Maggie Lied All Along!!! The Real Reason Why The Croat Captured Hershel!!!
Maggie Lied All Along!!! The Real Reason Why the Croat Captured Hershel!!! The Walking Dead Dead City Episode 5
Жүктеу.....
Пікірлер: 95
@michaelphantom708711 ай бұрын
Irrelevant fact but "Liar" was the last thing the Governor said to Rick before decapitating Hershel (Maggie's father) in front of them all.
@euder9096
11 ай бұрын
Yes, well remembered.
@Nflprodz278
11 ай бұрын
I saw that and was like oh damn poor Maggie lol
@WalkerSlayer9878
11 ай бұрын
It’s also the last thing Gage said to Maggie before she left him to die. The way it’s written in blood there, you’d think it’s Gage haunting her from beyond the rotten Flesh. It’s a nice touch.
@miilamb2044
11 ай бұрын
No. It was Anakin who said Liar
@nahthanksno8299
10 ай бұрын
And when Negan finally dies, hopefully Maggie whispers “murdering piece of shit without a single redeeming quality” in his ear. Fair’s fair, after all. Last I checked, everyone lies at some point. But only monsters murder.
@robhill998911 ай бұрын
Telling Negan would have meant that Maggie was asking him for a favor, as opposed to him feeling like he owes it to her and Hershel. It goes from, I need you to do this to help me get my son back to I’m trading you for my sons life. She’d much rather control him by guilt tripping him into the fiasco. Also if you remember, she picked up a knife when he was in the shower which makes it seem a lot more sinister.
@thomassimmonds676411 ай бұрын
Maggie set up negan as bait for the Croat in return for her son back, so the only reason she took negan out of everyone else from the community was to use him as bait
@clem2660
11 ай бұрын
Woaw nobody expect it 🤣
@CrookedBear
11 ай бұрын
Kinda sick to be honest ☹️
@hunterrajcanji9870
10 ай бұрын
@@CrookedBearHow tho Negan killed her fucking Husband like whattt and killed so many of her people nothing Negan does will ever makeup for what he's done😂
@CrookedBear
10 ай бұрын
@@hunterrajcanji9870 I’m aware of that but she doesn’t need to constantly be an asshole to him, she needs to fix her problems rather than take them out on Negan. She isn’t even trying to heal is the problem. She claims to have forgiving him but she turns around and does this.
@KingOfKings27X6
6 ай бұрын
@@hunterrajcanji9870Maggie did a great job getting rid of Negan that’s what everyone wanted to do get rid of Negan because they don’t want a threat onto their 4 colonies
@WalkerSlayer987811 ай бұрын
So much for “Neggie” Lmao y’all Shippers gotta drop that bullshit for real 😂😂
@afitcouchpotato4014
11 ай бұрын
You need to edit the nickname you gave then that sounds so racist 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@WalkerSlayer9878
11 ай бұрын
@@afitcouchpotato4014 Well that’s what every Negan / Maggie shipper has gone by knowing them as! 🤣🤣
@clarejean3309
11 ай бұрын
that's for damn sure!
@afitcouchpotato4014
11 ай бұрын
@@werewolfroad * sigh *
@Batt-man
11 ай бұрын
@@werewolfroadRacism is bad because it’s hating a person based on the colour of their skin, not who they really are. What the hell are you talking about by ‘following the narrative’ (please lay it out for me)
@New2RetroReviews11 ай бұрын
Lets be real....if Maggie had just told Negan what was going on, he would have gone regardless. Negan doesnt like seeing kids hurt, he knows what this guy does, and much like with Carl and Judith and even Herschel, Negan will go the distance to save/protect. This is just bad writing for two chsracters who now understand each other and have before this series began.
@jeremiahc620
11 ай бұрын
No it's great writing cause it shows that Maggie & her people are just as bad as Negan. The only difference is that Negan doesn't pretend to be some great person like they do ha
@CorsonDrax
11 ай бұрын
it's not at all bad writing, what are you smoking?
@New2RetroReviews
11 ай бұрын
@@CorsonDrax you see I actually pointed out whats wrong, you just asked me what am I smoking because you have no actual way to argue this.
@giantrobby5050
11 ай бұрын
Is this not the same Negan who was a swing away from bashing Carl’s brain in if Shiva hadn’t interfered?
