One difference is, Liza sounds like the child she is when she sings this. Judy at that age sounded like a grown up. But Liza still sang it very well. That's a hard song to live up to.( Hard voice to live up to)

@jpierce8148

4 жыл бұрын

True! But she definitely sounds like Judy Garland’s child lol

@susanb2015

4 жыл бұрын

You mean Judy's singing voice is tough to live up to.

@frenztrue3216

4 жыл бұрын

Liza was 13 and Judy 17... so pretty big age difference

@susanb2015

4 жыл бұрын

@@frenztrue3216 She was younger when she sang You Made Me Love You and other songs in her movies. She was a much better singer than her daughter. Than almost everyone.

@johncommand1619

4 жыл бұрын

reakky goood Not well

I love how Liza made Over the Rainbow her own song with her sweet and naive voice.

I've seen interviews saying she promised her Mom she wouldn't sing this song because Judy wanted to be remembered for it. Liza said she always sings it at home in the shower etc. She looks and sounds like Judy, both are stars. Judy was one of the hardest working kids and adults in show biz. Love her.

Although there are places in this song where Liza sounds like her mother, her overall tone doesn't. This rendition is higher pitched than Judy's, so Liza sounds younger than her mother's version from the Wizard of Oz. Judy Garland conveyed so much emotion in every note she sang that it made you feel her no matter what the song was. To me, nobody compares to Judy Garland; and I don't think Liza ever wanted to. She's a great talent in her own right.

@jpierce8148

3 жыл бұрын

Luckily, Liza found her own style with cabaret and made a name for herself rather than relying on her mother's style

@PaulLHunziker

3 жыл бұрын

Yes I would say Judy's had a huskier tone to it.

@emaguire5917

3 жыл бұрын

A good book to read ......... "Finding Dorothy" by Elizabeth Letts. Guaranteed to make you cry when you read how Judy Garland was TOTALLY ABUSED during the filming and production of "The Wizard Of Oz", and her BITCH of a mom encouraged it. Not only was she abused, they even kept her drugged up. I will NEVER be able to watch that movie again without bawling my eyes out.

@twistoffate4791

2 жыл бұрын

@@emaguire5917 I will look for the book.

@jonathankieranwriter

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I always saw a resemblance to her father and little resemblance to Judy. Vincent Minnelli was a real looker. 🎉

Liza is a good singer. She doesn't have her mother's blow you out of the water singing voice, but she sings well enough and by golly can sure put on a show! She definitely inherited her mother's ability to put on a show and keep the audience attention.

At this age Liza looks nothing like Judy but a dead ringer for her dad. Very talented as usual!!

@MaskedMan66

7 жыл бұрын

No, I see Judy, especially in the eyes, nose, and lips.

@markwhitman72

7 жыл бұрын

Then you haven't looked at Vincente! Liza looked more like Judy later during her Cabaret New York New York days.

@MaskedMan66

7 жыл бұрын

Mark Whitman I've seen him. She favors her mum, no doubt.

@malindaylayla8119

7 жыл бұрын

Liza is really the only one who favors Judy the most from out of all 3 of her kids though. Lorna & Joe in my opinion are the ones who REALLY didn't look anything like Judy Garland in any way at all & never really has to me, not Liza.

@oliver91ist

4 жыл бұрын

I see a little of both in Liza, if you look at photos of Judy with her sisters you can see Lorna and Joey in their faces

Even at that young age, authentic and first rate version of herself. Sounds so modern and yet classic at the same time. She is one of the greatest actor singer dancers of our generation. She moved me to tears.

Judy had Wizard of Oz. Liza had Cabaret. Both won Oscars, Grammys and Tonys.

@sidneyspence9261

Жыл бұрын

And Tracy Jordan is still waiting 🤣

@lethaluks2942

9 ай бұрын

Did Judy win an oscar as a juvenile? I know she was robbed when she didn’t win one for a Star Is Born!

@kathrynmolesa1641

6 ай бұрын

@@nickxero2740 Sure they do.

Magical. Heart-breaking. And Liza emerges. Phenomenal

Just like her mother ❤️❤️🥺 beautiful angel

Gosh she sounds just like her mother

@arxsyn

6 жыл бұрын

Anthony C She does! Except Liza's voice in the clip is still on the childish side. She didn't have a grown woman sound yet. You can hear the child like tone in her high register. The rich lower register is a dead ringer for her mom's. Judy was known her remarkably mature womanly tone as a young girl. she was a contralto.

