard about him

@mskpir00

4 ай бұрын

What did you hear about him?

@alifrahman5430

4 ай бұрын

@@mskpir00 he turned into a cross dresser

bros reading chat gpt word for word 3x speed 😂

Perfecto

SuperOmar! ❤

Assalam Alaykum wa rahmatullah everyone. So in short, in Shi'ism Imammah is treated as Tauheed in the Sunni Tradition. You see in Our Tradition; our literature gives emphasis of singling out Allaah in Worship. The matter is so serious in such a way that violating it makes Jannah Harram for that soul or individual. Then the emphasis of Following Allah's messenger (Sallallahu alayhi wa sallamu). Well in the messengers the matters is so serious that we cannot deny even 1 authentically proven messengers from our literature. That is also disbelieve. Our grand scholars of Sunni Tradition even considered Following Allah's messenger a part of Tauheed.

@ahmedharajli189

4 ай бұрын

What?

You are looking for the names of the Imams in the Quran? No one claims this, but Imamate principle is established through Quran and Hadith. We have specific Hadith naming these Imams. The Quran also doesn’t say the name of “the Mahdi” but all sunnis and Shias hold firm to the belief, description, and his name through Hadith. So much so that sunnis say you are not Muslim if you don’t believe in the Mahdi, but his name is nowhere in the Quran. Most sunnah is not mentioned in detail in the Quran.

SUPER OMAR 🫡

100 reasons against sunnis and shia. Only Quran

La ilaha ill-Allah 🌹☝🏻❤️

another point he is reading script on screen like a robot. doesnt prove a single evidence through out the video just mere self believe opinion. trying to brainwash the youth, sometimes these youtubers forget to read their own books and makes their own fatwa but rejects their big scholars and hides the ugly side but truth in their own books. Go watch Hassan Allahyari and see his level, he goes live every week for debates, be a man and try to debate with him. He will show you what real knowledge looks like. Not a single person has been able win against his arguments. The best muhaddith of the current era

