Abandoning nationalism is the first step to unity in ummah...

@kalijasin

7 ай бұрын

Is that why Palestinians are being massacred?

@billyjesus5442

7 ай бұрын

thats leftist communist Marxist talk.

@berkturkoglu

7 ай бұрын

If someone detests his own nation, he will have no value to the Ummah.

@monotheism6616

6 ай бұрын

Turks will never abide that advice!!!.

@adnanibnnoor_1

6 ай бұрын

All idiots are here , Is there any one ever checked that in Quran is ISLAM is a religion or not , or just taking based on old stories, Second Ummah Allah SWT mentioned in Quran is in tact and they are always united, which does not comprise of labelled muslims of today.

“Allah does not change your condition until you change yourself”

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

@RichAsher

7 ай бұрын

​@@syedbaqir2687come on please we all follow one God one book. There is no more room to spread hate

@m-kh3ild734

7 ай бұрын

@@syedbaqir2687stop causing fitnah

@m-kh3ild734

7 ай бұрын

@@RichAsheryes don’t listen to that guy his spreading fitnah we are all Muslim and we all commit mistakes even this guy commenting

@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj

7 ай бұрын

@@syedbaqir2687 shia rafidis are mushrik kuffaar according all scholars of ahkul Sunnah

This was not heated, it was a very important conversation to have, both Shaykths were very cordial. Remember disagreement doesn't always = heated/argument. Most Muslims agree with either viewpoint and both have a lot of crossover than most people realise. The truth is that we need to decide on one and go for it as the world around is moving much faster than most understand. I don't think either point is inherently or Islamically wrong. Personally, I used to agree with Shaykh Mehmet Usta's point until very recently, now I think Shaykth Uthmans point is closer to what we need to do but still hold our leaders accountable to at least some degree until we get to a better point as a better Ummah religiously.

@pulseed2466

7 ай бұрын

Shykh uthman has a history of misbehaving while talking to any Other daee, i witnessed it on his channel 1 message foundation, he has uploaded a short where he insults dr. Zakir who has contributed much to the dawah field for more than 40 years and his works on dawah are beneficial. Yes his some views, fatwas taken from other scholars etc might b lil controversial but that doesn't justify a man who calls himself a shykh uses words which are insulting in nature

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

All of us muslims can unite when every muslim comes on the straight path. The path of the prophets and the salaf as-salih. Quran and sunnah with the understanding of the salaf.

@uzzy_787

7 ай бұрын

@@pulseed2466no one cares how many years he’s given da’wah if he gives incorrect fatwa he’ll be corrected

@tazboy1934

7 ай бұрын

​@@LearnTawhidThat is propaganda of wahabi

@m-kh3ild734

7 ай бұрын

@@pulseed2466stop causing fitnah about brothers

Can we not do both? Can we call back the way of Quran and Sunnah AND hold Muslim leaders of the world accountable?

@kittyyycattt8726

7 ай бұрын

And dont forget thier Evil scholars According to Hadith

@safwan7346

7 ай бұрын

100%. Part of Quran and Sunnah is holding our leaders accountable. That’s one of the points Sheikh Usta was trying to make.

@marshallmuki2924

7 ай бұрын

You can hold leaders responsible but there is conditions.

@kittyyycattt8726

7 ай бұрын

@@marshallmuki2924 like what?

@marshallmuki2924

7 ай бұрын

@@kittyyycattt8726 5 conditions We see: Meaning that it is not a rumor Disbelief: That which is kufr based off the Quran and Sunnah Clear cut: When there is no other way in looking at it meaning only one interpretation Proof from Allah: Back with evidence from the Quran And more benefit from doing so then harm: Will a conflict arise for example as a result of rebelling which will cause more harm to the nation then good. All of these have to be met for rebelling.

I can understand what Shaykh Uthman is trying to say and totally agree with him on this. If the root isn't strong then the ummah will not have a strong bonding or oneness.

@reffness

7 ай бұрын

One thing the Isra Hell is good at grooming their young.. most of them are on the same page… sadly how many friends or family members you know follow Islam correctly… they are a minority!

@ordinaryman3949

7 ай бұрын

I want to debate uthman he is running 🏃‍♀️ from me

@HMAAAz

7 ай бұрын

Ideally that would be good. But realistically it's not. So what he wanted to say until every single of us completed the five pillars then we can worry or do something of our tortured brothers and sisters? So we can just turn ourselves a blind eye and let them be killed.. Is that the solution?

@EAGLE-nc5lz

7 ай бұрын

​@@ordinaryman3949 i think ur too Small uthman can't see u

@ordinaryman3949

7 ай бұрын

@@EAGLE-nc5lz but I think I am bigger than them that he debate on streets.

Uthman’s point is deeper than Usta’s. How can we expect the Egyptian, Jordanian or any other Muslim government to embrace Islam and act and sacrifice for Islam if their own population don’t do the same? How can the homes of a land not implement Islam but we expect governments of those lands to implement it?

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

@00786faiz

7 ай бұрын

Isn't it the government's responsibility to declare their state as a Sharia state ? Why do they adjust their policies as to what the masses want. Establish Sharia and make people follow it.

@NajashiProductions

7 ай бұрын

@@00786faiz Yes, but look at most of the people. They don’t apply sharia in their own home but they want a “shariah” state. Most of these countries do declare they’re a sharia state in their constitution but they don’t apply it because the people would revolt or cause issues. We need to get better collectively. People and State.

@thewaytosalvation145

7 ай бұрын

It's a red herring. Top Down Process is stronger than buttom up. The Mamluks were harsh amd corrupt but yet they implemented Shariah in the society and NEVER did they Ally with Kufr against Islam. Like Saudi & USA

@Emsyaz

7 ай бұрын

​@@syedbaqir2687shias who invoke Ali, Hussein, and 12 imams in du'a and worship are indeed mushrik

I understood both. The main problem is what the colonialists have installed into our governments, society and the Ideology how we think about how we live our lives.

@masudsaleh5155

Ай бұрын

How can we change that?

Shaykh uthman is right on this one. I'm from Germany. And the brothers and sisters here all live for themselves. And those who are really looking for a society only find the Muslims who have nothing else to do but talk against other Muslims. And as soon as you say "I learn from so and so" they stamp you and the connection is broken again. 💯% shaykh uthman on Point.

@azirtube6512

7 ай бұрын

Same in the UK

@kingslayar5

7 ай бұрын

Muslims brothers protested for Palestine in Germany and and UK so don't spread lies

@zentraldeen3215

7 ай бұрын

​@@kingslayar5Allah created the situation and brought Muslims together الحمدلله do you think after that they all go for coffee ? What world do you live in? Read properly before you accuse someone of lying. You are the best example. No manners, but a mouth as wide open as a barn door

@thewaytosalvation145

7 ай бұрын

You can't change that without proper governments

@kingslayar5

7 ай бұрын

@@zentraldeen3215 it's not an accusation it's a fact of reality. Don't lie by just saying things personally as anecdotal evidence But how could you not know the brothers and sisters protested for Palestine in your country ?!

Are you sharing this to get views, or because it's beneficial? Be sure to check your intention.

@roy-kn7pi

7 ай бұрын

this not good it looks like is coming from a bad intention just to get view. We shouldn't support this!

@Gamily000

7 ай бұрын

He shared a conversation. It's not like they were cussing at each other: Each one just has a different solution to the same problem.

@greatcaledonianpenicillin5378

7 ай бұрын

@@Gamily000 Exactly. I think peoples worries come from a good place but this was an important and cordial conversation that the Muslims should be a part of it.

@adnanibnnoor_1

6 ай бұрын

*** MY challenge to all hypocrites , label Muslims fake muslims **** 1) Which verse in Quran says Muhammad SAWW is given Quran or any Book. or to say , show me any verse which has name of Muhammad SAWW and words like Quran and Book in it, 2) Which verse says Musa AS is given Taurat , with Word Taurat and Musa AS name in the same verse . 3) Which verse mentioned that Quran came down 1400 years ago. IF can not answer these questions then know Iblees AS shaitan has already suck you in the hell fire pit as you are a Hypocrite. ***********************************************************

@masudsaleh5155

Ай бұрын

He runs ads, so.......

