Mark is gently ripping him to pieces, like he rightly deserves. Those movies were such a wasted opportunity. Mark speaks for all of us here.

@Ghjgfjjgv

7 ай бұрын

I agree the movies are bad, but why does he sh*t all over them any chance he gets? I seen an interview where he said he thought the part where the lightsaber goes to Rey was going to go to him instead and he was gonna fight Kylo, these movies aren’t about him, he already had his trilogy. From what I’ve seen, he seems like an egomaniac who is bitter he wasn’t the main character of this trilogy

@georgebwp9890

7 ай бұрын

​@Ghjgfjjgv The miscommunication between 7 8 and nine is Disgusting and Ryan Johnson Wanted to make film where half the audience hates it and half the audience likes it. He said that in an interview he had no interest in making a good star wars film. And the films was supposed to be about luke laya and han

@Ghjgfjjgv

7 ай бұрын

@@georgebwp9890 I agree, the petty directors undoing everything in the previous movie before them was dumb, but it’s just the way he speaks, he sh*ts all over it any and every chance he gets, you just know if he was the main star like he so clearly wanted to be then he wouldn’t act the same

@georgebwp9890

7 ай бұрын

@Ghjgfjjgv he would if they changed the character Off screen like they did in these movies.i understand his Frustration Luke skywalker would have never got to the point that they showed in the sequels. Disney wanted an immediate return with their investment with Star Wars. So they pushed the films out without any care. That's why no one sees them as cannon

@matthewatwood8641

7 ай бұрын

Been saying😐 He truly does🙂

To just roast the guy to his face is amazing

@ZeroAudioOutput

6 ай бұрын

He later tweeted about how he thinks the movie is great and he regrets saying any of this.

@---jx3ql

6 ай бұрын

​@@ZeroAudioOutputwas that one of the forced or later removed tweets?

@---jx3ql

6 ай бұрын

Best is how he hide his face cause he knew if Mark says that its more than fair critic and true

@ZeroAudioOutput

6 ай бұрын

@@---jx3ql It's still up, but feel free to believe your conspiracies

@---jx3ql

6 ай бұрын

@@ZeroAudioOutput just comformed facts

From the very beginning Mark stood with the fans. Thank you.

"Forget the past, kill it if you have to. You're doing a pretty good job" Rian Johnson: "I'm trying" That says it all right there.

@llcoolg8682

6 ай бұрын

Right?? Rian Johnson is such a lousy pos director… he had 0 qualifications to direct such an important Star Wars film. I swear to god it was all Kathleen Kennedy’s plan to hire him on just because Rian wanted to make such a dumbass film that literally NO ONE wanted to fucking see or hear! Same with JJ Abrams. They all fucking suck and have ruined Star Wars.

@davidm4566

6 ай бұрын

This is basically new disney slogan across the board in Marvel and Star Wars.

@chriswilliams3084

Ай бұрын

@TheBerylknight - Excellent point. Johnson's ego...his arrogance...all on display with that one small statement, as well as with his cocky attitude about not changing anything if given the opportunity. It almost feels like Johnson wanted to direct Episode IX so he could be the one to oversee and implement what would be some of the more important moments of the saga, some of which felt rushed and out of place...some that should have happened in the last film (E.g. The revelation of Rey's parents, Snoke's death, the final showdown between Kylo Ren and Luke, and, of course, the death of Luke Skywalker). I can easily imagine a scenario where, even though Johnson was picked to make VIII instead of IX, he decided that he would include said important moments anyway, as a way of saying "Screw you Disney."

Man said this to his face, Mark is the man. The best.

The Sequels were terrible and not canon.

@mistajankins6388

7 ай бұрын

They're definitely Canon, and that's the worst part about them

@Magical-Melon

6 ай бұрын

Whatever Disney says the EU is cannon and always will be

@ricktheexplorer

6 ай бұрын

@@Magical-Melon Disney says all EU doesn't exist, it's part of why they are horrible with Star Wars.

@Magical-Melon

6 ай бұрын

@@ricktheexplorer fuck disney i dont care about what they think the EU will always be cannon

@TurtlePower-69

6 ай бұрын

George Lucas says they ain't cannon and that's good enough for me

Once Luke threw his lightsaver into the water l was done what is that BS

@JnEricsonx

7 ай бұрын

And then JJ for what its worth tried fixing that shit in the next film.

