Patreon: www.patreon.com/classicaltheist Twitter: twitter.com/classicaltheis

@CyberFenix000

3 жыл бұрын

I was just thinking about Societas Perfecta!

We live in a society Classical Theist: Yes, but what IS society?

@littlesaintwilliamofnorwic8500

3 жыл бұрын

As Aquinus teaches us, Bottom text

You seriously need to make more videos.. You're always reaching the highest level with these and that doesnt happen very often on KZread anymore. Thanks, man and God Bless!

Every time I see "Medieval Popery" in the intro I crack up. It's as if it were a much discussed and hotly contested subject matter. hehe

@patrickgallacher9478

3 жыл бұрын

What is medieval popery?

@fiveadayproductions987

3 жыл бұрын

@@patrickgallacher9478 Medieval doctrines, practices, and ceremonies associated with the Pope or the papal system in Roman Catholicism.

Interesting, thanks. The volume however was very muted. Perhaps your further discussion might be presented a little louder. Thanks anyway

@Meshuggapeth

3 жыл бұрын

I have my headphones on 30% and I can hear

make more of these please cozy needs it

Very Based take. As usual I can rely on Classical Theist to make superb content on KZread, and absolutely epic responses on Twitter. Makes me want to do similar things.

Without watching this video I can safely say that something I vaguely remember reading about Catholic Social Teaching one night while drunk said that Jesus wanted gay marriage.

@dannybecker1241

3 жыл бұрын

Based

Nice introduction, was hoping you'd delve into Catholic Social Doctrine. A video/series on Grace would be epic expounding Catholic teaching (not just addressing critique). Especially created/uncreated grace; subjective/objective redemption, causa formalis, materialis etc and the divisions of grace: - Gratia Dei (Creatoris)-Gratia Christi (Redemptoris) - Gratia Externa-Gracia Interna - Gratia Gratis Data-Gratia Gratum Faciens. - Gratia Habitualis (sanctiticans)-Gratia Actualis - Gratia illuminationis - Gracia Praeveniens - Gratia Sufficiens And the principle errors of Pelagius, The Reformers, Baius, Jansenius, Quesnel

Integralism is based, but most integralists on twitter are cringe.

@johnalveraz9344

3 жыл бұрын

Often its a front for leftist to to say that their beliefs are compatible with CST

@tr1084

3 жыл бұрын

Cringe is a consequence of the fall and is inseparable from being on twitter.

This video was so good no one dislikes it.

Though I don't agree with the interpretation, I understand why some Orthodox believe in the tollhouses because, though you may have a state run by the church, do you have citizens whose hearts are run by the church? Who is to say that some of these seemingly upstanding individuals won't drop the facade the moment temptation is given? I'm excited to see more of these!

is "In Taberna" podcast cancelled btw? been so long since the last episode..

Just curious as to when the rest of these videos will come out? I'm very curious

¡Viva la Falange! José Antonio ¡Presente!

Any chance of getting your content into podcast form?

@ClassicalTheist

3 жыл бұрын

I give all the audio files to my videos as part of the patreon deal

Can you translate your video for French Public?

Does Catholic integralism describe an economic model or a form of government?

@zoomervince2457

3 жыл бұрын

Both

@ClassicalTheist

3 жыл бұрын

We’re certainly going to get to that!

@zoomervince2457

3 жыл бұрын

@@BamBoJam Distributism

@camperiv1

3 жыл бұрын

Neither. Integralism can have both different economic models and form of governments.

@account2871

3 жыл бұрын

@@zoomervince2457 I feel that distributism is going to be the natural free market progression in response to automation. In a way it's already happening with 3D printing.

Integralism?! I thought only in Brazil we had this Ideal.

@imatomato6402

3 жыл бұрын

Lusitanian integralism, the variant particular to Portugal, was labeled as "National Communism" by Antonio Salazar, which should go to imply it doesn't refer to a singular thing.

