Hearing "the Bow tie man is the go to person for Redstone tutorials"... How!? I'm an idiot 😂 But like you said in the vid, there are lots of insane redstoners who never do anything with their builds, so it's great that people are slowly starting to make content for it 😅 Thanks so much, well put together video. Also... I'm sorry for stealing your top spot on 3x3s 😮😅

@dredstone5608

4 жыл бұрын

Road to 1milion sub!!:)

@LNC123yt

3 жыл бұрын

Third big fan btw I did I triple piston extender cause I was inspired by you

@bobbob-io1tn

3 жыл бұрын

Hello

@lachieoverlord1253

3 жыл бұрын

@@dredstone5608 how….?

@chlarynce1502

2 жыл бұрын

I'm really I big big big!! Huge!! Fan

Yeah I can forgive most of the little quirks and problems of Bedrock, the inconsistencies however is unforgivable, lol

@Bazzable

3 жыл бұрын

Bedrock redstone is how it was originally intended to be half of the "features" in java redstone were originally glitches that they didn't feel like fixing

@GoggledGecko

3 жыл бұрын

@@Bazzable yeah, that's true. Honestly I prefer Bedrock redstone, that's why I made tutorials on it. It can just be a bit demotivating when you suddenly find out that it apparently doesn't work anymore, even though it worked like 5 times during testing

@yuborthedominator687

3 жыл бұрын

@@Bazzable useful glitches is what made all the tech smash melee for example. It makes things more fun!

@Bazzable

3 жыл бұрын

@@yuborthedominator687 still you can't call one bad it's in the opinion some people like bedrock redstone better and java better I they made everything one of them it would ruin it

@ashlyy1341

3 жыл бұрын

given bedrock's universal nature and more efficient code (how much of that is using C++ rather than java and how much is better optimisation), it'd be nice if the reliability of java redstone and the faster pistons made it across even if some of the other stuff didn't. movable tile entities seems like both a blessing and a curse depending on what you're doing. i do prefer the java ui though

12:45 - I prefer to term these types of farm “growth-tick abuse” of which “zero-tick based growth-tick abuse” (or “zero-tick growth abuse” for short) is a subset.

@RedstoneWizard1983

2 жыл бұрын

I call them forced update farms.

First of all, thanks for the shoutout I wanted to say that observers have a 2 tick delay for the first 3 in a chain and then a 1 tick delay for the rest (roughly). Also, on the topic of weird pulses on bedrock, if you build a piston based monostable (repeater going into piston set to 2 ticks and repeater set to 1 tick going into block before it extends) and change the timings to 3 ticks (for the repeater going into the block) and 1 tick, on the falling edge you will create a pulse that works in the opposite way than the "0 tick pulses" that I mentioned.

@CraftyMasterman

4 жыл бұрын

more shoutouts for you :p

@Benthehuman

4 жыл бұрын

CraftyMasterman yee thanks once again

@jonathanpeters4240

4 жыл бұрын

Also redstone lamps, for what it’s worth

@Aydentv

4 жыл бұрын

what do you mean opposite of zero tick.. like a 1.5 tick lol??

@Benthehuman

4 жыл бұрын

Ayden tv It's correct name is a p tick. I will be doing a vid abt them soon

This is one of the few people who actually tried and understand Minecraft Bedrock (from gameplay mechanics to community) before giving a rant...

Sadly, you're right, good bedrock youtubers are kind of hidden, a ton of them have less than 100 subscribers, so you just have to find them.

@shaunpathrosepaul6804

3 жыл бұрын

Ibxtoycat is a bedrock advocate

@instructorsnow3266

3 жыл бұрын

@@shaunpathrosepaul6804 no, he doesn’t do redstone or tech at all, just casual vids

@eggiesadventuresoffun3282

3 жыл бұрын

@@instructorsnow3266 what about silent whisperer

@instructorsnow3266

3 жыл бұрын

@@eggiesadventuresoffun3282 he’s not a good bedrock youtuber, he’s in the bad youtuber category like skippy6gaming etc

As a bedrock edition player, i can confirm the redstone here sucks lol (Only upside is moving containers which is really useful) But the inconsistencies here are horrible, its just like a flying machine will sometimes work and sometimes just destroy itself

@dangamertop9253

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, you can download Minecraft java for Android phones now, not official of course, because there is no point playing bedrock if your pc runs java

@darth3911

2 жыл бұрын

I have both versions i want a update to fix the redstone in bedrock i have made a hidden door inside of the bedrock edition the redstone for it is 3 times larger then what would be needed in Java.

