Is it better to build a new stadium or redevelop Old Trafford?

@yangzhang9527

2 ай бұрын

build a new stadium

@user-wx9fl6kg9l

2 ай бұрын

Build a new stadium!

@Moh4mm4dAmin

2 ай бұрын

Definitely a new stadium

@Crusader47

Ай бұрын

@@yangzhang9527 why lol

@Crusader47

Ай бұрын

@@user-wx9fl6kg9l why lol

25 years from now Manchester United will still be at the current Old Trafford actions talk loader than any words.

He's definitely right about the state of premier league stadiums

@alaskanmalamute101

Ай бұрын

Yea they suck compared to Germany and Spain..English clubs too focused on blowing all there cash on wages and transfers.

The bernabau is lit🔥🔥

@thorstenkk1983

Ай бұрын

yeah the new Bernabeu looks nice, but they will continue to have difficulty with their grass as the solution they have made dont work. The grass has not been this bad in many years and they have to figure that out. What Ratcliff said about the premier league dont have any top class stadiums like the barnebeu and nou camp is not true, as the Tottenham Hotspurs have one of the best stadiums in the world.

@mysticalA257

10 күн бұрын

@@thorstenkk1983 he meant in terms of capacity wise and looks. tottenham stadium may have the looks but not the capacity. even a worn down stadium like old trafford has more capacity than spurs

No club in England is allowed a stadium that is bigger than the National Stadium, Wembley. That is why all the stadiums are below 90k cos there not allowed to go above it. Wembley is the issue as much as its a joke, 90k for a National Stadium? when a club like ManUtd could have a 120K stadium and fill it every home match and LFC and other could probably get pretty close. That is why he wants a Wembley of the North its his way of getting round the rules, a rule that needs to be changed !!!!!!! Maybe someone will do one of those Petitions to Parliament and get them to create a committee to investigate the issue !!

@philipferguson1148

5 күн бұрын

I have looked not sure if there is that rule anymore

Why should Untied have government financial assistance? Then again, having Satan on your badge probably helps.

@prakashm1468

2 ай бұрын

Says an envious idiot

@OGCHuila

2 ай бұрын

Because they are the biggest and most successful club in England. A legacy brand comparable in stature to Madrid or Barca. Man Utd needs a fitting Stadium like the aforementioned two clubs. (Btw not a Red)

@OneEpicEric

2 ай бұрын

@@OGCHuila If they were the biggest club in the world then they don't need government assistance. Everton, Arsenal and Spurs did it on their own.

@Crusader47

Ай бұрын

@@OneEpicEric bro to be fair real madrid and barca got government assistance lol

@OneEpicEric

Ай бұрын

@@Crusader47 As much as. I love the cross of St George being on Barcelona's badge, Spanish football has nothing to do with the British tax payer.

A New Stadium with a business model similar to Santiago Bernabeu and Camp Nou capacity is the go route. The stadium will sellout anyway but hosting more events will cover for the cost of the building while giving the club much needed direction.

@rondolbalfour1856

Ай бұрын

Real Madrid and Barca didn’t build a new stadium so why should man united build a new stadium smh 🤦🏽‍♂️

@ezequielcrespofigueroa2047

Ай бұрын

@@rondolbalfour1856 RM stayed at The Bernabéu because of its location. They have also renovated that building multiple times so it has been kept in great condition throughout the years. Once the area around their training ground gets developed Real Madrid has enough land left to build a state of the art new stadium. As for Barcelona, they literally teared down 60-70% of the stadium and building everything up again. OT it’s an old building and expanding and renovating will cost way too much money plus they’ll need permission from neighbors to build on top of the railroad. A brand new stadium on the same ground they own will help the club build something that will fit the club and fans need.

@rondolbalfour1856

Ай бұрын

@@ezequielcrespofigueroa2047 okay, appreciate the info

@theend9494

Ай бұрын

yep would go with the team all foreigners

Many Premier League stadiums give me OCD.