Subhanallah when USA waged war on Iraq and Afghanistan , people were saying we are blaming the US government not the people . But when we are talking about Muslim world governments , the people are to blame not the governments

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

shirk,bid'ah,kufr, immorality, no knowledge of true Islam leads to Disunity in the ummah therefore we are defeated and humiliated. Now is the rising action, return back to way of the prophets, the salaf as-salih in understanding the Qur'an and sunnah. Every muslim should know Tawhid and what falls to shirk.

@nutzhazel

7 ай бұрын

Because unlike other religions, Islam is The Way of Life, hence weak people will only produce weak leadership. What we're witnessing today is the product of weak Muslim households producing weak Muslims leaders.

@penguinman38

7 ай бұрын

That was a different scenario

Very important discussion that our imams need to start having regularly - actually talking about the long-term solutions rather than having a defeatist attitude and thinking small!! Sh Usta's political expertise is also very important for contextualizing and understanding the actual root cause of the Ummah's broken state it's in today.

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

@m-kh3ild734

7 ай бұрын

@@syedbaqir2687stop speaking fitnah

@penguinman38

7 ай бұрын

From watching the video, it became apparent that Mehmet Usta has a lack of knowledge in regards to politics. The Rafah border being closed isn’t even Egypt’s fault. The problem is that people are not learned in these events so they take anyone who speaks about them eloquently as knowledgeable. May Allah rectify us.

Both great points presented on each side of the argument. I think generally what's left out as a solution is the synergy of both concepts together. This would provide us with a holistic action plan for the ummah. A plan where we educate ourselves and our communities, but simultaneously holding the vision to all gather under some sort of sovereign unity. The method of the Prophet SAW and the Sahaba is our blueprint for success as a unified body. The Prophet SAW spent years bolstering the Sahaba upon Tawheed correcting any tainted beliefs from pre-Islam. But all of that was done with greater plans, which the senior Sahaba were very much aware of. And you see that beautiful organic progression of training these people, who once were the most disgraced, to become the greatest giants the world has seen. In summary, we should do the education part, thoroughly and correctly, whilst also pinpointing and steering our efforts towards a direct concourse to unification and our own Muslim lands.

@masudsaleh5155

Ай бұрын

🎉❤❤🎉🎉

Beautiful discussion 👌

🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:00 🔑 Shaykh Uthman emphasizes the duty of Muslims to work for peace and justice on Earth, uniting Muslims and non-Muslims. 00:14 🔑 The need for Muslim unity is discussed, with the call for Muslims to unite regardless of their cultural backgrounds. 00:27 🔑 Frustration with traditional methods of protest and calls for change is expressed, with Western leaders' responses being criticized. 01:11 🔑 The importance of Muslim unity as one Ummah is stressed, with a call for an end to divisions among Muslims. 02:10 🔑 Historical context is provided, highlighting the challenges faced by the Muslim world since World War I. 02:38 🔑 The importance of unity and the need for a unified structure among Muslims are emphasized for the revival of the Muslim Ummah. 03:07 🔑 The need to address the issue of Muslim division is discussed, and the importance of allowing differences of opinion on certain issues is emphasized. 04:31 🔑 The importance of grassroots efforts in Islamic Revival is emphasized, with a focus on individual responsibility in promoting the faith. 05:56 🔑 The need for a return to the basics of faith, the Quran, and the Sunnah is highlighted for Muslim unity and revival. 08:02 🔑 Different interpretations of Islamic beliefs are discussed, with a call for tolerance and respect for differing opinions within the Muslim community. 09:02 🔑 The discussion shifts to the role of Muslim leaders and the responsibility of the Muslim Ummah in choosing leaders who prioritize Islamic values. 11:01 🔑 The importance of returning to the fundamentals of faith and developing a strong connection with Allah is highlighted for the betterment of the Ummah. 13:32 🔑 The responsibility of Muslim governments in the suffering of Muslims in places like Gaza is discussed, emphasizing the need for these governments to take action. 15:10 🔑 The call for unity among Muslims is reiterated, with an emphasis on allowing room for different interpretations of Islamic beliefs while focusing on common ground. 19:59 🔑 The importance of the entire Muslim Ummah returning to Islamic principles and values is discussed, with a call for self-improvement and responsibility. 20:12 🤔 The discussion revolves around unity in the Muslim world and the importance of common factors like Salah (prayer). 20:55 📜 Salafis emphasize belief in the Quran, the Prophet Muhammad, and his Sunnah. They respect the early generations but don't necessarily reject those with differing views. 21:28 🕌 Different Islamic scholars, like Malik, Shafi, or Ahmed, represent various schools of thought, but followers should respect the diversity within Islam. 22:51 🌍 Blaming the problems of the Muslim world solely on individuals not praying is simplistic. The colonial powers' historical actions still affect the region today. 24:29 💬 Colonial powers had a role in establishing certain leaders in the Muslim world, but the responsibility for their actions rests with the leaders themselves and the citizens. 25:13 🤝 Muslims should engage with leaders, military personnel, and people of influence to give them da'wah (religious advice) and encourage positive change. 26:54 🤝 Disagreements within the Muslim community are counterproductive; unity is essential for addressing common challenges. 27:34 🤲 Praying is just one example, but it symbolizes a broader issue - a lack of focus on religious values and ethics. 28:16 🛡️ The focus should be on addressing core issues like avoiding major sins, rather than just political actions and blaming external forces. 29:36 💡 While historical colonial actions have had an impact, Muslims today must take responsibility for their own issues and not solely blame external powers. Made with HARPA AI

@-Black-White-

7 ай бұрын

Najo...

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

@kalijasin

7 ай бұрын

Handing Muslims over to be massacred is Not doing the work of peace and justice.

@ContreLesZouaves

7 ай бұрын

الخونة عملاء آل سعود خرجوا من جحورهم Traitors, agents of the Al Saud, came out of their holes قال صلى الله عليه وسلم: "لا تزال طائفة من أمتي على الدين ظاهرين، لعدوهم قاهرين، لا يضرهم من خالفهم إلا ما أصابهم من لأواء، حتى يأتيهم أمر الله. وهم كذلك"، قالوا: يا رسول الله وأين هم؟ قال: "ببيت المقدس وأكناف بيت المقدس" He, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, said: “A group of my nation will continue to adhere to the religion, victorious over their enemy, and those who oppose them will not harm them except the calamities that have befallen them, until the command of God comes to them. And they are like this.” They said: O Messenger of God, and where are they? He said: “In Bayt al-Maqdis and the outskirts of Bayt al-Maqdis.”

@shahreyar_yahya

7 ай бұрын

@@syedbaqir2687ya miskeen…you are going into every comment reply section and puking your unreliable claim. You have been asked to bring the proof for ur claim why don’t u do that instead of vomiting ur stupidity in everyone’s comment???!!!

The last thing we need at the moment is disunity. There are just differences of opinion like any human has. May Allah have mercy on us all.

@reality-now

7 ай бұрын

Absolutely, what a waste of time and energy !

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

You can't deny there already is disunity. But what we need is to Unite on the straight path. No shirk no bid'ah no polytheism. Only Tawhid☝️

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

@TravelBandit

7 ай бұрын

​​@@syedbaqir2687 If someone does takfeer and curses the wife of our Prophet SAW, which is his most beloved person and his honor, you think theyre "muslim"?..

@kalijasin

7 ай бұрын

It is not permissible to perform takfir mu`ayyan without indisputable evidence, authority, and due process.

This is not the time, nor the place! Each and every single one of us needs to be united for Palestine. Have some shame. In Chicago, a six-year-old Palestinian boy was stabbed 26 times with a 12 inch knife.. Where are our leaders? They shouldn’t be arguing right now!

