I’m so happy you did this video. I haven’t seen anyone else compare the two. This helps us decide which would be best for me. Before I thought that painterly would be best for me now I’m thinking soft ochre. Thank you for doing this one, it’s very helpful.

I was already leaning on soft ochre, but this video along with a few others has decided it for me! Thanks for showing us this!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

💙happy you found it helpful!

Wow. What a difference. Can't wait to see part 2! :)

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Right?? Crazy...

Looking forward to part 2 and this is crazy!!! You could totally see a difference, I have only tried Painterly and was not a fan personally.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I know right.... who woulda thought! Maybe give soft ochre a chance next time if they havent changed the formula lol.. Ima pick up a new one later today and see what happens

Love that you did this comparison. I’m surprised that they performed differently!! I’ve never tried the paint pots, but I have been curious about trying something like that or the P.Louise base to have a creamier base.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I have a plouise vs mac paint pot comparison and wear test video as well. The plouise doesnt work well for me application wise 🙄

@msparker3500

5 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner oh I missed that video off I go. That sounds very interesting since everybody is talking about the P.Louise that I don’t even know where to get.

INTRIGUED O.o can't wait for part 2!

You’re tempting me with that 80’s Baby palette again 😉. I use Painterly but I’m interested to try Soft Ochre now cos there’s defo a difference! Xx

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Pretty insane huh...

Love ❤️ your eyes! Colors go very nicely together! I'd love to try this 😍 .. I just purchased the paint pot painterly it's being shipped to my home with make up brushes 🙌 I can't wait 🤗 to try this out!! Thanks for video

Huh. Weird. Really glad you did this though as it shows the importance of the substrate, and to not necessarily blame the shadows. Thanks for doing this!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Right?? Crazy how a primer can change the performance of shadows that much

Wow! They really do apply so differently, depending on the base! I honestly didn’t think the base mattered so much...MIND BLOWN!! I’ve only ever used Soft Ochre, and I think I’ll stick with that!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

RIGHT??? Crazy... I literally cant review anything else until I buy a new one now lmao

Looking forward to the part 2 video. I was actually considering buying a paint pot, since I haven't yet found a primer that I love, and colour wise I would probably have reached for painterly. Instead I will wait for your feedback. Could they have changed the formula? 🤔 anyway, thanks for another useful video 👌

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Ima pick up another soft ochre today and see what happens... I'm super curious now. And honestly the one that I've gone through wasnt more than maybe 4 months old if I had to guess

Thanks for this!! I actually am new to using primers on my eyes. I checked out the paint pots and I was so lost as to which one to get!!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah its confusing for sure

Wow huge difference!! I noticed right away with that red shadow 🧐🧐🧐 love the eye look 😍💕❤️

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

RIGHT...?? So crazy Thanks!

Interesting! I have not used paint pots in many years, but I definitely remember them having somewhat different textures depending on the colors. I remember having a brown one and an acid green one that had a thinner texture than others, and I had a white one that was thick and always made shadows vibrant. Never owned the two you have though. Hmm 🤔 it will be interesting to see you test a new Soft Ocher against it, see if age makes a difference. Since I’ve started watching your videos I’ve been wanting to go back to paint pots again, so I’m very curious for part 2 😁

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Interesting... I could kinda see it with colors that are be meant to be worn as eyeshadows, but I think most people use these two as primers, so you would think the formulas would be the same. Im picking up the new soft ochre today. The one I had wasnt even that old.. maybe 4 months? I used it every day pretty much, so its not like it was dried out. I cant wait to see what the new one is like

This video was so helpful to me! I have a paint pot in Bare Study (please don't judge me - I thought it would be pretty and brightening, but I almost NEVER reach for it because it adds shine where I don't need/want it), so I was seriously considering trying out Painterly. But now I'm thinking Soft Ochre might be better... LOVE the liquid lipstick as eyeliner! The final look is sooo pretty!!!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Thanks! This as so interesting for sure. I wonder if they meant for the formulas to be different... it doesnt make sense if they did tho

Thank you for doing this video! 👍🏼 I Can’t wait for part 2!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

There wont be a part two, the results were identical to this video with the new vs new! I've updated in other videos, but Im not gonna make a separate video on it :)

Okay so thank you for talking me out from buying painterly. I wanted to try it out and see if it offered a better difference. I currently own soft ochre and will be repurchasing it during Ulta 21 days 😀. Now Im staring to think could eyeshadow palletes have been reviewed badly for the painterly base?

