Hi All, Initially, I planned to make a video highlighting a potential glitch in the income tax portal in 87A rebate calculation. I spent two days researching and checked hundreds of clients with special rate income, finding only one reason for the change. Despite my efforts, this video has received many negative comments, with some calling it a " _pathetic interpretation_ ." Please understand the hard work that goes into making a 15-minute video or an infographic. Tax matters are always open to different opinions, and I respect everyone’s views. However, having a different opinion does not mean one is wrong. Thank you for understanding i will soon make a new video soon and *this video is also 100% correct as confirmed by income tax department and income tax calculator is now calculating as per this video only.* Regards, Vivek Awasthi

@shankhajitsrimani763

18 күн бұрын

@@FinTaxPro but how ITD will justify someone who Would have got this in old regime & filed new regime bcos it was offering 25k in new regime... Now suddenly in between how ITD can change this?... In that case they should also allow change of revised filing under old regime... Otherwise they can be challenged in court of law!!

@fintaxproadvisoryllp3135

18 күн бұрын

@@shankhajitsrimani763 You don't know you can revise the ITR. You don't nee to go court to revise your return..

@shankhajitsrimani763

18 күн бұрын

​@@fintaxproadvisoryllp3135... In revised ITR, is regime change selection allowed if someone has already filed with new (default) regime for fy23-34?... since regime change is allowed only once in NY FY?

@swapnilmahajan2191

18 күн бұрын

Sir pl help in this case Salary Income 650000/- LTCG 250000/- Interest 28000/- Total Income 92800/- Std deduction 50000/- Net Total Income 878000/- As per Income Tax portal Total Tax Approx 34000/- Rebate us 87A 18000( on other than LTCG Tax) Net Payable Tax Rs 16000/-Aprrox. But while checking with winman there is no rebate available and total Tax is payable of Rs 34000/- What should I do ? Go with Income Tax Portal or winman ? Pl suggest any solution?

@swapnilmahajan2191

17 күн бұрын

@@FinTaxPro sir pl reply

Even being a CA, I too got confused "What is happening?". Thanks for the interpretation and clarification with the video.

Exactly yehi problem tha last 2 days se... aapne clear kar diya Thank you ❤

Excellent explanation. So far the best teacher to teach us all this complicated things in very easy to understand way. Respect you Sir.

Thank you bhai, one week se videos dekh raha hoon aaj correct information mili hai.

Absolutely relevant topic nowadays, I am also facing difficulties regarding this matter for few days . thanks for this discussion.

Sir, probe your memory. After 87A threshold expiry, in old regime, the normal slab rate above 5.0 lakh was 20%. Slab rate above 10 lakh was 30%. But, Spl rate for equity LTCG was 0% or 10%. Spl rate for equity STCG was 15%. Note that the spl rates, in view of very high risk, were always kept LOWER than slab rates. Now trickery starts. In new regime, slab rate upto 12 lakh is 5%, 10%, 15%. Thus, slab rate is now lower but spl rate is now higher. Equity LTCG and STCG rates have not been reduced proportionately in new regime to keep them lower as earlier. Thus, the LTCG and STCG rates are rendered NOT LOWER than slab rates. The high risk evaporates. Equity is treated like a shopkeeper commodity. Equity investors, who are special voters, notice the trickery. Income is gained from salary, interest, and equity LTCG, STCG. New Tax threshold is 7.0 lakh. You do not tax below 7.0 lakh interest or salary income but levy tax on below 7.0 lakh equity CG income. This is pure discrimination, not permitted under Constitution. Equal treatment is being denied. Those who make discriminatory rules or law, are reneging on their Constitutional oath. You have power to make only those rules, which are compliant with Constitution.

Thank you sir aapne sara doubt clear kar diya ...

Since 15 days i was searching about this only this video clear tnanx a lot sir ❤ for this information now we r clear to fill old regime

Sir if we claim this rebate 87A through old regime so will it be correct? or there is a chance of getting notice for claiming that. Asking this as its getting applied automatically so just wanted to confirm with you once.

Sir but Computax still allows Rebate 87A and also in computation it shows rebate u/s 87A so is it any possibility of demand if we file through computax..??

