I sometimes wish the Sheikh would turn off comments like he used to do before. So many people are misguiding others when they have very little or no knowledge on the matter. Many probably didn't even watch the full video before commenting.

@user-vn1li5lw6p

11 күн бұрын

Actually they can't accept the reality

@mujariwa3696

6 күн бұрын

Some straight up misinterpret what he's saying. The same types who'd call in on the show like that photography kid.

@deonhart_0

5 күн бұрын

True brother

You say its better to be safe than sorry, but we are litteraly watching a video of you sheikh.

@priomquraishi1164

16 күн бұрын

He said taking halaal photos of covered men is permissible

@qarhsi

16 күн бұрын

Don't watch if you are doubtful?

@Atiurrahman27

16 күн бұрын

Necessity, for spreading the knowledge. Taking photos for memories or posting on digital media where everyone sees is not under necessity

@qasimarshid5362

16 күн бұрын

As long as the awrah is covered it is permissible as he already mentioned in the video.

@adnanamjad8365

16 күн бұрын

Ruling on videos, let alone informative ones, are completely different from those of photos. More lenient, one could say.

This sheikh is actually good but i thought in the begining he is super strict or misjudge situation But now I realize His way of talking is different than others.

@temmy9813

16 күн бұрын

"Super strict" when it goes against your desire! You better learn

@qarhsi

16 күн бұрын

​@temmy9813 take it easy brother. He is probably in the process. At least he is approving that shaykh is reliable.

@mak3129

16 күн бұрын

@temmy9813 I pity u.

@temmy9813

16 күн бұрын

@mak3129 Ignorance is a deadly disease

@mak3129

16 күн бұрын

@@temmy9813 I hope u will definitely reach Jannatul Firdaus by letting go of all lifely pleasures , insulting others ,being overly condescending to others and living as an empty husk that sucks the living out of everyone around him. May Allah guide and protect us.

In my humble opinion, a photograph is like a reflection in the mirror or on top of water. It is not a drawing, rather it is a reflection. Thus in sha Allah there is no problem at all

@user-uv3sv3qd2x

12 күн бұрын

Cameras capture light not draw

@danatnazhmukhambetov7613

12 күн бұрын

@@user-uv3sv3qd2x however, applying filters that deviate from true colours can be viewed as altering Allah's creation and thus haram. Same as photoshopping. Or photo editing in short

@user-uv3sv3qd2x

12 күн бұрын

@@danatnazhmukhambetov7613 There's something wrong with your head Cuz there's no way 😂

@danatnazhmukhambetov7613

12 күн бұрын

@@user-uv3sv3qd2x was it very necessary to insult me now? Couldn't you be more polite? Do you think you won't be punished for that on the Day of Judgement?

@danatnazhmukhambetov7613

12 күн бұрын

@@user-uv3sv3qd2x I misspelled "photoshopping" and wrote "photoshooting" instead

Heavy on the scale سبحان الله وبحمده سبحان الله العظيم SubhanAllahi wa bihamdihi, SubhanAllahil 'Adheem (Allah is free from imperfections,and His is the praise.Allah The Great is free from imperfections.)

Mashallah .

@user-hk9kn7tm4p

16 күн бұрын

Allah always A capital name of the only King of all the worlds please always A capital

@Georgodegeorgo

16 күн бұрын

Says who? There no capital letters in arabic

Assalam-o-Alaikum!

Its because at the time of rasoolullah (SAWS) the pictures were painted by artists, and we already know we aren't allowed to draw pictures of animals or make statues of them, because on the day of judgement Allah ta'ala will call the painters and tell them to bring life to the drawings imitating the creations of Allah, but photos is different, you take photos, the camera shows what ever is there, you arent drawing it, just recording the animal.

Thank you

Assalam Walekum Sheikh I want to ask is it ok to just put a wet finger in the nose and clean it while doing widu cause tape water could be dangerous to fill up in the nose there are various types of bacteria which are very deadly please clear my doubt I am really consent about it.❤

@qarhsi

16 күн бұрын

Wa alaikum salaam. Brother, shaykh has clarified this issue in the past. He doesn't respond to comments. Unless you have clear proof that it is harmful, you cannot make it an excuse not to sniff it up. When I sniff, a lot of times water goes to my throat, which could invalidate fasting. Yet shaykh said I can't just put wet fingers up but must sniff water in. Hope this helps.