@mr.awesome6011
8 ай бұрын
Negan has already saved Hershel once and owned up to killing Glenn when Hershel figured out it was him. He wouldn't have thought twice to step up if Maggie simply asked for help.
@stephanieweisbart77711 ай бұрын
Look at the pain and sorrow on his face😢
@CrookedBear11 ай бұрын
Maggie isn’t an issue, just just has issues.
@madiehulen119910 ай бұрын
Come on let’s be real Negan knew what he was walking into that why he asked Maggie all throughout the season to take care of Ginny for him. He knew once he saw the wanted posters that he wasn’t coming back
@JavierMartinez-oj3rg11 ай бұрын
I know Maggie had a reason to do what she did to save Herschel, but to be fair, she did displaying a bad human traits, being a liar and dishonorable person considering negan wasn’t even given the exact truth he was just lied to just to get what she wanted clearly she’s stupid enough to think that her actions justify the ends
@charlesdavid410611 ай бұрын
Maggie is playing a dangerous game once Negan finds out bout Ginny! She’s better 10 steps ahead for what’s bout to come.. besides Negan got a soft spot for endangering kids so can’t wait for next week final ep
@RickGrimes1123
11 ай бұрын
Dont think so. Of negan Makes one wrong move she will kill him instntly.
@RickGrimes1123
11 ай бұрын
@jasper7714 I dont think so 🤣
@cole5953
11 ай бұрын
@@RickGrimes1123Maggie already lost a one on one fight with negan lol. While negan was holding back even. Maggie doesn't stand a chance.
@bartosz914411 ай бұрын
I hope that what she did to Negan will bring some karma to her
@mappingshaman52803 ай бұрын
Kind of crazy when you realise this is the reason maggie didn't want to join that group. Because she knew if she did, they'd all have to die
@joshcoop129511 ай бұрын
To be fair they fought it out then the truth came out, he held nothing against her son when he wanted him dead in Walking Dead, Negan just told him when he grew up then they'll settle their Differences..
@euder909611 ай бұрын
Damn...
@LemonDrop-zt9xx11 ай бұрын
Why does Negan's daughter look so weirded out by what's in the cylo?
@spriteking3944
11 ай бұрын
@jasper7714Adopted daughter
@desixox3 ай бұрын
How old is Hershel, ik years have gone by but geez
@Allnamestakenzomg10 ай бұрын
Why did the Croat want Lalo so much?
@ahmedabbasi409411 ай бұрын
Why doesn't the Croat capture Negan himself? If Maggie could, so could he.
@nemanjavujicic4784
10 ай бұрын
Because the main show ened and now it’s time for milking money on dumb spin offs. 6 episodes and 95% of every episode is walking, talking, killing walkers and 5% is action (and important storyline)
@miilamb204411 ай бұрын
Let’s be honest here. Todd Howard has the biggest lies
@JonathanEvans197711 ай бұрын
Damn this is some shit right here 😭. I mean I can't say I blame her because her son's life is at stake here so she's doing what she has to make sure he lives but Negan has no idea smdh. It's wild how Ginny peeped out the lie though. How did she know Maggie was lying?
@JStaxxx2017__
11 ай бұрын
Let's not forget neagan beat Glenn to death with a baseball bat. So off that reason alone he shouldn't trust maggie
@jackkeane6
11 ай бұрын
Because Ginny saw that Maggies settlement had loads of grain and was lying about the Croat taking it all
@miilamb204410 ай бұрын
Greatest Liar: Todd Howard
@kylevandrunen621811 ай бұрын
yes he did kill glean and he got a big punishment but he dont need to be handed over to the croat he will die
@bartosz9144
11 ай бұрын
I hop
@himeko-foster11 ай бұрын
I doesn't understand it can someone explain me what realy happend
@michaelphantom7087
11 ай бұрын
So basically like Cammy said Maggie said that they were raided by the Croat and Hershel was taken but she needed Negan's help because Negan knew the man who took him and implied Negan would have the sway/power to get Hershel back. She lied The Croat took Hershel and will keep him until Maggie brings Negan to him and exchanges Negan for Hershel. Maggie lured Negan there under the idea that he was helping her, but in reality she was exchanging him for Hershel.
@dermetzger11 ай бұрын
... Elisa Lam?