Im shia after see this video im more shia ❤ proud to be 12ver shia

@Angelo-Rules

12 күн бұрын

​ *It is a disappointment that the mathhab that has prided itself on championing the thaqalain, have failed to uphold the greater of the two; the book of Allah (subhanahu wa ta’ala). As well as the minor thiql (as Sunnis have more narrations from Ahlulbayt).* Where is the Mushaf which the Imams narrate and transmit from each other? Where is the chain of: Al-‘Askari from the way of Al-Hadi from Al- Jawad from Al-Ridaa form Al-Kazim from Al-Sadiq from Al-Baqir from Zayn Al-‘Abideen from Al-Husien (the grandson of the Prophet) or Al-Hasan (the grandson of the Prophet) from Ali [May Allah be pleased with them all]? *Did the students of these Imams narrate everything from them except the Quran?* *If the Companions were Apostates, especially the famous ones from among them, and they were the ones that transmitted the Quran: How can a Shi’ah trust the narration of those who he believe are Apostates? This Quran that is between our hands today, is from the narration of those companions of the Prophet [May Blessings of Allah and Peace be upon him and his household].* The difference between Sunni and Shia is that our scholars unanimously agree that the Quran is not distorted you can use as many weak hadith as you want. *You won't hear any ridiculous scholars and personalities of Sunni Islam mouthing off these ridiculous things like Shias do despite the Shias being only 10% and Sunnis being majority. You'd think since there are more Sunnis you'd find more ridiculous claims like this coming from Sunnis but it is opposite.* For that reason you will find that *the scholars of Ahl Al-Sunnah are strict in this matter, and say that whoever says that the Quran is Muharaf is a Kaffir.* and they clearly declare such a thing based on what Allah the Exalted said: {Indeed, it is We who sent down the Qur'an and indeed, We will be its guardian}Hijr 15:9 Any sunni who believes that a part of Qur'an has been lost due to goats eating it or men changing it, is a kafir. There is no difference of opinion on this in sunni Islam. No buts no ifs. Your misunderstanding does not change our stance. Aisha (ra) did not believe in tahreef. Stop putting your own view on the hadith. You are just seeing what you want to see. It wouldn't have mattered if goats ate it because people memorise the Qur'an. What you're basically going to find is that this will likely lead into the topic of abrogation and abrogation was completed whilst the Prophet (pbuh) was alive. Islamqa covers this very well. Shias might attempt to steal the chains in the Sunni books and attribute them to themselves, which is pathetic and shows the weakness of their way. The fact that the Imami Shia went out of their way and try and steal a popular Sunni chain from our own books, shows that they have nothing to offer, it shows that their books do not contain a chain of transmission to the Qur’an, it *shows that they did not give proper care to the most important weighty thing, so how then can they claim that religion is only taken from the infallible when they can’t attribute their holy book to their own infallible?* `Asim bin abi al-Nujoud, Hafs bin Sulayman and Hamzah al-Zayyat are all great Imams of Ahlul-Sunnah, the Twelvers cannot prove that they were Rafidhi imami Shia neither through their books or ours. If they were to prove that they were Shia, the Shia of the time were Sunni in their worship, and even if they try their best to prove that they were Rafidhah, then even the Imamiyyah at the time had different sects all of them enemies who make Takfeer on each-other. How the Twelver Shia reached the conclusion that these two men are Imami Rafidhah is beyond me, there is absolutely no indication of this. By consensus`Asim and Hafs are two great Imams of Qira’at. The weakness attributed to Hafs is in regards to his skills as narrator, and the accusation of him being a liar is a baseless exaggeration. And if true still doesn’t strengthen Shia’s view. The rules for the authentication of a narrator in a Hadithi chain are different than the rules for the authentication of a Qur’ani recitation. Hundreds of narrations from their infallibles prove that the followers of Ibn Saba claim distortion. *and the statement that the chains of transmission of these narrations are weak cannot be accepted for reasons such as:* First: The Shiites do not consider the chains of transmission and their lim il rijjal (hadeeth sciences) is very inconsistent Second: The narrations of distortion are abundant (mutawatir) according to them, and if this were the case, their chain of transmission should not be of concern Third: There are Shiite scholars who authenticated the chains of narrations of Hadiths regarding distortion Fourth: Whoever rejects the many narrations about distortion, which amount to nearly two thousand narrations, is obligated to reject the narrations of the Imamate and the narrations of the rajah, the bidaa, and the infallibility, because as their their scholar, Yusuf Al-Bahrani, said: If these narrations aren’t accepted (i.e. the narrations of distortion), despite their abundance and spread, it would be possible to reject to the other narrations related to the religion, since the principles are one, as are the chains, narrators, sheikhs, and transmission. M. Baqir al-Majlisi also said that Shia narrations that speak of the corruption and distortion of the very text of the Qur’an area at the same level as narrations that support the Shia belief in Imamah. There are over 1000 [Shia] Hadiths confirming speaking of the corruption of the Qur’an. If the Hadiths of Tahrif in Shia books are rejected by sensible Shias, then they are no longer in any position to object why their entire collections of Hadiths should be rejected from A-Z as the same “liars” who attributed the “lie” of the distortion of the Qur’an to the Ahl al-Bayt, narrated also others “lies and exaggerations” [Imamah, Wilayah, ‘Ismah, Ghuluw etc.]. The narrations of distortion that the Shiites have are narrated from the twelve imams who believe in their infallibility, while all those who narrate the absence of distortion from him are the scholars, not the imams. They do not narrate from the imams, and not a single narration says that there is no distortion. Rather, they transmit two thousand narrations from the imams that say there is distortion, and those from whom they quote that there is no distortion are scholars who can aren’t infallible. As for the infallible ones, they quoted from them the statement of distortion, so the Shiites are required to take the words of the infallible ones and not the words of others. Nimat Allah Al-Jazairi said: The narrations that indicate distortion exceed two thousand hadiths. Then he said: He did not come across a single hadith that said otherwise. Yusuf Al-Bahrani said: However, there is no opposition to this narration, as I know, other than a mere claim that is devoid of evidence and does not go beyond mere gossip. All shias should either follow their infallibles or leave this evil religion. here is a list of references of Shia scholars: Fihrist of shia scholars and their believe in tahrif of Quran

But didn’t prophet Mohammad pbuh say there will be 12, and 11 of them will be the progeny of Ali and Fatima?

@fahadalam8322

5 ай бұрын

False hadith

@sy6553

5 ай бұрын

The Prophet pbuh said they will be Quraish, not specifically descendants of Fatimah. The mahdi will be a descendant of Fatimah RA

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

If the last of the 12 is from Fatimah, then what does that tell you about the 11 prior? My brother. Open your eyes. Please. Don’t let life long existence as a sunni close your eyes to the truth.