@ThylineTheGay

2 жыл бұрын

@@darth3911 bedrock having java redstone and java having movable tile entities would be the best parity fix ever

@darth3911

2 жыл бұрын

@@ThylineTheGay That and a command expansion currently bedrock edition lacks the ability to get custom damage and durability on weapons/armor and also lacks the ability to get the max lvl of enchantments

@timewarpdrive77

2 жыл бұрын

container minecarts go bRRRRRRR

Nice subtle roast on Skippy 6 gaming. I always had a suspicion he didn't come up with ideas on his own.

@martinzapata7289

4 жыл бұрын

A “suspicion”. Lol, it’s clear he doesn’t have an fing clue about what he shows in his videos.

@Aydentv

4 жыл бұрын

i have seen my builds i have posted on reddit, discord, and other places show up as a tutorial on his channel like a week ir so later.. same design.. same spaghetti ghetto redstone.. i recomend ppl watch rogue fox, the bowtie man, and eg2pro if they want to learn about redstone.. smh so many bedrock youtubers are simply content theives.. no credit given, claim its their design, or they wanna do it but the bedrock verison cant.. lol bedrock redstone can do anything java redstone can.. but the timings and some circuits most be changed cuz we dont have quasi connectivity, block spitting, etc.. ive seen and downloaded a Sahara with sahara now and the lottery thing made in bedrock!! with the same look made block for block... it is but eg2pro i believe.. he also did iskalls run mini game as well

@asherkime5910

3 жыл бұрын

That guy doesn’t even have ideas

I was able to make a randomiser in Bedrock Edition using the inconsistency in pistons being powered at the same time by the same block.

@theseangle

Жыл бұрын

Lol, is there a statistic? Is it 50/50 chance (giving a large sample)? Or like 60/40? Knowing Bedrock the latter case being true won't surprise me

@ninjadude_yt404

Жыл бұрын

@@theseangle I’m not sure, it felt like a 50/50 chance. I’ll need to try this.

Yes, Can really relate to the "it doesn't work" experience. I'm part of a coding community where people ask question, and some of them just say "it doesn't work" and doesn't provide any details. Others just throw some random code and expects us to complete the rest of it. So annoying, At least put some effort onto it before giving up.

@lohostege

2 жыл бұрын

Somebody: "It doesn't work!" You: Sees a semicolon is missing

0-tick means a redstone pulse that takes 0 ticks, similar to 1-tick, 2-tick etc. 0-tick farms are farms that work with 0-ticks and 0-tick piston doors are doors that work with 0-ticks. The bedrock "0-tick farm should be called "3-tick farm" bevause that clock give 3-tick pulses. In the ovserver with sticly piston thing can be called a 0-tick pulse,but it is kinda useless compared to java 0-tick

Bridging the gap between Java and Bedrock Redstone will be the best way to ensure it'll work first time, beyond manually checking over it and comparing to the tutorial. In my opinion, the Java's piston mechanics and Bedrock's movable storage blocks should be consistent across both versions.

@ThylineTheGay

2 жыл бұрын

yeah, movable tile entities would be literally the greatest thing for java since observers.

@idkyet9458

2 жыл бұрын

i don't think java's piston mechanics should be on bedrock because it just doesn't make sense

@Request_2_PANic

2 жыл бұрын

@@idkyet9458 With how useful they are for T flip flops, there's a reason Java players wanted them back when they were patched.

@Chorismos

Жыл бұрын

​@@Request_2_PANic I think One-tick pulses on a Honey Piston would be good but I don't think QC should come to Bedrock.

@Request_2_PANic

Жыл бұрын

@@Chorismos I saw a video from Rays Works since this mentioning the idea of including both Java and Bedrock Redstone mechanics as different kinds of components like with the calibrated sculk sensor.

it should probably be said that the weird psuedo 0-tick can also be done by having an observer running into sand with a piston facing upwards,redstone dust next to the sand on top of an opaque block. I probably did a terrible job making it WAY more complicated than it actually is.

i remember building a 3 by 3 piston door, i decided to make my own design and it was soo big and bulky that it took up half of my base. i still wonder how it worked, it later broke itself and still stands in my old world till today,

Omg comments on tutorials are either super gratifying, or literally the worst most annoying comments you can ever receive

There are ways to make double, triple etc extenders on bedrock but it has a different circuit

0 tick is very possible on legacy console, i made a useless machine that extends instantly and retracts in 0.3 seconds. Same design as on my synergy plot (mqxf)

@tjneumann7828

2 жыл бұрын

0 tick pulses? Yes. 0 tick based growth abuse farms? No.

