Really incredible to think of how this all develops.

can you imagine if humans had fake hundred dollar bills that grew on our triceps which we wiggled every time a handsome potential mate passed by?

Coursera brought me here too, and Man this video was interesting!

Nature is incredible. I learn about new things everyday and still get so amazed!

@AmoMe2009

Жыл бұрын

Same!!!!!!

"The mussel squirts its young into the bass's mouth" SEE LADIES ITS JUST NATURE

@CosmicWaffle26

8 жыл бұрын

lol woow XD

@ellissweet

8 жыл бұрын

+shabadoo1 Mmm... but it's the female who squirts, so try again.

@TitanMarkus

6 жыл бұрын

But when I "squirt" my youngs into bass's mouth, its only "Sir please leave the aquarium"

@on-line10

Жыл бұрын

cringe tf idiotic-_-

@on-line10

Жыл бұрын

@@CosmicWaffle26 cringe tf idiotic -_-

Had it not been mentioned in coursera, it would have taken me long time to see this particular video! Thanks!!

I came here through mohamed noor's course: Genetics and evolution. Wonderful video!

The image shown here of the inside of the gill is fascinated!

Thanks, Coursera! I love this video...

@Amal757

3 жыл бұрын

Dan Otten which course?

@siddhiacharya83

3 жыл бұрын

@@Amal757 Introduction to Genetics and Evolution

Can you imagine if, through evolution, these mussels would evolve to use their lures for hunting?

Thanks to coursera I learned about the evolution of a perfectly designed of the trolling living creature :')

I love the explanation of evolution at the end. Mimicry seems to be among the strategies people find most suggestive of intelligent design.

@gemstonegynoid7475

4 жыл бұрын

A slightly fleshy mussel is slightly more attractive than a bare mussel. Fishy looking flesh is more attractive than vague flesh. Over millions of years, its brilliantly designed by nature

@ogreman-lll-957

2 жыл бұрын

Intelligent design is fraudulent. It’s creationism.

This video was filmed in my lab at Missouri State University and belongs to BBC. If you are going to steal others property- at least attribute them.

@Xphyzeek

5 жыл бұрын

Go drink a keystone light

Wondrous. Tks Dr. Noor.

totally awesome - great footage for my animal biology students!

So fascinating!

Yes, the thought had occurred to me. That would have to be very high, otherwise the ability to recognize would develop slower than the form of clams. Because, I think you'll agree, the latter is very high. Unless evolving fear (or gastronomic preference?) is easier than randomly evolving looks.

Awesome video. Thanks!

Nature, you are so cunning

"À la pêche aux moules, moules, moules, je ne veux plus aller maman......" très impressionnant !

"ever since Darwin" by Gould, chapter 12 brought me here.

Outstanding!

Fantastic!

Dr. Noor is the best!! :)

Yay Dr. Noor!

Nice!

OMG, incredible, nice move!

Mohammed Noor is awesome!

I came from Coursera as well. But i understood nothing from this beautiful video. Why this creature uses this masking? Does it eat small tasty fishes? Or what is it for?

That amazing!!

Very cool

Same here!

mind blown ...

this will hound me furr ever.

I could not understand why this is behavioral , which part is behavioral ?

Wow. Some of those lures talk about convincing. What's the expression, 'the blind watchmaker'.

What documentary is this off?

amazing!!

amazing!

Triumph of Life

Science is composed of a number of branches. All modern biology is based on our knowledge of evolution, and the sole purpose of the theory of evolution is to describe speciation, or why we see myriad species on the planet (btw, like many words, "theory" has multiple meanings. When used in science, a theory describes how a set of facts fit together). Physics describes how something comes from nothing, cosmology describes how the Universe formed, abiogenesis is the science of how life began, etc.

