As a Scotsman I quite enjoyed this version, well done lads.

@stevenjohnson2414

9 жыл бұрын

Robert Murray Thanks that means a lot.

Not ashamed to say I cried listening to this. My grandfather sang this to me all the time when I was little, and these four young men just absolutely blew my mind.

Fantastic!!!!

For a group of young men so young -- and a creative beginning and confident voices -- I expect to hear more in the FUTURE!!!

Very nice job, of a challenging arrangement, especially by a young quartet. I hope each of you are still singing!

Well sung, lads! These are the kinds of songs that keeps a country together.

Omg, I've been in love with this song for years, but now even more. Good job guys!

This is great! I love it.

This is the best that I have ever heard in my life.

These guys did an amazing job!

Sounds Great, amazing!

i live there and this is fantastic

Great and beautiful........ Good chant

Wonderful.

🌹😘👍beautifully done.

wonderful!

omg i love this one of the best i ever seen

simple... AWESOME !

Awesome !

Amazing

Well done!!!

that was awesome

Awesome beautiful

made me cry :)

Great stuff

Marvelous

Wow might sound sad but I had a tear in my eye make me so proud to be Scottish well done

Good boys

Dear quartet singers. superbly done L Lomond, for sure. I am an Alma College vocal singing alum who did, eons ago, sing with their choir. Alma College is a Scotch ancestry school called the Alma Scots. They have kiltie dancers, bagpipers and wonderful choirs. This quartet version is a very similar one that their current choir does. C if you can find it on line...under Alma College. Alma is still the home of the annual Highland Festival each year...May or June???? Thanks, guys---sounds really, really good; keep it up. Hope to maybe see some other songs you do. Wonderful. Makes me home and college-sick.

omg thts so cool it reminds me of the guys in my chior when they sang it :) A+

I'm no scotsman but I will say a job well done. Go raibh maith agat! Keep up the good work.

Very nice:) one of the best versions of this song. Been trying to see what vid could help for second soprano. Bravo to you all:)

From left to right the names are Justin Howe, Mitchell Lemmon, Leonardo Escobar, and Steven Johnson. We performed this in Elko, Nevada and yes the sound was a little off. We haven't been able to record anything since but we look forward to doing it with higher quality equipment.

@stevenjohnson2414

10 жыл бұрын

And we were messing around in the beginning so sorry if anyone has an issue with that.

@lukeventers4755

2 жыл бұрын

Steve I sing tenor with the Mission Valley Choral Society in Northwestern Montana and we're doing the Johnathan Quick? arrangement for an upcoming festival.

Loch Lomond by Matthew Curtis is the best one by far. Look it up

I’ve sung this arrangement before. It’s really fun.

i thought these chord progression were pretty interesting even with the lack of bass. cheers i loved it.

best version yet

As a Scott and a human well done boys

I really like it. I see some negative comments. but regardless I think you were GREAT. Be proud :D

Gràdh à Alba♥️🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

It’s the Jonathan Quick version

Jonathan Quick arrangement? And realtime interpretation?

I very much enjoyed this and cannot find any more of their performances! Who are these guys? Where was this done? Who arranged it? I was nearly brought to tears by the opening solo and the performance got better as it went along. I am imagining how much greater this presentation could have been with better sound equipment. Thank you for posting this gem and please let me know how I can listen to more like it! Bravo! - Chas Wilson, a new fan of yours from Tacoma, Washington, USA

@Orovir You have every right in the world to dislike their arrangement. I only took issue with your statement that they are "supposed to be a fairly professional group." I called your level of respect in to question based on this statement. Whether you liked their performance or not, they are a VERY professional quartet and immensely talented.

Your post should list the name and location of the school, and the name of the 4 singers. This was awesome !

Wow, baritone much?

@kallegeorge3913

7 жыл бұрын

Truly, restraint is not that hard

@madcowjr8728

6 жыл бұрын

Bass this song is SATB

@monkeyfarman Ultimately you have to just decide to do what you're going to do even when the jealous and untalented try to drag you down to their level. Cheers to the quartet! Nice mellow sound.

Very impressive, well done. @Orovir "A fairly professional group" ... Realtime are the 2005 International Champions of the Barbershop Harmony Society for a reason. I've heard their rendition of Loch Lomond live and it gives chills. Please learn some respect.