Sheikh uthman has no idea how people in power get the power. People are just puppets. He was acting as if the ummah put Saudi leaders democratically to their places 😂

@ALI4801590

7 ай бұрын

he literally said how those people were put in power as their puppets perhaps you need to rewatch and listen carefully. A true muslim (momin) is not anyones puppet except that he only follow's what ALLAH has commanded. As you yourself differentiated betwenn ummah and saudi leaders can you tell me where these saudi leaders come from or did they not originate from thee same ummah? its very easy to say they are puppets....

@friendly4186

7 ай бұрын

You've no idea what he said, may be you've english problem. If you re-watch, you might understand, he clearly explained, even for dictators, they need army, and armies can do coupe and install their own kings. And the army is from people. If these army is raised from religious families, and they get in Power, they'll kick out non religious monarchs.

@friendly4186

7 ай бұрын

And your laughing emoji makes you 1st graded fool. You're laughing at Sheikh..

@safwan7346

7 ай бұрын

You make it seem like the military were created by the masses, when in reality, that isn’t the case at all. If you actually look at history, especially since WWI, it’s the few powerful forces that influence the masses. When that happens, it’s very easy for people of power to install their own puppets that act on behalf of their masters. Hence, they’re able to influence those that ENTER the military which are THE PEOPLE! The military is an establishment that is setup by the influentials bud. So is it justifiable to say that it’s the Ummah’s fault that they elected rulers that are tyrants when it’s the few that actually have the power to sway the sentiments of the people and shut up anyone & anything that try to get in their way. Doesn’t make any sense whatsoever…

@dova238

7 ай бұрын

​@@ALI4801590 The Saudi regimes grandfathers were part of defeating the Hashemites dynasty who wanted a Khilafa state in the whole Arabian peninsula. Arab revolt was an armed rebellion against the ottomans, which at the time many Muslims from outside the empire thought it was a great betrayal by the Hashemite Arabs which was led by Sharif Hussein bin Ali with the collaboration of the British empire and her "Allies" like British Raj and North African colonies who were also Muslims fighting against Ottoman Muslims over holy Lands. However, you have to get the context right and why the "betrayal by the Hashemite dynasty" was justified, although collaborating with the unbeliever's (i.e. British empire) was a grave mistake which would bite them in the back in the future. In the late Ottoman Empire, Sultan Abdul Hamid II’s reign (1876-1909) particularly stands out for attaching greater importance to his Arab subjects. Abdul Hamid II would pay due attention to enlisting their loyalty, He did this by strengthening the Islamic foundation of the empire as the common bond between Arabs and Turks, he took a keen interest in Arab provinces; he ensured that their governors and other senior officials were paid higher salaries and were more experienced and better qualified than most of their colleagues serving elsewhere. He placed profound importance on the provinces of the Hejaz and Syria. 47.3 percent of the empire’s railroads built during his reign, spanning 2,350 kilometres, were in the Hejaz and Syria. The Arabs were not merely ‘subject people of the empire’, controlled by the sultan through force, but, instead, were ‘collaborators in the imperial project’. In 1908, Sultan Abdul Hamid II appointed Sharif Hussein bin Ali from Hashimite family, as Emir of Makkah. He was close allies with Abdulhamid II, which is why he got appointed as Emir of the Holy Lands. Undoubtedly, the reports of his benevolence were well known among the Arabs and his praise circulates on their tongues. Thus, many prayed for him and think well of him, they saw numerous good deeds were occurring through his hands. He was the Servant of the Two Holy Cities. God had enlightened his eyes by the blessings of these two cities. As such, while real political power layed in the capital of Constantinople, the relationship between Ottoman Sultans and their Sunni Arab subjects, at least up to the early twentieth century, was one of close collaboration. Sunni Arabs recognised that they had a stake in the continuation of the empire and prayed for its success. in the Young Turk Revolution in 1908 which led to Abdul Hamid capitulating and getting ousted of power in 27 april 1909. The Young Turks had now gained direct control of the Ottoman Empire with the sultan (Mehmed V) playing a merely titular role. The Ottoman Arabs’ close connection to Sultan Abdul Hamid II stood in sharp contrast to the ambivalence they felt for the CUP; the CUP (Committee of Union and Progress) were firmly committed to pursuing nationalistic reforms in the empire which caused many displacements and genocides of ethnic minorities in the empire. Following the sultan’s deposition, Sharif Hussein’s relationship with the CUP began to decline. The CUP had attempted to enforce an increasingly centralising policy on the Hejaz, encroaching upon the province’s special status and privileges and undermining the Sharif’s authority. The rupture in relations, however, came when the CUP propelled the Ottoman Empire to enter World War I on the side of the Central Powers against the Allies. Despite CUP desires, the inhabitants of the Hejaz were not keen to engage in hostilities. Moreover, Sharif Hussein had also discovered a CUP plot to replace him. Against this backdrop, Sharif Hussein launched his rebellion in the Hejaz against the Ottoman Turks on 2 June 1916 with the aim of securing independent statehood for the newly imagined Arab nation. Sharif Hussein justified his rebellion in religious, rather than nationalistic, terms. Hussein accused the CUP of betraying the Islamic basis of the Ottoman state and contravening the preservation of the historical rights of the two holy cities. Rather than a secular Arab nation-state, Sharif Hussein was more interested in creating an Islamic polity based on the Sunni model of a caliphate. British Secretary of State for War, appealed to Emir Abdullah, one of Sharif Hussein’s sons, for assistance in the Allied war effort, enticing him with the prospect of an Arab caliphate: ‘If the Arab nation assists England in this war that has been forced upon us by Turkey, England will guarantee that no internal intervention takes place in Arabia and will give the Arabs every assistance against external foreign aggression. It may be that an Arab of the true race will assume the Caliphate at Mecca or Medina and so good may come by the help of God out of all evil which is now occurring.’ Little did the Sharif know, however, that the British were concurrently engaging in secret negotiations with the French, beginning in November 1915, to discuss the post-war fate of Ottoman territories. The final agreement, concluded in May 1916, would infamously come to be known as the Sykes-Picot Agreement. Under the terms of the agreement, the Ottoman territories that encompassed present-day Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Iraq were to be divided into various French- and British-administered areas with Palestine acknowledged as an international zone (it would later come under British administration). With the Bolshevik revolution in Russia, the Soviets immediately withdrew from the war as a member of the Allies and leaked the agreement to the Russian press in November 1917. Several days later, the full text was published in the Manchester Guardian. Jamal Pasha, the wartime Ottoman Governor of Syria, exposed the agreement in a public speech in Beirut in December, declaring Hussein to be a traitor to Islam. How ironic was his comments given that the pasha(general) himself was unaware he was following orders from Kaffir's(CUP). Many of the former Arab territories of the Ottoman Empire, would be replaced by Western colonialism. Indeed, the emergence of the modern Middle East and many of its conflicts, most notably the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, are a direct consequence of the decisions taken by the great powers during and in the immediate of aftermath of the First World War. When the post-war settlement on the fate of Ottoman territories had been revealed and the scale of betrayal became evident, Hazrat Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad (ra) wrote: ‘Undoubtedly, those same people who are happy with this decision, or their future generations, will look back on this treaty and lower their heads in shame. Just as future generations tend to look back at historical events and the decisions taken by their forefathers with bitterness and indignation, so too will the future generations of the Allies look back at the present decision with shock and remorse.’

hello! just a muslim brother from Saudi Arabia! the answer of how this conflict will end is simple! its so simple, no one noticed it! its mentioned that a companion once said! I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) saying, "Straighten your rows; otherwise, Allah will create dissension among you." [Al- Bukhari and Muslim]. i see it everyday when im praying at the mosque people dont even try, they dont even try to line up properly to pray and that's why our hearts are different and divied. prayers aren't a redhairing, its the difference between islam and disbelief! may allah guides us all.

Like the old saying goes: If the foundation is not solid, the walls will eventually crumble. Sheik Uthman is 💯 correct.

@goldenbrown3283

7 ай бұрын

Sheikh uthman is the one crumbling the wall with his lies !!! He has been caught out so many times but his ego gets the better of him !!!. No good reading something five times a day that you don't understand !!!!. Muslims do not understand the Qur'an . They just give it lip service !!!!.

