I don't agree that it all sounds manufactured. It CAN sound like that if you allow it to but with loose quantising, velocity adjustments and special attention to the humanize function, you can lift it above the dull, lifeless stuff beginners come out with. It's like anything, it's how you apply yourself to the task. With enthusiasm and attention to detail you can make ordinary become extraordinary.

@thatlogicproguy

13 күн бұрын

Preach!!!! 💯 agree

Why are you keeping the click track on ? We cant hear anything 😅

@jellewierda3828

14 күн бұрын

it's part of the track ;-)

@thatlogicproguy

13 күн бұрын

I was so locked and focus bro that I didn’t even hear it. 😂

Sorry, couldn't really follow your instructions. Logic Pro produces a 'default' sequence of chords and this doesn't seem to allow me to edit them. Thanks anyway

Man that click needs to go. Why do you have it on?

@thatlogicproguy

14 күн бұрын

I was so zoned in. I don’t even notice it. Cheers!

Don’t get me wrong, I think this and the last update are good moves and I’m excited for the beginners who can really benefit from it, but is there anything new a seasoned pro can take advantage of other than the new saturation plugin?

@thatlogicproguy

14 күн бұрын

Have you seen the MIDI Input routing feature? That has many implications. I would also look at the ability to bounce external instruments or I/O in real time. There are some Marquee tool improvements as well.

Thanks for the insight 👌

@thatlogicproguy

10 күн бұрын

🙏🔥👍💪💯

Looks like several people aren't happy with the click track as I was going to suggest. I appreciate the demo.

@thatlogicproguy

11 күн бұрын

🙏👍🔥🔥💪

Super!!!Thank you so much

@thatlogicproguy

13 күн бұрын

🙏👍💯💪🔥

3:55 to jump past drummer vets

Great!

@thatlogicproguy

15 күн бұрын

🙏👍💯💪🔥

So is it possible now to play electronic drums via midi and the bass and piano players will playalong with me live?

@thatlogicproguy

16 күн бұрын

If you program it…👍💯

..still no option to extract chords from a song..?? regards

@thatlogicproguy

17 күн бұрын

Try chord.ai app it’s so good!!!

@StevenCharlesJazz

10 күн бұрын

@@thatlogicproguy Went there, but their website only says, "Coming soon"...

I tired to update it on App Store but the update is not there, is it coz I’m in Europe ?

@thatlogicproguy

16 күн бұрын

M1?

@volenbolen

15 күн бұрын

You need to update your OS to access the new update, it's available on Sonoma only

@thatlogicproguy

14 күн бұрын

@@volenbolen macOS Ventura 13.5 or later is ok too

Just a tip as an educator of 20 years. Slow down everything to a speed that is easy to follow. It is a common mistake with beginning teachers, they speak far too fast and you see it all the time on computer instruction videos. The instructor flies around the screen clicking the way they do as a user, which is not how somebody trying to learn something new absorbs information...

@thatlogicproguy

14 күн бұрын

Thx for the tip. My demographic is 20 to 60 years old so it’s definitely a balancing act. My slower paced material I mostly reserve for paid courses🙏💯👍🔥💪

It falls flat... What would really be useful is to be able to drag a midi track up to the Chord track and have the Chord track auto populate the chords. Also, to be able to lock a midi input to the chord track would be awesome for creating in-key melodies. Oh well, maybe next time.

@thatlogicproguy

16 күн бұрын

You can definitely do something similar if the Apple Loops contain the chordal information within their metadata. Your second point sounds awesome and someone already did it. Company is called “Feel Your Sound” product is called “melodic flow”. Would be nice if it was built on (I’m sure it’s coming 😉)

Having used Logic with chord track for a week - the chord track keeps changing edits I do in midi tracks - like an annoying spell checker. That feature is not for me - I have my own ideas after 60+ years of composing music.

@thatlogicproguy

7 күн бұрын

Thank you for sharing your insights

Why can’t the chord track just follow the midi regions I just played? Not innovative

@thatlogicproguy

13 күн бұрын

Does not work that way sir. You can assign the Chords on the “Chord Track” first and then ask the midi to follow the chord track. I’ll be talking about this on my next video.