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Haha youre welcome! Def stick to soft ochre. I'm gonna get some back ups of it myself, I go through them pretty fast lol

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

And yeah I can absolutely see some peole judging palettes too harshly because they arent using the best primer.

@e.mo.4194

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner yes the day has finally arrived to stalk up on paint pots. Thank you for this analysis. ❤

Love this video. And u r very talented. Thank u for doing this but I ha e a question. I got the bare nude with a shimmering pearl is that a primer. Or what did I get haha.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much! Lol I think its just a cream shadow but it can be used as a base as well? The whole explanation of what the paint pot actually is confuses me cause its marketed as an eyeshadow primer I dont think 😂

This is such a good video. I tried by your recommendation the pain pot (paintry)- my sister gave me her's because she don't use it anymore (thus it is an old one) and although eyeshadows stay a bit better it still fades after 2-3 hours. I quite frustrated to be honest. Don't know what's wrong with me eyes, nothings holds more than 1-2 hours tops. The soft ochre paint is my last hope.... definitely waiting for part 2

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I hope soft ochre works out better for you. I think it will! I ahve yet to film part two, but my new soft ochre is exactly like the one I just went through, thank god!

Great video! The mystery continues...but at this point I'm glad I have the soft ochre, LOL!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Thanks! I'll get to the bottom of it lol

I have the painterly but is close to a year old and it is very opaque on my eyes. Haven't noticed patchiness but then I'm half blind when doing my eyeshadow anyway... I also use the Bare Minerals gen nude in the lightest shade and like it as well. It's a creamier texture than the paint pot, and depending on the look I'm going for I rarely set it and doesn't dry down too fast. May do a comparison between the two if I can remember when I get ready in the morning. Curious to see your outcome with part 2.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Interesting.. id love to know if you notice a difference. The 'old' paint pot I had wasnt even old, maybe 4 months. I went through it really fast (probably because some days I do upto 3 looks lol

Fascinating! Thanks for doing this!

Very interesting! I've only used Painterly, so I can't speak to both. But, I've always enjoyed using Painterly, aside from my eyeshadows creasing if I wear them all day. I have oily eyelids, though.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

You should REALLY get soft ochre next time... seriously night and day, especially if you have oily lids

This is very interesting, I'm looking forward to part 2. I have been meaning to pick up a new Painterly since I have more pink in my skin than yellow. But if your old and new soft ochre act the same then I may need to switch over.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I mentioned in another video that I probably wont do a follow up as the old paint pot is just like the new one I just got. They are simply different formulas... pretty lame if you ask me. Soft ochre is SO superior its not even funny

@sarahlecain7981

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner that is so disappointing. I mean good to know but sad that there is such a difference in formula.

I think the soft ochre is more flattering to your skin tone. Your looks are always beautiful, and as an Image Consultant trained in color theory, I appreciate your tutorials bringing in the color wheel!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Awe thank you so much!

I love the paint pots in indianwood and groundwork as all over lid shades, and have always considered buying one of these to use as a primer but couldn't ever decide which one and have yet to purchase. The paint pots I do use crease a little halfway thru my day, so I'm not sure how these would work as a primer even though I know these have holy grail status for many. 🤔 as always, much love anette. 🖤

@hayleylongster4698

5 жыл бұрын

I do think the reason I like them so much as primers is because I have dry skin - they don't crease on me but have the consistency of being a 'creasey' - or siliconey - product shall we say so I can see them creasing on people with normal or combo skin and maybe not working at all for people with oily lids. Depending on your style though you might still like them as primer, like if you prefer a more undone look (to be fair I also like a grungey look and I actually enjoy some fading or creasing throughout the day.) Anyway that was a rant. Groundwork is SO GREAT though. I also use it as cream contour and it is *perfect* in every way

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

When you use them as eyeshadows, do you put any powders on top? I'm guessing no and thats why they crease. With the ones I use, I obviously put shadows on top which makes them not crease as its basically the same as setting it. I dont think it would b an issue

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Im def more on the oily side and never have problems with them creasing, so maybe they just work for everyone lol

@hayleylongster4698

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner Lol I think you're right! After all weren't they formulated for people with oilier lids in the first place? Well.... for MUAs to use on people whose shadow creases or doesn't last

Interesting! I recently got a new Painterly and thought the texture and feel was different (thinner and more slick) than my old one but I assumed it was just because my old one had gotten so old and dry and I just didnt remember what it felt like when it was new. I've been using UD primer a lot more lately. The soft ochre would be far too yellow for me but I definitely do see a difference on your face!!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

They must have changed it then huh. I think the soft ochre is a bit too yellow too, but as long as I cover everything with eyeshadow its fine. I would never use it on its own tho

It makes sense to me that a thicker formula would be more tacky and hold the colour more. This was interesting thanks for sharing.