@diegozuniga6122

6 ай бұрын

It wasn't actually his, still that's the only part I don't have a problem with, I mean his Father literally killed children with it, is not something you really wanna have around

@ivantryon1162

6 ай бұрын

@@diegozuniga6122it was his first lightsaber

@diegozuniga6122

6 ай бұрын

@@ivantryon1162 yeah, but at that time, he lost it 40 years ago, because Darth Vader cut his hand and right after that he learned that he is his father. Also then he learned about order 66 and everything his father did with that lightsaber. Not so many good memories with that thing.

@viktorvondoom5950

6 ай бұрын

​​@@diegozuniga6122If that was the case where is the acknowledgement? If Luke had started at it and remarked on the sabers dark past before throwing it away or at least had a painful expression on his face, we would have got it. Instead he just threw it over his shoulder like it was trash. So no, I do not believe that was the intent if that scene. Rather it was meant to be a Cheap attempt at a joke

We certainly got something we didn't want

Really shows how intelligent Mark is when he can subtly rip Rian apart, and the guy seems clueless. I think Mark should have been commissioned to help write some scripts. He is a huge fan, after all, and knows what we the fans wanted.

When your main series actor disagrees strongly with your writing...THATS THE CUE TO REWRITE YOUR SCRIPT

@thePsiMatrix

6 ай бұрын

Mark makes at least 3 that have grown to despise the Disney Trilogy as much as the rest of us. Adam Driver and John Boyega have both said 'done' to it as well. But no, they keep doing stuff 'that fans don't want and we do'.

@shaneh3109

6 ай бұрын

@@thePsiMatrix legit all they had to do, was make money off the toys and merch from the first 6 movies. They didn't need to destroy star wars. Heck if they wanted to...they could've just made rogue one and left it at that

@Heffelz8

6 ай бұрын

It's not even so much that he is one of the main actors in this movie, it's so much more that he IS Luke Skywalker and should have so much more to say about the development of that character than Rian.

@bconroy328

6 ай бұрын

​@@thePsiMatrix make it 4 Oscar issac legit was also pissed at his character too

@shaneh3109

5 ай бұрын

@@bconroy328 So was John b. They did those boys dirty

I love how the stupid people clap when Mark says "No we give them something we want" 🙄

@BenjaminDaCunha-ys8ty

7 ай бұрын

Basically any Star Wars fan at a convention or opening night premiere. I was at Last Jedi opening night and people clapped I couldn’t believe it.

@llcoolg8682

6 ай бұрын

Lmao dude I think you’re the stupid one here. They were literally just agreeing with what Mark was saying…💀💀

@sora2534

6 ай бұрын

​@BenjaminDaCunha-ys8ty I thought Star Wars fans were smart

@JP-eu2dc

6 ай бұрын

What are you getting about here?

Who star wars listens to when making new shows/films: Fans: 5% Own opinion: 15% Critics: 80%

@WhiteManOnCampus

7 ай бұрын

Nah, the critics have been provably bought off for other Disney productions, and have silenced dissent. Disney tells the critics what to say, the critics don't tell Disney what to make.

@mikeo9074

7 ай бұрын

Critics don’t exist anymore, now they’re just paid journalists.

"Give them something we want Not something they want."... And that is why you fail!😢

@wolfatron3980

6 ай бұрын

That is why we get so much shlock from delusional directors, making shit that nobody wants, they did it to halo, Velma, star wars, and it's starting to happen to the witcher, they think they know better than the fans and would rather scrap everything that came before just to fit what they want

RJ and Kennedy are hemorrhoids on Star Wars and should never have been brought it. They killed off the great characters and pushed new ones that no one cares about. They used Star Wars like it was their own creation.