7:15 the switch is on the top here, so its the same distance from both pistons, on the java, it was closer to the one in front

@eddie1538

Жыл бұрын

Thats not even ho it orks. I have a broken vv key.

This is the reason why it took my 3 months to build a 6x6 from scratch

My biggest gripe about bedrock is that it was forced on me, PS4, and broke so much stuff im still finding and fixing things to this day. It makes small kelp, sugarcane, ect farms so stupidly slow. Painful.

@rubydotson1857

2 жыл бұрын

At least the legacy edition is still available

@CreeperBoyGamingyt

2 жыл бұрын

@@rubydotson1857 as long as you have the Minecraft disc and not the virtual download of it, you have access to it. At least, as far as I know. I haven’t checked in a while.

@woooshbait9696

Жыл бұрын

@@CreeperBoyGamingyt he need to learn some redstone and stop copying from youtube video

steve blinking is so cursed

08:25 "discovered by ben the human" As much as I like his content, no he didn't discover them 😂 there are videos showing C pulses before that

Also the trapdoors dont make u crawl in Bedrock ;-;

@idkyet9458

2 жыл бұрын

you can use water to crawl and also this epic glitch kzread.info/dash/bejne/Y4SXmNFmptG9hM4.html

Bedrock itself is pretty good, except the redstone. If they make redstone parity between both versions that would be absolutely amazing

console differences could also include: +you can move tile entities +lamps update pistons +fencegates update pistons -noteblocks don't work

@CraftyMasterman

4 жыл бұрын

You can't move containers on legacy console?

@Cwee957

3 жыл бұрын

@@CraftyMasterman chest

Just the video I needed. Also I failed trying to make the magic cobble smaller

This channel deserves way more subs

Yeah.. Bedrock redstoner really underrated And very forgotten

@BigTadger

3 жыл бұрын

Its a shame as I moved from java to bedrock for the redstone it's much harder and more impressive in my opinion I love building redstone 😂

@cactuslol7669

3 жыл бұрын

Forgiven what the literal hell is not glitched in bedrock. It’s overrated

God Legacy console looks so much more visually pleasing than Console Bedrock (not even the texture pack, it just looks more polished)

@spocite

2 жыл бұрын

TRUEE

Java Redstone is technically "buggy-er" but since it has been like that for a long time, it has become not a bug, but a feature.

@darklordofbavaria6398

2 ай бұрын

The advantage of Java is that the Bugs are consistent and predictable so you can use them.

I love that mechanic, it's so handy for flying machine stuff 11:05

Ok, but what’s up with the subtitles??

The weirdest redstone misconception I've seen so far was from a bedrock youtuber briefly ranting about a 'bug' where observers will clock pistons that they're both observing and powering. However, this behavior also happens on Java and gave me a lot of pain when I first got back into redstone.

There's a way to make unlimited distance wireless redstone (it uses loaded chunks). The way it is done is using torch clocks and controlled by a particular torch/piston clock.

Your and Kwipla's channels are growing quickly. 2K is close!

@Cwee957

4 жыл бұрын

Kwipla's voice is so nice 😂... he could do ASMR

@justdavid3117

4 жыл бұрын

@@Cwee957 agree xd

20:34 Yup, I know that feeling too well ._.

@VoidedandLost

3 жыл бұрын

😅 It may have taken me a year to find this video but I was just going to make that same comment! Lol! 👍

I remember me and bowtieman talking in the comment section weeks ago, but now he stopped uploading, and i miss him

people just slapping '0 tick' on their farms drives me mad too, its terrible...

dude im addicted to your vids

I agree, when playstation switched to bedrock it forced me to buy a pc. You could push buttons around with pistons on ps4 java edition though, which I miss.

I used to play bedrock edition and was part of the technical players that just didn't post about the technical stuff I did but ever since I switched to linux I kind of had to use the java edition which sucks because I like the movable tile entities, no quasi-connectivity, and redstone redirection into pistons which the java edition doesn't have. The pain points I experience from both are different but at least I have more tools at my disposal in java to diagnose issues than I have on bedrock with mods.

A lot of what you said can’t be done in bedrock can be done but you have to do it differently

The bow tie man inspired me to start tnt compressing on bedrock edition

2:50 If you pause, you can see the lamps don't "turn on and off at the exact same time".

This came out on my birthday :)

Does this work on bedrock?