I had the same issue with a brand new soft ochre as you did painterly. I wonder if maybe it needs to be dried out some or past the top layer. So interesting!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Ah really?? My new soft ochre ended up being exactly the same as the old hmmm

@brandieharrell4135

5 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner maybe I need to try another one. I thought it was super thin. Maybe I’ll use it again and if it’s the same maybe exchange it. Weird.

I have only tried painterly and it is pretty dry and not very tacky. I thought I just got a bad one... Maybe there is a shade close to painterly with the consistency of soft ocre??? That would be ideal! Thanks so much for doing this comparison. It was extremely helpful! I can't wait to see part 2!💜

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Haha that would be ideal, but these are the only two that would work for my skin tone. My other paint pot thats empty wasnt even that old.

I have been wondering which one of these to buy, & you definitely made up my mind for me. Soft Ochre it is! Lol! TFS! ~ Nona

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yes, def get soft ochre!

@NonaSmith_mysocalledlife1977

5 жыл бұрын

🌷🦄 🌷🦄 🌷

I recently got the painterly paint pot and have never had any of them before. It does seem like a light formula to me. I didn't know it was any different before.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I think its just that shade of the paint pot thats different, not that they changed it?

I’m currently catching up on older videos of yours because I can’t sleep and I’m sick. I’m smacking myself right now.. I just ordered painterly (my first paint pot) because I have been struggling with finding a primer that doesn’t crease on me and got a lot of recommendations for painterly. It’s coming today in the mail and now I’m nervous about it. I watched your video on the smashbox primer vs soft ochre before this too. Ugh. 🤦🏼‍♀️ I hope it works for me.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

4 жыл бұрын

Hope you end up liking it. You might be able to exchange it for the soft ochre one if it doesnt work out for you?

Do you think that since the painterly is newer, the soft ochre developed a little more of the “tack” as it aged and therefore caused the discrepancies?

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I actually bought a new soft ochre and compared it to the new painterly and the result was the exact same. The one I was using in this video really wasnt that old, like 3 months maybe, and since I use it at least once a day it was still fresh

I love the soft orchard, I accidentally bought the sparkly one from Mac and I don’t like primers with shimmer, shimmer to me needs to come from the eyeshadow I think I’ll return the shimmer Mac paint pot bc the soft orchard is just so good with all shadows. Thanks for and video

I did not notice any difference once the eyes were done as a eye primer. The only think I found different was when she first applied it. The painterly was pink and the soft ochre was yellow based. So if just want to cover veins around the eyes, or even out the color, depending on your skin base (yellow, pink, or neutral), you may prefer one over the other.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I feel like it was easier to see in real life when applying them. It always looks more even on both eyes after putting on mascara and liners and stuff. But I will never use painterly again. Of course the color of them will change the color of the shadows a bit, but it was night and day on how it applied on each side. And I even think a lot of people have given eyeshadow palettes bad reviews because theyve used painterly and the shadows just havent cooperated it that primer as well. Just my opinion tho

Are the Mac paint pots primers or eyeshadows?

Interesting! Waiting for part 2. Im guessing the older pot has dried up and become thicker maybe tackier too. It would make sense why concealer works better than the thinner consistency of eye primers on me.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Spoiler alert, my new paint pot is just like my old one 😂 (thank god...)

