The Greek knowledge was more of natural philosophy, the Muslims introduced empirical sciences and scientific methodology

@user283_

Жыл бұрын

Yeah

@insaanabdulla4522

Жыл бұрын

Your statement is exaggerated and inaccurate brother. The Archimedes principal is crucial, and i repeat, it is absolutely fundamental to the study of Fluid mechanics. And any Physicist or Engineer would tell you that fluid mechanics is the bed rock of many areas of science and technology which directly impact all our lives. Humanity would not be able to advance in many fields if we didn't have this principle with us. And Archimedes came up with this principle by means of experimentation. To say that all that Greeks did was Natural Philosophy and no experimentation is not an accurate statement.

@insaanabdulla4522

Жыл бұрын

No doubt, the Muslims like Ibn Al Haytham were crucial for the Scientific method to be fully realised. But to say that no one before the Muslims engaged in any form of emperical sciences is inaccurate. Aristotle for example was know to have conducted experiments in somewhat of a similar way to that of the scientific method. Although much more primitive in its procedures. Still, credit needs to be given where due.

@dinoraul119

Жыл бұрын

You are confusing two things.. science from muslims and science from islam are two different things. For example, a muslim may make a spaceship with speed of light but that does not imply it is because of islam

@myinstgiscarbenuim1693

Жыл бұрын

@@dinoraul119 well actually yes it is , the seeking if knowledge was heavily stressed in Islamic teachings and it's actually a worship better than fighting for the sake of islam, in order to get any advancements or flourishing in science you have to get people who are actually interested in seeking knowledge and in science in the first place, and not only that but also ethical and moral use of science , that's why islam is the reason Muslims were so advanced in science without the teachings you would get a society that was the same as ones that were neighboring it

Brothers you hit a major point around the 13 minute mark which I wrote my dissertation about. Especially when you look at enlightenment arguments against "religion" but quickly realise its actually arguments against Christianity, many of which do not apply to Islam. An example is spinoza's argument against miracles.

@sil3ntsoldier236

Жыл бұрын

What were Spinozas argument against miracles. Plz tell

@arslanaliazeem

Жыл бұрын

How can we read your dissertation? Do you have a link please?

@markward3981

Жыл бұрын

@@sil3ntsoldier236 Better to do research and educate yourself. That is beyond a KZread comment.

@jamworthy14

Жыл бұрын

@@markward3981 he said miracles are something we dont understand , in a sense where angels and god is portrayed as fairy tales spinoza is correct here as angels are just another creation like human are different creation and jinns are a different creation and stars and planets are a different creation and we think we are superior when we dont understand it. ignorance

@RodioXYZ.

Жыл бұрын

Also, Mohammed didn't fly on horse...

I feel like sitting with these brothers mashaALlah

this channel needs more attention. allahumma barik lahu..

on the last point about atheism inhibiting science, you should look up creatorgate. Dr.Eyad qunaibi did an excellent summary in his arabic channel explaining the timeline of events; In short, a chinese researcher wrote a paper in a chinese journal studying the human hand, in his summary he praised the craftsmanship of the 'creator'. this one line caused the western atheists to throw a temper tantrum, blue haired twitter mob style, demand retractions, and eventually severely lower the journal's overal 'quality score'. an entire science journal got cancelled because they couldn't handle one publication where someone implied there was a creator. those atheists are guilty of the zealotry they attribute to others.

Ibn Khaldun said, “The vanquished always want to imitate the victor in his distinctive characteristics, dress, and all his other conditions and customs”. إن المهزوم مولع بتقليد المنتصر، أبن خلدون

I was really waiting for these topics to be discussed from your side, very informative session. JazakAllah khairan.

Jazakum Allah khair Br Hijab. Great analysis as usual.