@abutalsafuba2179

7 ай бұрын

I dont think Sh Usta diasgreed. He was giving the solutions to current problems. And Sh Uthman was reiterating an important point, but not mentioning the solution.

@ContreLesZouaves

7 ай бұрын

الخونة عملاء آل سعود خرجوا من جحورهم Traitors, agents of the Al Saud, came out of their holes قال صلى الله عليه وسلم: "لا تزال طائفة من أمتي على الدين ظاهرين، لعدوهم قاهرين، لا يضرهم من خالفهم إلا ما أصابهم من لأواء، حتى يأتيهم أمر الله. وهم كذلك"، قالوا: يا رسول الله وأين هم؟ قال: "ببيت المقدس وأكناف بيت المقدس" He, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, said: “A group of my nation will continue to adhere to the religion, victorious over their enemy, and those who oppose them will not harm them except the calamities that have befallen them, until the command of God comes to them. And they are like this.” They said: O Messenger of God, and where are they? He said: “In Bayt al-Maqdis and the outskirts of Bayt al-Maqdis.”

@abdellatifaitbihi1774

7 ай бұрын

@@abutalsafuba2179 usta has an agenda: egypt didn't start a lost war against israel and the west so egyptians have to have war against the egyptian army and destroy their country. make no mistake he's carefully chosen egypt and jordan, he could of chose turkey. there is one majority sunni islam but there r other religions or islams. Mixing them all, like this Ikwani is trying to do, and ignoring that their faith on Allah, on Quran, on prophet and on the Sahabas ... are completely divergent is just rediculous. even within the same sunni islam, you can find a drunk loser who stands there and claim that if the president or king was not in power, he would go and free palestine and he can't even make his wife cover her legs

@penguinman38

7 ай бұрын

The solution he gave in the debate would honestly cause more harm than good. He blamed Egypt regarding the Rafah crossing when that isn’t even Egypt’s fault. He jumps the gun and used arguments that sound eloquent but are not sound Islamically and even from a political perspective.

I think Shaykh Uthman is conflating two separate issues. Inadequacies in adherence to Islamic practices by the Muslim ummah should not remove blame from the tyrants who seem to be ruling all of our Muslim countries from Pakistan all the way to Egypt. Besides, even if we agree to just stick to strengthening our imaan and practices, we would still be required to condemn, call out, and move against the evil actions of our so-called leaders, as we do have a sahih hadith that asks Muslims to point out and stop evil by hand. If not that, then by speech, and if not that, then at least by hating it in our hearts. Shaykh Uthman has done something similar with Brother Haqiqatjou, and now he seems to be doing it again here.

@donotaskmemyname3902

7 ай бұрын

Othman is a narrow minded and malignant madkhali. May Allah expose him.

@Bananas-PEELED

7 ай бұрын

he is a hard line salafi who has to parrot certain stances sadly. This is the najdi fitna our beloved Peace and Blessings be upon him warned us about in an authentic hadith, blessed are the people of Yemen (thrice), cursed is najd, for the horn of shaitan is from najd.

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

No shirk and no bid'ah. That's what salafiyyah is. Follow the Quran and sunnah with the understanding of the salaf as-salih

@nutzhazel

7 ай бұрын

But that's the main point. Inadequate Islamic knowledge of the Muslims ummah will only produce Muslims leaders with inadequate knowledge in Islam. Muslims with inadequate knowledge in Islam won't know what exactly they're protesting for or if their call against the Islamic government is within the Islamic teachings or just following the democracy or liberal line of thinking. To produce good, just and religious future Muslims leaders we need to start from the ummah, otherwise we will keep continuing to put anyone as leaders and then blame them when everything went wrong.

@Hikmah1995

6 ай бұрын

Bro the leaders are from the ppl. If the leader is corrupt than the ppl also are! Blaming leaders does not solve the issue. Also we must hear and obey the leader like the Prophet S’Allahu Alayhi Wa Salam told us unless they command us to do kufr

title of this video makes Shaykh Mehmet Usta bad person and creates that notion before attenting to the video itself, so please rename it. As Shaykh Uthman himself in the video said, their opion just differs, their point of views differ, but the intention is the same just the approach is different, Shaykh Mehmet Usta is not just saying words here, you can see the senserity in his behaviour (btw i don't have 'ilmul ghayb that's what i sensed) so in my opinion title should be changed smth like "2 Shaykhs are exchanging their views and trying to find a solution for todays trials" or smth like that. Jazakallah khair

@nahinisrat1182

7 ай бұрын

Agreed 100%

@Bananas-PEELED

7 ай бұрын

but one is a sheikh and the other isnt, by his own admission and by the fact he cant even read, write or speak arabic at a basic level T_T

@Servantofraheem

7 ай бұрын

@@Bananas-PEELED well, on this one i have no knowledge, but both of them had good points, but Mehmet Usta going extreme with his idea but had a good point

@Bananas-PEELED

7 ай бұрын

@@Servantofraheem Yes brother, I agree they both have good solid points, the Muslims really need to unite and improve their pillars individually and as a collective!

@nutzhazel

7 ай бұрын

Agreed 💯 I thought I would be listening to an argument, instead it's just a matter of different opinions to solve a common problem.

May Allah bless you Sheikh Uthmaan. You spoke Haqq. People will quote Ghandi that you have to "be the change you want to see in the world" when our Prophet pbuh was that example 1400 years ago.

Some people shouldn't talk about geopolitics. They're so narrow minded.

Alhamdulilah 🤲 for Islam May Allah swt bless you brother's

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

Some of y’all don’t understand sheikh uthman The Quran and sunnah overrides everything. Can’t be emotional How many of you pray Fajr in the mosque or Fajr on time How many of u miss prayer at work Sooooo many. How many free mix and go to protest begging humans lol… Think about it. We are soo far away from the deen Only Allah can help us. Return back to true deen and Allah will give us victory

@hattorihanzo7937

7 ай бұрын

Ghuraba are ghuraba for a reason

its true.....we Muslims congregate in 5 times prayers....but once dispersed we r mostly not united.....the meaning of the solah has to be carried out amongst Muslims being united

@user-wk7iv8he2l

7 ай бұрын

There is no 5 ritualistic Salaat in the Quran. The Salaat described in the Quran by Allah is so spiritual fulfilling. The Quran is complete and has everything in it you need. Unlearn the Tasfeer and the Hadith, those are Jewish and biblical versions... The Quran may seem on the superficial layer similar to those story´s, but only for those who rush in it´s interpretation!!!!

There needs to be way more conversations like this. So people can be clear about different opinions. Muslims should not shy away from such conversations providing thry are as cordial as this one. You do not need to take sides. I personally mostly agree with Sk Uthman however i do get the grievance of Sk Mehmet i do agree with one point that dawah should also be extended to those who are in influential position and leadership positions. Change beings with ones self.

My Pashtun Afghani grandfather used to say,"one Allah, one Quran, and one flag!"

As muslim layman watching this, i can see how divided we are.😢

@Dofaa

7 ай бұрын

we are not divided...that's called Jahl of Quran and Sunna...ignorance in most people...may God protect us from ignorance...

@SuomiHamalainen

6 ай бұрын

@@Dofaa So who's the jahl? The people doing nothing while our mandem our getting obliterated, or the people criticizing the rulers for not doing anything for the mandem?

Completely agree with Sheikh Usta. He is trying to revive the hearts of the lions of Islam, and the politicians. A bystander is as guilty as the perpetrator

@Life_Is_A_Test

7 ай бұрын

Look at Afghanistan in isolation did Allah (swt) gave them victory? So many super powers tried to conquer but all failed. Now do they have any duty for the Ummah. From Prophet Muhammad (sws) hadith so far I know they will join Imam Mehedi. If I am not mistaken them other than Khorasan.

@BlizzardOfSeptember

7 ай бұрын

@@Life_Is_A_Test Ok... but what does this have to do with my comment. I don't even understand whether you're for or against my point.