@copperysinger5985

13 күн бұрын

@@thatlogicproguy thangs for replying

@copperysinger5985

13 күн бұрын

@@thatlogicproguy it would be ideal to be able to drop midi chords or record real time playing chords. But as it is, it doesn’t serve a productive purpose. The time it takes to input each chord progression for an entire song would is a waste because you can record your progressions bass and melodies at a more productive time frame. Imagine writing an entire composition by limiting only writing the notes and chords. This design is kick in the face to musicians wanting backing bass and keys. This function has been in Cubase since 2016.

@thatlogicproguy

13 күн бұрын

Lots of great examples for sure. I think it will evolve and get there for sure. This is the “Apple” way. They tread with scrutiny and carefully.

ok, already today’s youth can’t no longer play any instrument, with this kind of tools it’s gonna be even worst.It’s the end of musical theory as we know it

@lunarproductions1176

17 күн бұрын

yes they can, there are still kids wanting to learn the old school rock and roll! im a music teacher and see it all the time. dont no how i feel about this good for writing and demos but fake as for creativty. we are being replaced

@gasparucciox9706

17 күн бұрын

@@lunarproductions1176 i use LOGIC pro since 22 years , i produce music etc , so i know what you mean , i LOVE logic pro, it's an essential tool for me, that's not the problem.But what i see is more and more ad popup on tools on how build a song even if you don't know the difference from a C to D , so...what i mean it's that music is music , and it's the same since 1000 years or more , doesn't matter if your the Ramones , Vivaldi or a techno producer, the more musical rules and theory you know the better is the result, if the actual trend is to skip music theory, music have no future.....beside i know that there are still young people who learn music etc i'm a boomer with a solid contact with reality!

@VEXUS920

17 күн бұрын

I teach kids music production and composition. Tools like this when implemented well can go a long way in teaching kids theory faster. I personally use Cubase it has a more advanced chord track it’s helped me a lot in understanding the function of chords in my compositions. It’s all about perspective

@thatlogicproguy

17 күн бұрын

🙏🔥💯👍💪

You lost me at 44 seconds. Where is the Chord track? I could not get the screen you are on. Had I been able to start I probably would have been fine.

@thatlogicproguy

16 күн бұрын

Global tracks

@RICHFOW

16 күн бұрын

@@thatlogicproguy Yes I see it right away when you say that. I knew it would be easy but needed that help. thanks

I think that this part of the update is great, especially for beginners. I already use drummer to help sketch out ideas and can see myself using bass player as well to assist with the initial idea. I only wish they had added a session guitar. In my opinion, that has been Logic’s achilles heel. The guitars either didn’t sound realistic or weren’t able to be easily programmed. It would be great to have a session guitar so I don’t have to run to third parties like Native Instruments just to get a strumming pattern

@thatlogicproguy

17 күн бұрын

🙏💪👍💯🔥 wish more folks had your positive outlook sir

Turn the clock off

@thatlogicproguy

13 күн бұрын

👍⏰

Sounds canned like always. I think these tools are good for organizing and writing, but as far as finished pieces. No thanks. They're good for getting things going though. I got tired of fighting with Drummer so I bought some v drums .. Drummer is a good way to get started quickly on things though. I'm not really all that blown away by this stuff. It's ok.

@hardlines2635

17 күн бұрын

Sounds like you’ve turned into your Dad, do you ever find yourself saying, That’s just noise.

@thatlogicproguy

14 күн бұрын

Back in my day 😉….i agree though this is a good tool. Not looking forward to all of the generic tracks I am going to hear from noobs and folks that think dragging in loops is equivalent to making music. I remember when the Step Sequencer came out “All Hands Beat” was on every song I heard from up and coming producers. So tired of that pattern region loop

@Fiveash-Art

12 күн бұрын

@@hardlines2635 My Dad loved progressive noise rock. Noise is fine .. canned and boring sounding is the antithesis of creative and provocative. Your argument makes no sense .. essentially this drag and drop stuff sounds like elevator music. I'd figure most old people would love that. 😂