Mr. Bhardwaj's humour is just like his films. Easy & Dark... :D He is such an Amazing Director & storyteller.

@vimalsinghbisht6951

7 жыл бұрын

Shetty's films would not give amazing cinematic experience but they can surely make you rofl. Great Entertainer.

It's so sad that none of Vishal's films made money because he is genuinely the BEST filmmaker on the panel. Yes he's made some duds, but Maqbool, Omkara, and Haider were amazing (I can't remember Kaminey unfortunately). Even Hollywood hasn't adapted Shakespeare so beautifully yet.

@Jaankari

7 жыл бұрын

Absolutely. Certainly the MOST brilliant filmmaker in India as of now. He didn't make any dud. 7 Khoon Maaf and Matru Ki Bijlee Ka Mandola had a lot to offer, but they weren't that accessible.

@vasanthrathod1910

7 жыл бұрын

Jaankaari haider is the best !!!

@krishnenduchakraborty2839

7 жыл бұрын

Kabali Da! vishal's all films are commercially and critically successful.That's why he is one of the successful filmmaker in mainstream hindi cinema!!

@tweetyburd8046

7 жыл бұрын

errr... did you not watch the interview?? vishal literally just said that his films all have made zero profit. they're all flops or have just broken even. that's not commercial success buddy.

@krishnenduchakraborty2839

7 жыл бұрын

Kabali Da! Bro go to Wikipedia and see his films box office record.You can see his all films are made with medium budget but they are all commercially and critically successful.Maybe here he jokingly said this,I don't know.His track record amazing.He is successful filmmaker that's why UTV produce his films otherwise UTV aren't produce his film.He is a mainstream hindi cinema's filmmaker but he made different type of film that's why he is genious!!!!

I loved the classic 'maqbool' by Vishal Bhardwaj. This movie is gonna be eternally loved by future generations to come.

Vishalji and Rohit are honest filmmaker

Respect for Vishal. He's awesome but unlucky at the box office. And also Rohit for the honesty. Shoojit was surprising cause i love his movies. Felt he would have a lot to share but he didn't.

vishal seems the most intelligent men on this panel..

@ramkapoor4609

4 жыл бұрын

Priyanka Verma ...he IS.....

@SagarKumar-wz4qd

3 жыл бұрын

He is genius....

"Golmaal Again was A Crap": Rohit Shetty, never seen any director being so Honest Abt their work. Respect

@personalsecrets6905

4 жыл бұрын

It was Golmaal returns...

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

Bro he doesn't really care about cinema only box office matters to him

@onebitstory

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-fk8md4jn3i There are very few who care about the Cinema and Generate revenue. SS Rajamouli , Sanjay L Bhansali, Raju Hirani, etc are few names who win at both ends.

@onebitstory

3 жыл бұрын

@@personalsecrets6905 leave the 1st one out & nearly all are crap 😂

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

@@onebitstory yah but there is large number of ppl who genuinely care about cinema vishal,anurag,vikram,zoya,shootjot r fine examples

Vishal's humour..... Omg... He's on fire

This is so far better than this years directors

@K.A.S.H

4 жыл бұрын

Completely agree

@sandykhp

4 жыл бұрын

lol u r right the panels more entertaining

Logic may take over, but always give preference to the emotion. - Vishal Bhardwaj

2 years later and the questions remain the same 😒😒😒😒. Came here after watching this year's Mami directors meeting

As always, Rohit Shetty being his honest self. Have never seen him being fake and thats what makes me love him more for the person he is. His films are such fun, no matter how I feel I'll watch any of his films and I feel happy. He entertains the best for me.... And his honesty shines through his films. Love you Rohit always

@PraveenKumar-pj3cy

4 жыл бұрын

Truee❤

@sanghamitragautam3325

3 жыл бұрын

His movies are therapeutic, like andaz apna apna his movies are fin , no brainer and love watching them after a long exhausting day , it just makes you laugh,

Vishal sir is a legend👍😙

Vishal & Rohit r too funny

Didn't realize Vishal was so funny!

