Musicians react & review ♡ TXT - What If I Had Been That Puma
Музыка
Balance game? Puma? Whatever - it's still fire and we want to know more! Their vocal range, mix, and everything always hits on point. This one was different yet again, and we are ready for more! Let's get it!
Kpop producers and singer-songwriters react to Tomorrow by Together's What if I had been that puma (밸런스 게임) (Lyrics video)! Enjoy!
Sound at / hsausages
Follow us on IG: @handsomesausages
#txt
#whatifihadbeenthatpuma
#tomorrowbytogether
Timecode
0:00 Intro
1:41 Reaction
5:18 Initial Thoughts
5:56 Guitar vs Vocals
6:35 Keys & Rhythm
7:01 Discrepancy
7:25 Autotune vs Members
8:32 Lyrics
9:06 TXT forever
Пікірлер: 50
Most people don't like this song with the excuse of using too much autotune. So what? Here , Txt used it in the best way possible. But this song was performed in their world tour n it got viral for its choreography. A song that has similar fate like this was eternally when it too got viral for its choreography. I hope people appreciate such masterpieces 🥺🥺🥺.
@yanie5067
Жыл бұрын
ikr, this song is one of my fav tho.
@sirasira773
Жыл бұрын
Song and vibe is really good but I also don't it's heavy auto tune.
There are so many little references to their other songs in Balance Game!! For starters, it’s obviously referencing PUMA by making references to the real-life puma that was the inspiration for PUMA-when a puma escaped a zoo in Daejeon and was shot dead. In Balance Game, Soobin says he’d have probably just stayed in the zoo, but Beomgyu follows up by saying that he doesn’t know how the puma would feel-so he doesn’t want to make a choice. That’s why the English title is “What if I had been that PUMA?” aka, what choice would I have made? Even just the concept of pitting two different choices against each other is something they’ve explored in songs like Blue Orangeade and Angel or Devil. In Blue Orangeade, the concept is “we like different things, and yet we love that and think it makes us work even better together!” while the concept of Angel or Devil is “I want to pursue you, but I can’t figure out if I should be sweet and slow, or if you’d prefer me to be bold and assertive? I want to do it the right way, the way that wins your heart.” Balance Game also references Can’t We Just Leave the Monster Alive? by having a video game concept (referencing EXP & the having to choose between A or B, like in a game). CWJLTMA has the narrator stating that they don’t want to kill the monster, the final boss, that they want to stay within this game and hide forever, to choose to not finish the game. CWJLTMA is about not wanting to grow up and become adults. PUMA is about debuting and entering a vicious industry. Balance Game is about the initial decision right before PUMA, the fear of making the choice to escape the zoo, the fear of not having any experience, of wondering if escaping is the right thing to do. They also reference Run Away a couple of times, like when Soobin says, “Run away!” In the background during Yeonjun’s part in verse two. TXT and their lyricists and other creatives are incredibly good at weaving together the lyrics of a lot of their various songs to tell a cohesive story-it’s wonderful! It’s like how Nap of a Star & Can’t You See Me? have a TON of directly parallel lyrics.
TXT IS COMMING BACK ON JANUARY 27TH 🎊 🎉 STAY TUNED And thank u for your reaction ❤
We know everyone been asking for lollapalooza - we may do this as a separate thing later down the road as we usually have limited time to record, BUT for now, let us know what songs we can check out and we'll get to it right awayyyy Happy New Yearrr
@persik3775
Жыл бұрын
Oh thankyou for considering about it. Please react to txt's japanese single - 1. Ito 2. *Ring* (how to love someone who isn't you) 3. Hitori no yoru. All of their vocals shine in these songs.😊
@littlebeary
Жыл бұрын
TXT - OUR SUMMER
@littlebeary
Жыл бұрын
TXT - GHOSTING
@littlebeary
Жыл бұрын
TXT - WISHLIST 🙏
@hilwahzahro1236
Жыл бұрын
Ring and Hitori No Yoru 🙏
I became addicted to this song when the album dropped, it was always on repeat, it was such a bop, and the use of autotune in this one is a genius move actually
TXT Comeback on Jan 27 2023!
Blue Orangede- one of the earliest songs and one of the best and most favorite b-side of TXT. 😊
Another great video! From what I recall, this song titled What If I Had Been That Puma was a follow up to their other song Puma previously released in The Dream Chapter: Eternity album, which was inspired by the puma zoo escape story that happened in 2018. WIIHBTP flips the story putting the members in the puma's perspective with the choice of either staying trapped in its cage or escaping and finding freedom, hence the Korean title Balance Game. I tried to explain the premises of the story as best I could so if I missed anything, got something wrong, or if it simply doesn't make sense, I apologize lol. Anyways, TXT comeback The Name Chapter: Temptation coming January 27!! Can't wait for the drop and you guys' reactions to the release!!