IMO just build a new stadium at that point. I'll never understand the over the top attachment supporters have to the stadium even if its falling apart. The club = the people. Not the stadium. I also don't get why they don't build new stadiums while honouring the way the old stadium looked but making it more modern. Architecturally you can do so much but a lot of the new stadiums choose to be generic.

@Crusader47

Ай бұрын

nah i think they should just redevelop like barca and madrid cheaper and its heritage

@ama6487

Ай бұрын

liverpool fc existed solely because of anfield rent dispute with everton fc back then

Stadium So Beautiful I like it resemble Tottenham Hotspur Stadium

the reason why the uk stadiums are lacking behind is because its to expensive to build in the uk taxed to much etc.. blame the government for not helping businesses and just being greedy and councils.

Unlike Real and Barca, Manchester does not have an alternative field to play during the reconstruction. And another thing is that, Old Trafford does not have the potential to rebuild and develop like Santiago Bernabeu and Camp Nou. So the best option is to build a new stadium.

@abdirisaqjacda9305

2 ай бұрын

Why they don't have the option to renovate instead of building a whole new stadium

@Moh4mm4dAmin

2 ай бұрын

@abdirisaqjacda9305 because Old Trafford is limited from two sides. North stand is limited to a water canal, and south stand is limited to the train railway.

@abdirisaqjacda9305

Ай бұрын

@@Moh4mm4dAmin Oh that is the reason

@rondolbalfour1856

Ай бұрын

Who says they don’t have the option to renovate?

@rondolbalfour1856

Ай бұрын

This is the first I’m hearing that they don’t have the option to expansion

Multi billionaire owners but they can’t afford to build a new stadium without government help. No thank you. Not the people’s problem. Take out some more loans, you’ve got enough already, maybe pay some off first.

@Aman-mcz

2 ай бұрын

Are you mad, if you own 10k can you give 1k just like that when can get help instead.

@SimonInSanDiego

Ай бұрын

@@Aman-mcz why should tax payers money be used? Take out loans if you can afford it.

@Aman-mcz

Ай бұрын

@@SimonInSanDiego it is goverments money and they use it what for what they see fit, anyways a good stadium will increase employment, revenue and tourism which helps govt.

@MarkSmith-lu7ly

Ай бұрын

@@Aman-mczThe gov’t don’t have any money, it’s tax payers money. Why should I or anyone else for that matter pay a penny in tax to fund ManU (a privately owned company) to have a new stadium. Ratcliffe hasn’t got a clue, never going to happen!!!

@MarkSmith-lu7ly

Ай бұрын

@@Aman-mczOur government don’t have any money, its tax payers money you’re talking about and its not about to be spent on Jim Radcliffe’s play thing.

Berbabeu is epic now.

United must be careful with their move if they don't want point deduction like what happened in Everton during their stadium construction.

If this happens it would be fantastic

At present The Old Trafford Stadium is still incomplete & needs is an upgrade of the SBC stand & East & West quadrant to be completed first before you can sort out the roof. This Stadium has a lot of potential & can be one of the best stadium in Europe if not the world with the original design cos it has authentic & character with the potential capacity of at least 90K, all it needs is an refurbished & some TLC. Take Note: The Stadium Expansion Must Not Exceed the rail way track! Man Utd 's Old Trafford 'The Super Bowl of Stadiums known as 'The Theatre of Dreams' is unique & a Colossal of a stadium. Worth a View, please share! Keep it in the family!

@SuperMagnum83

Ай бұрын

It cannot be the best stadium unless it's a new build, a revamp wouldn't even be the best in Manchester much less the world. Checkout Sofi Stadium, Mercedes benz stadium and Allegiant stadium to see what a state of the art modern stadium can look like. These stadiums are what a new Man United Stadium should be looking to surpass, it would make the revamped Bernabeu and Camp Nou look second rate.

