No video

LOST ARK - What does the (Night's Edge) Soul Eater assassin class do?

⯈ / saintone
⯈ / saintonelive
0:00 - Intro
0:44 - Overview
2:35 - Engravings and Stats
5:59 - Soulstone and Deathlord
11:24 - Build Variation
19:24 - Chaos Dungeon
19:58 - Hell Mode
22:23 - Summary
LOAWA Armory Link: loawa.com/char...
The LOAWA armory is a real-time tracker of character information taken from LOA KR’s public API. Therefore, if you’re looking for my raiding set-up on it and it looks weird, I’m probably not currently wearing my raiding set-up. If you can’t understand the page, you can use Google Chrome’s built-in translator to help yourself.

Пікірлер: 145

  • @Saintone
    @Saintone9 ай бұрын

    I made a mistake in the summary saying that 4/3/1 was more freeform and afterwards said 4/2/2. 4/2/2 is the more versatile playstyle one! There is the minor quirk of entering the Deathlord mode at a bad time and it's probably the only downside to this build. If you don't fix it, it can screw up your baseline rotation for the rest of the fight, but it's not hard to fix it, so really if you're keen on this build don't let that scare you off. The main takeaway is not to use Lethal Spinning right before you enter Deathlord mode. You need that skill to be off cooldown within a few seconds of entering Deathlord so that you can cast it twice. If you enter Deathlord and you had just used it a moment ago you'll only be able to cast it once and that skill is a fairly big chunk of your damage while in your identity. As long as you're aware of that, you have some freedom of how to adjust your rotation. The 4/3/1 rotation is a 120 identity meter generating rotation which gives you approximately 20 seconds to enter Deathlord from the time that you use your first spender before needing to make some adaptations. Again, it sounds trickier than it actually is. Overall she's a relatively easy class to play. I have my own personal reservations as far as enjoyment goes, but there's no denying she's very powerful and is pretty close to high tier backattack classes in damage without being a positional class herself.

  • @ismetgoren7158

    @ismetgoren7158

    9 ай бұрын

    Can you tell me mr saint is this vlass playable with express gems, 7 all and few 8

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    @@ismetgoren7158 Yes it will work, but the tail end of the rotation to enter Deathlord identity will be a little tight.

  • @Psyzenn

    @Psyzenn

    9 ай бұрын

    Why not spec night edge ?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    @@Psyzenn Pardon? Specialization doesn't do much for this engraving.

  • @Psyzenn

    @Psyzenn

    9 ай бұрын

    @@Saintone Sorry. I mixed the builds.

  • @Stoopzz
    @Stoopzz9 ай бұрын

    Good Video, Sir

  • @got2beable
    @got2beable9 ай бұрын

    I love and missed watching guides of saint so much. They are so clear and easy to understand while having so much information in it. Such a huge value

  • @SungJinwoo666
    @SungJinwoo6669 ай бұрын

    Thank you very much for the great video and all the info for the class. I am thinking of playing her crit build as a top 6 in my roster.

  • @shadowrom8296
    @shadowrom82969 ай бұрын

    not playing anymore for a long time now but still enjoying watching your video

  • @niccoSun
    @niccoSun9 ай бұрын

    Thank you for the video, Saint. I tend to gravitate towards classes that can constantly attack, so Nights Edge will be for me. I do enjoy hitting big numbers, but spec classes feel like they are running in two feet of mud.

  • @Jason-hd7sh

    @Jason-hd7sh

    8 ай бұрын

    the spec build literally runs raid captain wym.

  • @_Tomon
    @_Tomon9 ай бұрын

    Thanks, I was hoping you will manage to upload this video. I would love to see such an excellent take on the spec version as well, because for once I'm actually leaning away from swift version but I understand you prefer to talk about things you actually understand really well.

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Unfortunately when a new class comes out I usually only go in-depth on one of the two builds. Zeals uploaded a solid video on the other spec though.