@mormo123hhhmohammed7

5 ай бұрын

​@@B11Zero which hadith says 11 descended from fatima?

@stuffsummedup22

5 ай бұрын

I've only ever seen Quraysh. Where did you find this hadith about them being from Ali and Fatima?

Solution Hassan Allahyari ✌🏻

Beware of shia - list of their lies 1. “Bad’ah” ALLAH tells a lie.(Usool Kaafi, Vol. No.1, Page No. 148. A Shia doctrine.) 2. All Imams are equal in rank and status to Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.s).(Usool Kaafi, Vol. No. 1, Page No. 270) 3. There are seventeen thousand Ayah in real Qur’an.(Al Shafi, Vol. No. 2, Page No. 616) 4. Sahabah (R.H) became infidel by denying the divine right (Wilayat) of Ali. First three caliph and other Sahabas became infidel by denying the divine right of (Wilayat) of Ali.(Usool Kaafi, Page No. 420) 5. All the people rejected Islam after the death of the Prophet except three. Miqdad, Abu Zar and Salman Farsi.(Quran Majeed by Maqbool Hussain Dehlevi, Page No. 134) 6. “Difference between ALLAH and Ali”.(Jila-ul-Ayoun, Vol. No. 2, Page No. 66)

When they say Ali should have been the 1st caliph after the Prophet, they directly saying Allah made a mistake in choosing the successor…

@searchforlight3288

5 ай бұрын

We do not say that 'Ali (a) should have been the 1st caliph of Rasul Allah (s), but rather that he IS the 1st caliph of Rasul Allah (s). Others claiming that position doesn't change that fact. The likeness of 'Ali (a) in this ummah is Harun (a) in Bani Israil. {And We appointed for Moses thirty nights, to which We added ten, whereby the term of forty nights set by his Lord was fulfilled. And Moses said to Aaron, his brother: 'Be my caliph [take my place] among my people, act righteously, and do not follow the path of those who create mischief.'} (Q7:142) When Allah ordered the Messenger of God, Moses (a) to go to the mountain, he did not leave them to their own devices. Rather, he appointed his brother Aaron (a) as his caliph among his people. Undoubtedly, the Apostle of God, Aaron (a) was the caliph of Moses (a). But did he rule over the people? {He [Allah] said, “Yet, We have surely tested your people in your absence, and the Samiri led them astray.” .... So he brought out for them a calf-a mere body with a lowing sound. And they said, “This is your god and the god of Moses, but he has forgotten.” And Aaron had most surely said to them before, “O my people, you are indeed being tested by this, and indeed your Lord is the All-Merciful, so follow me and obey my command.” ... He [Moses] said, “O Aaron, what prevented you, when you saw them going astray, from following me? Have you disobeyed my command?” He said, “O son of my mother, do not seize me by my beard nor by my head; I feared you would say, ‘You have caused division among the Children of Israel and have not regarded my word.’”} (Q20:85-94) Despite Moses (a) having appointed his brother as his caliph over the people, the Children of Israel abandoned Aaron, refused to follow his obey his commands and instead followed Samiri. Does this mean that Aaron was not the true caliph of Moses, because he did not exercise policital authority over them? Or that Samiri was the rightful caliph, because he did? Certainly not. 'Ali in the case of this ummah is like Aaron in the case of Bani Israil. Allah has made no mistake.

@hassans5571

5 ай бұрын

@@searchforlight3288 Ali gave Bay’ah to Abu Bakr so if he acknowledged he wasn’t the first caliph by action and word irrelevant on how long it took for Ali to give Bay’ah, who the heck are you to say he was?

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

Ali refused to give allegiance for first six months. Just reflect on this. And where is your evidence Allah chose Abu Bakr?

@madaxwayne

5 ай бұрын

@@B11Zero so he did give bayah then lol

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

For the sake of unity and under pressure. If you see the context you’d agree with Ali because it’s for the good of the ummah. Ali doesn’t care about shia - he cares about Islam. Even now we are discussing not debating. This is helping both of us become better inshallah.

Shirk is the only reason necessary but there are thousands of other reasons too

@mohammadaminsumar582

5 ай бұрын

Specify what type of shirk?

@phillipholland6795

5 ай бұрын

@@mohammadaminsumar582 Deifying Ali, and their so called "imams", among many other examples.