May Allah Accept your works, and make it a means of acceptance and Guidance for the Ummah!

so amazing, thanks brothers

BarakAllahu Feekum brother Hijab. A Muslim voice of reason!🤍🖤

Pythagorism emerged from earlier tradition (Orphic tradition). Yet, Greeks claimed it as mere philosophy. Then philosophy being taken an end by itself transformed epistemology. In that sense the Greeks inaugurated modern world crisis by replacing wisdom (supra natural and traditional) with profane science/philosophy (purely human and purely rational)'. Renaissance is therefore the beginning of the Dark age as it also is characterized by profane science/ philosophy: 1) lacks first principles, 2) accumulation of unfounded hypothesis and, 3) insignificant details. When Muslims scientists were in charge, they changed the game by just inserting the concept of God in to scientific and philosophical enquires. Which grounded them firmly in to first principles. As sphere of universal principles is equivalent to sphere of metaphysics, their grounding in Tawheed helped them to access essentials of reality/truth through intellectual intuition. That is why their discoveries is still in use at every sector. From Algebra to Optics through medical surgeries and medicinal plants, what they gave us is still in use. Their accuracy is directly related to their principal methodology. On the flip side, The Modern world has lost its depth and no longer begins in certainty or truth, but aim only at applications. Hence it ends up confusing science and industry. If it is applicable at the moment, no scientist cares about the metaphysical/reality/truth. Newtonian physics though applicable, the emergence of Quantum physics falsifies it. Darwin is going to end up the same at some point , but how many wars did it instigate, and how many lives lost because of it. Who cares, Modern world keeps confusing science and application. 👉 Summarized from different chapters in 'Crisis of the Modern world' by René Guénon.

May Allah bless you MH ❤

Hafadhakum Allah wa Barakah fiykum wa zadakum min fadlihi Ustadhuna aljaleel ameen

@MS-Hussain

Жыл бұрын

Ameen

@AntiAtheismIsUnstoppable

Жыл бұрын

@@MS-Hussain No. Camel urine cannot cure stomack pain. Where did you dig up that bs?

@MS-Hussain

Жыл бұрын

@@AntiAtheismIsUnstoppable 🐷 Urine will surely cure u ☺️

يعطيك العافية محمد حجاب

Br Subboor is premiering/going live with a video at 7pm, which will likely go on till 8:30pm. Decisions decisions

Why Winning is Important for Muslims 32:03 - 36:00

May Allah protect you

Important point: Hellenic culture (ancient Greek city states and Alexander's empire/successor states) had much more cultural, ethnic, philosophical etc exchange and relations with the ancestral peoples of the many peoples who belong to Islam in modern times. Alhamdulillah. Some evidence: 1. The Greek script itself decends from an adaptation of the semitic Phoenicians script. Later going on to influence the Latin and Cyrillic script. 2. When Alexander went marching he didn't go to France or Germany, he went with his armies to Anatolia, Syria, Iraq, Filistin, Egypt, Persia, Afghanistan, Central Asia(Alexandria Eschatae) and Sindh. Some of successor states lasted for centuries. Examples: Ptolmeic Egypt, Selecusia, Greco-Bactrian Kingdom, and its successor Indo-Greek Kingdom. They were not known as Greeks in the east at this time but as Yuna(Ionians).

Mashallah

Assalam alaikum Where is Hamza tzortsis channel on yt?he said he is going to have one on instagram

Mr Hijab as you know you will find the equivalent of yourself, in terms of evaluating historical events, cultural clashes, etc,, in all other nations. You are not an exception. Trying to demean Greek philosophy, logic, mathematics, is a favourite passtime of philosophers and historians from all walks of life.

@hibatuadam2777

Жыл бұрын

You are not unique either. There's trolls like you everywhere

@petrospetroupetrou9653

Жыл бұрын

@@hibatuadam2777 I am unique, so are you.

how do I join the gathering as a student? 😀

I am a mother from Gaza and I have orphaned children. We have no one after God. My husband died years ago and there is no one for us after God. I have a lot to do in life, but time is running out for me and my kids. Please stand by my son. The doctor told me that the child wants the operation on his eyes as soon as possible, but I have nothing to attribute to the operation. The doctor said that the operation costs, but I have nothing for the operation, please. I hope my brothers don't forget me about this Even by God, most of the time, there is nothing in the house, no food or drink, alhamdulillah The phone is located in Al-Ula, next to the Palestinian flag written in Arabic 🤲🕋😭

@jadeysi4

Жыл бұрын

May Allah bless you and your Children and may he grant you Goodness, Food, Drink and Protection. May he have mercy on you and your children and may he grant you Jannah, insha'allah. Stay strong, patient and grateful, Sister. Alhamdullilah

Explain yoga, ayurveda, veganism, evolution

♥️♥️♥️

No doubt Al Khwarizmi (May Allah have mercy on him) invented Algebra as we know it today. But we as muslims have to acknowledge that the Hindu numericals which he adopted were crucial to many of his works. The mathematical concept of zero was crucial to the development of modern mathematics which the world inherited from the hindus.