@Life_Is_A_Test

7 ай бұрын

I agree with you, but I just mentioned the Afghanistan as a practical sign of victory with sticking to Quran and Sunnah.

@noumanqureshi8489

7 ай бұрын

​@@Life_Is_A_Testask the Afghan people and they want the liberal west to return.

@Life_Is_A_Test

7 ай бұрын

@@noumanqureshi8489 how do you know? Muslims personally like to live as per Islam. But USA/ Europe they interfere with their politics and put Govt. Whatever suits them. That's why any leader want to run according to Islam people are happy. But western countries don't want that.

"..getting rid of one tyrant just gonna bring another tyrant.." this completely sold me.

This wasn't heated. They simply had a disagreement and spoke on their differences. The word "heated" has a negative connotation, and I don't think it is appropriate to apply that to this discussion. In my opinion, its very easy to assume by the title, if taken at face value, that the 2 Shaykh's disagreement was a bigger deal than it actually was. The title is a little misleading, and things like this could potentially lead to further separation across the ummah.

Yes, it's correct that we can't launch a successful campaign against the oppressors if we are not praying or abiding by the main aspects of Islam in majority. (What Sheikh Usman meant to say.) And it's also correct that the people in power in the government and in the military ranks are families that inherited the power from their colonial masters. (What Sheikh Mehmet Sh said) Both have to be fixed at the same time.

@breal101

7 ай бұрын

Wrong you are living in fantasy land. It's people with non educated opinions like yourself that delay the help of Allah. First the people must change, then everything else will change naturally. Allah Does not change the state of a people until they first change their own state. You can be stubborn all you want In calling for the leaders of governments to be over thrown and Muslims killing Muslims, either directly or indirectly, but it is those people that are a stain on the ummah and prolong the suffering of Muslims. They are the direct cause of Muslims dying in Palestine. They are the cancer.

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

Why blame the rulers when we ourselves are worse. we don't know the basic principles of our religion , some of us are liberals, people of innovation etc. We disgrace ourselves and took our religion as joke. May Allah the almighty forgive us and put us on the straight path. The only way to unite and be successful is to follow Qur'an and sunnah with the understanding of the salaf as-salih

@ThePaahchan

7 ай бұрын

​@@LearnTawhidBecause rulers policy allowed us to be in this position. I was irreligious, liberal in some aspects because of our education system. Until Allah SWT guided me back. Alhamdulillah.

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

@@ThePaahchan I'm not speaking up for the rulers but they didn't force you to stop reading Qur'an and understanding Tawhid. You can easily listen to fatawa of major scholars. So stop blaming everyone else beside yourself. The ruler is not an angel but make dua for them and yourself that Allah guides you on the straight path. The path of the salaf as-salih. Salafiyyah Qur'an and sunnah.

@ThePaahchan

7 ай бұрын

@@LearnTawhid Maybe I wasn't clear enough. I was practicing before I wasn't anymore. Then I am again. Since I was young, all the society around me, even religious leaders are conditioned to think our system is "normal". I'm talking about early 90's to 2000s here. My mum and dad era from the 80s and 90s(since post-liberation era in the 50s), they said Muslims during that time don't know that alcohol is forbidden. They don't know Hijab is obligatory. Until our prime minister change the policy of religious education is mandatory in the public education. His wife starts wearing Hijab and citizens start to follow. My mum said that's when they know about Hijab. So yes, the leaders still have that post-colonial mentality. Rulers should be blamed the most because they have the power to control and influence all. Of course, we should blame ourselves too but not without put the number one blame on the policy-maker.

Maybe this coming together and discussing these topics is beneficial. But people do get confused easily for lack of ilm

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

@Nanou-zw7vh

7 ай бұрын

​​@@syedbaqir2687 Maybe you don't understand the reality of the shia sect

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

@@Nanou-zw7vh I do and they on right path since Prophet said that my ahlul bayt is like ship of Noah(AS). The only sect with most ahadith and close to ahlul bayt are shias

@Nanou-zw7vh

7 ай бұрын

@@syedbaqir2687 So, you're rally don't Know!!!

@Nanou-zw7vh

7 ай бұрын

@@syedbaqir2687 Je vais écrire en français, je suis plus à l'aise avec ma langue maternelle. Alors les chiites rejettent les compagnons du prophète, ils insultes la mère des croyantes Aicha, ils idolâtrent Anli et ses fils Hassan et hussein. Il appellent après eux et les invoquent. Ils disent que le Qurane actuel a été falsifié. Leurs égarements sont tellement nombreux الله المستعان

A while back i used to have the same view as Sheikh Usta but after I started really learning about Islam beyond the school level I came to realise that our success definitely lies in coming back to Quran and Sunnah first and then mobilize. If for eg a bad leader is removed he will simply be replaced by another corrupt one from amongst us.

Very Good conversation.

I agree with brother Uthman. Without Allah swa support, we have no chance of victory. We are out numbered , and over powered. Allah swa will not change our condition, until we change ourselves.

@annonymousghostdetector8425

7 ай бұрын

true

@elafzal5866

7 ай бұрын

This ummah has been reduced to being keyboard warriors, chanting slogans, putting " i love my prophet" in dp's and doing jihad on social media and protesting with lefties holding up flags but abandoning the prayer Qu'ran and Sunnah and they expect victory.

There can be no unity until we individually return back to the understanding and implementation of the companions starting with our hearts then with our actions, period.

@mdfahd24

6 ай бұрын

Such an impractical statement.

@Polster-lx5ph

3 ай бұрын

​@@mdfahd24Grow up. So ridiculous

@mrmsali2667

3 ай бұрын

This is the highest ignorant of you and like those who blame the Muslims. ummah Really, you can't be more ridiculous than this!

@mdfahd24

3 ай бұрын

@@Polster-lx5ph What? He's literally making no sense. There is no way practical, every individual whole of society turns back to Allâh - Munāfiqun existed everytime, this wasn't even approach of RasūlAllahﷺ to fulfil the fard of establishing the governance of Islām, which all the Taghūti regimes today propogate. You need enough amount of righteous people and power to establish Khilāfah ala Minhajun Nabuwah which fulfils so many Fardul Kifayah of Ummah until then we are all living in Jāhiliyyah as stated by RasūlAllahﷺ. You should educate yourself instead of acting as ignorant.

@Polster-lx5ph

3 ай бұрын

@@mdfahd24 Rejection of the hadith. Following the salaf is the goal as mentioned in the hadith, obviously people like you find the sunnah incredibly difficult upon yourself. It is a proof against you. Your understanding of the Khilafah is incredibly weak and plain wrong.

Very good illustration of the source of difference between Muslims and Muslim Brotherhood.

@safwan7346

7 ай бұрын

Wdym by difference between Muslims and MB? How do you know this sheikh is from Muslim Brotherhood habibi? Did you verify that he’s part of that group? Did you ask him? It’s better to verify instead making assumptions you have no evidence for and follow the example of our prophet saw when it comes to these kinds of actions. Have a nice day.

Both raised good points

First time I do not agree with Shaekh Uthman

@mrmsali2667

3 ай бұрын

Because Ustan Uthman is totally ignorant about politically and it is a shame and such people shouldn't talk about a subject that they aren't capable and no knowledge. The problem is just because the great dawah carrier doesn't make him or her knows every every subject in Islam. I am greatly disappointed and fully disagree with Ustad.

The whole ummah doesn't have to be good because it's always a small group which rise up and shepherd the herd.

We need these kinds of frank talks. Some groups have hijacked the arena and want the entire vast playground left for them. Any disagreement with them warrants a ticket to hell fire. Arrogance is their norm. Either my way or the highway. They always bully, harass and intimidate those who differ with them. They waste their resources, energy on these trivial issues. I wish we all come together and use our resources wisely instead of throwing dust on each other. May Allah guide us all

What can we do if the muslim leaders dont' act? For example saving the innocent Palestinians from the unjust oppression when neighbouring muslim countries do not help.