@asha.m

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner so the new painterly has become thicker? Or the new ochre is like the old ochre? Sorrry im confused 😂

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

The new soft ochre is exactly the same as the one I just went through. It didnt change at all from when its new until I used it up. They are simply just different formulas. Someone told me they went to MAC and asked and the girl who worked there said the same thing. I think thats crazy that a product with the same name, just different shades have a different formula. They should be two different lines and have different names if thats the case imo

@asha.m

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner thats not right. The difference should be in shade only. For me ochre is my shade so trying this is still a go. I thought the ochre looked natural with your foundation. Painterly looked pink, but again im looking at a screen 😊

A makeup artist at Mac said that soft ochre performs better in regards to showing the true color of eye shadows.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I wish would advertise it this way. I've had other people say that their mac employees say the same thing, but I've never seen that in writing. I feel like they should add that on their site

I'm so glad I came across this video! Did you ever do part two? I tried to find it but didn't see it.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I did not. They turned out to be the same regardless of age, so whatever I said in this video is the final conclusion. Get soft ochre lol

@notreallyawaitress10

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner Thank you! I will buy soft ochre 😊

YES I've been waiting for this *video for such a long time! I have neutral skin so am always questioning which one of these I should use (paint pots are my fave primer too) (anybody have a cruelty free dupe?)

@naomilasby7744

5 жыл бұрын

Me tooooooo!!!!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Oh good! I wasnt sure if anyone would be interested, so I mostly did it for myself lmao

@hayleylongster4698

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner Totally interested. If only it can stop me having the internal debate with myself every time I buy a new one lol (I think I like the shade of ochre better for 'cancelling' out my lids but I like painterly better for matching with my shadows as I wear as lot of cool tones on the daily. But if one of them really did perform better than the other I would stick to that shade) (Tbh watching this video made me reflect and honestly, I think have noticed soft ochre is better for working with bright shadows, definitely, as it has more of that 'pop' blanked out effect that using using a white base has. Which is weird cause you'd expect the cool toned shade to have more of that white Base! )

@sailorpleiades9004

5 жыл бұрын

Hayley Longster BHcosmetics has a cruelty free dupe of the Mac Paint Pot’s, they’re called- Smooth Canvas Long-Wearing Eyeshadow Primer & they’re under $10.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Have you tried both?

How do you pull off bright hair and bright makeup at the same time?? 😍

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Its all about attitude 😉

I don’t think it’s because it’s older, I’ve watched a lot of videos with people saying they don’t perform the same.

So I just did a test on my arm. I don’t have soft ochre but I compared it against shape tape and primer potion and the painterly made the shades so light and I had to use way more to get the colour to show up. I wondered why it was so thin so I might just return it because it’s not doing what it’s supposed to do. Why have it when a thick concealer works even better

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Right?? Its much thinner and more liquidy for sure. Concealers crease on me tho which is why I dont like using them, but I get why most ppl can get away with using concealers as primers

@PlantBasedU

5 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner it has to be a new formula because even James Charles was telling everyone to go buy paint pots for his new morphe palette and he seemed to get good coverage from his painterly along with other youtubers. This was just sad and I looked at it and it just wasn’t grabbing the colour as much

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I hope the new soft ochre one i bought today isnt a new formula as well or I'll cry... I dont know how I'm suppose to review eyeshadows without having a primer that I like lol

@PlantBasedU

5 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner no doubt! Return it if it’s different. Maybe a thick concealer is the next best thing

Ladies the Mac paint pot is on sale for $11 at ULTA!! ✨🙌🏼

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Just bought two backups haha

@fabyg9483

5 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner I got another soft ochre 😊❤️

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

🤗

I have soft ochre which I’ve had for ages and just got painterly, to be honest I hadn’t noticed a difference - but then I’ve not tried them against each other like this... maybe you got a bad one?

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

4 жыл бұрын

Do you use colorful shadows? If you do, try them side by side next time, or you wont really notice a difference

@WithNicci

4 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner yea I’m more of a natural colours kinda girl.. maybe that’s why I’ve not noticed 🤷🏻‍♀️ great video though thanks for sharing :)

interesting i have not tried the mac paint pots yet but as soon as i do i will be trying soft ochre xx

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Very interesting...

I honestly think the soft ochre looks better for your skin tone. Im debating which color to buy. Which color u think is better Aside from it being creasing?

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Depends what kind of looks you normally do. For more neutral looks I would go for painterly and for colorful looks I would do soft ochre. They are different formulas, and the color of them shouldnt be the deciding factor.

@elenitsaantos2394

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner thanks girl :)

@melodiechartier5173

5 жыл бұрын

soft ochre is way too yellow for her skin tone, it looks off, but the formula seem better...