@TheRockeyAllen

Жыл бұрын

The entire "my invention," "your invention" argument is futile, don't you think? All knowledge is from Allah, and all knowledge has been sent down by Allah through various nations and times

@2stoon

Жыл бұрын

Who's refuting that exactly? I don't think anyone respectable in their field would ever do that.

Timing is not suitable for ppl of the subcontinent. If possible, do think abt it. Yes we can watch later, but everyone wants to be in live. Jazakallah, may Allah bless u all

@jaisalrw3494

Жыл бұрын

Muslims now exist all over the world (alhamdulillah). So its not possible to cater to every region. I'm from Nepal and I don't mind not being able to see live

@MS-Hussain

Жыл бұрын

@@jaisalrw3494 right my bro. That's why I said if it's possible. There is 5:30 difference bw India and UK. By the time they start, we go to sleep.

@Nadzz711

Жыл бұрын

its pre-recorded, its not a live recording

@AtheistReligionIsCancer

Жыл бұрын

@@jaisalrw3494 No. The sun does not set in a pool of hot water. Where did you dig up that bs?

@drmodestoesq

Жыл бұрын

@@AtheistReligionIsCancer Surah al-Kahf 83-101 Translation (Yusuf Ali) 83. They ask thee concerning Zul-qarnain. Say, “I will rehearse to you something of his story.” 84. Verily We established his power on earth, and We gave him the ways and the means to all ends. 85. One (such) way he followed, 86. Until, when he reached the setting of the sun, he found it set in a spring of murky water: Near it he found a People: We said: “O Zul-qarnain! (thou hast authority,) either to punish them, or to treat them with kindness.”

I'm sure the guy who invented the cannon was a Hungarian Jew that sultan Mehmet paid in regards to Constantinople

@drmodestoesq

Жыл бұрын

What evidence is there that Orban was a Jew?

That guy that speaks in the background is practically whispering. I always have to strain to actually hear him, why so secretive?? 😂

Actually professor George Saliba is Muslim and he is originally from Lebanon

What mobile does Hijab have?

numbers help us to calculate how many years it takes to produce present 8 billion human today

@insaanabdulla4522

Жыл бұрын

Yes. Exactly! Numbers that the Muslims predecessors adopted from the hindus.

The way I see it is that science is an insufficient tool to fully understand our reality. As human beings, we simply do not have the intellect, scope and knowledge sufficient enough for us to fully understand the grandeur of existence. Therefore, it is only logical to assume a higher power such as god must exist.

@lizadowning4389

Жыл бұрын

Nice, that's the fallacy of argument from ignorance.

@hibatuadam2777

Жыл бұрын

Correct. Good point

❤️❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹

🇿🇦

Brother hijab please research Muslim advancements in cryptography and how all the digital revolution wouldn't have happened without it.

@balarab1

Жыл бұрын

I can give you a video summary in Arabic about it if needed.

@insaanabdulla4522

Жыл бұрын

The digital revolution wouldn't have happened without a lot of things. To name a few : -Electricity -MOSFET Transistors - Internet -Digital Logic -Integrated circuit Chips And many more... And even if cryptography formed the base of some of the above mentioned technologies, the entire credit of Cryptography doesn't all go to our Muslim Ancestors. Science has always been a combined effort.

@balarab1

Жыл бұрын

@@insaanabdulla4522 the internet it self wouldn't have been possible without cryptography, if we follow your logic we can reduce every advancement in humanity to its basic elements, but would that make it insignificant?