Not a heated debate, more like a difference in interpreting history and results

@penguinman38

7 ай бұрын

But it has to be called out that Mehmet Usta’s interpretation of history was over generalized which can lead to dangerous conclusions. May Allah protect us.

Remove your divisive title. Stop promoting disunity. Unity in the ummah is what we need right now

The Quran says “do not divide yourselves into sects, each celebrating what they have”

Unity comes first. You can't have a Jummah or Janaza by telling muslims to fix themselves without the community comming together to actually learn and be guided.

Both the tactics should be applied.... First dawah and then accountability of the leaders.

@muslimsakemuslim7956

7 ай бұрын

We dont need to blame anyone. When the ummah becomes better either the leaders will change with better ones or they will better themselves as the ummah progresses. We have to aknowledge that the leaders are just like us the people, they follow same trends and lifestyle so how can we expect someone like Umar or Sallahussin to come out of nowhere.

@kalingtekseng3489

7 ай бұрын

@@muslimsakemuslim7956 that will take decades.... the suffering people don't have that much of time.... don't you see how the non believers operate to dominate others.... they certainly aren't loved by Allah but they do what they have to do.... we must unite and at the same time all changes must be in line with Islam..... the leaders are to blame.... they hold the power, can a common man intervene on such a stage or is it easier for the leader of Nations.... don't you see USA and Russia, how it entered this war although it's intervention is illegitimate.... and how Russia is fighting the whole of Europe on its own..... It's the leader who leads and it's courageous. Iran is doing better for Palestine than most of other countries.

@masudsaleh5155

Ай бұрын

We have been doing dawah for years, but we don't hold our leaders accountable

@kalingtekseng3489

Ай бұрын

@@masudsaleh5155 what's that supposed to mean? Not interested in you, just the rulings. The great sheikhs speak up against corrupt leaders. They have been studying for years. They end up in jails for speaking the truth. We can't be sheep to people, only follow Allah and the messenger that's it.

"What is Unity in Islam? - Discussion with Shaykh Uthman and Shaykh Mehmet Usta" I think it's good titles. Tbh they both on the same page, it's just they explain it in the way they see it. But they on the same page basically.

@kinanisam4345

7 ай бұрын

No, they are not. One is blaming the victim people and one is blaming those in power who were brought by the colonials.

A state is the best mechanism to educate the masses - not groups For those who don’t pray then there is hudood and tahzir which can only be implemented by a legitimate authority

Lets improve our Islam within us and remain silent! who is with me?

I love Sheikh uthman but I have to agree with Mehmet. It’s like Uthman doesn’t want to provide solutions. Of course we should pray this is a given. It’s just weird that he doesn’t want to mention things like Egypt closing their borders and how other countries don’t speak out.

@cobansalat

7 ай бұрын

Uthmans solutions are from quran and sunnah and backed up by real knowledge and proven by historic and recent events. The human is somtimes lazy by nature and in denial. Always blame others: the west, zionists, rulers. Who puts the ruler in place? God only. The ruler is same like the people. We have to change ourselfs thats the only solution. But very uncomfortable so we blame others

@mdashekerabbi8308

7 ай бұрын

everyone agrees with Mehmed that we should unite, but when it comes to practicality sheikh Uthman disagrees.

@kittyyycattt8726

7 ай бұрын

​@@mdashekerabbi8308why cant one not fight or revolt against the taghout rulers and Thier evil scholars "But but but they are salafis"😂

@mdashekerabbi8308

7 ай бұрын

@@kittyyycattt8726what?

@kittyyycattt8726

7 ай бұрын

@@mdashekerabbi8308 uthman farook is taking away the blame from the Taghout Rulers and thier Evil Scholars

People are not looking for knowledge anymore they just want Drama

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

Learn from the scholars upon the way of the salaf as-salih. Ahlusunnah. Learn starting with Tawhid. And know what's shirk

Monetizing from This ? Why the hell ads are keep coming

Imam Malik (d. 179H) said: "The latter part of this Ummah will not be rectified except by that which rectified its earliest part."

I completely disagree with Sheikh Uthman. He believes like many like him that the companions of the Prophet were almost angels while we have the historical evidence of disunity among companions, acts which are unislamic by muslim commanders and many other examples which is an evidence that Muslims were Humans afterall. And it the wholistic approach towards life, a natural approach towards survival, is what lead to Allah's victory being granted to Muslims. We need the same today. Correcting our individual acts isnt enough.

@hattorihanzo7937

7 ай бұрын

Correcting individual acts is for everyone for life thats what people need to understand. To react when urgent need is another thing. Its similar to seeing a crime and just watching people film and do nothing

“Verily, Allah will not change the (good) condition of a people as long as they do not change their state (of goodness) themselves (by committing sins and by being ungrateful and disobedient to Allah)” [al-Ra’d 13:11]

@syedbaqir2687

7 ай бұрын

This hypocrite shaykh uthman is calling shias muslims mushrik and even kafir and quotes weak ahadith ignoring important ones like hadith of Ghadeer hadith of saqlain hadtih of saqlain hadith of cloth

Brother Usta and brother Uthman are both right and wrong cause the leaders hold a great responsibility into protecting their ummah which are just sitting there eating and sleeping with ease astaghfrullah. Plus the ummah also ain't doing nothing when they should all get together and make our leaders make moves and stand up for our Islam, Muslims and most important for our Iman.

I agree with sheikh Uthman I saw people seating in front of the restaurant while people are praying in a Muslim country

100% we're supposed to be united and we ain't doing JACK!! We need to get together and do something.

@rcc5547

7 ай бұрын

Unite upon what exactly? Are you willing to unite or put a Muslim leader in power who who supplicate to the dead? Or a leader who insults our mother Ayesha??? Or a person who prefers secular politics vs what Allah has revealed?

@DestinyAwaits19

7 ай бұрын

@@rcc5547 Exactly.

@mdfahd24

6 ай бұрын

​@@rcc5547Unite upon which Sahaba United. Simple as that. Quran and Mutawatir Ahadith gives you whole Aqeedah and methodology of System of Islām from social issues to Economics to Military campaigns to foreign policies. What you talking Abt?

@rcc5547

6 ай бұрын

@@mdfahd24 the same Thing you’re talking about.

Sure Unity is extremely important but it does NOT trump, in the hierarchy of Islam’s priorities, the establishment of fundamental practice and correct doctrine. Brother Uthman is exactly right. The model of the Messenger ﷺ and the Salaf is without question the only model to emulate.

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

No bid'ah no shirk no kufr, every muslim should know that the evidences and proofs are in Quran and sunnah with the understanding of the salaf as-salih . Only upon the straight path can we all unite

@enz23Truth

7 ай бұрын

​@@LearnTawhidThats what the khwarij do, accuse fellow Muslims with such labels while thinking themselves as the most pious rightly guided people. Arrogance and pride has diseased their heart.

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

@@enz23Truth those labels kufr mushrik bid'ah are in the hadiths what are you talking about?

@elafzal5866

7 ай бұрын

​@@enz23TruthMisguided people throw this khawarij or wahabi card to defend their misguidance. Why dont you own up to the fact and reality that the way of the salaf is the only way. Period.

@enz23Truth

7 ай бұрын

@elafzal5866 the self claimed righteous people who you claim to be in the truth are always spitting venom and judging others more than they bring their self to accountability, because they think their perfect. Very dangerous mentality to have. Trust me I've been there.

We need both to be activated, but need more effort on the ruler side.

Very interesting.. I feel both have good valid points in this

Protest works sheikh uthman. Its sad hearing from uthman a pashtu not believing in resistance . Subhanallah

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

Did the sahaba protest? Evidence?

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

There's a difference between those who actually follow Islam and those who follow the disbelievers. I've heard and seen disbelievers protest, but I've never heard of the salaf protesting for their rights staqfurulah

@enddaoccupation

7 ай бұрын

@Abdalfatah. the history of Islam is not only the sahaba. This narrow way of thinking.