@prajwalsharma248

6 жыл бұрын

He wrote ishqiya, dedh ishqiya, matru ki bijli ka mandola..!!

My favourite Rohit Shetty sir😎😎😎😎😎

The guy who made " Maqbool" thinks , he is same like these directors, brother, please , with Maqbool, you made HISTORY. there are lectures about your movie and " parinda" in our classes.

@Cinemaheals

6 жыл бұрын

lectures based on a movie copied off shakespeare congrats

@prajwalsharma248

6 жыл бұрын

umar ali copy nhi kehte use,jnaab, its an adaptation of Macbeth.

@datsrohan

6 жыл бұрын

+umar ali then GODFATHER is too copy coz it is based on Novel of same name. Adaption & copying/remaking is two different thing.

@kriyato1

4 жыл бұрын

@@Cinemaheals just like your parents copied your name from a Mahabharat charecter.

@meghnasaha4349

4 жыл бұрын

@@Cinemaheals adaptation kehte hai dumbass. Unlike most other directors he credits his source

Super Rohit Sir

Vishal Bhardwaj and Shoojit Sarkar are Gems

This discussion was extremely educating for a small filmmaker like me. Loved every bit of it. Such beautiful people with beautiful work and each with a mind of their own. Thank you MAMI..

Wow !! This is what talent and taking your own path looks like ..Vishal Bhardwaj is a gem ..he may never had the hits other folks in the panel had but he was the one who ruled this panel...Guy does not even has to boast about the box office ...and when he said all his movie failed , all the other successful directors realized would that hit count even matter :-)

This clearly demonstrates why Vishal bhardwaj is a phenomenal, exceptional from others.

Vishal Bharadwaj and Rohit Shetty are absolutely adorable.

i heart vishal bhardwaj.

Big fan of Vishal sir and Shoojit sir. We need more directors like them.

Plz like this video only for Rohit Shetty and Vishal Bhardwaj both of them are gems of Bollywood 🔥🔥🔥

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

Rohit shetty is no where near a gem

Rohit was so candid..

I love the whole panel of directors. This interview is a crash course for aspirants. But what I liked the most is honesty when Rohit Shetty told that Golmaal again was crap and Vishal Bharadwaj said none of his movie made money so far. It needs guts to say it by the way, in front of crowd

great set of interviews guys...good show ..

I'm amazed to see that No one is mentioning Zoya Akhtar .I mean I really love her movies and would love to meet her some day and have a conversation. This is my dream

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

Mine too Freaking love her

@saisresthdas1519

3 жыл бұрын

Same here

Joya is really confident and strong both individually and in her craft..

@adityaramachandran2852

4 жыл бұрын

Finally someone all praises for the super talented Zoya Akhtar

vishal n shoojit r good as their movies

Vishal Bharadwaj superb! Great panel

Loved listening to Shoojit Sircar, Vishal Bharadwaj and Rohit Shetty. Their eclectic and wide life experience reflects in their conversation. Lesser said the better about Zoya Akhtar.

@ramadevigokarla625

3 жыл бұрын

Same feeling mate Zoya is fine for me but the other female director is annoying

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

U really prefer a crap like rohit over gauri and zoya Lmao

Shoojit is saying film is not his first love still making some the Best films of Bollywood

Vishal Bhardwaj is ICONIC

SHETTY ANNA KILLING IT LIKE A BOSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Missed Anurag Kashyap here.

Here for Bharadwaj Sir. Love his work P. S. Expected better questions though 🙁

Have worked with Shoojit for an ad film for one of my brands.... I agree with two of his confessions: he doesn't take stress.. very chilled out and he wraps up his shoot in the evening ...and sleeps early

@subharanshumukherjee9799

6 жыл бұрын

Vineet Chugh j

I don't like Rohit Shetty's movies, but he is honest, self-aware and he closely listens to everyone. He is like Micheal Bay of our industry. Underrated.

calcatta and creative,,,,,,wahh satyajitray,bimol roy,dibakar benarji,sujjit,aporna sen sharma,,,,,,

Awesome directors - gave us some great movies. my favorite here is Rohit Shetty - hes just so awesome

Really enjoy this; I'm a new fan of Bollywood and these type of platform open my eyes to that world.