It looks like Allianz Arena

Real Madrid rennovation cost is between 900m and 1B dollars it's not like you reported 1.5B pound which is even more in dollars madrid took 650M loan followed it by 250M from Morgan ans chase with interest rate 3% all to be paid over 25 years

❤

This is what am talking about. United needs to challenged the top guns of European football when it comes to stadiums.

Following the 2 Spanish Giants was started by Sir Matt. La Liga certainty does not lag the EPL. 2 different products with some different strengths. Rivalry is key and indeed these 2 leagues are the 2 biggest. Italy used to have the #1 league but changing times and financial investments occur.

Billions in debt man utd you got no money

@TheWelwyn21

Ай бұрын

They have, you can't be that thick its well hidden when needed it will be used. Have you seen how much they've spent on players and wages

Nice

There's nothing wrong with the Old Trafford stadium that a bit if TLC won't cure. All it needs is the Upgrade of the Sir Bobby Charlton Stand & East & West quadrant to complete the original design & a Levelled Retractable New Roof + modern refurbishment of the rest of the stadium to warrant at least 90K capacity Take Note: The stadium expansion MUST NOT exceed the rail track Let's complete the Old Trafford Stadium, we feel with 1bn budget in 18 month to 2 years copying Real Madrid project with the right people it can be achieved in line with progress on the pitch cos we deserve more! Worth a view, please share!

@TheLusianPopa

Ай бұрын

you dont seem to understand....its not a capacity issue. OT is SEVERELY OUTDATED in the sense the legroom is TINY, seats are very narrow, and it lacks the hundreds of luxury vip suites that a club of that stature should have....they dont have where to add more luxury suites i the current stadium.And completely rebuilding all the tiers with deeper threads/legroom and putting wider seats will really decrease even the current capacity. Just by having 50 cm wide seats instead of the current 45 cm wide would drop the overall capacity by 10 % to something like 68 K....increase the legroom by 10 % and you would lose another 10 % of that 68 k..... OT with emirates/wembley style legroom and seat width would be 62K tops... seriously, the ONLY benefit for staying in the same lace is not having to play somehwere else for several years... long term a brand new state of the art, larger capacity more corporate friendly stadium is the only way to go IF you want to compete with the likes or madrid, barca, munich, psg etc

@SuperMagnum83

Ай бұрын

The rakes of the side and end stands are at different gradients which is why the upper corners look awful, also legroom is cramped, concourses too small and the facade is very dated and all this work can't be done without the team playing somewhere else for 3 years. too many issues so it has to be a new build.

Man Utd's Old Trafford Stadium that a bit of TLC won't cure. All it needs is the Upgrade of the Sir Bobby Charlton's Stand with a 2nd tier to complete the original design & the removal of the 3rd tier of the Sir Alex Ferguson's Stand & replaced by TV Screens for all 4 corners. We also want a Levelled Retractable New Roof + modern refurbishment of the rest of the stadium to warrant a 90K capacity in comfort. SBCS 25K + SAFS 25K + SES 20K + ES 20K = 90K. Take Note: The Stadium Expansion should Not Exceed the rail track. Old Trafford Stadium known as 'The Theatre of Dreams' unique in style is the Super Bowl of stadiums & is potentially The best Stadium in the country, possibly the world. Let's complete the Old Trafford Stadium, we feel in 18 month to 2 years copying Real Madrid project with the right people it can be achieved in line with progress on the pitch cos we deserve more! Worth a view, please share!

That cp nou is going to look pure 🔥

Obviously not been to the Tottenham Hotspur stadium as yet!

the prem has tottenham stadium.

Most British stadiums were built at the turn of the century. The factory owners formed a football club, usually next door to factory and the local pub. Most football were started up where, heavy industry was located. In London most football clubs were located near the Thames river by the docks. It would be very hard for Man Utd to stay in their present location. Its. It would be better if they move from Old Trafford and build a 100 thousand seater super stadium. They have the money.

