Hey look who’s upping the production value!

@markt43

3 жыл бұрын

At first, I thought you were being glib about the webcam quality.

@triopsate3

3 жыл бұрын

Oh hey, it’s science thor.

@williamfrick8350

3 жыл бұрын

You should play some more EDH with other youtubers, I still cherish your Windgrace gameplay.

@jaydub5515

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed, that's science!

RIP post-game talk, you will be missed.

Love the changes, but I'm kinda missing the end game wrap up and the MVP card.

@LethalPigeon7

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah I'd much rather have that than the statistics, though both are good. Having both would be ideal, but I mostly just miss the MVP segment.

@nimenpalac454

3 жыл бұрын

Yes I hope those come back

@slothe111

3 жыл бұрын

Actually I like the stats, can we have both?

@LethalPigeon7

3 жыл бұрын

@@slothe111 Yeah noone in this comment chain is saying we shouldn't.

@Orelusz

3 жыл бұрын

Same I was expecting the wrap up and the MVP segment. It gives you a better oversight of the match.

I love that changes have been made to make sure PwP doesn't fall behind in style, but I would like the after game recap again, also I liked seeing artwork of the cards in opening hands. I recognize cards more by artwork than by name

@artemoila1

3 жыл бұрын

agree. much faster to recognize cards from the artwork, that is why I dislike extreme alterations that obscure the original art.

@spencerstanley4759

3 жыл бұрын

@@artemoila1 I'm okay with like, alternate frames and full arts of cards, since if they're meta cards you'll end up knowing both artworks. But I'm assuming you despise the new Modern Horizons 2 artworks? The ones where it's just sketch art, so you can't see what you're looking at?

@artemoila1

3 жыл бұрын

@@spencerstanley4759 alternate frames are fine, as long as the artwork is visible. I don't like the new sketch artworks for two reasons actually. The important one is the one we are talking about but I just like the colorful art anyway, personally

@spencerstanley4759

3 жыл бұрын

@@artemoila1 I agree fully, like the alternate lotus cobra from zendikar rising for that exact reason.it's pretty and hypnotic. I actually liked all of the zendikar alters because of the sharp corners of the frame.

The new changes look very snazzy, but showing the opening hand in a pile makes it harder to tell what each card is at a glance

@slowaltima

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed, I liked the old way better because you could easily see what was in hand and what was the mulligan

A little odd not hearing your post game recap but I'm digging the changes.

@slowaltima

3 жыл бұрын

I love the post game recap and most valuable card.

@chrisclark9371

3 жыл бұрын

I also missed the game recap. I like hearing the mvp of the match.

Congratulations for Folger for the win. He manage to stay vigilance amidst the heavy stack and disruptive piece in the boards and keep constant pressure with Najeela ability to threaten the boards with army of soldiers. The most valuable cards is without question the Storm Cauldron. The tax of returning lands everytime you tap it for mana manage to slow the boards heavily and stop many strategy to storm off.

Who else thought back to that one game with all the misplays with Ashiok when he was in Stephen’s opening hand?

@dimitriosdoulgeris4659

3 жыл бұрын

The April Jokes episode was hilarious.

I literally am on this channel like crack, this content is the best when it comes to cEDH. The production value and voiceover is miles ahead of your rivals. Keep doing what you do

Here's my feedback to the changes: Love the new intro, the production quality is great and the music is honestly better than what you have always used in your videos PLEASE make all 7 cards in a player's hand readable. This was a problem in your older videos too; watching this channel introduced me to a lot of cards I had never seen before, so being able to actually read what they do when seeing a player's opening hand is vital. While I would prefer to keep the discussion of the Most Valuable Card and Most Valuable Player, I don't think its absence was too missed for me. Definitely keep the statistics slide at the end of the video, I love it! Overall I'm really digging these changes to the show, I would just highly, highly recommend going back to showing the textboxes of all 7 cards in an opening hand

Kodama/Sakashima always feel so close to going off and then it just doesn't :( love seeing the deck, though

@Savage_Mr_Bean14

3 жыл бұрын

Easily couldve at 6:50 if he wouldve searched a field of the dead with expedition map. Instead he much later tutors an inventors fair... :/ disappointing..