I was fan of all of the others on the panel , But Rohit as an individual stole the show here and made me his fan.

@3:00 no we have not looked up and gone through it.... and that too rohit shetty’s filmography.... man how I wish I was a “Rajeev Masand level welaa.” Although in this case it is a good idea for Rajeev masand to do.... anything that is going to keep him busy and no time is left to write another one of his brilliant gems of journalism “the blind articles”

Rohit 💋💋💋💋💋💋

Rohit Shetty is the best director in the world 💐💐

@harshbhosale8720

3 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 u can be a comedian ....

@thilakkumar8739

3 жыл бұрын

@@harshbhosale8720 it's a fact dude, go and google

@harshbhosale8720

3 жыл бұрын

@@thilakkumar8739 I think his films say morr than Google .... 🤣🤣 To a person like me who watches Anurag Kashyap and Martin Scorsese it's hard to believe that Rohit Shetty is nice director ...

@thilakkumar8739

3 жыл бұрын

@@harshbhosale8720 ya thats y Rohit Shetty's films are making very good business worldwide & he's currently the most wanted & no 1 director in Hindi movies dude. Each & every has different taste dude.....not necessary that everyone shud like a particular director. U mentioned anurag kashyap....I'm not a fan of anurag kashyap but I respect his work. Same goes with Rohit Shetty....almost all his movies are blockbuster & people all these years aren't watching his movies simply....they like his movies and we need to respect every one

@harshbhosale8720

3 жыл бұрын

@@thilakkumar8739 no 1 director yes in commercial bollywood cinema ... But that's not real cinema ...

Anupama: Rohit, do you blow up another car if youre tempered? Rohit: You know what I'll remake 'temper' without blowing up cars and you'll eat your words. Just kidding. Love his films. They provide wholesome entertainment for a change. Waiting for simmba

Feeling so sad for vishal sir 😞.

Sanjay Leela Bhansali and Raju Hirani... Most loved directors are missing on this panel 😵

Only Vishal was answering intelligently & intellectually

Sunday is worser then Golmaal returns 🙏🙏

wtf ?? vishal's films didn't make money???? unbelievable. ..I love his works especially harder,omkara,and eagerly waiting to watch rangoon

where is the full video?

🎬🎥

Vishal Bharadwaj > Soojit > Zoya > GauriShinde >>>>>>>>>>>> RohitShitTea ( except for his 1st Golmaal, which, btw for me, is among the best comedy films I hv seen)

49:13 Vishal Sir very funny person and Rohit Sir too

Can someone please let me know the names of the makers Shoojit mentioned at 32.55

@aniketchatterjee6308

7 жыл бұрын

Satyajit ray, Ritwik Ghatak, Bimal roy

@socialcasm5995

7 жыл бұрын

TEKINA ANI thanks mate.

@aniketchatterjee6308

7 жыл бұрын

you're welcome..

Pre-fame Renil spotted at 13:05 :D

All are the baap directors 👍

Rohit Shetty is most honest man and best among all.

Hot day in Mumbai Bihar ja ke aao kabhi.

I am only here for vishal bhardwaj

3:00 That’s Abhishek Bacchan….Rohit didn’t like his acting at all 😂

Rohit just hates critics isn't it?

