I think you should let them talk among each other longer, but that's just what I want. Rather than checking bullet points within a certain agenda that we don't know came from a nobel winner or not

@Melki

Жыл бұрын

27:00 Because women are good with chemistry, not mere "representation" please keep the integrity of the prize --- I have deeper admiration to Richard Saul Wurman now somehow --- 46:00 Turned out nice in the end to my surprise

@fariszfm

Жыл бұрын

That's how I've noticed her past interviews go. On the flipside that's a lot of interesting ppl to interview in 47 minutes.

@MrRinre

Жыл бұрын

I was so confused when the interviewer immediately abandoned the topic when the other individual stated that a student didn't want to live a life of research. That was a very valid point. Most women have different priorities in life like raising a family.

@davidlarson3905

Жыл бұрын

No you're absolutely right - that's exactly what we all want lol. It's a great privilege to be able to watch this, talk but the pace here was kinda grueling.

@danielduvana

Жыл бұрын

That might not go as well as you’d like. A group of people who don’t know each other discussing without a structure might not be as interesting and good as you may imagine. But it would be fun to see either way.

Such an insightful conversation between intellectual giants. Wonderful to see such amazing content available for free on KZread.

@janjantimalsina1465

Жыл бұрын

👍

@weakw1ll

Жыл бұрын

This felt way too short

@richjones7313

7 ай бұрын

yes. why is this free? we should be paying to see this! in fact you should be paying me to reply to you. i motivate you and your family

@sukyungyu6264

7 ай бұрын

Completely agree❤

Please don't ever stop hosting and broadcasting this talk. It is such an enlightening talk. Congratulations to all the Nobel Laureates with their outstanding achievements.

@arifulislamleeton

Жыл бұрын

Thank you

The only thing lacking really is the time allotment. Would have been fun if this could go on for 2 hours so we can really let the conversations flow.

@user-mv6he6gl8m

Жыл бұрын

Agree. Maybe they could do a cut version for television and another "directors cut" with all the answers and huhums around the table.

@peterummur6799

Жыл бұрын

I agree that a longer time slot would have been fascinating zeena badawi was brilliant

@mehdiezzine292

Жыл бұрын

Yes i also didn’t like how directed the discussion was , I mean these are some of the greatest scientists of our time i think they can find subjects to discuss between themselves on their own just fine

@wutaeworld

Жыл бұрын

@@mehdiezzine292 THIS! i heard more from the interviewer than The scientists that were being interviewed! room for improvement definitely.

For the love of God, make this format at the very least 1h30 long. It is a very rare occasion to hear those brilliant minds exchange thoughts and it is a disappointment that this opportunity lasts less than a lectures worth, as well as portions being noticeably cut out. People that watch this are in it for a longer, uncut debate format. It seems that some of the laureates are eager to speak more, but they aren't given the chance to express themselves properly. Thank you for considering a change in this format, many will be deeply grateful as the reach of this platform has the potential to inspire and educate. My suggestion is to bring out a shorter format to give an overview like this video does, but also the longer uncut version where the laureates are able to speak freely and have an actual conversation.

Listening to them is not only an experience of pure joy but also amazing that difficult subjects are talked in such a simple way. Very well conducted.

@solapowsj25

Жыл бұрын

Amazing 👍.

@richardokonicha

Жыл бұрын

pure joy yes

@MrRobertFarr

Жыл бұрын

Yes, it's a pleasure to listen to these clever folks .

@Gadreel_

Жыл бұрын

"Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication"

@rolandobarrientos6993

Жыл бұрын

agree, this journalist is awesome, but in general i think is a bad idea gather all this brilliant minds together, cause obviusly each one has its own field of knowledge!

As a PhD student using Carolyn technology, I am fully inspired to also push the boundaries of knowledge!! Carolyn is an inspiration for me and I hope to one day be able to be in one of her lectures

@MrRobertFarr

Жыл бұрын

Ah yes.