  • @soloplayer000
    @soloplayer0009 ай бұрын

    As always appreciate the guide and effort sir Saint ❤️

  • @tylerrose4279
    @tylerrose42799 ай бұрын

    Awesome video, I think you sold me on this class.

  • @EllyYoutube
    @EllyYoutube9 ай бұрын

    Great video! This will help me tons!

  • @blackspirit86245

    @blackspirit86245

    9 ай бұрын

    Hi Elly!

  • @domee1122
    @domee11229 ай бұрын

    Thanks for the great Vid on the Class, will probably switch from Igniter, sadly getting frustrated :c

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Stay strong. Eventually Sorceress will have their day.

  • @footvantage06

    @footvantage06

    5 ай бұрын

    @@SaintoneIt seems that day has come.

  • @RanduMandu
    @RanduMandu9 ай бұрын

    Is there a large dps difference between full crit, crit/swift hybrid/ and the full swift variants?

  • @dimasbram7176

    @dimasbram7176

    9 ай бұрын

    i mean she's already a spammy character, idk why some people build high swift on her

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Not much. Some of the value of swiftness is lost due to Deathlord's innate CDR and how it interacts with swiftness CDR. Also the philosophy that more CDR isn't as useful if you can't cast off cooldown. Most people will either do full crit or 50/50 and I think that this decision should be made based off of using Adrenaline 1 or 3 and what's on your bracelet/elixirs, as well as if you're using Hallucination or Nightmare. It's not a great answer but they're close enough where you can do it off of preference/how the rest of your itemization looks.

  • @GrentonCasts
    @GrentonCasts9 ай бұрын

    GOOD VIDEO YEP, MY DIRECTOR SAINTONE

  • @unowtimsayin
    @unowtimsayin9 ай бұрын

    Finally, someone is calling the skill colors by proper names and not saying blue and purple for the turquoise and pink.

  • @rapoltiana

    @rapoltiana

    9 ай бұрын

    Those are the same people that call red or magenta instead of purple in brel G3

  • @Aegis.

    @Aegis.

    9 ай бұрын

    hes not xd

  • @Viruxs29
    @Viruxs299 ай бұрын

    Im really looking forward to Night edge souleater hopefully it brings back my motivation for lost ark, Also, I cant find any video footage on 4-2-2, did you not have any within this video? you mention it alot however theres no gaemplay for it from what I can see? Maybe im being blind though!

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Not on my KZread, but there's still several VODs of me playing 4/2/2 before I changed my build to 4/3/1 last week.

  • @cingpoyy
    @cingpoyy8 ай бұрын

    hi saint thanks for the guide dumb question, maybe u answered this a lot too but other than full 10s CD gem, whats the comfort gem to play this class? i feel like lv 7 and 8 from the event still gave lot of downtime since we put the 8s on reaper & gullotine (i suppose)

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    8 ай бұрын

    Even with level 10 gems, there will typically be downtime before your second round of GS/RS that puts you into edge state. That's typically okay, since the only time that counts is the time between first to time until second round of those attacks. Besides cooldown gems, the only things that will reduce those cooldowns are more swiftness and C+J. After those two gems, I recommend Harvest/Vestige gems for increased comfort. Harvest is helpful for always getting in three in edge state. Vestige is useful for safety situations on identity gauge where you need to raw cast it for 10% identity meter.

  • @cingpoyy

    @cingpoyy

    8 ай бұрын

    @@Saintone thanks a lot mister saint! appreciate it!

  • @Shibby
    @Shibby9 ай бұрын

    Useful video Sainty-poo.

  • @nicolesv8677
    @nicolesv86778 ай бұрын

    Hello! Thank you a lot!!!! Can you show your Chaos Dungeon build?

  • @darka86
    @darka869 ай бұрын

    Thank you saintone

  • @Raizy
    @Raizy9 ай бұрын

    Hey Saint, just wondering why does both build don't use the other pink skill(The one where you spin then explode)? Is it really bad?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    The other skills just work out better in terms of cooldown sync and the built-in stack for generating 40 identity instead of 30 (Vestige used once with crystals and once without).