@gaminglikeaproallthetime45639 ай бұрын
1:33
@traption46177 ай бұрын
Why I never liked her return. She just bought problems with her.
@dorgyamtso483011 ай бұрын
Wait, I’m kinda confused. What happened
@cammmmyyyyyy
11 ай бұрын
Maggie lied about being raided, they took her son and are holding him for ransom in exchange for negan
@dorgyamtso4830
11 ай бұрын
@@cammmmyyyyyy ohhhh damnnnn, now this is actually getting interesting
@cammmmyyyyyy11 ай бұрын
So maggies the villain basically
@dragonjames7911
11 ай бұрын
Pretty much
@Nflprodz278
11 ай бұрын
I don’t think so. She probably still wants the croat dead because of taking her son but this is something she had to do. Sure y’all would’ve done it
@RoboZombie44
11 ай бұрын
@@Nflprodz278as much i hate to admit it but you're right
@HarveyDent13
11 ай бұрын
Nope, not at all. Croat (the bastard who kidnapped her son) is. Maggie sold Negan out, that doesn't make her a villain by any means. She has no obligation to put her son's life in jeopardy for the bastard that smashed her husband's skull in.
@TheRealRickGrimes
11 ай бұрын
@@HarveyDent13Well that "bastard" saved our people from Alpha and Alpha was messing up the group when she was alive. Saved kids from dying such as Judith, Lydia and even saved Hershel from commonwealth soldiers. In the series finale Negan felt remorse for what he did to Glenn. So say whatever you want but Maggie not being honest with Negan is making her worse than Negan was back then. If she was honest with him I guarantee you he would have helped her still since he has a soft spot for kids
@masterzombie16111 ай бұрын
Thank god I never continued the show after season 8.
@thequirkygirl6244211 ай бұрын
Negan deserves to be handed to the Croat. He caused all of this because was a psychotic and shitty leader, who abused his power to the point where Hilltop wanted out, to the point where his sheep were killing anyone they came across, to the point where Sherry, Dwight and Sherry's sister Tina ran away, and to the point where Rick's group wanted to get rid of the threat.
@bartosz9144
11 ай бұрын
No he didnt at this point he helped more than of their groups. Also at this point Rick and his group were no saints.
@appledoesrandomstuff
11 ай бұрын
crazy how ppl think negans bad just bc he killed glenn and abraham when rick killed like 100 of his men
@CodeeXD
11 ай бұрын
Ricks people slaughtered men in their sleep on the word of a conman in exchange for some food and was planning on doing that to hilltop anyway if they didn't hand over their supplies. Much worse then anything negan did.
@appledoesrandomstuff
11 ай бұрын
@@CodeeXD true
@thahotkidd
10 ай бұрын
@appledoesrandomstuff3609 that would be a valid point except we as the audience got to see first hand what kind of people the saviors were. They were literally going around enslaving communities that they outnumbered under the threat of death. They usually operated by killing at least one person from any new group they came across just to make their point.
Пікірлер: 95
Irrelevant fact but "Liar" was the last thing the Governor said to Rick before decapitating Hershel (Maggie's father) in front of them all.
@euder9096
11 ай бұрын
Yes, well remembered.
@Nflprodz278
11 ай бұрын
I saw that and was like oh damn poor Maggie lol
@WalkerSlayer9878
11 ай бұрын
It’s also the last thing Gage said to Maggie before she left him to die. The way it’s written in blood there, you’d think it’s Gage haunting her from beyond the rotten Flesh. It’s a nice touch.
@miilamb2044
11 ай бұрын
No. It was Anakin who said Liar
@nahthanksno8299
10 ай бұрын
And when Negan finally dies, hopefully Maggie whispers “murdering piece of shit without a single redeeming quality” in his ear. Fair’s fair, after all. Last I checked, everyone lies at some point. But only monsters murder.
Telling Negan would have meant that Maggie was asking him for a favor, as opposed to him feeling like he owes it to her and Hershel. It goes from, I need you to do this to help me get my son back to I’m trading you for my sons life. She’d much rather control him by guilt tripping him into the fiasco. Also if you remember, she picked up a knife when he was in the shower which makes it seem a lot more sinister.