No end game wrap up? I always enjoyed those personally

I appreciate that you can take an almost 3 hours game and condense it down to an 18 min video

If you are tapping mana to cast a spell (e.g morphic pool + sol ring for toxic deluge) the cauldron trigger doesn't go onto the stack until you are done paying the cost for that spell and it's already on the stack. Good game, but something to keep in mind /w storm cauldron/silence in the future!

@Luffarjevel

3 жыл бұрын

It deoends on if the caster announces the spell though, doesn't it? If he just preemptively taps his lands so that he can replay it after and have mana open for interaction for example, it would play out like this scenario. Obviously not getting full context in the video, otherwise what you are saying is correct.

@LethalPigeon7

3 жыл бұрын

As has been pointed out, this is purely context-dependant, context we don't have without in-game audio.

@Oursacredwar

3 жыл бұрын

@@Luffarjevel good point!

Up until I discovered this page I have never seen Najella. I don't play CEDH. But I love this deck now

No card of the game? To be fair, it'd probably be Storm Cauldron or Edric, but still.

@evanczthehunter57

3 жыл бұрын

it would've 100% been storm cauldron, let's be honest.

@zanderwoods5434

3 жыл бұрын

@@evanczthehunter57 One may think, but you also gotta realize that Edric drew the winning player so many cards that game. There's no way it wasn't a huge help.

@evanczthehunter57

3 жыл бұрын

@@zanderwoods5434 At the same time, how different would the game have been without Cauldron?

Absolutely love the changes at the beginning and the end! However, some aspects I think you can improve upon is displaying the opening hands and omitting the analysis. In the opening hands sections, the cards overlap similarly to the way they did in your first few episodes. In the conclusion, I miss the game analysis, MVP, MVC, etc. other than that, this was one of the most fun PWP videos I’ve seen in a while. Awesome stuff!

When MTGMuddsta and PWP upload within an hour of each other. Noice Please bring back post game commentary.

The production quality of these videos is amazing!

I love the new style with the graphics and stats at the end. I still wouldn't mind your recap voiceover at the end along with the stats.

Great changes, and great game! However, I do miss the Most Valuable Card of the game and the wrap-up in general. Anyway, keep up the awesome content!

This is the best cEDH game I’ve seen in a long time. Perfect timing with answers when different players tried to pop off, some lesser played cards shining (looking at you, Storm Cauldron) and a very tight finish. I miss the end game narration but we all know Edric was the MVP!

Solid changes and great new way for doing the intro etc.!!!! Keep it up, guys!

Love the new format! Congrats, y'all!

Amazing game!! Clicked as early as possible seeing different commanders and loved that the 4 decks where doing their stuff (of course some more than others). Loved even more that it wasn't Thoracle. And lastly, loved how it was a different game because of the 5cmc Artifact.

Oooooh, that intro is 🔥!!! EDIT: Scratch that, the intro and new deck tech layout is sick! Great work!

This new style and music are amazing!!

Whoa, what a glow up! I'm loving the new logo and graphics, keep up the great work guys.

Love the new editing. Looking very sharp. Love this channel. Nice work.

The presentation is great, chef kiss

Love the spruced up editing!

Najeela is so powerful, the rest of the group had thought they put foldger out of the game twice but he still came back and won.

That was really cool line at the end. Loved it.

The change to the intro was destined to happen and it’s a cool touch to have the opening hands displayed in sort of a 3D style view! You guys provide top notch CEDH content and you’re a growing. As always keep up the excellent work!

looking to build a nejela deck, 5/10 dual lands so far.

@LethalPigeon7

3 жыл бұрын

It's reserved list cards, wotc is practically begging you to use proxies.