@veelighted7

6 жыл бұрын

Film! One of our greatest gifts.

@DDumbrille

5 жыл бұрын

"Gosh", you've got to be kidding.

@mmjhcb

5 жыл бұрын

She sounds nothing like her mother (until the later rendition, sadly). In fact, were she not Judy Garland's daughter, she couldn't have even gotton on AGT at age 13 had it existed then.

@TheKonga88

4 жыл бұрын

She sounds shit.

She’s sings just as beautiful like her mom did ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

She sounds like her mother!

@kittenlalisa

6 жыл бұрын

Katy Katastrophe she really does🖤

@DDumbrille

5 жыл бұрын

You both need your hearing checked ASAP.

@mariahwhitneycelinejanetmadona

5 жыл бұрын

DouglassD they do have similar tones in some places

@TheSazzy47

5 жыл бұрын

@@DDumbrille so do you

@TheSazzy47

5 жыл бұрын

@@DDumbrille doubles

Her voice is just developing. And oh, what a voice it will be.

So beautiful n touching!

She has her dad's eyes & her mom's mouth & voice.

@liz3424

4 жыл бұрын

My sediments exactly!

she got all her mother talent and her father nose just a great talent

She sounds so sad singing this version.

@mrmusiclover87

4 жыл бұрын

Well, it is a sad song

I distinctly remember several interviews where Liza said she would never sing Over the Rainbow because it was her mothers song and that Judy didnt want her to.

in the last clip she only sang that one part because she promised her mom she would never sing that song and she always kept her word

@LuisGarzaHo

5 жыл бұрын

What? That's weird, maybe she hated the song in secret? I never expected that promise

@lesliebrooke84

4 жыл бұрын

Ryan Gregorakos Not true. Lorna sings it often! You can find videos on KZread.

@osahju914

4 жыл бұрын

OH Global it was more about not living in Judy’s shadow

The latter show was taped on the evening of September 10, 2001, just hours before the World Trade Center was attacked. Liza's next performance was singing, "New York, New York" first on The Rosie O'Donnell Show and then at Citifield for the New York Mets, when baseball resumed in late September. She is the ultimate trouper.

The BEST Performance other than Judy, her mother.!!!! No one came close to singing it better❤️

Considering how far away Liza stayed from her mother’s back catalog over the years and specifically this song, I had no idea that she had ever even sung Over the Rainbow at any point of her career. Wow, thanks for posting. 🌈

@wayneboyd9171

6 ай бұрын

U don’t kno ur history. Liza has sung this song several times over the years

She's so adorable, I'm gonna cry😭🌈❤

Had no idea this existed. What a treat! Thanks for sharing!

Liza Minnelli was a great singer she still is she is really good she sang this song just like her mother did her mother be so proud of her

Such a sweet voice!

In the second clip when Liza was much much older, when she walks out on to the stage & before she starts to sing - I thought it was Lady Gaga doing an impression of her

I love Judy and Liza...

she's so lovely

LOVELY LIZA !!!

I love finding obscure gems like this! Thanks so much for sharing!

Great performance

Wonderful Liza!

I get the chills !!!! She sounds just like her mother

@DDumbrille

5 жыл бұрын

You already said that. But she doesn't. At either age.

@moonshot_72

3 жыл бұрын

No, she doesn't

@MaskedMan66

2 жыл бұрын

@@DDumbrille Yes, she does, amazingly so, especially when she speaks her lines in the movie _Journey Back to Oz._

@DDumbrille

2 жыл бұрын

@@MaskedMan66 Sigh. We're talking about her SINGING voice, not speaking lines. Sheesh...

@MaskedMan66

2 жыл бұрын

@@DDumbrille I added her speaking voice to the mix, deal with it. ;-)

The young girl here singing "Over the Rainbow" would later, and not that much later, give a brilliant performance as Sally Bowles in "Cabaret" and would be performing the "Mein Herr" number using a chair as a prop/dance partner with choreography of Bob Fosse.---Even in this youthful, early performance we can already see the beginning of Ms. Minelli's own distinctive quality as a performer.

@nicolympara

4 жыл бұрын

👏👏👏

@ettydavis

3 жыл бұрын

Liza is a great singer and performer I love Liza with a Z!❤️

Thank you! So beautiful

Beautiful

Wow what a beautiful performance. Thanks!

What a beautifully sweet, unadorned performance. She sings every note exactly as Harold Arlen wrote it. I wonder if her mom gave her any tips. I love seeing the older Liza giving the song to Michael Jackson. (I could have done without the bubbles, I think.) What a great clip. Thank you!