@UToobUsername01

2 жыл бұрын

Any science that is theory means it cannot be proven or disproven through experiment only through observations. Basically it's mythology. Only real science is when you know exactly how something works and can replicate the effects yourself by manipulating variables in nature to get the exact result. For instance we know that the theory of the globe earth has now been sucesfully disproven through analysis of the shape of the surface and through balloon experiments which do not show curvature. But ancient greeks thought they knoew it was round using sticks and it is often referenced by less intelligent people that this is how we know the earth is a ball. Yet when you test the theory is falls flat. All those who thought the earth was a ball will not debate with Eric Dubay or Nathan Oakley because they can't use the scientific method to show and demonstrate it. Psuedo science is all the sciences that do not allow you to recreate the experiments yourself to prove the theory. They are guesses about how something works but not the way it works in real life. Facts are things you can prove through repeated experiment and get the same results all the time no matter how many times you reproduce the experiment yourself in the lab to disprove the theory. The darwinian evolutionists do have merit in that there is a thing called natural selection but no evidence we were around millions of years ago or that we live in a spinning ball earth which emerged from a milky way galaxy which is one of many galaxies in a universe that came into existence by an explosion. That is mythology. A lot of the pagan civilisations of ancient times worshipped the sun as a god and so many people working in NASA (being occultists) names all the "planets" after ancient pagan gods. This is done on purpose to hopefully convert the rest of society to their nature worship religion one day. The bible says the star are merely lights or luminaries with no physical form. Just light only. The sun is not a burning ball of gas. It is merely light that is close to the earth. Proof of this is the sunrays coming from clouds. The god rays always point towards a singkle point which you can trace back to a single source which is narrow. If the sun is huge the rays of light would not converge on a single point when you trace back from the ground back to the sun. The sun therefore is a small object close to the earth if you just use geometry and get a ruler to trace the line back to its source. You were lied to as children by your own government an religious leaders who bought into the great deception. The reason truth is covered up is it will upset the many scientists whose jobs rely on the theoretical sciences to be true to still be able to be called scientist. So nothing is done to correct old scientific theories. It is not much different to when traditional martial artists were challenged on their bleiefs by mixed martial artists like Bruce Lee who only used the scientific method to show how their techniques are inefficient in practical use in real street fights against boxers and other disciplines who did not use fancy unnecessary motions. The way to know truth is ask questions about the thing you know to debunk your own beliefs in case you were lied to by your teachers. Only then will you get the answer. And so Flat Earthers today are victorious since we have experiments that cannot be debunked. The theoretical science of globe earth however will contiue to be taught at school because the original occultists at NASA who came up with the fake images need people to believe they are realy going to the moon and exploring space in order to justify the budget they get from tax-paying public and for secular humanists to believe the earth is the centre of the universe and not earth. Earth is flat, unmoving, and contains a dome to hold in the atmosphere so gases such as oxgen do not escape and cause us all to suffocate. The movie "The Truman Show" was a subtle way for the elite to make fun of the masses to say "we know the truth and will make this movie as a comedy to poke fun at the people who believe they can ever go to mars or venus or pluto or other planets but never actually do it". If the masses of low IQ normies can be fooled about space, then they can be tricked about anything going forward and using the latest deep fake technology to create hoax images. The elites have basically become gods now because they can manipulate any mind to believe anything and steer their actions based on feeding them convincing-but-false information. And today its being done all the time. 911 terror event was one example where dumb people who are not experts in explosives thought that burning jet fuel is hot enough temperature to melt ginourmous steel beams despite engineers and architects telling you it is impossible. Nobody listens because science is boring and the government has control over the mainstream media to cover anything up that may not make sense scientifically by using fake science to explain their BS. However there is a small group of people devoted to exposing the lies. This group will be necessary in future to help wake up the masses to lies so that they can think for themselves and stop being manipulated so easily.