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

He only cares about box office

SHOOJIT SARCAR JUST SAID IT PERFECT ! ALL THE GREAT FILMS INDIA CAN MAKE HAVE ALREADY BEEN MADE BY INDIA'S GREATS .. AND THE WHOLE WORLD ALREADY KNOWS ABOUT IT .. THESE ARE ALL JUST PEOPLE HAVING NOTHING BETTER TO DO AND JUST GOING ABOUT IT FOR EMPLOYMENT REASONS DATS ALL !! .. THE MOST APT STATEMENT MADE ABOUT INDIAN FILM INDUSTRY AND ESPECIALLY THAT BOLLYWOOD WHICH IS ONLY GOOD ENOUGH FOR PROPAGANDA NOW NOTHING MORE. LOLS

Anurag kashyap is not here....why

I have registered for mami for the first time in life. So far, pretty disappointed with the Ticket booking system. nothing has been available in the last three days even if i tried at 9 am in the morning. If anyone can suggest how to make sure....

@DivyakantPandya

4 жыл бұрын

You have to book at sharp 8. Specifically login at 8 and be as quick as you can. It's first come first serve system and others do it so obviously there won't be any available for 9. There's nothing wrong about system. Login at the correct time and be faster and you'll surely get it. I'm booking all 4 what I want most of the time. All the best.

@DoveSharma

4 жыл бұрын

@@DivyakantPandya yup, I figured it out on the 3rd day. Now I wake up at 7:45 and keep refreshing the page 😁

3:0 Rohit Shetty not work again Abhishek so probably he was

So.... The discussion is flooded with applause for one man "The Director of Shakespeare's Trilogy" (I dont take his name is respect like I dont take names of my parents)...but then his films don't make money.. Is he good enough for India to be on discussion panels and inspire film schools while you guys watch films like, kick, dabang and singham. and their sequels upon sequels.... Its heart breaking that your cinema going behavior is discouraging new comer film makers to be Sir (The Director of Shakespeare's Trilogy), Shekhar Kapur, Anurag Kashyaup, Sudhir Mishra, Mani Ratnam and many of this ilk.

Joya akhtar is like benafsa sonawla.

Vishal Bhardwaj

In terms of Best director Vishal > Shoojit > zoya > Gauri > Rohit In terms of Best commercial director Rohit > Zoya > Shoojit > Gauri > Vishal

@ramadevigokarla625

3 жыл бұрын

Bro I Rohit is much better than gauri any day Not a fan of his work but I hated dear zindagi

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

@@ramadevigokarla625 stop this nonsense Gauri has great films like dear zindagi, English vinglish while rohit shetty has crappy cinema

12:05 I think that’s Abhishek Bacchan cause in kwk Rohit seems really irritated by him 😅😂

How many movies did Gauri did..? It is a genuine question..

@anushapurohit5680

4 жыл бұрын

Two films.

I agree with the chappal rule. They're way too casual

Anupama Chopra’s laugh is creepy

May b I think that's Abhishek who take 37 takes ....😂

@abhishekkumarthakur4266

4 жыл бұрын

Hope sooo nice thought

@vazs26

4 жыл бұрын

That was Sanjay Mishra is Dilwale! You can see the "making of" of the movie for knowing that.

@rishi095

4 жыл бұрын

Maybe Fardeen Khan

Aisa kuch nahin iinka jo pehla show maine dekha tha woh khatron ke khiladi aur tab main bhot darti thi .

Rohit to chchhaya hi hua h. Nishi makes very good films and Vishal Bhardwaj is also amazing And even all are good Never mind the film's collection but they make very very good film. And ma'am Anupama Chopra you laugh unnecessarily

Confession of the sinners.

When you do conversations in your own language automatically the conversation becomes more powerful, impactful, and beautiful nevertheless I don't know why the Hindi film industry is practicing the UK or the USA language for their Hindi audience. Be original and stay with your own language proudly if you want to make something incredible. Hindi ki baat hi kuch aur hai boss.

Rohit you'll just blow up a car if you're in a bad temper' - So aptly sums how insignificant and braindead some people's cinema is, validated just by box office. Thank you Anupama Chopra for so jokingly making such a truthful remark.