  • @TheMythicRealm
    @TheMythicRealm9 ай бұрын

    Does it matter which gear you choose, hallucination or nightmare? Does it highly depend on which skill tree you are or can you go with either skill tree?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    I don't think it really matters much. Hallucination is a really solid choice though if you have lower level cooldown gems since it lets you offset some stats to swiftness without sacrificing that much crit chance.

  • @Maalaboy
    @Maalaboy9 ай бұрын

    So is full crit viable CD-wise (skill spamming) with the super mokoko lvl 7 gems (and NM set i guess but since you regularly refill mana boundless doesnt matter i think?), or is 60/40 or 50/50 advised for spamming skills off cd over crit (and more white numbers)?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    It will work! It may be a little tight though.

  • @hitokirifred
    @hitokirifred9 ай бұрын

    hai, thanks for another great guide is 413 viable with 60/40 halu adre 5? went trixion to try our rota with what express gave me and was pretty smooth, wondering if im loosing a lot dps or its fine?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Hello, your skill build loadout is independent from your stat/set loadout. You can mix and match them, though 413 will flow a little bit better with some extra swiftness if you don't have high level cooldown gems.

  • @hitokirifred

    @hitokirifred

    9 ай бұрын

    @@Saintone thanks, will keep more swift for now :)

  • @asunayuuki1705
    @asunayuuki17059 ай бұрын

    Can you use MI with a 50/50 crit/swift? Will the extra Swift nullify the atk spd reduction from MI?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    You can do it. It won't fully nullify the attack speed penalty.

  • @havoc3478
    @havoc34788 ай бұрын

    Dude can you help me i cant use my ULT Deathbringer. What can i do? it always say i need awakenin chaos shard.. I avail the supermokoko annd i choose night edge souleater

  • @justarod6059
    @justarod60599 ай бұрын

    I got a question till when is the character selection on the pass can't see my pc broke waitting on parts

  • @nefelheim8923
    @nefelheim89239 ай бұрын

    i see some tier list video, in this videos Night's Edge is S class, but Full Moon A class. Why? On loawa most of high GS players use Full Moon and only few people use Night's Edge.

  • @Ch1hf
    @Ch1hf6 ай бұрын

    what stat distribution do you run on your 422 build, i saw the community guide recommends not going full crit if you dont go 431, is it a big deal if i run full crit on 422?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    6 ай бұрын

    422 I was playing split stat build but your stat distribution is independent of your skill loadout.

  • @kanyewestonhiskanyequest1235
    @kanyewestonhiskanyequest12357 ай бұрын

    Is there a text document anywhere? for 422 with actual tripods?

  • @tnsora156
    @tnsora1569 ай бұрын

    Hi Saintone! I just wanted to ask if its ok still going adren 1 in 5x3+1 without the crit chance elixer with this build?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    You can do it but you may feel like your crit chance is a little low. But it should be fine.

  • @aicechannel5949
    @aicechannel59498 ай бұрын

    Thanks for a great vid. I have a question about reversed stone (raid captain2) Is it stronger than standard 5+1 and how much weaker it is to adre 2? Thanks!

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    8 ай бұрын

    I think this is fine. The damage difference is negligible as long as you use Adrenaline 3 as a core engraving.

  • @aicechannel5949

    @aicechannel5949

    8 ай бұрын

    @@Saintone thanks for replying so quickly! Im relieved that my luck didnt go to waste. And I can use this in the spec build as well right?

  • @TheHellScarf
    @TheHellScarf9 ай бұрын

    hey @Saintone I want to go for 431 but only aiming for level 8 gems in purple skills, do you think is worth it or just stick to 422? Thank you, love your videos and twitch!

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    That would work. 413 and 422 is preference, but both will work with level 8 in purple.

