Mysticism: Virtue or Vice? - w/ Zevi Slavin

Zevi Slavin is the educator at and creator of ‪@SeekersofUnity‬. Where he is Exploring the History and Philosophy of Mysticism racking up over 725k views to date.
Mendel is a family man, troubled yeshiva kid, Philo/Psych dropout, seeking his own education with delusions of grandeur.
WARNING! Watch at Your Own Risk!
THIS EPISODE IS NOT FOR YOU
If questions such as...
"What is 'The Truth'? Why should I care?
How can I recognize it?
Where is there room for me in 'objective reality'?
Why create such a terrible world?"
... Are not running around your head.
I don't wish to corrupt your peaceful mind
In this conversation we dive into the murky waters of Torah, mysticism, rationalism, existentialism, doubt, belief, psychedelics grand-narratives and more.
For those who choose to listen, I hope you get a taste of solace knowing you are not alone.
To see more of Zevi's perspective (which I highly recommend) visit ‪@SeekersofUnity‬
Looking forward to your feedback.
Enjoy the show.
UX Tip: When we take turns talking it is Noted
00:00 Intro
00:51 How Seekers Started
04:01 Keeping Income and Passion Separate
07:24 Jordan Peterson Sells Out?
08:10 The Starving Artist
10:06 Gamara: The First Podcast
11:13 What is a Seeker of Unity?
16:04 Unity vs Sameness
25:15 Why Bother Creating the World?
33:11 Righteousness is Boring
34:27 Why would you want to be an FFB?
36:46 Dangers of Mystical Thinking
39:20 Science of Mystical Experience
50:15 The New World Order?
52:14 Judaism is True?
54:19 Joey Rosenfeld: Into Darkness
55:33 Path of Truth p1
1:00:03 Story: Beauty in Judgement
1:02:52 Path of Truth p2
1:06:04 "Accept the Truth from He Who Says It"
1:06:40 Mendel: Chaotic 'Truth Testing Ramble'
1:09:09 (The Archetypal Argument p1)
1:10:00 (Perspective on Uncertainty)
1:12:28 Mendel's Fear and Psychedelic's
1:14:02 Zevi: Swoops in to Save Me
1:14:12 Two Gods of the Yid
1:18:36 The Ark of the Covenant
1:20:34 Mendel: The Inescapable Truth p1
1:21:30 (The Two Realities of Tablets)
1:23:21 (The Necessity of Oral Torah)
1:25:52 "Go Away G-d!"/ Why we reject Hashem
1:26:44 Mendel's Problem with Chabad
1:27:30 'Thinking Aloud's 'WHY'
1:28:25 Zevi: Meta Analysis of History
1:31:37 Where is my place in the story?
1:34:33 Mendel: How do we make it through exile?
1:36:45 Podcasting is changing the world
1:37:26 Zevi: The Powerful Abraham J Heschel
1:40:00 (Tangent)
1:41:05 Between Heresy and Orthodoxy
1:44:20 Mendel: Jordan Peterson, Order and Chaos
1:45:20 Zevi: Jews, Archetypal Smugglers?
1:47:54 Mendel: Freud's Jewish Joke
1:50:36 Zevi: Atheism's Contribution, Rav Kook
1:53:52 Sharing Between Traditions
1:58:43 Truth Isn't Jewish
2:01:49 Mendel: The Art of Loving
2:07:25 God Doesn't 'Exist'
2:13:36 Zevi: Forced to Question
2:15:08 Mendel: What Constitutes the Highest Aim?
2:21:07 Zevi: Ethics of Schopenhauer vs Spinoza
2:25:39 Can We Separate Art from the Artist?
2:30:57 What We Learn from King David
2:36:02 Holding on to Our Humanity
2:37:38 Closing up

Пікірлер: 20

  • @alykathryn
    @alykathryn Жыл бұрын

    The Unity I seek is the unity of a Choir. where the beauty lay in the diversity of the voices and roles, singing different parts to the same song. Individual pieces forming a whole that is larger than any of its constituant parts, unique facets of a gem shining in compliment to one another, joining in chorus to sing the song of life, in uninity together. 💜💚

  • @esthersilberberg8692
    @esthersilberberg8692 Жыл бұрын

    "It's in the differences that we can find identity and it's in identity that we can find differences." Copyright this line fast. It's brilliant.

  • @madsenketty
    @madsenketty Жыл бұрын

    I, love, being with you

  • @SeekersofUnity
    @SeekersofUnity Жыл бұрын

    What a pleasure to be in conversation with you Mendel. Thank you for putting this together.