Amazing audience

New stadium... Best in the world. Nothing less will do.

Please! Incluam opções de legendas em outros idiomas!

I'd like a new stadium, as Old Trafford is coming towards the end of its natural life, not to mention the difficulty there is extending the South Stand due to the railway line. Let's build something truly great and not just a copycat design. It's not going to happen, but how cool would it be if we had a single tiered stadium? Just imagine something like that end stand at Tottenham's ground the whole way round.

I’m not paying for it with my money.

Nice new stadium but Glazers will pocket huge slice of profits.

they didn't have any extra space & their structures were already relatively sound unlike old trafford

Am support Manchester united ❤

Spurs got one of the best in the world Sir Jim

@johntate5050

Ай бұрын

I agree and although smaller, Everton's new stadium looks amazing.

New stadium 😂. They won't even pay 15m for Dan Ashworth 😂

@SuperMagnum83

Ай бұрын

A new stadium is worth the cost, 15m for a director of football is stupid.

Utd still following everyone else’s style no change there then

We want an Expansion to approx 90K capacity, Modern refurbishment & a Levelled Retractable New Roof! There's an completed stadium design on WHF!@UtdWesleyy with a comment stating: So apparently we are looking at an expansion of Old Trafford. It’s been talked about for years but put off because of the complications around the south section of the stadium but if we do manage to do it… 2 Tier SBC Capacity: 88,000+ We're sure that can be achieved with minimal fuss by observation cos its already laid out going by our walk around the stadium experience. Take Note: The Stadium Must Not Exceed the rail way track! Worth a view, please share!

Forever Manchester united!

para mim os estádios da premier league ja estão muito ultrapassado tem que renovar para o futuro deixar esse negócio de retro pro passado

@Ddssxxk

2 ай бұрын

Verdade o estádio do Chelsea Stamford brige e muito pequeno

@Ddssxxk

2 ай бұрын

O estádio do Tottenham O emireites Stadium estádio do Arsenal Ethiad Stadium Wembley Estádio olímpico de Londres Sao estádio novos e modernos o Everton está terminando o seu novo estádio

Looks more like the old wembley just without the towers

The Glazers have decided to go for option 2 which is modernising the existing stadium. They've just sent their van driver to B&Q to collect the first batch of MDF.

First Build a good team, Bring some good talant at Man utd, Start winning some title n then build a new stadium.

You have to build and invest to remain competitive. English football has the fans, the international appeal and the finances to do it. Yet they lag behind internationally particularly against the US market, big two in Spain, arguably behind PSG and Bayern. Time for the Premier League to develop stadiums for future generations.

@SuperMagnum83

Ай бұрын

They are. Everton and Spurs have new stadiums, Arsenal is not new but is modern enough. Man City and Liverpool are expanding, Newcastle are looking to expand and sounds like Man United will build a new 90,000+ stadium. Aston Villa and Chelsea are disappointments though, Villa canceling their new stand and Chelsea are always failing to get anything started.

first they should ask if they build a new team or redevelop the actual squad

Best redevelopment in every way

A new team would be nice!

Why not

温暖な気候でもないしサンチャゴ・ベルナベウみたいにおもいっきり最新の全天候型スタジアムがベストでしょう。 お金は知りません（笑）

They need some tarpaulin for the time being.

New build be better take to much cost and longer to do

Will it have indoor toilets?

What about a big top tent it will do for all the clowns you got playing for them my mate wants to leave it as it is hes says when he goes he can watch the game and have a shower at the same time dump lol ctid 😮

It will cost more to renovate Old Trafford than to build new.

Shame they haven't got a team befitting the club and the brand, so the stadium seems pointless!

The North Remembers

But the Bernabeu and Camp Nou have decent teams playing there, don't they?

Qatar would have been the best owners for us..they would completely transform this club in every sector

Money is not an issue. It's PROFITS that people are after. £100 a ticket...at least.