@insaanabdulla4522

Жыл бұрын

@@balarab1 the internet in its entirety wouldn't be possible? Don't you think that a bit of a stretch brother? I'm not computer scientist, so please do correct me if I am wrong, but cryptography is crucial for encryption of data. This is what keeps the information on the internet safe and secure. The role of cryptography is primarily related to encryption of data then. But would the internet not exist at all if there was no encryption? Not at all! The concept, the idea, the functioning of the internet would still exist, although without encryption, information would surely not be protected.

@balarab1

Жыл бұрын

@@insaanabdulla4522 It's a bit complicated but internet is a network between computers, any network if not encrypted on fundamental protocol bases will be a mess, every device can access and edit all information without a way to stop it. nothing even near the internet that we know today will be possible and the project will be canceled from its beginning.

1:40 The four horsemen and their wife 🤣

The real shift in Europe happen in 1815 with the treaty of Vienna directly after the defeat of Napoleon… this new found unity in Europe allowed this civilization to advance under a new unified European front. The Muslim’s fractured and started in fighting Mohammed Ali Pasha’s rebellion, the first Ottoman-Wahabbi war etc… this allowed Europe to capitalize and advance on Eygpt… once they opened the Suez, they were able to better supply their troops in India which resulted in their victory over the Mughals…. And the rest is Victorian History!

@markward3981

Жыл бұрын

I think it is not the primary cause but a contributing cause. Thanks for posting. May Allah help us

@RevelationvsDesires

Жыл бұрын

@@markward3981 true the Qadr of Allah is primary!

@markward3981

Жыл бұрын

@@RevelationvsDesires Explain please

@RevelationvsDesires

Жыл бұрын

@@markward3981 Asalamulaikum explain what brother?

@markward3981

Жыл бұрын

@@RevelationvsDesires Walaikum Asalaam wa Rahmatulahi What exactly you meant . Just for clarity. Shukran

Aaron Bruder du liegst richtig es geht nicht darum, dass du uns das Essen vorschreibst, auch wenn du uns das empfehlst was du selber konsumierst, im Endeffekt motivierst du uns, uns gesund zu ernähren.🩵

Based on your talk, are you saying that Islam needs to become a world hegemonic power ala Great Britain or USA? African theorists are saying pretty much the same. Is this a sane attitude or desire to adopt and promote?

@akhlaqali1139

Жыл бұрын

Yes

@EV-EV-EV

Ай бұрын

Yes

Betty is…. Betty is…. Betty is…. 😂😂😂😂😂😂

քʀօʍօֆʍ

You mention finding coal in Britain, but coal without innovation is useless. The Arabs had oil but couldn’t even dig it out of the ground. You’re missing a key ingredient: innovation and a passion for invention thar existed in the culture then, the same one that existed in the Islamic golden age. 😊

The main reason Muslims translated Greek texts were to strengthen their religion and improve their health.. Not because they were inspired by Greek thinking.

@geesihalas6590

Жыл бұрын

The greek of that day was an egyptian, athenian, constantinoplean, half-persian and kretian greek. They are more middle eastern than european. The european of the nordic and the west just want to claim greek taking out of its relationship with east. The eurocentric west is doing that to boast his false pride. Not that Sweden had to do with Greece or Has to do with it now than their immediate neighbours that they shared culture, religion and science. The eurocentrics project their wishes and the blondman identity on that brown world of the mideterranean sea. Both the Romans, the Greeks were first or second citizens of Alexandria, Tunis, Gaza and Istanbul. No need to project the modern political & religious identity of today on the past. Particularly when it is about ethnogeographically similar nations.

@petrospetroupetrou9653

Жыл бұрын

@@geesihalas6590 That's a myth propagated by authors and religions jealous of Greek achievement. In the Olympic Games in Greece from 1000 BCE, only Greeks participated, from all the parts of Greece. Greeks have been living in Greece for thousands of years..indigenous.

@akhlaqali1139

Жыл бұрын

Learning our religion from confused filthy pagans 🤣 muslim scholars heavily refuted Greek delusions even mocked them. And no the Greeks were not special to us, we took knowledge from many other civilisations which were fat superior than grooks

@petrospetroupetrou9653

Жыл бұрын

@@akhlaqali1139 Buddy, you are deluded big time, and lied to. Without Greek thinking no religion, no Quran. Wake up. They are spitting on you and you think its raining .