  • @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    Жыл бұрын

    Looking forward to doing it again

  • @SahasraraIm
    @SahasraraIm Жыл бұрын

    Just from the top of my head what sticked ... In the reverse order ... Like the idea of no-self or anatta is not nihilism. It goes to the heart sutra. There was a nice occurrence where a lay person asked Dalai Lama on the heart sutra and received a beautiful answer which is the gist of the "Form is emptiness". Where the Buddhist point is that there is no fixed I, the I that we perceive and invest with identity is ungraspable, it shifts like the river of life, or the mind stream, which Heraclit spoke of, and in which we cannot step twice in the same river. When we ask "Who am I ?" said Dalai Lama we can see that I am not the body, I am not the thoughts ... which we sometimes invest with identity. In Hinduism the body-mind type, the Dosha is acknowledged and so is the type, the swabhav, like in action oriented, feeling oriented, thought oriented. Based on the body-mind type we can make choices that are conductive to our well-being, knowing which foods to eat, how to dress, the colors that soothe us, the type of meditation that is most suitable, whereas swabhav informs us more on the way we approach our spiritual search, perhaps as I see it, in approaching a religion. There are religions or spiritual practices which are more devotional, or some that are more truth, or action oriented. In this way we don't fight our body-mind and psychology but we integrate it harmoniously and honor it as our unique gifts and talents. Regarding the trees ... That's a lovely subject ... Like in the proverb, "The apple doesn't fall far from the tree." Like it fell in Newton's head ... but apple fell many times, but that one triggered something ... the conditions were such that it sparked insight ... We are fruits of the trees of our ancestors ... really in a way when we talk, our ancestors talk in us, trees leaning their branches on each other, caressing ... I loved the idea of spiritual smuggling. It occurs to me that Gurdjieff mentions it the way of the sly man. And the opening ... I enjoyed that "Am I true, only if I am true ?" Here is a passage that I read last night from Haim Shapira's book "The wisdom of King Solomon" from a passage with insights from the Kotzker Rebbe: "If I am I because you are you, and you are you because I am I, then I am not I and you are not you. But if I am I because I am I, and you are you because you are you, then I am I and you are you." I see two voices in Zevi :) one that sees infinite and the one that battles with the jewish identity ... I believe that's in everyone ... of the culture, society ... some are so deep and we take them to be true that even the idea of questioning their validity doesn't come up, because deep inside we feel that something foundational about our identity would shake and whatever we thought of ourselves as true would crumble and we wouldn't know who we are ... But isn't that the first step we need to take in order to really know ? The mind clings between the known and the unknown ... but in order to see we need to step into the unknowable ... The beautiful paradox is that jews couldn't conceive of Jesus outside judaism and most christians cannot conceive of Truth in hassidism. But infinite welcomes and embraces paradox. I enjoyed it when you said "I hear you". That was deep ... that came from a deeper place ... And that with the names ... that we remember the names of the people who we love ... I think it goes to voices ... Sometimes when we can't hear our own voice, our Guru we tend to look "outside". And there is no really "outside" and "inside", that's what the doubting intellect, the object referral way of perceiving the Universe: sensations, images, feelings, thoughts as objects in a "world out there" whereas "the world in here" is what is merging subject and object, the ultimate truth and the conventional truth. Moving from conventional truth (object referral) which is perceived as external as in parents, teachers, caregivers, society to ultimate truth (Self-referral) which is maturing is moving from childhood to maturity, from seeking love and safety outside to Being love and loving ourselves. Community is an integral part of this ... the family, which doesn't need to be the family we have blood ties with, but a family where we feel we belong. Whereas in childhood we adhere to community, to rules in order to survive, maturing means we can form our community or be humble and accept the communities that are welcoming us in their midst. Acceptance means that we let go of expectations we have on other people, and acknowledge that not everyone can or should provide for everything we need, but that existence in its abundance fulfills our deepest needs and that when we are open we can recognize that we are being provided, cared for, nurtured and that we are never alone (not in a big brotherly way :)) on our journey and appreciate life more. Appreciation opens the way to abundance consciousness.

  • @Devotionalpoet
    @Devotionalpoet Жыл бұрын

    Really loved this conversation, thank you both 🙏🏻✨ I conquer with Zevi about exploring other religions and being moved by their mystics, then coming back to Judaism with an even deeper fusion and appreciation. I also liked the example of seeing you clear the Shabbos plates before your wife (any wife anywhere preparing Shabbos would so appreciate that help of a husband! A spectacular note to take to emulate lol) But seeing the beauty in others, to love all, when in relationship, is truly so beautiful to have that security to not feel that your love ( in a partner) is something to posses. To feel that comfort with a partner and see Love together in all people, things, etc. is truly a blessing.

  • @eliyahupereira
    @eliyahupereira Жыл бұрын

    This was great, dialogue is important... Didn't agree with everything but completely love the platform and would love to join you one day!

  • @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    Жыл бұрын

    I don’t even agree with everything I saw 😂 thank you for listening and the feedback

  • @ReynaSingh
    @ReynaSingh Жыл бұрын

    Came here from Zevi’s channel. Keep it up, really enjoyed this conversation!

  • @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    Жыл бұрын

    Awesome! Thank you! Welcome aboard 😊

  • @MaizlechRND2
    @MaizlechRND2 Жыл бұрын

    Great explanation of Tiferet @Zevi and @Mendel unreal distinction between aim and goal - KEEP EM COMIN!

  • @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    Жыл бұрын

    Thanks! Will do!

  • @gazzthompson
    @gazzthompson Жыл бұрын

    Fantastic

  • @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    @thinkingaloudwithmendel

    Жыл бұрын

    Thank you! Cheers!

  • @madsenketty
    @madsenketty Жыл бұрын

    How one little bird, in a nest, can be so divisive…😂 ❤ 1:41:34

  • @mediocrates3416
    @mediocrates3416 Жыл бұрын

    How do you love yourself? You fill your own need immediately, without a thought. *Then*, if it doesn't work out, you try something else; you never stop.

  • @SahasraraIm
    @SahasraraIm Жыл бұрын

    Seems like thinking has been heavily influenced by christian based culture ... and philosophy ... Deepak speaks of the Law of Detachment and the wisdom of uncertainty ... That's Friday ... usually what I noticed is that planning somehow breaks up on Friday and some things we might not have expected do happen ...

  • @alohm
    @alohm5 ай бұрын

    18:40 not unlike Jung's Enantiodromia

  • @alohm

    @alohm

    5 ай бұрын

    19:20 The tetralemma in Greek (Pyrrhon Of Elis) and the Catuskoti in Sanatana...