Overview of their works Medicine 09:35 Chemistry 17:45 Physics 28:53 Economics 37:42

@edwconr

Жыл бұрын

'Biology is what, Chemistry is how and Physics is why'. Original Thought, Dr. P. Edwards Conrad.

@JunkBondTrader

Жыл бұрын

@@edwconr Great quote, as long as you don't over think it hah.

@salmanghori5571

Жыл бұрын

Thx. Karan!

@weakw1ll

Жыл бұрын

Goated

@lancelot9393

Жыл бұрын

@@edwconr Biochemistry is all of them ;) 🧬

I met professor Zeilinger a month ago in public traffic in Vienna and i was actually afraid of him and it reminded me how powerful intellect and education actually is. I just froze in place and I had never been that intimidated of a human and believe me, I have seen some strong dudes but this was very different.

@ekesandras1481

Жыл бұрын

afraid that he might beam you away ;-)

@tim90003

Жыл бұрын

He teleported fear from his quantum computer's output into your quantum computer's input!

@HumptyDump37

Жыл бұрын

@@ekesandras1481 I spat my noodles out reading this

@josemenesesmontano411

Жыл бұрын

Low key if I was in the presence of a person whose intellect is on another level I would be in shock and awe as well

@brianwade8649

Жыл бұрын

@@HumptyDump37 I sprayed out my milk when I read that you spat out your noodles.

The clip from 82 send shivers down my spine, when Bergström mentioned genetics, whilst his son, Svante, received his Nobel Prize for his research on said field! He lived a kind of double life, with two families, and hardly anyone knew about Svante being his son. Really fascinating story!

@aldjix

Жыл бұрын

He didn’t raise his son but he also turned out to be brillant ?

@ivanleon6164

Жыл бұрын

while inspirational, and remarkable, it also show how close the circles on top research is, wish more people entered science.

@mohammedfaqih499

Жыл бұрын

@@ivanleon6164 but is that the case with this guy? Was the circle actually closed with him inside? Was he part of the circle?

@tinahussei3672

Жыл бұрын

The whole thing of this discussion was weird and spooky !

@nostalgia545

11 ай бұрын

Privilege begets privilege. Usually professors get their kids internships while other kids have to beg professors for chances to wash test tubes in labs.

I am an intellectual nobody, but I thoroughly enjoyed listening to all this genius. It gives me confidence that all the elements of progress are here and we have the people to find it.

@faridshahid1833

9 ай бұрын

That's not true - you are not an intellectual nobody

What a great conversation. As a young man in Johannesburg, South Africa, am inspired. Africa needs to sit on this table in years to come. Brilliant minds!

@michaelmaps2004

Жыл бұрын

😂 they should create their own table not wait for people who might get uncomfortable having them around

@dennismassawe7078

Жыл бұрын

I agree with the previous response. Africa must wake up to the fact that it needs to create it's own knowledge and all tables of recognition.

@obadokamara139

Жыл бұрын

Shouldn't I be worried because "Africa needs to sit on this table in years to come" I think we should

@tonye.8023

Жыл бұрын

I'm a Nigerian and these are my thoughts: A gathering of brilliant minds with Nobel-level excellence celebrates their well-deserved efforts and results in different facets of human endeavor. Meanwhile, a certain group of over 200 million people in a certain West African country is debating whether to vote for a thief, a drug lord, or a prudent man. Just go sit in a quiet corner and put this into perspective.

@tonye.8023

Жыл бұрын

@@dennismassawe7078 Kinda interesting that we Africans are always injecting "need to" and "must wake up" whenever we talk about excellence and performance on the global stage. These are feel-good statements. They don't translate to action.

Thanks for bringing back the Nobel Minds roundtable discussions. I am looking forward to more!

@MrRobertFarr

Жыл бұрын

I also watched and listened.