@George-pp2hr

6 ай бұрын

You said it. When I sat for the Force Awakens I was expecting something since back in the day 1977 blown away by an amazing phenomenon called 'Star Wars' the beginning with the Star Destroyer from overhead that's miles long, to the first battle with the Stormtroopers, Darth Vader walks in stops looks around ... I can go on forever. For me as 10 year old the excitement .. was....and on the wide screen... My God! It feels like the ships are going to come out of the screen! Aaaaaaah! Back to the point I was about to make.. I forgot.. Oh yes The Force Awakens nothing. I came out of the theatre with a sour face. Oh boy! So much CGI... I couldn't get enough ...Not.. and The last Jedi I was expecting to see Luke Skywalker but I lost him only to show up a few second intervals at a time... What happened to Luke I was thinking. Towards the end he's vanished like Yoda..just like that. This film I left the theatre with a screwed face. Unnecessary sequels. Thanks all.👍🦘🐨

I can’t even imagine what George thinks about all of this..

@davidm4566

6 ай бұрын

You can see in some of the interviews. It's sad and breaks my heart, but at least he walked away with $2B in cash and $2B in disney stock. Hopefully he sold that stock before it significantly dropped in price.

@Klaus_Kinski179

Ай бұрын

​@@davidm4566it dropped because he sold😂

It is hilarious that the audience is cheering that sick burn. Unfortunately I think they might not have caught the sarcasm and were actually cheering just to cheer or the literal thing he said.

Rian is a great writer for original ideas, his ideas just don’t work for established franchises though

@priestesslucy3299

7 ай бұрын

For real. Take away all the names linking TLJ to the starwars and it's a pretty good standalone movie. But it's a terrible Starwars film

@JnEricsonx

7 ай бұрын

This. I LOVE the Knives Out films. But he did that from ground up. Sometimes you don't fuck with established things.

@blacksheddie1972

6 ай бұрын

The whole problem with the sequel trilogy is Kathleen Kennedy threw out Lucas’ story treatments. They didn’t even have an overarching story plot and let each director make it up on the fly. Absolute madness. I can’t even watch the old ones now. Even after I seen the force awakens I was done.

Sheeple clapping at the end thinking it was a compliment 😅

You also have to lay blame at JJ Abrahms as well since he was Executive Producer for the entire trilogy so he signed off on what Rian was doing.

“Kill it if we have to” “That’s right” 😂 I’m done

Too bad Disney, Ryan, Kathleen Kennedy, and JJ Abrams don't care for George Lucas's creation. One of the reasons I like my version of the sequel Trilogy more is that it actually has respect for George Lucas's creation

@godphoenix66x

7 ай бұрын

George didn't care about it either. That's why he sold it to the Hacks at Disney. He only cared about money. Always remember that.

@lionbolt2136

6 ай бұрын

​@@godphoenix66xLucas is a really old guy. Don't think he would have the time or energy to direct the sequel trilogy. And the clone wars show was causing Lucas to lose money rather than make it.

"We have to give them what they don't expect and what we want." They've been doing that throughout hollywood for a while.

No comment, Mark said everything. But can you believe stupid people say he is also responsible because he excepted the role? That is the laziest excuse I’ve ever heard.

"incredibly daring" isn't how i describe the last jedi

@llcoolg8682

6 ай бұрын

More like “incredibly fucking senseless, incoherent, incompetent, lazy, ridiculous, retarded” I could get going. Like seriously how in the hell was that directionless movie approved…

We have to do the opposite lmaoooo

And in another video he also saying that starwars fans treated many of the actors of these movies unfair and nasty 😂

The ART of sarcasm

Disney comlletely destroyed Star Wars in such a way its unrecoverable.

@JJ-zo7jv

6 ай бұрын

Star Wars can always be recovered, the lore/stories to tell are practically infinite. It’s just that under Disney, they actively hate everything that was already established and want to break the rule nonstop. So in a sense I agree, but Disney needs to be squashed

The pure hubris of Ryan Johnson ruined Star Wars

And that sentence that Mark says, is the EXACT reason why 7,8, and 9 were dumpster fires

What other industry do the producer of a commodity say "don't make what our customers want, do the opposite!"

They need to reboot the sequel trilogy, just remake them. If they suck, they suck... nothing to lose, currently they suck, so 🤷🏻‍♂️

Based Hamill.

The sarcasm and the look on his face speaks volumes.

"no, no, we have to give them something they don't expect but what we want" The crowd cheering... lol

Something tells me the crowd isn't getting his sarcasm there at the end....