@TommyLellan

5 жыл бұрын

Star Sky I hate how modern renditions of this song deter from the original melody! It’s so annoying

@jonathankieranwriter

2 жыл бұрын

Forget the bubbles: I could gave done without Michael Jackson. And Minnelli in that beleaguered wig, simpering praises to Jackson as if he were some saint … she seems drugged out of her wits.

@MaskedMan66

2 жыл бұрын

You mean Dorothy sang it for the Scarecrow? How cool!

@MaskedMan66

2 жыл бұрын

@@jonathankieranwriter You got a problem with MJ?

@eidolon1809

2 жыл бұрын

I could have done without seeing MJ's Fankenstein face.

Precious little Liza has her mother's voice.

I seen her in concert she was fabulous we waited to see her come out and she spoke to all of us in Glasgow years ago she is a lovely lady ❤❤❤

That was just lovely!

Well that really brings me back I remember this

She did good.

She really did sound like her mother but it's just as beautiful

Thank you Liza, one of our Greats who else but the daughter of Vincent Minnelli & Judy Garland. ALSO. We cannot forget Lorna Luft another beautiful voice. Thankyou girls both legends.

what a magic....

Thank you for adding. Another treasure from the Judy/Liza Songbooks. I know her mother told her to do her own music, and be her own star. However, Im sure it would have been amazing tribute project back when her voice was stronger.

Wow

Liza is the greatest entertainer in my book.

Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you! For posting this.

My God. Amazing, Thank you for this. What a gift.

Sounds like her mom-looks like her dad. Nice combo!

Goosebumps. What is it? Charisma? So tender and powerful.

Magnifique. Liza fille de Judy. Talent de génération en génération.

Never saw this before . Thanks for sharing !

Lovely and enchanting....!

She sounds so much like her mom, and yet makes this her own.

@SteaksauceandRob

5 жыл бұрын

You meant to say “own” but you’re right about she “won”

@MaskedMan66

2 жыл бұрын

@@SteaksauceandRob Thanks, it's been corrected. Took a bit of time, but there you go. 🙂

Bravo

I cried when I heard this

Beautiful !

Blessings always

It's te best is Beatiful :' ) Liza Milleni and Judy Forever

Wow. Amazing 🥺💗

She is her mothers daughter by every definition

Oh my heart how lovely n true those days were🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤

So young and cute!!!...great clip!!..👏👏👏

❤️❤️❤️❤️

The earlier version deserves a remaster in stereo.

Judy's voice at 13 was strong and amazing. Her kids had to train their voices where Judy's voice was natural

@sleepymisty9667

6 жыл бұрын

Saxon C ~ Yes, and if you didn't know Judy or the song and only heard her, you would think she was an adult singing.

@DDumbrille

5 жыл бұрын

But she was in movies since 1935 -- when she was THIRTEEN -- and sounded like an adult.

@joshuaalexander6296

5 жыл бұрын

Saxon C that’s so true. which proves how incomparable Judy is. Such an amazing talent

@robertnovoa341

4 жыл бұрын

Judy Garland's voice sounded flawless when she sang Over the Rainbow in The Wizard of Oz, other than that it wasn't really flawless maybe because when she got a little older from her voice it began to change which would be logical_ but there's a movie where she sings about a trolley 🎵🎶ding ding ding goes the trolley...🎶 there her voice sounding Flawless as well, still I haven't seen any other movies yet but I will check them out. still she was a beautiful woman although she had her weaknesses as we all have_ men, women, kids because we are only human not human and God as Christ was and is. But about her daughter Liza Minnelli_ she sounds like she is still being trained by her mother but she still can't get it right, not as right as her mother would want it. and maybe that was one of the problems. but we all have family problems it is part of life in this Fallen World. ❣🕊

@orion8835

4 жыл бұрын

Garlands voice was trained . Her father was a tenor and it was not at all a natural anything . The gift was there but it was trained that is how she was still able to sing when as ever drug addict . Technique.

Luv it. Singing for a better world.

❤

Wonderful 👏 🐦

Keep it up with the posts bro! Solid bro

little Liza singing mommy's song, i love it!!!!!!!! Dorothy junior!!!!!!

Liza will & would ONLY sing this song for 'ONLY' M.J.💖💖💝💖💝💖🎤🎤😘🎤😘🎤😘

Much Much more than I ever Expected.