@louise_rose

Жыл бұрын

Yes it's really cool! For many years, the programme was hosted by Bengt Feldreich, a famous science reporter from Sweden (and a bit of a showman), under the title "Snillen Spekulerar" (Speculations of the Geniuses) and after he died it was transferred to the BBC, Zeinab Badawi is an excellent interviewer/moderator, I've seen her lots of times on BBC World News, she's quick-witted, highly intelligent and very good at carrying this sort of high-powered round-table talk; a worthy successor of Feldreich in every way.

The host; she is brilliant. I don't know about her though, but she managed to keep this flawless environment throughout the discussion and light and bright humor! It was great to watch and listen to the brilliant minds talk

These people are bright and talented but they work extremely hard in their fields to achieve their breakthroughs. Incredible role models of achievement and decency.

It sends shiver down my spin watching intellectuals of this caliber gathering to exchange ideas. The output is pure brilliance. Congratulations to the price winners. Much love.

@rmnogueirap

Жыл бұрын

"down my spin" I want to believe this was a very intended pun! If yes, a good one! :)

@MrRobertFarr

Жыл бұрын

Yes it's a good presentation to watch.

@arifulislamleeton

Жыл бұрын

Thank you

D most precious Roundtable interactions of 2022,,, Wish, it was at least 2hrs so as to see more interactions amongst d great minds.

These are the kinds of shows we need to have on tv

@baqi007

Жыл бұрын

I know right

I have never seen the presenter Zenaib Badawi this excited in any of her works. This is indeed a special occasion.

The world is a much better place for these talented laureates. Very grateful for their work in their respected fields.

Inspiring and amazing minds! I enjoyed a lot listening to everyone! Highly educational indeed!

What a joy listening to such great minds and humble beings! Extremely inspiring discussion.

it is agonizing the thought that i will never have the capability to become any laureates in my lifetime, the brains is too smol

Hey Nobel Prize, please continue to upload videos like this as it serves as a bridge to greater global insights. Shout-out to the 2022 Laureates and Zeinab Badawi for being such a prolific presenter. Thank you!

I ABSOLUTELY love how Bertozzi turned around the question about women advocacy on the men in the room. I feel often when women reach great heights, the immediate question thrown on them is how THEY’RE gonna use their newfound platform to advocate for other women, it’s like some weird forced expectation on them and the very first thing they’re usually asked. Bertozzi really diplomatically and beautifully focused it on the other people who have a lot more power to do that than her. Yeah it’s great she’s got that accomplishment but don’t always make it on the woman to do it for other women.

It is quite remarkable that Nobel Minds program was able to attract their royal highnesses. Dark clouds hanging over the sky, we need this kind of discussion on television, not once a year but at regular intervals. Getting exposed to new kind of topics really makes me open-minded. Good thumb from Japan 👍

@CarlosSalazar-dd2ee

Жыл бұрын

Most enlighting and world's entertaining class. big YES!!!!

@herculeumkite

Жыл бұрын

Diversity makes people open-minded

@jinettew.3192

Жыл бұрын

'their royal highnesses'. This is not the place for fawning on people born into titles. Respect the people around the table please.

@Sid_Kill

Жыл бұрын

I think the groundbreaking achievements contributed by the scientists in the Nobel prize society would be really beneficial in technological and medical advancements in their country which is why it's not surprising Royal families would be interested in it as well.

@MrRobertFarr

Жыл бұрын

Yes, The Crown Princess and her husband, a gym owner. Perhaps they, are in the Network of Karate Nerd Jesse Empkamt the famous KZreadr ?! The Crown Princess is a really beautiful woman.

Love everyone that got recognized this day. Really inspiring for me as a freshman studying and hoping to get into research in the near future.

@ursularogers1419

Жыл бұрын

👏👏👏👏minute 26:45

We ought to give a credit to the host for moderating this round table in a classy and humorous way. Excellent conversation!

I’m so happy these talks are back in person!