  • @TheHellScarf

    @TheHellScarf

    9 ай бұрын

    @@Saintone thank you sir, have a good day

  • @Kunaives
    @Kunaives9 ай бұрын

    I hate how it all just seems like reskinned animations from the other assassins. Players deserve better. Great vid either way

  • @FirsTiiPoN
    @FirsTiiPoN9 ай бұрын

    Hi sir I have question 413 better than 503 ? or What is the difference between 503 and 413? I'm expecting an answer from you.

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    8 ай бұрын

    503 uses an extra purple skill to increase the damage in the edge state. But in return, it has a much more strict identity meter generation compared to 413 which is much more practical due to Soul Drain providing so much.

  • @FirsTiiPoN

    @FirsTiiPoN

    8 ай бұрын

    ​@@SaintoneI appreciate the information and advice you have shared.

  • @Xinatre
    @Xinatre9 ай бұрын

    Just gimme the man, which holds double dagger at the Intro, as a male assassin.

  • @andrewallsworth6101
    @andrewallsworth61019 ай бұрын

    wait what skill do you replace for asteros for the 4-2-2 build and what rune would go with it?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    4-2-2 replaces Reaper's Scythe for Astaros. There's a lot of rune options for it, I used Overwhelm but Focus is another good option, as is Galewind. The build variation is in the Nexus community guide.

  • @syzpj627
    @syzpj6279 ай бұрын

    so whats the stats distribution for full moon and how easy is the rotation? no stress?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Low stress, pretty easy rotation. Stat distribution is preference but you'll build set and possibly engravings around it.

  • @photograhy
    @photograhy9 ай бұрын

    Hey Saint, will you be making one for Full Moon engraving or not?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    I won't be, sorry. Zeals put out a video on that engraving though.

  • @MoreVxVClips
    @MoreVxVClips9 ай бұрын

    got recommended to use the story express isntead of south vern pass on my soul eater as first character, since i usualy enjoy the narrative of games. would that be right?

  • @912phillips

    @912phillips

    9 ай бұрын

    Yes if it's your first time and you generally enjoy questing, the story express is a great way to get some rewards and quickly move through the story (easier honing). Then an alt character can use the Powerpass to skip all of that content and you'll have 2 to play at end game. Keep in mind it is 20-30 hrs of story depending how fast you go, but if you enjoy story it's definitely the right call to Story express first!

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    As a brand new player, Story Express is alright. The Path of the Adventurer after boosting will also give you a abridged version of the story if you don't want to do Story Express. Story Express is still a 12-20 hours according to viewers who had done it recently (your mileage may vary).

  • @Buziak34
    @Buziak349 ай бұрын

    She is playable with lvl 7 cdr gems & full crit build ? This is my only concern for her. Im not gonna put lvl 9 gems on her too quickly. I must say that im little scared of her rotation. Is she worst then Evo scouter or Wd FI ? In term off management the rotation?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    It will work with level 7 gems, but the rotation will be a little tighter. You have 20 seconds to enter Deathlord mode after the first spender. Having higher level cooldown gems on the pink skill will just make it 1-2 seconds more lenient.

  • @Snoozememnon
    @Snoozememnon9 ай бұрын

    Choosing between pre dater and soul reaper aiii

  • @blackspirit86245
    @blackspirit862459 ай бұрын

    I wanna know what outfit is?! I hope it isn’t reaper exclusive because I’d love it on my bard.

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    It is Assassin exclusive, sorry. :(

  • @fugino6822
    @fugino68229 ай бұрын

    Once I read your ign backwards I cannot unread it now xD Is that a rather unhappy coincidence or was it intentional? :O Anyway, thank you for nice guide, kind Sir.