AMAZING MIRACLE

I think this is lovely

Gorgeous ❤❤❤❤

I trust no one will ever sing Over the Rainbow like Judy Garland. and I guess not even Judy Garland now.

I'm crying my eyes out right now!!! She sounds so much like her mother. I could imagine Judy and Liza having a duet and sing this song together!! I would just cry like no tomorrow! This is just so perfect!

LIZA an AMAZING and Under rated Talent!!

@dyanshane

7 жыл бұрын

I dont know how you can say under rated? She has won every award there is! She just got older and had problems.

Like mother ❤️ incredible she sounds like her mom when she sang it when she was16

God is she her mother !!!

@DDumbrille

5 жыл бұрын

Get your hearing checked ASAP.

@richardgallerani8817

5 жыл бұрын

@@DDumbrille that comment wasn't referred to her voice so much as her love for performing and the stage. Liza was always more like her mother than the other kids.

That was THE best laugh i've had in months!!! The first part when Liza was a young girl... was surprisingly beautiful. She sounded very much like her mother. The latter part, when she's older was a caricature of herself. She was dying on stage.

@arxsyn

6 жыл бұрын

Richie Gregory well she's an old woman in the clip. A Crone. Delightfully witchy. she looked great though

@icbaicba7765

5 жыл бұрын

the Michael Jackson presence creeps me out. Michael was no longer Michael by 1980

@AshMukherjeeOfficial

5 жыл бұрын

She sounded like her mother but I think she gave a very nuanced and authentic performance. The last one was like ‘ I am Liza Legend Broadway Minnelli darling!’

@naturalselectioninterventi4805

4 жыл бұрын

She looks like shes FAS in that first clip. I have always thought that but its MUCH more pronounced when she was a kid.

Judy Garland & Liza Minnelli: both my Mom's fav singers/entertainers, She must have caught Miss Garland live, along w/many other broadway/vegas stars & opera stars too. Mom carried "Show Tunes" on her "harrington piano quite well, like her mom(Bertha Stahl) & brother, Jerry. wish i had their skills & musical ear(written 100's of poems, songs, a book/short story, play 3 instruments, don't have "families' talent, nor do i sing) "que cerra"

Qué precioso angelito, ¡cómo cantaba!

Interesting. For most of her career, Liza was strict about never singing Over The Rainbow. If anybody requested it she'd say: "It's been sung". I always thought that was smart and classy. I knew she eventually sang it in later years; I didn't know she'd already done it as a child.

@PaulLHunziker

3 жыл бұрын

Yes just that one line. The earlier version of course her .other was still living.

@oliverbrownlow5615

2 жыл бұрын

I think what she's been strict about is not trading on her mother's legacy by relying on her repertoire, though occasionally she has sung songs that Judy sang at one time or another, but never the ones that were chiefly associated with her. Strangely, Judy doesn't seem to have bound Lorna to a similar promise, with the result that a while back Liza was touring with a show called *Songs My Father Taught Me,* while Lorna toured with a show called *Songs My Mother Taught Me.* I think the promise was good for Liza (and for her fans) in that it forced her to develop her own unique repertoire, and I have to think and hope that this was part of what was in Judy's mind when she asked for Liza's promise. On the other hand, it has always seemed to me a little unfair, because who has a better right to sing Judy's songs than her own kids? It's also startling to realize how many of the songs Judy habitually sang throughout her career were drawn straight from Al Jolson's repertoire -- even "You Made Me Love You," one of her earliest hits. Whose songs were these, really?

No one can match her mother

@AshMukherjeeOfficial

5 жыл бұрын

Saxon C no one is trying to. That’s why she made it her own.

💝

She caught the emotion of the song beautifully. Lovely.

The last clip Insane how much she portrayed her mother Its really so beautiful to see the legacy lived on after judy

Liza sounds just like Judy. They knew she would be a star too

Love Frances Gumm 👠 💛💋

I love Liza's early performances. This one is very rare, because Liza almost never covered Judy's songs. Interesting to compare to her voice performance as Dorothy for the animated film *Journey Back to Oz,* not released until 1972 (but I believe Liza's contribution was recorded much earlier, before her mom's death, and with her blessing).

For years Liza would refuse to sing this song, explaining "It's been sung." Okay, it's "her" song, but Liza manages to make it her own.

This was before she got her VOICE!

@philipanderson4673

4 жыл бұрын

...and then after she LOST it...

I wonder how hard it was for her to perform the exact song her mother is known for and made (it) famous. 😥