Maggie set up negan as bait for the Croat in return for her son back, so the only reason she took negan out of everyone else from the community was to use him as bait
@clem2660
11 ай бұрын
Woaw nobody expect it 🤣
@CrookedBear
11 ай бұрын
Kinda sick to be honest ☹️
@hunterrajcanji9870
10 ай бұрын
@@CrookedBearHow tho Negan killed her fucking Husband like whattt and killed so many of her people nothing Negan does will ever makeup for what he's done😂
@CrookedBear
10 ай бұрын
@@hunterrajcanji9870 I’m aware of that but she doesn’t need to constantly be an asshole to him, she needs to fix her problems rather than take them out on Negan. She isn’t even trying to heal is the problem. She claims to have forgiving him but she turns around and does this.
@KingOfKings27X6
6 ай бұрын
@@hunterrajcanji9870Maggie did a great job getting rid of Negan that’s what everyone wanted to do get rid of Negan because they don’t want a threat onto their 4 colonies
So much for “Neggie” Lmao y’all Shippers gotta drop that bullshit for real 😂😂
@afitcouchpotato4014
11 ай бұрын
You need to edit the nickname you gave then that sounds so racist 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@WalkerSlayer9878
11 ай бұрын
@@afitcouchpotato4014 Well that’s what every Negan / Maggie shipper has gone by knowing them as! 🤣🤣
@clarejean3309
11 ай бұрын
that's for damn sure!
@afitcouchpotato4014
11 ай бұрын
@@werewolfroad * sigh *
@Batt-man
11 ай бұрын
@@werewolfroadRacism is bad because it’s hating a person based on the colour of their skin, not who they really are. What the hell are you talking about by ‘following the narrative’ (please lay it out for me)
Lets be real....if Maggie had just told Negan what was going on, he would have gone regardless. Negan doesnt like seeing kids hurt, he knows what this guy does, and much like with Carl and Judith and even Herschel, Negan will go the distance to save/protect. This is just bad writing for two chsracters who now understand each other and have before this series began.
@jeremiahc620
11 ай бұрын
No it's great writing cause it shows that Maggie & her people are just as bad as Negan. The only difference is that Negan doesn't pretend to be some great person like they do ha
@CorsonDrax
11 ай бұрын
it's not at all bad writing, what are you smoking?
@New2RetroReviews
11 ай бұрын
@@CorsonDrax you see I actually pointed out whats wrong, you just asked me what am I smoking because you have no actual way to argue this.
@giantrobby5050
11 ай бұрын
Is this not the same Negan who was a swing away from bashing Carl’s brain in if Shiva hadn’t interfered?
@mr.awesome6011
8 ай бұрын
Negan has already saved Hershel once and owned up to killing Glenn when Hershel figured out it was him. He wouldn't have thought twice to step up if Maggie simply asked for help.
Look at the pain and sorrow on his face😢
Maggie isn’t an issue, just just has issues.
Come on let’s be real Negan knew what he was walking into that why he asked Maggie all throughout the season to take care of Ginny for him. He knew once he saw the wanted posters that he wasn’t coming back
I know Maggie had a reason to do what she did to save Herschel, but to be fair, she did displaying a bad human traits, being a liar and dishonorable person considering negan wasn’t even given the exact truth he was just lied to just to get what she wanted clearly she’s stupid enough to think that her actions justify the ends
Maggie is playing a dangerous game once Negan finds out bout Ginny! She’s better 10 steps ahead for what’s bout to come.. besides Negan got a soft spot for endangering kids so can’t wait for next week final ep
@RickGrimes1123
11 ай бұрын
Dont think so. Of negan Makes one wrong move she will kill him instntly.
@RickGrimes1123
11 ай бұрын
@jasper7714 I dont think so 🤣
@cole5953
11 ай бұрын
@@RickGrimes1123Maggie already lost a one on one fight with negan lol. While negan was holding back even. Maggie doesn't stand a chance.
I hope that what she did to Negan will bring some karma to her
Kind of crazy when you realise this is the reason maggie didn't want to join that group. Because she knew if she did, they'd all have to die
To be fair they fought it out then the truth came out, he held nothing against her son when he wanted him dead in Walking Dead, Negan just told him when he grew up then they'll settle their Differences..
Damn...
Why does Negan's daughter look so weirded out by what's in the cylo?
@spriteking3944
11 ай бұрын
@jasper7714Adopted daughter
How old is Hershel, ik years have gone by but geez
Why did the Croat want Lalo so much?