The sheer intellectual power in that room is astounding

I audibly gasped when Zeinab Badawi started to close the conference. I have an awful attention span, but those 47 minutes felt like 10 with the fascinating discussion and humble geniuses around that table. Please never stop this series.

It's very pleasant to watch these intelligent people come together!

Listening to every one is a new beginning to different fields of science and highly delighted at this noble feast

It is wonderful to listen to the great minds. Zainab, I think this is great format, however, at times it seemed some of the laureates were squeezed for time as they answered questions. I wondered if they were given the questions in advance with the time allotment for their answer.

please make this longer. it's a service to humanity to let these people exchange ideas publicly

This talk is an inspiration for me as a Junior Quantum Physicist. Wishing for more of such talks

@christopherreed3019

Жыл бұрын

make Nigeria proud

@MrRobertFarr

Жыл бұрын

Nice! Quantum Physics! I studied something similar with Dr. I forgot his name, back in 2004 ! He was the inventor of Maple , a computer package, for teaching Quantum Mechanics !

@hardikb15

Жыл бұрын

@@MrRobertFarr great!

@sakitperut123

Жыл бұрын

Good luck. Quantum is a blind end.

This was amazing. Loved all of this talk. It's 5am and I'm here watching and consuming. Maybe in 20 years; I'll be here at this talk just to sit and listen.

@visq

Жыл бұрын

I wonder if older civilizations had these talk of talks but because they weren't documenting like we do now, we wouldn't know.

@Studynow027

10 ай бұрын

​@@visqhahah sure they did !

Asking a bunch of nobel prize winners if they get the no bell wordplay joke. Brilliant

These videos are pure knowledge and cultural information. Hosting and broadcasting these talks extend our minds. Thank you.

You learn so much by watching only 47 minutes. Imagine having these amazing minds sit down together for 2 hours.

Dear Laureates, I am writing to express my heartfelt congratulations on each of your recent Nobel Prize wins. These are truly extraordinary achievements, and ones that are richly deserved. Your dedication, hard work, and talent have brought you to the pinnacle of your respective fields, and your contributions have made a lasting impact on the world. I am grateful for your tireless efforts to push the boundaries of knowledge and understanding, and for your commitment to advancing the common good. Your Nobel Prizes are a testament to your incredible abilities, and an inspiration to us all. Thank you for everything you have done, and for all that you will continue to do in the future. You are true role models and shining examples of what can be achieved through hard work, passion, and determination. With admiration and gratitude, Khalil.

@user-bm3vb2ji8h

Жыл бұрын

gratitude at its deepest!

@Madison_Sacha

Жыл бұрын

Spot on. Well said Khalil!

@Eisi456

Жыл бұрын

mate its not 1822...but i'm with you ;)

@miketurner9775

Жыл бұрын

I just read your comment in an English accent

@What.A.Life....

Жыл бұрын

@@miketurner9775 I did too. It only felt right to do so

Zeinab congratulations 🌹🌹🌹I religiously watch your Laureate's programme Decades back I used to follow your presentations on Africa on C4 late nights... when one particular country's annual turnover of 20 million dollars then was similar to a UK company's, and the IMF representative stationed there, was once a lingerie salesman...a lot of water has flowed since then...

Congratulations to all the winners! I think there is a tradition of finding the sequence in the medical fields and it is very probable to win awards with convincing experimental results.

We're really blessed by the technology to be able to watch these conversations..

Always a pleasure listening to such great minds of our times, thank you🙏

Who would have thought that one day we would have the pleasure of watching and listening to such brilliant minds live. Thanks to these remarkable scientists, whose research and inventions made it possible. It's an absolute pleasure to listen to these incredible minds. They keep unfolding the mysteries of the universe. I especially love the part shared by physicists here that we just don't know how things (particularly quantum mechanics here) work. That, indeed, is a very humble stance to many deep and mysterious questions, specifically the very existence of us. Why do we exist? How did we come here? Why the universe is the way it is? What is the purpose of life? The story of John Clauser is particularly very inspiring, how he went from being deemed crazy for his ideas and experiments, building things from the scratch, to winning the Nobel Prize after 50 years. His humble response when asked if he thinks quantum mechanics is a complete theory, Clauser answered: "I suspect there is a more fundamental theory below it, but that's purely conjecture. I don't know what it is. I confess also that I'm totally confused, I have no idea what all of this means."