  • @MikaOnline

    @MikaOnline

    7 ай бұрын

    Izanami is a japanese name and in his case, it's a character from the anime Spy x Family. His character's appearance / skins also resemble the anime

  • @fugino6822

    @fugino6822

    7 ай бұрын

    Pheww.. i guess :D thanks ;-) @@MikaOnline

  • @gindgaming
    @gindgaming8 ай бұрын

    what my +1 if i go adrenaline 3? cursed doll 1? raid captain 1? or ether predator 1

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    8 ай бұрын

    Ether Predator.

  • @xaviertumblod8955
    @xaviertumblod89559 ай бұрын

    why not go mass increase if it is swift build?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    It's an option. You will feel the attack speed penalty but you can do that if you're fine with that.

  • @joshtonreau
    @joshtonreau9 ай бұрын

    can you show us the new hairstyles :(

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    We don't have them yet! At the time of recording this video.

  • @joshtonreau

    @joshtonreau

    9 ай бұрын

    oh no worries I’ve just been scouring the internet trying to see if they’re available for the mages too since mages don’t/havent done up-do’s so I was curious lol thanks for the reply

  • @ktuyends
    @ktuyends8 ай бұрын

    Can you share chaos build bro? tks

  • @zolihoang9255
    @zolihoang92559 ай бұрын

    being an assassin, is she on the lower side of tankiness ? or she is a bit tankier for some reason ?

  • @FroggyTonki

    @FroggyTonki

    9 ай бұрын

    Bit tankier

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Medium tankiness.

  • @alexou857
    @alexou8579 ай бұрын

    I noticed i was dying a lot during raids, does she takes more dmg than other classes ?

  • @blackspirit86245

    @blackspirit86245

    9 ай бұрын

    Her defenses are probably closer to reaper compared to Deathblade and Shadowhunter. Assassin classes are in general lower on the defense coefficient vs others except maybe mages. Shadowhunter is the odd one out because she gets some minor healing during transformation.

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    As you get better at her and how her skills move her, you'll get better at positioning while attacking and be able to avoid more incoming hits.

  • @DoctorMario911
    @DoctorMario9119 ай бұрын

    I honestly rather wait til next powerpass to make this class since i rather not deal with an entrie server of soul eater

  • @meowmeow803
    @meowmeow8039 ай бұрын

    Neff brelshaza pls. As a new player, I‘m 1490 and unable to find any team to do brelshaza.

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    You can do it! Find other people in the same boat.

  • @notmorethanapotato6925
    @notmorethanapotato69259 ай бұрын

    can u also use 413 with astaros

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    I've seen it done before but it seems a bit janky to me. It can work though, and I think the Nexus community guide covers that specific loadout.

  • @MoreVxVClips
    @MoreVxVClips9 ай бұрын

    how is she as a first class for new player? am torn between her and slayer

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    She's pretty easy and the stuff they give you from the Super Mokoko Express should suffice to make the build operational. It's also pretty skill-point lenient which is good for newbies.

  • @MoreVxVClips

    @MoreVxVClips

    9 ай бұрын

    would i be good with only 2 characters? so far only souleater and predator seems interessting@@Saintone

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    @@MoreVxVClips These are fine, solid choices. Predator Slayer will need you to level ASAP though to increase your total mana pool though since she OOMs pretty easily early on.

  • @gial27

    @gial27

    9 ай бұрын

    @@MoreVxVClipsgot back into the game myself on pred slayer, definitely awesome class for progging, would recommend her aswell 👍🏼 but see which you like more and eventually u can use path to souleater event on either one

  • @MoreVxVClips

    @MoreVxVClips

    9 ай бұрын

    ​@@Saintone​ thanks. Last question, will it be possible to play soul eater decent with a controller? I recently started to have back and hand pains, where I would need a controller to play comfortably

  • @sergeylukin9111
    @sergeylukin91119 ай бұрын

    Make it more clear.Its igniter Sorc + Striker with elemental orbs. Z resets Damaging skill and give buff as Sorc. And this explay all what player need to know and image how game play be in all terms(sorc with delayed damage skills with same high stagger and destraction +Striker nature in combat and movement in skills). Full moon about be more igniter sorc, Dark moon be like clasical mixed stats striker. If you like striker or sorc=>Take Soul eater to your roster

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    This is not a video for Full Moon, sorry.

