This is probably the single most beautiful piece of music I've ever heard in my life. So devastatingly sad.

@koojaa

7 жыл бұрын

Aiodhan O'Connellan A glimmer of hope that ends up fading really fast as the song transitions into Eraser.

@michaeljaeschke1649

5 жыл бұрын

You can feel the pain in this song it's soooo freaking good!

@HiHi-is6nd

4 жыл бұрын

Only can the Melancholy truelly comprehend

@elgrooster

4 жыл бұрын

If you ever hear this song live, it WILL make you cry. I seen and experienced it.

@JohnRovere

2 жыл бұрын

You should give Leaving Hope a listen.

The Downward Spiral album is Trent's best. He analogizes this song to be the eye of the hurricane.

This has always been my favorite NIN song, even when I discovered it's a cover of David Bowie's Crystal Japan. However, this song on piano-it's as though Moonlight Sonata and A Warm Place merged into the saddest, greatest thing I've ever heard.

@ryno4ever433

9 ай бұрын

This is a new piece of trivia for me, so thanks for that

This is NIN's best piece in my opinion. They say a picture speaks a thousand words. A melody has no limit.

Like a tsunami of sound. I have listened to this hundreds of times. Trent Reznor is like VAN GOGH. If we could live 200 years from now we would see NIN in a museum.

@joan6839

6 жыл бұрын

Steven Burnette exactly. Is the Mozart of our time

My most favourite song of all time. You play it beautifully.

@boynamed_sue

10 жыл бұрын

I absolutely agree with you.

@USF-yo4uh

8 жыл бұрын

+Gloomy Sunday Productions it's a melody Trent accidently took from David Bowie. Check it out David Bowie-Crystal Japan

@GloomySundayProductions

8 жыл бұрын

Fascinating. I'm sure Bowie didn't mind, since they enjoyed creating with one another and performing together.

My favorite piano rendition of any Nine Inch Nails song ever made. The way you play this song literally moves me to tears. This is a masterpiece.

@AlohaNLight2All

2 жыл бұрын

Same..I'm crying.. just so much emotion..

Trent Reznor is such an under appreciated composer. Great job! I could listen to this all day :0)

@USF-yo4uh

8 жыл бұрын

+Killah Kam love trent, but he does take this melody from david bowie's - crystal japan.

@LRRPFco52

2 жыл бұрын

@@USF-yo4uh The origin of the piece is from Crystal Japan, which really feels like traditional Japanese music if you’re familiar with it. What Trend Reznor did was adapt the overall progression of the song into a fairly adept diatonic Western classical piece using some very interesting and powerful concepts in music theory. If you look at how he creates harmonic tension through melodic momentum with inversions and even 2nd interval tension, hinting at resolution that only manifests once the final C note is added to the last bar of the ascending melody, that’s what really creates the inescapable “catch" to the song. Another interesting thing about that point in the motif is that it really shifts the tonal center from Dm to F Maj, F Maj of course being the relative Major of D Minor. This is how the feeling is manipulated from a very deep sadness to a sense of hope and unexpected brightness or innocence. Those techniques are nowhere present in Crystal Japan, as beautiful and serene as it is common to Japanese pre-Western exposure music. A Warm Place really illustrates what an accomplished musician and instrumentalist Reznor is. The way he hits certain diads and triads with both hands at key times in the piece are very well constructed and executed, so that the listener isn’t even thinking about the instruments, but feeling purity in music.

@thewired4607

2 жыл бұрын

@@LRRPFco52 thanks for the free lesson mate

I wish this song had some extended version. Like... an hour long extended version. It's so beautiful - both this cover and the original.

i want this cover version to be played at my funeral

@raideroutlaw2489

7 жыл бұрын

Jack Groskreutz right in the feels

This song has so many memories with it. I remember listening to this on repeat

this is the stuff that made Al Jourgensen realize his protege surpassed him in so many different ways...I got chills listening to your rendering...its seamless & beautiful...TRENT RULES

this made me feel amazing inside

Yo that was incredible. I hope all is well after 12 years. Man I wish I could like this video again every time I rewatch it.

This is one my favorite parts of The Downward Spiral.

@i_am_the_void

3 жыл бұрын

written by David Bowie)

@justinbuonvino4168

Жыл бұрын

@Simple Simplicity 101 Look up 'David Bowie Crystal Japan' here on KZread. Trent asked for permission, and was given blessing, from Bowie to absolutely model this song after Crystal Japan. It's how their friendship, and collaboration on a version if "I'm Afraid of Americans", got it's start.

This song means so much to my heart. Hearing it again brings me to tears. I honor my mother and her struggle with heroin to this...a warm place.

thank you!

wow!!... just.... wow. its great watching you play it. you provide a great deal of vu compositional insight into one of the most hauntingly beautiful melodies ever made. when one hears the album version, with all its synth arrangements, its hard to get a grasp on the fact that it was entirely written on piano; you bring said fact into a glaringly undeniable light. Thank you for sharing.

i used to vacation, because of its' proximity to europe, in Egypt. i travelled there at least 8 or 9 times and the smell of the desert, petrolium and the salty red sea, the nothingness of the desert, the vast spaces, the wind. i found myself listening to this song over and over again, everytime i went there. imagine my surprise, years later, realizing my my dream desert song was called 'a warm place'. thanks for this version, VK

Sorry that I can only post in one of your threads. You have a rare gift in that you can convey emotion in your music. Through repetition, practice, and passion you do something not many artists are able to. Please continue doing what you are doing. It would be a shame for the world to miss out on what you have to offer. I have seen many of your songs and you make me feel something. That is the true caliber of an artists. Can you make me feel something.