@RodioXYZ.

Жыл бұрын

To strengthen their religion? So their religion was weak.

1:00:50 It is common descent that is evidentially on par with heliocentrism. Not the theory about mechanism. None of the third way scientists dispute that common descent is an established fact comparable to the earth orbitting the sun. And Dawkins never claimed natural selection is as secure as this. He explicitly accepts that it isn't. Only the part that refutes islam is known with certainty. Hijab is making the standard creationist error of conflating the fact of evolution with the mechanisms of evolution.

@wandering3ngineer

Жыл бұрын

Some clarification. Can you elaborate vis a vis the facts of evolution vs the mechanism? Are you saying that the Islamic position disregards the concept of common descent? And that this common descent is something that is an established fact of evolution?

@DetInspectorMonkfish

Жыл бұрын

@@wandering3ngineer common descent is one thing, the mechanism of how the species diverged is another. There is some debate about mechanism, and questions about the exact role natural selection plays. But none of this casts doubt on the established fact that humans share close ancestors with chimpanzees. Which conflicts with special creation as described by the quran.

The WHY (purpose) question can't be answered by science, nor can it be answered by religion. It's an impossible to answer question and therefore useless. Religion claims it does answer it but gets no further than cry "god" and "goddidit" However, that's doesn't explain a thing. It doesn't get us any further in understanding. It is begging the question and as such a fallacy in itself. Therefore, it is not a category fallacy since the "why question", as impossible to answer, clearly belongs to another category than the WHAT and HOW questions, which are possible to answer.

@h.k.3704

Жыл бұрын

Religions, doesnt matter which ones, mostly answer the why question regardless of how true people think they are, because most of them either believe in afterlife or reincarnation etc, i.e immortal consciousness or soul. They are theories based on either ignorance or philosophy. On the other hand, science promotes nihilism. There is absolutely no reason to exist, due to the fact that we die. For every action there is a reaction but when you look at the big picture of human life, you wont get a reaction for your action but death/nothingness which is not a reaction. İf we were immortal there would then be no reason to beg these questions and religions would be fewer and lighter in importance.

please find wisdom!

How can i attend these sessions? Are they open to everyone

Quran taught everyone including western civilisation.

@EV-EV-EV

Ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂😂

After complaining about what happened 20 years, 50 years, 100 years, and more ago, how much progress has been made in the last two years, five years, or ten years? So, what was the point of this 60 minutes video? It is time to move on!

@oayysz8909

Жыл бұрын

Complaining ? , watch the last minute a summary of the very educational historical points and contemporary misconceptions are mentioned.

delusional

This guy doesnt know what he is talking about.. all those book behnd him , he didnt even read them..

There are no real gods There are only people that believe gods are real. The problem with using gods as explanations, apart from the fact they explain nothing, a god can be anything you need or want it to be. You are limited only by what you can imagine

@discoveringtruth594

Жыл бұрын

How do you know there isn't a God? You lie, that's why the punishment in the hereafter is justified against you. Secondly, God explains everything, original existence, intelligent universe, consciousness, objective morality etc. etc. Atheism? The worst of *Delusions*.

@Spined1234

Жыл бұрын

I'm guessing you don't believe in justice, human rights and morality either since there's no scientific evidence for it.

@mickqQ

Жыл бұрын

@@discoveringtruth594 I know that gods don’t exist, the same way I know fairies and leprechauns and imps do not exist. There is no hereafter , death is the end. Gods don’t explain anything, There is a difference between an answer, and an explanation. Gods do not explain anything.

@mickqQ

Жыл бұрын

@@Spined1234 Why would I need scientific evidence to believe in human concepts of justice, rights , morality etc

@Spined1234

Жыл бұрын

@@mickqQ Oh so you don't need scientific evidence to believe in God, right?

Embarrassing

Step by step guide on "How to defend Islam?". 🤣🤣🤣 Brainwashing works magically.

@RodioXYZ.

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂

Islam and science = oil and water

Mashallah