  • @SamMoonRyong
    @SamMoonRyong9 ай бұрын

    balls for traction

  • @NepNyaa
    @NepNyaa9 ай бұрын

    is 512 build worth looking into ?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    I haven't tried it myself but the limitations of 2 pink skills in builds disrupts the flow of SE's gameplay in my personal opinion without significant gain since turquoise skills don't do much more damage than unempowered pink skills and taking more than four purple skills doesn't improve your identity skill cycling when in state. I'm sure it would work though.

  • @user-yo3gz2eg7i

    @user-yo3gz2eg7i

    9 ай бұрын

    Thanks for the info@@Saintone

  • @kheath580
    @kheath5809 ай бұрын

    before elixirs what is the optimal 5x3+1? which engraving is the +1?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Ether Predator I guess.

  • @Nooodlicious
    @Nooodlicious9 ай бұрын

    is full crit and 422 a thing?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Yes, the set choice and the skill loadout choice are individual from each other. You can play any set with any skill variation, but your stat distribution will be impacted by your set.

  • @Nooodlicious

    @Nooodlicious

    9 ай бұрын

    thanks!@@Saintone

  • @Shadow_Dragon55
    @Shadow_Dragon559 ай бұрын

    Nice so she's basically controller friendly

  • @michaelfriesorger3771
    @michaelfriesorger37719 ай бұрын

  • @thegrumpylobster2937
    @thegrumpylobster29379 ай бұрын

    Any 503 enjoyers?

  • @user-lf5ev1hx1n
    @user-lf5ev1hx1n2 ай бұрын

    If the letters on your keyboard are in English, why the hell would you ever have the language on screen in an asian variant?

  • @jacklau5529
    @jacklau55295 ай бұрын

    SE/Slayer> Aero lets goo bozos

  • @Jarot_TV
    @Jarot_TV9 ай бұрын

    Sadly this is a dead game on NA ;/

  • @brainswag
    @brainswag9 ай бұрын

    I have to watch 2 minutes of a crappy mobile game ads just to see this video? And I cant even change the ads nor skip it the 2nd time. XD Thats crazy... 2 fucking minutes.

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Adblock it.

  • @nuxbot919
    @nuxbot9199 ай бұрын

    Looks boring

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Sadly a lot of people felt the same way in Korea. She ended up being less popular than other class releases despite being very strong.

  • @nuxbot919

    @nuxbot919

    9 ай бұрын

    @@Saintone she looks flashy, very cool animations, looks fun on paper but lacks substance imo :/ Good video as always you're the goat !

  • @Akreyie

    @Akreyie

    9 ай бұрын

    If this looks boring, then what looks fun to you?

  • @Akreyie

    @Akreyie

    9 ай бұрын

    @@nuxbot919 >Looks boring >Looks flashy and cool animations huh.jpg

  • @nuxbot919

    @nuxbot919

    9 ай бұрын

    @@Akreyie Gameplay is meh to me at best. You do you it's my opinion.

  • @ARXEMxSAMA
    @ARXEMxSAMA9 ай бұрын

    OMG so boring video man... just for the music. All info was greate, but music...

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    There's music in the video?

  • @youdumbcat
    @youdumbcat9 ай бұрын

    What about the biblioteca? Library?? o.O

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    9 ай бұрын

    Western players are very studious.

  • @hollow379
    @hollow3794 ай бұрын

    sir did you delete your soul eater?

  • @Saintone

    @Saintone

    4 ай бұрын

    I stopped playing her over half a year ago! I didn't really enjoy her gameplay or aesthetics despite how strong she was.

  • @hollow379

    @hollow379

    4 ай бұрын

    @@Saintone ah i see i asked bc the link doesnt lead anywhere. Understandable sir ty for response.