@cmdrsausage

3 жыл бұрын

My friend I think you will find that there are only 9 dual lands haha. We don't talk about plateau hehe

@Agumon2509

3 жыл бұрын

I use 10 shocks and fetches with lands suck as mana confluence n such n have never had an issue with color fixing

@esimplx

3 жыл бұрын

Proxy proxy proxy. I own lots of reserved list stuff from years of playing legacy, but unless you plan on taking part in sanctioned tournaments there is absolutely no reasons to support the reserved list by paying for these cards. Any self respectibg cedh playgroup should encourage proxy usage.

@LethalPigeon7

3 жыл бұрын

@@esimplx exactly, thank you

The intro looked incredible! Keep it up guys

Love the new style! But I'll echo a couple sentiments posted by others: having the cards in the opening hand stacked can make it more difficult to follow. I don't know all of the cards by heart and will often pause the opening hands to read cards I'm unfamiliar with, which now sorta requires going to another site. The recap was also pretty cozy.

When I first started watching commander content I didn't like this channel but now that I'm more comfortable with the format and want to actually be a competent deck builder, this channel has become much more interesting for me.

I love the Kodama Sakashima deck so much.

I understand that retention rates on the post game wrap up weren't great, but maybe you can still include MVP and MVC on the game results screen. Overall liking the increased production value!

Great video as always. As most people have commented, please bring back the game recap. I miss the "Ladies and gentlemen, what a game!"

I think the toxic deluge should have been on the stack before mana was paid for it so silence would not have done anything.

@Omenshaper

3 жыл бұрын

He floated the mana before announcing his intent to cast Toxic Deluge. This is one of those extremely rare cases where the mechanics of casting a spell actually mattered.

@Frommerman

3 жыл бұрын

He could not in this case, because he had to cast the sol ring before casting the deluge.

@LethalPigeon7

3 жыл бұрын

@@Frommerman Noone responded to the sol ring, it was cast using nonland sources and resolved. The response was to a cauldron trigger when floating mana prior to casting deluge.

@r3dmanMIC

3 жыл бұрын

@@Frommerman He could, because the silence was in response to the Cauldron trigger (to make him bounce a land for nothing). He could, instead, have announced "I'm casting toxic deluge, paying these costs" and it would have worked.

@Benjammn

3 жыл бұрын

@@r3dmanMIC That is just bad manners in my eyes. I get that it technically matters, but still. Such a small technicality, especially since he had the opportunity to respond when Sol Ring was cast. The only thing someone can learn from this is to announce casting your spell before paying costs.

The stats are still here. I'm happy, changes look good.

Love the new logo and opening!!!

Changes are great for opening the channel to options like Legacy and Vintage play: which maintain the "most powerful cards in the most powerful formats" motiff. Significantly cleaner, without reducing the production value that defines the channel.

Love the opening!

I must say i liked the side by side view of the hand better, made it easier to see what the starting hands were HOWEVER, the addition of the mat/sleeve type was a touch i was not expecting but appreciate

Nice upgrade to the opening

Like the new style and opening, same familiar PWP Green tho love it

The new style looks great :D

Love the new intro kings

Well well well, I was enjoying the videos before but OMG this opening is something else! I'm also missing the post-game recap and analysis, let's hope it comes back soon.

Nice changes! The recap removal was flawless. It really caused some spikes before 😭 (mnemonic betrayal *cof*)

Digging the new look! Kinda miss the MVC discussion

Most valuable card: Edric, most spicy card: Storm Cauldron.

Sick chamges but I like being able to read the opening hands

Love the new video production and logo design. The two things that were missing for me were when the opening hand was displayed and the missing post game recap. For the opening hand, it's a lot harder to read the card with them angled like this.

I vote to add the commentary back in at the end!

I know this has already been said, but i really miss the post-game recap/most valuable card. Other than that I'm really enjoying the new changes

the new editing is 🔥

Love the changes. And I seriously don’t know how you guys find time to get in so many matches, edit, narrate, and upload.