Imo the autotune in this song sets up the atmosphere very nicely coz it makes me picture an 8bit game with options Yes or No. This or That. I think the autotune was like that on purpose and I love this song so much. The storytelling is also cool. This song is related to PUMA. In PUMA, they are the "main characters" which are the PUMAs. They live and tell the story in that MV. In this song, they are just the player, making choices for the PUMAs without much serious consideration, wanting to even skip it. This is also reminding me of "Cant we just leave the monster alive?" which has the same setup, where they are the gamers that can reset the game as many times as they want. TXT is coming back on January 27 with The Name Chapter: Temptation! XD
You should react to Ring, it's a japanese track and it has the best bridge of their discography so far, their vocals are insaaaane, also, Opening Sequence, one of the best songs they have
Do look forward to txt comeback 1/27th
this was one of my favs, please react to their song "new rules" it's so gooddddd + the choreography is so cool & fun
Thank you for reacts my boys. This is my top list from TXT. Thanks for great feedbacks, and yeah our boys always serveds a new/differents and the fresh one. Once again, thank you
This is my 1st time commenting and can you react to txt's cover? They have like as i remember : Sherlock (shinee's cover) Sriracha Replay (shinee) Could you please react to this thank you! I loved u guys reaction!
Thanks for reacting to this! I have some collaborations with other artists that txt collabs with : ("ps5" by salem ilese ft. TXT yeonjun and taehyun) she's also one of the producers of txt anti-romantic! And also pls reacts to (valley of lies iann dior ft. TXT)
how can ppl not like this song its literally so groovy
This song is a perfect example of how you can use auto tune effectively. The effect is there without masking their voices! Their colors and clarity still manage to push through beautifully.
they are coming back on 27th guys!!! cant wait for it
A masterpiece of a song tbh 😌
Happy new yearrrrr!!! Thank you for reacting to my request
TXT- RING PLEASE 😭😭😭
Suggestions: For TXT: Trust Fund Baby (beautiful ballad) New Rules (best with watching a live performance, the dance adds to it so much) For SKZ: Placebo 2020, their "Kingdom" cover of "I'll Be Your Man" by BTOB is also a masterpiece For others: Any of BIBI's "Lowlife Princess" album (particular favorites are Wet Nightmare, Witchhunt, and of course Vengeance) As always love your reactions guys, thank you for sharing them! Happy New Year 💜🫰
9:12 THIS MONTH ON THE 27TH WITH THEIR NEW MINI ALBUM "THE NAME CHAPTER: TEMPTATION"!! LOOK FORWARD TO IT!!!
@plantbusiness6374
Жыл бұрын
Fair Warning: especially to casual fans and listeners, this album might focus on a lot more in their lore, theme-wise, concept-wise as well as the lyrics. While there are various stories their mvs tell, like the stories from their title tracks, it is not exactly the same as the txt universe/the star seekers. You can see which contents are connected to it because it's labeled at the very end of the mv or at least there is a logo somewhere. We might not know a lot so far abt the album theme but there are a lot of references in the concept trailer with the themes that is also seen in other media contents of their lore such as the webtoon and webnovel.
If you had just waited a couple more weeks you could be early reviewing their comeback! just kidding. we’ll wait for years now. Ok, they had a song Puma and a song Can’t We Just Leave The Monster Alive? and I think of this title as a combination or reference to both but not exactly.
7:25 aside from them actually doing great in this track with the use of heavy autotune and still being able to use it efficiently for them that still allow the users to enjoy, in one of their behind/interview videos they did share that this track was one of the fun tracks they recorded to. As per Beomgyu, everyone in the booth and even the producer in the studio were just vibing and dancing along with the music. Which kinda amazes me, maybe some artists that try to use autotune in their tracks might find it hard to utilize it to the best of their abilities without messing the whole thing up, txt is literally just having fun with it.
i feel like im spamming sometimes but i actually don't know how much you see on comments so i will request again 😁 hope you react to more woodz u guys are my favorite channel 😁
@HandsomeSausages
Жыл бұрын
Absolutely! Woodz is absolutely amazing so we're at it soon!!
I personally don't like the autotune in this song, but not because I think it's a sign that TXT is bad or that autotune itself is bad; I just don't like it. I _love_ the live version of this song because the autotune isn't so heavy. Thank you for the reaction
Red Lights PLEASE
I rlly like this song but after 2 times Yeah the autotune is abit too much It fits this song but wish they tune it down abit Cuz without the too much autotune i LOVE this song
Next Stray Kids (Bangchan, Hyunjin) Red Lights PLEASE!!!💚💚