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

​@@UToobUsername01 "stop being manipulated so easily" says the person manipulated by a 2000 year old book which contradicts itself several times

@UToobUsername01

Ай бұрын

@@Phantomphan613 The bible includes the old testament making it older than 2000 years. Technology was far more advanced in ancient times. There was a loss of knowledge which created a regression to primitive state. "but but but my history teacher told me it was just a myth man! " You believe your government school? You guys still believe the world is a ball. You guys still believe in the moon landing when it's not a solid object you can land on. You still believe that 911 was a terror attack. You just believe stuff without any evidence. It's called An Appeal to Authority logical fallacy. Why do people believe the bible? PEople witnessed the event first hand. That is why it is trusted. Just like you believe physical people exist because you meet them daily. But some of those virtual people you see online may be AI. The Bible? all proven because of prophetic events. Since you didn't live 2000 years ago you find it hard to believe but that is like a 5 year old kid finding it hard to believe that world war 2 happened just because he wasn't born then. From a 5 year old kid's perspective there were NO jews in concentration camps since he wasn't around in the 1940s so it was all BS legends created by old men to trick him into hating germans because it happened over half a century ago? LOL This folks, is why dumb people can never advance. You got to go to school and learn logic. There is evidence of a Flood in all cultures around the world and the ground shows this. Hiding evidence because you cannot handle the truth doesn't make you right. Just like how the government hiding the wreckage of 911 by sending it to china to stop an investigation into what happened isn't going to change the it was an inside job. Your government school are LYING TO YOU. You can prove this with science. No offence to Asmon but he isn't educated enough on the topic for anyone to take him seriously so I don't want to argue about this here. debate is how we prove who is lying and unlike Nathan Oakley or Andrew Wilson this guy would never allow it.

@UToobUsername01

Ай бұрын

@@Phantomphan613 To the guy responding to my replies: KZread is now censoring my replies. They don't appear on my screen after I respond to yours. Sucks to be on this platform. I hate these mofos.

and they lived happily ever after

Amazing

It doesn't eat the fish. It sends eggs into the fish mouth who live off the fish blood until they grow up to become adults to do the same thing to another fish :)

thanks reddit

Filmed by Green Umbrella at Missouri State University. Backus is in Violation of Copyright

@FaithlessFate87, it's PBS/Nature/Trials of Life/ep3, The Eternal Arms Race. ~47 minute mark of this video: l5RHBsGeY10

Damn nature, you scary!

what is the original documentary that this is from?

@00bubblewrap

6 жыл бұрын

Natural Born Hustlers by PBS (www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/natural-born-hustlers-about/13389/)

2:10 My God! Are you kidding!!

nature works in a weird way...

Do you know what the source of this footage is? Do you own it?

Coursera friends, can our coursera course account for credits in university?

me too :)

is the host fish harmed?

Firefox Browser brought me here!

So did I.

Это то, что мидии в муках кризис идентичности выглядит. Или, что более вероятно, он выглядит как рыба, чтобы другие хищные рыбы пресечь на него, выпустив паразитический личинки моллюска. Они зажим на жабрах рыбы и усваивать питательные вещества.

SLAP LIKE NOW BASS

Fucking mind blown

Perfect example of evolution

@ToweringCrane

2 ай бұрын

Bullshit. Where’s the feedback loop of a clam outsmarting a higher order predator? What selection process can occur if a fucking mussel has no sensory input to know it’s offspring downstream are surviving? You’re talking about several orders of higher intelligence and lack of any sense organs/environmental stimuli to even begin a selective adaptation process.

Мидий является паразитом на бас рыбы. Для того чтобы выжить, младенцы мидий нужно жить внутри бас течение нескольких недель. Он использует маскировку, потому что она нуждается, чтобы обмануть бас в получении достаточно близко, что он может освободить его потомство в рыбе. Чтобы сделать это, он должен выглядеть как вид рыбы, что бас люблю поесть. I hope that made sense. I used google translate. Did it help you understand?

@14h8h8l

8 ай бұрын

Это не мидии, а перловицы

wow

Why are the fish getting better at spotting fakes? It's not like their procreation depends on not falling for it, right?