I really love the new opening, I just miss the epic music at the start :) Since I was never really a "watching the wrap up"-person, I wont miss it too much, except for the MVP card, maybe. I think it might be good, if you could for example give a shout out to sth special like in this cards the amount of cards drawn with Edric.

Oh my shit, your quality is the best!

Love the new logo!

I like the new look. much wow

I preferred your old layout and music, and also miss the recap. Not meant as hate, cause you guys are my fav magic team, by far ❤️ Glad you’re still making content!

ayo is that a new intro. it looks amazing!

Love the new intro 😍

Yoooo sick new opening!

Would love to see y'all play some Canadian Highlander sometime!

I wouldn't mind the recap returning. But otherwise keep up the good work guys!

Yo that new intro is sick asf

Loving the changes for the most part. Could you go back to the post-game recap and MVP card please?

Great new style! Have to agree with some of what was mentioned before, kind of miss the post-game, but to me the most important is that the opening hands / deck introduction now take longer and are actually less clear than before. Your previous version was something I liked a lot about this channel. Maybe the animations can be sped up and the cards shown next to eachother again?

I really missed the end game wrap up here

Storm cauldron is one of those cases where it significantly hurt 2 decks more than it did the other. It's such a risk because even though the deck can leverage it I feel like it really helped najeela while additionally slowing down the other 2 decks which really didn't work in anyone's favor but najeela

Love the new intro

6:50 Zack could've used expedition map in response to the remaining Kodama triggers, fetched a field of the dead to his hand, cheated it to field with kodama trigger, then looped oboro, generating infinite zombies... been looking at kodama/silas pairing lately...

I thought you changed the music for a second. Trickery.

Oooooh i like the overhaul

Uhhh baby what a game!!

6:00 Stephen had spilling bowl foil island. Best island ever printed dont care what haters say.

Bruh it's so weird not having the old song, but the new changes are great!

Love the new opening. Miss the card of the game.

This intro was absolute fire!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!!!11!!

Love the update miss the recap

Oh my gosh Winota cEDH is literally my favorite deck ever I've been working on a moonfolk tribal deck with Zimone or Jadzi in the CZ (I hate Tatyova and Aesi with a passion, and Patron of the Moon is kinda bad lol) and I'm kinda tempted to switch the commanders to Sakashima Kodama

i did not know Run away together was a cedh worthy bounce spell

wow run away together, i never saw its potential in edh but it goes nice in multiplayer

WOOOOOOAH NEW FORMAT LETS GO

Great game!

I love the new intro! But, can you show the starting hands as flat cards? They're easier to read that way.

OMG these NEW animations for the splash screen are EPIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Keep it going! You folks are great! is there ever going to be a female player? That would be neat!

@PlayingWithPowerMTG

3 жыл бұрын

We've had one in the past, and there are some in the upcoming videos too.

16:06 he can still cast toxic deluge, if he started casting deluge first and then tap mana for the spell

like the new logo, but I'm missing the intro's music, that track made it sound like we are about to watch something epic

Wow new intro so cool

i like the new logo

Stephen would've been able to cast the Toxic Deluge... If you say you want to cast something you can cast it, tap all your stuff for the mana and only when the thing you're casting goes onto the stack, all triggered abillities follow. It all depends on how you announce it, but even in a tournament a judge would very likely rule in your favor, even if you said "i tap the land for black" first, as you can take back any mana-abillity and the intention to cast the spell is obvious. (Might be different on high-stakes tournaments, tho :D)

Looking to build a Kodama/Sakashima deck and looking for inspiration, so I wanted to ask what's the combo for this list? I'm looking it over and don't see the usual landfall stuff, can someone please explain? They say "loop Sunscrorched Desert with Kodama's ability", but that doesn't seem very easy in the list. You can use Oboro Breezecalled to get it back into your hand, sure, but what then? Usual combos I saw involved Meloku the Clouded Mirror, for that you just need one copy of Kodama on the field and the land itself.

I really missed the post game talk, but great changes overall