A stadium fitting for man u current state?😂 mid stadium then 😂😂

@Heremenow497

Ай бұрын

Who's a mid table ya muppet 🖕🖕🖕🖕

LOL. This is never happening.

Only one old trafford!

@robertmclellan3658

Ай бұрын

Owed Trafford

@ironore1000

Ай бұрын

Yeah, old.

Yup ..just Like Cteh n westham stadium that are build by the help of government.

At the moment the yids stadium is the best in the country then arsenal then Wembley

@johntate5050

Ай бұрын

Everton's new stadium is better than Arsenal's.

old trafford > new trafford

No. Just no, end of.

They have the land and their deep pockets so they as joint owners should cough up only problem is 6 are jews and 1 isnt . the longer they take to decide the dearer it will cost with inflation. the glazers need to sell up or put up. I reckon for a 100,000 stadium with a retractable roof and pitch with all restaurants and mini shopping malls and bars like spurs have will come to at least 5 billion if its to be the biggest and best outside wembley and if they do do it then re sale will be 10 billion plus if the arabs want to buy. they would also recoup the costs as well as selling parts of the old ground from the turf to seats and bricks scrap metals toilets etc plus a ground sponsorship nameing rights and revenue by the bigger capacity and three sets of executive boxes in each stand plus concerts and sporting events so whats the issue even if it costs 5 billion in total get on with it ratcliffe and glazers or sell up.

Dream on.. The only thing big about Man utd is that heap of rusting scrap metal mistakenly called a football stadium. Nothing will change get on with it.

If you're a billionaire you make a mint out of it. Buy doing it yourself and with the right people especially the club will benefit. And so will everyone involved.

if the english league was that good why are all english top teir teams not ugrading there stadiums would be a waste of time at manchester united because there not a top team anymore they may fill it but they will soon go bankrupt because they would need to be in the top 5 every year to have a chance in getting any revenue in manchester united are not going forward there going backwords they had there ups now its all the way downs

There is no fcuking way tax payer money should be used for this!!!!

New stadium! Old Trafford is awful inside, it looks and feels like it was built 100 years ago, which it was. It lacks comfort, proper facilities, ease of access and emergency escape paths. All of that is inside the building, so scrap it and rebuild because that's what you're doing if you're renovating anyway. So why limit the stadium with a canal and a railway? Move 500 yards and build a new one.

So another generic looking ground 😂

When the new stadium is being built where will they play their matches? The Wembley of the North already exists ... The Etihad Stadium !

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

stop speaking and build it

Since RATCLIFFE has come in we have gone worse.

Important 😂😂😂 premier league is only important for English people

@johntate5050

Ай бұрын

No it has the highest global viewing figures of all the leagues.

Britain... The most miserable place on earth

@AlbertoDeniaCerezo

Ай бұрын

Why are you saying that?

@asensibleyoungman2978

Ай бұрын

Oh dear! Someone's jealous.

@Crusader47

Ай бұрын

such a relevant comment lmao i can tell u from spain

@johntate5050

Ай бұрын

Are you brave enough to tell us where you come from?

Ask the glazers to give back the money they robbed

Why should tax payer's money help pay for this stadium? I can't stand Manchester United.

@relaxingthoughts3447

Ай бұрын

It boost the economy by creating new jobs and bringing in more tourists etc

@scotthowes6560

Ай бұрын

@@relaxingthoughts3447 don't talk nonsense! If the owner's of Manchester United put there hands in there own pockets it would achieve the same.. I'm talking about tax payer's money people who don't support that shite

@DS9TREK

Ай бұрын

​@@relaxingthoughts3447 then United can pay for it with private money

@Yesman10

Ай бұрын

Nah, hold the government to ransom, career politicians are just wasting it anyway so may as well give Mancunians something to buzz off. Spanish government have been helping Real Madrid for decades

play at the millenium stadium and renovate get a new stadium after the glazers are gone