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

The history of the perfect generations of muslims are the sahaba and the salaf mentioned in this hadith. We follow Qur'an and sunnah with the understanding of these salaf as salihiin. Sahih al-Bukhari 6429 Narrated `Abdullah: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "The best people are those of my generation, and then those who will come after them (the next generation), and then those who will come after them (i.e. the next generation), and then after them, there will come people whose witness will precede their oaths, and whose oaths will precede their witness."

@swordofallah5431

7 ай бұрын

Protest isn't the same as resistance..

What i see here is Sheikh Mehmet taking about the short term solution and Sheikh Uthman taking about the long term solution Both are correct and both can be implemented

@muslimsakemuslim7956

7 ай бұрын

Both are not correct. One is only blaming the leaders while the other showing that the whole ummah is lost which is true. The other guy are talking like the muslim leaders are not part of their population. If the population are weak in iman how are supposed to think we will get a better leader? Even if we get a good leader how is gonna rule when the people are lost, they would kill him for going against their desires just like they did against Uthman and Ali.

@friendly4186

7 ай бұрын

For me, short term looks not so good, simply it'll fail, how will you convince sisi? He'll execute you if you say anything to him. He is modern day Qaarun, And US is pheros empire.

@LearnTawhid

7 ай бұрын

There is no easy way out, no short term. You can't skip Tawhid and the manhaj of the prophets and the salaf as-salih. You have to learn and implement the basics for us to Unite on The Truth

@OCEAN-fc9wl

7 ай бұрын

Long term > short term

@dan138zig

7 ай бұрын

​​@@LearnTawhidThe issue is when this so called "manhaj" people think they hold the only truth and key to jannah. When they have more acceptance of differences then we can unite

There is no unity without common foundations and objectives.

@penguinman38

7 ай бұрын

Exactly! And unity has to be based on the Quran. The Sunnah. Uthman bin Farooq was in the right here.

They are arguing & agreeing about the same thing. The people not just the leaders need to wake up.

What is this Seikh saying, Egyptians blocking aid to Gaza? Seikh they literally are not allowing foreigners to cross into the rafah border into Egypt until they can allow the aid to be delivered to Gaza. In terms of Egypt not allowing Palestinians to come into Sinai is simply because Egypt was the Palestinians to stay firm on their land and not move from it, otherwise it’ll be stolen like all the other parts of Palestine, even the Hamas leader thanked Egypt for its stance and said that “we will not move from our land”. If anything Egypt is doing the most to help Palestine.

@dova238

7 ай бұрын

Oh yh Egypt is helping whilst Muslims Bredrin are dying from bombs in ghaza

@nutzhazel

7 ай бұрын

Yup, Eqypt knows what is at stake there. If the Palestinians move out from Gaza, they will be no more Palestine.

@AbdelFlix

7 ай бұрын

@@dova238 they cannot move out of Gaza. That’s their whole plan!

@eddyyusuf7034

7 ай бұрын

So egypt wants Palestinians to get massacred ? Or does it make sense to open the border and save the lives

@masudsaleh5155

Ай бұрын

​@@AbdelFlix🤡

Shaykh Uthman is on point.

@ash-bj1qc

7 ай бұрын

You are right! lets improve our Islam within us and remain silent!

@mdfahd24

6 ай бұрын

Naah. He making childish excuses to avoid actual work.

I don't understand. Why don't do both at the same time?

I just don't understand why we cant point out the wrong actions of our leaders instead we should just work on ourselves and hope for change

@oulangkous718

6 ай бұрын

Because u don't have the full picture. Your government might be captured and leader with a gun to his back. What good is your criticism then? Make Dua and make dawah and raise donations.

Who put them in power "the colonialist". As simple as that. Shaykh uthman comes across as a sellout on this topic. How can you not criticize these rulers, when you see saudi making deals with israel. The ummah is getting stronger and we see that by all the support palestine gets, but what can the people do when the leaders are puppets? W Shaykh Mehmet on this

@ARM4170

7 ай бұрын

I love sheikh Uthamn's Dawa and he is appreciated for that. But he is far too reserved when mentioning the tyrannical puppets that don't give a thought about the Ummah. Likes of Aal Saud who were aided by the colonial british to stay in power. Sh Uthman should not be silent on tyrants. That is aiding them.

@nutzhazel

7 ай бұрын

Arabs Muslims are only 20% from the total Muslim population in the world. Your use of "we" for the Arabs to represent the Ummah is highly misleading.

I follow shiek uthman but i majorly disagree with him in this whole conversation and agree with brother mehmet who i have just seen in this video for the first time. Shame that has uthman has madkhali beliefs.i will stop following inshallah

@zainzoala1083

26 күн бұрын

Please fear Allah and stop disrespecting labelling Muslims

@kingslayar5

26 күн бұрын

@@zainzoala1083 😂😂😂😂 sorry I don't speak stupid, reading your sentence hurt my brain.

@kingslayar5

26 күн бұрын

@@zainzoala1083may Allahs curse be upon all that are madkhali 👍

Sheikh Utsa is right on one thing, blame the corrupt leaders placed by the colonialists, as someone who lives in a country with a corrupt leader i can vouch that common people didnt elect her nor did they elect their military, both the PM and the military are sitting with their might, so dont waste time focusing on normal people, rather focus on the leaders and give them dawah or get rid of them, until they are taken care of common people will keep sleeping, but i also agree to give dawah to common people but dont focus on common people they have no power, if you blame them it will make them depressed and mentally weak

Salam brothers, polite note, please change the title from heated as this was not heated. This was a very important topic and I think the two brothers were very professional in their exchange. In fact I wish we all have discussion in this manner even if u disagree on things. Personal I for the first time agree with both sides. May Allah guide us.

@user-yj2ug4xb1k

7 ай бұрын

It did get heated though.

@ImjusSmoove

7 ай бұрын

@user-yj2ug4xb1k personally I didnt think so but that just my opinion.

It’s not the time for disunity akhi , I don’t understand what the point is in posting this

syaikh Uthman 🔥🔥☝️

I think they are both correct. Sheikh Utaman is saying collectively the ummah needs to change and at least start praying. And Sheikh Usta is saying that the people that are already praying need to do more.

@masudsaleh5155

Ай бұрын

Exactly 🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤

both are valids . BarakAllahu fikum jamiaan

Shaykh Uthman ❤❤❤❤

@ContreLesZouaves

7 ай бұрын

الخونة عملاء آل سعود خرجوا من جحورهم Traitors, agents of the Al Saud, came out of their holes قال صلى الله عليه وسلم: "لا تزال طائفة من أمتي على الدين ظاهرين، لعدوهم قاهرين، لا يضرهم من خالفهم إلا ما أصابهم من لأواء، حتى يأتيهم أمر الله. وهم كذلك"، قالوا: يا رسول الله وأين هم؟ قال: "ببيت المقدس وأكناف بيت المقدس" He, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, said: “A group of my nation will continue to adhere to the religion, victorious over their enemy, and those who oppose them will not harm them except the calamities that have befallen them, until the command of God comes to them. And they are like this.” They said: O Messenger of God, and where are they? He said: “In Bayt al-Maqdis and the outskirts of Bayt al-Maqdis.”