@PrivateLZG

2 жыл бұрын

Ok I might have to downgrade my grammar for the future lmao

Console is the perfect version, c'mon why Mojang didn't make they all with same mechanism

I figured out how to do 1 tick pulses (sticky piston spots out it’s block) you need to have said block be a slime block and hit it with a stalagmite, which will cause it to stay in the same spot

The "It didnt work thing" I can relate to bc I did the redstone padlock and it didnt work, I relooked it and I made it backwards on accident

Honestly a mix of both would be nice, each of the good from java, and the good from bedrock

The 0 tike thiny isnt powering the 2 lamps at the same time

You have to use the 3 6 Redstone dust for double piston extenders

the doulbe piston for bedrock just have different repeater timings than java. so it does exist

Yeah inconsistencies is the main reason why I move from bedrock to Java, just imagine troubleshooting it, that'll be torture.

I Love piston randomizer cuz of s gambling games that U can make

I swear in the video that the instant repeater doesn't turn the light on and off at the same time.

You can also use levers on pistons in bedrock, just like in the legacy version

My issue is that it *does* work... until I save and come back. Then it stops working and I am not skilled enough to figure out what Bedrock broke.

"holy spinal pain" - youtube captions

Ik that a lot of redstoners dislike not being able to move tile entities with pistons, but sometimes it's pretty nice when dealing with slime and honey

I was just making a giant xp farm and I just realized my bud switch is impossible to make

I warn you, DO NOT watch this video with subtitles

we call the farms zero tick farms cuz alot of ppl think it is zero tick cuz they think the random tick speed is broken and the world think it is glitching the world to remo e the random tick speed that grows plants etc to 0

oh god he didnt even mention the flying machines in bedrock.....

Everyone always says movable containers is soooo good but no one thinks about the restone implications try working with flying machines and not having easy access to immovable objects the negatives outweigh the positives

Lol the 0 tick pulses sound effects

My two favorite youtuber is watching this video 😀

want a java vs bedrock rant from a bedrock players perspective

19:10 *Hot garbage* Me: Smallest 4x4 door is 540 blocks

I used to love redstone cuz the xbox one edition redstone made sense You can imagine my disappointment of xbox one edition being discontinued I left a one star review on bedrock

7:00 that can be actually used to generate a random number dang

14:20 Do you think it uses 0 tick pulses?

The only reason piston budding works in java and not in bedrock is because when Mojang made the piston, Mojang copied the code from the (I think) iron door. In bedrock, on the other hand, Mojang redid the entire code for the piston.

I play BE and legitimately liked the video before it even started playing. This topic needs far more publicity from both sides of MC, so hopefully Mojang will see this and decided to not let the redstoners of BE die out.

To explain Java zero tick (I’m on bedrock) it also uses update order. In the Minecraft code all the repeaters do their math before all the comparator because code runs top to bottom and the since the repeater was added before the comparacter it’s earlier in the code

@rednc325

3 жыл бұрын

Not really. Comparators power later in the tick because of "tiletick priority", which is the order in which components power within a tick. 0 tick monostables which rely on tiletick priority aren't used much at all too.

@woooshbait9696

Жыл бұрын

bedrock doesnt have update order, it run everything at once and it randomize the process that cant happen simultaneously

@asherkime5910

Жыл бұрын

@@rednc325 that's why tile tick priority exist, because repeaters are earlier in the code

@asherkime5910

Жыл бұрын

@@woooshbait9696 ok, nobody is talking about that

There is a glitch in bedrock it happened for me the sticky piston didn’t retract the block

Thanks for adding console!😊

LOL I am a bedrock redstoner. But my builds are very huge

Ok, but on the topic of asking if something still works, if someone just says “it doesn’t work” without anything else, I get that it can get really annoying. But some people are asking if the red stone still works in newer versions. And that’s not the redstoner’s fault and they should not get offended by it. It’s because the red stone changes in an update sometimes breaks stuff. Especially stuff that uses weird quirks and glitches. Anyways, I just wanted to point that out

So you don't know about the sand method on bedrock?

Honestly i respect this, not flaming the other side because its not the same.I have played both and every side thinks the other is stupid which is untrue both sides are fun and the redstone and features are different which is kinda dumb but its still minecraft and minecraft is fun on either sides

Yup said it all good but I would like to point out that on Java the the budding with 2 high pistons is because of something most people cal quasi connectivity and it’s just that pistons check if the block above them are powered in Java.

Btw way double piston extender is is 3 6 0 for the ticks

@rednc325

3 жыл бұрын

On java it's 2 4 0, so he used that to demonstrate the difference between Java and bedrock.