@mohammadaminsumar582

5 ай бұрын

@@phillipholland6795 unfortunately what you've been taught is wrong, or probably taught by someone who hates shias for whatever reasons. Firstly, shias believe in the oneness of Allah and him being the one and only God . Secondly, the imams are our role models, they help us get closer to Allah (swt) and they're our guides to achieve this goal. Maybe we can have a conversation and I can have answers to your misconceptions?

@phillipholland6795

5 ай бұрын

@@mohammadaminsumar582 If those are your beliefs, I respect you as a Muslim, but this is not what I have seen usually. If the Imams are role models and not equal to or higher than Messengers, that is also fine. But I have seen people in Iran bowing and praying to Imams photos, and even their graves. They have pictures of Ali (idolatry) and they have ceremonies where they idolize and praise him without praising his Creator. I know all Shias are not the same, but the main ones I saw doing this are Twelvers. Maybe you are from a different sect ?

@mohammadaminsumar582

5 ай бұрын

@@phillipholland6795 well not everyone's perfect isn't it? Those people that bow to the pics, they don't believe Imam Ali(as) is the God, but their love is so extreme that they do these things. I'm sure you have people in your sect that don't follow the sunnah, imagine someone judged your whole community and said you're kafir just because a few people in your community aren't following the sunnah. That's absurd isn't it?

So you expect the names of every single imam to be written explicitly into the Quran? All these signs in Quran and Hadith isn’t enough for you? Want the angles to come down and name them for you as well?

Boo 2:35 😂

@Warrior3I3

5 ай бұрын

😂

MY DAWWWGGGGG SUPEROMARRRR

chatgpt ahh polemic

@omarhashmi2390

5 ай бұрын

You cant refute him though

@omer1340

5 ай бұрын

facts, bros legit reading off of a Google doc at like 3x speed wallah what is this

By the way it is Ali A.S.

@Abd_Allah_1445

5 ай бұрын

No definitely not. Write it or copy it, not always saws, swt, a.s. and fighting with people who don’t use it.

@seanshui5909

5 ай бұрын

what?@@Abd_Allah_1445

All this hate against Shias and its all the Shia countries who are doing anything to help oppressed palestinians (majority sunni). What have the leaders of majority sunni countries done?

@Nader_shah-r9y

5 ай бұрын

Sunnis are just powerful on internet in battles they follow their Master Umar(la) who ran away from many battles

@Nader_shah-r9y

5 ай бұрын

Whereas Shias are following the way of Imam Al Hussein(as) standing with the oppressed for the sake of Islam

@Nader_shah-r9y

5 ай бұрын

These examples are fine to show Who are following real islam Shia or sunni

@skmcee7863

4 ай бұрын

@@Nader_shah-r9y Why doesn’t Iran deploy its army then?

Your video is one shows shis are on HAQ because you are denying them as a follower of bani umayya. Shias took islam direct from Rasool ALLAH where as you take your deen from Bani umayya. You can deny everything but you cannot deny the Imam Mehdi if you do it means you have no knowledge at all because all sunnis accept that Imam MEHDI is hujjat and will reappear. If deen and haq was very easy to accept abu bakar would not have chosen saqifa to appoint himself as a leader of muslims as he had no superiority over IMAM ALI a.s in any form and thats the point so called muslims deviated completely and now you have no chance in your life. After RASOOL ALLAH ALI is haq and haq is ALI accept it or not deen is not forced on you as many sahabas who lived with our prophet deviated. You cannot justify your teachings at all its a waste of time.

Please think about it properly. Allah has a unique way how He appointed the leaders or caliphs of Islam through prophet Muhammad. It is a shame sunnis failed to realized this: all leaders appointed or arranged their successor before they died except prophet Muhammad? Muhammad is not only a Prophet of God, but he was also the leader of the ummah. There is no reason he will not appoint the next leader. He actually appointed Ali but the quraish elite lead by umar dont want Ali. Umar said the arabs (he mean the quraish) will not accept the prophethood and leadership will come only from the family of prophet Muhammad. Sunnis were the victims of some elite quraish tribes in general and the arrogance of Umar in particular. Umar offer himslef as the leader of the opposition against the idea that the caliphate will also be from the family of prophet Muhammad. The envious quraish tribes rallied behind Umar.