@Zakriya_official

16 күн бұрын

​@@qarhsi Nigeria fulry it's a very deadly virus which goes up from your nose to your brain and start eating your brain which kills you on 12 days you can also search it on internet I know your issue this is something else it is more likely to enter your brain in areas like our that's why I asked this question and also there is no treatment of it.

@Zakriya_official

16 күн бұрын

​@qarhsi I am just being a little bit careful about it Allah knows better I am afraid of it that's why I just put wet fingers in my nose cause koshika khasta if it went up your nose to your brain can kill you in 12 days.

@SoleilMagica

15 күн бұрын

This depends on the country, but if you are unsure if the tapwater is safe or not, you can always boil it for 10min and then pour it in a bucket once it has cooled down.

@vickychangi1131

10 күн бұрын

I never sniff the water..it goes to my brain I guess because I find it difficult to sniff it . I just rinse my nose with water. I don't think my Wudhu is invalidated. If we follow small small things and abandoned prayers by thinking the prayers will become invalidate then most people will not pray.

If I’m wrong in taking photographs may Allah forgive, I will not say the haram is halal, May Allah forgive me

Good question from brother McLovin

@mussabkamhieh549

15 күн бұрын

Al Salamu Alaikum brother, hope you're doing well. I advise you not to make fun of your muslim brother. It's not worth it at the day of judgment to get punished for making people laugh at him :)

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

That is exactly what i pictured 😂

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

​@@mussabkamhieh549 Life without laughter and fun is no less than hell brother

@mussabkamhieh549

14 күн бұрын

@rishikeshwagh yes brother, laughter is an absolute necessity, but not at the expense of others :)

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

@@mussabkamhieh549 I'm sure Mr. McLovin doesn't mind.

But you are in the video ? Right

@user-uf5cs5vf4c

Күн бұрын

So what is wrong?

Salam alikum the camera don't show perfectly the reality

Allah knows best but I think taking photos of Mahram women shouldnt be an issue if they are well protected. Hacking and loosing phone is hypothetical daleel. If thats the case then wife or sister can also be kidnapped from the market or school ? so should we stop sending them to schools and markets ?

sheikh assim is the goated sheikh

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

Had a beard like a goat. That's about it

What about ai pictures can I do that on my account

@umertheclumsytube193

16 күн бұрын

No

@BurgerBurger-db9ft

16 күн бұрын

You are a living thing so no.

Assalam Alaykum Shaihk. By the way our videos in youtube and social medias in general are the similar of pictures. What about this? You and many shaihks around the world have their own channels in social media. So, in this order of ideas you are commiting haram when your face is everywhere in youtube, tiktok, etc. Thanks.

@fihamahmed5574

13 күн бұрын

watch the video!!!!!

Funny thing is, even the thunbnail of this video had a photo of a man holding a camera. Maybe that was a picture not a photo 😅

@jeetroy900

16 күн бұрын

he said you can take pic of men ( with awrah covered),children

@Wonderin_Universe

16 күн бұрын

He said it in the video photos are permissable of men who are covered and their photos must not be used in an indecent way, and you can take photos of children who are covered.

@definitelynotcharaznable7749

16 күн бұрын

​@@BluerRay786yeah, but he permitted the editor to put the thumbnail and edits on the video. Otherwise, he should make statements

@asmasharif9121

16 күн бұрын

​@BluerRay786 Why are you defending him when it's not needed​@BluerRay786. Jeetroy900 has already cleared, giving reference of sheikh from this very video.

@asmasharif9121

16 күн бұрын

​@definitelynotcharaznable7749 please listen to the video with attention. Sheikh just mentioned: Appropriate pics of men and children are allowed. The thumbnail you keep mentioning is of a man isn't it?

I even saw Saudi Government's official photographer capturing memories of high profile visitors right in the Haram, in front of Kabbah.

@user-bm6wx5mu2z

9 күн бұрын

Does that make it halal¿

Mans is asking us to not take pictures of our own wives. Crazy.

But photography is haram because as generations pass by haram becomes easier so now no one draws its only pictures taking

In subcontinent’s Hindus before it was only murties but now they worship keeping photos of their gods

what about photo with my wife but wearing hijab?

@hishamalaker491

Күн бұрын

Yeah its alright, if he thinks taking videos is halal then a photo is the same thing just slower.

What about videos

@-anwar6245

16 күн бұрын

they’re halal

@BurgerBurger-db9ft

16 күн бұрын

​but videos are a stream of photographs or images played at a high speed.

trees arent living creatures?

@sksamimali6589

16 күн бұрын

So are bacteria, virus etc we can't see them but they are everywhere.