I wish pistons were consistent

It's not that it's different, it's that it's inconsistent.

4:26 ehm ehm.. This is possible in bedrock but the middle one need to be 2 (4tick) redstone repeater and the first one is 1 (4tick) redstone repeater and the ladt one, just like in the video, normal redstone.

Whats your name on xbox ? Cause someone named craftymasterman joined my friend Snoworde and RedSignial's map 🤔 . Anyway, java is the best version ... 1 tick pulses do all the job

@CraftyMasterman

4 жыл бұрын

ye redsignal invited me sometimes

@Cwee957

4 жыл бұрын

@@CraftyMasterman oh ok so you have seen his smallest 6high door ? I don't know how this guy do this type of things 😂 i can't even do a compact 7x7 door 😒

They still haven't fixed the Steve skin glitch wtfff

i made a 3x3 piston door in bedrock it is 10000x worse than my 4x4 on hava

It doesn’t matter what you play it matters if you have fun

@elijahsmall5873

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@Somebrokenglass

3 жыл бұрын

@@elijahsmall5873 See your getting it:D

@elijahsmall5873

3 жыл бұрын

@@Somebrokenglass I've always have.

to me bedrock redstone seems like what someone might think that java redstone works, but then did it completely differently

I never really understood why they made them so different? Were there different dev teams and no one between the two teams ever talk?

@nickbozonelos4446

3 жыл бұрын

Its because they're actually written on 2 different programming languages. Java is made on, well, java, and Bedrock is made on C# I believe

@williamludwick77

3 жыл бұрын

@@nickbozonelos4446 right I knew they were written in 2 different languages, I just meant why didn't they have the outcome of what things do be the same? I realize that you can't just take the code from one and copy/paste into another, but the different dev teams could have worked together to figure out a joint solution that would make them act the same so that we don't end up like we are - with basically 2 different communities (Java vs Bedrock)

@nickbozonelos4446

3 жыл бұрын

@@williamludwick77 Sure, that's a good point. I'm not really sure why it's so different. Especially with redstone, my guess is that the formatting/structure of C#, since it's a simpler language, doesn't allow for some of the more complex and nuanced features of java, such as the redstone priority, or the instant pistons, or the ability to 0-tick. As for the other features, beats me honestly. Bedrock never actually got a combat update, so all of their combats mechanics except for the removal of blocking and the addition of shields are the same as pre-1.9. Its wacky

@nickbozonelos4446

3 жыл бұрын

@@williamludwick77 Welp, I just spent 5 minutes weiting a response, trying to answer the question the best I can, and KZread just said 'none of that'. Sorry man, I'll try to condense it and respond in another comment lmao

@williamludwick77

3 жыл бұрын

@@nickbozonelos4446 it's ok. I was just complaining about the inconsistencies between the 2 versions.

It's weird to think that alot of Java redstone techniques are little quirks/bugs due to the limits of the engine

25:20 luckely you don‘t mean me crafty xD

captions had a stroke on this video

I genuinely love how salty you feel for things so inconsequential

i really dont understand, what the point of bedrock minecraft is. to just name a few things for java: - mods - better redstone - looks better (my opinion, maby just because im used to java) - mods (yes again) - no microtransactions things for bedrock: - RTX (if you have the gpu for it) (also just use a shader in java and its looks better) - moveable containers (yea is nice but again java has mods for things like this) - runs better and the world renders faster (optifine, sodium) So yea java better, wayyyy better

@poom323

2 жыл бұрын

Cheaper(pocket edition)

@raymondstheawesome

2 жыл бұрын

bedrock was made for devices that don't support the java programming language. and also for cross-platform play

@rfreaky4717

2 жыл бұрын

@@raymondstheawesome They why is it worse than java in so many ways?

@siamcheese

Жыл бұрын

Also better visuals wen your the window when render dragon was Installed to bedrock

Yes I tried to use 0 tick For the 3x3 doors in java and it works properly. But I try to do it on bedrock edition with a different setup because bedrock pistons don't spit out their block So it ends it up to be a 1.2 tick 3x3 door

@siamcheese

Жыл бұрын

I think even if you somehow manage to one tick a piston in bedrock it won’t spit out the block

I have multiple farms in my pocket edition world that aren't exactly like that but are just slightly slower than the bamboo farm he shows at 15:52

Sometimes you get so used to a glitch it becomes a normality.

@hibblebins

11 ай бұрын

Its not a glitch, its a feature.