The number 1 is worshipping Ali as God and number 2 believing in their imams being infallible

He looks like he's being held hostage۔

Script needs some improvements, didn"t work well lol😂

❤❤❤❤l

- Whether one who denies imamate of the 12 imams is a kafir is dispted among the shia, and most shia scholars will say it is not such - I think you made a mistake in assuming that the Shia way of thinking requires that there be evidence for succession of *each* imam, and that saying if they can't prove all these by direct evidence shows 12er shiism to be weak. I disagree, since Shias for one would not believe any of these men would lie since their ahadith and tafasir show they would not do that, and the lack of evidence for something is not sufficient evidence to disprove it. I am a Shia who is sort of in a spiritual journey trying to choose which path of Islam I want to take, but I just want to give some advice on how to better approach it if, according to you guys, you want to give 'dawah' to Shias. Also maybe being less hostile would help, honestly just the intro alone gets me defensive and makes me feel more strongly shia haha.

@wavez4224

3 ай бұрын

In kinda in the same situation as you and I strongly agree. Many of Sunni videos about Shia are hateful rather than trying to be informative which makes no sense if their goal is giving dawah. Another thing is that Shia will use Sunni books to prove points in Shiism and contradictions in Sunnism. However I hardly ever see it going the other way in Sunni videos using Shia Hadith, rather they use their own Sunni Hadith. Arguing from your own sources is like going to a Christian and saying “the Quran says x so you’re wrong” like it doesn’t make sense unless they accept the Quran to begin with. Similar idea here. Another thing is that I feel like there are quite a few things that are rejected not necessarily because they are false but rather because of the domino effect it creates. For example with Tarawih if they say it’s bida then it means Umar started bidas and then it leads to a whole new discussion on reliability of Umar. So rather than accepting the point they do their best to accept Umar. This is just one example but this is true for almost any topic in Nakshwani’s series like prophet appointing Ali, following Ahlul Bayt, Attack on Fatima’s house etc This just my thoughts on the divide between the 2 sects at the moment

@AhmedHassan-vo5fz

2 ай бұрын

@@wavez4224I appreciate your calm approach but there are reasons why Sunnis don’t need to quote Shia Hadith to support their beliefs. It’s because Shia Hadith are not authentic, and Sunnis quote Quran for their core beliefs, without any gymnastics. If someone just read the Quran, he would never accept Shiism and Imamah as true as there is no “clear evidence “ while there is for every core principle in Islam. And regarding Taraweeh, Umar did not start it. There are many Hadith that show the prophet prayed night prayers with the sahaba in ramadan, and even the Hadith that says Umar told the people to form one jamat, people were already praying it and no companion complained, including Ali.

@AhmedHassan-vo5fz

2 ай бұрын

You know what is strange, Shia are happy to say their imams lie”taqqiyah” and essentially be hypocritical I.e say one thing in public but say another in private. But they accuse the sahaba of the same and then curse them, come on , this can’t be logical that people better than prophets would be acting like Hypocrites.

@ahmedharajli189

2 ай бұрын

@@AhmedHassan-vo5fz do shias say the sahaba lied out of fear for their lives or do they say they lied because they wanted to usurp power? Taqqiya does not directly mean lying, that’s kadhab. Taqqiya may involve lying to conceal one’s identity if there is fear of death, but you can’t just say shias believe the imams did hypocritical things.

@AhmedHassan-vo5fz

2 ай бұрын

@@ahmedharajli189actually that’s what Nifaq is, do you think the munafqs during the time of the prophet did not fear for their lives, it’s also the same with anyone who accepts Islam because he doesn’t want to die. I am just saying the Shia are not consistent. Why would the Imams fear for their lives in preaching truths . The prophet SAW did not fear to preach truth neither did prophet Musa AS or other prophets including the ones that were killed. Even the companions, did not fear to be killed. Bilal could have been killed and many others. This is not an excuse. Taqqiyah=Nifaq.

Despite their flaws, at least the Shia try and stand up & fight for Palestine, unlike the spineless Sunni regimes.

Anyone believes Kitab al-Kafi by Yaqub kulayni is not in Islam or Muslim......Shia Rafadahi sect can't be find from Al Qur'an.

Super Omar 😂😂 the guy who got destroyed by Hassan Allahyari

Wallahi I'm happy for these videos. 1, 100 or 1000 reasons. The amount of Sunnis reverting to shia is as fast as non Muslims accepting Islam. Allahu akbar. This one reason mentioned in this video is enough to convince a Sunni to become shia if they come with open mind

@flaror3496

5 ай бұрын

Actually the evidence says otherwise.