Why doesn't the Croat capture Negan himself? If Maggie could, so could he.
@nemanjavujicic4784
10 ай бұрын
Because the main show ened and now it’s time for milking money on dumb spin offs. 6 episodes and 95% of every episode is walking, talking, killing walkers and 5% is action (and important storyline)
Let’s be honest here. Todd Howard has the biggest lies
Damn this is some shit right here 😭. I mean I can't say I blame her because her son's life is at stake here so she's doing what she has to make sure he lives but Negan has no idea smdh. It's wild how Ginny peeped out the lie though. How did she know Maggie was lying?
@JStaxxx2017__
11 ай бұрын
Let's not forget neagan beat Glenn to death with a baseball bat. So off that reason alone he shouldn't trust maggie
@jackkeane6
11 ай бұрын
Because Ginny saw that Maggies settlement had loads of grain and was lying about the Croat taking it all
Greatest Liar: Todd Howard
yes he did kill glean and he got a big punishment but he dont need to be handed over to the croat he will die
@bartosz9144
11 ай бұрын
I hop
I doesn't understand it can someone explain me what realy happend
@michaelphantom7087
11 ай бұрын
So basically like Cammy said Maggie said that they were raided by the Croat and Hershel was taken but she needed Negan's help because Negan knew the man who took him and implied Negan would have the sway/power to get Hershel back. She lied The Croat took Hershel and will keep him until Maggie brings Negan to him and exchanges Negan for Hershel. Maggie lured Negan there under the idea that he was helping her, but in reality she was exchanging him for Hershel.
... Elisa Lam?
1:33
Why I never liked her return. She just bought problems with her.
Wait, I’m kinda confused. What happened
@cammmmyyyyyy
11 ай бұрын
Maggie lied about being raided, they took her son and are holding him for ransom in exchange for negan
@dorgyamtso4830
11 ай бұрын
@@cammmmyyyyyy ohhhh damnnnn, now this is actually getting interesting
So maggies the villain basically
@dragonjames7911
11 ай бұрын
Pretty much
@Nflprodz278
11 ай бұрын
I don’t think so. She probably still wants the croat dead because of taking her son but this is something she had to do. Sure y’all would’ve done it
@RoboZombie44
11 ай бұрын
@@Nflprodz278as much i hate to admit it but you're right
@HarveyDent13
11 ай бұрын
Nope, not at all. Croat (the bastard who kidnapped her son) is. Maggie sold Negan out, that doesn't make her a villain by any means. She has no obligation to put her son's life in jeopardy for the bastard that smashed her husband's skull in.
@TheRealRickGrimes
11 ай бұрын
@@HarveyDent13Well that "bastard" saved our people from Alpha and Alpha was messing up the group when she was alive. Saved kids from dying such as Judith, Lydia and even saved Hershel from commonwealth soldiers. In the series finale Negan felt remorse for what he did to Glenn. So say whatever you want but Maggie not being honest with Negan is making her worse than Negan was back then. If she was honest with him I guarantee you he would have helped her still since he has a soft spot for kids
Thank god I never continued the show after season 8.
Negan deserves to be handed to the Croat. He caused all of this because was a psychotic and shitty leader, who abused his power to the point where Hilltop wanted out, to the point where his sheep were killing anyone they came across, to the point where Sherry, Dwight and Sherry's sister Tina ran away, and to the point where Rick's group wanted to get rid of the threat.
@bartosz9144
11 ай бұрын
No he didnt at this point he helped more than of their groups. Also at this point Rick and his group were no saints.
@appledoesrandomstuff
11 ай бұрын
crazy how ppl think negans bad just bc he killed glenn and abraham when rick killed like 100 of his men
@CodeeXD
11 ай бұрын
Ricks people slaughtered men in their sleep on the word of a conman in exchange for some food and was planning on doing that to hilltop anyway if they didn't hand over their supplies. Much worse then anything negan did.
@appledoesrandomstuff
11 ай бұрын
@@CodeeXD true
@thahotkidd
10 ай бұрын
@appledoesrandomstuff3609 that would be a valid point except we as the audience got to see first hand what kind of people the saviors were. They were literally going around enslaving communities that they outnumbered under the threat of death. They usually operated by killing at least one person from any new group they came across just to make their point.