Thank you. Finally found video, I was searching for😊

Very important point discussed. Thank you ❤

Thank you aapne saara confusion dur kar diya

Agreed sir, but in Section 115BAC (1A) they have written as "total income" and not "other than special rate income" so as per this rebate u/s 87A should be allowed for special rate of income as well.

Nice video, So if we have both income- special rate and non special rate then tax on non special rate we will get rebate u/s 87A and remaining we have to pay (special rate) ?

Sir, you have explained very smartly and and my confusion is over, thank you sir hatta of❤

Worst Tax Structure of Indian Govt. 😡

This is a hot topics,,,,last two days i am trying to short out the problem

Thanks Brother ❤ Bhagavan Aapka Bhala Kare Aapne Hamara Bhala Kiya Hai😊

Very important and informative lecture ❤ you sir ji 👌👏

will i get rebate if my salary is 527750 and stcg is 20000 ltcg is 8000 , and VDA is 1199, and dream11 is 15000 , if not how much tax i have to pay?

Sir plz tell me where to show sbi life maturity income which is reflected in AIS and tds deducted u/s 194DA.should I take the amount credited shown by AIS or some other amount for showing in ITR1?

Great discussion. I'm searching this issue . Income tax Calculator also give wrong calculations. my short term capital gain is 2.4 lakh ,intraday 1.25 lakh with 65 thousand other income and zero salary income ,will i get tax rebate under section 87a in itr 3 old regime

kya detailed samghaya, very nice!!! Small investor who use to earn some money with small capital will now suffer.

Income from units of a business trust (Section 194LBA) , I had shares of Embasy REITS. I am not finding where to fill this income in ITR 3. Please help.

Thanks For Sharing Helpful Information 👍👌

Very informative . . Thank you sir🙏

I have one question if you can answer. This new logic of rebate 87A under new tax regime is applicable from this year only or it will be applicable for previous years as well?

@FinTaxPro

21 күн бұрын

It is applicable for AY 2024-25 sir.

@Ankur-uc7vi

19 күн бұрын

@@FinTaxPro Thank you for the reply and one more query if we claim this rebate 87A through old regime so will it be correct? or there is a chance of getting notice for claiming that. Asking this as its getting applied automatically so just wanted to confirm with you once.

@tauseefmd-oc7yz

18 күн бұрын

@@FinTaxPro will we get rebate 87A through old tax regime? If it is applying in old tax regime?

Sir what about ltcg exemption of 1 lakh on shares &mf.that is also covered under special rate .?

Strange,found that STCG on Equity, which should have been included under 87a ,is no longer reflecting

Sir , my gst no is suomoto cancelled and 270 dayds over , so no revocation option . What can i do ? Please sir

Wrong interpretation, wahan total income bhi likha hai plus "special rates" mentioned nahi hai. Infact sec- 87A ke under specifically likha hai ki 112A ke against rebate nahi milegi for old n new regime. Infact CA final may2024 attempt ke study mat. questions mein pura pura 25000 liya hua hai. Ye glitch ke karan hai...

Yes, stcg is not being adjusted in rebate

Thanku sir same problem thi muje bhi , clear ho gya

Form 16 old tax regime mein file hua hai, kya ab ITR New tax regime se file kar sakte hai...?

Thanks for the explanation sir

Sir ek client ka actual sales tha 2cr exempt sales hain unka milk sales but bank loan ke liye usne sales dala 5 cr to uska gst portal pe adjustment ya amendments kise Kare pls reply

Income of spl rate of tax is not to be added in total income for 87A rebate purpose . It means on income of spl rate of tax we have to pay tax and balance income chargeable to 115BAC we will get rebate max 25000 if that income is below 7 lacs. Am I right ?

I am using Winman Software and it is showing full rebate but where as i also encountered the same issue in Income Tax portal. lets wait foe few days so that there may be any update from department.

Proviso inserted from 1st April 24 so its mean it will applicable from fy 24 25 and not 23 24...? Please answer.