God bless this era. We can watch such a incredible program on KZread free. Thank you for the program and KZread.

someone should give that lady a noble prize, for conducting the interview so candidly. I have been around academicians most of my life, and they often refrain from expressly articulating unless they are made very comfortable.

All these exceptional minds in one room. Priceless.

It's fascinating how simply they explain extremely hard stuffs. Probably this is a quality that makes them the best of human kind.

As a graduate student in Bioengineering at the University of Cauca, it inspires me to learn and apply knowledge for the good of humanity and, when the time is right, help train the next generation of researchers who are pragmatic and well-grounded in both the areas of engineering and biomedical sciences, as well as being good people, using knowledge and technology for good. Greetings from the municipality of Jamundí, in the department of Cauca in Colombia.

Congratulations to the moderator! Jumping from one topic to another so smoothly and adding a pinch of humor along the way was masterpiece.

@jihaneboumediane288

Жыл бұрын

I was thinking the same, she's brilliant

Amazing how it seems to run in the family somehow, for many.

Been a tradition watching these discussion for a long time. Not gonna miss this time either!

it's so crazy that they explained such diverse topics so fluently and I understood all of it...they got me interested in research.

36:36 very important point about the group and having a platform where “stupid” ideas can be shared without fear/shame.

Thanks for spending the time to create and share this content awarenesses/perspectives/etc ❤️🤙🏾

Congrats to all Laureates. And also congrats to the presenter, which conducted it very well!

Those scientists are truly humble and funny, they are attractive. The iconic line i remembered is art and science are two sides of a coin.

It´s outstanding having this opportunity for listening to these remarkable minds. Thanks a bunch for sharing this kind of content.

This should be way longer or a series spanning multiple themes

What a treat... Supreme minds gathered under one roof aloft that which is impossible. The cherry topping bringing it all sublimely together provided by the wonderful Mrs. Badawi

Such inspiring people together in one place. This show is on a different level.

I always enjoy watching this interaction every year. Thanks to the BBC for producing such a programme.

@MrRobertFarr

Жыл бұрын

I only just started watching, it popped up on KZread.

Beautiful discussion and even more elegant and finesse in conducting this roundtable discussion by the lady. This is mind-blowing and much needed every year.

This is quality and beauty of the mind.Weare all created with purpose and potential but when we understand the principles there is curiosity in discoveryThank you Zainab for your enthusiasm and dynamism Really enjoy the moment

It's so satisfying to listen to this and watch how they push the boundaries of knowledge

This was amazing 😢….brings a tear to my eye. I just turned 35 and just my thirst for knowledge and mature dialogue has greatly increased 😎🤘🏼 which doesn’t leave me many options with so much ignorant content being force fed to us via social media in todays world. I wish much success and positivity to whomever is reading this

This really portrays what nobel minds mean. Such a beautiful, insightful, warm, dedicated discussion. The genuises are geniuses for a reason and that is super clear in this video; their attitude towards the discussed knowledge is discerning..

Listening to them is not only an experience of pure joy but also amazing that difficult subjects are talked in such a simple way.

To witness the humbleness of some of the brightest minds on Earth really is a spectacle.

I LOVE!!! Dr. Bartozzi's answer when asked about women in STEM... "good question, but one that is more directly addressed by incumbent majority." Excellent point.

Congratulations to all the Nobel prize winners. From the audience side a student asked this excellent question. That is , from where do the great ideas emerge ?. Superbly got the answer in one word, "Obsession" from the great minds side. Thanks for this very valuable programme arranged by the Nobel committee.