Exactly thank you mark👏🏼🫶🏼

Don’t blame rian Johnson, blame jj abrams.

Too bad The Last Jedi destroyed Star Wars; I had such high hopes for the Disney sequel trilogy...

I dont recognize anything SW that Disney puts out as canon or otherwise, period

@JJ-zo7jv

6 ай бұрын

I respect that. I feel the same with the exception of CWS7 and Bad Batch

@davidm4566

6 ай бұрын

@@JJ-zo7jv Rogue One was pretty good, too.

I love the last Jedi! Mark played it beautifully ❤

Mark was so correct. Give the audience what they want.

Yeah like like would try to kill his nephew.. in his sleep.. after turning vader from the dark side. Totally logical. GJ ryan, you totally nailed luke skywalker. Oh and thank you for that grrrrreeeaaattttt scene where luke drinks the space cow milk. Amazing movie creativity here. 🖕🖕

Star wars sequel reboot is a must

@JJ-zo7jv

6 ай бұрын

Been saying this. They need to get on it. Can’t imagine what George is going through right now 😂 my heart would be in pieces

@zool8139

6 ай бұрын

@@JJ-zo7jv shit on star wars from a massive height

Just a heads up- In 10-15 years, there will be young people who love the sequel trilogy. Be ready for it, because it’s coming.

So many great movies shut down sadly though like I want Narnia 4, Eragon 2, Dark Crystal Age of resistance season 2 etc….

He is so gracious about something he knows is hot garbage ❤

Thank you Mark for who you represented in my childhood. I'm disgusted by what people like Rian did to such a great franchise.

I still like the last Jedi, but damn I hate the other two movies in the trilogy.

That last part about “Not what the fans want, what we want.” is very clearly reflective of Disney’s Star Wars, and is precisely why the movies don’t hit well with the fanbase. If your goal with making a Star Wars film is “to make men uncomfortable”, then you’re unfit to make a Star Wars film. You should be focused on making a good Star Wars film, not focused on making a portion of the fans uncomfortable, not preaching your personal political beliefs, not whining about race/gender wars….purely have your focus be making a good movie!!! Yet, they are baffled when the movies fall flat….

The thing about it is there's nowhere else for Star wars to go but up as far as the movies go. I am a humongous fan and grew up with the story but we need better subject matter.

@jeffhembd9471

7 ай бұрын

Without retconning the last couple decades, there is no up. It is downhill til it disappears.

People are misinterpreting Mark Hamill.

This was great. Mark Hamill was against Rian Johnson’s portrayal of Luke, and he got on board with it by telling him he almost had to think of Luke as a different character. That he’s “not my Luke Skywalker.” When that happened, the producers at Disney should have pulled up and said wait, we have a problem. And they should have replaced Johnson.

He's literally complimenting Rian here. Watch the full interview

All said he still played the part and made the movie if he felt that strongly about it turn the part down but oh yeah money

They absolutely destroyed Luke and he’s really pissed about it

Recognises his TLJ script as “daring” and says he learned a lot from him, having insisted upon making a film that (hopefully) surprised audiences and lived up to at least his own artistic standards - but - because of a playful jab at the start of the clip, was “Roasting” him? 👏🏻 👏🏻 👏🏻

Why were the people cheering. The guy writing the movie is telling you to F off

Give them something we want, not what they want, is the correct way to make art. Of course, you have to want something good.

@davidm4566

6 ай бұрын

If you're a famous artist who commands large sums of money for anything with your name on it, then yes. Otherwise, for the majority of artists, if you want to make money you make art that people will buy. You can still keep making art that you want on the side, though. Test the waters periodically to see if it will sell. Maybe you will get famous one day and be able to make only what you want; I guess that's the dream.

the audience doesn't know what they want untill they have it. However, the audience most certainly does know what they dont want. RJ and Disney is all about giving the audience exactly what we dont want

Got to love that man

Oh, how will he ever recover? If that's a "Roast", why did the audience agree at the end? Not even a sun tan.

What rain Johnson did was give us something we didn’t want.