We need people like khalid bin walid now

@kamilmunir4218

7 ай бұрын

He would start with whipping Muslims first!! And unfortunately our own people will be the first one to run away from him. There are too many opinions, could be seen from this chat. It’s easy for us to expect a ruler like Abu Bakar but we want to stay as we are. Muslim’s affairs are not like that of a disbelieving folk. West may look United but Allah has informed us 1500 years ago that their hearts are divided. We can go on and on with our intellectual reasoning but the bitter truth is that Allah SWT has removed our fear from our enemies. It doesn’t befit Allah SWT that he would forsake the believing people and let disbelievers have the upper hand until we cross the limits of Allah SWT. We see shirk happening in our own people and we have no problem which is the greatest wrong and oppression in this universe, yet there is no reaction from us. Yes our hearts bleed when we see our Muslims brothers and sisters getting martyred by their enemies but we don’t think about the eternal hell for those amongst us that are dying on misguided beliefs which are totally alienated to Quran and Sunnah. We have seen the unity this respected guest is highlighting. Even the Palestinian resistance groups can’t get on with each other and every now and then they have to go and sit in haram and make arrangements with each other so trying to unite the whole ummah he must be day dreaming. After the soviets left the afghans killed more of their own people than Russians ever did. The only way the ummah can unite is the way the sahaba RA United and that was ‘Allah SWT United their hearts as HE SWT addresses the prophet AS ‘He brought their hearts together. Had you spent all the riches in the earth, you could not have united their hearts. But Allah has united them. Indeed, He is Almighty, All-Wise.’ The companions simply followed the instructions given to them. They didn’t steer left or right or brought their own opinions over the prophetic command. That’s how they had just rulers and people like khalid bin Waleed as their military generals. Slandering the Muslim rulers like this and calling them ‘so called Muslims’ doesn’t serve justice to anyone other than serving the interests of the enemy. It only weakens Muslim nations further. The rulers are the mirror of their own people. Allah exposes the true characteristics of a nation in the face of their rulers. Allah knows best. May Allah guide us all and unite us upon Tawheed and sunnah and aid our Muslim leaders and help our brothers and sisters who are suffering and those who have become martyred may He grant them the highest place in paradise. Ameen Salam Alaykum Warahmatullah

@oj1291

5 ай бұрын

Allah will bring these people once we turn back to his religion as Uthman said. Remember the history of the Tatars? They almost eradicated Islam, but because the Muslims sticked to the religion, الله brought forth Saif ud Deen Qutz and Baibars and we beat the Tatars alhamduillah. Returning back to the religion is the first step to unlocking these things

Is Rami in Canada? 🇨🇦 love Tim’s

Uthman wants to eradicate the root of the evil while Usta focuses on a point that will not benefit and is mere emotionalization.

Shaykh Usta is 100% on point, the thing is you can pray til your blue in the face but if you dont take practical action our situation will never change, shaykh usta is more correct Allah knows best. Shaykh Uthman is secularising islam in a way by only focusing on rituals and theology

We need to return to Islam and start loving each other again.

The other aargument doesn't X out the other. We have this mindset nowadays. Why can't we do both.

I guess now I know why brother Daniel doesn't like Sheikh Uthman at all. Look at how misinformed he is, thinking that these terrible, useless Arab leaders are a representation of us Muslims and not of the foreign powers who helped them be there in the first place by force. Look at what happened in Syria and Egypt when we tried to change the bad leaders. How many innocent people have died on the streets or had to flee to Europe, and how many international powers intervened with their armies to save the puppets in power. Sheikh Uthman needs to reconsider where he is standing. Dodging the blame, backing the kafir leaders and blaming the helpless victim people is a shameful madkhali stance on his part. He really needs to listen to brother Mehmet with an open heart without arrogance and learn. I guess spending too much time with Sneako and that so-called Warner did him absolutely no good whatsoever.

@swordofallah5431

7 ай бұрын

Where r u from? And if you're the leader,what would u do

@QuinnTheTailor

7 ай бұрын

​@@swordofallah5431 if i was muslim leader, i would arrange a meeting with all muslim nation and also invite other nations who oppose the bombing and occupation of Palestine. Going into the war with Israel will probably cause millions of deaths... because USA will help out and Israel might use nuclear bombs. So war is not an option. But there are other ways to inflict pressure. You can put embargos and sanctions in place... remember how Saudi and the UAE had sanctioned Qatar? Not allowing foods and other products to be exported into Qatar... and only because of oil and money. But when it comes to muslim lifes that are in danger. They are doing nothing. Muslim nations can unite and blockade Israel from all sides. Not exporting food, oil, electricity and other products. They can block their access to the Mediterranean. They can send aid ships to Gaza and ignore Israels warnings. What's Israel gonna do? Attack the Aid ships that 20 nations together send for help and risk declaring war to all of them?

Here's an upside with the title, people are gonna click lol 😂. But fear Allah

So basically Sh Mehmet called for unity at first, then brother Uthman gave a solution for unity which is to go back the Quran and sunnah. I agree because if we are united in iman then we could do big things, even strong enough to push our leaders to be more active. The condition right now the ummah is blaming the leaders individually without taking any effort to unify ourselves to be stronger. Instead while blaming the leaders, we also blame each others for our tiny differences in opinions. That makes us further away from unity and further away from making any changes. No one's letting any leaders off the hook. But what's an ant gonna do challenging an elephant by himself. The ants should be united first then make a challenge.

Most of ... (not all ) the Muslim leadership cares much about the dunya rather than what awaits them in front of Allah... it must be a balanced equation

I agree white the sheikh otman 100%

Typical uthman madkhali response. Guard saudi at all cost

@kinanisam4345

7 ай бұрын

I never knew that he has that side in him. Very disappointing.

@masudsaleh5155

Ай бұрын

​@kinanisam4345 He is on Saudi payroll

As human being we will argue amongst each other. But please lets not highlight it. The last thing the Ummah needs is division. We need to become 1.

Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala says: شَرَعَ لَـكُمْ مِّنَ الدِِيْنِ مَا وَصّSY بِحٖ نُوْحً وََا لَّذِيْۤ اَوْحَيْنَاۤ لَيْكَ وَمَا وَسّينَا بِٖۤ ِٖۤ ِٖرِيْمَ وَمُْوسى وَعِيْسٰى اَنْ اَقِيْمُوا الدِِيْنَ وَ لَا تَتَفَرَّقُوْا فِيْهِ ۗ كبـرَ عَلى المُشْرِكِيْينَ مَ تَدُوُوُمْ لَيْهِـ ۗ لَلَهُ يَجْتَبِيِْ الَيْهِ مَنْ يَّشَآءُ وَيَهْدِيْۤ الِلَيْهِ مَنْ يُّنِيْبُ syaro'a lakum minad-diini maa washhoo bihii nuuhaw wallaziii auhainaaa ilaika wa maa washshoinaa bihiii ibroohiima wa muusaa wa 'iisaaa an aqiimud-diina wa laa tatafarroquu fiih, kaburo 'alal-musyrikiina maa tad'uuhum ilaiih, allohu yajtabiii ilaihi may yasyaaa- u wa yahdiii ilaihi may yuniib "Allah has explained to you - among the matters of religion which He has decreed - what He has commanded Prophet Noah, and what We (Allah) have revealed to you (O Muhammad), and also what We have commanded Prophet Abraham and Prophet Moses and Prophet Isa, that is: "Establish the position of the religion, and do not be divided or disagree on the basis". It is difficult for the polytheists (to accept the religion of monotheism) that you call them to. God chooses and allows whoever He wants to accept the religion of monotheism, and give guidance to His religion whosoever refers back to Him (obediently)." (QS. Ash-Shura 42: Verse 13)

Unity ay..... Can't even talk with unity or respect on a 30 min dialogue.... How can we deal with national or global issues. I agree with the majority of comments here this video is no good take it down and let it be a message to the sheike

I totally agree with shaykh Uthman … “Verily, Allaah will not change the (good) condition of a people as long as they do not change their state (of goodness) themselves (by committing sins and by being ungrateful and disobedient to Allaah)” [al-Ra’d 13:11]

@mohamedadan5120

7 ай бұрын

One person or group can start the change.

@donotaskmemyname3902

7 ай бұрын

Wrong. as long as we are under the control of secular states and rulers we will never become better...we need to distroy these national countries and live under a united khilafa...then a muslim can improve. today education, mosques, every aspect of life is under the control of western ally rulers. Othman is spreading the Madkhali rhetoric which is opposite to what Islam teach. Why you interprest the Ayah as individuals change and not Omma as a whole change?

17:46 Sheikh Uthman where are the leaders come from?

Long time no see, brother, is something happened to you?

100% agree. Those quiet rulers in the muslim countries have to go. Shame on them for doing nothing against this. All this could not happen if the Ummah was united. We need one Caliph who rules the whole Ummah.