@rashmiupadhyay1728

21 күн бұрын

Yes

@FinTaxPro

21 күн бұрын

You should take our practice course if you are confused in this basic point 😅 Jokes apart this is added by FA 2023 and applicable from AY 2024-25. Rest you can refer memo to Finance Act 2023. Rest i have already explained these basics in our practical course.

@pankajgupta6503

21 күн бұрын

Please provide the memo link​@@FinTaxPro

Winman software me to returns uplaod ho rahe hai with benefit of Rebate for STCG 111A and winning from gaming

Sir I am not getting 87a rebate on salary income even in old tax regime that's also in total is less than 12500/- from salary income. Other stcg is 1100/- extra. Total rebate under 87a in my case is 0.can u explain why

Wrong interpretation of Act...please read Sec 87A again and interpret it correctly. Earlier Sec 87A used to talk about old tax regime(5lakhs), but after proviso was inserted, it talks about new tax regime(7lakhs).

please guide how to show treasury Bill gain as STCG on portal, which is income other than capital gain where STT not paid

Plz halp on stcg tax I have 31k profit in stcg In Last FY DO I NEED TO PAY 15% on it or not There is no other sources of income In this PAN

Thank you sir

Dear sir the link of notes provided by you is not opening

Thank you so much sir ❤❤❤

Well researched topic sir.. highly useful...

Thank you 👍 sir

Sir could you pls tell us if we have claimed under 87 A before this change. then do we have to revise the ITR before any intimation or demand comes further ?

@sarthaknawal8481

14 күн бұрын

yes 28 june ko rebate mil gaya tha jab reture file kiya tha. ab kya ho ga form me bhi rebate mention hai

Agar LTCG, 1 lac se kam hai to new tax regime mein tax dena hoga? Aur kya 87A rebate milega if LTCG is less than 1 lac but tax liability ban rahi hai from other incomes heads

Sir, 87A Rebate Marginal Relief is applicable with Form 10E or Not?

Thankyou sir, really helpful.

Good information Sir

Exactly same issue I paid tax on short term capital gain....even I was confused how it is payable

And what about assessee who filed itr 10 days before and got rebate 87A

Sir, pls share itr computation

So if my normal income is Rs. 695000 and STCG u/s 111A is 50000. My total income goes to 745000, but i will get rebate u/s 87A for normal income as it is less than 700000 and tax liab will be 15% of 50000 plus cess. Right? Also, if my normal income remains 695000, and my special rate income goes to say 50,00,000 , i will be still getting rebate for normal income as it is less than 700000. But a rebate on tax when your total income is 56,95,000 does not sound logical.

@rahulagarwal4330

21 күн бұрын

@@harshitarora4465 yes in one of my clients its normal income is 6.95 lacs and capital gain income is 7 lacs and still he is getting rebate

With the respect grievance raise by you, as checked your case with higher officials, if your total taxable income includes special income which are chargeable to special rates of taxes is upto 7 lakhs as per new tax regime then rebate u/s 87A will be available only to the extent taxable income which is chargeable to normal rates of taxes as "Rebate u/s 87A(1A) is not allowed for any special rate income" So, accordingly kindly proceed to file the return. I got these reply from the department. It means it is not an error of income tax site.

@Ankur-uc7vi

19 күн бұрын

So this thing is applicable only in case of new tax regime and not in old tax regime? Because in old tax regime rebate is available for special income also.

@amit_rajpurohitt

19 күн бұрын

@@Ankur-uc7vi yes but in old regime rebate is available only for upto rs 12500

Thanks a ton Sir

Outstanding Sir

My employer have filed for New Tax Regime. But, while filing ITR, I opted for Old Tax Regime by filling 10IEA. Now, there I don't know why Rebate under 87A is showing 0 and not 12500. Even though I opted for Old Regime, can I fill for New Regime with default option "No"?????????? Please 🙏🙏🙏 reply 😢😢😢😢 Or, I have to opt for New Regime again

@Ankur-uc7vi

17 күн бұрын

does salary person or normal individual also needs to file 10IEA? or is it for only business purpose?

Sir fir ab stcg me total 3.15 lack profit hua h to kitna tax lgega.....?