I have been using Painterly for years without issue. Soft Ochre is very yellow on me. I do like the Paint Pots best after they've been open for awhile. Not sure if that has anything to do with it.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Do you use colorful shadows? A lot of people have told me painterly is better for neutrals and painterly works best for bright colors. Makes sense to me. I way prefer the color of painterly and I think soft ochre is too yellow as well. My shadows just perform better for me using it, so I dont want to switch. I dont really find them to be any different regardless of how long its been open for, but that could be because mine is basically always fresh cause I use it every day

@rockpaperscissors.

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner I mostly use colorful shadows, yes! How weird! I guess that's why they say makeup is personal. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I bought a new Soft Ochre a month or so ago and Painterly two days ago. Painterly is definitely a thinner formula, and one month won't account for that.

looking fwd to pt 2 thank u

I just realised I forgot to comment 🙈 it was interesting seeing the difference and I’m looking forward to updates thoughts. I don’t the formula should change that much with age!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah same, it wasnt even that old... maybe 4 months, and I had used it pretty much every day

@Pruelaroo

5 жыл бұрын

What? That's a youngling. @@AnnettesMakeupCorner

I'm cool toned so started using painterly back in 2017 to see what the fuss was about and I have to say it was a game changer for my eyeshadow looks, so to see you having issues using it compared to the soft ochre surprised me, as my eye makeup matches yours on the soft ochre side when I use my painterly paint pot. So I'm wondering if it's a newer batch issue? I do know that skin types can also play a factor in how products work for us all, it's so hard when ppl ask for recommendations because there is no one size fits all. I'm also now concerned that they've messed with the paint pot formula, because nothing else compares, so definitely interested in seeing how you find a new soft ochre xx

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Well I'm happy painterly works for you tho! And I totally agree, Makeup is SO individual and what works for me might be terrible for someone else and vice versa

I have only tried painterly, and, unfortunately, my eyeshadow creased. It did seem a thinner consistency.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah im not surprised tbh. They are SO different!

Did you do a part 2. As cannot find it

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

4 жыл бұрын

I didnt, no cause the results were exactly the same

It's surprising just how big a difference it makes using different primers, even when they're from the same company.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah pretty weird...

Ok I'm not crazy lol. My most recent painterly is very thin and wet and just not working well. Cant wait to see part 2 ..

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Bought a new soft ochre today, I'll test it out shortly! Stay tuned 😉

I wish I watched your video first!I ordered Painterly and picked it up yesterday. I turned my car around and went to the mall in the middle of your video. It's 5 minutes until the mall closes. I bought Soft Ochre. I MADE IT JUST IN TIME! 😂

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

2 жыл бұрын

Hahaha hope it works out for you!

@giggles1219

2 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner Thank you so much for sharing!

I tried painterly, and I'm not satisfyed. I get so Much texture. I'll just keep buying the Estee lauder eyeshadow base, i Think... soft ochre is too yellow on me....

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

How is the Estee lauder one in comparison?

@karinaks88

5 жыл бұрын

No texture, but the color/undertone is a bit peachy/pink. I like it. But everybody was talking About the painterly Paint pot, so i had to try it. And The price is arround the same here in Denmark.

@karinaks88

5 жыл бұрын

And in my opinion, the eyeshadow are more tru to color and blends Very well.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Interesting, I'll see if I can look at it in store next time!

What! I never knew they had two different ones. When I went in and asked for a yellow undertone, they still ended up giving me the pink undertone painterly paint pod. I was so confused and I actually hate the painterly paint pod. It crumbles my eyeshadows and makes my colors very weird. Now I understand why.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

4 жыл бұрын

Yea they are SO different its insane

@amber13000

4 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner so glad I found this video. I am getting the soft ochre next time.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

4 жыл бұрын

🙌 it should work better!

@mameeocean6194

Жыл бұрын

They actually have dozens of different colors to choose from

Beautiful

I've only had Painterly. I will say that I wasn't impressed when I first got it. I ignored it for months and recently started using it and have loved how it works for me. However, I don't have any experience with soft ochre to know if there is a difference. Looking forward to part 2.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

I really wonder if there will be a difference too

Well darn. I’m a very fair cool tone and have Painterly. Now I feel like I need Soft Ochre.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah soft ochre will work still, Im fair too and its okay on me. Not ideal, but I prefer the ways shadows go on top of it. I wouldnt wear it on its own without shadows on top

I’ve never tried these but have wanted to, I’m very fair so assume I’d use painterly but I don’t think I want to now! That palette is just so beautiful 😍

Im playing comment catch up as ush🤣 Its so weird how bad one of the pots were! Maybe the changed the formula for the worse🙈? Did you get a new Soft Ochre too? Is it like the old one?