@youshi96

16 күн бұрын

@@sksamimali6589 yep

@daniay4164

16 күн бұрын

Trees have no souls according to hadiths.

@youshi96

16 күн бұрын

@@daniay4164 he said living creatures, he didn’t say soul

@daniay4164

16 күн бұрын

@@youshi96 The ruling for drawings is that it's impermissible to draw objects which have a soul. And therefore, since trees and plants do not have a soul, it's fine to draw them or take pictures of them.

So this video himself making is haram

So no passport photos of women then? To travel for Hajj?

@mubeenplayz5246

16 күн бұрын

If its a necessity (i.e your government forcing you to show your face for a passport)And something good or halal

@IslamicClipsHub

16 күн бұрын

this is whisper of shaytan he makes u question things passport is obligatory

@homeschoolislaamiyyah2967

16 күн бұрын

what is necessary is necessary.

@mak3129

15 күн бұрын

​@@mubeenplayz5246 YES YES bend the rules when it is advantageous for u but refuse to accept or acknowledge that in this day and age this is not applicable to us and was refering to sculptors that would worship statues back then . There werent any cameras in prophet ( SWT) times. Hence this hadith/saying should be challenged by others in an attempt to learn its true meaning and futher our understanding . Blind following , Misunderstanding and stupidity is at its peak here.

@mubeenplayz5246

15 күн бұрын

@@mak3129 where am i bending the rules ? And calm down you are not a scholar stop acting like one arrogance is going to take a lot of people to the hellfire for one reason or another , i just conveyed what i heard from the sheikh in another video on a similar topic

I think vidoes are ok

@user-jc2vp4rr7m

16 күн бұрын

The shiehk is in a video 😂😂😂😂

@asmasharif9121

16 күн бұрын

​@@user-jc2vp4rr7mmen with their awrah covered are allowed pic/videos. Sheikh is doing a great job of spreading our deen. May he be rewarded well by Allah!

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

​@@asmasharif9121 because he earns his money on KZread, it's ok for him to have his photos and videos all over the internet. But it is haram for others

@shwanmirza9306

13 күн бұрын

​@@rishikeshwagh How about not slandering Sheikhs? You know that arrogance is a sin, right?

@rishikeshwagh

12 күн бұрын

@@shwanmirza9306 Brainwashing gullible people is a bigger sin, right? This 'Sheikh' is dangerous to society.

Clarification Needed: No photos of women family members (mothers, sisters, daughters) without hijab or no photos of them regardless of hijab??

@aron2015

16 күн бұрын

Has already been answered.

@swuffy464

16 күн бұрын

@@aron2015if it’s already been answered then when you reply to the comment, either give him the video link or directly answer.

@taimurahmad

16 күн бұрын

He already answered. Regardless of h1jab no h1jab. No photos of women are allowed

@k00lmoh

16 күн бұрын

you can't even if they are in full hijab because it defies the purpose of hijab, even if the camera won't be shown to anyone it can still be hacked

@Peaches10608

16 күн бұрын

​@@k00lmohwhat if the photographs of women are printed and in an album and only the family will see? Your response of hacking makes no sense if the photographs are already printed

The Salafi doctrine on pictures has got to be challenged. There’s never any discourse about the images of the Gulf country leaders on walls and if there’s any pushback, the Salafis will pull out the khawarij card

@homeschoolislaamiyyah2967

16 күн бұрын

pictures of men are not haraam.

@taimurahmad

15 күн бұрын

Its not salafi doctrine peesay--its a fiqhi masalah thats spans across multiple madhabs. I've seen hanafis take similar stamces... its just about who takes their rligion seriously...

@EconomicsDomain

15 күн бұрын

@@taimurahmad In my experience, it's almost exclusive to the Salafis

@fihamahmed5574

13 күн бұрын

@@homeschoolislaamiyyah2967 hanging photos on a wall is definitely haram. This video is talking about taking digital pictures.

@fihamahmed5574

13 күн бұрын

Every salafi I know of says that is haram. what are you talking about?

But hey! Let's keep making videos and pictures for the thumbnails.🤔 Change is good. And a good shave too.

@user-wl5ke5xn5f

15 күн бұрын

Lay off the pipe bro

Videos are the integrals form of photo. Why you make videos???

If taking pics is halal for men then I don't understand why it's not halal for women. If we take pics to keep memories for ourselves, Not to upload on social media. So you mean we're still committing sin??