Disney should put the rey trilogy in noncanon events

Well they are nailing not giving us what we want. 😅

People all uploaded this stuff years ago. True fans already know of all this

Later on, he’d become quite different about the whole thing though. KK got to him and, it took a while for him to bounce back.

What would have really made Luke skywalker perfect for The Last Jedi, is if during "The First Order" showdown with Luke skywalker on Crait is if they actually show how powerful he really was at that time in his life as well as how powerful he actually was in legends after the events of return of the jedi (Episode 6) As legends Luke Skywalker could very easily devastate the first order army present on Crait, as he could munipulate black holes in space using tge force, rip entire fleets of star destroyers out of the sky like they weigh nothing, and many many more feets that show he is Anakin Skywalker's son, as he was at the height of his potential in "legends". Honestly Kylo Ren, would have quickly realised he stands no chance against his uncle, as his armies are being destroyed all around him. All the while he isnt even physically present in that part of the galaxy just as he was currently depicted. It wouldnt fix The last jedi as a movie but it would have made the lore just a little bit closer to what a real star wars movie would have been.

Sequel trilogy is awful, even worse than the prequels. Would have never dreamed any Star Wars entry could be worse when I first saw the prequels, but Disney proved otherwise.

what does he mean with: "a run of the trilogy part"?

That philosophy at the end is horrible man. “Something they (the fans) don’t expect, that we (Disney) want.” When in reality it should be something the fans don’t expect, but the fans would want. That explains why they keep making these bone head decisions with characters and movies in general. It’s like full steam ahead without any regard for the fandom.

The Disney Star Wars erra is an abomination!

Do the opposite… Rian Johnson learned how to write scripts from George Costanza.

The barking seals...🙄

Irony poisoning is so sad! Yes we like surprises, but in order to have a plot-twist you need a plot in the first place! Ffs 😂

He’s so bitter about not getting to be the big heroic star of the whole trilogy. Also, just because a character says “let the past die, kill it if you have to”, that doesn’t mean the film ENDORSES what the character says! Johnson also wrote Rey as completely rejecting that idea and finding it abhorrent when Luke rejects the past. He’s always complaining, even back from the days of the original trilogy, when he wanted Luke to turn to the dark side, and called ROTJ “so predictable and pat”.

The sequels ... uhm.. well it was good to see Mark, Carrie, Harrison but unfortunately lost within these films. Thanks Mark for speaking for all of us loyal to the original films. Cheers Mark Hamill!

If JJ Abrams could have done all 3 movies ( or if they would have just used the 3 scripts that George Lucas had sold them when he sold Disney the company) it would have been awesome and it sucks in some ways but he was working on Star Trek Beyond at the time that Disney wanted to do number 8 and that's why JJ couldn't do eight when they wanted him to and then he came back to 9 like what is the crap did they do???

@davidm4566

6 ай бұрын

JJ is not a good writer/producer. His "Mystery Box" is what left Rian Johnson painted into a corner, because there was no plan. He also left the Star Trek franchise broken and in pieces as well.

Mark wasn't exactly part of the solution. He cashed the checks.

@godphoenix66x

7 ай бұрын

Well that's how it works. You work under contract, you get paid. You expect him to work for free? It's not Mark's fault the movie/script was trash. People say the dumbest things.

@jeffhembd9471

7 ай бұрын

@@godphoenix66x I expect him to recognize a bad script and say thanks but no thanks. Same expectation I would have for everyone associated to this hot mess of a franchise. Demand excellence.

@julythrunov

7 ай бұрын

@@jeffhembd9471he wasn’t given an entire script before he signed the contract. In your cartoon mind, he can just say “i don’t like this, I refuse!” but in reality they would sue the shit out of him! When he signed the contract he had met with George Lucas prior to Disney buying Star Wars, he can’t just back out whenever he feels like it. It doesn’t work that way.

@jeffhembd9471

7 ай бұрын

@@julythrunov Excuse it all you want...he went along with the crap and got paid for it...good for him. He helped himself but he did not help the franchise.

@julythrunov

7 ай бұрын

@@jeffhembd9471 he is in no position to “help”, he signed a contract, a written agreement to abide by their rules. If actors can just “decide” to “not do it” at will, no film would get produced, it doesn’t work the way you are imagining it in your mind. That’s not an “excuse”? it’s a matter of fact.