1) Anupama Chopra continously smiles and laughs. It is so annoying. 2) Rohit Chopra is formulaic film maker. He has no clue on art of film-making. 3) Zoya Akhtar and Gauri Shinde are pretentious directors. They survive on making buzz on their movies 4) Vishal is rare gem. He deserves to be there. 5) Shoojit knows his craft like none other.

Rohit Shetty here... But why

The audience is full of teenagers 🤔

Is Gauri shinde actually a director? She doesn't know anything about directing!!!

@ripulvig5260

4 жыл бұрын

But she has made a fabulous movie called English vinglish

@javierdecius5076

4 жыл бұрын

Ripul Vig and Dear Zindagi

@MoreFriesplease

4 жыл бұрын

She a great director. Films and ads.

some of the questions were really stupid...like they asking Rohit that do you like action and all...come on, that's his background so obviously he likes it..Plus some other questions also

Anurag Kashyap hona chahiye tha

WHAT THE FUCK ARE THESE QUESTIONS!!! Ask them something about movies not their daily routines and how many times the take coffee.

WhAts rohit shetty doing in this great filmmakers

What is Rohit Shetty doing there

Even though some scenes of Rohit Shetty's movies were crap, I would still rate comedy movies as - tough to make. You can easily make someone cry or think, but no matter how much you try, no ones going to laugh if the comedy is not good. On the stage I see that there is a sense of over acheivement on the faces of Shoojit, Gauri and Zoya. As though they feel Rohit doesnt deserve anything or he must be sorry for his work. Dil Dhadakne Do was an utter crappy stereotypical over-the-top display of family drama. And still she gets to feel proud of it! Bullshit. I might not like few of his movies, but some of the Golmaal stuff was awesome. So he deserves some appreciation too.

@sudhangshudas3099

6 жыл бұрын

thiruvetti But Rohit Shetty's Golmaal, Golmaal again and Chennai express are really hillarious.

@saiashwin26

6 жыл бұрын

I dont like his movies but i agree that the elitist mentality exists, i mean even he knows he isn't making high art

@adityaramachandran2852

4 жыл бұрын

Zoya Akhtar is one of the finest directors of this generation and u criticizing Dil Dhadakne do and praising Golmal shows a lot about you and your brains .IDIOT

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

Seriously rohit over zoya guys go get some brain

@thiruvetti

3 жыл бұрын

@@adityaramachandran2852 So you think comedy movies like Golmaal are easy to make.. 😂😂😂😂 But DDD, which was just run-on-the-mill rich bollywood story was better. Even biggest of Hollywood directors have accepted making Comedy movies are the toughest. So try talking some sense. Do you even know about comedy timing???

Isn't Farhan's sister Indian ? Why is she telling Indians this and that as if she is foreigner :-)

two of the most non-talented people (so called movie critics ) are interviewing the most talented people in industry .

Anupama ji aap kripya kam hasiyega.

18:00 Whats wrong with Chappals?????? Steve Jobs used to go barefoot to his office...... I LOVE CHAPPALS...FU

Rohit shetty is the only brilliant guy there. Others are knowledged but not intelligent to understand common sense of human to get entertained.

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

Are u fr??rohit is the dumbest one here He doesn't deserve to share stage with these geniuses

@personalsecrets6905

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-fk8md4jn3i that's what am saying others are genius he's brilliant. They do art he does entertainment

@user-fk8md4jn3i

3 жыл бұрын

@@personalsecrets6905 they make masterpieces he makes trash cinema

@personalsecrets6905

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-fk8md4jn3i one man's trash is other man's gold. They make masterpiece and their cinema is for them. While Rohit films are for mass audience unlike the highly educated and who wants enlightenment instead of entertainment in cinema. Others make movies for themselves and Rohit make movies for audience that's why his movies are collecting more money than others.

@harshbhosale8720

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-fk8md4jn3i I agree with you

Zoya can't just say " the Indians are always throwing litter", what do you by that huh....maybe some do this or many but not everyone...so take care of that when you say ....