Well explained well done

WOW INFORMATION 😊

CIRCULAR OR NOTIFICATION, DATE ? PL SAY.. PL COME WITH INCOME TAX OFFICIAL CIRCULAR OR NOTIFICATION

Thanks Sir Ji

Bro, in case of female 87a reduction is coming under special rates too. please check it once

New tax regim me agricultural income par rebate Milegi ya nhi?

Sir new regime opt karne se last year ka short term capital loss show nhi kar raha

Thanks Vivek sir ❤

Very useful 🎉

Thanks

Fark kya h dono short term capital gain mein jismein 87a benefit milega or jismein nhi milega section nhi details mein btao

[11/07, 11:33 AM] Vinay Kumar: 1 person staying in dubai & India in fy 2023-2024...got salary as foreign remittance of around 11 lakhs...how it can be shown in IT Return, In India also he had done consultancy job of around 2.5 lakh [11/07, 11:34 AM] Vinay Kumar: How to show in IT Retuen & which form ITR..

I have total income including STCG of 5500, is below 250000 although income tax is charged on STCG by the portal.

Sir mujhe to Mila hai mera VDA ka 5500 ka profit tha lekin computation me to dikh raha tha Lekin TDS se less nahi kia. New regime me

@FinTaxPro

21 күн бұрын

Old regime m file karo mil jayega

You are right Sir according to 87a.

Excellent information

Excellent

5 july se before itr file kiya hai vo kya kare sir

Brother Sidha batao na ki Income under capital gain me rebate nahi milega

Tax estimatior me TCS ka figure total amount credited ka aa raha hai but only TCS ka amount ana chahiye

Very very good video

Even in old regime , its showing as 0

@rajhtc355

Күн бұрын

@@abhishekagarwal1476 yes same here

Very nice

Super sir

Govt. Ne jhatka maar diya . Jor ka jhatka dhire se laga diya.❤❤❤❤

Plz explain if my total income is

Sir crypto main 91 Thousand ka profit hai magar maine New tax regime se file ki hai and total income mera dikha raha hai 1lakh 65 thousand toh main old tax se revised kardun kya??

@rasheedakbar9929

8 күн бұрын

Old tax main toh rebate mil jayega na??

Wahh sir ky video bnai👍🏼

Sir, in one of my client … Normal income 6.5 lacs ka h and capital gain 7 lacs ka to total income is approximately 14 lacs but fir bhi software 23500 ka rebate de rha h … is it correct?

@FinTaxPro

21 күн бұрын

Okay i will this case as well.

@rahulagarwal4330

21 күн бұрын

@@FinTaxPro okay sir, please let me know whats your view on the same

Thank u sir me 3 days se calculation kar raha hu but rebate ke baare me koi book me nhi mioa or icai ke module me bhi nhi dikha

Sir please make another video on Marginal relief, income tax calculator also calculate relief however portal does not

Helpful vedio

Sir NRI return filing ka bhi video share kare rebate, exemption deduction related

I filed ITR-3 in the new regime in AY 2024-25 with Rs 1.40 lakh as a capital gain. GTI was Rs 3.75 lakh. I got a Rebate. Next year, AY 2025-26, let's assume I earn Rs 6 lakh from Capital Gain only. I won't get any Rebate, right? Sir, explain one more thing. If I file ITR-2 in AY 2025-26 in the old regime and is it possible to go to the new regime again in the AY 2026-27? if yes, how many times I can shift from old to new and visa-versa?

@indianfoodieexplorer

21 күн бұрын

@@DVNair only one time exit from old to new is allowed if you have business income

@DVNair

21 күн бұрын

@@indianfoodieexplorer What if I don't have business income from next year onwards

@indianfoodieexplorer

21 күн бұрын

@@DVNair doesn’t matter to income tax department according to my knowledge. It’s clearly written in law… once you have declared business income and filed form for old tax regime. You can re-enter only once in lifetime.

@DVNair

21 күн бұрын

@@indianfoodieexplorer There was an F&O trade in AY 2024-25. Only one F&O trade. It's not my daily business. Hence, filed ITR-3 in the new regime. There will not be any F&O trade from this year onwards. Will file ITR-2 in AY 2025-26.

You are real gem...you save 2600