@sologamer8287

15 күн бұрын

Well they say it’s not allowed for women due to the potential fitna like it could get hacked and stuff so scholars are saying that they should not post online.

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

Don't listen to the Sheikh. He himself has his photos and videos all across the internet. Nothing wrong with taking photos.

@shwanmirza9306

13 күн бұрын

​@@rishikeshwagh Not for women since they wear Hijab

@taimurahmad

13 күн бұрын

Yes because it defies thw purpose of h1jaab.....photos can be hacked when you repair mobile many times you see it

@rishikeshwagh

13 күн бұрын

@@taimurahmad Y'all act like it's a crime for women to have a face

I have seen video youtube chanelle islam response Chanel, talk in the school of Imam Malike the Malikite drawing is authorized because they consider that drawing is not imitating the creation of Allah it is the shape of statues which are prohibited

@Redoni04

16 күн бұрын

Source? any references from Imam Malik?

@Leon-S_kennedy

16 күн бұрын

@Redoni04 mohammed nadhir talks about it on youtube watch the tape on youtube ( islam réponse, mohammed nadhir les dessins, he explains that in Malikite schools it is authorized the video is in French by account

@Leon-S_kennedy

16 күн бұрын

@@Redoni04 in youtube islam reponseee chanelle mohammed nadhir ( les dessins et poupée)

@thecrochetboy

15 күн бұрын

@@Redoni04 how would imam Malik know about photos and videos. They didn’t exist during that time.

Smh. Is this really a question

I like to watch these videos so I can feel grateful for being free from religion.

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

Now you know exactly why you shouldn't go back

@mrhidayatmn

12 күн бұрын

idk bro but i can see the hook. you're still not free from religion. if i were you i'd never care. to leave any comment on a religious content? absurd. just let go of the hook and embracing freedom 100% like you've always wanted. scroll away, don't engage, be truly free from religion. and be a slave for something else.

@Kivamusicchannel

12 күн бұрын

@@mrhidayatmn bahahaha Sure, Jan.

Taking photos are haram ❌ Photo in Thumbnail ✅

The scholars that say it is haram to take pictures of living creatures, as it falls under imitating the creation. I really want to hear their argument, cause I can’t make sense of it. Capturing an image through the reflection of light etc, isn’t that just saving an image of the moment? You haven’t created the image, the image has already existed, your hand has not created anything, you’ve only captured the reflection of light through a lens to get the moment saved. A video is also just images being captured and saved in high speed. So is you settle with the argument that taking a picture is haram, then so would a video be. Meaning this video of the sheikh is haram. Meaning broadcasting the Haram on television during prayers is haram, etc.

@jaafarvandenberghe

15 күн бұрын

Exactly, that's perfectly described what I'm thinking too

@thecrochetboy

15 күн бұрын

@@One-ov4ow Shaikh has a very weak argument. The argument that I find the most satisfying is that the principle on which pictures were prohibited during the time of Prophet SAW was due to shirk as people used to worship the pictures they made. That principle should prohibit every picture or video that leads to shirk directly or indirectly. Everything else must be allowed. I think we unnecessarily go on to make halal things haram because we’re too cautious about everything which is very dangerous. It’s one of the biggest harams to declare halal things as haram by ourselves

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

​@@thecrochetboy Better safe than sorry says the Sheikh

@thecrochetboy

14 күн бұрын

@@rishikeshwagh you can’t label things as haram for everyone just to be safe 🙂

@rishikeshwagh

14 күн бұрын

@@thecrochetboy That's what the Sheikh thinks

Peace be upon you.

I find it weird because we have profile pictures and we have to have ID on us, so I don’t know how we are supposed to not take pictures all

@TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper

16 күн бұрын

Don’t be a kafir. Take off your profile picture NOW.

@osidjekskxjndd9224

16 күн бұрын

Well IDs are completely different case, different from just a photograph which you have a choice whether to take it or not, compared to a photo ID which might be used for documentationa for example. Thats just what I think

@drluigi8563

16 күн бұрын

@@osidjekskxjndd9224 but you still need one regardless was my point, most people wouldn’t live without an ID

@kayki8421

16 күн бұрын

@@osidjekskxjndd9224 If necessity makes some thing halal. Then it is halal in normal time too. Why you are putting your Verdict to other?

@likeacandle5722

16 күн бұрын

@@kayki8421 no it does not. please do not share misinformation. necessity can make some times eating pork permissible(not halal but temporarily permissible). but that is for a certain and very specific time, place and situation. but this does not make pork halal in general. likewise, taking picture govt id or passport is a necessity for traveling, hajj and umrah and such. So, for that it is permissible. other than that, Shayekh explained very well regarding the photography question. he has another recent video on the topic i explained above. please check that out for relevant query.