@Luke-bq7sd

Жыл бұрын

such a great answer. words cannot do it justice

@megerzizo6639

Жыл бұрын

yeah, that was what I noticed from the whole interview "obsession"

Brilliant, I hope scientists from other parts of the world also become proficient at research and join this prestigious club.

It's so satisfying to listen to them explain their work in a simple, interesting and passionate way. Thank you for bringing it to us. And thanks for all the research work and tackling global problems for us. 🙏 Respect

I consider myself lucky to have been able to listen to and understand this discussion. I congratulate the team for making this and rendering it accessible, for free, to people all across the globe. However, I have some feedback: 1) Since people from around the world are watching it, wouldn't it be better if we had subtitles in foreign languages? In the absence of subtitles, only the English speaking layer of the population is able to understand this. Young minds and new ideas are scattered all around the world and not all of them understand English. 2) The questions regarding dearth of women at the top of their fields, be it science, arts or even Hollywood, should be posed to men and not the women. Hence, I completely agreed with what Prof. Bertozzi affirmed in the video. If not for the aforementioned points, I am absolutely in awe of this discussion and glad that I got the chance to witness this. Thanks!

@edwconr

Жыл бұрын

I am thankful for the subtitles.

This is awesome, listening to all these laureates at a go! It's amazing how these Sciences feel intertwined in a way...I study economics and I really hope more women in the field get as far as to become Laurates

They should make it longer and not force the presentator to keep interrumpting, we want to hear them talk!

@zazu3006

Жыл бұрын

i concur

This should be a long format conversation. So much new information that needs to be cross referenced and discussed from other fields.

I would have had a lot of anxiety sitting in a closed room with rather serious looking nobel prize winners (in general) . The interviewer did a great job keeping such a positive happy mood.

Oh my God, imagine that you are sitting with them!!! Greetings from Egypt 🇪🇬

You see now they're just normal people speak normal english. they have no super thinking power.they just use thier Brains in the right place and time. that's what made them special and briliant. While we just waiting the opportunity to come they run after it. Really appreciat such a great talk.

Thank you for such a talk! An honor and a pleasure to listen to all these brilliant people

As a translation and Interpretation student that has nothing to do with the topics this gentlemen and lady brought out, I found it quite delightful and informative, trying to get new words and understading the main ideas of the topics, it should be emphasized that english is not my mother tongue. Loved it, greetings from Peru to all of you.

Watching this is pure joy, thank you for posting

Shoutout to all scientists who are working hard to make Lives better but do not receive much accolades !

One of the things that fascinates me is the fact there's no Nobel prize in Computer Science.

How lovely to watch this talks. How amazing they were all modest that's the number one listen from this video Thanks to you all and many thanks for you zainab you were great as well.

I could listen to them for hours

27:26 As I started applauding laureate Prof Caroline from here, the audience followed suit!! Fantastic answer!!

It was amazing to watch it from 🇮🇷 Iran with my family, it might even help minds come closer.👌

longer talks please. they have great insight that requires more time to unravel

Very inspiring discussion!

She is just having so much fun in this, I wish I was this lucky to get an audience with 1 laureate, let alone 10

@osamaz2780

Жыл бұрын

Asking each of the laureates, "How much neanderthal you got in you"

I pay my honor and respect to all these Nobel laureates. It is a wonderful moment for me to see such amazing Nobel minds. They are the pioneers of human civilization. So I salute them.

Man, these are heroes of our time, though not as much in the limelight. God bless them....And Zeinab is awesome as a moderator. She was so elegant and proper in handling all those geniuses around her. Wow...

This is very inspiring and informative for me as a young man who loves and enjoy science.

The host explaining the No bell joke to that group is about the funniest thing I've seen this month.

@ergyst

Жыл бұрын

Their reaction too 😂

It is a joy to watch these brilliant minds when they discussed on their experience

Imagine the mental potency thats sitting at that table, let alone in that room. Absolutely stunning.