The emotion this song emits is incredible. Absolutely fantastic!

14 years go by, and this shows up while I'm scrolling, so I let most of it play out in my head til it's over before clicking to find yours beautifully rendered. Thx!

very great! Also it looks like disembodied hands..even better xx

This is one of my favourite Nine Inch Nails songs. Thank you, when it's just the piano it is beautiful.

OMG. I love your videos and this is one of my favorite NIN songs.

This and ghosts track 17, 13 are climatic

1:09 that's a spicy stretch

This is wonderful. I've loved this song for 16 years and you made it new again.

yep..... always have loved that song .... it was beautiful the crisper notes from the piano. Very well done, thank you.

Words escape me, absolutely beautiful.

I'm finally able to play this piece! Thank you so much for sharing this beautiful cover ❤

GOOSEBUMPS

Great job. One of my top 10 songs. Thanx

Thank you so much for this moving interpretation of my favorite song by NIN.

Beautiful. One of my favorite songs

this is one of the songs that can always make me feel better. It's on of the songs that I listen to while just wandering around outside, completely alone with my thoughts, as if I'm the only one left in a post apocalyptic wasteland.

very well played!! this song is so sad, yet so beautiful. It gives me shivers every time i hear it

You have a spirit that just flows into the piano. I love sitning to yor music..

You're really amazing. I've seen so many of your covers and each one is just perfect. You play with such feeling, I love it.

My favorite Christmas song.

beautiful. my favourite song ever, so much emotion without a single word

Magnificent I truly appreciate your cover

Beautiful.

Beautiful. Thank you.

Beautiful

Gorgeous rendition. Thank you.

Simply beautiful.

Simply beautiful...

You captured the spirit of the music fantastically! Absolutely wonderful.

Very awesome in this masterpiece of nin yeah great tastes in genres of music as well vk

Perfect! Bravo!!!

This is absolutely amazing. You are the first person to successfully bring me to tears via piano playing. Thank you so much for uploading.

Absolutely beautiful. I love how you played the beginning slightly lower, really accentuates the deepness of the emotion in the piece. Lovely, lovely job.

beautifully played.

just beautifully done. thank you for sharing your talent with us.

beautiful and chilling

Just love it....

Incredible!!

Hauntingly beautiful

That was fucking AMAZING. Props. Mad fucking props

Wow, absolutely beautiful. Excellent job.

can't get enough of this!!

Wow, stunning

Thank you for this.

just amazing, flawless, just blow mw away, seriously, congrats

Sublime. Bravo.

wonderful! this was a longtime ago, i used to fall asleep to this in high school!! i love this still< still find myself searching the ipod for this today! Great job! i wish i had the talent!!

You are one talented individual! You have given me the desire to learn the piano, and not just playing by ear. Thank you!!

So hauntingly beautiful 💙

Jesus. Thank you for this. Amazing!!!!

That was beautiful piano verison of A Warm Place. i was watching it three year ago. that was pretty good sound. i lov it.

Fantastic. I thought I was the only one who loved this song so much. Kudos.

Beautiful cover, very nice!

pure bliss

vk does it justice for fucking sure....this should have been part of the soundtrack for requiem for a dream

Great play !

Good job!! A piece that is so sad but it can also put you at peace. Great piano version! Beautiful!

You make amazing videos :) ive watched 4 or so videos back to back! You are truly talented. You have a gift. And as a fellow musician id like to say you are awesome. If i had the chance to start some sort of music project with you i would

this was played amazingly. i love the reach you are getting. well done. this is by far my most favourite piece by nine inch nails thanks for sharing this!! im going to check out your other vids now :D

absolutely beautiful

gorgeous! loved it!

That was beautifully played. Thank you very much for sharing this

and again, your taste in music is impeccable! -song is hypnotic

Amazing

Absolutely beautiful, i felt like the first time i heard the original one, so amazing!

this is absolutely brilliant, not often someone puts up a piano cover that really hits the song, i think i may like this more than the actual song....

Im breathless. The sound, rythm. AMAZING

Excellent!

How impressive! And I knew it was an emotional piece, but when I heard you make it on the piano, it seemed to be a new piece on its own. Wonderful job. That did a number on my heart. I don't know if I'm sinking or floating.

LOVE IT

Love it. Gives me goosebumps.

@vkgoeswildofficial

7 ай бұрын

Thank you

@andyfagan2136

7 ай бұрын

@@vkgoeswildofficial No problem. Where do you you hail from?

This is freaking awesome! Pulling out my dusty old Yamaha keyboard as I write this to copy what you have accomplished right here.

Flawless.

Pretty awesome!

Great gravitas!

excellent! A Warm Place is one of my fav NIN songs.

Thanks to you I fell in love with Nine Inch Nails all over again. :-D Your piano playing is beautiful!

Wow! Beautiful. Thanks for sharing.

Beautiful =] just sent shivers down my spine

This kinda saved me today so thank you :)