Have you read Heinrich A. Rommen's "the state in Catholic thought"

You need to increase gain please. Info is good.

Hey, I understand that this type of thing is really important, and I want to learn about it, but I am very uninformed on the subject and these videos do not help purely because I do not understand the words/concepts spoken of. How did you learn so much as to understand these videos?

@michaelnelson3652

3 жыл бұрын

Here are some beginner resources that come to mind: classicaltheism.com - lots of beginner podcasts that on philosophy, church teaching etc. aquinas101.com (and on youtube) - good video series on St. Thomas Aquinas edwardfeser.blogspot.com - Ed Feser's blog has a bunch of content and you can use the search function in the upper left hand corner to look up various topics (integralism, divine simplicity etc.)

What's with the wacky trance music in the background?

When's the next EMJ interview?

Thomas Crean just recently did an interview about his book. Here is the link for those interested: kzread.info/dash/bejne/fmF10dd7kayrk9I.html

Thank God for the Catholic third position 🕊️❤️☘️🙏

So you think its a good idea to reintroduce a kind of Papal imperialism that was one of the reasons for the collapse of Christian faith in the first place?

In this series, could you talk about how a Catholic integralist would view the Inquisition? The abuses of the Inquisition are often brought up as a reason why some people think Catholic integralism is a bad idea.

@zoomervince2457

3 жыл бұрын

We don't have to defend ourselves from an event that happened 500 years ago

@ConciseCabbage

3 жыл бұрын

Zoomer Vince - if it’s a direct result of the ideology that you promote, yes you do. Because it would happen again under the same ideology.

@camperiv1

3 жыл бұрын

The Church did not torture anyone, it was the State. The Church in a way protected the accused and tried to prove their innocence

@carsonianthegreat4672

3 жыл бұрын

C S , it’s really not

@aesop1451

3 жыл бұрын

But no one asks classical liberals and Protestants to defend their system and all the problems they've caused.

We must bring about a New Jerusalem on earth

I suspect you may want to re-evaluate your idea of Vermuele's politics...

@Vloke6

3 жыл бұрын

Why?

Only one contention: the implicit anthropology seems off - man's given virtues contradistinct from how they are in a social scene is a totally meaningless object of political thought because there was no pre-society from which human social orders emerged. We have always lived within social orders of some form or another - we have always had authority and sociality. Humans have never existed without partnership or without some social object of highest shared significance - some common good. However, Vitoria's argument could and should be employed against the likes of liberals and anarchists who take this state-of-nature as some intrinsic good or more fundamental mode of human social organisation. Though, these faulty anthropological assumptions don't seem to be very critical components of Integralism.

Catholic integralism sounds like rebranded Darwinistic humanism. We’re all a bunch of animals and to preserve ourselves and our species we need to form societies. I have heard this verbatim in biology and mythology classes.

@bbseal6174

Жыл бұрын

I suppose you can point out a few commonalities but the moral system motivating integralism is nothing similar and so it comes to vastly differnerent conclusions. i don't see what you mean.

Hey didn't you say recently that you'd be uploading more frequently? What gives?

I’d love to talk to you sometime about political philosophy on my channel. Would you be interested l?

Your video on how Vatican II was never meant to be infallible and was only “pastoral” (reconciling V2) was absolutely DESTROYED by the Dimond Brothers video: Was Vatican II infallible?

@FirstNameLastName-is6yb

2 жыл бұрын

No, it wasn't.

I dont think these claims are controversial to any Christian or at least informed Catholic. What I think is controversial is the part in which heretics start being burned and crusades being called. I mean, if this is integralism, then all Catholics are integralist by definition. But obviously what people have in mind when they think of integralism is a sort of authoritarian government where people's conscience is not respected and faith is imposed by force. I think that is the controversial part.

I can't concentrate on what you are saying because of that horrible sound in the background

@camperiv1

3 жыл бұрын

Spyro soundtrack is trademarked CT