It was sad what we got

Little Ryan is a disgrace

And yet Mark still did all 3 movies… who is really to blame here? Answer: everyone involved…

@davidm4566

6 ай бұрын

True. He saw that he was not able to change the script, collected the money, and did it anyway. At least the others blindly thought people would like it, while Mark knew how the fans would react.

To be honest though, I can’t understand how anyone can think that the Last Jedi is worse than Rise of Skywalker

Do the opposite of what the fans want The fans want-a good movie Disney-produces bad movie

It was poorly written. Period. Talk about expectations all you want. I don’t expect a poorly written story. Well, when it comes to the Woke, and contemporary storytellers in general - I most definitely have come to expect trash.

"The Last Jedi" should've been about the last REAL JEDI. Not some refurbished trope to be in the way lol

They got what "they wanted" a crappy movie that not only bombed. But help kill a great franchise. Good job.

The last 3 Star Wars movies were trash they were a lazy version of the original 3 movies

I liked the first and third sequel well enough. The Last Jedi was absolute trash though. Doing the exact opposite of what people expect is not creative. It’s actually quite lazy.

The sequels are as appetizing as the toilet water of a Crohn's patient.

Mark Hamil didn't destroy the sequel. J. J. Abrams did that 😂

Rian is an absolute tool

And they did, they Killed off Luke in the wimpiest way possible

@SuperOttoify

6 ай бұрын

Wimpy? He died while he instilled hope not in the resistance, but Ben Solo. He did what he always did. Don't misunderstand me, I'm not all for the sequel trilogy, but Luke's death was more symbolic than people think it was.

Either Ruin is a good sport or Ruin is clueless af!

My favorite characters are Ezra Bridger, Chopper, R2D2, Wedge, Ahsoka Tano, Hera, and BB-8....don't really care about the rest of the characters or their story arcs. R2D2 is the only one that transcends to other story lines.

Honestly except a couple of issues there and luke, I thought that the RJ one was the best of the three.

Real peice of crap at the end of Carrie Fischers career. I don't think Marks spoken on that either, if he does feel gipped for her then i doubt he could stay as calm talking about princess Leia

Because the new trilogy blows goats ass! I'm so fed up with this trend in Hollywood and it's been going on for decades, they buy rights to something because they know it makes money then they quickly slap together the biggest pieces of crap they can because they know you people will spend your money to watch it. I don't get why writers keep going on strike when writing in Hollywood wasn't been good in fact it sucks, turning out one unoriginal piece of shit after the next. If anything we all should go on strike against all of them because their collective efforts are weak

Look, the sequels have their problems. Like being a grumpy dejected man isn’t one of them. It serves the story and Mark Hamil has said as such. Everyone loves to quote when he said, “that’s not Luke” but no one ever mentioned when he later said he regrets saying that out loud because as he said, it serves the story they are telling. The problems with the sequels are that they don’t say anything. They don’t convey anything. The originals were about the Vietnam war and American oppression, as well as Hollywood oppression on film makers. The prequels were about George Bush’s over reach in the war on terror and how democracy falls to fascism. All made by a massive team of people mind you. Don’t get it in your heads that George Lucas did it by himself or was some kind of uniquely stand out person above all others. Marcia Lucas for example was incredibly important. All the editors were. Marcia Lucas is largely responsible for why the trench run is as suspenseful as it is. Her editing was very important. And George Lucas re-edited the movies to cut Marcia Lucas out of royalties after their divorce. The sequels aren’t about anything. They just look like Star Wars. It’s just aesthetics. That’s the problem of the sequels. Not Likes character.

In theory yes you have to give the audience something they dont expect 100%, as soon as you start pandering to fans you end up with a complete mess like the rise of skywalker. However, you give them something they don't expect in a way that you give them something BETTER than they expect that no one saw coming, not do exactly what you know they don't want and the exact things that will alienate the audience. Rian had some pretty good themes behind TLJ like the balance of the force being somewhere between the light and dark and questioning the ideas of the prequel jedi, but theres so many better ways it could have been executed. Making Luke a grumpy man for the entire first half of the film then killing him off after doing virtually nothing in this entire trilogy... That wasn't it.