Aww

Ok

Anyone here after Lex + Eric Weinstein conversation?

Largemouth bass after getting squirted with larvae: WHAT THE FUCK? My gills feel kinda sticky. What's goin' on?

Humans are excellent at pattern-recognition. What if human intelligence was created by co-evolution with a lifeform like this Mussel? And what if that lifeform still exists to this day?

@UToobUsername01

2 жыл бұрын

Evolution is not science. The instructions on creating is outside the realm. It's the same reason you can't explain how cryptids like bigfoot have super speed despite being physical creatures. There is a supernatural side to nature that darwinians hate to address. Same with UFO where people assume they are things not creatures with non-biological bodies. (ie a spirit is controlling the craft and it is alive but the physical machine itself is not manufactured. (real UFO have no seam lines)

sounds like a MIRACLE in my book!

@SyphADL87

2 жыл бұрын

All life is a miracle!

@AnonymousuomynonA

2 жыл бұрын

@@SyphADL87 GOD IS GREAT!

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

🤡

Incorrect. They evolved over millions of years, the mussels that were sucessful were the ones that were more often than not attacked by fish, their lure slowly evolved into what looks like a fish today.

what happen to that fish tho

@Scythemantis

4 жыл бұрын

It lost a little blood but would've survived. Parasites typically are nonlethal :)

@ogreman-lll-957

2 жыл бұрын

@@Scythemantis probably dies from it most of the time

damn

i still dont know how they got to this level of this complex mimic (and the mere explanation that it was randomly set and selected by several millennia does not convince me)

@captainna2133

2 жыл бұрын

Read ever since darwin by stephen gould. There he offers beautiful explanation. Pdf is available

Why am i here

Moderator of r/Atheism here, "Fishing is so much fun" - only true atheists and Anonymous members will get that dank allusion to reddit.

@QteaTheSwag

8 жыл бұрын

The amount of creationists here saying "Oh! Its gawdz wiiill!"

"Damn nature you scary" - only redditors and family guy enthusiasts will understand that meme

@trebvvv

9 жыл бұрын

Too late for the fake neckbeards, already been done.

@lefedoraathiest5299

9 жыл бұрын

Trevor Underwood Le reddit is filled with kind and nice people, *le tip fedora* good day m'gentlman.

@trebvvv

9 жыл бұрын

oh nice meme young gent! are you apart of le epik reddit armie like I am? *le epik tip*

@lefedoraathiest5299

9 жыл бұрын

Trevor Underwood We are the reddit army. *Fedora tip* M'sirgentlman

It said large mouth bass but the fish im seeing look like fuckin minnows 😆

Evolution or creation !!!

hay raj. overheat is getting centured because he disagrees with the establishment. to say "the mussles are blind and have never seen striped shiner yet that can emitate them very well" is a slow gradual process is debatable unless like the old time religions the positions are not defensible. brother dawin, dawkins and others have said macro evolution is complicated things that give the appearance of having been designed for a purpose. its only dogma that keeps them from intell design

poor leopard mussel

Does faith lead to the truth? If yes, as you believe Atheists have more faith than Creationists, you must also believe that atheists are correct about evolution. If no, then I am glad you agree with atheists that faith cannot lead to the truth.

Blind evolution ah ah ah

@ogreman-lll-957

2 жыл бұрын

You believe in talking snakes and magic fruit.

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

Better than fairy tales

Blind evolution? Right.

@ogreman-lll-957

2 жыл бұрын

Evolution has always been blind. Cats or birds don’t intentionally try to evolve or something it’s population Genetics.

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

What's your explanation? Sky daddy?

Who came here from Deep dive :)

I believe in both creation & evolution

někdo z primy ? :D

“God did it.”

This is not your video- you are violating copyright.

@ihitvpns2711

7 жыл бұрын

Chris Barnhart u need proof

@sasharenee9854

5 жыл бұрын

what r u gonna gain from it

@ghostridersinthesky21

Жыл бұрын

Chris -> 🤓

Not sure if trolling or just ignorant!