@JuBaNmAn

5 ай бұрын

Because a lot of people are becoming misguided, that means that it must be correct??? Very odd.

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

It’s not the numbers it’s that we finally have a free and open media where truth can no longer be forced into silence. Just see Maulana Tariq Jamil (a very well respected sunni scholar from Pakistan) who said that Prophet Mohammad pbuh only chose Ali as his successor before his death. This sunni scholar is still sunni. Because truth is above sunni shia. We have to be Muslim first my brother. That is true power of Islam. If we don’t unite Allah will not give us victory in Palestine.

@syedjaffer2125

5 ай бұрын

Check Iran's statistics again, literally more atheists than shia, save your people before you come for the Sunnis💀

@TheFaro2011

5 ай бұрын

Hard to believe this one.

Ahsent

12:40 “Credible objective and universally compelling evidence”. Can such a standard be met by anything?

Yeyyy so happy to see Omar join the Sunnah Discourse Team. Alhamdulillah ☺️❤️

you dont know about beautiful shia concepts. the Hezbollah of Lebanon (Shia), Yemen and the Houthis (Zaidi Shia), Iraq and Iran (Shia) are finishing Israel's matter. Please tell the Sunni countries of Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Turkey, UAE, etc if they don't help, then don't harm the axis of resistance.

Please go slow.. can't understand your words properly

SOLOVOT

Sorry guys but their dad told them to be shia so theyre gonna be shia

I love how he is using mathematical and logical notation to disprove shiasm XD based

I have more than one reasons not to be a Shia ever

Abdullah ibn Saba, never succeeded to corrupt the last and final revelation while Paul succeeded to corrupt the teaching of Eesa/Jesus, peace and blessings be upon him. The rawafid are a poison knife at the back of this Ummah. History bear witness to this and everytime they thought they succeeded they were humiliated, may Allah guide the sincere ones among them and the rest may Allah take care of them. Ameen.

@Zaid26127

5 ай бұрын

I'm trying to study history akhi. Can you give me examples of when this happened? I'm thinking during the crusades maybe or the fatimids? Can you confirm and provide examples in history? Jazakallah khair

@sy6553

5 ай бұрын

​@@Zaid26127you want examples of abdallah bin saba corrupting or paul corrupting

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

What garbage is this about Abdullah ibn Saba. I’ve been hearing it forever. This and many rumors are only created for Sunnis to not investigate the truth about Ghadir Khum. Don’t fall for it. Investigate investigate investigate. Don’t stop investigating.

@B11Zero

5 ай бұрын

Brother we need sunni shia unity at the moment. This brother is trying to divide us by lying about shias (Abdullah ibn sabah is a myth never existed). Shiism became Shiism to defend the wishes of Prophet Mohammad at Ghadir Khum. That’s all. Nothing else. If you were alive inthe past wouldn’t you also be on the side of the shia? To defend the wishes of Prophet pbuh and not succumb to the illegal coup of Abu Bakr against the wishes of Prophet pbuh? Which side would you be on.

@Zaid26127

5 ай бұрын

@@B11Zero We need to be united upon the correct 'aqeedah. If you want unity, follow Qur'an and the sunnah with the understanding of the 3 best generations. May Allah ﷻ increase your knowledge and guide all of us

Causing division in a time like this. Shame on you. Go look at your Sunni countries that are doing 0 to help Gaza. Take a look at who is actually fighting alongside them.

@adgame0625

4 ай бұрын

So that means shias are the ones on truth?!??😂. Well, let us look at history, we start with who opened Jerusalem. Just that for now

Honestly the weirdness of their faith is, they're holding a grudge that the sahabih let go. And it's got such a Catholicism set up, middlemen, but worse, they're magical!

@redmidigit8995

5 ай бұрын

Riding on a horse with wings and a human face to 'heaven' and creatures made out of fire that can see humans and change shape and posses also seems pretty magical. Whats the yardstick then..

@omer1340

5 ай бұрын

it's important because it's disproves righteousness of the sahaba and the misdeeds certain "sahaba" did, we aren't just obsessed with them for no reason, especially considering majority of Muslims are unfortunately following misguided "sahabas"

Reason 1 is shirk