Digital photography of any living being is impermissible, according to the major scholars upon the clear evidences from the Sunnah. Many, many major scholars are in agreement upon this. The few scholars who disagree made their judgement of the matter based on their understanding of digital photographs, but in reality their stance is not backed up by the evidences in the Sunnah.

@BGS395

16 күн бұрын

Who are the major scholars?

@DaniyalX

16 күн бұрын

then what are you doing here on youtube? Videos are collections of digital images.

@improveself3263

16 күн бұрын

Why does sheikh have a pfp on Twitter? Why does they have thumbnail

@vorqoo

16 күн бұрын

Give us names of reliable and truthful scholars that does not allow photography of living things.

👀 see So anything with Eyes *Not* permitted to be replicated in *drawing* or other- *wise*

Images are not permissible. That's idolatry. Which begs a question as to what is the shaikh doing in a video.

@richsteve6970

16 күн бұрын

It's a video not physical photo physical photos are haram but digital photos are not.... the digital ones are not real it's just reflection

@likeacandle5722

16 күн бұрын

watch the full video again.. do not comment half way through.

@Furious_Retro

16 күн бұрын

Speak with knowledge akhi

@DeenAlIslamEN

16 күн бұрын

Watch this video again, which you haven't watched yet.

@salvatorearanzulla9104

16 күн бұрын

​@@DeenAlIslamEN hey babe how are you

First he says one CAN’T do such and such like a final ruling. Then he says it’s better to be safe than sorry🤡

@qarhsi

16 күн бұрын

He still takes a middle view. There are a lot of scholars who don't allow photos at all. If you aren't pleased with his answers and wish to take photos, will you be pleased with the stricter opinion?

@thecrochetboy

16 күн бұрын

@@qarhsi well I think it’s more about analysing the argument behind a ruling than deciding based on what sounds more pleasing. The argument sounds silly that it’s allowed to photograph landscapes and not animals because animals are living. I mean, trees are living too. For me, the strongest argument is going back to understanding why pictures were prohibited at the time of Prophet SAW. And it’s clear that it was purely based on the shirk element as the people used to make pictures to worship them. And I think the ruling should stick to that principle. As long as there’s no hint of shirk or means to lead to shirk, every photography and videography should be allowed. Also I saw another comment saying that physical photographs are haram while as digital are permissible. How silly does that sound? People tend to forget the basic principle behind a prohibition which is the main problem

Man...the Quran informs us that the same people who destroyed the previous Abrahamic religions were...you guessed it right. Your scholars. The Quranists/Submitters of GOD are rising. We do not believe in your manmade books that you attribute to the Final Prophet. Good luck on the day of judgement.

Why do you treat women so badly?

@vintagevibes2977

16 күн бұрын

Who does?

@rayblitz1713

16 күн бұрын

Wdym treat women badly? Whos doing it

@lnoorplaylist

15 күн бұрын

@@rayblitz1713 He probably said that bcz sheikh said in this video that taking pics is okay for men but not for women. even when those women are taking pics to keep memories for themselves and they don't upload it anywhere. I don't believe that it makes sense.

When we watch tv. Even an unknown lady can watch your video. If it is halal then taking picture of women is also halal if she is not in indecent dresses. Tv is the combination of millions of photos. Bottom Line is what is halal to c in naked Eye that is also Halal through lenses too. Either it is still of Moving photographs. As long as it is not Mimicry. Only thing is you can not hang some ones photo that is it. Technology can be use in proper Islamic way.

@AbdulazizKider

16 күн бұрын

This is not how islamic rulings are made. First off the logic you used is really flawed, and also as a layman you shouldn't be making rulings

The more I try to be a better Muslim the problem occurs, this has become an addiction for me (digging for more information), and the more I do the more I hate people and myself😑 How can there be difference of opinions if it is solved? I am dying inside 🥹 The things he said about covering awrah and stuff is correct otherwise sins will be exposed if actually done.

In subcontinent’s Hindus before it was only murties but now they worship keeping photos of their gods

But photography is haram because as generations pass by haram becomes easier so now no one draws its only pictures taking

@hishamalaker491

Күн бұрын

Man you have a picture in your pfp what do you say about that? So no its not haram, Photography is just a reflection I didnt draw anything or alter the creation of mimic it, I merely took a frame and a reflection of it.