God is amazing

@ogreman-lll-957

2 жыл бұрын

Explain how your magic imaginary friend did this.

@aolson1111

2 жыл бұрын

god does not exist.

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

*SCIENCE* is amazing

I would like to pose my muscle as a treat to the female species and see if I can imitate this mussel. I can make it twitch, wanna see?

@hydro577

9 жыл бұрын

I'm not falling for this again .

9gag

why doesnt the bass realized it beings tricked like no fish is just gonna swim in one place and waddle its fins because it nows its gonna die. so then the bass should know that the lure isnt legit and leave it alone but instead the bass just completely lacks common sense and reason

@jakej4441

9 жыл бұрын

cause god wills it

@joshh7213

9 жыл бұрын

Because the muscle is not harming the fish. If it's not threatening fish survival then fish won't be so quick to adapt against it, but even still it says that fish are adapting to avoid some lures and lure are constantly evolving to be better.

@jackamatyus

9 жыл бұрын

As a guess, because falling for the trap isn't selected against, since it doesn't affect the bass' reproduction. However, hesitating to eat easy prey is probably selected against, so fish that fall for the lure are selected for, whilst ones that hestitate to take easy prey (real or not) are selected against.

@mrmojorisin1996

9 жыл бұрын

sorry guys i was just pretty high and thought of the fish as a person my b

@kellyrainey7999

9 жыл бұрын

Alex Don't apologize that was a good question. You can see the first bass isn't really falling for that trick. He is just watching it, it's the second bass that actually strikes.

Things like this is why I think God directed development of life.

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

🙄

the designer/creator is the one who would have supplied the original code, like believing the Bacterial flagella evolved with no programed code. dawin dogma is fascinating but has to be taken on faith. dawin knew that if complexity arising without obvious transitions, his theory would be in trouble. if modern dawinist Critiqued his theory as he did, we would see science in action, but follow the money...dawinism=money

@ORDERnPROGRESS

5 жыл бұрын

Darwin*

And we are expected to believe that this creature just 'evolved' by chance and/or circumstance ?? Please !!! That's as far-fetched as accepting that the dragonfly's intricate flight engineering also just 'happened' to develop. The eyes of a dragonfly also contain some 56,000 lenses. Put that down to evolution also. Good old evolution. What a croc.

@thepresidentfromsaintsrow4588

5 жыл бұрын

owo im sorry did we offend sky daddy

@Scythemantis

4 жыл бұрын

The video itself explains to you that it is not "by chance." It is because the actions of the fish determine which mussels reproduce, and so the actions of the fish are breeding the mussels for those forms just like humans have bred countless species to the way we want them :)

@ogreman-lll-957

2 жыл бұрын

Volume of something is completely subjective. So it doesn’t matter if it has a trillion lenses that’s your interpretation

Only God the Creator could have made this clam which has limited intelligence and is blind. It cannot even know what the lure fish looks like and certainly by itself cannot manufacture a fish lure. The information required is already coded in its DNA by the Creator. if it were evolution the clam would never have lasted long trying to lure the bass through trial and error.

@Loouise

3 жыл бұрын

why would he make it blind that's just HORRIBLE! I hope we catch this creator guy and put a stop to his extravagant and cruel experiments!

@jch8376

2 жыл бұрын

@@Loouise happy as a clam .

@ogreman-lll-957

2 жыл бұрын

Wrong. God didn’t do it.

@ghostridersinthesky21

Жыл бұрын

“I dont know the explanation for this therefore its god” why dont you look up darwin and his theories on evolution

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

Lol imagine still thinking god exists

God's wonderful creation. A cool creature. God knows what a bass looks like, he created it, looks like he created a muscle to look like another thing He created. Lets give God the glory, not any man's insignificant theories.

@aolson1111

2 жыл бұрын

god does not exist.

@Phantomphan613

Ай бұрын

🤮

Amazing