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

😂. I got a new one, and its just like the old one I had... thank god lol

@MakeupByAnnki

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner Thats good, but so flippin strange!! Are you gonna return the painterly one?

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah I think so. I just need to film the update first

Great video! Thanks xo

I have had the exact same issue with these two shades

This is an awesome video! I appreciate the post and among subscribing!

Maybe you should try sending a DM to Tataylaa bc she uses Painterly and I seem to remember her saying she liked painterly more then soft ochre. If I’m remembering correctly then she has used both. I wonder also if Mac did a formula change and your soft ochre is the old formula. It could also be that it’s dried out a bit and that’s made it more opaque bc it has less water in it.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

She doesnt really do colorful makeup tho and work with shadows the way I do. I just bought another soft ochre one, so I'll find out for myself and see which one I prefer and if the formulas have changed or not. I'll make another video soon!

So what is the conclusion now? :-)

Wowww this is wild!

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Crazy right?!?!

I clicked ion this one soo fast, always wondered about this.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Haha did it answer your question? If you wanted an update, I bought both, tried them new and they are just like they were in this video... so yeah, dont buy painterly

@msparker3500

5 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner Thought I hade Soft ocre but turned out that either they told me the wrong name or gave me the wrong colour. I wonder what your favorite would do to my eyeshadow.

The thing is, I think there can be inconsistencies in batches. Not necessarily just bc one is older, but because they’re made in different batches. Imagine if the dude working didn’t add all of just one ingredient. Or they didn’t let it mix for as long. There’s any number of things that could happen during the process of making these that would make them different. You could get another painterly and it could be from another batch and be different. Especially when products have been around for a long time, when multiple batches are being made... the chances of it being made in 2019 the exact same as when they first came Out with these, years ago.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

IIts possible, but the difference shouldnt be THIS big. Its not even the same product anymore...

I have both and I didn’t care for painterly I like soft ochre more and it doesn’t crease on me at all vs painterly does

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

4 жыл бұрын

Ive heard other people say that painterly creases too. Crazy how big of a difference there is!

@DesiGlamLife

4 жыл бұрын

Annette's Makeup Corner I just wish it wasn’t so yellow if it had the coloring of painterly it would be perfect. I don’t know how the same formula can be so different

Very pretty..

I have tried both. I stared with soft ocre and it was too yellow. Then I got painterly. In the end it gave me too much texture on my lids. Sister inherited them and she was very happy

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah they are 100% different formulas then!

❤️❤️❤️

Bah, I really hate the yellow of soft ochre but there was obviously a difference, so I ordered the soft ochre one :P

I like the painterly side

It’s my first time buying Mac paint pot! I definitely will pick up Soft Ochre

The red WAS different. What a bummer...

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Right???? So weird...

It was definitely different on each color you used.

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Right??

@pamelahewlett1750

5 жыл бұрын

Yes. Every color, including the shimmer

And now they've changed to formulation and Painterly works better!!... 😎✌🏼

@danielleromanmartinez3600

Жыл бұрын

Realy?😮

I hate soft ochre, n love painterly. Ochre is so yellow n dry for my skin. Painterly is amazing

I know this video is several years old but I couldn’t resist commenting. I have owned several Soft Ochre and Painterly paint pots. I prefer the Soft Ochre. I find that the Soft Ochre paint pot has a better texture. Eyeshadows apply far better on the Soft Ochre. The formula of the Painterly is not as nice as the Soft Ochre.

🌸🌸🌸🌸🌸

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

💙

Ure rt.. there is a difference....

@AnnettesMakeupCorner

5 жыл бұрын

Totally!

@ladypurple8464

5 жыл бұрын

@@AnnettesMakeupCorner i only have painterly so ive not been able to compare.. all i know is my juvias eyeshadows works beautifully with it lol... but then juvias always work ha ha . Im interested in hearing if MAC has a reply for u.... well wait for part 2.. ha en fin kveld. Alltid moro å se dine videoer. 😉