Really good you can hear the bases too much some times

@Orovir Professionalism is not so much a personal preference as you think it is; they sing around the world on shows for money, which of course makes them a professional group by definition! Singing is their job. I don't mind if you don't care about my calling your respect into question, I'm really only continuing this conversation so people who see this video and these comments don't read your original comment and write Realtime off.

I like the arrangement. the volumes were a little off, but otherwise very good!

better than the lead singer on the BW Mens chorus. surprised!

All four of you have lovely voices but you need to listen to each other a bit more. It's all a bit con belto! If you aren't singing the tune at any given point, and you can't hear the tune being sung, you're too loud. You could put in more dynamics too. But on the whole this is a good performance of a challenging arrangement, so well done.

some balance issues...tough when you put best in the title haha. bit much in whoever is singing the majority of the 3rd's of the chords, but good job still!

Check out my quintet's version of this song, I believe it is the best ever.

@reimardietz4212

7 жыл бұрын

Mason Hertz

Lol to say the least! There's no point in the song he should be that loud, but he was the whole time!

I think the base was a little too loud but he was nervous, you guys were amazing otherwise!

@thenicoletti

10 жыл бұрын

the basses you cant even hear. its the bari's that are way too loud

@lukeventers4755

2 жыл бұрын

If you can't spell the word, "bass" then don't bother commenting.

my only complaints are that the bass and baritone were a little too loud, and the vowels could use some work. the four of you have wonderful voices! very nice job!

and i get the mad at are baritones for being to quite, now i think i will stop

sorry. i think there is not "THE BEST". its moderate. The intro does not fit! Where is the bass in the first and second part? lead and bari are to dominant. only the third part is in balance. i know, this song is not easy to sing. i think the sound would be better whithout micro.

@HunnyBadger1199

9 жыл бұрын

i agree it was fair but personally i was in a high school choir that didnt even perform this but instead learned it for fun and still it sounded better this version was to choppy and not well arranged

@cocochanelleke

9 жыл бұрын

TheErb1999 Very good performance and harmony, do not let anyone tell you otherwise. It is not perfect, but still brilliant! Believe that from an old biddy who still loves that song when it is delivered well.

@GreenestGanja2

9 жыл бұрын

Tobias Bob Lol alright there Johannes Brahms, calm down. Although, I guess when you state "the best," you're up for criticism.

best ever, hm? google loch lomond jonathan quick... and make up your own mind

This is good, but if you Google "Loch Lomond - sung by Matthew Curtis" You will find a better version.

I thought he was a bit too loud...

Cheesy as hell lol

the bass is too loud? I can't even hear the bass

I will agree with you to the fact that these boys lack the artistic side of this piece but I followed your HD chorus and i can't say that they are much better they have zero blend I had to fight to hear the first tenor part all in all extremely unimpressed Iowa St still have the best in my book.

Really good but in my humble opinion the "midle" voices are too loud ....

@mitchell8808 I rather listen to a baritone who is dead on his part and out of balance then listen to a bari who is completely off his part.

need some kind of artistic interpretation in this, it is very static. type this into the search, HD Chorus - Loch Lomond, much better version of this song.

The pronounciation wasn't that great but other than that it was great. Tak' is pronounced as tahke

not to bad. it sounds like its being sung 3 parts. the lack of bass sound and the over powering bari/ lead parts throw off balance. also from singing this song, some of the pronunciations were off. all in all not to bad

@stevenjohnson2414

10 жыл бұрын

Thanks for your comment. The arrangement called for some different pronunciations which is why we sang it that way but I appreciate the comment.

Would be nice not to LOOK UP the lyrics.

Someone please tell the baritone to quit screaming...

not balanced lol

Och Rrrrubbish

is not biutifful im sorry

Not the best ever. Definitely not. Good harmony, but way too much baritone. Peter hollens, To name one

that was not good. there is no blend whatsoever. Definitely unimpressed and definitely not the best by far.

@liamtaylor2564

5 жыл бұрын

I'd like to see you do better

@kninep12

5 жыл бұрын

Dalton Bantz channel fixed it. 😏

This is definitely not a good version of this wonderful song - LEAVE IT ALONE PLEASE